Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Rebuild
Guide
Things to consider before
rebuilding your paper machine
– a practical guide book.
Introduction
Things to consider before rebuilding your paper machine
This guide book is intended for paper and board makers and machine owners and
it will guide you through what needs to be considered before, during and after a re-
build project. It will help you answer questions about how to decide on the type and
scope of the rebuild, how to plan it, what’s involved in building it, how to ensure a
smooth ramp up to full production and how to minimize the risks.
At Valmet, we have great experience and expertise in rebuilding all kinds of ma-
chines and we asked our experts to provide tips, advice and industry insight to help
you demystify the rebuild process.
Plan it
Build it
Use it
The numbers quoted in this guide book are based on the experience of Val-
met’s experts. They are provided to give you a rough idea of the typical times,
costs and calculations involved in a rebuild. However, they should not be used
to calculate costs, schedules or targets for your own rebuild. The costs and pro-
posals for each rebuild must be assessed and calculated on a case by case basis.
New machines vs
Rebuilds
If you have the choice between buying and rebuilding an old paper machine to your specifications or build-
ing a brand new machine, what should you consider?
The basic rule of thumb is that a rebuild will always be much more demanding than new installation. An old
machine, even if it’s only 10 years old, comes with limitations. It will take more time, money and engineering
to ensure that the old and new components work well together. Meeting the start-up curve will take longer
time. Conversely, a new machine is a pre-tested whole that is designed to work in unison.
Why consider a
Rebuild?
Rebuilds can improve productivity, quality and efficiency, and they can enable you to produce different
grades. They can also help your company reach strategic business goals, including measures to improve mar-
ket position, to meet new market needs or to match a competitor’s capacity and/or quality. In the current
market, common rebuilds are conversions of printing and writing paper machines.
It is worth ensuring that the technical and process goals of a proposed rebuild will also meet the business
goals. The good news is that whatever the requirement, there are many options and possibilities to improve
both your machine and your business.
Some of the most common reasons for There are other reasons that rebuilds may
rebuilding a machine include: be needed. As sustainability and environ-
mental protection become more import-
• To convert to grades that meet ant, many old machines also need to be
changing market demand modernized to meet current standards.
• To convert to more profitable grades
• To increase efficiency • To improve energy efficiency
• To increase speed and production • To reduce pollution and emissions
capacity • To meet new regulations
• To improve reliability and runnability • To change to cheaper raw materials
• To remove bottlenecks • To improve safety
• To reduce costs
• To improve quality
Before deciding on the details of your rebuild, consider that the machine may be in use for another 10 to 20
years, or even longer. This means that the decisions made before the rebuild will affect its productivity and
profitability for years to come. This includes balancing the operating costs of the rebuilt machine against the
capital costs. Although the initial investment may be large, a well-scoped rebuild should result in clear finan-
cial benefits over the lifetime of the machine – careful work at the beginning will pay off in the long run. To
ensure a successful rebuild, everything needs to be clearly defined, from the proposed targets to the sched-
ule, the costs, limitations and the market situation now and in the future. It’s also an opportunity to pre-plan
the long-term development of your machine and take into account how future rebuilds could be implement-
ed, as well.
New technologies enables Fiber based packaging pro- A rebuild provides a good
replacement of some of the ducers take great pride in opportunity to upgrade the
more expensive pulp raw providing options that are control and monitoring sys-
material with lighter filler more sustainable than plas- tems, as well as the ma-
material. tic packaging. chine.
The result is a product A rebuild may enable Integrating your machine
which is lighter in weight your customers to reduce and processes with the In-
but which performs just as the environmental foot- dustrial Internet will pro-
well, if not better. You can print of their packaging, as vide you with significant
produce more board us- well as supporting them in improvements in process
ing less raw material and their efforts to respond to awareness, analysis and
less energy, reducing both consumers’ needs for sus- control, and plenty of data
your costs and your envi- tainable choices. There is a to play with. This will im-
ronmental impact. growing need for packag- prove profitability through
Lightweighting is a kind ing products which are pro- stabilization of your pro-
of grade conversion, how- duced without a tradition- cesses and by saving energy
ever the process speeds al plastic barrier and which and raw materials, and re-
are usually higher and the are designed for full fiber ducing downtime.
conversion will place more recovery in a recycling pro- In addition, the industrial
demand on components cess. internet allows remote con-
throughout the machine, nections to the supplier’s
starting from the process support team, enabling fast-
preparations. er start-up and ramp-up,
easier optimization and a
very short response time.
1–4 weeks
Build it
• Comissioning
and testing
3–6 months
• Pre-engineering
• Concept
development
Sustainability
It is important to reserve enough time for sustainability issues. Sustainability may cover significantly more
than obtaining permits and minimizing environmental impact, and can include anti-bribery policies, health
and safety, and corporate responsibility, for example. You may also need to demonstrate that your suppli-
ers are sustainable. Choosing a supplier with a good track record makes it easier to ensure that your rebuild
meets the relevant requirements, and the most reputable paper and board machine suppliers also audit their
partners to ensure that their entire supplychain is responsible and sustainable.
Case study
Kruger – Linerboard grade conversion
Kruger converted their newsprint machine in 2017 to produce the
finest 100-percent recycled high-strength linerboard on the market, with
the help of Valmet. During initial planning, their PM10 machine, at the
Trois-Rivières mill in Canada, was identified as the best candidate for
conversion. Kruger also took advantage of Valmet’s piloting services to
develop the rebuild scope and Valmet’s pilot machine in Finland was
adapted to show the different grades that could be produced.
Regulatory needs
☐ New safety and sustainability standards
☐ Safety certification
☐ Environmental restrictions and permits
☐ Planning permission
☐ Any necessary special permits
A complete understanding of the mechanical condition and technical specifications of the machine is need-
ed before realistic goals can be set. However, a common challenge is obtaining the documentation and tech-
nical data, especially with older machines. Often the documentation is incomplete, out-of-date or not avail-
able at all.
Studies, audits and condition analysis can be used to get around this and to determine the condition and ca-
pacity of the machine, while 3D laser scanning can be used to make accurate technical drawings.
All these factors must be considered, as well as the associated costs and schedules for civil engineering.
50%
time there will be no production at all. Therefore, the paper
maker needs to consider how to serve and retain their cus-
tomers during the shutdown and prevent competitors from
taking their business.
As a result, the total investment needed must cover planning of the total cost.
costs, the actual rebuild, side costs such as civil engineering
and permits, and the income lost due to the shutdown. The
rebuild itself might only account for 50% of the total cost or
even less.
Customer
profit, €
Increased
profits
Payback time
difference
Start-up Time
Higher initial investment of a rebuild corresponds usually to higher long term profitability. If you focus sole-
ly on fast payback time, you see only half a picture. Rebuild investments calculated in millions are always in-
vestments for the next 5 or 10 years – not only 1-2 years.
Pre-engineering is done before the rebuild begins and it involves specifying all the work that the rebuild
will require. This means identifying everything that needs engineering work, from each different section of
the machine that needs to be upgraded, changed or rebuilt and the work and technologies this will involve,
down to the details of every pipe that needs to be moved, changes in supporting structures, cable runs, au-
tomation planning, the timing and duration of the shutdown and more.
This information is essential for refining the rebuild concept and ensuring it is realistic, profitable and on
schedule, and it will minimize surprises and risks.
Pilot trials
Another way to refine and validate your rebuild concept is by running pilot trials to test the process, con-
cept, chemistry and other parameters planned for the machine. After the pilot trials, you will be able to fi-
nalize your rebuild concept and scope. Pilot trials can be bought from expert paper engineering companies.
Pilot trials are generally run on special machines which can be set up and reconfigured quickly to test dif-
ferent process parameters. This enables you to test every step of the process you want to run in your rebuilt
machine, including different raw materials, stock preparations, end product quality levels, paper and board
coatings, and machine technologies. It also allows you to compare different processes, products, concepts
and technologies.
Pilot machines produce finished product samples for you to evaluate, which makes it much easier to decide
if the product quality is what you want. For this reason, pilot trials are particularly valuable if you want to
change the quality or grade that your machine produces.
Case study
SAICA – Off-line coating grade conversion
The S.A. Industrias Celulosa Aragonesa (SAICA) El Burgo mill in Spain updated
one of their machines to produce board grades with a new off-line coating ma-
chine. The investment aimed to replace the white fibers in white top liners with
something else to produce grades that were printable with standard flexo print-
ing technology.
Pilot trials proved invaluable to making the project a success. They used pilot
facilities at Valmet Paper Technology Center to speed up the concept and coat-
ing definition, and to test different ingredients and different coating amounts.
This enabled them to test the final products at each step of the path from the
very beginning all the way to a ready-made printed box. Using this process of
trial and improvement, they ensured that the very first rolls off the rebuilt ma-
chine were high quality, with excellent appearance, even coverage and enhanced
brightness.
PLAN IT VALMET REBUILD GUIDE BOOK 15
Build it
From idea to reality
– Transformation begins
Project delivery
Once everything has been planned, the rebuild can begin. Even before the project delivery begins, it is im-
portant to ensure excellent communication between all employees, contractors, subcontractors and other
partners. Each party should have clearly defined roles and responsibilities, and the schedule should be ar-
ranged to ensure that all the necessary components, permits and manpower are available at the right time.
Project management
Ensuring that the rebuild project is managed well will save you time and money. However, rebuild projects
are so large that most paper and board makers have neither the resources nor the expertise or experience to
manage them. It is strongly recommended that you use professional project managers from an outside com-
pany to manage the project for you.
These rebuild experts will have the experience to know what needs to be considered and an understanding
of all the steps and processes involved. They will take responsibility for managing all the contractors, suppli-
ers and consultants, and for keeping the project on schedule. This will ensure that all the parts and people
turn up on time, in the right place, and with the right permits.
Personnel
training
A good team of skilled personnel makes a huge difference to the success of a rebuild and they should already
be familiar with the new equipment and processes when the machine starts up. This means that they need to
be trained in advance. It’s a good idea to take training into account from the very beginning to ensure that
both your personnel and the training team are available at the right times.
You should discuss training needs with your supplier, including the number of people involved, the amount
of training and how long it will take.
Start-up
After commissioning, the machine can then be started up, i.e. production is slowly started. The machine
supplier should help with this phase as well because they will know how to get the best out of their technol-
ogy. If everything goes well, the start-up may only take a few days. depends on the size of the rebuild. De-
pending on the size of the rebuild, the start-up can take from 1-8 weeks.
Case study
Mondi – Press section modernization
Mondi rebuilt and modernized the entire press section of PM 5 at their
Štêtí mill. Keeping shutdown time to a minimum improves the over-
all profitability of a project. Therefore, Mondi and Valmet worked to-
gether to make the rebuild – and especially the commissioning phase
– as efficient as possible. This was achieved with a pre-assembled and
pre-tested press section that enabled fast onsite assembly. The smart
modular design also reduced the civil work needed. Both the technolo-
gy and automation were supplied by Valmet, which ensured the project
went smoothly. In addition to lowering costs, the short shutdown time
meant that the project stayed on schedule, and in fact they had sellable
sack kraft paper just three days after the start-up.
20 VALMET REBUILD GUIDE BOOK BUILD IT
Use it
Use it
Ramp-up
and full production
In the ramp-up phase the speed of the machine will carefully be raised until it reaches the target levels of ca-
pacity, productivity and quality. In contrast to Commissioning and Start-up, the Ramp-up phase may take
several months. Depending on the machine, the paper maker may need support from the machine supplier
for 3 to 12 months. There are several things that need to be considered:
There are different types of agreements or other working methods to cooperate with the machine suppli-
er to further improve your start-up curve and to secure the operator know-how and process understand-
ing learned from the training during the start-up period. Even if the rebuild is small, an effective adoption
of the new maintenance actions and other operations must be ensured, and machinery, equipment and pro-
cessed optimized. The agreements can be adjusted to improve and support your operations for several years.
Do’s Dont’s
Plan well Know your own strengths
The importance of good planning cannot be over-em- Your company specializes in making paper and/or
phasized. The success of the whole rebuild depends on it. board. Other companies specialize in rebuilds. They
will be familiar with all the requirements and tech-
nical needs, and the best industry practice, and they
will solve problems much faster.
Know your machine’s potential and its
limitations
If you don’t, you won’t know what can be improved or Don’t cut corners
the problems you need to solve, what the result of the Remember the long term profitability of your ma-
rebuild will be or what you’re spending your money on chine before you try to save costs in the plan-
ning phase. Skipping steps at the beginning or us-
ing cheap contractors will eventually cost you more
through delayed schedules, slow optimization, low
Do pre-engineering
reliability and late payback.
This is one of the keys to a successful rebuild.
Get a machine supplier or professional consul-
tant to help to do pre-engineering. This will re- Don’t forget the civil engineering
duce the risk of things going wrong or taking too Very many times companies only budget for work
long and ensure the profitability of your investment. on their machine but forget the other costs. This
leads to huge cost overruns. And if you forget to
budget for the civil engineering, it’s also going to be
late and delay your rebuild.
Choose a reputable supplier
Use a supplier that is experienced in pre-engineer-
ing, pilot trials and rebuild work. Using a single sup- Avoid grey areas
plier may be more expensive in the beginning but it It is essential that the delivery scope for each suppli-
will pay off in the long run – the project will go more er is very clearly defined and that the communica-
smoothly and you will avoid delivery limit risks and tions are clear. There should be no room for misun-
communication problems between suppliers and derstanding. Everyone involved must know who is
contractors. responsible for what and what the timetable is. Mis-
understandings make projects late.