Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The concentrationsof Ce•a and CeTMin rain were measuredat Fayetteville, Arkansas,during
the period betweenNovember 1964and December1965.The Ce•/Ce• data indicate that the
radiocerium isotopesproducedby the May 14, 1965, Chinese nuclear test explosiontraveled
eastward and circled around the world at least twice. The mean troposphericresidencehalf-
time of the cerium isotopes was calculated to be approximately 40 days. Measurements of
variations of the ratios Ce•44/Sr
•, Cem/Sr•, and Cem/BaTMin rain yielded experimentalevi-
dencesfor the atmosphericfractionation of nuclear debris.
7o OCT.,eEXPLOSION
M^Y
,4
EXPLOSI ON
P(0)
-1-Q(8.8)
= 3.0 (3)
where P is the total amount of Ce•" in the
5O -• tropospherejust beforethe May 14, 1965,nu-
clear explosion
and Q is the amountof CeTM
o 40
addedto the troposphereby the explosion.Solv-
ing (3) for Q/P, we have
_• •0
I0.0 - r\
NUCLEAR
XA•RRIVAL
OF
EXPLOSION /FIR,ST WAVE
5.0-
4.0- x{( SECOND
3.0
\ CYCLE Sr89/Sr90
2,0-
0.5-
0.4-
0.3-
0.2-
0.05 I I I I I I I I • I I I I
14 20 I I0 20 I I0 20 1 I0 20 I I0
MAY JUNE JULY AUG, SEPT.
1965
Xe•4ø • Cs
•4ø /g-)Ba•O
16 see 66 see 12.8 day
the northern temperate zone in the casesof nu- The variationsof the Cd"/Cd 4' and Srs*/SFø
clear explosionssuchas the one studiedin this ratiosin rain, shownin Figure 2, representthe
work. ease of the ratio of two isotopesof the same
In view of the large vertical wind shear and elements.
In the caseof •he Cd•'/Cd4' ratio,
horizontaleddy diffusionin the troposphere, their precursors are quitesimilar,andthe possi-
most investigatorshave in the past expected bility of fractionationis very small. There-
such a cloud of nuclear debris to have been fore the Cd•NCd •' ratio may be taken as a
dispersedbeyond recognition within a few good indicationof the age of the debris.But
weeksand certainly before'two or three circuits fractionationmay occur in the precursors
GLOBAL CIRCULATION OF CeTMAND CeTM 1677
3O
2O
0 0 0
0
O 5
o
o
o
o o
o o o o
• 2
o o
o o
0.5
0.4
0.$ i i i i i i i i i i i i
14 20 I IO 20 I I0 20 I IO 20 I
MAY JUNE JULY AUG. SEPT.
1965
I0.0 -
NUCLEAR
EXPLOSION (I)
(II)
5.0 -
o /
4.0 -
/•/ o
3.0 -
2.0 - o
o • o
I.O - o // x
0.5
o //øo/ o
0.4 -
/ x
0.3 - / /•Xx
0 141 / 89
0.2 - /
x// x
/ x 141/140
/ x
/.
0.1 -
0.05
of Sr•9/Sr9øbecauseof the differencein their longer than that of Kr •ø (33 sec). For this rea-
half-lives(3.2 m,•nfor Kr• and 33 secfor Krgø). son, Sr8• and CeTMare expectedto be highly
The patterns of variationsof the fractionated relative to each other. Thus we
ratio and the Sr•/Sr•ø ratio in rain appear to shallassumethe 'apparent'meanresidencetime
be quite similar,as shownin Figure2, which for Sr8• to be quite different from the values
clearly demonstratesthe fact that the debris obtainedfor the Ce isotopes,and write that
has circled the world at least two or three
times.
Figure 3 showsthe variation of the Ce•"/ ßexp[--(ha -- ha' q- ka,-- ka,,)t] (6)
Sr•ø ratio in rain. The half-lives of CeTM and
Sr•øare both fairly long, and hencethe strato- whereB/B' is the Ce•/Sr • ratio in the tropo-
sphericinventories of theseisotopeswerequite spheret daysafter the nuclearexplosion(t --
large in May 1965,when the Chinesebombwas 0 on May 14, 1965), [B/B']o is the Ce•/Sr 89
exploded. Thus most of the CeTMand Sr•ø fall- ratio in the freshdebrisinjectedinto the tropo-
out observed duringthis periodhad its origin sphere at I -- 0, the .X'sare the decay con-
in the U.S.S.R. and U.S. test series conducted stants of CeTMand Sr% k• is the reciprocalof
before1963.The straightline in Figure3 cor- the 'apparent'meantroposphericresidencetime
respondsto the equation for CeTM,and k•, is that for SF•.
The straightline I in Figure4 corresponds
to
where T is the Cd"/Sr øøratio observedat time Ce•/Sr ss= 0.3 exp(0.0306t) (7)
t and So is the Cd"/Sr 9øratio in the strato-Solving(6) and (7), we havek•, -- 0.065,or
sphereat t = 0. If this line is extrapolated the meantropospheric.residence
time 1/k•, --
backto the fall of 1962,a valueof Cd"/Sr•ø 16 days for Sr•.
similar to the productionratio is obtained.The Similarly, the Ce•'•/BaTMratio in rain has in-
scatterof the experimentalpointsin Figure 3 creasedwith a sloperoughlycorresponding
to
most likely reflectsthe nonuniformityof the the straightlineII in Figure4'
Ce•"/Sr•ø ratio in the stratosphere [Palmer
e• a/., 1967]. Ce•4•/]Ba
•4ø: 0.13exp(0.0438t) (8)
The variationsof the Ce•/Sr• and Solving(8) and (6) for k•,, we have k•, =
BaTMratiosare plottedin Figure4. Because of 0.0285for BaTM.This correspondsto a value of
their short half-lives,theseisotopeshad their 1/k•, -- 35 days for the mean tropospheric
originexclusively in the May 14, 1965,Chinese residence time of Ba TM.
nuclear explosion.Because these are ratios of Table 2 summarizes the calculated values of
isotopesof differentelementswhoseprecursor the 'apparent' mean tropospheric residence
historiesare quitedifferent,a pronouncedfrae- time for variousfissionproducts.The valuesof
tionationeffectis to be expected. mean tropospheric res;dencetime thus calcu-
Although the experimental points scatter lated vary from 16 daysfor Sr• to 57 daysfor
quite randomly,an interestingtrend is seenin CeTMand CeTM.The resultsshowthat the longer
Figure4; boththe Ce•/Sr• ratioandthe Ce•/ the half-life of the gaseous
precursorthe shorter
Ba•ø ratio appear to have increasedwith time the mean residence time.
after May 1965. These data indicate that CeTM Rao et al. [1966] have recently studied the
was initially depleted relative to Sr• and Ba•ø fissionmassyield distributionin single fallout
duringthe first few weeksafter the May 14, particles. They found that the fissionproducts
1965, nuclear explosionand that the trend re- with fairly 'long-lived'gaseous precursors,such
versedafter July 1965. as Sr• and BaTM,are depletedin singleparticles,
As has been mentioned earlier, the mean whereasthe mass-yieldcurve for the bulk of the
troposphericresidencetime for the Ce isotopes rainwater sampleshowsthat the yields of Sr•
appears to be greater by a factor of 2 than and BaTMare enhanced.Clark ei a.1. [1967]
that for Sr•ø.The half-life of the gaseouspre- have alsoobservedthat volatilefissionproducts
c.ursor
of Srøøis muchlongertha•nthat of Ce•'•, .;:':and
thosewith gaseous
or volatile precursors
and the half-lifeof Kr• (3.2 min) is much are highlydepleted
in singlefalloutparticles.
GLOBAL CIRCULATION OF Ce TM AND Ce TM 1679
TABLE 2. Calculated Values of the 'Apparent' local fallout in the vicinity of the test site (Lop
Mean TroposphericResidenceTime (1/k •,) Nor), and hence the debris collectedat Fay-
for Various Fission Products
etteville should have been depleted in the Ce
Mean
isotopesrelative to the Sr isotopes.This is ex-
Tropospheric actly what we have observedduring the first
Residence severalweeks (up to the beginningof July) at
Fission Gaseous Time 1/k T, Fayetteville, as shown in Figure 4. After the
Product Precursor days middle of July, it is possiblethat a large frac-
tion of the debris from the May 14, 1965, ex-
Ce TMand Ce TM 2-sec Xe TMand
plosion,whichwasinjectedinto the troposphere,
1-sec Xe TM 57
Ba •ø 16-sec Xe •ø 35
was removed from the troposphere.If some of
Sr 90 33-sec Kr 9ø 30* the larger particles, which entered the lower
Sr s9 3.2-min Kr s9 16 stratosphere,started being transported to the
troposphere at about this time, a sudden in-
* This value is based on the work of Cooperand crease of the CeTMrelative to Sr• may have
Kuroda [1966]. been observedin the ground level rainwater.
The net result of the combination of the above
The extent to which these 'volatile' fissionpro- effects,i.e., an initial depletionof Ce• in the
ducts are depletedseemsto be proportionalto form of the local fallout plus an increasingcon-
the size of the particles; i.e., the greater the tribution from larger particles which entered
particlethe greaterthe depletionof the volatile the stratosphere, may be the cause for the
fissionproduct chain. longer 'apparent' mean residencetime for the
These resultssuggestthat Sr•9 (with 3.2-min Ce isotopes.
Kr 89precursor)shouldbe enrichedin smaller We are in the process of investigating the
particlesand CeTM(with 2-secXe TMprecursor) relationship between the fallout particle dis-
shouldbe enrichedin larger particles.Sincethe tribution and the fission product ratios in the
apparent mean residencetime of the smaller individual particles, and it is hoped that we
particlesis expectedto be longerthan that of may be able to offer a better explanationin the
the larger particles,it followsthat Sr8• should near future.
stay longer, on the average,in the atmosphere Acknowledgments. We are grateful to Dr. B. D.
than CeTM.This is exactly opposite from the Palmer, Mr. J. N. Beck, and Mr. W. W. Cooper
conclusion reached earlier on the basis of the for their advice and to Mr. M. Myers for help in
the sampling work.
data shownin Figure 4. This investigation was supported by the United
For the time being,we are frankly unable to States Atomic Energy Commission under con-
explain these puzzling results. However, the tract At-(40-1)-2529.
following tentative explanation is suggested. REFERENCES
Beck and Kuroda [1966] and also Cooper and
Beck, J. N., and P. K. Kuroda, Radiostrontium
Kuroda [1966] have recently reportedthat a fallout from the nuclear explosion of October
considerable fraction of the debris from the 16, 1964, J. Geophys. Res., 71, 2451-2456, 1966.
Chinese nuclear explosionsentered the strato- Clark, R. S., K. Yoshikawa, M. N. Rao, B. D.
Palmer, Myint Thein, and P. K. Kuroda, The
sphere.It. is difficultto estimatethe amount.of time-interval between nuclear detonation and
Ce isotopeswhichenteredthe stratospherefrom formation of single fallout particles, J. Geophys.
our data, but if Cem and CeTMare enrichedin Res., 72(6), 1967.
larger particlesrelativeto Sr8•and Sr•ø,we may Cooper, W. W., and P. K. Kuroda, Global circula-
expectthat a relativelysmallfractionof the Ce tion of nuclear debris from the May 14, 1965,
nuclear explosion, J. Geophys. Res., 71, 5471-
isotopesmay have entered the stratosphere. 5473, 1966.
The Ce isotopeswhich enteredthe stratosphere Kuroda, P. K., On the stratospheric Sr•ø fallout,
may be expectedto return to the groundlevel Argonne Natl. Lab. ANL-5920, pp. 1-40, October
1958.
much more rapidly than the Sr isotopes,which
are enrichedin smaller particles. On the other Kuroda, P. K., Y. Miyake, and J. Nemoto, Stron-
tium isotopes: Global circulation after the Chi-
hand, much of the Ce isotopeproductionmay nese explosion of May 14, 1965, Science, 150,
have been rapidly removedin the form of the 1289, 1965.
1680 THEIN AND KURODA
Kuroda, P. K., B. D. Palmer, Moses Attrep, Jr., isotopesin the atmosphere,manuscriptin prep-
J. N. Beck, R. Ganapathy, D. D. Sabu, and aration, 1967.
M. N. Rao, Fallout from the nuclear explosion Rao, M. N., K. Yoshikawa,D. D. Sabu, R. Clark,
of October 16, 1964, Science, 147, 1284-1286, and P. K. Kuroda, Mass-yield distribution of
1965. the fissionproducts in fallout particles from the
Menon, M.P., K. K. Menon, and P. K. Kuroda, May 14, 1965, nuclear explosion,Science,153,
On the stratosphericfallout of bomb-produced 633-635, 1966.
cerium isotopes, J. Geophys. Res., 68, 4495-
4499, 1963.
Palmer, B. D., K. K. Menon, and P. K. Kuroda, (Received July 12, 1966;
Radioactive strontium, cerium, and manganese revised December 5, 1966.)