7/17/2021 Pakistan fails to reap demographic dividend

EXPRESS NEWS
URDU E-PAPER
ENGLISH E-PAPER
SINDHI E-PAPER
CRICKET PAKISTAN
EXPRESS LIVE
CAMPUS GURU
EXPRESS ENTERTAINMENT
FOOD TRIBUNE





TODAY'S PAPER |
JULY 17, 2021 |
ADVERTISE

Pakistan fails to reap demographic dividend

Experts do not see overpopulation as real factor behind poverty

Anadolu Agency July 11, 2021 

A Pakistani flag flies on a mast as paramilitary Frontier Corps soldiers talk while guarding at Karachi's District Malir prison, August 23, 2013. PHOTO: REUTERS

KARACHI: Pakistan has many introductions – a leading cricketing

nation, the land of several defunct civilizations and the sixth most
populated country in the world.

The second most-populated Muslim nation, just after Indonesia, is home to

over 200 million with rich ethnic and cultural diversity.

Yet, the South Asian country, experts say, has missed on reaping the dividend
of its unique demography and large population.

"Pakistan is going through a phase of demographic transition, experiencing

once-in-a-lifetime opportunity of reaping the demographic dividend as the
working-age population bulges and the dependency ratio declines,” said Durre
Nayab, a joint director at the Pakistan Institute of Development Economics, a
research institute and public policy think-tank in Islamabad.

She told Anadolu Agency that if appropriate policies are not formulated, the
demographic dividend can, in fact, be a "cost," leading to unemployment and
an unbearable strain on education, health, and old age security.

"The country can make use of this opportunity through three mechanisms,
which are labor supply, savings, and human capital," she said.

For economic benefits to materialize, she argued, there is a need for policies
dealing with education, public health, and those that promote labor market
flexibility and provide incentives for investment and savings.

The increasing number of people entering working-age, she said, is acting as a

"double-edged sword."

"If they do not enter the labor force the very logic of demographic dividend is
defied, but if they become economically active it poses a big challenge to the
country’s economy to provide them gainful employment," said Nayab.

"This is quite improbable in the absence of sound economic policies and

educated and skilled workers," she said, adding that the "poor" state of
education and skill in the country is leading to high unemployment rates,
especially among the youth, more so the educated youth, which can lead to
instability.

Census disputes

Population recording itself has been a long-running dispute in Pakistan,

pitching provinces and communities against each other for their "due share" of
national resources based on their numbers.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/2310022/1?fbclid=IwAR2i3KOo5E9XB0bbNrm0TOyJZhzvCKMGTDMp1zaAqFzE2wCD5Ntp5FS_cLY 1/5
7/17/2021 Pakistan fails to reap demographic dividend

It also forced the government to delay the census, which, according to the
Constitution, is scheduled every five years.

The sixth census, which was slated to be held in 1998, was held in 2017 after a
gap of more than 18 years.

So much so, the definitive figures of the 2017 census were announced in May
after more than three years due to objections from two provinces – southern
Sindh and northwestern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa – which accused authorities of
deliberately reducing their numbers.

Pakistan's population is now 207.8 million.

Northeastern Punjab remains the most populous province with slightly less
than 110 million, followed by Sindh with 47.8 million, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
34 million and southwestern Balochistan 11.3 million.

The population of the northwestern tribal belt is slightly less than five million.

The commercial capital of Karachi remains the largest city with more than 15
million people, followed by northeastern Lahore with 11 million.

Experts and politicians, however, appear to be skeptical about population

figures for Karachi, claiming the city's actual population is somewhere around
25 million.

More than 106.4 million people in Pakistan are men, while 101.3 are women.
Over 60% of the population resides in rural areas.

Fertility trends

Raza Ali, a Lahore-based analyst who often writes on census issues, sees
declining fertility trends in Pakistan with urban women having fewer children
than rural.

The fertility rate, he said, also declines as educational and income level of
women increases.

Punjab has the lowest fertility rate, mainly because of urbanization, followed
by Sindh.

Currently, northwestern Balochistan province, which covers 42% of Pakistan

in terms of land, but lowest in terms of population, has the highest growth
rate. According to Ali, Punjab has the lowest growth rate.

"No single factor is responsible for these trends," Nayab said. "It is a
combination of many socio-economic, cultural and religious factors. Female
participation in the labor force, especially those employed in gainful
employment, impacts these rates too.”

That, she said, is one reason that the combined action of education,
employment and income lowers fertility rates.

With increasing education, employment and awareness norms of a smaller

family are gradually becoming acceptable.

"The pace, however, is still slower than in other countries of the region such as
India, Iran, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Nepal. Only Afghanistan is behind us,"
said Nayab.

"The young couples would have fewer children once the opportunity cost of
having more kids increases. That is what has been observed in all countries of
the region showing a faster fertility decline."

Over​population not real issue

Many, including government officials​, dub the growing population as one of

the key causes of poverty.

However, Anjum Altaf, a former dean at the School of Humanities and Social
Sciences, Lahore University of Management Sciences​, sees the assertion as
"over-blown" and an evasion from real issues.

"There are a number of problems with this simple proposition. No need to be

fooled by arguments about [over] population," Altaf told Anadolu Agency. "Do
ask yourself why China went from a one-child policy to a two-child policy and

https://tribune.com.pk/story/2310022/1?fbclid=IwAR2i3KOo5E9XB0bbNrm0TOyJZhzvCKMGTDMp1zaAqFzE2wCD5Ntp5FS_cLY 2/5
7/17/2021 Pakistan fails to reap demographic dividend

is now going to a three-child one? If overpopulation is a problem, how did

China become a superpower?"

"How is Bangladesh doing so much better than Pakistan along with all
economic and social indicators with an equal population, less area, and much
fewer natural resources?" he argued.

Population, he said, is not a "very useful" measure by itself simply because it

fails to account for the size of the land in which the population resides.

Pointing to a vast Russia and a small Singapore in terms of area, Anjum said
the appropriate indicator to use to make valid comparisons is "population
density," which means population per unit of land area.

Nonetheless, he said, simply looking at the population or population density

explains "very little" about a society’s problems.

"Just take the examples of Belgium, Pakistan and Somalia. Belgium has a
much higher population density, Pakistan is in the middle, whereas Somalia
ranks very low. Using this indicator, Belgium is not the one with the most
difficulties. Nor does Somalia have the fewest," he said.

In Pakistan, he added, Balochistan has the lowest population density among

the provinces, but it is by no means better off than the other federating units
because of its low population and population density.



E-PUBLICATIONS

EPAPER TMAGAZINE T.EDIT

MOST READ
24 HOURS 3 DAYS COMMENTED

Pakistan, Russia cut deal on pipeline

project

China postpones JCC meeting

Updated Jul 16, 2021

Afghan peace moot postponed

after Ghani’s snub
Updated 17 hours ago

The next Afghan war

Updated Jul 16, 2021

Eid in controlled, limited

environment: SAPM
Updated Jul 15, 2021

Join Us

https://tribune.com.pk/story/2310022/1?fbclid=IwAR2i3KOo5E9XB0bbNrm0TOyJZhzvCKMGTDMp1zaAqFzE2wCD5Ntp5FS_cLY 3/5
7/17/2021 Pakistan fails to reap demographic dividend

  

RELATED

Government plans steps to tackle What China’s poverty reduction Corruption principal cause of
poverty experience means to the world poverty, inequality in developing
countries: NAB chief

RECOMMENDED STORIES

Intellectual poverty Death in the Himalayas: Poverty, Pakistani YouTuber endeavours to

fear, stretched resources propel end poverty with business videos
India's Covid-19 crisis

LATEST

Uproar in Senate after NAB’s delay irks PAC Civil service matters Large scale strategic Shops can stay open Govt releases Rs121b
govt bills presented sub-committee not high court projects a priority: during ‘prayer times’ for ex-FATA
domain: SC Asad in Saudi Arabia

COMMENTS (1)

wajid | 4 days ago

| Reply

Bangladesh s population is significantly lower than Pakistan. They managed to control population growth while Pakistan hasn t.

Name (required) Email (required)

Write your comment here

Post comment

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

T.EDIT

https://tribune.com.pk/story/2310022/1?fbclid=IwAR2i3KOo5E9XB0bbNrm0TOyJZhzvCKMGTDMp1zaAqFzE2wCD5Ntp5FS_cLY 4/5
7/17/2021 Pakistan fails to reap demographic dividend

The Accessories Edit The Beauty Edit Make-up tips to sweat proof your look

MOST READ

Pakistan, Russia cut China postpones JCC Afghan peace moot The next Afghan war Eid in controlled, Local govts in Punjab
deal on pipeline meeting postponed after limited environment: to wait a few weeks
project Ghani’s snub SAPM more

OPINION

Digital skills a Cost of a divided Waiting with bated EOBI stands on six The next Afghan war Climate induced
necessity post-Covid world breath broken pillars displacements

Pakistan Life & Style Fuel Prices Pakistan About Us Style Guide FOLLOW US
Business T.Edit Gold Prices Pakistan Online Advertising Privacy Policy
World Sports Prayer Timing Pakistan RSS Feeds Copyright
Opinion Blog Weather Forecast Pakistan Subscribe to the Paper Code of ethics
Videos Contact Us Mobile App
Careers

This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten,

redistributed or derived from. Unless
otherwise stated, all content is
copyrighted © 2021 The Express Tribune.

https://tribune.com.pk/story/2310022/1?fbclid=IwAR2i3KOo5E9XB0bbNrm0TOyJZhzvCKMGTDMp1zaAqFzE2wCD5Ntp5FS_cLY 5/5