Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Design and code-checks of concrete members (Scia Engineer 15.0 and newer version)
Contacts 9
Abstract 10
Concrete in Scia Engineer 15 11
Command properties 15
Command properties 15
Name 15
Selection 15
Type of loads 16
Filter 16
Print Combination key 16
Values 17
Extreme 17
Output 17
Drawing setup 17
Section 17
Action buttons 17
-2-
Concrete settings - Design Defaults 72
Design defaults 72
Output 88
Numerical output 88
Numerical output 88
Graphical output 94
Graphical output 94
Design 96
Design of reinforcement 96
Longitudinal reinforcement 96
Shear reinforcement 97
Internal forces - theory 97
Introduction 97
Parameters influence the calculation 98
Additional tensile forces caused by shear and torsion (shifting of bending moments) 107
Determination whether member is in compression 108
First order bending moments with imperfection 108
Calculation of second order effects 111
Design of reinforcement for rectangular section 114
Design of reinforcement for circular section 115
Design of reinforcement for other cross-sections 116
Checks for all type of cross-sections 117
Literature 120
Slenderness 120
Introduction 120
Buckling data 121
Creep coefficient 121
Estimation of ratio of longitudinal reinforcement 122
Calculation of slenderness 122
Calculation of limit slenderness 123
Warning and errors 126
Abbreviations 126
Literature 127
Reinforcement design - theory 127
-3-
Chapter 0
Introduction 127
Design of longitudinal reinforcement 130
Design of shear reinforcement 140
Torsional longitudinal reinforcement 152
Check 155
Checks 155
Stiffness 155
Introduction 155
Assumptions 158
Theory 159
Setup 162
Errors and warnings 162
Capacity - response (ULS) 163
Introduction 163
Assumptions and limitations 163
Theoretical background 163
Effective depth of cross-section 167
Inner lever arm 167
Errors and warnings 168
National annexes 169
Capacity - diagram (ULS) 170
Introduction 170
Assumptions 170
Theoretical background 171
Setup 178
Errors and warnings 180
National annexes 181
Shear + torsion (ULS) 181
Introduction 181
Equivalent thin-walled closed cross-section 181
Parameters influencing the calculation 184
Determination stirrups around section 185
-4-
Calculation number of stirrup link (number of cuts) 185
Stirrup for torsion 186
Calculation of average characteristics of shear reinforcement 187
Calculation characteristic of shear reinforcement 187
Calculation procedure 188
Width of cross-section for shear check 192
Effective depth of cross-section for shear check 192
Inner lever arm for shear check 193
Calculation basic characteristics for shear 194
Shear check 194
Calculation procedure 195
Calculation of basic characteristics 197
Torsion check 198
Calculation procedure 199
Check of interaction shear and torsion 202
Warnings, errors and notes 202
Abbreviations 203
Literature 203
Stress limitations (SLS) 203
Introduction 203
Assumption and limitations 203
Theoretical background 206
Setup 208
National annexes in stress limitation 210
Errors, Warnings, Notes 211
Crack width (SLS) 212
Introduction 212
Value of strength for calculation of cracking forces 212
Check of normal stresses (occurrance of crack width) 212
Type of strength for calculation of cracking forces 213
Use of effective modulus of concrete 213
Type of maximal crack width 214
Type of strength for calculation of cracking forces 214
Parameters influencing the calculation 215
Calculation of mean strain in the reinforcement and concrete 215
-5-
Chapter 0
-6-
Minimal number of bars in circular column (9.5.2(4)) 245
Minimal bar diameter of transverse reinforcement (9.5.3(1)) 246
Maximal longitudinal spacing of stirrups (9.5.3(3)) 246
Maximal centre-to-centre bar distance (9.3.1.1(3)) 246
Concrete settings 247
Concrete settings for beams 249
Check min. bar distance 249
Minimal bar distance 249
Check max. bar distance 250
Maximal bar distance 250
Check max. bar distance (torsion) 250
Maximal bar distance (torsion) 251
Check min. reinforcement area 251
Check min. reinforcement area for secondary member 251
Check max. reinforcement area 252
Check min. mandrel diameter 252
Check max. longitudinal spacing (shear) 252
Check max. longitudinal spacing (torsion) 252
Check max. transverse spacing (shear) 253
Check min. percentage of stirrups 253
Check max. percentage of stirrups 253
Settings for beam slabs 253
Check min. bar distance 253
Minimal bar distance 254
Check max. bar distance 254
Check min. reinforcement area 254
Check max. reinforcement area 255
Settings for columns 255
Check min. bar distance 255
Minimal bar distance 256
Check max. bar distance 256
Maximal bar distance 256
Check max. bar distance (torsion) 257
Maximal bar distance (torsion) 257
Check min. reinforcement area 257
-7-
Chapter 0
-8-
Contacts
SCIA nv SCIA Nederland B.V.
Industrieweg 1007 Wassenaarweg 40
3540 Herk-de-Stad 6843 NW ARNHEM
Belgium Netherlands
All information in this document is subject to modification without prior notice. No part of this manual may be reproduced,
stored in a database or retrieval system or published, in any form or in any way, electronically, mechanically, by print, photo
print, microfilm or any other means without prior written permission from the publisher. SCIAis not responsible for any direct
or indirect damage because of imperfections in the documentation and/or the software.
© Copyright 2015 SCIA nv. All rights reserved.
-9-
Chapter 1
Abstract
SCIA Engineer 15 brings completely new solution for 1D concrete members. New technologies of the Open design,
powered by our SCIA Design Forms platform, have allowed for a complete revision of the design and checking of reinforced
concrete 1D members. This allows to us the use of all well know features of this platform such as very nice and detailed lay-
outs of calculation, using equations in output etc. Beside this, we offer more - rearrangement of the service tree, new con-
crete setup and member data and couple of new checks. Described solution works for all kind of shapes of non- prestressed
cross-section (e.g. with holes) subjected to all types of loading (e.g. biaxial shear combined with torsion). Generally these
new module provides the following advantages:
l high performance - design and checks run very fast using parallel process providing results in very small calculation
time
l transparency - detailed output enables to verify each intermediate steps of check using formulas with values and proper
units; assisting in dealing with EN 1992-1-1
l dynamic figures - drawing of stress-strain state of cross-section, reinforcement pattern or interaction diagram
l smart settings - new revised global and member settings, including 'quick search' function
l general solution
l supporting interaction of all internal forces (N, My , Mz , Vy , Vz , T);
l supporting arbitrary cross-section shapes including openings & arbitrary reinforcement positions
l revised and updated generic functions for design & checking of reinforced concrete columns & beams
l code compliance - supporting compliance with EN 1992-1-1:2004/AC:2010-11, corrigendum including National
Annexes (currently 18 NA´s).
The revised design and checks functions are developed within the Scia Design Forms environment. This platform is linked
as post-processor to Scia Engineer. The new reporting style makes use of its advantages regarding the presentation of res-
ults. Next to text and tabular output, also formulas, code references, dynamic images and diagrams are included to increase
the insight in the calculation!
The Concrete Toolbox is the new 'calculation heart', used by the Scia Design Forms. It contains a set of code- independent
functions for the design and checking of reinforced concrete members. It makes use of advanced generic algorithms, how-
ever in full compliance with e.g. the Eurocode assumptions. This means they are valid for arbitrary cross-section shapes and
reinforcement positions. They also support the interaction of any mixture of internal forces (N, My , Mz , Vy , Vz , T).
There are also some limitations. New concrete checks do not support the following items:
l numerical cross-section
l cross-section with more components
l phased cross-section
l member or cross-section with different material than concrete material – composite cross-section
l different reinforcement materials in one section
l concrete ribs are not supported
- 10 -
Concrete in Scia Engineer 15
Nevertheless, existing old solution for concrete design and check is still available. The functionality of existing concrete
checks is activated in Project data - Functionality - Old concrete checks (see the following figure).
- 11 -
Chapter 2
- 12 -
Concrete in Scia Engineer 15
When we go into concrete tree we can also see completely different arrangement of the tree. The concrete tree is split into
four parts:
- 13 -
Chapter 2
- 14 -
Command properties
Command properties
Command properties
Concrete checks run from the new commands mentioned in chapter "Concrete in Scia Engineer 15" on page 11. The com-
mand for these checks includes standard items where it is possible to select member, type of load, filter, extreme and others.
The description of all values is the following.
Name
User is allowed to name the Check. It might be very useful for better specification and orientation, especially in engineering
report. Default name is always name of the command in the tree.
Selection
This attribute influences the total amount of members, which will be taken into the concrete checks. There are four pos-
sibilities to be chosen from:
- 15 -
Chapter 3
l Named selection – only 1D members from certain named selection, will be checked. new attribute “Named selection” will
appear in the properties
Type of loads
By this attribute user defines the type of the load for checks. There are three possibilities to choose from:
In dependence on selected type of the load, new attribute Combination or Load cases or Class will appear right under this
attribute. User may select desired Combination, Load case or Class from filtered list here.
Filter
It is possible to define filter for adjusting already selected type of selection. This will affect the number of 1D member taken
into the check. User may select one from the following possibilities:
Again, after selection one possibility a new appropriate attribute will be displayed right under, for further selection.
- 16 -
Command properties
Values
Each design or check includes its own values. Usually Unity check is the first typical value for all checks. There is also pos-
sibility to see More component.
Extreme
This attribute defines which results should be shown in Preview window or document. User may choose from three pos-
sibilities:
· No – results for all members and sections will be displayed on selected 1D members; in case of envelope combination all
combinations are displayed
· Section – results for all section which are defined (see next chapter for type of section)
Output
This attribute defines type of numerical output. There are available three levels of numerical outputs:
l Brief – one table for all checks with the unity checks, default Engineering Report table.
l Standard – more detailed output coming from Scia Design Forms.
l Detailed – very deep output coming from Scia Design Forms
Drawing setup
By selecting edit button for this parameter, a 1D results display dialogue will be open. Here user may specify the rep-
resentation of check results on 1D member. This dialogue is a standard dialogue for graphical presentation of results on 1D
member. The most important settings are the following:
Section
When the extreme section is selected then there are four types of section which can be evaluated.
Action buttons
There are two buttons in the lower part of the Properties dialogue.
l Refresh – this button starts the process of check itself and it is needed to press this button to refresh previous checked res-
ults and to get new results, based on chosen attributes)
l Preview – this button opens Preview window with tables containing results of finished check
- 17 -
Chapter 4
1D member data
These settings overwrite the global settings for a specific member. Member data can easily be copy-pasted to similar mem-
bers. There is differentiation based on type of member (beam, column, beam slab). As in the case of setup, Member data
has been also restyled. Local settings contains a contain about the same input parameters and calculation settings as the
global settings in setup. Moreover, user can set his/her own value of limit deflection and limit width of crack, define more
environmental classes than just one as in previous version.
Old concrete member data
- 18 -
Concrete member data
- 19 -
Chapter 4
Solver settings
General
Creep
Type input of creep coefficient
Type of calculation creep coefficient:
Description - user value - creep coefficient inputted directly by the user
- auto - creep coefficient is calculated automatically by the program
Default Combo box ; Type = Auto / User input; default = Auto
φ
Code Annex B.1
Level Standard
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
Relative humidity
Description Relative humidity of ambient environment
Default Edit box; RH = 50%
Code Annex B.1
Level Advanced
Figure 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
- 20 -
Concrete member data
SLS
Use effective modulus of concrete
Possibility to use effective E modulus of concrete. It means the long-
Description term behaviour of concrete is covered in the analysis of the crack width,
stress limitations and stiffness calculation.
Default Check box, default NO
Code 7.1(2)
Level Advanced
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
Internal forces
Isolated member
The geometric imperfection is calculated as for isolated member, if this
Description
parameter is ON
Default Check box; default True
Code 5.8.8.2
Level Advanced
Member Column
- 21 -
Chapter 4
- 22 -
Concrete member data
Design As
Design method (beams)
Method for design of longitudinal reinforcement for beams and beams
Description
slab
Combo box; Auto / Uniaxial around y / Uniaxial around z / Biaxial;
Default
Default Auto
Code -
Level Advanced
Member Beam / Beam Slab
Interaction diagram
Interaction diagram method
Possibility to set method for evaluation of results using interaction dia-
gram:
- NRd - assuming MEd is constant
Shear
Type calculation / input of angle of compression strut
Type calculation of angle of between of compression strut and member
Description axis for shear check
- Auto: automatic calculation of minimum angle based on condition
- 23 -
Chapter 4
VEd<=VRd.max
- User(angle) : the value is inputted by the user as angle
- User(cotangent) : the value is inputted by the user as cotangent of the
value
Combo box, Auto / User (angle) / User (cotangent); default User
Default
(angle)
Code 6.2.3
Level Standard
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
- 24 -
Concrete member data
Torsion
Equivalent thin walled cross-section
Type of equivalent thin- walled cross- section used for calculation of
Description
cross-section capacity in torsion
Combo box; Automatic / From stirrups from torsion / From effective
Default CSS / From effective rectangular CSS; / User input of thin-walled closed
cross-section; default Automatic
Code 6.3.1(3)
Level Advanced
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
- 25 -
Chapter 4
Cracking forces
Type of strength for calculation of cracking forces
Type of tensile strength of concrete used for calculation of cracking
Description forces in SLS checks (stresses and deflections). It is possible to select
between fctm (Table 3.1) and fctm,fl (Clause 3.1.8).
Default Combobox fctm / fctm,fl (default fctm )
Code 7.1(2)
Level Advanced
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
Crack width
Type of maximal crack width
Possibility to automatically determined crack width according to expos-
Description ure class, combination and type of structure or to set user defined value
of crack width
Default Combo box; Auto / User; default Auto
Code 7.3.1(5)
Level Standard
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
- 26 -
Concrete member data
Deflections
Maximal total displacement L/x; x =
Maximal total (nonlinear+creep) displacement allowed for 1D member
Description
expressed as span / depth ratio
Default Edit box; xtot = 250
Code 7.4.1(4)
Level Standard
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
Design defaults
Structural class
Design working life is information used for determination of minimal con-
Description
crete cover
Default Edit box , default = 50 years
Code 4.4.1.2(5), table 4.3N
Level Standard
Figure -
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
- 27 -
Chapter 4
- 28 -
Concrete member data
Chemical attack
Description Additional Exposure class caused by chemical attack
Default Combo box; None / XA1 / XA2 / XA3; default =None
Code 4.4.1.2(12)
Level Standard
Figure -
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
- 29 -
Chapter 4
Concrete characteristic
Type of concrete
To take into account additional deviation to nominal concrete cover
Description
caused by production type
Default Combo box; In-situ / Prefabricated ; default = In-situ
Code 4.4.1.3(1P, 3)
Level Advanced
Figure -
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
Beam
Longitudinal
Material
Description Information about material of longitudinal reinforcement
Default Link to library; default taken from setting in Project data
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam
- 30 -
Concrete member data
Upper
Diameter of upper reinforcement
Description Information about diameter of upper of reinforcement
Default Edit box; default ds,u = 16mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam
Lower
Diameter of lower reinforcement
Description Information about diameter of lower of reinforcement
Default Edit box; default ds,l = 16mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam
- 31 -
Chapter 4
Side
Type of cover of side reinforcement
Description Information about type of cover of side reinforcement
Default Combo box; Auto / User; default = Auto
Code 4.4.1
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam
Stirrups
Material
Description Information about material of stirrups reinforcement
Default Link to library; default taken from setting in Project data
- 32 -
Concrete member data
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam
Diameter of stirrups
Description Information about diameter of stirrups
Default Edit box; dss = 8mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam
Number of cuts
Description Information about number of cuts for shear reinforcement
Default Edit box; ns = 2
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam
Angle
Angle between shear reinforcement and the beam axis perpendicular
Description
to the shear force
Default Edit box; α = 90deg
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam
Beam slab
Longitudinal
Material
Description Information about material of longitudinal reinforcement
Default Link to library; default taken from setting in Project data
Code -
- 33 -
Chapter 4
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam slab
Upper
Diameter of upper reinforcement
Description Information about diameter of upper of reinforcement
Default Edit box; default ds,u = 16mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam slab
Lower
Diameter of lower reinforcement
Description Information about diameter of lower of reinforcement
Default Edit box; default ds,l = 16mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam slab
- 34 -
Concrete member data
Column
Longitudinal
Material
Description Information about material of main reinforcement
Default Link to library; default taken from setting in Project data
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Column
Main
Diameter of main reinforcement
Description Information about diameter of main of reinforcement
Default Edit box; default ds,m = 16mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure
Member Column
- 35 -
Chapter 4
Stirrups
Material
Description Information about material of stirrups reinforcement
Default Link to library; default taken from setting in Project data
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam / Column
Diameter of stirrups
Description Information about diameter of stirrups
Default Edit box; dss = 8mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam / Column
Number of cuts
Description Information about number of cuts for shear reinforcement
Default Edit box; ns = 2
- 36 -
Concrete member data
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam / Column
Angle
Angle between shear reinforcement and the beam axis perpendicular
Description
to the shear force
Default Edit box; α = 90deg
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Beam / Column
This group of items is related to user defined shear reinforcement which is considered as real inputted reinforcement on
member. This replaces user defined shear reinforcement which is not taken into account for design. Check shear and tor-
sion is not influenced by this settings.
Material
Description Information about material of inputted stirrups reinforcement
Default Link to library; default taken from setting in Project data
Code -
Level Advanced
Figure -
Member Beam / Column
Angle
Angle between shear reinforcement and the beam axis perpendicular
Description
to the shear force
Default Edit box; α = 90deg
Code -
Level Advanced
Figure -
Member Beam / Column
- 37 -
Chapter 4
Code -
Level Advanced
Figure -
Member Beam / Column
- 38 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Find
There's also a 'Find' function, where the user can insert a search term. It brings some kind of filtering of items in the setup.
This function enables searching the defined value anywhere in the Concrete setting dialogue
View
Furthermore, very useful new thing is possibility of switch type of view of items of setup - concrete commands view, code
chapter view or list view. The first view is according to commands (Concrete commands view) used for design and check.
- 39 -
Chapter 5
- 40 -
Concrete settings (structure)
List view
Additionally, the User has also possibility to create his own view based on filtered items and use them for quick changes later
on. User defined view can be crated using Save actual view and definition of the name.
Afterwards, this view is possible to select in User item. This user view is possible to save or import from the file using Save
views into file, and Import views from file.
- 41 -
Chapter 5
Filters
The user can choose between a Standard or Advanced level, which filters the amount of data. The example is visible on
group Solver settings - General.
Standard view
- 42 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Advanced view
Default
Finally, when the user wants go back to predefined values it is possible to easily press button default and all settings are
restored.
l Solver settings
l Design defaults
Solver settings
General
Limit value of unity check
Description Limit value of unity heck when the check is still OK
Default Edit box , default = 1,0
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
- 43 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Figure
- 44 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Creep
Type input of creep coefficient
Type of calculation creep coefficient:
Description - user value - creep coefficient inputted directly by the user
- auto - creep coefficient is calculated automatically by the program
Default Combo box ; Type = Auto / User input; default = Auto
φ
Code Annex B.1
Level Standard
Figure -
Relative humidity
Description Relative humidity of ambient environment
Default Edit box; RH = 50%
Code Annex B.1
Level Advanced
Figure -
- 45 -
Chapter 5
SLS
Use effective modulus of concrete
Possibility to use effective E modulus of concrete. It means the long-
Description term behaviour of concrete is covered in the analysis of the crack width,
stress limitations and stiffness calculation.
Default Check box, default NO
Code 7.1(2)
Level Advanced
Figure
Internal forces
Use equivalent first order value
The first order moment is taken into account as equivalent first order
Description
moment, if this parameter is ON.
Default Check box , default True
Code 5.8.8.2(2)
Level Advanced
Figure
- 46 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
- 47 -
Chapter 5
Figure
- 48 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Internal forces SLS
Use geometric imperfection
The geometric imperfection is taken into account for calculation first
Description
order eccentricity, if this parameter is ON.
Default Check box, default True
Code 5.2.5
Level Standard
Figure -
Design As
Coefficient for reduction of strength of the concrete in compressive concrete
Coefficient for reduction of strength of the concrete in compressive con-
Description crete which is used for calculation design value of resistance of concrete
compressive strut nRd = Acc ·Redfcd·fcd
Default Edit box, default Redfcd = 0,85
- 49 -
Chapter 5
Code -
Level Advanced
Figure -
Interaction diagram
Interaction diagram method
Possibility to set method for evaluation of results using interaction dia-
gram:
Description
- NRd - assuming MEd is constant
- MRd - assuming NEd is constant
- 50 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Division of strain
Calculation precision for one of the diagram “branches” during gen-
eration of interaction diagram. The value means how many times the
Description
strain plane is readjusted from the position of section under full com-
pression to the position of section under full tension
Default Edit box; 200
Code -
Level Advanced
Figure
- 51 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Shear
Type calculation / input of angle of compression strut
Type calculation of angle of between of compression strut and member
axis for shear check
- Auto: automatic calculation of minimum angle based on condition
Description VEd<=VRd.max
- User(angle) : the value is inputted by the user as angle
- User(cotangent) : the value is inputted by the user as cotangent of the
value
Combo box, Auto / User (angle) / User (cotangent); default User
Default
(angle)
Code 6.2.3
Level Standard
Figure
- 52 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Figure
- 53 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Torsion
Equivalent thin walled cross-section
Type of equivalent thin- walled cross- section used for calculation of
Description
cross-section capacity in torsion
Default Combo box; Automatic / From stirrups from torsion / From effective
- 54 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Stress limitation
Indirect load
When the stress in reinforcement is caused by the indirect load
Description (imposed deformation) then the stress should not exceed different max-
imal value
Default Check box, default NO
Code 7.2(5)
Level Advanced
Figure
Cracking forces
Type of strength for calculation of cracking forces
Type of tensile strength of concrete used for calculation of cracking
Description forces in SLS checks (stresses and deflections). It is possible to select
between fctm (Table 3.1) and fctm,fl (Clause 3.1.8).
Default Combobox fctm / fctm,fl (default fctm )
Code 7.1(2)
Level Advanced
- 55 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Deflection
Maximal total displacement L/x; x =
Descrip- Maximal total (nonlinear+creep) displacement allowed for 1D member
tion expressed as span / depth ratio
Default Edit box; xtot = 250
Code 7.4.1(4)
Level Standard
- 56 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Figure
Detailing provisions
Longitudinal reinforcement
Check min. bar distance
Setting if minimal clear bar distance of longitudinal reinforcement for
Description
beam is checked or not.
Default Checkbox YES
Code 8.2(2)
- 57 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Figure
Figure
- 58 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Figure
- 59 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Figure
- 60 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Code 9.2.1.1(3)
Figure
Stirrups
Check min. mandrel diameter
Setting if minimal mandrel diameter of stirrups for beam is checked
Description
or not
Default Checkbox NO
Code 8.3(2)
Figure -
Figure
- 61 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Figure
- 62 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Code 6.2.3(3)
Figure -
Beam Slab
Longitudinal
Check min. bar distance
Setting if minimal clear bar distance of longitudinal reinforcement for
Description
beam slab is checked or not.
Default Checkbox YES
Code 8.2(2)
Figure
Figure
- 63 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Figure
- 64 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Column
Main
Check min. bar distance
Setting if minimal clear bar distance of longitudinal reinforcement for
Description
column is checked or not.
Default Checkbox YES
Code 8.2(2)
Figure
- 65 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Figure
Figure
- 66 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Figure
- 67 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Figure
- 68 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Figure
- 69 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Transverse
Check min. mandrel diameter
Setting if minimal mandrel diameter of stirrups for column is checked
Description
or not
Default Checkbox NO
Code 8.3(2)
Figure -
Figure
- 70 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Figure
- 71 -
Chapter 5
Figure
- 72 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Chemical attack
Description Additional Exposure class caused by chemical attack
Default Combo box; None / XA1 / XA2 / XA3; default =None
Code 4.4.1.2(12)
Level Standard
Figure -
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
- 73 -
Chapter 5
Concrete characteristic
Type of concrete
To take into account additional deviation to nominal concrete cover
Description
caused by production type
Default Combo box; In-situ / Prefabricated ; default = In-situ
Code 4.4.1.3(1P, 3)
Level Advanced
Figure -
Member 1D member (Beam / Column / Beam Slab)
Beam
Longitudinal
Upper
Diameter of upper reinforcement
Description Information about diameter of upper of reinforcement
Default Edit box; default ds,u = 16mm
Code -
Level Standard
- 74 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Member Beam
Figure
Member Beam
- 75 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Member Beam
Lower
Diameter of lower reinforcement
Description Information about diameter of lower of reinforcement
Default Edit box; default ds,l = 16mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure
Member Beam
- 76 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Level Standard
Figure
Member Beam
Figure
Member Beam
Side
Type of cover of side reinforcement
Description Information about type of cover of side reinforcement
Default Combo box; Auto / User; default = Auto
- 77 -
Chapter 5
Code 4.4.1
Level Standard
Figure
Member Beam
Figure
Member Beam
Stirrups
Diameter of stirrups
Description Information about diameter of stirrups
- 78 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Member Beam
Number of cuts
Description Information about number of cuts for shear reinforcement
Default Edit box; ns = 2
Code -
Level Standard
Figure
Member Beam
Angle
Angle between shear reinforcement and the beam axis perpendicular
Description
to the shear force
- 79 -
Chapter 5
Beam slab
Longitudinal
Upper
Diameter of upper reinforcement
Description Information about diameter of upper of reinforcement
Default Edit box; default ds,u = 16mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure
- 80 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
Figure
Lower
Diameter of lower reinforcement
Description Information about diameter of lower of reinforcement
Default Edit box; default ds,l = 16mm
Code -
- 81 -
Chapter 5
Level Standard
Figure
Figure
- 82 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Level Standard
Figure
Column
Longitudinal
Main
Diameter of main reinforcement
Description Information about diameter of main of reinforcement
Default Edit box; default ds,m = 16mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure
Member Column
- 83 -
Chapter 5
Figure
Member Column
Figure
Member Column
- 84 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Stirrups
Diameter of stirrups
Description Information about diameter of stirrups
Default Edit box; dss = 8mm
Code -
Level Standard
Figure
Member Column
Number of cuts
Description Information about number of cuts for shear reinforcement
Default Edit box; ns = 2
Code -
Level Standard
Figure
Member Column
- 85 -
Chapter 5
Angle
Angle between shear reinforcement and the beam axis perpendicular
Description
to the shear force
Default Edit box; α = 90deg
Code -
Level Standard
Figure -
Member Column
Figure
- 86 -
Concrete settings (structure)
Figure
- 87 -
Chapter 6
Output
Numerical output
Numerical output
Results are displayed in a numerical as well as a graphical way, including dynamic images of interaction diagrams and stress
/ strain distributions.
Level of output detail
The level of output detail can be chosen in the Properties menu (Output). Generally, there are three levels of output
l Brief output - lists the unity check values of the selected members, or the required area of reinforcement. It is a simple
table for all checks with the unity checks, default Engineering Report table.
l Standard - more detailed output coming from Scia Design Forms
l Detailed - first gives an overview of the input data, then followed by a detailed calculation - very detailed output coming
from Scia Design Forms. It also includes dynamic images displaying:
l Drawing of cross-section including reinforcement layout
l Stress and strain distributions in different limit states
l 2D prints of 3D interaction diagrams
- 88 -
Output
- 89 -
Chapter 6
- 90 -
Output
- 91 -
Chapter 6
- 92 -
Output
- 93 -
Chapter 6
Graphical output
Graphical output
Graphical output depends on amount of selected component. When only on value is chosen then only one value is drawn
without any additional text or information. When more values are chosen then all selected values are drawn parallel to
centreline of the beam with some predefined space between diagrams (for general drawing settings refer to "Displaying the
internal forces"). Additionally, each diagram is described by the explanatory text. Hereafter, you can find the graphical out-
put for Check response Unity_check; (εcc ) or (σcc ) .
- 94 -
Output
l When the values without unity checks are chosen, then colours are the following
lValue below min – red colour
l Value in range – grey colour
l Value above max – blue colour
l When the values with unity checks are chosen, then colours are the following
lValue below min – grey colour
l Value in range – green colour
l Value above max – red colour
- 95 -
Chapter 7
Design
Design of reinforcement
First you get an overview of the input data for the design:
l Slenderness calculation (for member type 'column'), determining if 2nd order effects need be taken into account.
Longitudinal reinforcement
The design of longitudinal reinforcement to resist N, My and Mz is done according to the Ultimate Limit State requirements.
Design method is selected based on type of member (beam x column) and according to the acting load. There is not any
limit for type of cross-section (formerly for columns rectangle and circle) nor for load type (formerly for beams - My or Mz ).
In case the required area of reinforcement exceeds the available space on one layer, more layers (with adapted lever arm)
are automatically generated. Designed reinforcement is automatically recalculated to real bars afterwards.
- 96 -
Design
Shear reinforcement
The design of shear reinforcement to resist Vy and Vz is done according to the ULS requirements. Formerly, there was pos-
sibility to design shear reinforcement just for Vy or Vz .
- 97 -
Chapter 7
l The shifting of bending moments is taken into account only for beams and beams as slab and in both directions
l The second order effect and geometrical imperfection are calculated only for column in compression
l Cross-section with one polygon and one material is taken into account for calculation second order effect and imper-
fection in version SEN 15
l The material of all reinforcement bars have to be same in SEN 15
where
- 98 -
Design
where
Angle between concrete compression strut and beam axis perpendicular to the shear force can be calculated automatically
or input by user in SEN depending on parameter Type calculation/input angle of compression strut. This parameter
can be changed in Concrete setting (if 1D concrete member data is not defined) or in 1D concrete member data. There are
the following options:
l Auto - angle of compression strut is calculated automatically as minimal value between θmin and θmax to condition accord-
ing to equation 6.29 in EN 1992-1-1
T Ed V Ed
+ ≤1
T Rd ,max V Rd ,max
where
l User(angle) - angle of compression strut be input directly by the user as an angle. If the inputted value is outside of the
interval θmin and θmax , the minimal or maximum value is taken into account for calculation
- 99 -
Chapter 7
l User(cotangent) - angle of compression strut be input directly by the user as cotangent of the angle. If the inputted value
is outside of the interval θmin and θmax , the minimal or maximum value is taken into account for calculation.
Minimal and maximal angle of compression strut is parameter of national annex and can be
edit in Manager of national annex
l Design - angle of shear force for member =Beam, can be set directly in Concrete setting (if 1D concrete member data is
not defined) or in 1D concrete member data , see pictures below. For member = Column, the angle most shear rein-
forcement is always 90 degree and can not be changed.
- 100 -
Design
l Check - angle of stirrups is loaded from inputted shear reinforcement. There is possible to input shear reinforcement only
with angle 90 degree in SEN 15
Type of member can be defined in properties of member via parameter Type or directly in
1D concrete member data
where
- 101 -
Chapter 7
Isolated member
Check box for determination, if the member is isolated member or not. Default setting is determined automatically by pro-
gram and the member is isolated, if to this member are not linked the others members. This setting can be changed in 1D
concrete member data for Member type =Column (Advanced mode). This setting is used for calculation length of the
member for calculation geometrical imperfection, clause 5.2(6) in EN 1992-1-1.
- 102 -
Design
Buckling data
The detailed description of inputting buckling data and way of calculation buckling data are described in [3]. There is
described general functionality, but for concrete member there are additional parameters for definition of buckling data.
These additional data are important for calculation eccentricities caused by imperfection (see clause 5.2(5) in EN 1992-1- 1)
and they can be defined in tab-sheet Buckling data in dialogue Buckling and relative lengths (member properties >
parameter Buckling and relative length > button Edit ).
l Combo box Tot. height – this combo allows to set type of calculation of total height of building or length of the isolated
columns. There are two items in combo box:
o Calculate – the tot height. will be calculated automatically as sum of lengths of the all members in buckling system
o User – the value can be input directly by the user. The input value will be taken into account if Calculate = User
l edit box Tot. height – this edit box allows to input total height of building or length of the isolated columns directly by the
user. The input value will be taken into account if item User is set in combo box Tot. Height.
l edit box my - is the number of vertical members contributing to the total effect of the imperfection perpendicular to y axis
of LCS. It means, that value is used for recalculation of bending moment around y axis. Only one value can be set for all
columns in buckling system
l edit box mz - is the number of vertical members contributing to the total effect of the imperfection perpendicular to z axis
of LCS. It means, that value is used for recalculation of bending moment around z axis. Only one value can be set for all
columns in buckling system
The important parameter for calculation of buckling data is type of structure (braced or
unbraced). The global type of structure can be set in Concrete Setting (Design defaults
> Default sway type) . For example , the structures is braced perpendicular to y axis of
GCS , if parameter Sway around y axis =NO (it means the structure is not prone to sway
perpendicular to y axis)
- 103 -
Chapter 7
The imperfection shall be taken into account in ultimate limit states and need not be considered for serviceability limit states,
see clause 5.2(2P) and 5.2(3) in EN 1992-1-1, therefore default setting in SEN is:
l ULS - use geometric imperfection = Yes , it means geometric imperfection will be taken into account
l SLS - use geometric imperfection = No , it means geometric imperfection will not be taken into account
- 104 -
Design
If check box Use second order effect = Yes, then the second order effect will be taken into account, if conditions below
are satisfied:
Design defaults
Design defaults is a special group of properties for, where user can define the basic parameters (diameter of longitudinal
and shear reinforcement, type of value of concrete cover...)for design of longitudinal and shear reinforcement.This setting
can be done in Concrete setting (if 1D concrete member data is not defined) or directly in 1D concrete member data. Th
- 105 -
Chapter 7
Three type of 1D members with different design defaults parameter are supported in SEN 15:
l Beam - member predominantly loaded by bending moments, for which longitudinal and shear reinforcement can be
designed. There are the following parameters:
l Longitudinal reinforcement
l diameter of upper/lower reinforcement
l type of cover of upper and lower reinforcement (auto or user defined value)
l type of cover of side reinforcement (upper, lower or user define value)
l material of longitudinal reinforcement (only in 1D concrete data)
Stirrups
l diameter of stirrups
l number of cuts (number of shear links)
l angle of shear reinforcement
l material of shear reinforcement (only in 1D concrete data)
l basic (user defined stirrup) - where user can defined user value of area of shear reinforcement per meter with some
angle and material of this reinforcement.
l Beam as slab- member predominantly loaded by bending moments for which shear reinforcement is not designed (for
example cut of 2D member).There are the following parameters:
l Longitudinal reinforcement
l diameter of upper/lower reinforcement
l type of cover of upper and lower reinforcement (auto or user defined value)
l type of cover of side reinforcement (upper, lower or user define value)
l material of longitudinal reinforcement (only in 1D concrete data)
l Column- member predominantly in compression for which longitudinal and shear reinforcement can be designed. There
are the following parameters:
l Longitudinal reinforcement
l diameter of upper/lower reinforcement
l type of cover of upper and lower reinforcement (auto or user defined value)
- 106 -
Design
l for beams
a = z ⋅ (cot( θ ) − cot( α )) / 2
- 107 -
Chapter 7
where
Automatic calculation of angle between the concrete compression strut and beam axis is
calculated by simplified method for shifting with the following simplifications:
l shear of member for calculation value VRd.max is calculated as minimum width of cross-section at whole cross-section
perpendicular to direction of shear forces
l value Ak and uk for calculation of TRd.max is calculated for effective rectangular cross-section, which has the same cross-
sectional area and same perimeter as inputted cross-section
where
- 108 -
Design
l the equivalent first order bending moments are taken into account. It means, that bending moments will be same at whole
length of the member. This option is used if check box Use equivalent first order value = Yes in Concrete setting (if
1D concrete member data is not defined) or in 1D concrete member data
M oez M oey
e oy = , e oz =
N Ed N Ed
l the first order eccentricity is calculated from bending moments in current section. It follows, that bending moments in each
section can be different. This option is used if check box Use equivalent first order value = No in Concrete setting (if
1D concrete member data is not defined) or in 1D concrete member data
Mz My
e oy = , e oz =
N Ed N Ed
where
The 1st order equivalent moment is calculated according to clause 5.8.8.2 (2) in EN 1992-1-1
M0,ey = max (0,6*M02,y +0,4*M01,y; 0,4* M02,y )
M0,ez = max (0,6*M02,z +0,4*M01,z; 0,4*M02,z )
where
M01y(z) is first end bending moments around y(z) axis of LCS with lesser absolute value as second end bending moment.
|M01y(z)|< |M02y(z)| The same values are used for calculation limit slenderness
M02y(z) is second end bending moments around y(z) axis of LCS with greater absolute value as first end bending moment.
|M02y(z)|≥ |M01y(z)| The same values are used for calculation limit slenderness
The user (real) reinforcement defined via REDES and free bars are not taken into account
for calculation effective depth of cross-section for design reinforcement to column ( Type
of check = Design ULS in service Internal forces)
- 109 -
Chapter 7
The inclination is calculated around both axes ( axis y and z) of LCS according to formula:
where
F0 is the basic value of inclination. The value is National parameter, it means that value can be different for each country.
The value can be set in Manager for national annex > EN 1992-1-1 > General > ULS > General > Theta_0 )
α h is the reduction factor for length of column or height of structure. The value is calculated according to formula
α m,y(z) is the reduction factor for numbers of members calculated according to formula
l is length of column or height of structure depending on, if the member is isolated or not, see "Isolated member" on page
102
my (mz ) is the number of vertical members contributing to the total effect of the imperfection perpendicular to y(z) of LCS. It
means, that value is used for recalculation of bending moment around y(z) axis of LCS. These value can be defined in Buck-
ling data, see "Buckling data" on page 103
The effect of imperfection for isolated column and for structure is taken into account always as an eccentricity according to
clause 5.2(7a) in EN 1992-1-1.
where
Fi,y(z) is the inclination around y(z) axis of LCS (perpendicular to y (z) axis of LCS)
l0,y(z) is the effective length of the member (column) around y(z) axis of LCS (perpendicular to y (z) axis of LCS), which can
be defined in Buckling data, see "Buckling data" on page 103
The direction (sign) of value of eccentricity caused by imperfection has to be same as dir-
ection (sign) of first order eccentricity.
e 0,min, y = max ( b
30
, 20mm ), e 0,min, z = max ( h
30
, 20mm )
where
- 110 -
Design
The minimum eccentricity is taken into account,if check box Use minimum value of eccentricity =Yes ,see
The direction (sign) of minimum first order eccentricity has to be same as direction (sign) of
first order eccentricity
is the 1st order eccentricity in direction of y (z) axis of LCS ,see "Calculation of
e0,y(z)
first order eccentricity without effect of imperfection" on page 109
is eccentricity caused by imperfection in direction of y (z) axis of LCS, see "Cal-
ei,y(z)
culation of eccentricity due to imperfection" on page 109
e
is minimum first order eccentricity in direction of y (z) axis of LCS, see "Min-
0,min,y imum first order eccentricity" on the previous page
(z)
After calculation of first order eccentricity including effect of imperfection, the 1st order moment, including the effect of imper-
fections around y (z) axis of LCS is calculated:
M0Ed,y(z) = NEd* eoEd,z(y)
l General method - equilibrium and resistance is verified in the deformed state, deformations are calculated taking into
account the relevant effects of cracking, non-linear material properties and creep, see clause 5.8.2(2) in EN 1992-1-1,
l Simplified method based on nominal curvature according to EN 1992-1-1, clause 5.8.8
- 111 -
Chapter 7
NEd is the design axial force in calculated section of the column (in SEN value N)
e2,z(y) is the second order eccentricity in direction of z (y) axis of LCS
YES NO
NO YES e =0
2y(z)
NO NO
where
(1/r)y
the curvature around y(z) axis of LCS (perpendicular to y (z) axis of LCS) , see
(z)
is the effective length of the member (column) around y(z) axis of LCS (per-
l0,y(z)
pendicular to y (z) axis of LCS), see "Buckling data" on page 103
is a factor depending on the curvature distribution around y(z) axis of LCS
according to clause 5.8.8.2(4) in EN 1992-1-1.
cy(z) l for constant first order bending moment (non zero) at whole length of the
column and in case that equivalent bending moment is taken into account
(see"Use equivalent first order value" on page 101 ) , value 8 is used
l otherwise value 10 is used
slenderness ratio around y(z) axis of LCS, see "Calculation of slenderness" on
ly(z)
page 122
ly limit slenderness ratio around y(z) axis of LCS, see "Calculation of limit slen-
(z),lim
derness" on page 123
The direction (sign) of final value of second order eccentricity has to be same as direction
(sign) of first order eccentricity
Calculation of curvature
The curvature for calculation of second order eccentricity is calculated according to clause 5.8.8.3 in EN 1992-1-1.
(1/r)y(z) = Kr*K ,y(z)*(1/r0)y(z)
f
where
- 112 -
Design
It follows that the calculation of curvature depends on many parameters and factors, but the most important are the fol-
lowing:
Coefficient Beta
Slenderness of the column for calculation of factor K ,y(z) is taken into account by parameter (by(z)) , which is calculated
f
according to formula:
where
- 113 -
Chapter 7
l for symmetrical reinforcement and in case if all reinforcement is not concentrated on opposite sides, but part of it is dis-
tributed parallel
l for other cases (check) - the effective depth is calculated from plane of equlibrium or by simplified calculation, if this value
cannot be caluclated from this plane, see "Coefficient for calculation of effective depth of cross-section" on page 98
where
the radius of gyration of the total reinforcement area in direction of y(z) axis of
isy(z)
LCS
b dimension of cross-section in centre of gravity in direction of y axis of LCS
h dimension of cross-section in centre of gravity in direction of z axis of LCS
asy
distance of centre of tensile reinforcement from tensile edge of css
(z)
Calculation the radius of gyration of the total reinforcement and distance of centre of tensile reinforcement from tensile edge
depends on shape of cross-section and if the internal forces are calculated for design of reinforcement or for checks.. It
means, this value can be different for design of reinforcement and for checks.
The user (real) reinforcement defined via REDES and free bars are not taken into account
for calculation effective depth of cross-section for design reinforcement to column
- 114 -
Design
where
- 115 -
Chapter 7
where
- 116 -
Design
where
where
- 117 -
Chapter 7
For unsymmetrical cross- section with unsymmetrical reinforcement according to recommendation of [4] the following for-
mula should be used
ε yd + ε cu
(1 / r o) y (z ) =
d z (y )
where
εyd
- 118 -
Design
l Auto - the direction for calculation second order effect and geometrical imperfection is determined automatically accord-
ing to conditions 5.38a and 5.38 b in EN 1992-1-1
The uni axial calculation for automatic determination is taken into account, if conditions below are satisfied, otherwise
biaxial calculation will be used
l Uniaxial - second order effect and geometrical imperfection is taken into account only in one direction (more unfavourable
direction). In case, that more unfavourable direction can not be assigned (accidental bending moments, effective length
and css properties are the same in both directions), the second order effect and geometrical imperfection will be taken
into account in both directions.
l Biaxial - second order effect and geometrical imperfection is always taken into account in both directions
There are no rules for determination of unfavourable direction in EN 1992- 1- 1, therefore in Scia Engineer is used pro-
cedure described in [5], where unfavourable direction is determined according to equation below:
N Ed ⋅ e 0 Edz ⋅ λ y
ηy =
eq
N Ed ⋅ e 0 Edy ⋅ λz
ηz =
b eq
- 119 -
Chapter 7
Literature
1. EN 1992-1-1: 2004 Eurocode 2 : design of concrete structures – Part 1: General rules and rules for
building
2. ENV 1992-1-1: 1991 Eurocode 2 : design of concrete structures – Part 1: General rules and rules for
building
Slenderness
Introduction
Slenderness and limit slenderness of the column should be checked before design or check of the members. Using of
second order effect in calculation depends on the check of slenderness, because if the check is slenderness is greater than
limit slenderness), the second order effect has to be taken into account for column calculation.
YES
NO
The slenderness and limit slenderness is calculated according to clause 5.8.3.1 and 5.8.3.2 in EN 1992-1-1. The following
preconditions are used for calculation :
- 120 -
Design
l The slenderness is calculated for beams and columns and for general load (N+My+Mz)
l The limit slenderness is calculated only in case that axial forces is smaller than zero (N < 0 kN)
l Cross-section with one polygon and one material is taken into account in version Scia Engineer 15
l The material of all reinforcement bars have to be same in Scia Engineer 15
Buckling data
The detailed description of inputting buckling data and way of calculation buckling data are described in [3]. There is
described general functionality, but for calculation of slenderness and limit slenderness are important the following prop-
erties
l properties for calculation effective length of the member around y and z axis
l if the member is braced (Sway = NO) or unbraced (Sway = YES ) around a and z axis
The important parameter for calculation of buckling data is type of structure (braced or
unbraced). The global type of structure can be set in Concrete Setting (Design defaults
> Default sway type) . For example , the structures is braced perpendicular to y axis of
GCS , if parameter Sway around y axis =NO (it means the structure is not prone to sway
perpendicular to y axis)
Creep coefficient
This value can be set in Concrete setting by using Advanced level or in 1D member data (advanced mode is ON), if is
defined. Creep coefficient can be calculated automatically by using input ages of concrete and relative humidity (see annex
B.1 in EN 1992-1-1), if the Type input of creep coefficient =Auto. If Type input of creep coefficient =User value.,
then creep coefficient can be input directly by the user.
- 121 -
Chapter 7
l mechanical reinforcement ratio (µ) in calculation limit slenderness (clause 5.8.3.1(1) in EN 1992-1-1)
l mechanical reinforcement ratio (µ) in calculation second order eccentricity (clause 5.8.8.3(3) in EN 1992-1-1)
l radius of gyration of the total reinforcement area (is ) in calculation second order eccentricity (clause 5.8.8.3(2) in EN
1992-1-1)
l calculation of exponent of interaction formula x in biaxial bending calculation (clause 5.8.9.(4) in EN 1992-1-1)
These values should be calculated before design of reinforcement, but before design we do not know area of rein-
forcement. It follows that for calculation of this value
The third solution is implemented in Scia Engineer via parameter Estimation ratio of longitudinal reinforcement for recal-
culation internal forces, where user can set ratio of reinforcement, which will be used for calculation of the values above.This
value can be set in Concrete setting by using Advanced level or in 1D member data (advanced mode is ON), if is
defined. Total area of reinforcement is calculated according to formula:
As =µ .Ac
s
where
Calculation of slenderness
The slenderness (slenderness ratio) is calculated according to clause 5.8.3.2(1) in EN 1992-1-1.
where
l is the effective length of the member (column) around y(z) axis of LCS (per-
0,y
pendicular to y (z) axis of LCS), which can be defined via Buckling data, see
(z)
"Calculation of slenderness" above
i
is the radius of gyration of the uncracked concrete section in direction of y (z)
c,y axis of LCS
(z)
The simplified values and formulas for calculation of effective length for isolated columns,
braced and unbraced frames are described in clauses 5.8.3.2(2-4) in EN 1992-1-1
- 122 -
Design
The slenderness is calculated in each section, it follows that for arbitrary member and mem-
ber with haunch, the slenderness can be different along length of the member
The limit slenderness is calculated according to clause 5.8.3.1(1) in EN 1992- 1- 1. The limit slenderness and the slen-
derness are always checked separately for each direction according to 5.8.3.1(2) in EN 1992- 1- 1. The formula for cal-
culation of limit slenderness in EN 1992-1- 1 is national parameter, it means, that different formula, method or value can be
used in some countries, see concrete setup ( Manager for national annex > EN 1992-1-1 > General > ULS > General
> lambda_lim )
There are changes in calculation of limit slenderness for some national annex see the table below
- 123 -
Chapter 7
The limit slenderness is not calculated if normal force (relative normal force) is com-
pressive.
The limit slenderness is calculated in each section, it follows that for arbitrary member,
member with a haunch, member with non- uniform normal force along the length of the
member or member in which the reinforcement is not constant over the length of the mem-
ber, the limit slenderness can vary along the length of the member.
is creep ratio loaded from concrete setting (if concrete member data is not defined
f
on column) or concrete member data
where
- 124 -
Design
B = √(1+2∙ω)
Mechanical reinforcement ratio - design
Mechanical reinforcement ratio depends on total area of longitudinal reinforcement. For design of reinforcement, total area
of reinforcement is calculated from estimation ratio loaded from Concrete setting (if concrete member data is not defined )
or concrete member data, see"Estimation ratio of longitudinal reinforcement" . The mechanical reinforcement ratio is the
same at whole length of the column and it is calculated according to formula:
f yd
ω = µs ⋅
f cd
where
µ it is estimation ratio of longitudinal reinforcement loaded from Concrete setting (if concrete member data is not defined )
s
or concrete member data
fyd design yield strength of reinforcement. The quality of reinforcement can be input in Project data(if concrete member data
is not defined ) or in concrete member data
fcd design value of concrete compressive strength
Shape of bending moment is expressed by ratio of first order end section bending moments without influence of imper-
fection in direction of the selected local axis. The ratio of these moments (value r m ) depends on type of member and on
shape of shear force.
l if type of member is unbraced around local axis (sway= YES), then rm = 1,0
l if type of member is braced around local axis (sway= NO) and first order moments arise only from or predominantly due
to imperfections or transverse loading (maximum bending moment along the member is not at the beginning or at the
end of the member ), then rm = 1,0
l otherwise, value rm is calculated according to formula
where
M01y(z) it is first end bending moments around y(z) axis of LCS with lesser absolute value as second end bending moment. |
M01y(z) |< | M02y(z) | The same values are used for calculation oflimit slenderness.
M02y(z) it is second end bending moments around y(z) axis of LCS with greater absolute value as first end bending moment.
| M02y(z) |≥ | M01y(z) | The same values are used for calculation of limit slenderness.
rm.y(z) ratio of bending moment around y(z) axis of LCS which is used for calculation limit slenderness around y(z) axis of
LCS
The coefficient C is calculated according to formula:
- 125 -
Chapter 7
If normal force is not uniform along the length of column or the part of the column (for arbit-
rary member and member with haunch), the maximum value of normal force at length of
column or the part of the column will be taken into account.
Abbreviations
Abbreviation Explanation
SEN Software SCIA Engineer
PNL Physical nonlinear calculation
GNL Geometrical nonlinear calculation
LCS Local coordinate system
GCS Global coordinate system
- 126 -
Design
Abbreviation Explanation
REDES The module in SEN for inputting user reinforcement to 1D member via template
SLS Serviceability limit state
ULS Ultimate limit state
Literature
1. EN 1992-1-1: 2004 Eurocode 2 : design of concrete structures – Part 1: General rules and rules for
building
2. ENV 1992-1-1: 1991 Eurocode 2 : design of concrete structures – Part 1: General rules and rules for
building
l statically required longitudinal reinforcement, see "Design of longitudinal reinforcement" on page 130
l longitudinal reinforcement including detailing provisions
l statically required shear reinforcement, see "Design of shear reinforcement" on page 140
l shear reinforcement including detailing provisions
l torsional longitudinal reinforcement, see "Torsional longitudinal reinforcement" on page 152
l additional tensile forces caused by shear is taken into account by shifting of bending moments, see clause 9.2.1.3(2)in EN
1992-1-1,
l cross-section with one polygon and one material is taken into account,
l practical (user defined) reinforcement is not taken into account.
Design defaults
Design defaults is a special group of properties for, where user can define the basic parameters (diameter of longitudinal
and shear reinforcement, type of value of concrete cover...) for design of longitudinal and shear reinforcement.This setting
can be done in Concrete setting (if 1D concrete member data is not defined) or directly in 1D concrete member data.
- 127 -
Chapter 7
Three type of 1D members with different design defaults parameter are supported in SEN 15:
l Beam - member predominantly loaded by bending moments, for which longitudinal and shear reinforcement can be
designed. There are the following parameters:
l Longitudinal reinforcement
l diameter of upper/lower reinforcement
l type of cover of upper and lower reinforcement (auto or user defined value)
l type of cover of side reinforcement (upper, lower or user define value)
l material of longitudinal reinforcement (only in 1D concrete data)
Stirrups
l diameter of stirrups
l number of cuts (number of shear links)
l angle of shear reinforcement
l material of shear reinforcement (only in 1D concrete data)
l basic (user defined stirrup) - where user can defined user value of area of shear reinforcement per meter with some
angle and material of this reinforcement.
l Beam as slab- member predominantly loaded by bending moments for which shear reinforcement is not designed (for
example cut of 2D member).There are the following parameters:
l Longitudinal reinforcement
l diameter of upper/lower reinforcement
l type of cover of upper and lower reinforcement (auto or user defined value)
l type of cover of side reinforcement (upper, lower or user define value)
l material of longitudinal reinforcement (only in 1D concrete data)
l Column- member predominantly in compression ffor which longitudinal and shear reinforcement can be designed. There
are the following parameters:
l Longitudinal reinforcement
l diameter of upper/lower reinforcement
l type of cover of upper and lower reinforcement (auto or user defined value)
- 128 -
Design
l There is possibility for define design defaults for all type of 1D member (beam, column, beam slab)
l the material of longitudinal and shear reinforcement is not possible to input/edit in this setting, but material is loaded from
project data and it is same for all type of members
l only design defaults of selected type of member can be edited in this setting
l material of shear and longitudinal reinforcement can be edited directly in concrete member data
Design method
User can set type of method for design reinforcement for columns and beams This setting can be done in Concrete setting
(if 1D concrete member data is not defined) or directly in 1D concrete member data for Member type =Column or beams by
using Advanced mode/level
Concrete setting 1D concrete member data for beam 1D concrete member data for column
Four type of methods for design statically required reinforcement are supported for beams and columns:
l auto
l uniaxial around y
l uniaxial around z
l biaxial
Uniaxial method around y axis is always used for type of member =beam as slab.
Biaxial method independently on selected method is always used for circular and oval
columns
- 129 -
Chapter 7
The automatic method for design of reinforcement is based on ratio of bending moments around y and z axis and on value
of limit ratio of bending moments for using uniaxial method. This limit value can be set and loaded from concrete setting
(Advanced level). Default value is 0.1. It follows, if ratio of maximal bending moments around y and z axis for all combinations
in current section is lesser than limit ratio of bending moments, uniaxial method is used for design, otherwise biaxial method
is used
- 130 -
Design
l The stresses in the reinforcing steel are given by the design stress–strain relationships (bilinear with or without inclined
horizontal branch stress-strain diagram)
Four methods are supported in SEN 15 for design of reinforcement for beams and columns, see "Design method" on page
129
l uni-axial around y axis, see "Uniaxial method for design" on the next page
l uni-axial around z axis, see "Uniaxial method for design" on the next page
l biaxial, see "Biaxial method for design" on page 137
l auto, see "Automatic method for design" on page 139
Uniaxial method around y axis is always used for type of member =beam as slab.
Biaxial method independently on selected method is always used for circular and oval
columns
Designed required area is for better overview and graphical presentation recalculated to directions of cross-section (mem-
ber) LCS axes, see "Recalculation reinforcement to directions" on page 135
Except of statically required longitudinal reinforcement (As.req) , the program calculates provided longitudinal reinforcement
(As.prov ). It is statically required longitudinal reinforcement area recalculated to real bars , where:
l diameter of longitudinal reinforcement is taken into account (cross-sectional area of bars with input diameter)
l minimal number of bars per edge is 2
l number of bars is rounded to integer
l corner bars are taken into account for all edges (half of bar is taken into account for one edge, and half of bar for second
edge)
- 131 -
Chapter 7
l for method uniaxial around y, the bending moment MEdz is ignored, it follows that reinforcement is designed only for
normal forces NED and bending moment MEdy
l for method uniaxial around z, the bending moment MEdy is ignored, it follows that reinforcement is designed only for
normal forces NED and bending moment MEdz
- 132 -
Design
l beam
l beam as slab
- 133 -
Chapter 7
l column
a s = c nom + d ss + 0.5 ⋅ d s
where
The edge, for which parameter of upper reinforcement is used, is the edge above axis
which is crossed by line in direction of bending moment resultant for dangerous com-
bination, which causes the biggest linear stress in the cross-section
- 134 -
Design
The edge, for which parameter of lower reinforcement is used, is the edge under axis
which is crossed by line in direction of bending moment resultant for dangerous com-
bination, which causes the biggest linear stress in the cross-section
Maximal number of layer which is taken into account is 5 in SEN 15. The program finishes with error when maximum num-
ber of layer (nmax =5) is inefficient.
Design for more layers is supported only for beams and beams as slab
- 135 -
Chapter 7
- 136 -
Design
This method allows to design reinforcement for normal force (NEd) and biaxial bending moments. This method is based on
interaction formula, equation 5.39 in EN 1992-1-1.
M Edy a M Edz a
M +
Rdy
M Rdz ) ≤1
where
M
Ed-
is design moment around y axis
y
M
Ed-
is design moment around z axis
z
is the design moment resistance around y-axis, it means inter-
M
section of interaction diagram and line parallel with My axis across
Rd- the point with coordinates [NEd,MEdy ,0], see "Theoretical back-
y ground" on page 171
is the design moment resistance around y-axis, it means inter-
M
section of interaction diagram and line parallel with Mz axis across
Rd- the point with coordinates [NEd,0,MEdz ], see "Theoretical back-
y ground" on page 171
is exponent of interaction formula
- 137 -
Chapter 7
Procedure of calculation:
l program designs initial area of reinforcement according to linear stress on the edges of the cross-section
l program increases area of reinforcement, generates interaction diagram around y and z axes and checks interaction for-
mula in iterative calculation, till interaction formula is not satisfied
l if interaction formula is fulfilled, then program checks plane of deformation and increase area of reinforcement , if the
plane of deformation is not found
- 138 -
Design
There is possibility to used automatic method for design. The program automatically select uniaxial or biaxial method accord-
ing to values of bending moments around y and z axis. It follows:
(
min M Edy ,max , M Edz ,max ) ≤ Ratio
Ratio = lim
max (M Edy ,max , M Edz ,max )
l biaxial method (see"Biaxial method for design" on page 137 ) is used in other cases
where
- 139 -
Chapter 7
Different method for design of reinforcement can be used in each section along the mem-
ber in dependence on values of bending moments around y and z axis from all com-
binations
l design for biaxial shear force,see "Design of shear reinforcement for shear forces" on page 142
l design for torsion , see "Design shear reinforcement for torsion" on page 147
l design for interaction shear force and torsion, see "Design of shear reinforcement for interaction shear and torsion" on
page 149
Design is provided according to clause 6.1 -6.3 in EN 1992-1- 1. Design reinforcement for shear and torsion is commonly
based on the theory of the concrete truss-model too. In this theory a virtual truss-model is imagined in a concrete beam. This
truss-model has a set of vertical (or slightly diagonal), horizontal and diagonal members. The vertical bars are considered to
be the stirrups; the horizontal bars are the main reinforcement and the diagonal bars are the concrete struts.
- 140 -
Design
l The shear forces in both direction are taken into account and design of shear reinforcement is done for resultant of shear
forces
l The parameters of plane of equilibrium (value, d, z and h) are recalculated to direction of shear force resultant
l The design shear resistance of the member without shear reinforcement (VRd,c ) is calculated according to clause 6.2.2
(1) in EN 1992-1-1, if section is cracked in flexure, otherwise clause 12.6.3 in EN 1992-1-1 is used
l Design value of maximum shear force will be calculated according to clause 6.2.2(6) (VEd,max ) and 6.2.3 (3,4) (VRd,max )
in EN 1992-1-1
l Design value of shear resistance is calculated according to 6.2.3 (3,4) (VRd,s ) in EN 1992-1-1
l The number of shear link is loaded directly from Design defaults from concrete setting or concrete data, see "Design
defaults" on page 105
l The angle of compression strut can be calculated automatically or defined by user, see "Angle between concrete com-
pression strut and beam axis" on page 99
l The torsional cracking moment (TRd,c ) is calculated according to clause 6.3.2(5) in EN 1992-1-1
l Design value of maximum of torsional resistance moment (TRd,max )is calculated according to clause 6.3.2(4) in EN
1992-1-1
l The angle of stirrups for design shear reinforcement for torsion has to be perpendicular
l There are 5 possibilities for calculation thin-walled closed section, see "Equivalent thin-walled closed cross-section" on
page 181
- 141 -
Chapter 7
l Cross-section with one polygon and one material is taken into account in version SEN 15
l The user(practical) reinforcement is not taken into account
l Design should be done only in case that the angle between gradient of the strain plane and the resultant of shear forces is
not greater than 15 degrees
l Inclined compression chord or inclined tensile chord are not taken into account
l The widths of cross-section for shear checks (value bw and bw1) are calculated automatically. There is no possibility for
definition of user value in SEN 15
Except of statically required shear reinforcement per meter (A swm.req), the program cal-
culates provided shear reinforcement (A swm.prov ). It is statically required shear rein-
forcement, where the spacing of the stirrups in longitudinal direction is rounded to 25 mm
As was mentioned above, there exists general concept of “strut- and-tie” model for the prediction of shear effects in con-
crete. In this model, the top compression and bottom tensile members represent the compressive concrete and tensile rein-
forcement, respectively. The procedure for design can be represented by diagram below:
- 142 -
Design
The formulas which are used for the calculation of each component of this model are the following.
Generally, there are two possibilities for calculation of shear capacity of concrete dependently on existence of cracked in
bending:
Shear concrete capacity in region cracked in bending – formula 6.2.a,b in EN 1992-1-1
Additionally, there is calculated maximal shear force (VEd,max ) ) without reduction by β for member where load is applied in
the upper side of the member (see formula 6.5 in EN 1992-1-1).
- 143 -
Chapter 7
Maximal capacity of concrete compressive strut (VRd,max ) is determined according to formula 6.9 in EN 1992-1-1, because
as has been mentioned before, the angle of stirrups (θ) is always perpendicular to member axis.
α cw ⋅ b w 1 ⋅ z ⋅ ν 1 ⋅ f cd
VRd ,max =
cot( θ ) + tan( θ )
Statically required cross- sectional area of the shear reinforcement per meter is calculated from the formula 6.13 in
EN 1992-1-1
Asw .re V Ed
A swm.req = =
s l .re z ⋅ f ywd ⋅ (cot( θ ) + cot(α )) ⋅ sin(α )
Design value of shear force sustained by shear reinforcement (VRd,s ) is calculated according to formula 6.13 in EN 1992-1-
1
Asw
VRd , s = ⋅ z ⋅ f ywd ⋅ (cot( θ ) + cot( α )) ⋅ sin( α )
s
Design value of shear force sustained by shear reinforcement (VRd,s ) is calculated according to formula 6.13 in EN 1992-1-
1
Asw
VRd , s = ⋅ z ⋅ f ywd ⋅ (cot( θ ) + cot( α )) ⋅ sin( α )
s
Final design value of shear force (VRd ) carried by member is calculated based on the following formulas depending on type
of member and area of shear reinforcement.
l for beam as slab and for other member with only detailing stirrups (Aswm.req =0)
VRd = VRd , s + Vtd + Vccd ≤ min(VRd .max , VEd ,max ) + Vtd + Vccd
where
- 144 -
Design
Asl
ρl = ≤ 0, 02
bw ⋅d
σ ccp − σ c ,lim 2
f cvd = f ctd 2 + σ ccp ⋅ f ctd − ( 2 ) σ ccp > σ c ,lim
- 145 -
Chapter 7
the design value of the maximum shear force which can be sustained by the
VRd,max
member, limited by crushing of the compression struts
coefficient taking into account state of the stress in the compression chord,
α cw see note 3 in clause 6.2.3(3) in EN 1992-1-1. The value 1 is always taken
into account for non -prestressed structures
inner lever arm of cross-section recalculated to direction of shear forces res-
z
ultant, see "Inner lever arm for shear check" on page 193
strength reduction factor for concrete cracked in shear loaded from Man-
ager for National annexes, see note 1 and 2in clause 6.2.3(3) in EN 1992-
1-1.
ν1 = ν σ wd > 0, 8 ⋅ f ywk
ν1
ν1 = 0, 6 σ wd ≤ 0, 8 ⋅ f ywk a d f ck ≤ 60MPa
f ck
ν1 = 0, 9 − > 0, 5 σ wd ≤ 0, 8 ⋅ f ywk a d f ck > 60MPa
200
- 146 -
Design
For member with inclined chords the additional forces haves to be taken into account for
shear check according to clause 6.2.1(1). The calculation is prepared for taking into
account also inclined chords. Nevertheless the calculation itself is not implemented yet. The
partial components are explained in the following figure.
As was mentioned above, there exists general concept of “strut-and-tie” model for the prediction of torsion effects in con-
crete. In this model, the top compression and bottom tensile members represent the compressive concrete and tensile rein-
forcement, respectively. The procedure for design can be represented by diagram below:
- 147 -
Chapter 7
The formulas which are used for the calculation of each component of this model are the following.
Torsional cracking moment is calculated according to equation 6..26 in EN 1992-1-1 ,provided that the stress caused by tor-
sional moment is equal to design axial tensile strength of concrete (value fctd). It follows:
T Rdc = 2 ⋅ f ctd ⋅ t ef ⋅ A k
Maximum of torsional resistance moment (TRd,max ) is determined according to formula 6.30 in EN 1992-1-1.
T Rd .max = 2 ⋅ ν ⋅ α cw ⋅ f cd ⋅ A k ⋅ t ef ⋅ cos( θ ) ⋅ sin( θ )
Statically required cross-sectional area of the shear reinforcement per meter is calculated according to formula below:
Aswt .re T Ed
A swm.req = =
s l .re 2 ⋅ A k ⋅f ywd ⋅ cot(θ )
Design torsional resistance moment of torsional reinforcement (TRd,st ) is calculated according to formula below
T Rdst = 2 ⋅ A k ⋅ ( )⋅f
Aswt
st ywd ⋅ cot( θ )
Final design value of torsional moment(TRd ) carried by member is calculated based on the following formulas
l for member without or with only detailing stirrups for torsion(Aswm.req =0)
- 148 -
Design
T Rd = T Rd , c ≤ T Rd .max
where
- 149 -
Chapter 7
Only minimum reinforcement is required (see provided that the following condition (equation 6.31 in EN 1992-1- 1) is sat-
isfied:
T Ed V Ed
+ ≤1
T Rd ,c V Rd ,c
The maximum resistance of a member subjected to torsion and shear is limited by the capacity of the concrete struts. In
order not to exceed this resistance the following condition (equation 6.29 in EN 1992-1-1) should be satisfied:
T Ed V Ed
+ ≤1
T Rd ,max V Rd ,max
Statically required cross-sectional area of the shear reinforcement per meter is calculated according to formulas
Asw .re V Ed
A swm1.req = =
s l .re z ⋅ f ywd ⋅ (cot(θ ) + cot( α )) ⋅ sin( α )
T Ed V Ed
Aswt .re +
2 ⋅Ak ns ⋅ z
A swm2 req = =
s l .re f ywd ⋅ cot(θ )
The force in shear reinforcement caused by shear and torsion effect can be calculated according to formula
- 150 -
Design
Fswd = ( T Ed
2 ⋅ Ak
+
V Ed
ns ⋅ z )⋅ st
cot(θ )
The maximum force which, can be carried by shear reinforcement is give by formula:
Fswd ,max = A swt ⋅ f ywd
where
- 151 -
Chapter 7
Additional tensile forces caused by torsion are calculated from the equation 6.28 in EN 1992-1-1 :
T Ed
Fsdt = ⋅ u k ⋅ cot( θ )
2 ⋅ Ak
where
The required cross-sectional area of the longitudinal reinforcement for torsion is calculated in case, that sum of design axial
forces (NEd) and Additional tensile forces caused by torsion (Fsdt ) is tensile (bigger than 0). This area is calculated by using
biaxial method for design, see "Biaxial method for design" on page 137 with following preconditions:
- 152 -
Design
In a simplified way said, the longitudinal reinforcement for torsion is designed according to formula below,
F dt
∆A s =
σd
where
Additional tensile forces caused by shear forces is taken into account in design of statically
required reinforcement by shifting of bending moments, see "Additional tensile forces
caused by shear and torsion (shifting of bending moments)" on page 107
- 153 -
Chapter 8
Practical reinforcement
- 154 -
Check
Check
Checks
First you get an overview of the input data for the checks:
l Capacity check for N-My -Mz interaction - based on resistance calculated from interaction diagram
l Response check - based on check of ultimate stresses and strains for N-My -Mz interaction
l Check of shear and torsion
l Check of interaction of shear, torsion, bending and normal force
Stiffness
Introduction
The behaviour of reinforced concrete is not linear-elastic, even with loads within working stress limits, and it is therefore
necessary to adjust either E or I depending on the magnitude of the applied load. In addition concrete is subjected to sig-
nificant long term strains due to creep and shrinkage, which will affect the curvature and stiffness of a reinforced concrete
structures.This chapter describes how the curvature and stiffness of a reinforced concrete section is calculated.
Stiffness presentation command is used for presentation of calculated stiffness. The procedure for calculation of stiffness is
based on the requirements mentioned in chapter 7.4.3 from EN 1992-1-1. Generally, two states of cross-section are con-
sidered:
l I) uncracked cross-section - which is loaded below the level when tensile strength of concrete is reached, here the
cross-section with tensile strength is used
l II) fully cracked cross-section - which is loaded above the level when tensile strength of concrete is reached, here the
cross-section without tensile strength is used
The stiffness is decreased when the load achieve cracking moment (M y,cr ). The dependency of stiffness on cracking
moment is visible from the following figure. The curve is not linear due to tensile stiffening which partly higher then cross-sec-
tion completely without tensile strength
- 155 -
Chapter 9
The behaviour of the reinforced cross-section can be also expressed in term of moment and strain (deformation) diagram.
The final value of stiffness is calculated using interpolation formula between state (I) deformation for uncracked concrete
section (x=0)and state (II) deformation for fully cracked concrete section (no tension carries) (x=1)dependently on the ratio
of stress in reinforcement from cracking load and acting load.The dependency of cracking moment on strain in concrete is
visible from the following figure.
- 156 -
Check
The distribution of the reinforcement stress in crack and between cracks can be graphically expressed on the following fig-
ure. Reinforcement stress is higher in crack and concrete stress is zero in crack. The final values of stiffness is dependent on
the tension stiffening of concrete in cracks based on distribution coefficient.
- 157 -
Chapter 9
The plane of the equilibrium is calculated for particular state of cross-section using method described in chapter "Theoretical
background" on page 163 . There are used different stress-strain diagram towards the Capacity- response (ULS). Stress-
strain diagram based on the serviceability limit state are used for the finding of the plain of the equilibrium. Generally, this
command uses the iterative method for the interaction of the normal force (N) with uni-axial or bi- axial bending moments
(My + M z ). Additionally, there is possibility to calculate short-term or long-term stiffness which is applied via modified stress-
strain diagram.
Assumptions
The same preconditions are used for calculation as mentioned in chapter "Assumption and limitations" on page 203
SCIA Engineer is able to calculate short-term or long-term stiffness. This type depends on setting in Global settings - Solver
settings - General - SLS - Use effective modulus of elasticity.
- 158 -
Check
Theory
The calculation procedure can be described in the following steps:
1) Calculation of uncracked cross-section
The cross- section characteristics for uncracked cross-section (using the linear stress- strain diagram with a tensile branch
for concrete and reinforcement) are calculated. This state is signed with bottom index I
.
- 159 -
Chapter 9
σ normal concrete stress on un-cracked section at the most tensioned fiber of con-
ct
crete cross-section
σ is value of strength for determination if crack width will be calculated or not, see
cr
chapter "Value of strength for calculation of cracking forces" on page 212
When the cracks appear then the following steps are done
4) Calculation of cracking internal forces
The cracking internal forces are calculated based on the uncracked CSS characteristics and tensile concrete strength. After-
wards, these cracking forces are used for calculation of stress in reinforcement (σsr).
5) Calculation of distribution coefficient
Beforehand the distribution coefficient is calculated the reinforcement stress for acting load (σs ) and for cracking load (σsr )
has to be known. There is coefficient β which is determined according to duration of the load:
β = 1,0 - for short-term load
β = 0,5 - for long-term load (based on using Use effective modulus of concrete = true)
- 160 -
Check
The distribution coefficient (in fact coefficient of tension stiffening) is calculated based on the type of load (β) and also on the
ratio of reinforcement stress for cracking and acting load
x=1-β•(σsr/σs )2
6) Calculation of fully cracked cross-section
The cross-section characteristic for full cracked cross- section (using linear stress- strain diagram without tensile branch for
concrete and reinforcement) are calculated. This state is signed with bottom index II.
axial stiffness,
- 161 -
Chapter 9
and curvatures.
Output values
There are presented the following output values:
Setup
The same values which are used for stress limitations are used for Stiffness calculation (see chapter Stress limitation -
"Setup" on page 208 These values are:
List of Errors
Number Type Description Description/Solution
Plane of equilibrium was To increase amount of reinforcement or to increase dimensions of cross-section or to increase
E0/1 Error
not found. quality of the used materials
List of Warnings
Number Type Description Description/Solution
The selected combination is not serviceability - char- Please change type of combination to serviceability - char-
W5/3 Warning
acteristic acteristic
The selected combination is not serviceability - quasi- Please change type of combination to serviceability - quasi-
W5/4 Warning
permanent permanent
List of Notes
Number Type Description Description/Solution
The calculation was not done (because numerical cross-section, phased
N0/1 Note
cross-section, member or cross-section with different material as concrete
- 162 -
Check
l The area of longitudinal reinforcement is not subtracted from concrete area in the first step
Theoretical background
Calculation procedure
Imagine a diagram representing the strain in a reinforced concrete cross-section. Generally, the cross-section can be non-
symmetric to y or z axis and loaded with a combination of N, My and Mz. Then the vector of strain consists of three nonzero
values ε = {εx ; εy , εz }. This vector determines so called plane of deformation (see following figure). More information can
be found in VONDRÁČEK, R.: Numerical Methods in Nonlinear Concrete Design, Diploma thesis, 2000.
- 163 -
Chapter 9
Corresponding plane of strain for plane of equilibrium in one plane bending only (My) is shown in following figure. Never-
theless, the distribution of the stress in compression part depends on type of stress-strain diagram of concrete. When bilin-
ear diagram is used then distribution is constant or linear constant. In case of parabola- rectangular diagram the stress
distribution is constant or linear-parabola.
The previous figure shows a non specific case, but let us imagine an ultimate state. Under the ultimate state, we understand
a case, where either concrete or steel is strained to limit value. We can draw some cases in a similar diagram. The basic
assumptions of this limit strain method show the following figure. Generally, four limit strain states can occur. The numbering
(1-4) in the following figure represents particular state types of the cross-section. The state (1) corresponds to the optimal
failure when ultimate compressive strain in concrete (εcu) and ultimate tensile strain in reinforcement (εud) are reached. In
case of state (2), the ultimate limit strain in concrete is assumed within considering the strain in prestressing at the beginning
of plastic branch (ε s ). The state (3) expresses the starting of the concrete crushing. Finally, the state (4) represents the
reaching of ultimate compressive strain for axially loaded member decreased due to brittle failure effect.
The following checks are performed
verification of strains
verification of stresses
- 164 -
Check
verification of strains
verification of stresses
verification of strains
verification of stresses
- 165 -
Chapter 9
Output values
There are presented the following output values:
- 166 -
Check
l The most compressive fibre can not be determined (the whole cross-section is in tension)
l Resultant of forces in tensile reinforcement can not be determined (whole section is in compression)
l equilibrium is not found
l distance of the most compressive fibre and Resultant of forces in tensile reinforcement is lesser than 0,5⋅h
where
is coefficient for calculation effective depth of cross-section loaded form Concrete setup, if effective
Coef
d depth of cross-section is not possible to calculate from plane of equilibrium ). Default value is 0,9.
h is height of cross-section perpendicular to neutral axis.
l
If there are the most compressive concrete fibres with the same value of compressive
stress, the fibre which is the nearest to straight line in direction resultant of bending moment
and crossing the centre of gravity of cross- section, is taken into account for calculation
effective depth .
l part of inner lever arm (distance from centre of tensile force to centre of gravity of cross-section) – value z+ or projection
this value to straight line perpendicular to neutral axis – value zrec+
l is part of inner lever arm (distance from centre of compressive force to to centre of gravity of cross-section)– value z- or
projection this value to straight line perpendicular to neutral axis – value zrec-
There are some exceptional cases, when inner lever arm is not calculated from plane of equilibrium:
l The most compressive fibre can not be determined (the whole cross-section is in tension)
l Resultant of forces in tensile reinforcement can not be determined (whole section is in compression)
l equilibrium is not found
In this cases, the inner lever arm and parts of inner lever arm is calculated according to formula
z=zrec = Coefz ⋅d
z+=zrec+=z- =zrec - = 0.5⋅z
- 167 -
Chapter 9
where
is coefficient for calculation inner lever arm of cross-section loaded form Concrete setup, if inner
Coef lever arm of cross-section is not possible to calculate from plane of equilibrium ). Default value is
z
0,9.
d Is effective depth of cross-section
List of Errors
Number Type Description Description/Solution
To increase amount of reinforcement or to increase dimensions of
E0/1 Error Plane of equilibrium was not found.
cross-section or to increase quality of the used materials
The maximum value of the characteristic concrete cyl- To decrease value of the characteristic concrete cylinder strength
E0/2 Error
inder strength was exceeded of used material or change of limit in concrete setup
The minimum value of the characteristic concrete cyl- To increase value of the characteristic concrete cylinder strength
E0/3 Error
inder strength was exceeded of used material or change of limit in concrete setup
The maximum value of the characteristic yield strength To decrease value of the characteristic yield strength of non-
E0/4 Error
of non-prestressed reinforcement was exceeded prestressed reinforcement or change of limit in concrete setup
To increase amount of reinforcement or to increase dimensions of
E0/5 Error Limit strain of concrete was exceeded
cross-section or to increase quality of the used materials
List of Notes
Number Type Description Description/Solution
The calculation was not done (because numerical crosssection, phased cross-section, member or
N0/1 Note
cross-section with different material as concrete material is used)
N0/2 Note The prestressed reinforcement is not taken into account
- 168 -
Check
National annexes
There are the following changes in check response related to material characteristic dependent on national annexes
Chapter 2.4.2.4 - Partial safety factor for concrete (γc ) and reinforcement (γs ) for permanent, tran-
sient and accidental design situation
There are the following differences in particular NA.
Permanent and transient Accidental
National annex
γ γ γ γ
c s c s
Standard NA 1,5 1,15 1,2 1,0
Polish PN-NA 1,40 1,15 1,2 1,0
German DIN NA 1,5 1,15 1,3 1,0
Chapter 3.1.6 (1)(2)- Coefficients taken into account longterm effects on compressive (α cc ) and
tensile (α ct) strength according to EN1992-1-1
There are the following differences in particular NA.
National annex α α
cc ct
Standard NA 1,0 1,00
German DIN-NA 0,85 0,85
Finnish SFS – EN NA 0,85 1,00
Belgian NBN – NA 0,85 1,00
Greek ELOT – EN NA 0,85 1,00
0,85 for compression in flexure and for axial loading
British BS – EN NA and Irish – EN NA 1,00
1,0 for other cases
- 169 -
Chapter 9
Assumptions
Assumptions and limitations
There are the following assumptions:
- 170 -
Check
l The area of longitudinal reinforcement is not subtracted from concrete area in the first step
Theoretical background
First the section is in pure compressions, then it will be over- reinforced until it reaches the point where it is balanced
designed. After the point of balanced design the section will reach pure bending, then under-reinforced and finally will be in
pure tension.
Generally the interaction diagram is used to find the capacities for the checked cross-section. The searching of capacities
depends on used method for finding intersection with interaction diagram. This method can be the following:
l NRd - the bending moment My and Mz are constant and the intersections are searched in the vertical direction
l MRd - the normal force N t is constant and the intersections are searched in horizontal direction
l NRdMRd - the used eccentricity is constant and the intersections are searched in direction of constant eccentricity
l MRdy - the bending moment around z axis and normal force are constant and the intersections are searched in hori-
zontal direction in plane N-My
l MRdz - the bending moment around y axis and normal force are constant and the intersections are searched in vertical
direction in plane N-Mz
See the example of interaction diagram sections for particular method type:
- 171 -
Chapter 9
- 172 -
Check
- 173 -
Chapter 9
- 174 -
Check
- 175 -
Chapter 9
- 176 -
Check
Output values
There are presented the following output values:
- 177 -
Chapter 9
Setup
There are several parameters which affect generation of the horizontal and vertical cuts of interaction diagrams. These val-
ues are stored in Concrete settings (structure). The parameters for interaction diagram are the following:
Interaction diagram method - this option enable to select appropriate interaction diagram method. The following
approaches can be applied:
- 178 -
Check
Division of strain - this option explain precision of calculation of diagram point during generation of vertical cuts. The value
means how many times the strain plane is readjusted from the position of section under full compression to the position of
section under full tension.The value influences the accuracy and the speed of calculation
Default value = 250. with limits <0;10000>.
Number of points in vertical cuts - number of direction (number of "branches") in which interaction diagram is cal-
culated during generation of interaction diagram.
Default value = 36. with limits <0;10000>.
- 179 -
Chapter 9
List of Errors
Number Type Description Description/Solution
The combination of internal forces is outside Change (a) the dimensions of the cross-section, (b) the amount of rein-
E6/1 Error
of interaction diagram surface forcement and/or (c) the quality of the used materials.
List of Warnings
Number Type Description Description/Solution
There is no intersection between the interaction diagram sur- Change (a) the dimensions of the cross-section, (b) the
W6/1 Warning face and the section plane, according to the selected method amount of reinforcement and/or (c) the quality of the used
of check. materials.
Change (a) the dimensions of the cross-section, (b) the
It's not possible to generate the horizontal section M -M
W6/2 Warning y z amount of reinforcement and/or (c) the quality of the used
because N is outside the maximal or minimal capacity N .
Ed Rd materials.
It's not possible to generate the vertical section N-M Change (a) the dimensions of the cross-section, (b) the
z
W6/3 Warning because M is outside the maximal or minimal capacity amount of reinforcement and/or (c) the quality of the used
Edy
M . materials.
Rdy
List of Notes
Number Type Description Description/Solution
The calculation was not done (because numerical crosssection, phased cross-section,
N0/1 Note
member or cross-section with different material as concrete material is used)
N0/2 Note The prestressed reinforcement is not taken into account
N0/3 Note The "Free bars " reinforcement is not taken into account
There is some detailing longitudinal reinforcement, which is not taken into account for the
N0/4 Note
ULS and SLS check
There is some detailing stirrups, which is not taken into account for the check shear and tor-
N0/5 Note
sion
N2/1 Note The normal forces and bending moments are zero (N =0,M =0,M =0)
Ed Edy Edz
Unity check value is zero because N is also zero and the selected method for the check is Change method of check to
N6/1 Note Ed
N . M ,N M ,M or M .
Rd Rd Rd Rd Rdy Rdz
Unity check value is zero because M is also zero and the selected method for the check Change method of check to
N6/2 Note Edy
is M . M , N M or M .
Rdy Rd Rd Rd Rdz
Unity check value is zero because M is also zero and the selected method for the check Change method of check to
N6/3 Note Edz
is M . M , N M or M .
Rdz Rd Rd Rd Rdy
- 180 -
Check
National annexes
Chapter 12.3.1(1) - Coefficients taken into account longterm effects on compressive (α cc,pl) and
tensile (α ct,pl) strength of plain or lightly reinforced concrete according to EN1992-1-1
There are the following differences in particular NA.
National annex α α
cc,pl ct,pl
Standard NA 0,80 0,80
Finnish SFS – EN NA 0,80 0,60
Irish – EN NA 0,80 0,60
Swedish 1,00 0,50
Singaporean 0,60 0,80
The all check area calculated according to clause 6.1 -6.3 in EN 1992-1- 1. The following preconditions are used for cal-
culation :
l The checks are calculated for beams and columns and for general load (N+My+Mz)
l Cross-section with one polygon and one material is taken into account in version Scia Engineer 15
l The material of all reinforcement bars and stirrups have to be same in Scia Engineer 15
l The checks should be used only in case, that the angle between gradient of the strain plane and the resultant of shear
forces is not greater than 15 degrees
- 181 -
Chapter 9
l Automatic -then program calculates equivalent thin-walled cross-section according one method below. It means that pro-
gram tries to create equivalent thin-walled cross-section from stirrup for torsion at first, and if this method is not suc-
cessful, program uses method based on shape of cross-section. This is the default setting.
l From stirrups for torsion - program tries to create equivalent thin-walled cross-section around stirrup, where check box
Torsion is ON, see "Stirrup for torsion" on page 186. If equivalent thin-walled cross-section was not successful created or
stirrup for torsion is not defined, program finishes with some warning/error. This method is not supported for design of
shear reinforcement, because user(practical) reinforcement is not taken into account and therefore for design method
From used Css- is used, if this method is selected.
l From used Css. The program tries to create equivalent thin-walled cross-section from current cross-section by offsetting
the value tef . If equivalent thin-walled cross-section was not successfully created program finishes with warning/error.
l From the effective rectangular cross-section. The program tries to create an equivalent rectangular concrete thin-walled
cross-section the perimeter and area of which are the same as the perimeter and area of the original cross-section. It fol-
lows, that effective rectangular cross-section with the following dimension will be created:
2
u + u − 16 ⋅ A
h ef =
4
- 182 -
Check
b ef = A / h ef
where
If equivalent thin-walled cross-section was not successfully created program finishes with some warning/error.
l User input - equivalent thin-walled cross-section can be defined directly by the user, it means, that user has to define fol-
lowing properties:
l area of thin-walled cross-section (Ak,user)
l outer circumference of thin-walled cross-section (uk,user)
l effective wall thickness (tef,user)
This method is available only in 1D concrete member data. If the member is not prismatic (arbitrary member or member
with haunches), equivalent thin walled cross-section is recalculated to each section of the member according to formulas
below:
A k ,user
A ki = A i ⋅
Am
u k ,user
u ki = u i ⋅
um
Ai um
t efi = ⋅ ⋅ t ef , user
ui Am
where
- 183 -
Chapter 9
The user (practical) reinforcement is not taken into account for design of shear rein-
forcement, therefore when method From stirrups for torsion is used, the thin-walled cross-
section from current cross-section is created
l coefficient of effective depth of cross-section, see "Coefficient for calculation of effective depth of cross-section" on page
98
l coefficient of inner lever arm, see "Coefficient for calculation of lever arm" on page 98
l angle of concrete compression strut, see "Angle between concrete compression strut and beam axis" on page 99
l angle of shear reinforcement , see "Angle of shear reinforcement" on page 100
l type for determination equivalent thin-walled cross-section, see "Equivalent thin-walled closed cross-section" on page
181
- 184 -
Check
The stirrups around section are taking into account on a length corresponding to horizontal projection of a length of com-
pression strut (the width of concrete strut), which can be calculated according to formula
δ = z ⋅ cot( θ )
where
is inner lever arm of cross-section , see "Inner lever arm for shear check" on page
z
193
Angle between concrete compression strut and beam axis perpendicular to the
θ shear force, see "Angle between concrete compression strut and beam axis" on
page 99
l Automatically calculation – the number of links is calculated as number of intersections of stirrup with straight line per-
pendicular to direction of shear force resultant, where this line is crossing the centre of polygon
- 185 -
Chapter 9
There is taken into account for torsional check only the stirrup where check box Torsion is ON. This check box can be
switched ON/OFF in dialogue Stirrup shape (action button Edit stirrup shape in properties of Stirrup or in library of stirrups).
- 186 -
Check
Only one stirrup can be taken into account for check of torsion in Scia Engineer 15.
As it was mentioned, there is a possibility to define more stirrup zones (more stirrups) around section with different prop-
erties, therefore it is necessary to calculate average characteristic. The average characteristics are calculated from stirrups
within calculated interval, see"Determination stirrups around section" on page 185 and in this calculation distance of stirrups
from the section (value ∆) is taken into account. It means that stirrup , which is nearer to the section has bigger influence on
average values than stirrup with bigger distance.
The shear reinforcement in Scia Engineer can be inputted via REDES (stirrup zone) and via Free bars. There is possibility
to input more stirrup zones and more free bras(stirrups) to member with different parameters. Therefore it is very important
to set the region for taking into account stirrups around the section and to calculate average characteristics of shear rein-
forcement for shear check.
- 187 -
Chapter 9
Calculation procedure
As mentioned above, it exists general concept of "strut-and- tie" model for the prediction of shear effects in concrete. In this
model, the top compression and bottom tensile members represent the compressive concrete and tensile reinforcement,
respectively. The horizontal members are connected by the compressive virtual struts and reinforcement tensile ties. The
axial forces in tensile ties should be transmitted by the shear reinforcement. Consequently, the maximal force in concrete
struts (VRd,max ) and shear force retained by the shear resistance (V Rd,s ) have to be compared with acting shear force
(VEd). The procedure for check can be represented by diagram below:
The formulas which are used for the calculation of each component of this model are the following. Generally, there are two
possibilities for calculation of shear capacity of concrete dependently on existence of cracked in bending:
Shear concrete capacity in region cracked in bending - formula 6.2.a,b in EN 1992-1-1
- 188 -
Check
Additionally, there is calculated maximal shear force (VEd,max ) ) without reduction by β for member where load is applied in
the upper side of the member (see formula 6.5 in EN 1992-1-1).
VEd .max = 0.5 ⋅ b w1 ⋅ d ⋅ ν ⋅ f cd
Maximal capacity of concrete compressive strut (VRd,max ) is determined according to formula 6.9 in EN 1992-1-1, because
as has been mentioned before, the angle of stirrups (θ) is always perpendicular to member axis.
α cw ⋅ b w 1 ⋅ z ⋅ ν 1 ⋅ f cd
VRd ,max =
cot( θ ) + tan( θ )
Design value of shear force sustained by shear reinforcement (VRd,s ) is calculated according to formula 6.13 in EN 1992-1-
1
Asw
VRd , s = ⋅ z ⋅ f ywd ⋅ (cot( θ ) + cot( α )) ⋅ sin( α )
s
Final design value of shear force (VRd ) carried by member is calculated based on the following formulas depending on type
of member and area of shear reinforcement.
l for beam as slab and for other member with only detailing stirrups (Asw =0)
VRd = VRd , s + Vtd + Vccd ≤ min(VRd .max , VEd ,max ) + Vtd + Vccd
where
- 189 -
Chapter 9
N Ed
σ cp = ≤ 0, 2 ⋅ f cd
Ac
σ ccp − σ c ,lim 2
f cvd = f ctd 2 + σ ccp ⋅ f ctd − ( 2 ) σ ccp > σ c ,lim
- 190 -
Check
design value of the shear force which can be sustained by the yielding
VRd,s
shear reinforcement.
the cross-sectional area of the shear reinforcement calculated as aver-
Asw age area from all stirrups within calculated interval, see "Calculation of
average characteristics of shear reinforcement" on page 187
the spacing of the stirrups calculated as average area from all stirrups
s within calculated interval, see "Calculation of average characteristics of
shear reinforcement" on page 187
the design yield strength of the shear reinforcement.
fywd
f ywd = 0, 8 ⋅ f ywk σ wd ≤ 0, 8 ⋅ f ywk
For member with inclined chords the additional forces haves to be taken into account for
shear check according to clause 6.2.1(1). The calculation is prepared for taking into
account also inclined chords. Nevertheless the calculation itself is not implemented yet. The
partial components are explained in the following figure.
- 191 -
Chapter 9
l value bw – this value is calculated as the smallest width of the cross-section in tensile area of cross-section perpendicular
to direction of resultant shear force. This value is used for calculation shear resistance of concrete (VRdc ) according to
clause 6.2.2(1)
l value bw1 – this value is calculated as minimum width of cross-section between tension and compression chord per-
pendicular to direction of shear force. These values are used for calculation:
l design value of maximum shear force VEd,max (calculation without reduction β), clause 6.2.2(6)
l design value of maximum shear force limited by crushing of the compression struts (VRd,max ), clause 6.2.3(3,4)
l design value of shear force carried by shear reinforcement (VRds ), clause 6.2.3(3,4)
l the most compressive fibre can not be determined (the whole cross-section is in tension)
l resultant of force in tensile reinforcement can not be determined (whole section is in compression)
- 192 -
Check
where
Inner lever arm in EN 1992-1-1, clause 6.2.3 (3) is defined as distance of forces in tensile and compression chord, it follows
that it is distance of position resultant of tensile force (tensile reinforcement) and position of resultant of compressive force
(compressive reinforcement and compressive concrete). In EN code it is not defined how to calculate inner lever arm if dif-
ference between direction of resultant of bending moment and resultant of shear force is significant. Therefore in Scia Enign-
eer is used the same principle as for calculation of effective depth, it means that inner lever arm is calculated as projection to
direction of shear force resultant. There are some exceptional cases, when inner lever arm is not calculated from plane of
equilibrium:
l the most compressive fibre can not be determined (the whole cross-section is in tension)
l resultant of forces in tensile reinforcement can not be determined (whole section is in compression)
l equilibrium is not found
where
- 193 -
Chapter 9
It is very important for shear check to calculate cross- section characteristics which have influence to shear resistances. It
means the following characteristics:
l width of cross-section for shear check (value bw and bw1), see "Width of cross-section for shear check" on page 192
l effective depth of cross-section (value d), see "Effective depth of cross-section for shear check" on page 192
l inner lever arm (value z), see "Inner lever arm for shear check" on the previous page
The EN code gives these values to relation with bending load, but there is problem to calculate these values, if difference
between direction of resultant of bending moments and resultant of shear forces is significant. In this case the code EN does
not give any recommendation. Therefore in Scia Engineer, if the angle between resultant of bending moments and res-
ultant of shear forces is greater than 15 degrees, the program gives the warning and in this case the more sophisticated
method (for example biaxial shear method) should be used.
Shear check
The shear check is commonly based on the theory of the concrete truss-model. In this theory a virtual truss-model is ima-
gined in a concrete beam. This truss-model has a set of vertical (or slightly diagonal), horizontal and diagonal members. The
vertical bars are considered to be the stirrups; the horizontal bars are the main reinforcement and the diagonal bars are the
concrete struts. The check of biaxial shear is calculated according to preconditions in clause 6.2 in EN 1992-1-1.
l The shear forces in both direction is taken into account and shear check is done for resultant of shear force
l The parameters of plane of equilibrium (value, d, z and h) are recalculated to direction of resultant shear force
l The design shear resistance of the member without shear reinforcement (VRd,c ) is calculated according to clause 6.2.2
(1) in EN 1992-1-1, if section is cracked in flexure, otherwise clause 12.6.3 in EN 1992-1-1 is used
l Design value of maximum shear force will be calculated according to clause 6.2.2(6) (VEd,max ) and 6.2.3 (3,4) (VRd,max )
in EN 1992-1-1
- 194 -
Check
l Design value of shear resistance is calculated according to 6.2.3 (3,4) (VRd,s ) in EN 1992-1-1
l The number of shear link can be calculated automatically or defined by user (in properties of stirrup zone), see "Cal-
culation number of stirrup link (number of cuts)" on page 185
l The angle of compression strut can be calculated automatically or defined by user, see "Angle between concrete com-
pression strut and beam axis" on page 99
l The angle of stirrups for check is always perpendicular to member axis.
Calculation procedure
As mentioned above, there exists general concept of “strut-and-tie” model for the prediction of torsional effects in concrete.
In this model, the top compression and bottom tensile members represent the compressive concrete and tensile rein-
forcement, respectively. The horizontal members are connected by the compressive virtual struts and reinforcement tensile
ties. . Consequently, the maximum of torsional resistance moment carried by concrete strut (T Rd,max ) and torsional
moment retained by the torsional resistance (T Rd,s ) have to be compared with acting torsional moment TEd ). The pro-
cedure for check can be represented by diagram below:
- 195 -
Chapter 9
The formulas which are used for the calculation of each component of this model are the following.
Torsional cracking moment is calculated according to equation 6..26 in EN 1992-1-1 ,provided that the stress caused by tor-
sional moment is equal to design axial tensile strength of concrete (value fctd). It follows:
T Rdc = 2 ⋅ f ctd ⋅ t ef ⋅ A k
Maximum of torsional resistance moment (TRd,max ) is determined according to formula 6.30 in EN 1992-1-1.
T Rd .max = 2 ⋅ ν ⋅ α cw ⋅ f cd ⋅ A k ⋅ t ef ⋅ cos( θ ) ⋅ sin( θ )
Design torsional resistance moment of torsional reinforcement (TRd,st ) is calculated according to formula below
T Rdst = 2 ⋅ A k ⋅ ( )⋅f
Aswt
st ywd ⋅ cot( θ )
Final design value of torsional moment(TRd ) carried by member is calculated based on the following formulas
l for member without or with only detailing stirrups for torsion(Aswt =0)
T Rd = T Rd , c ≤ T Rd .max
- 196 -
Check
where
The torsional resistance of sections is calculated on the basis of a thin-walled closed section, even if the section is actually
solid. For solid members, the section is idealized as a thin- walled section. There are several options for generation of thin -
walled cross-section in Scia Engineer, see "Equivalent thin-walled closed cross-section" on page 181
- 197 -
Chapter 9
where
the total area of the cross-section within the outer circumference, includ-
A
ing inner hollow areas
u the outer circumference of the cross-section
minimal distance between edge and centre of the longitudinal rein-
asl
forcement.
The important parameters for check of torsion calculated from the centre line of the effective thin-walled cross-section are:
l the area enclosed by the centre-lines of the thin-walled cross-section, including inner hollow areas (value Ak )
l the circumference of the centre line thin-walled cross-section (uk )
Torsion check
In normal building structures, torsion generally arises as a secondary effect, and specific calculations are not necessary. Tor-
sional cracking is generally adequately controlled by reinforcement provided to resist shear. Even when torsion occurs, it
rarely controls the basic sizing of the members, and torsion check is often a check calculation after the members have been
checked for flexure. In some cases, the loading that causes the maximum torsional moment may not be same that induces
the maximum flexural effect. In some cases, reinforcement provided for flexure and the other forces may prove adequate to
resist torsion.
The torsion check is commonly based on the theory of the concrete truss- model too. In this theory a virtual truss- model is
imagined in a concrete beam. This truss-model has a set of vertical (or slightly diagonal), horizontal and diagonal members.
The vertical bars are considered to be the stirrups; the horizontal bars are the main reinforcement and the diagonal bars are
the concrete struts.
- 198 -
Check
l The parameters of plane of equilibrium (value, d, z and h) are recalculated to direction of resultant shear force
l The torsional cracking moment (TRd,c ) is calculated according to clause 6.3.2(5) in EN 1992-1-1
l Design value of maximum of torsional resistance moment (TRd,max )is calculated according to clause 6.3.2(4) in EN
1992-1-1
l The angle of compression strut can be calculated automatically or defined by user, see "Angle between concrete com-
pression strut and beam axis" on page 99
l The angle of stirrups for check is always perpendicular to member axis.
l There are 5 possibility for calculation thin-walled closed section, see "Equivalent thin-walled closed cross-section" on
page 181
Calculation procedure
As mentioned above, there exists general concept of “strut-and-tie” model for the prediction of shear and torsional effects in
concrete. In this model, the top compression and bottom tensile members represent the compressive concrete and tensile
reinforcement, respectively. The horizontal members are connected by the compressive virtual struts and reinforcement
tensile ties. .The procedure for check interaction of shear and torsion can be represented by diagram below:
- 199 -
Chapter 9
Only minimum reinforcement is required (see provided that the following condition (equation 6.31 in EN 1992-1- 1) is sat-
isfied:
T Ed V Ed
+ ≤1
T Rd ,c V Rd ,c
The maximum resistance of a member subjected to torsion and shear is limited by the capacity of the concrete struts. In
order not to exceed this resistance the following condition (equation 6.29 in EN 1992-1-1) should be satisfied:
T Ed V Ed
+ ≤1
T Rd ,max V Rd ,max
The force in shear reinforcement caused by shear and torsion effect can be calculated according to formula
Fswd = ( T Ed
2 ⋅ Ak
+
V Ed
ns ⋅ z )⋅ st
cot(θ )
The maximum force which, can be carried by shear reinforcement is give by formula:
Fswd ,max = A swt ⋅ f ywd
The additional tensile force in longitudinal reinforcement caused by shear and torsion is calculated according to formula:
Fsd = ( T Ed
2 ⋅ Ak )
⋅ u k + VEd ⋅ cot( θ )
The maximum force which, can be carried by longitudinal reinforcement is give by formula:
Fsd ,max = A sl .tor ⋅ f yd
- 200 -
Check
where
- 201 -
Chapter 9
l The special assumptions for shear check are described in "Shear check" on page 194.
l Assumptions for check torsion are described in "Torsion check" on page 198
l Only minimum reinforcement is required provided that condition clause 6.3.2(5) in EN 1992-1-1 is satisfied:
l The maximum resistance of a member subjected to torsion and shear is limited by the capacity of the concrete struts. In
order not to exceed this resistance the condition in clause 6.3.2(4) in EN 1992-1-1 should be satisfied
l Inclined compression chord or inclined tensile chord are not taken into account
l The widths of cross-section for shear checks (value bw and bw1) are calculated automatically. There is no possibility for
definition of user value in Scia Engineer 15
l only one stirrup can be taken into account for torsion check, see "Stirrup for torsion" on page 186
l Free bars reinforcement is not taken into account
l The area of longitudinal reinforcement is not subtracted from concrete area.
- 202 -
Check
Abbreviations
StartWritingHere
Literature
StartWritingHere
Introduction
Stress limitation (SLS) check is based on the calculation of stresses in particular component (concrete fibre, reinforcement
bar) and comparison with limited values with respect of EN 1992-1-1 requirements. Based on the internal forces, concrete
cross-section and reinforcement defined by the user, SCIA Engineer is able to calculate the plain of equilibrium of a member
or a single cross-section and find the actual value of stresses in each component.
Generally, stress limitation from the point of the serviceability limit state is based on the verification of the following states:
l compressive stress in concrete - the high value of compressive stress in concrete could lead to appearance of lon-
gitudinal cracks, spreading of micro-cracks in concrete and higher values of creep (mainly non linear) . This effect can led
to state when the structure is unusable.
l tensile stress in reinforcement - stress in reinforcement is verified due to limitation of unacceptable strain existence
and thus appearance of cracks in concrete .
The method described in chapter "Theoretical background" on page 163 is used for determination of the plane of the equi-
librium. There are used different stress-strain diagrams towards the Capacity- response (ULS). Stress- strain diagrams
based on the serviceability limit state are used for the finding of the plain of the equilibrium. This check provides the cal-
culation of the stresses in particular components for each state of cross-section.
Generally, this check uses the iterative method for the interaction of the normal force (N) with uni-axial or bi- axial bending
moments (M y + M z ). Additionally, there is possibility to calculate stresses for short-term or long- term stiffness which is
applied via modified stress-strain diagram.
l The area of longitudinal reinforcement is not subtracted from concrete area in the first step
- 203 -
Chapter 9
As an example the preparation of the stress-strain diagram for C25/30 (fck =25MPa, Ec =31GPa) is visible from the following
figures.
Concrete SLS short-term uncracked
- 204 -
Check
As an example for the reinforcement material the stress- strain diagram for B400 C(fyk = 400MPa, Es =200GPa) is visible
from the following figure.
- 205 -
Chapter 9
Note: The maximal stress in SLS diagram is used as 5 x f ck (f yk ) for concrete, rein-
forcement respectively.
Theoretical background
1) σct ≤σcr - no crack appears; the cross-section is considered as uncracked and SLS linear diagram
with tension is used for another steps of the calculation.
2)σ ct >σ cr - crack appears; the cross- section is considered as cracked; the cross- section is recal-
culated using SLS linear diagram without tension.
where
σ
normal concrete stress on un-cracked section at the most tensioned fibber of concrete cross-section
ct
is value of strength for determination if crack width will be calculated or not, see chapter "Value of strength for cal-
σ
culation of cracking forces" on page 212
cr
- 206 -
Check
this verification is calculated against to longitudinal cracks in concrete and it is provided only for expos-
ure classes XD, XF and XS. Generally, maximal compressive concrete stressσc,char has to be lesser
than maximal allowed compressive concrete strength for characteristic combination σc,char,lim = k1 ˣ
fck . It can be expressed as follows:
σc,char,lim ≤ k1ˣ fck
where k1 is NA parameter, standard value is k1= 0,6.
2) verification of concrete stress under quasi- permanent load according to chapter 7.2
(3)
this verification is calculated against to considering of linear creep only. When the condition is not ful-
filled then non-linear creep calculation should be considered. Generally, maximal compressive con-
crete stressσc,qp has to be lesser than maximal allowed compressive concrete strength for quasi-
permanent combination σc,qp,lim = k2ˣ fck . It can be expressed as follows:
σc,qp,lim ≤ k2ˣ fck
where k2 is NA parameter, standard value is k2= 0,45.
3) verification of reinforcement stress under characteristic load according to chapter 7.2
(5)
this verification is calculated against to considering of unacceptable cracks and deformation in the con-
crete. Generally, maximal reinforcement tensile stressσs,char has to be lesser than maximal allowed
reinforcement tensile strength for characteristic combination σ s,char,lim = k3 ˣ fyk . It can be expressed
as follows:
σs,char,lim ≤ k3ˣ fyk
where k3 is NA parameter, standard value is k3= 0,8.
Additionally, when the stress in reinforcement is caused by an imposed deformation then the maximal
strength is increased to k4ˣ fyk , where k4 is NA parameter, standard value is k4= 1,0.
The option for imposed deformation is described in chapter "Setup" on the next page .
Unity check is maximum from all partial unity checks. It means
Unity check = max (σc,char/σc,char,lim ;σc,qp/σc,qp,lim ;σs,char/σs,char,lim )
The procedure above can be done for short-term or long-term state. It means stress-strain diagram including or not effect-
ive modulus of elasticity can be used. Effective E modulus of elasticity is based on the creep coefficient. and it is calculated as
follows
The coverage of long-term behaviour in the calculation is possible to set in Global settings -
Solver settings - General - SLS - Use effective modulus of elasticity.
- 207 -
Chapter 9
Load cases are considered as standard load used for the stress limitation check
Output values
There are presented the following output values:
Setup
The following items have impact on the calculation of stress limitation check.
Imposed load
Additionally, when the stress in reinforcement is caused by an imposed deformation then the maximal strength is increased
to k4ˣ fyk , where k4 is NA parameter, standard value is k4= 1,0.
The option for imposed deformation is available in Global settings-Solver settings - Stress limitations -Indirect load (imposed
deformation).
- 208 -
Check
0 MPa it means that crack width is calculated if there is some tension in cross-section
it means, that crack width is calculated only in case, that normal concrete stress on un-cracked section at the
fct,eff most tensioned fiber of concrete cross-section is greater the mean value of the tensile strength of the concrete
effective at the time
fctm it means that mean tensile strength of concrete in time 28 days is taken into account, see picture below
it means that the mean flexural tensile strength (EN 1992-1-1,clause 3.1.8(1)) is taken into account. This value
f
should be used if restrained deformations such as shrinkage or temperature movements are taking into account
ctm,fl for calculation of crack width
- 209 -
Chapter 9
The value presented in material properties of concrete (picture above) is mean tensile
strength of concrete in time 28 days. If cracking is expected earlier than 28 days, it is neces-
sary to input value fctm (t) at this time to material properties (EN 1992-1-1,clause 3.1.2(9))
National annex k
1
Standard NA 0,6
Polish PN – EN NA 1,0
0,5 (XD,XF and XS)
Belgian NBN– EN NA
0,6 other exposure classes
Chapter 7.2(3) - Coefficients used for calculation of allowable concrete stress under quasi-per-
manen combination in case of linear creep can be considered according to EN1992-1-1
There are the following differences in particular NA.
National annex k
2
Standard NA 0,45
- 210 -
Check
Chapter 7.2(5) - Coefficients used for calculation of allowable stress under characteristic com-
bination in case of unacceptable cracking or deformation appears according to EN1992-1-1
There are the following differences in particular NA.
National annex k k
3 4
Standard NA 0,8 1,0
Dutch NEN – EN NA 0,0 0,0
Finnish SFS -EN NA 0,6 0,8
Swedish SS - EN NA 1,0 1,0
The following errors, warnings and notes may be occurred during the stiffness calculation.
List of Errors
Number Type Description Description/Solution
To increase amount of reinforcement or to increase dimen-
E0/1 Error Plane of equilibrium was not found. sions of cross-section or to increase quality of the used mater-
ials
Limit concrete strength is exceeded under the characteristic Increase amount of reinforcement, dimensions of the cross-
E5/1 Error
combination of " & State & "-term loads (EN §7.2(2)). section and/or quality of the used materials.
Limit reinforcement strength is exceeded under the char-
Increase amount of reinforcement, dimensions of the cross-
E5/5 Error acteristic combination of " & State & "-term loads (EN §7.2
section and/or quality of the used materials.
(5)).
Limit concrete strength is exceeded under the quasi-per-
Increase amount of reinforcement, dimensions of the cross-
E5/2 Error manent combination of " & State & "-term loads (EN §7.2
section and/or quality of the used materials.
(3)).
List of Warnings
Number Type Description Description/Solution
The selected combination is not serviceability - char- Please change type of combination to serviceability - char-
W5/3 Warning
acteristic acteristic
The selected combination is not serviceability - quasi- Please change type of combination to serviceability - quasi-
W5/4 Warning
permanent permanent
List of Notes
Number Type Description Description/Solution
The calculation was not done (because numerical cross-section, phased
N0/1 Note cross-section, member or cross-section with different material as concrete
material is used)
N0/2 Note The prestressed reinforcement is not taken into account
N0/3 Note The "Free bars " reinforcement is not taken into account
There is some detailing longitudinal reinforcement, which is not taken into
N0/4 Note
account for the ULS and SLS check
- 211 -
Chapter 9
l The crack width is calculated for beams and columns and for general load (N+My+Mz)
l Cross-section with one polygon and one material is taken into account in version Scia Enigneer 15
l The material of all reinforcement bars have to be same in Scia Engineer 15
l Normal stress on un-cracked section at the most tensioned fibre for determination if crack occurred or not (check of nor-
mal stresses), should be calculated for characteristic combination of the load according to EN 1992-1-1, clause 7.2(2).
There is made simplification in Scia Engineer 15 that this normal stress is calculated for the same type of combination as it
is used for calculation of crack width (load/combination/class inputted in service Crack control.
0 MPa it means that crack width is calculated if there is some tension in cross-section
it means, that crack width is calculated only in case that normal concrete stress on un-cracked section at the
fct,eff most tensioned fiber of concrete cross-section is greater the mean value of the tensile strength of the concrete
effective at the time
σ
normal concrete stress on un-cracked section at the most tensioned fibber of concrete cross-section
ct
is value of strength for determination if crack width will be calculated or not, see chapter "Value of strength for cal-
σ
culation of cracking forces" above
cr
There is possible to present cracking forces (N cr, M cry , Mcrz ) in numerical output. This cracking forces are forces which
cause reaching of value fc,teff (occurring of crack width in cross-section) in the most tensioned fiber of concrete cross- sec-
- 212 -
Check
tion in direction of first or second principal stress. For calculation of this cracking forces is used condition, that eccentricity of
inputted forces and cracking forces has to be the same.
fctm it means that mean tensile strength of concrete in time 28 days is taken into account, see picture below
it means that the mean flexural tensile strength (EN 1992-1-1,clause 3.1.8(1)) is taken into account. This value
f
should be used if restrained deformations such as shrinkage or temperature movements are taking into account
ctm,fl for calculation crack width
The value presented in material properties of concrete (picture above) is mean tensile
strength of concrete in time 28 days. If cracking is expected earlier than 28 days, it is neces-
sary input value fctm (t) in this time to material properties (EN 1992-1-1,clause 3.1.2(9)).
EN 1992- 1-1 does not give instruction how creep under varying load should be taken into
account for calculation of the crack width. The creep can be generally taken into account by
assuming that effective module of elasticity (EN 1992-1-1, clause 5.8.7(2) ) for calculation
modular ratio (E s /Ec,eff ≈ 15). A Lower value of modular ratio (greater value of module of
elasticity of concrete than effective ) may be used where less than 50 % of the stresses
arise from quasi-permanent load. The different value of modulus of elasticity can be input
directly in material properties, see picture below, but these changes has influence to FEM
analysis too.
- 213 -
Chapter 9
Auto it means that maximal (limit) value of crack width will be calculated according to EN 1992-1-1(Table 7.1N)
User it means that user defined value will be taken into account for particular member
fctm it means that mean tensile strength of concrete in time 28 days is taken into account, see picture below
it means that the mean flexural tensile strength (EN 1992-1-1,clause 3.1.8(1)) is taken into account. This value
f
should be used if restrained deformations such as shrinkage or temperature movements are taking into account
ctm,fl for calculation crack width
- 214 -
Check
The value presented in material properties of concrete (picture above) is mean tensile
strength of concrete in time 28 days. If cracking is expected earlier than 28 days, it is neces-
sary input value fctm (t) in this time to material properties (EN 1992-1-1,clause 3.1.2(9)).
σ f ct ,eff
− kt ⋅
ρ p ,eff
(
⋅ 1 + αe ⋅ ρ p ,eff ) σ
εsm − ε cm = max ; 0.6 ⋅
E E
where
From the formula above follows that difference between mean strain in the reinforcement and concrete mainly depends on:
- 215 -
Chapter 9
l The section is loaded by load/combination/class selected in service crack control, see chapter 3.2.1
l Transformed section is used
l Plane section remains plane after loading (deformation) too
l Tensile strength of concrete is not taken into account (cracked section)
l Ideal bond between concrete and reinforcement is taken into account, it means that change strain of reinforcement εs
and concrete fiber εc in the same position is the same
l The linear strain-stress diagram of concrete and reinforcement with infinite branch is used, it means, that distribution of
stress is linear and depends on change of strain (Hooke’s law)
kt factor dependent on duration of the load. The following values should be used according to code EN 1992-
- 216 -
Check
The value of kt in SEN depends on type of modulus of concrete. If check box "Use of effective modulus of
concrete" on page 213 is ON, the value 0.4 is used, otherwise value 0.6 is used.
is the mean value of the tensile strength of the concrete effective at the time.
f
When the cracks may first be expected to occur.The value can be set by "Type of strength for calculation of
ct,eff
cracking forces" on page 214.
factor dependent on duration of the load. If check box "Use of effective modulus of concrete" on page 213 is
kt
ON, the value 0.4 is used, otherwise value 0.6 is used
ratio of reinforcement within effective area of concrete in tension. This ratio is calculated only for non-
prestressed reinforcement (prestressed reinforcement is not taken into account for check crack width)
ρ according to formula
p,eff As ,eff
ρp , eff =
A c ,eff
A
area of non-prestressed reinforcement (see chapter 4.4) within effective area of concrete in tension
s,eff
the effective area of concrete in tension surrounding the reinforcement. This is area of reinforcement
A
bounded by line, which is in distance hc,eff from the most tensioned fibre of concrete in the direction of bend-
c,eff ing moment resultant
the depth of effective area of concrete in tension surrounding the reinforcement.
h c , eff = min2.5 ⋅ h − d ;
( ) ; 0.5 ⋅ h ← if x ≤ h
h−x
h
3
c,eff
h c , eff = min[2.5 ⋅ ( h − d ); 0.5 ⋅ h ] ← if x > h
the height of cross-section in direction of resultant of the bending moments (thickness of FEM element in
h
centroid)
d effective depth of cross-section in direction of resultant of the bending moments
depth of concrete in compression calculated for uncracked section with taking into account conditions in
x
chapter 4.6.1.1.
ratio of design value of modulus of elasticity of the most tensioned reinforcement and modulus elasticity of
the concrete
αe
Es
αe =
Ec
design value of modulus of elasticity of the most tensioned The value is loaded from material properties of
Es
the reinforcement, see picture below
Ec modulus of elasticity of concrete. The value is loaded from material properties of the concrete
- 217 -
Chapter 9
The program finishes with error if area of non-prestressed reinforcement As,eff is zero,
EN 1992-1-1 does not give instruction, how creep under varying load should be taken into
account for calculation of the crack width. The creep can be generally taken into account by
assuming that effective module of elasticity (EN 1992-1-1, clause 5.8.7(2) ) for calculation
modular ratio (Es /Ec,eff ≈ 15). A lower value of modular ratio (greater value of module of
elasticity of concrete than effective ) may be used where less than 50 % of the stresses
arise from quasi- permanent load. The effective module of elasticity can be taken into
account by check box Use effective modulus of concrete (see 2.1.3 ) .The different value of
modulus of elasticity can be input directly in material properties, but these changes has influ-
ence to FEM analysis too.
s ,max ( )
= 1.3 ⋅ ( h − x ) ← if ss > 5 c + 0.5 ⋅ d s or ρp , eff = 0
k ⋅k ⋅ k ⋅ d
s r ,max = min k 3 ⋅ c + 1 2 4 s ; 1.3 ⋅ ( h − x ) otherwise
ρ p , eff
- 218 -
Check
where
k
coefficients of calculation loaded from national annex setting (Manager of national annex >code EN 1992-1-1 >
3 SLS)
, k4
c cover of the most tensioned reinforcement calculated in direction of resultant of bending moments
k1 coefficient which takes account of the bond properties of the bonded reinforcement
l k1 = 0,8 for high bond bars (in SEN bar surface = ribbed)
k1
l k1 = 1,6 for bars with an effectively plain surface e.g. prestressing tendons (in SEN bar surface = smooth)
- 219 -
Chapter 9
σ
normal concrete stress on un-cracked section at the most tensioned fibber of concrete cross-section
ct
- 220 -
Check
is value of strength for determination if crack width will be calculated or not, see chapter "Value of strength for cal-
σ
culation of cracking forces" on page 212
cr
It is possible to present cracking forces (Ncr, Mcry , Mcrz ) in numerical output. These cracking forces are forces which caused
reaching of value fc,teff (occurring of crack width in cross-section) in the most tensioned fibber of concrete cross-section in
direction of first or second principal stress. For calculation of this cracking forces is used condition that eccentricity of inputted
forces and cracking forces has to be the same.
σ f ct ,eff
− kt ⋅
ρ p ,eff
(
⋅ 1 + αe ⋅ ρ p ,eff ) σ
εsm − ε cm = max ; 0.6 ⋅
E E
where
From the formula above follows that difference between mean strain in the reinforcement and concrete mainly depends on:
l The section is loaded by load/combination/class selected in service crack control, see chapter 3.2.1
l Transformed section is used
l Plane section remains plane after loading (deformation) too
l Tensile strength of concrete is not taken into account (cracked section)
- 221 -
Chapter 9
l Ideal bond between concrete and reinforcement is taken into account, it means change strain of reinforcement εs and
concrete fiber εc in the same position is the same
l The linear strain-stress diagram of concrete and reinforcement with infinite branch is used, it means, that distribution of
stress is linear and depends on change of strain (Hooke’s law)
factor dependent on duration of the load. The following values should be used according to code EN 1992-
1-1, chapter 7.3.4(2).
The value of kt in SEN depends on type of modulus of concrete. If check box "Use of effective modulus of
concrete" on page 213 is ON, the value 0.4 is used, otherwise value 0.6 is used.
is the mean value of the tensile strength of the concrete effective at the time.
f
When the cracks may first be expected to occur.The value can be set by "Type of strength for calculation of
ct,eff
cracking forces" on page 213.
factor dependent on duration of the load. If check box "Use of effective modulus of concrete" on page 213 is
kt
ON, the value 0.4 is used, otherwise value 0.6 is used
ratio of reinforcement within effective area of concrete in tension. This ratio is calculated only for non-
ρ
prestressed reinforcement (prestressed reinforcement is not taken into account for check crack width)
p,eff according to formula
- 222 -
Check
As ,eff
ρp , eff =
A c ,eff
A
area of non-prestressed reinforcement (see chapter 4.4) within effective area of concrete in tension
s,eff
the effective area of concrete in tension surrounding the reinforcement. This is area of reinforcement
A
bounded by line, which is in distance hc,eff frpm most tensioned fibre of concrete in direction of bending
c,eff nmoment resultant
the depth of effective area of concrete in tension surrounding the reinforcement.
h c , eff = min2.5 ⋅ h − d ;
( ) ; 0.5 ⋅ h ← if x ≤ h
h−x
h
3
c,eff
h c , eff = min[2.5 ⋅ ( h − d ); 0.5 ⋅ h ] ← if x > h
the height of cross-section in direction of resultant of the bending moments (thickness of FEM element in
h
centroid)
d effective depth of cross-section in direction of resultant of the bending moments
depth of concrete in compression calculated for uncracked section with taking into account conditions in
x
chapter 4.6.1.1.
ratio of design value of modulus of elasticity of the most tensioned reinforcement and modulus elasticity of
the concrete
αe
Es
αe =
Ec
design value of modulus of elasticity of the most tensioned The value is loaded from material properties of
Es
the reinforcement, see picture below
Ec modulus of elasticity of concrete. The value is loaded from material properties of the concrete
- 223 -
Chapter 9
The program finishes with error if area of non-prestressed reinforcement As,eff is zero,
EN 1992-1-1 does not give instruction, how creep under varying load should be taken into
account for calculation of the crack width. The creep can be generally taken into account by
assuming that effective module of elasticity (EN 1992-1-1, clause 5.8.7(2) ) for calculation
modular ratio (E s /Ec,eff ≈ 15). A Lower value of modular ratio (greater value of module of
elasticity of concrete than effective ) may be used where less than 50 % of the stresses
arise from quasi- permanent load. The effective module of elasticity van be taken into
account by check box Use effective modulus of concrete (see 2.1.3 ) .The different value of
modulus of elasticity can be input directly in material properties, but these changes has influ-
ence to FEM analysis too.
s ,max ( )
= 1.3 ⋅ ( h − x ) ← if ss > 5 c + 0.5 ⋅ d s or ρp , eff = 0
k ⋅k ⋅ k ⋅ d
s r ,max = min k 3 ⋅ c + 1 2 4 s ; 1.3 ⋅ ( h − x ) otherwise
ρ p , eff
- 224 -
Check
where
k
coefficients of calculation loaded from national annex setting (Manager of national annex >code EN 1992-1-1 >
3 SLS)
, k4
c cover of the most tensioned reinforcement calculated in direction of resultant of bending moments
k1 coefficient which takes account of the bond properties of the bonded reinforcement
l k1 = 0,8 for high bond bars (in SEN bar surface = ribbed)
k1
l k1 = 1,6 for bars with an effectively plain surface e.g. prestressing tendons (in SEN bar surface = smooth)
- 225 -
Chapter 9
E5/1 Error Check was not done, because plane of equilibrium was not found. To increase amount of reinforcement or to
- 226 -
Check
Abbreviations
Abbreviation Explanation
SEN Software SCIA Engineer
PNL Physical nonlinear calculation
GNL Geometrical nonlinear calculation
LCS Local coordinate system
GCS Global coordinate system
REDES The module in SEN for inputting user reinforcement to 1D member via template
SLS Serviceability limit state
ULS Ultimate limit state
- 227 -
Chapter 9
Abbreviations
Abbreviation Explanation
SEN Software SCIA Engineer
PNL Physical nonlinear calculation
GNL Geometrical nonlinear calculation
LCS Local coordinate system
GCS Global coordinate system
REDES The module in SEN for inputting user reinforcement to 1D member via template
SLS Serviceability limit state
ULS Ultimate limit state
- 228 -
Check
Literature
1. [1] EN 1992-1-1: 2004 Eurocode 2 : design of concrete structures – Part 1: General rules and rules for building
2. [2] ENV 1992-1-1: 1991 Eurocode 2 : design of concrete structures – Part 1: General rules and rules for building
Literature
Deflections (SLS)
Introduction
The calculation of deflection is done according to chapter 7.3.4 from EN 1992-1-1. The verification of deflections should be
performed due to the following reasons:
l Unacceptable deflection should not affect proper function of the structure or aesthetic - limit for total deflection
l To avoid damage to partitions and finishes due to increments in deflection following their construction - limit for additional
deflection
The behaviour of the reinforced cross-section for deflection needs is the same as used for the stiffness calculation and can
be also expressed in term of moment and strain (deformation) diagram. The final value of stiffness is calculated using inter-
polation formula between state (I) deformation for uncracked concrete section ( x =0) and state (II) deformation for fully
cracked concrete section (no tension carries) (x =1) dependently on the ratio of stress in reinforcement from cracking load
and acting load.The dependency of cracking moment on strain in concrete is visible from the following figure. The value of
deformation is then recalculated from the stiffness and acting load.
- 229 -
Chapter 9
Assumption
The same preconditions are used for calculation as mentioned in chapter "Assumption and limitations" on page 203
SCIA Engineer is able to calculate short-term or long-term stiffness. This type depends on setting in Global settings - Solver
settings - General - SLS - Use effective modulus of elasticity.
- 230 -
Check
l check is performed on linear/envelope or code combination (it is not necessary to define concrete combinations)
l check is done for selected members (Current CDD runs for whole structure)
l Deformation caused by shrinkage is not automatically taken into account in version SCIA Engineer15.
l Verification based on limiting span / depth ratio according to 7.4.2 is not implemented.
l The check is done only on user defined reinforcement (check using theoretical designed reinforcement is not supported).
l The calculation of deflection depends on the internal forces used for the reduced stiffness. Therefore the
check of deflection doesn’t work for case where the internal forces are equal to zero but deflection are
not zero. Typically for cantilever structure of member with free overhang. Here the results cannot be con-
sidered.
Theory
As mentioned in EN 1992- 1- 1 chapter 7.4.1(3) calculated deformations should not exceed those that can be accom-
modated by other connected elements such as partitions, glazing, cladding, services or finishes. In some cases limitation
may be required to ensure the proper functioning of machinery or apparatus supported by the structure, or to avoid ponding
on flat roofs.
Generally two main situation are required to be checked:
l Total deflection - The appearance and general utility of the structure could be impaired when the calculated sag of a
beam, slab or cantilever subjected to quasi-permanent loads exceeds span/250. The sag is assessed relative to the sup-
ports. Pre-camber may be used to compensate for some or all of the deflection but any upward deflection incorporated in
the form-work should not generally exceed span/250
l Additional deflection - Deflections that could damage adjacent parts of the structure should be limited. For the deflec-
tion after construction, span/500 is normally an appropriate limit for quasi-permanent loads. Other limits may be con-
sidered, depending on the sensitivity of adjacent parts.
The calculation procedure used in new Deflection check can be described in the following steps:
1) Calculation of short-term stiffness - short-term stiffness is calculated using 28days E modulus for acting load
- 231 -
Chapter 9
2) Calculation of long-term stiffness - long-term stiffness is calculated using effective E modulus based on creep coef-
ficient for acting load
Unfortunately, for time being there is not possibility to distinguish between short-term and long-term part of the load in com-
bination. Therefore some precondition has been established for determination of long-term part of the load. Long-term part
of the load (LongTermPercentage) is estimated based on the type of combination for check. There are three main
SLS combinations:
3) Calculation of ratios - stiffness ratios are used as simplified method for calculation of particular deflections (see
below). These values are calculated for each state according to points 1 and 2 above. Generally , the values are ratios of lin-
ear stiffness of concrete component only divided by resultant stiffness taking cracks into account.
ratio = Stiffnesslin / Stiffnessres
For example:
ratiouz =EIz,lin / EIz,res
4) Calculation of particular component - Several particular components are needed for calculation of total and addi-
tional deflection
As mentioned beforehand, the short- and long-term stiffnesses are calculated using a so-called creep factor. This creep-
factor is dependant on the relative humidity, outline of the cross-section, reinforcement percentage, concrete class, etc.This
factor is used to divide the short- term stiffness and obtain the long-term stiffness, Thus by taken the concrete stiffness for
short- and long-term and the representative compression strength the program calculates the stress and strain diagram.
Generally , the components calculated below can be graphically presented on the following figure
Linear (elastic) deflection - is the sum of short-term and long-term elastic deflection
ᵟ lin = ᵟ lin,s+ᵟ lin,l
Immediate deflection - to calculate the immediate deformation, the deformation of the permanent load is calculated using
the short-term stress and strain diagram. Additionally by subtracting the immediate deformation from the total deformation,
the programs calculates the additional deformation.
ᵟ imm = ᵟ lin,lˣ ratio s
Short-term deflection - is the multiplication of short-term elastic deflection and short-term ratio
ᵟ s = ᵟ lin,sˣ ratio s
Long-term deflection + creep - is the multiplication of long-term elastic deflection and long-term ratio
ᵟ l,creep = ᵟ lin,lˣ ratio l
- 232 -
Check
Output values
There are presented the following output values:
Setup
The following items have impact on the calculation of deflection check. Both are stored in Concrete settings (structure) -
Global settings-Solver settings - Deflections
- 233 -
Chapter 9
Additionally, both values above can be modified using Concrete member data per each member.
- 234 -
Check
List of Errors
Number Type Description Description/Solution
Change (a) the dimensions of the cross-section, (b) the amount of reinforcement or
E0/1 Error Plane of equilibrium was not found.
(c) the quality of the used materials.
The limit additional deflection in (y) dir- Change (a) the dimensions of the cross-section, (b) the amount of reinforcement or
E8/2 Error
ection is exceeded. (c) the quality of the used materials.
The limit additional deflection in (z) dir- Change (a) the dimensions of the cross-section, (b) the amount of reinforcement or
E8/3 Error
ection is exceeded. (c) the quality of the used materials.
The limit total deflection in (y) direction Change (a) the dimensions of the cross-section, (b) the amount of reinforcement or
E8/5 Error
is exceeded. (c) the quality of the used materials.
The limit total deflection in (z) direction Change (a) the dimensions of the cross-section, (b) the amount of reinforcement or
E8/6 Error
is exceeded. (c) the quality of the used materials.
List of Warnings
Number Type Description Description/Solution
- 235 -
Chapter 9
List of Notes
Number Type Description Description/Solution
The calculation was not done (because numerical cross-section, phased
N0/1 Note cross-section, member or cross-section with different material as concrete
material is used)
N0/2 Note The prestressed reinforcement is not taken into account
N0/3 Note The "Free bars " reinforcement is not taken into account
There is some detailing longitudinal reinforcement, which is not taken into
N0/4 Note
account for the ULS and SLS check
N2/1 Note The normal forces and bending moments are zero (N=0,My=0,Mz=0)
The maximal effective concrete strength is exceeded; cracks appear under the Change (a) the dimensions of the cross-sec-
N8/1 Note " & State & "-term characteristic load combination. Furthermore, the concrete tion, (b) the amount of reinforcement or (c)
stress-strain diagram without tensile branch is used. the quality of the used materials.
Detailing provisions
Introduction
Requirements for detailing provisions of reinforced concrete members are another step of proper design respecting safety,
serviceability and durability of structure.
Generally SCIA Engineer distinguishes three main types of member within their detailing provisions:
The following table shows which checks of detailing provisions are performed for particular member type:
longitudinal shear
Member type
(main) (transverse)
6.2.3(3) - Maximal percentage of shear reinforcement
8.2(2) - Minimal clear spacing of bars 9.2.2(5) - Minimal percentage of shear reinforcement
9.2.1.1(1) - Minimal area of longitudinal reinforcement 9.2.2 (6) - Maximal longitudinal spacing of stirrups
(shear)
Beam 9.2.1.1(3) - Maximal area of longitudinal reinforcement
9.2.2 (8) - Maximal transverse spacing of stirrups
9.2.3(4) - Maximal centre-to-centre bar distance based on torsion
(shear)
Code-Independent - Maximal clear spacing
9.2.3(3) - Maximal longitudinal spacing of stirrups (tor-
sion)
8.2(2) - Minimal clear spacing of bars 9.2.3(3) - Maximal longitudinal spacing of stirrups (tor-
sion)
9.5.2(1) - Minimal bar diameter of longitudinal reinforcement
9.5.3 (1) - Minimal diameter of transverse rein-
Column 9.5.2(2) - Minimal area of longitudinal reinforcement
forcement
9.5.2(3) - Maximal area of longitudinal reinforcement
9.5.3 (3) - Maximal longitudinal spacing of transverse
9.5.2(4) - Minimal number of longitudinal reinforcement bars reinforcement
- 236 -
Check
Assumption
l Stirrups can be defined with perpendicular direction to axis of the member (α =90°).
l Shear bends are not able to define, therefore check of detailing provisions for them is not supported
l Only checks mentioned in previous chapter are supported
l Each check of detailing provisions includes differences per national annex if those exist.
l k1 and k2 are coefficients defined in NA. For standard Eurocode k1=1 and k2=5.
l •φis diameter of maximal longitudinal reinforcement
l dg - maximal stone diameter in concrete mixture
l slb,min is minimal clear distance defined as fixed value in chapter 8.2(2)
National annex k k
1 2
Standard NA 1,0 5,0
Czech ČSN – EN NA 1,5 5,0
Slovak STN – EN NA 1,5 5,0
0,0 for d ≤16mm
g
German DIN-EN NA 1,0
5,0 for d >16mm
g
0,0 for one reinforcement layer
Austrian ONORM-EN NA 1,0
10,0 for more reinforcement layers
Finnish SFS-EN NA 1,0 3,0
- 237 -
Chapter 9
Furthermore maximal allowed percentage of shear reinforcement is calculated as follows (see formula 6.12).
ρw,max =0,5.αcw .νfcd / fyd
where
where
- 238 -
Check
Furthermore minimal allowed mandrel diameter of stirrup is determined as follows from table 8.1N
for φs ≤ 16mm; φm,min=4. .φs
for φs > 16mm; φm,min=7. .φs
- 239 -
Chapter 9
German NA doesn’t give the limit for minimal tensile area of longitudinal reinforcement. In
this case unity check is =0
* The procedure for Dutch NEN-NA gives another rule. The values from table above are
marked as A s,min,1 . Additionally necessary area from ULS (A s,req ) is calculated as
As,min,2 = 1,25 * As,req . Finally, the minimal allowed value of longitudinal reinforcement is:
As,min = max (As,min,1; As,min,2).
The verification for SFS, SS and SIST NA is not done at all and unity check is set to
UC9.2.1.1(3) =0
- 240 -
Check
Furthermore minimal allowed percentage of shear reinforcement is calculated as follows (see formula 9.5N).
ρw,min = 0,08.√fck / fyk
where
l UC9.2.2(5) =ρw,min/ ρw .
- 241 -
Chapter 9
l s = 0,9•d
l,max
French NF-EN NA
for h > 250mm
l s = max( 0,75•d•(1+cotg (α))
l,max
for V ≤ 0,3•V
Ed Rd,max
l l s = 200mm
l,max
German DIN-EN NA
for 0,3•V < V ≤0,6•V
Rd,max Ed Rd,max
l s = max(0,25•h;200mm)
l,max
Slovak STN-EN NA max( 0,75•d•(1+cotg (α)); 400mm)
- 242 -
Check
l Beam
UC = max ( UC8.2(2); UC8.3(2); UC6.2.3(3); UC9.2.1.1(1); UC9.2.1.1(3); UC9.2.2(5); UC9.2.2(6); UC9.2.2(8); UC9.2.3(3);
UC9.2.3(4);
UCmax_bar_distance(user))
l Beam slab
l Columns
Output values
There are presented the following output values:
- 243 -
Chapter 9
l Unity check shear - unity check of detailing provisions for shear reinforcement
Clause 9.5.2(1) - minimal bar diameter of longitudinal reinforcement for National annex
There are the following differences in particular NA.
- 244 -
Check
- 245 -
Chapter 9
- 246 -
Check
Concrete settings
The following items have impact on the calculation of detailing provisions check.These values are stored in Concrete set-
tings (structure)-Global settings-Solver settings - Detailing provisions.
- 247 -
Chapter 9
l Beam
l Longitudinal
l Stirrups
Column
l Main
l Transverse
Beam slab
l Longitudinal
- 248 -
Check
Beams
Longitudinal reinforcement
Figure
- 249 -
Chapter 9
Figure
Figure
Figure
- 250 -
Check
Figure
Figure
Figure
- 251 -
Chapter 9
Code 9.2.1.1(1)
Figure -
Figure
Stirrups
Figure
- 252 -
Check
Code 9.2.3(3)
Figure
Figure
Beam Slab
Longitudinal
- 253 -
Chapter 9
Figure
Figure
Figure
- 254 -
Check
Figure
Figure
Column
Main
- 255 -
Chapter 9
Figure
Figure
Figure
- 256 -
Check
Figure
Figure
Figure
- 257 -
Chapter 9
Figure
Figure
Figure
- 258 -
Check
Figure
Figure
Transverse
Figure
- 259 -
Chapter 9
Figure
Figure
Figure
- 260 -