Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Implementation of Total Quality Management in Order To Imp 2015 Procedia
The Implementation of Total Quality Management in Order To Imp 2015 Procedia
com
ScienceDirect
Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 1016 – 1022
2A>BFIE>F>GM:MBHGH?MHM:EJN:EBMRF:G:@>F>GMBGHK=>KMH
BFIKHO>IKH=N<MBHGI>K?HKF:G<>:G=>GA:G<BG@MA>E>O>EH?
<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG
1G>[:G:2HI:EHOBV:
)$0 ,-$.2*!,"/% 0/'.2*!*)*($- ,"/% 0 ,$
"HBG@;NLBG>LLBG:<HFI>MBMBO>:G==RG:FB<>GOBKHGF>GMK>JNBK>L<HFI:GB>LMH<HGMBGN:EERBFIKHO>:G=>GA:G<>MA>BK;NLBG>LL
I>K?HKF:G<> :G= <:I:;BEBMB>L -G> H? MA> D>R =>M>KFBG:GML H? MA> LNKOBO:E H? MA> <HFI:GR BG LN<A <BK<NFLM:G<>L BL MA>
:IIEB<:MBHGH? MHM:EJN:EBMRF:G:@>F>GM'GK><>GMR>:KL
MA><HFI:GRF:G:@>F>GMBLFHK>?H<NL>=HGMHM:EJN:EBMRF:G:@>F>GM
PAB<A E>:=L MH F:QBFBSBG@ <NLMHF>K L:MBL?:<MBHG :G= EHR:EMR 2A> :BF H? MABL LMN=R BL ?H<NL>= :M >Q:FBGBG@ MA> :MMBMN=>L H?
<HKIHK:M><EB>GMLHG:O:KB>MRH?>E>F>GMLBFIE>F>GM>=2/+IKH<>LL
IKHOB=>=;R;:GD$HKMA>LMN=R
=:M:P>K><HEE><M>=NLBG@
MA>LNKO>RF>MAH=:G=MA>LM:MBLMB<:E:G:ERLBL LN<A:L <HKK>E:MBHG:G=FNEMBIE>K>@K>LLBHG:G:ERLBL0>LNEMLH?MA>K>L>:K<AIHBGM
HNM MA:M MHI F:G:@>F>GM <HFFBMF>GM
<HNKM>LR :G= K>LIHGLB;BEBMR MHP:K=L HNK <NLMHF>KL :L LB@GB?B<:GM ?:<MHKL H? L:MBL?:<MBHG
1MN=R K>LNEML A>EI ;:GD F:G:@>KL MH B=>GMB?R JN:EBMR >E>F>GML MA:M G>>= MH ;> BFIKHO>=
MH BG<K>:L> MA> E>O>E H? <NLMHF>K
L:MBL?:<MBHG:G=>GA:G<> MA>BK;NLBG>LL
© 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
T 2A>NMAHKL.N;EBLA>=;R#EL>OB>K*M=
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
1>E><MBHG:G=
HKI>>KK>OB>PNG=>KK>LIHGLB;BEBMRH?^.>MKN+:BHK_3GBO>KLBMRH?2BK@N+NK>L
$:<NEMRH?#G@BG>>KBG@
Peer-review under responsibility of “Petru Maior” University of Tirgu Mures, Faculty of Engineering
<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG
2212-0173 © 2015 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of “Petru Maior” University of Tirgu Mures, Faculty of Engineering
doi:10.1016/j.protcy.2015.02.145
Snežana Topalović / Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 1016 – 1022 1017
!
# -- ) )#,. ,$-.$-*!
$H<NLHG!HGLNF>KL
!HGMBGN:EERBG<K>:LBG@<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG
!HGMBGNHNLK>=N<MBHGH?K>:E<HLML
LRLM>F:MB<:IIKH:<A
&HKBSHGM:EBGM>@K:MBHGH??NG<MBHGL:G=<E:LL>L
.:KMB<BI:MBHGH?:EE>FIEHR>>L
'G<ENLBHGH?LNIIER<A:BG:G=<NLMHF>K<A:BG
MA> <>GMK:E ?B@NK> BL <HGLNF>K 'G HK=>K MH F>>M <HGLNF>K =>F:G=L
BM BL G><>LL:KR MH BFIE>F>GM MA> JN:EBMR
F:G:@>F>GMLRLM>F/+1MA:M<HFIEB>LPBMAMA>K>JNBK>F>GMLH?'1-
# , '.$*)-#$+*!)/-.*( ,-.$-!.$*)
'GMA>F:KD>MBG@:G=F:G:@>F>GMEBM>K:MNK>
MA><HG<>IMH?<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG:MMK:<ML MA>:MM>GMBHGH?F:GR
:NMAHKL !NLMHF>K L:MBL?:<MBHG BL MA> K>E:MBHG ;>MP>>G >QI><M:MBHGL :G= I>K<>BO>= I>K?HKF:G<> H? MA>BK
IKH=N<ML
L>KOB<>L 89 !HGLNF>KL:MBL?:<MBHGMHP:K=LMA> IKH=N<M
L>KOB<>BL F>:LNK>=;R MA>I>K?HKF:G<>LH?MA>
IKH=N<ML
L>KOB<>L
@BO>GMA:MMA>L:MBL?:<MBHGH?LN<A:O:KB:;E>MA:MBLGHM:IK><BL>F>:LNK>F>GM2A>K>?HK>
F:GR
K>L>:K<A>KL
;R F>:LNKBG@ L:MBL?:<MBHG
>G=>:OHK MH JN:GMBM:MBO>ER :G= H;C><MBO>ER >QIK>LL MA>BK I>K<>IMBHG H?
<HGLNF>KL 2A><HG<>IMH?L:MBL?:<MBHGBLBG>QMKB<:;EREBGD>=MHMA>EHR:EMRH? <HGLNF>KLEHR:E<NLMHF>KBLHG>
Snežana Topalović / Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 1016 – 1022 1019
#
'G HK=>K MH BGO>LMB@:M> MA> =>@K>> H? <NLMHF>K L:MBL?:<MBHG ;R D>R O:KB:;E>L BFIE>F>GM>= BG 2/+ IKH<>LL
2AKHN@AMA>LM:MBLMB<:EI:<D:@>1.11
P>K>?BKLM<:E<NE:M>=MA>O:EN>H?MA><H>??B<B>GMH?K>EB:;BEBMR !KHG;:<A]L
:EIA: 89
MH <A><D MA> BGM>KG:E <HGLBLM>G<R H? MA> LM:M>F>GML MA:M P>K> ?HKF>= :KHNG= MA> L:F> O:KB:;E>L 2A>
1020 Snežana Topalović / Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 1016 – 1022
O:EN>LH?MA>:EIA:<H>??B<B>GMK:G@>:G=BGM>KO:E?KHFMH
PA>K>BMBLK><HFF>G=>=MA:MMA>O:EN>L:K>@K>:M>K
MA:G 89 'G MABL LMN=R
MA> O:KB:;E>L BFIE>F>GM>= 2/+ <HFFBMF>GM H? MHI F:G:@>F>GM
<HNKM>LR
K>LIHGLB;BEBMR
M:G@B;E>>E>F>GML:G=L:MBL?:<MBHGLAHP:AB@A=>@K>>H?K>EB:;BEBMR2:;E>
;><:NL>MA>K>LNEMBG@
AB@A E>O>EL H? :EIA: <H>??B<B>GML K:G@BG@ BG MA> BGM>KO:E ?KHF MH
:G= MA>K>?HK> <HG?BKF>= MA> BGM>KG:E
<HGLBLM>G<RH?MA>BK:LLH<B:M>=LM:M>F>GML
2A>?BKLMLM>IP:LI>K?HKF>= ;R <HKK>E:MBHG:G:ERLBLH?MA>O:KB:;E>LH?2/+:G=<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG
BGHK=>K
MH =>M>KFBG> MA> >QM>GM H? MA>BK BGM>K=>I>G=>G<> 2A> H;M:BG>= O:EN>L H? .>:KLHGL <HKK>E:MBHG <H>??B<B>GM LAHP>=
MA:M :EE O:KB:;E>L @>G>K:M> LB@GB?B<:GM IHLBMBO> <HKK>E:MBHG PBMA <NLMHF>K L:MBL?:<MBHG ;:GDL ^!HFFBMF>GM H? MHI
F:G:@>F>GM_ :G= ^0>LIHGLB;BEBMR_ =>FHGLMK:M> : AB@A =>@K>> H? <HKK>E:MBHG ;>MP>>G ^!HNKM>LR_ :G= <NLMHF>K
L:MBL?:<MBHG :II>:KL FH=>K:M> <HKK>E:MBHG
PABE> ^2:G@B;E> >E>F>GML LAHP IHHK <HKK>E:MBHG PBMA <NLMHF>K
L:MBL?:<MBHG2:;E>
2:;E>!HKK>E:MBHG;>MP>>GO:KB:;E>LH?2/+:G=<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHGBG;:GDBG@
2/+O:KB:;E>L !HKK>E:MBHG<H>??B<B>GMLPBMA<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG
!HFFBMF>GMH?MHIF:G:@>F>GM
!HNKM>LR
0>LIHGLB;BEBMR
2:G@B;E>>E>F>GML
!HKK>E:MBHGBLLB@GB?B<:GM:MMA>E>O>EM:BE>=
2:;E>0>LNEMLH?MA>FNEMBIE>K>@K>LLBHG:G:ERLBL=>I>G=>GMO:KB:;E>L:MBL?:<MBHG
2/+O:KB:;E>L U M 4'$
!HFFBMF>GMH?MHIF:G:@>F>GM
!HNKM>LR
0>LIHGLB;BEBMR
2:G@B;E>>E>F>GML GL
0>LNEML:K>LB@GB?B<:GM:MMA>E>O>EI0>LNEML:K> LB@GB?B<:GM:MMA>E>O>EI
0>LNEML:K>GHMLB@GB?B<:GM:MMA>E>O>EIGL0
$BG:EER
MA> BFIE>F>GM:MBHG H? FNEMBIE> K>@K>LLBHG =>M>KFBG>= MA> >??><M H? ?HNK BG=>I>G=>GM O:KB:;E>L
<HFFBMF>GM H? MHI F:G:@>F>GM
<HNKM>LR
K>LIHGLB;BEBMR
M:G@B;E> >E>F>GML BG L:MBL?:<MBHG :L MA> =>I>G=>GM
O:KB:;E>*H<:M>=K>@K>LLBHGL :K>IK>L>GM>=BG2:;E>BG=B<:M>:LB@GB?B<:GM>??><MH?MAK>>BG=>I>G=>GMO:KB:;E>L
^!HFFBMF>GMH?MHIF:G:@>F>GM_U
M
^!HNKM>LR_ U
M:G=0>LIHGLB;BEBMR U
M 'G MA> <:L> H? 2:G@B;E> >E>F>GML U
M GH LM:MBLMB<:EER LB@GB?B<:GM >??><M
'G=>I>G=>GMO:KB:;E>L>QIE:BG:;HNMH?MA>O:KB:;BEBMRH?MA>=>I>G=>GMO:KB:;E>2AKHN@AMA>4'$O:EN>L
MA>
M>LM>=:G=MA>IKH;E>FH?FNEMB<HEEBG>:KBMR'?MA>@BO>G<H>??B<B>GMO:EN>MH;>@K>:M>KMA:G 89
FNEMB<HEEBG>:KBMR
H<<NKL:L:IKH;E>F'GMABLLMN=RP>K>H;M:BG>=;R:IIKHIKB:M>O:EN>LH?MA>4'$<H>??B<B>GMBGMA>K:G@>H?MH
Snežana Topalović / Procedia Technology 19 (2015) 1016 – 1022 1021
2A> LN<<>LL H? :GR HK@:GBS:MBHG BL =>M>KFBG>= ;R MA> ;>A:OBHK H? <HGLNF>KL
LH MA>R G>>= MH NG=>KLM:G= :G=
K>:EBS> MA> <NKK>GM :G= ?NMNK> G>>=L :G= >QI><M:MBHGL H? <HGLNF>KL
LMKBO> MH F>>M MA>BK K>JNBK>F>GML
:G= >O>G
>Q<>>=MA>BK>QI><M:MBHGL2A>IKBF:KRINKIHL>H?:GRHK@:GBS:MBHG
BGMABLLMN=R;:GDBG@MA>BGLMBMNMBHG
BLMHF>>M
:G= >Q<>>= MA> >QI><M:MBHGL :G= =>F:G=L H? MA>BK <NLMHF>KL
LH <NLMHF>KL P>K> L:MBL?B>= :G= >O>GMN:EER ;><HF>
EHR:E +H=>KG <HG=BMBHGL H? ;:GDBG@ LMK>LL MA:M MA> L>KOB<> H??>KL AB@A JN:EBMR ;>LM P:R MH :<AB>O> <HFI>MBMBO>
:=O:GM:@> :G= :<AB>OBG@ ?BG:G<B:E LN<<>LL 'G HK=>K MH :<AB>O> MABL
MA> ;NLBG>LL IKH<>LL BG PAB<A MA> IKH=N<M BL
BFIE>F>GM>= :G=
HK L>KOB<>L FNLM ;> ;:L>= HG MA> 2/+ :IIKH:<A :GDL FNLM <HGMBGNHNLER PHKD HG BFIKHOBG@
:G=BFIKHOBG@;NLBG>LLIKH<>LL>LPBMABGPAB<AMH<K>:M>?BG:G<B:EL>KOB<>L
'G MABL I:I>K P> BFIE>F>GM>= :G >FIBKB<:E LMN=R MH >Q:FBG> MA> K>E:MBHGLABI ;>MP>>G 2/+ :G= <NLMHF>K
L:MBL?:<MBHGBGMA>;:GDBG@BG=NLMKR :L>=HGMA>?BG=BG@LH?MA><HKK>E:MBHG:G:ERLBL
BMP:L<HG?BKF>=MA:MMA>K>BL:
IHLBMBO><HKK>E:MBHG;>MP>>GMA>?HNKO:KB:;E>LH?2/+<HFFBMF>GMH?MHIF:G:@>F>GM
<HNKM>LR
K>LIHGLB;BEBMR
"
II>:K:G<>H?>FIEHR>>L
+H=>KG>JNBIF>GM
89 2AB:@:K:@:G 2
7:BKB +
":E> % IKHIHL>= FH=>E H? 2/+ BFIE>F>GM:MBHG ;:L>= HG :G >FIBKB<:E LMN=R H? +:E:RLB:G BG=NLMKR
'GM>KG:MBHG:E(HNKG:EH?/N:EBMR0>EB:;BEBMR+:G:@>F>GM
89 1NK>LA<A:G=:K%1
0:C>G=K:G!
G:GMA:K:F:G0,2A>K>E:MBHGLABI;>MP>>GL>KOB<>JN:EBMR:G=<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG \ :?:<MHKLI><B?B<
:IIKH:<A(HNKG:EH?1>KOB<>+:KD>MBG@
89 +>AK:1
&H??F:G(+
1BKB:L"2/+:L:F:G:@>F>GMLMK:M>@R?HKMA>G>QMFBEE>GGB:'GM>KG:MBHG:E(HNKG:EH?-I>K:MBHGL:G=.KH=N<MBHG
+:G:@>F>GM
89 1:F:M ,
0:F:R:A 2
1::= ,+( 2/+ IK:<MB<>L
L>KOB<> JN:EBMR
:G= F:KD>M HKB>GM:MBHG 1HF> >OB=>G<> ?KHF : =>O>EHIBG@ <HNGMKR
+:G:@>F>GM0>L>:K<A,>PL
89 K:A 1
2>> 11* 0>E:MBHGLABI ;>MP>>G 2/+ :G= I>K?HKF:G<> H? 1BG@:IHK> <HFI:GB>L 'GM>KG:MBHG:E (HNKG:E H? /N:EBMR 0>EB:;BEBMR
+:G:@>F>GM
89 1:DMABO>E .
0:C>G=K:G %
0:CN 0 2/+ BFIE>F>GM:MBHG 2/ BFIE>F>GM:MBHG :G= LMN=>GML] L:MBL?:<MBHG H? :<:=>FB< I>K?HKF:G<> 2A>
2/++:@:SBG>
89 ):GCB %)
2:F;B +
5:EE:<> 5 <HFI:K:MBO> LMN=R H? JN:EBMR IK:<MB<>L BG AB@A>K >=N<:MBHG BGLMBMNMBHGL BG MA> 31 :G= +:E:RLB:
2HM:E/N:EBMR+:G:@>F>GM
89 %NIM:
!A>G '1>KOB<> /N:EBMR BFIEB<:MBHGL ?HK F:G:@>F>GM =>O>EHIF>GM 'GM>KG:MBHG:E (HNKG:E H? /N:EBMR 0>EB:;BEBMR +:G:@>F>GM
89 -HB)
*BG
!AHG@6*K>2/+IK:<MB<>LLNIIHKMBG@<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG:G=L>KOB<>JN:EBMR(HNKG:EH?1>KOB<>L+:KD>MBG@
89 -:DE:G=12HM:E/N:EBMR+:G:@>F>GM \ 2A>KHNM>MHBFIKHOBG@I>K?HKF:G<>1><HG=#=BMBHG-Q?HK= NMM>PHKMA \ &>G>F:GG
89 1M>O>GLHG(.KH=N<MBHG
-I>K:MBHGL+:G:@>F>GM$HNKMA#=BMBHG HLMHG'KPBG&HF>PHH=
89 7:BKB+2A>2/+E>@:LR %NKNL]<HGMKB;NMBHGL:G=MA>HK>MB<:EBFI:<M 2A>2/+(HNKG:E
89 $HMHIHNEHL !4
.LHF:L #* 2A> LMKN<MNK:E K>E:MBHGLABIL ;>MP>>G MHM:E JN:EBMR F:G:@>F>GM ?:<MHKL :G= HK@:GBS:MBHG:E I>K?HKF:G<> 2A>
2/+(HNKG:E
89 @NL
&:LL:G7 #GA:G<BG@.KH=N<MBHG.>K?HKF:G<>:G=!NLMHF>K.>K?HKF:G<>2AKHN@A2HM:E/N:EBMR+:G:@>F>GM2/+
1MK:M>@B>L$HK!HFI>MBMBO>=O:GM:@> .KH<>=B: 1H<B:E:G= >A:OBHK:E1<B>G<>L
\
89 %HE=F:G&&2A>HKB@BGL:G==>O>EHIF>GMH?JN:EBMRBGBMB:MBO>LBGF>KB<:G ;NLBG>LL2A>2/++:@:SBG>
89 (HAGLHG 551NI>KBHK<NLMHF>KO:EN>BGMA>G>P><HGHFR<HG<>IML:G=<:L>L!0!.K>LL
H<:0:MHG
89 +>AK:1
0:G@:G:MA:G1'FIE>F>GMBG@MHM:EJN:EBMRF:G:@>F>GMPBMA:?H<NLHG>GA:G<BG@<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG'GM>KG:MBHG:E (HNKG:EH?
/N:EBMR0>:EB:;BEMR+:G:@>F>GM
89 #DEH?(
5>LMENG=!NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHGBG=>Q:G=BMLKHE>BGJN:EBMRF:G:@>F>GM2HM:E/N:EBMR+:G:@>F>GM
89 @NL
)KBLAG:G1)
):=BK1*12A>LMKN<MNK:EBFI:<MH?MHM:EJN:EBMRF:G:@>F>GMHG?BG:G<B:EI>K?HKF:G<>K>E:MBO>MH<HFI>MBMHKL
MAKHN@A<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG:LMN=RH?+:E:RLB:GF:GN?:<MNKBG@<HFI:GB>L2HM:E/N:EBMR+:G:@>F>GM
89 ":YBV . 1M:GHC>OBV + 1NKO>R H? BGM>KG:MBHG:E LM:G=:K=L ?HK JN:EBMR F:G:@>F>GM LRLM>FL /+1 +H=>EEBG@ :G= -IMBFBS:MBHG BG MA>
+:<ABG>L NBE=BG@$B>E=L+-!+
89 ":YBV.0:SOHCF>XNG:KH=GBABG:<BHG:EGBALM:G=:K=:S:LBLM>FDO:EBM>M:'1-)O:EBM>M
89 1M:G=:K='1- /N:EBMRF:G:@>F>GMLRLM>FL 0>JNBK>F>GML'GLMBMNM>?HK1M:G=:K=BS:MBHGH?1>K;B:'11
89 0HLL(#2HM:EJN:EBMRF:G:@>F>GM$EHKB=:ME:GMB<3GBO>KLBMR
89 -EBO>K*0<H@GBMBO>FH=>EH?MA>:GM><>=>GML:G=<HGL>JN>G<>LH?L:MBL?:<MBHG=><BLBHGL(HNKG:EH?+:KD>MBG@0>L>:K<A
89 #$/+!NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG /N:EBMN5HKDBG@1><MBHG2PH+:K<A -<MH;>K
89 !AB>G2)
1N!&
1N!2'FIE>F>GM:MBHGH?:<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHGIKH@K:F:<:L>LMN=R'G=NLMKB:E+:G:@>F>GM":M:1RLM>FL
89 2>KSBHOLDB+/N:EBMRF:G:@>F>GMIK:<MB<>L:G=MA>BKK>E:MBHGLABIPBMA<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG:G=IKH=N<MBOBMRBFIKHO>F>GM+:G:@>F>GM
0>L>:K<A,>PL
89 +>AK:1
0:G@:G:MA:G1'FIE>F>GMBG@MHM:EJN:EBMRF:G:@>F>GMPBMA :?H<NLHG>G<A:G<BG@<NLMHF>KL:MBL?:<MBHG'GM>KG:MBHG:E(HNKG:EH?
/N:EBMR0>EB:;BEBMR
89 .:K:LNK:F:G
7>BMA:FE4
>KKR**1#04/3*:FNEMBIE>BM>FL<:E>?HKF>:LNKBG@<HGLNF>KI>K<>IMBHGH?L>KOB<>JN:EBMR(HNKG:E
H? 0>M:BEBG@
89 (HAGLHG +"
%NLM:?LLHG
G=K>:LL>G 25
*>KOBD *
!A: ( 2A> >OHENMBHG :G= ?NMNK> H? G:MBHG:E <NLMHF>K L:MBL?:<MBHG BG=>Q FH=>EL
(HNKG:EH?#<HGHFB<.LR<AHEH@R
89 !KHG;:<A*(!H>??B<B>GM :EIA::G=MA>BGM>KG:ELMKN<MNK>H?M>LM.RL<AHF>MKB<:
89 ,NGG:EER(!'GMKH=N<MBHGMHILR<AHEH@B<:EF>:LNK>F>GM,>P6HKD,6+<%K:P&BEE
89 $B>E="BL<HO>KBG@LM:MBLMB<LNLBG@1.11?HK5BG=HPL2AHNL:G=-:DL311:@> .N;EB<:MBHG