Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Construction and Building Materials: Gökhan Görhan
Construction and Building Materials: Gökhan Görhan
The evaluation with anova of the effect of lime admixture and thermal
cure time on fly ash paste activated with sodium silicate solution
Gökhan Görhan
Afyon Kocatepe University, Engineering Faculty, Civil Engineering Department, 03200 Afyonkarahisar, Turkey
h i g h l i g h t s
Fly ash was activated with sodium silicate solution and quenched calcium lime.
The samples were subjected to thermal curing at +105 °C for 12, 24 and 48 h.
The curing time had no statistically significant effect on water absorption.
The lime rate had no statistically significant effect on the apparent density.
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Class F fly ash obtained from Kütahya Seyitömer (Turkey) thermal power plant was used as raw material
Received 6 January 2015 in this study. Fly ash was activated with sodium silicate solution (water glass) and quenched calcium lime
Received in revised form 3 May 2015 was substituted to the mixture at rates ranging from 10% to 30%. Then, samples were formed in
Accepted 6 July 2015
4 4 16 cm metal molds by means of the vibration method. The samples were subjected to thermal
Available online 10 July 2015
curing in a laboratory type oven at +105 °C for 12, 24 and 48 h in order for them to acquire resistance.
After the curing process, the physical properties such as apparent porosity, apparent density, bulk den-
Keywords:
sity, water absorption by weight and linear shrinkage, and the mechanical properties such as flexural
Sodium silicate solution
Fly ash
strength and compressive strength of the samples were determined by the three samples for each mix-
Lime ture. After the physical and mechanical tests, a two-factor analysis of variance (ANOVA) and a compara-
Thermal cure tive analysis of the mean values were carried out in order to investigate the effects of the variables used
in the production and the preparation of the samples on the values. Consequently, it was determined that
in the fly ash–lime mixtures, 24 h curing for the samples with 20% lime substitution is very efficient and
that these samples yield the best compressive strength.
Ó 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2015.07.011
0950-0618/Ó 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
G. Görhan / Construction and Building Materials 94 (2015) 228–234 229
Geopolymer maintains its internal reactions after it takes form activation of fly ash. It is also stated that, due to the high Si content,
similarly to portland cement. The exothermic reaction of geopoly- the use of water glass during geopolymerization leads to a high
mer continues until it forms the three-dimensional oligomer mechanical resistance in samples [30]. However, the use of water
macromolecular structure. Water glass (sodium silicate) glass in the form of powder is observed to lead to lower perfor-
(Na2SiO3) or gibbsite (sodium aluminate) (Na2O-Al2O3) is added mance than when the liquid form is used [10].
so that the main components in the fly ash dissolve together with There is little information in the literature on fly ash activated
alkaline salt in a more regular fashion and this way, the properties with alkaline solution–calcium hydroxide pastes. It is pointed out
of the geopolymer material improve. Solutions to which these that the thermal curing of fly ash–CH containing systems at
chemicals are added are called solid-gel solutions. The use of a 100 °C, increases hydrate products to higher levels [20].
great amount of water in such solutions for the dissolution of Therefore, different from the literature, in this study, fly ash–lime
chemicals reduces the compressive strength properties of the pastes activated only with sodium silicate solution were subjected
material. The concentration of precipitate sodium ion is high in to thermal curing at high temperatures. Ca(OH)2 substitution was
such compositions. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) shows that carried out for the activation process of the fly ash to be more
sodium aluminate tetrahedral containing Al and Si, which are the effective during the preparation of the pastes and then the proper-
main elements of fly ash, facilitates the formation of the alu- ties of the samples were investigated. Two-factor ANOVA tests
minium bond structure and that water glass increases the were applied in order to determine the effects of the factors (curing
cross-linked silicate molecules [6]. time and lime rate of substitution) on the data obtained. The
Geopolymers are generally prepared at low temperatures using two-factor ANOVA test is a statistical method which analyses the
fly ash [2]. Fly ash, which is a thermal power plant solid waste, con- main effects of factors and the joint effect of two factors on a
tains silicon and aluminium which can be activated by alkaline dependent variable instead of analysing separately the effect of
solutions [17]. Since fly ash particles are formed at high tempera- two factors between groups on a dependent variable [31]. The lit-
tures, they have a chemically stable and glass-like structure. erature includes studies in which ANOVA tests are applied [32–38].
Therefore, the reactivity in the process of hydration of fly ash is
low. Alkali activations are used to increase the pozzolanic reactiv- 2. Material and method
ity of fly ash, and alkalis such as NaOH, Ca(OH)2 etc. are used in
these processes [18]. 2.1. Materials
Liquid solution which will be used in the activation process can
be either a single material or formed by mixing a number of differ- Fly ash with low levels of calcium oxide (CaO) and a SiO2/Al2O3
ent materials [17]. In the activation process, a strong alkaline med- ratio of 2.41 by mass was used in this study as raw material
ium is needed to increase the surface hydrolysis of the raw (Table 1) and it was obtained from Kütahya Seyitömer thermal
material particles with the dissolution of an amount of silica and power plant. The chemical composition of the fly ash was deter-
alumina particles in the material. This medium can be obtained mined by X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analysis and it is presented in
by using a single or combined alkaline solutions referred to as acti- Table 1. According to the data obtained from the XRF analysis,
vators [16]. the fly ash was of Class F according to ASTM C-618 [39].
The raw material of alkaline lime is CaO and is obtained by the Fig. 1 presents the XRD graphic of the mineralogical analysis of
sintering of CaCO3, also known as limestone, between 850 and the fly ash. According to the XRD analysis, the main minerals in the
900 °C. Limes are not used in the form of calcium oxide (CaO). fly ash are quartz, magnetite, anhydride, anorthite and hematite.
They have to be quenched, and the quenching of the lime is a S-KK 80 T quenched calcium lime, which conforms to TS 4022
hydration process. When quenched, the size of the lime increases [41], was used as replacement material during the production of
2–2.5 times. Deformation and cracks may occur in the material if the samples (Table 2).
the lime containing material is not thoroughly quenched. When
hydrated lime–calcium hydroxide Ca(OH)2–(CH) is treated with 2.2. Preparation of samples
plenty of water, CH particles are dispersed in suspension in the
water [19]. In the preparation of the samples, fly ash and lime were first dry
Information regarding the surface of CH particles in an environ- mixed until reaching a homogeneous state. Then, mixing water
ment where CH is abundant is scarce in the literature. However, which was equal to the sum of the mass weight of the mixture
one study shows that the consumption rate of CH increased in was prepared. Accordingly, one unit of dry material was mixed
the CH and fly ash mixtures with an increase in the content of with one unit of mixing water. The mixing water was prepared
CH during the first mixture. The increase in the consumption rate in a way that 1=4 of it was water and 3=4 of it was sodium silicate
was accounted for by the increase in the calcium ions in parallel solution (water glass) (Na2OSiO2) by weight for all the mixtures.
with the increase of CH surfaces in the solution. Another study Table 3 presents the prepared mixtures and the ingredients they
states that in the case of an increase in the CH/fly ash ratio in contain.
the starting material, the consumption rate of CH increases [20]. Through substitution, lime admixture was added to the fly ash
It is observed that in general studies on the activation of fly ash based mixtures activated with sodium silicate solution. After the
prefer to use two different alkaline activator materials, and differ- mixtures were homogeneously mixed, they were placed into
ent curing times and temperatures in the activation process. In one cement mortar molds (4 4 16 cm) with the help of a vibrating
of these studies, Thokchom et al. cured the samples produced by table. Then, the samples were subjected to thermal curing in a lab-
using fly ash and sand at 85 °C for 48 h [21]. Rickard et al. used oratory type oven at +105 °C. Three samples for each sample group
sodium silicate and sodium aluminate solutions for the synthesis were used in the physical and mechanical tests. Three different
of fly ash based geopolymer and cured the samples at 70 °C for curing times (12, 24 and 48 h) were used in the curing of the
24 h [22]. Sarker used sodium hydroxide and sodium silicate in samples.
the production of fly ash based geopolymer concrete and cured
the samples at 60 °C for 24 h. He suggested that the samples 2.3. Tests
yielded satisfactory results [23]. In addition, there are some studies
in the literature in which fly ash content geopolymer materials are After the curing processes, the samples were placed in a water
produced [24–29]. Furthermore, NaOH is a good activator for the tank for 24 h to determine their physical properties. Water
230 G. Görhan / Construction and Building Materials 94 (2015) 228–234
Table 1
Chemical analysis values of fly ash [40].
SiO2 Al2O3 Na2O Fe2O3 CaO MgO P2O5 SO3 K2O MnO TiO2 Cr2O3 LOI
46.30 19.20 0.51 11.00 6.34 4.76 0.10 1.54 2.45 0.11 0.87 0.12 3.26
(a) 60 (b) 60
App. porosity Water absorption
50 50
40 40
(%)
(%)
30 30
20 20
10 10
0 0
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3
Mixture Mixture
increase in the curing time increased the water absorption rates samples cured for 12, 24 and 48 h; A2, B2 and C2 samples had
while in the mixtures with 30% lime substitution the increase in the highest density. Considering the density values, we can state
the curing time reduced the water absorption rates. However, the that the samples with 20% lime substitution resulted in a better
effect of the increase in the curing time on the water absorption microstructure for each curing time (Fig. 3b).
rates of the mixtures with 20% lime substitution is not clear. Linear shrinkage ratios of the fly ash–lime pastes increased with
Furthermore, it is also reported that during the curing process, an increase in the lime substitution ratios. Accordingly, linear
materials are prone to high water absorption as a result of water shrinkage ratios of the pastes with 10%, 20% and 30% lime substitu-
and alkali movement on the surface of the geopolymer material tion ratios were 1.6%, 1.8% and 2.0%, respectively.
[47].
In general, bulk density is expected to increase with a decrease 3.2. Mechanical properties
in the apparent porosity ratio. The samples produced in this study
have a similar tendency. The bulk density values of the pastes Fig. 4 presents the flexural strength and compressive strength
cured for 24 and 48 h are in close proximity. However, the bulk values, which are two of the mechanical properties. According to
density values of the samples cured for 12 h were observed to be the findings, an increase in the curing time applied to the samples
lower than those of the samples cured for 24 and 48 h. Many stud- led to significant changes in their resistance values. In general, the
ies in the literature report that the applied curing time has a signif- flexural strength of the samples decreased with the prolonged cur-
icant effect on the resistance of alkali activated materials. ing time. It was determined that not only the curing time but also
Therefore, it is estimated that the 12 h thermal curing applied to the lime substitution ratios were effective on the reduction of the
the fly ash–lime pastes does not allow adequate chemical reaction flexural strength values. As a matter of fact, a certain level of loss in
in the material and thus, the bulk density remains at lower levels flexural strength was observed with the increase in the amount of
compared to the long thermal curing (Fig. 3a). The effect of the lime added to the mixture. Of the 10% and 20% lime substituted
lime admixture on the bulk density values of the samples cured samples, the highest flexural strength values were obtained from
for 24 h was unclear while a linear increase in the bulk density val- the pastes cured for 12 h while, of the 30% lime substituted sam-
ues of the samples cured for 48 h was observed with an increase in ples, the highest flexural strength values were obtained from the
the lime admixture. Lime contribution to the samples cured for pastes cured for 24 h (Fig. 4a).
12 h led to a decrease in their bulk density values. Of these sample It was observed that, in contrast to the flexural strength values
groups, C3 samples had the highest bulk density value of of the samples cured for 12 h, they were unable to exhibit com-
1081.7 kg/m3 (Fig. 3a). pressive strength. What is more, the compressive strength ratios
The apparent density values of all samples regardless of the cur- of the samples cured for 12 h were observed to decrease with the
ing time were between 1662.4 kg/m3 and 2081.1 kg/m3. Of the increase of the lime ratio in the mixture (Fig. 4b). Compressive
800
1500
(kg/m3)
(kg/m3)
600
1000
400
500
200
0 0
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3
Mixture Mixture
(MPa)
6
0.6
4
0.4
0.2 2
0 0
A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3 A1 A2 A3 B1 B2 B3 C1 C2 C3
Mixture Mixture
strength increased only in the samples with 10% lime substitution significant effect on the water absorption values of the samples.
with the increase in the curing time. Khatib et al. reported that a As a matter of fact, Table 4 indicates that the curing time, com-
3.5 MPa compressive strength was reached in the samples with pared to the ANOVA results, had an effect on apparent porosity,
10% lime substitution after 56 days [48]. From this perspective, it bulk density, apparent density, flexural strength and compressive
is clear how important the strength values obtained in the study strength values. In terms of mechanical properties, it can be stated
are. that the effect of the curing time on the compressive strength val-
The effect of the curing time is not clear for other substitution ues is more pronounced. Evaluating the mean values obtained
rates (20% and 30%). In fact, a previous study reports that even in according to the curing time and ANOVA results together, it was
the case of making preliminary improvement in the raw material, observed that the compressive strength values of the samples were
the chemical and structural properties of minerals are complex and at higher levels when cured for 24 h. These results are also sup-
yield different results [49]. ported by the ANOVA results. The flexural strength values were
Compressive strength values indicate that 24 h curing for the at higher levels when the samples were cured for 12 h. The flexural
samples with 20% lime substitution is very efficient and that these strength values of the samples cured for 12, 24 and 48 h were
samples yield the best compressive strength. It is also reported in 0.8 MPa, 0.7 MPa and 0.5 MPa, respectively. Hence, it was observed
the literature that the strength of pozzolan–hydrated lime mix- that the curing time did not have a statistically significant effect on
tures increases with an increase in the hydrated lime ratios and the water absorption of the samples, whilst it had a statistically
that the critical rate varies between 20% and 35% [50]. significant effect on mechanical properties such as compressive
strength and flexural strength values. As the analyses were carried
3.3. Statistical analysis out in the 95% confidence interval for the ANOVA results, the cur-
ing time was observed to have not a statistically significant effect
A two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) test was carried out only on the water absorption values.
for the data obtained from the samples and the results were pre- The mean values obtained by the lime admixture rate are pre-
sented in Table 4. Analysis was performed combined and sepa- sented in Table 6. The water absorption and apparent porosity
rately on the resulting data, for the effect of the lime rate and rates, which are two of the physical properties of the samples, were
curing time. According to the analysis, the lime rate had a statisti- observed to have decreased with an increase in the lime rate. The
cally significant effect on the apparent porosity, water absorption, highest mean water absorption and apparent porosity rates were
bulk density, flexural strength and compressive strength. However, 49.0% and 48.8%, respectively for the samples with a 20% lime rate.
the lime rate was observed to have no statistically significant effect The apparent porosity rates which decreased with an increase in
on the apparent density values. the lime rate led to an increase in the bulk density rates of the sam-
It was determined that the curing time had no statistically sig- ples and the highest bulk density (1019.3 kg/m3) was obtained
nificant effect on water absorption. However, it was observed that from the samples with a 30% lime rate. The mean apparent density
the combined effect of the lime rate and the curing time on the values tended to increase although the effect of the lime rate on the
apparent porosity, water absorption, bulk density, and compres- apparent density values was unclear.
sive strength values of the samples was statistically significant The mean flexural strength values of the samples decreased
(Table 4). with an increase in the lime rate. The mean flexural strength values
Mean values obtained by taking the curing time into account of the samples with a 10% lime rate and a 30% lime rate were
are presented in Table 5. Considering the mean values, it was 0.9 MPa and 0.4 MPa, respectively. The mean compressive strength
observed that the applied curing time had no statistically values of the samples varied depending on the lime rate and the
Table 4
ANOVA results of the values (a = 0.05).
Table 5
Mean values of the samples depending on curing times.
Group of Water absorption Apparent porosity Bulk density (kg/ Apparent density (kg/ Flexural strength Compressive strength
sample (%) (%) m3) m3) (MPa) (MPa)
A 48.8 45.7 935.7 1722.8 0.8 3.5
B 47.2 48.8 1033.7 2017.4 0.7 8.4
C 48.0 49.4 1033.8 2045.3 0.5 7.5
[26] A. Allahverdi, E.N. Kani, Construction wastes as raw materials for geopolymer [39] ASTM C 618, Standard Specification for Fly Ash and Raw or Calcined Natural
binders, Int. J. Civil Eng. 7 (3) (2009) 154–160. Pozzolan for Use as a Mineral Admixture in Portland Cement Concrete.
[27] S.E. Wallah, Drying shrinkage of heat-cured fly ash-based geopolymer American Society for Testing and Materials. ASTM International, West
concrete, Mod. Appl. Sci. 3 (12) (2009) 14–21. Conshohocken (PA, USA), 2003.
[28] D.L.Y. Kong, J.G. Sanjayan, Effect of elevated temperatures on geopolymer _ Demir, G. Görhan, E. Kahraman, A Microstructural Study on
[40] M.S. Basßpınar, I.
paste, mortar and concrete, Cem. Concr. Res. 40 (2) (2010) 334–339. The Phase Stability of Fly Ash/Cement Based Aerated Concrete, Proceedings of
[29] J. Temuujin, A. Riessen, Effect of fly ash preliminary calcination on the the 12th Conference of the European Ceramic Society – ECerS XII, Stockholm,
properties of geopolymer, J. Hazard. Mater. 164 (2009) 634–639. Sweden, 19–23 Jun 2011.
[30] M. Criado, A. Palomo, A. Fernandez-Jimenez, Alkali Activation of fly ashes. Part [41] TS 4022, Kireçler-Söndürülmüsß- Yapılarda Kullanılan (Hydrated Lime-For Use
1: effect of curing conditions on the carbonation of the reaction products, Fuel _ Buildings) 1993. TSE. Ankara –Turkey.
In
84 (16) (2005) 2048–2054. [42] T.C. Basßbakanlık Devlet Planlama Tesßkilatı Müstesßarlığı, ‘‘Madencilik Özel
[31] Sß. Büyüköztürk, Sosyal Bilimler için Veri Analizi El Kitabı. Pegem Akademi _
Ihtisas Komisyonu Raporu, Endüstriyel Hammaddeler Alt Komisyonu, Yapı
Yayıncılık. 2012. ISBN: 978-975-6802-74-8 (in Turkey). Malzemeleri-I’’, DPT: 2615 – ÖIK: _ 626, 2001.
[32] A. Terzic, L. Pezo, V. Mitic, Z. Radojevic, Artificial fly ash based aggregates [43] TS EN 772-4, Kagir Birimler, deney metotları – Bölüm 4: Tabii taskâgir
properties influence on lightweight concrete performances, Ceram. Int. 41 (2) birimlerin toplam ve görünen porozitesi ile bosluksuz ve bosluklu birim hacim
(2015) 2714–2726. kütlesinin tayini (Methods of test for masonry units – Part 4: Determination of
[33] M. Radlinski, J. Olek, Effects of curing conditions on the properties of ternary real and bulk density and of total and open porosity for natural stone masonry
(ordinary Portland cement/fly ash/silica fume) concrete, ACI Mater. J. 112 (1) units) 2000. TSE. Ankara-Turkey.
(2015) 49–58. [44] TS EN 771-1, Kagir Birimler, Özellikler- Bölüm 1: Kil kâgir birimler (Tuğlalar)
[34] P. Kumar, M. Aslam, N. Singh, S. Mittal, A. Bansal, M.K. Jha, K. Sarma, (Specification for masonry units – Part 1: Clay masonry units) 2005. TSE.
Characterization, activity and process optimization with a biomass-based Ankara-Turkey.
thermal power plant’s fly ash as a potential catalyst for biodiesel production, [45] TS 4790, Tuğla ve Kiremit Topraklarının Deney Metodu (Test Method for
RSC Adv. 5 (13) (2015) 9946–9954. Common Bricks and Roofing Tile Clays) 1986. TSE. Ankara – Turkey.
[35] C. Kalusuriya, V. Vimonsatit, W.P.S. Dias, P. De Silva, Design and development [46] TS EN 196-1, Çimento Deney Metotları- Bölüm 1: Dayanım (Methods of testing
of alkali pozzolan cement (APC), Constr. Build. Mater. 68 (2014) 426–433. cement – Part 1: Determination of strength) 2002. TSE. Ankara – Turkey.
[36] L.E. Zapata-Orduz, G. Portela, O.M. Suarez, Weibull statistical analysis of [47] B. Nematollahi, J. Sanjayan, F.U.A. Shaikh, Synthesis of heat and ambient cured
splitting tensile strength of concretes containing class f fly ash, micro/nano- one-part geopolymer mixes with different grades of sodium silicate, Ceram.
SiO2, Ceram. Int. 40 (5) (2014) 7373–7388. Int. 41 (4) (2015) 5696–5704.
[37] N. Chaudhary, C. Balomajumder, Optimization study of adsorption parameters [48] J.M. Khatib, R. Siddique, C. Halliday, S. Khatib, Lime activated fly ash pate in the
for removal of phenol on aluminum impregnated fly ash using response presence of metakaolin, Procedia Eng. 95 (2014) 415–418.
surface methodology, J. Taiwan Inst. Chem. Eng. 45 (3) (2014) 852–859. [49] D.R.M. Brew, K.J.D. MacKenzie, Geopolymer synthesis using silica fume and
[38] S. Yoon, P.J.M. Monterio, D.E. Macphee, F.P. Glasser, M.S.E. Imbabi, Statistical sodium aluminate, J. Mater. Sci. 42 (2007) 3990–3993.
evaluation of the mechanical properties of high – volume class F fly ash [50] S. Wang, Compressive strengths of mortar cubes from hydrated lime with
concretes, Constr. Build. Mater. 54 (2014) 432–442. cofired biomass fly ashes, Constr. Build. Mater. 50 (2014) 414–420.