Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A I S H WA RYA R A J E S H P I L L A I
INDEX
3.7 Spatial: Third Space 9.2 Pop-Up Kitchen for refugees and Asylum seekers, Merrett Houmøller
4.1 Understanding and decoding literature 9.6 Architectural scale- The Kitchen Praxagora – Turning the private and
1. INTRODUCTION
Unit Leader: Dr. Federico Wulff
INTRODUCTION
understanding and intervention in intercultural interactions in the urban Lewisham is an area that has embodied an intercultural
perspective by encouraging the implementation of policies
and architectural realm are essential to rectify ‘othering’ and ‘xenophobia’. which promote intercultural interaction. The current
policies which aim to enhance intercultural interaction
Meeting in the middle, metaphorically and literally in essence is the spirit
in the Borough are focused on the following four areas:
of interculturality. Traversing through the realm of the metaphysical Education, Neighbourhood, Language, and Intellectual
competence (London Lewisham: Results of the Intercultural
discourse of interculturality, this project intends to investigate borders Cities Index analysis, 2011).
2. BACKGROUND OF STUDY
Deptford is home to, a diverse ethnic population. This diversity is a result of the rich history of the dockyards to
2.2 LAYERS OF UNDERSTANDING
the current day. Deptford’s multicultural social context is a result of the historic Royal Naval victualling dockyards. For a better understanding of Deptford, the site is understood in relation In understanding the site in respect to the intricacies of the concept and in
During the Tudor times in the 1500s, Deptford (ie: suburbs of London) was popular for its holiday homes of English to the Morphological , tangible layer and the social layer - intangible layer. order to facilitate intercultural communication the site is interpreted as a
aristocrats. During 1800 the prosperity of the dockyards provided many employment opportunities as many workers These two layers complement each other. The social layer can be read dialogue of intersections of the social and the physical level as understood by
lived near the industries. The 1700s was the start of the gentrification process as the naval officers lived in grand through the morphology and the findings in research. this model.
houses in Greenwich and the workers in the industries lived near the dockyards and factories. (Allies and Morrison
Urban Practitioners, 2018)
Social level
Social level
Intersections
Physical level
Morphological level
Image : Design translation model of intersections in the social and physical level
Image: Layers of understanding
White White
South Asian Chinese
2.5 CONCLUSION
3. CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
The following key concerns of Deptford were identified after applying the
aforementioned complexities to the setting of Deptford for the purpose of identifying
disparities. A. Limited representation of people from diverse cultures in Deptford
in the public arena., B. From Deptford station to the north end of the high street,
there have been concerns about pedestrian safety and vulnerability to race-related
3.8 FEMINISM AS A SUBSET 3.7 THIRD SPACE harassment, and there is a need to improve design methods to make the city
3.6 INTERSECTIONALITY
OF THIRDSPACE more inclusive and avoid crimes. (Intercultural city report , London Borough of
Lewisham,2007).
When feminism is viewed as a subset Third places can be characterised as a new ‘Intersectionality’ was used and solidified
of third spaces, it can be seen as way of looking at a space and providing by Kimberle Crenshaw in the 1970s
representational blindspots and the meaning and significance to human life’s (Björnsdóttir & Traustadóttir, 2010), and it
boundaries of hegemonic discourses, as spatiality. These spaces are intended to refers to the different ways in which multiple
well as the kinks and cracks in the power transform ideas, experiences, perceptions, identities combine to create unique barriers
knowledge apparatus (Rose, G., 1997). and meanings in a deliberate, hesitant, and and how people may face discrimination
flexible manner (Soja, E.W., 1996). as a combination of their identification
with different social factors (Stienstra,
2012, pg. 458). This understanding of
intersectionality can be applied to the social
and morphological layers of Deptford to find CONCLUSION
and identify barriers and differences. Image: Intersections
Image: Feminisim as a subset of third space In conclusion, the research was condensed down to the following essential issues for a
SOCIAL SPATIAL CONCEPTUAL better comprehension of the conceptual framework: intersectionality, third spaces, and
Feminism
feminism as a subset of third spaces.
Third space
INTRODUCTION | THEORY | PRECEDENT STUDY | SITE SELECTION | DESIGN
4 . F I R S T L I T E R AT U R E R E V I E W:
KNOWLEDGE MAPPING
5 . F I R S T L I T E R AT U R E R E V I E W :
KEY FINDINGS
1. A multi-scalar social and spatial approach 2. Identification of hegemonies 3. Re-mapping of the urban realm
HENRY LAFAVE
(LEFEBVRE,H.,1968) 5.1 INVESTIGATING THE GAP
Spatiality
Spatiality
GILLIAN ROSE
(ROSE., G., 1997)
Power divisions in both realms.
BELL HOOKS.
(HOOKS ., B., 1989 ) 4. Integrating approach 5. Degrees of participation 6. Mitigating the otherness
KIMBERLY CRENSHAW
(CRENSHAW ., K,1989)
Spatiality
MICHEAL FOUCOULT
(SOJA., E., 1996)
Community Hegemonies
MARIA ARLEMO
(FRICHOT., H., ET.AL, 2018)
INTRODUCTION | THEORY | PRECEDENT STUDY | SITE SELECTION | DESIGN
6. INTERSECTIONALITY
6.1 INTERSECTIONAL APPROACH 6.4 CONFRONTING THE CONTEXT IN TERMS OF INTERCULTURAL COMPETENCE.
Intersectionality is focused on
understanding how different social
factors can intersect and reinforce
privilege and discrimination
(Nash, 2008). Instead of analysing
factors like race, class and gender
individually, intersectionality S y
p t
analyses how these factors work a i
t i l
together to produce privilege and a i
l i b
oppression (Erevelles & Minear, t y a Uk
i rain
2011). Understanding inequality, as c ian
defined by Henry Lafebvre (1968), o
S Ch
refers to ‘otherness.’ Identifying ine
this social obstacle is the first step se
n
toward a solution, which can be t atio
Image: Layers of understanding found in intercultural competence. sen
Sou
th A pre
sian Re
Bla
ck Car
ibb
6.2 INTERCULTURAL COMPETENCE ean
C U L T U R E
through an intersectional approach, Lo e h
rch
y
itim r a
r ie
conflicts can be perceived as a Ma cia
lH
bonding factor as a capacity to shift So
perspectives and bring forward
cross-cultural similarities (Landry,
C., & Woods, P., 2012). This
method of integration of the host
and guest can be done as an attempt ie s
to improve diversity and inclusion The mon
do ge
and also solves social differences. cky
ard He
The s
fa çad
Image: Layers of understanding e of
Dep
tfor
d
c ter
hara
lc
g ica ford
lo t
pho Dep
r f
Mo o
Understanding interculturality and applying it to the context to improve the safety of the city to mitigate multiracial crimes is a process that is a long-term vision. Understanding the demography
of Deptford and the needs of the first and second generation of migrants and immigrants is critical to informing the design process. Understanding culture as a representation of identities can
also be understood as a `representation of individuals. Every human has a multi-layered identity and as such culture is also very complex. It is not apparent it rather lies in the hidden dimension.
Culture can be understood as the background, and why people are the way they are and how they behave. Trying to understand this complex dimension is a step toward interculturality.
The diagram below is an understanding of this very notion, the intercultural node lying in the very middle of the identities of the current geography (Deptford) the people that live there carrying
their varied identities and the forgotten heritage muddled in gentrification.
INTRODUCTION | THEORY | PRECEDENT STUDY | SITE SELECTION | DESIGN
7. C O N T E X U A L A N A LY S I S - S I T E S E L E C T I O N C R I T E R I A
SECTIONAL VIEW- S2
Deptford high street
North Railway Resolution
Deptford South
underpass way
Railway side
Station Deptford
Selected nodes highilighted. High
Street
S3 The railway bridge in a sense splits the high
street into the north and the south. This spot is also
another hotspot for theft, that has been recorded at the
supermarkets.
LEGEND SECTIONAL VIEW- S3
8 . S I T E S E L E C T I O N C R I T E R I A A N D S TA K E H O L D E R
ZONE 3
9.PRECEDENT STUDY
Temple Tank
LEGEND
Temporary shops
Fort Gate
clothes
Night time
CONCLUSION
9. PRECEDENT STUDY
Creating pedestrian nodes of interaction The viewing from the higher floors of
the blocks to improve safety through
The perception of
safety during the
day and the night is
different for different
people and as such,
bringing life into the
city can also change the
perception of safety.
Better lighting design
can also improve this
perception of safety.
Workshop space
Micro architecture and information kiosks that are
open throughout the night can bring forth feelings
of safety at night.
INTRODUCTION | THEORY | PRECEDENT STUDY | SITE SELECTION | DESIGN
1 0 . P R O D U C T I O N O F S PA C E : T H E M A K I N G O F A N I N T E R C U LT U R A L N O D E
ECONOMY
1
LITERATURE REVIEW: L1.Henry Lafebrve- production of social space
24/7 rental shops to improve local enterprise available
L2. Edward Soja- varied definitions of third spaces based Placemaking to improve tourism on all days other than the market days.
It is critical to comprehend the multi-scalar influence that the Waste recycling unit community participation
intercultural node might have in order to apply an intersectional on scalability
approach effectively. A node produces an acupuncture effect and L3. Gillian Rose- hegemonies as blind spots in
hence functions as a mechanism rather than a single entity. The representation
urban, neighbourhood, and architectural scales all work together L4. Bell Hooks- radical openness to create inclusivity
to correct and address problems in a coordinated manner.
L5. Kimberle Crenshaw- Intersectional approach
L6. Michel Foucault- geo histories of otherness
CULTURAL
L7. Donia Petrescu- community and participatory
approach, rethinking economic dynamics of power
L8. Jane Jacobs- right to the city
L9. Maria Ariemo- degrees of marginalisation
Sounds and musical placemaking to depict the culture
Venue for cultural venues talks and gatherings. Learning and empowering through upskilling
2
CONTEXTUAL ANALYSIS:
C1 .Gentrification
In confronting the site, and understanding the needs of the context, C2. Need to improve the local economy and economic
it is understood that emphasis needs to be placed in improving opportunities for the locals.
the neighbourhood and improving the language of intercultural
C3 No urban representation of the rich heritage of the
FAITH
competence.
dockyards.
C4 Lack of representation of the diverse ethnic diversity
which is nearly half the population in the urban realm
C5. High crime rate and antisocial behavior. Community hall for the local events workshops
Common festival gathering space a learning process
and community events
3
HERITAGE
PRECEDENT STUDY
Methods of micro-architecture in an urban scale that are social P1. Pop up kitchen for refugees and asylum seekers
acupuncture in daily life and improving economic viability which P2.Temple tank market, main guard gate
is indeed a radical approach to gentrification. Moreover in an (Tiruchirappalli, India)
architectural scale, reversing the functions of the indoor and P.3 Barcelona super-blocks
outdoor to make the city a more accessible and equal level ground P4. R-cyclab Intercultural placemaking (statues/ art)
with respect to gender and language barriers. Thus, invoking the P5. The kitchen Praxagora Sweden A place to share and learn
spirit of community care and shared, learned experiences. Cultural identities and local heritage A place to share and learn
ISSUE THAT IT SOLVES.
1 1 . M U LT I - S C A L A R A P P R O A C H
1. URBAN SCALE A prototype pods of micro-architecture placed in nodes of danger, combating 2.NEIGHBORHOOD The square of the city is an important landmark and as such, the functioning 3.ARCHITECTURAL Micro-architecture, pavilion, and placemaking are the first line of interventions
problems of safety in the city. These pods not only improve safety, but also can SCALE of it has a huge impact on the residents that reside in the city. Permanent SCALE to change and repair social behaviour in cities and neighbourhoods. However,
be rented in a subsidised rate on a daily basis. pavilion located in this square with temporal activities to improve economy and according to Lafebrve, social behaviour is a mirror of societal perceptions that
High street Giffin square intervention. improve safety a radical approach to gentrification. Creating an impact on the Main Intercultural Node can only be changed over time. A community kitchen with an intercultural
(Micro Intercultural node) (Micro Intercultural Node) youth by creating activities to change the behaviour of people and visible background that serves as a local landmark to boost community social life
representations of different cultures in this node through temporal activities and representation. Domestic waste recycling workshop center is one of the
reinstating interculturality and representation in the heart of the city. initiatives offered by this centre. The first level houses a secure area for women
and refugees to learn occupational skills and participate in therapy sessions for
victims of violence.
INTRODUCTION | THEORY | PRECEDENT STUDY | SITE SELECTION | DESIGN
PAVILLION
PLACEMAKING
VOCAL HISTORY
MAP OF LANDMARKS IN
DEPTFORD
INTRODUCTION | THEORY | PRECEDENT STUDY | SITE SELECTION | DESIGN
CONTEXTUAL LEVEL
The design was created in response to literature that mentions L1, L3, L4, L7, and L8. The concept of thematic selection
is divided into two parts: Economic-social, cultural-social- tourism. In and of itself, Giffin Square is a significant
landmark in Deptford. Three interventional processes are used to construct the programmatic formulation: The site selection criteria is based on
the previous taxonomy of dangerous
1. Placemaking, vocal history spaces. Even though the Giffin square
2. Map of landmarks is the frontage for Deptford Lounge,
3. Pavilion, a space of temporal programs for celebration, representation, surveillance and economic activity the seating spaces in the square are
often reported to have anti-social
behaviour which needs to be rectified,
thus making it socially dysfunctional.
CONCEPTUAL LEVEL
Covered stage
An intersection of two circles Overlapping of two circles Intersection of the circles Morphology of the form Disruptions of divisions. Option 1 . Option 2
disrupted
The walls placed such
that there is no visual PROGRAMMATIC STRATEGY
obstruction
The wall dividing the space functionally but The pavilion serving as a space for informal
The walls being placed on a The walls dividing the space dividing pathways The experience of walking through the
still maintaining openness without any visual gatherings conducting talks, cultural events
raised platform. and usable space with just a platform which pavilion which has accessible openings on all
obstructions open to the public in a public space
can be transformed and doubled as a market three sides
INTRODUCTION | THEORY | PRECEDENT STUDY | SITE SELECTION | DESIGN
LITERATURE REVIEW:
LITERATURE REVIEW:
SITE PLAN
Micro-architecture is a tactical urbanism strategy that uses 24 hour pods to improve city safety. These
are temporary monitoring pods that serve the purpose of improving local economic viability. This
pod’s architecture emphasises safety at night by including a lighting scheme on the structure’s skin
that illuminates the entire space. This becomes not simply a visually prominent landmark, but also a
starting point for dialogue and conversation.
1
The site selection criteria is based on the The taxonomy of unsafe locations on the high street i in order
to reduce crime and also make the city inclusive to all even during night time with it’s lighting design.
SECTION A
PLAN
1 4 . A . A R C H I T E C T U R A L S C A L E – M A I N I N T E R C U LT U R A L N O D E
The main intercultural node of the architectural scale is a response to the surrounding context. The understanding and SITE PLAN
learning of this project stems from Donia Petrescu’s concept of community and participatory approach to rethink economic
dynamics of power (L7). Upskilling and education are used to strengthen and enhance the inclusion of marginalised
communities. Other findings from past research, such as P4 recyclab and P5 Praxagora’s kitchen, have been used to empower
marginalised groups by encouraging intercultural competence through sharing and learning via cooking. This location also
has a problem with domestic waste management, which can be addressed by the waste recycling workshop in this project. A
safe space for therapy and focus groups are also addressed as a first line of response for empowering refugee women.
Main entrance to
the ICN
Evelyn estate
Social housing
with recorded high
crime rates
Impoverished area
Under-used
park
Open walls and
seating
Railway
Under-used
station
Market parking
area Mixed use
residential
Waste collection
Deptford High point entrance
Street
The site is selected as an underused car park which has been selected as a part of the outer
london fund by the london borough of lewisham for a proposed redevelopment on the
site. The major reasons for this redevelopment scheme is the proximity to the highstreet
and also the lack of domestic waste management in the area. (London burrough of
lewisham, outer London fund sumbission, 2011)
1 4 . B . A R C H I T E C T U R A L S C A L E – M A I N I N T E R C U LT U R A L N O D E
SECTION 1
GROUND FLOOR PLAN
s1
3
communal space
FRONT VIEW
4
Intercultural art
on the periphery
of the outdoor
space , a tourist
arrtaction spot
emphasising the
local diversity.
1 Entrance Lobby
2 Community Kitchen
3 Informal Seating Area
Communal Space
4 Waste Recycling 9 7
Workshop
5 Domestic Waste
Collection and Sorting
Point
8
6 Therapy Consultation for
Victims of Domestic Abuse
7 Vocational Training
Centre for Adults
8 Computer Skills Training
Centre
9 Safe Space Focus Groups
and Therapy Sessions
CONCLUSION
By using an intersectional approach to identify people’s needs and promote interculturality through the
functionality of space and representation, a multi-scalar apparatus can help to improve surveillance, safety,
and promote local heritage and intercultural dialogues. The urban scale intervention is an immediate remedy
to improve the safety in the city. The architectural intervention is a long-term process that gradually alters
people’s mindsets over time to change the perceptions of people and make Deptford a Winclusive community.
16. BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Wulff,F. & Guirnaldos, M., (2015). Urban activation in a post-crisis Euro-Mediterranean scenario. Proceedings of the Institution 16. Lefebvre,H., 1968, Production of space, Writings on Cities, Available at : https://www.amazon.co.uk/Production-Space-Henri-
of Civil Engineers - Urban Design and Planning. 168. 288-292. 10.1680/jurdp.15.00019. Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/ Lefebvre/dp/0631181776 . Accessed on: 20 Jan 2022
publication/307824966_Urban_activation_in_a_post-crisis_Euro-Mediterranean_scenario/citation/download Accessed on: 20 January 2022 17 Hooks ., B., 1989 , Choosing the Margin as a Space of Radical Openness, Drake Stutesman; Wayne State University Press, Available
2. Dollman., C., 2015, The refugee crisis explained in 4 questions, Global citizen, Availabe at : https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/the- at: https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/44111660.pdf?refreqid=excelsior%3A2731b84482b1a3f6199ec3f7b7b80dc3&ab_segments=&origin=
Q5xoC4boQAvD_BwE . Accessed on : 6 April 18. Crenshaw ., K,1989, Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex:
3. Poynting ., S, Briskman., L., 2020, Asylum seekers in the global A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination
context of xenophobia: Introduction to the special issue, Journal of sociology, Volume 56. Available at: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/ Doctrine, Feminist Theory, and Antiracist Politics, University of Chicago Legal Forum, Available at: https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/
4. Refugee Council, House of Commons, 2017, Refugees 19. Frichot., H., Gabrielsson., C., Runting., H., 2018, Architecture and Feminisms: Ecologies, Economies, Technologies, Routledge
Welcome? The Experience of New Refugees in the UK Publishers, Available at: https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/architecture-and-feminisms-helene-frichot/1126500318., Accessed on the
All-Party Parliamentary Group Report on RefugeesAvailable at: https://www.refugeecouncil.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/APPG_on_ 20th Jan 2021
Refugees_-_Refugees_Welcome_report.pdf (Accessed on: 8th April 2021) 20. Jacobs, J., 1992, Death and life of great American cities, Library of congress publication data, Available at: http://www.petkovstudio.
5. Landry, C. and Wood, P., 2012. The Intercultural City. Hoboken: Taylor and Francis. Availabe at : https://www.routledge.com/The- com/bg/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/The-Death-and-Life-of-Great-American-Cities_Jane-Jacobs-Complete-book.pdf. Accessed on:
6. London Lewisham: Results of the Intercultural Cities Index analysis, 2011, Council of Europe and European Commission. Available at: 21. Nash, J. C. (2008). re-thinking intersectionality. Feminist Review, 89(1), 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1057/fr.2008.4.
https://rm.coe.int/16802ff6cc (Accessed on : 9th April 2021) 22 Erevelles, N & Minear, A. (2011) “Unspeakable” offences: disability studies at the intersection of multiple differences. Chapter 3 in
7. Potts, G., 2008, Overview of Deptford, London, BURA Director of Research, Policy and Best Practice, UCL.( Available at : https://www. Erevelles, N. Disability and Difference in Global Contexts: Enabling a transformative body politic.
ucl.ac.uk/urbanbuzz/downloads/projects_09/Deptford_Case_Study.pdf) Accessed on:10 December 2021) 23 Deptford Anchor Feasibility study, 2017, Lewisham council, BDP90RPT001 R02 , Available at: https://councilmeetings.lewisham.gov.
8. London Borough of Lewisham Licence no. LA 100017710 2018. Lewisham Characterization study. London: Allies and Morrison Urban uk/documents/s48834/Deptford%20Anchor%20Feasibility%20Study%202017.pdf Accessed on : 17th April.
Practitioners. Available at: https://consultation.lewisham.gov.uk/planning/lewisham-characterisation-study/ [Accessed: 12 November 2021] 24. Ravenscroft, T, 2018, Merrett Merrett Houmøller Architects creates a pop-up kitchen for refugees and asylum seekers, Dezeen.
9. Porzio, N , 2015 , Multicultural, Cross-Cultural and Intercultural, are you using these terms correctly?, Linkedin article, Availabe at: (Accessed on: 20 February 2022)
https://es.linkedin.com/in/niccolo-porzio?trk=pulse-article_main-author-card 25. Col·lectiu Punt 6, 2016. Nocturnas. The everyday life ofv woman nightshift workers in the Barcelona Metropolitan area. (Accessed on
10. Pedersen, P. (1988). A handbook for developing multicultural awareness. American Association for Counseling. : 28 February 2022)
11. London Lewisham: Results of the Intercultural Cities Index analysis, 2011, Council of Europe and European Commission. Available at: 26. Roberts, d, 2019, Barcelona wasn’t to build 500 superblocks. Here’s what I’ve learned from the first ones. Vox . Available at: https://
12. of learning difficulties, class, gender and religion. Disability & Society, 25(1), 49-62. doi:10.1080/09687590903363340. 2022)
13. Soja., E., 1996, Third Space, Blackwell Publishers, Available at: https://friendsoflincolnlakes.org/edward-soja-third-space-60/ Accessed on 27. Riba, M., 2021, The tactical urban planning of the superblocks of example district of Barcelona. Available at: https://www.e-zigurat.
14. Stienstra, D. (2012). Routledge handbook of disability studies (pp. 453-466) (N. Watson, A. Roulstone, & C. Thomas, Eds.). London: 28. BBC News,2020, How to build a city for women. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cdSSg9SZYAY&ab_
15. Rose., G., 1997, Feminism and geography, Polity press, Available at: https://wordery.com/feminism-and-geography-gillian- 29. Frichot., H., Gabrielsson., C., Runting., H., 2018, Architecture and Feminisms: Ecologies, Economies, Technologies, Routledge
rose-9780745611563# Accessed On: 19 Jan 2021 Publishers, Available at: https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/architecture-and-feminisms-helene-frichot/1126500318., Accessed on the