Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AN ANALYSIS OF THE
DIFFERENT TYPES OF
EDUCATION BOARDS IN INDIA
A report on
2|Page
Prepared for
Dr. Rayson K. Alex
(Department of Humanities and Social Sciences)
Group 13
Eddula Mourya Reddy 2017B4PS1025G
Harshvardhan Walia 2017B4PS1027G
Kartikey Sharma 2017B5PS0420G
Nikhil P. S. Bisht 2017B5PS0610G
N S Parrivesh 2017B5PS0619G
Samridh Deva 2017B5PS0588G
Vanshika Kapoor 2017B5PS0624G
Declaration
3|Page
We, the students of the Technical Report Writing Course (BITS F112) Semester-2, hereby
declare that the project work presented in this report entitled “An analysis of the different types
of education boards in India”, is our own work and has been carried out under the supervision of
Dr. Rayson K. Alex, Professor, Department of Humanities and Social Sciences, BITS Pilani,
This work has not been previously submitted to any other institution or course for any
examination.
Harshvardhan Walia
Kartikey Sharma
N S Parrivesh
Samridh Deva
Vanshika Kapoor
Certificate
4|Page
This is to certify that the report entitled “An analysis of the different types of education boards in
India”, has been done by us:
Eddula Mourya Reddy 2017B4PS1025G
Harshvardhan Walia 2017B4PS1027G
Kartikey Sharma 2017B5PS0420G
N S Parrivesh 2017B5PS0619G
Nikhil P.S. Bisht 2017B5PS0610G
Samridh Deva 2017B5PS0588G
Vanshika Kapoor 2017B5PS0624G
of the Technical Report Writing Course (BITS F112) during Semester-2 from BITS Pilani, K.K.
Birla Goa Campus, under the supervision of Dr. Rayson K. Alex.
__________________________
Dr. Rayson K. Alex
Acknowledgements
5|Page
We are immensely indebted to Dr. Rayson Alex for his guidance and encouragement. We are
also grateful for his advice regarding the making of the report and its analysis.
Our heartfelt gratitude goes to all the students for their help and collaboration in answering the
questionnaire of the survey. This gave us sufficient data to be able to compare the different types
We would not have been able to complete the report without their help.
Abstract
6|Page
India has more than 1.4 million schools and more than 230 million students enrolled in them. All
schools are not governed by a single board system. This report gives an insight to the major
boards and compares them on several factors such as syllabus, evaluation scheme offered by
boards, balance between practical and theoretical knowledge; which play a vital role in choosing
the board. Topics such as reservation and competitive nature of boards are also discussed in the
report.
A survey was also conducted to know the views of people on their respective boards so that more
firsthand information could be gained. Recommended changes and conclusions are mentioned in
the end.
List of Illustrations
7|Page
Fig 4.3 – State Board: Balance between Practical and Theoretical Knowledge
Contents
9|Page
Page
Acknowledgements ……………………………………………………………………. V
Abstract ………………………………………………………………………………… VI
Content
1. Introduction 11
6. Recommended Changes 29
10 | P a g e
7. Conclusion 30
8. Questionnaire 31
9. Appendix 33
10. Index 34
11. Bibliography 35
1. Introduction
11 | P a g e
The Indian school education system is one of the largest and most complex in the world. The
complexity of the system stems from India’s need to maintain standard and uniformity, while
giving scope for its diverse culture and heritage to grow and flourish across the length and
breadth of the country. After independence India has worked hard to provide access to almost all
its young people, but it has only just begun to focus on aspects of quality and seek to improve
learning outcomes.
This report gives an overall picture into this vast and continuously changing Indian School
Education System.
• Pre-school: Education at this level is not compulsory. The Montessori system is especially
• Private play schools: Catering for children between the ages of 18 months and three years.
• Kindergarten: This is divided into lower kindergarten (for three to four-year-olds) and upper
• Middle school/ Upper Primary school: Sixth to eighth grade (for 11 to 14-year-olds).
National Boards:
12 | P a g e
1. Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE): Established in 1962 under the purview of
MHRD, CBSE gives affiliations to both public and private schools. There are currently about
15,167 schools affiliated under CBSE. The board conducts final examinations, All India Senior
School Certificate Examination (AISSCE) for classes X and XII. It also annually conducts the
IITJEE (Mains) and AIPMT examinations for admission to undergraduate courses in engineering
(and architecture) and medicine in numerous colleges spread over India. CBSE is recognized by
the Indian government and by most of the universities and colleges in India.
governmental education board in India. It conducts the ICSE (for class X) and ISC (for class XII)
examinations in India. About 1,900 schools are affiliated with the CISCE board. The board was
set up in 1956 at the meeting of the Inter-State Board for Anglo-Indian Education, where a
proposal was adopted for the setting up of an Indian Council to administer the University of
conducting public examinations in India by the Delhi Education Act, 1973, passed by
3. State Government Boards: These educational boards are regulated and supervised by the state
apex organization for secondary and senior secondary education. A portion of the curriculum
focuses specifically on imparting knowledge about the state. Majority of Indian schools are
affiliated with the state government boards. The oldest state board is the U.P. Board of High
School & Intermediate Education established in 1922 as an autonomous body under the
Department of Education. Uttar Pradesh has the highest number of State board schools followed
International Boards:
13 | P a g e
Switzerland. IB World Schools in India offer three IB programs—primary years program (PYP),
middle years program (MYP) and IB Diploma program (IBDP). There are 109 IB World Schools
in India offering one or more of the three IB programmes. 50 schools offer the PYP, 11 schools
offer the MYP and 96 schools offer the IBDP. IB is recognized by the ‘Association of Indian
the universities.
international qualifications offering examinations and qualifications in more than 160 countries.
They are an examination board under Cambridge Assessment, founded in 1858 as a department
of the University of Cambridge. There are now over 310 Cambridge schools in India making
over 44,000 examination entries for Cambridge IGCSE and Cambridge International AS and A
Level.
14 | P a g e
Kula system. In it, the children who were interested in studying approached a teacher (Guru) and
requested to be taught. If the Guru accepted his request to be his student, he would then stay at
his place and help in all activities at home. The guru taught the child everything ranging from
Sanskrit to the Holy Verses, Mathematics and Sciences. All learning was closely linked to nature
and to life, and not limited to “textbook learning”. This type of schooling was adopted all over
The current school system, including foreign languages (English and others), was introduced in
India originally by Lord Thomas Babington Macaulay in the late 1830s. The curriculum was
confined to science and mathematics, and subjects like philosophy and metaphysics were
considered unnecessary. Classroom teaching broke the link with nature, and also the close
Set up in 1921, The Uttar Pradesh Board of High School and Intermediate Education, was the
first Board set up in India with administration over Rajputana, Central India and Gwalior. In
1929, the Board of High School and Intermediate Education, Rajputana, was established.
Eventually, in 1952, the constitution of the board was amended and it was rechristened Central
Board of Secondary Education (CBSE). All schools in Delhi and some other regions came under
the Board. It was the function of the Board to decide on things like curriculum, textbooks and
examination system for all schools affiliated to it. Today there are thousands of schools affiliated
to the Board, both within India and in many other countries from Afghanistan to Zimbabwe.
15 | P a g e
Whenever we talk about a particular board of education, a major point that comes to our mind is
the quality of its education. In a country like India which is vast, we have multiple boards of
education which are not on the same level as one another. The quality of syllabus varies
drastically between some major boards like ICSE, CBSE, and some state boards. The point that
was kept in mind by the ones who decided the syllabus for CBSE was that the country needs a
common syllabus, especially for the central board employees’ kids, who get transfers often.
CISCE which conducts the ICSE examinations also has a similar perspective. IB wishes to
maintain a common curriculum throughout the world so that wherever a child goes he'll be able
to continue his education without any problems whereas on the other hand, state boards give
more preference to the local crowd and focus more on their culture, morals, ethics, history,
language, etc.
When we talk about the quality of an education system, the first thing that comes to our mind is
how updated is the syllabus? The syllabus has to be changed frequently and to be kept up to date
with the changing society and growing science. So a quality board should be ever evolving.
CBSE and ICSE frequently amend their curriculum, they modify it every year, making necessary
changes and changing data, whereas on the other hand some state boards like the Tamil Nadu
state board still uses outdated information with some information being as old as of 1970s. The
syllabus should have the pre-requisites to join colleges. IB on the other hand focuses on quality
and provides good quality education in the subjects that the student chooses. IB and ICSE
provide knowledge in depth compared to CBSE and state boards which really helps the
Here we have graphs from our survey depicting students view on the quality of their boards:
Figure 3.2
Figure 3.1
Figure 3.3
The above pie-charts clearly show that ICSE maintains its quality of syllabus whereas CBSE
falters to do so, with State Boards with the worst scenario of all.
17 | P a g e
When talking about the quality of an education board, it is very important to analyze on what
aspects a particular education board grades its students. An improper grading system might mess
up with an individual's life. While grading a person, importance has to be given to the way he
performs in the subjects that he/she has opted for/ forced to study as well as co-curricular
CBSE carries out continuous and comprehensive evaluation system till 10th grade with a certain
amount of weightage give to non-academic aspects as well and a person with co-curricular skills
is eligible to get an upgradation of 1 point in 2 of his weak subjects, but when a student reaches
senior secondary school (11th & 12th grade), his /her performance is entirely based upon the
final exam and not on any other aspect just like the state boards. Every board does conduct
practical exams, but for a lesser weightage compared to the theoretical part and the way the
practical exams are conducted vary from school to school. In case of ICSE, in their secondary
school examination, 80% weightage is given to their final theoretical exam and 20% to their
internals which includes projects and viva and in the senior secondary examinations it's a 30-70
type examination and their projects are assessed in a systematic. IB's evaluation pattern is
completely different from that of other board. It carries about continuous evaluation pattern with
students having to work on projects, do fieldwork, write essays, etc. In fact the students need not
have to take up any exams till the end of the Diploma Programme. It focuses on improving one's
mental and philosophical abilities and prepares the student to face the outside world. IB's main
goal is to make sure that every student is assessed in a proper manner and his/her talent doesn't
go in vain.
18 | P a g e
The below graphs show how different students rate their board's evaluation pattern.
Figure 3.6
As we can see, the Evaluation of ICSE is considered better than both CBSE and State boards,
which are almost at the same average level.
19 | P a g e
Every student deserves to choose the subject one wishes to study. Only with interest one can
excel in a field. Many boards offer freedom in choosing subjects with varying levels and of
course the board makes sure one has the pre-requisites to choose the subjects of one's interests.
CBSE offers wide variety of courses with the necessary conditioning being that a student should
choose 1 compulsory language, 1 secondary language or any other elective, and 3 vocational
subjects which offer wide range of choices like science, marketing, banking, office secretary-
ship, lab assistance, accountancy, agriculture and related fields, nursing, fashion and textile
designing, baking, arts and much more. The student has to mandatorily take up physical and
health education and library as his internal subjects. Apart from these options the student can
take up science or commerce package. So on the whole CBSE offers courses in almost all the
fields, but however not so many students go for the vocational courses, but instead stick with
science and commerce packages with either CS or PE being their 5th subject mainly because of
lack of schools offering vocational courses. In state boards, Maharashtra state board offers a
decent range of choices with 4 compulsory subjects as English, 2nd language, environmental
education and PE with option to choose 4 electives such as science, social studies, political
science, food science, agriculture and related fields, defence, IT, arts, music, sociology,
philosophy, secretary-ship, design, etc. Haryana state board also has a similar structure with 2
compulsory courses and 4 optional courses with choices similar to Maharashtra board for open
schooling. The problem again lies with the schools since most of them don't support vocational
courses and students are forced to take up science or commerce streams. ICSE is even more
flexible by allowing the students to choose the number of electives they want (3-5 electives in
20 | P a g e
grade 11 and 12) with just English being the compulsory subject for senior secondary students
and English, social studies and a language being the compulsory courses for secondary students.
IB allows a student to choose subjects from 6 groups, 1 from each of the 5 major groups and
instead of an arts course one can go for another courses from group 1-5 which includes language,
science, mathematics, social science and a second language. A student is required to take up
higher level which offer a better depth in knowledge as well as standard level courses which act
The following graphs show the response on flexibility offered by different boards.
Figure 3.9
21 | P a g e
Creating a connection between what is taught, and its application, is very important for true
education can be taken a step further. CBSE, ICSE, State Boards and IB, all have experiments (in
science courses) and projects as part of their curriculum. In our survey, we asked people to rate
rated it very poorly in this aspect. State boards fare worse than CBSE with the lowest ratings
overall.
ICSE seems miles ahead of its competition in this aspect. Also, some CBSE and State Board
students have explicitly added in their survey that their practical exams were “fixed” and their
school teachers knew the external examiner who would come beforehand. We received no such
response from ICSE students, who contrastingly said their practical exams were difficult.
22 | P a g e
4.2 IMPORTANCE TO
OTHER LANGUAGES:-
Figure 4.6
State boards slightly surpass CBSE in this matter, while they both falter in comparison to ICSE.
ICSE offers a total of twenty one (21) *** languages to their students and CBSE offers thirty
(30) ***. Despite this, according to the survey, ICSE students feel their board stresses more on
the learning of a second language. This shows the lack of proper implementation of the systems
We are well aware of the competitive nature of the entrance exams post the 12th standard
examinations. Nearly everyone is required to take up one or the other exams to pursue their
career. These exams are highly challenging and require considerable time and effort to be put in
by the student in order to excel. We analyze the role played by the boards to give the students a
The CBSE curriculum is ideally suited to the competitive exams due to which there is a
migration from ICSE to CBSE after the 10th standard board exams. Apart from this CBSE also
encourages students to take up secondary courses apart from the compulsory courses to ease up
the load. The students from science stream are required to put greater efforts since very little
importance is given to the board. In stark contrast the art students are required to focus more on
board exams, this reduces their workload considerably but this does not take away the fact that
the cut-throat nature of the admission process requires the students to be highly competitive.
Figure 5.1
However, the response suggests that the CBSE board could improve their curriculum to improve
their position among the other boards in this aspect, with many people suggesting that the board
The main concern for the ICSE board has been to prevent the students from shifting to other
boards. ICSE being highly strenuous, requires a great effort from the students to cope up with the
curriculum, this being one of the reasons for an exodus to other boards after the 10th standard.
25 | P a g e
Figure 5.2
The admission process being the same for all the board students, the efforts needed to be put in
by ICSE students is more or less the same as compared to their CBSE counterparts. Surprisingly,
close to 50% of the students from ICSE suggest that their board has been doing pretty well in this
aspect contrary to the general notion that ICSE is a tad difficult compared to the others, which
One major talking point has been the relevance of different state boards. The syllabus is in tune
with the competitive exams but the overall belief is that the curriculum is relatively easier than
CBSE and ICSE. The board exams do not require the students to work hard which leaves them
Figure 5.3
The responses by the state board students suggest that having enough free time for preparation
doesn’t necessarily translate to competitiveness with most students feeling that the board could
definitely improve.
IB exams are usually held in May, very close to various Indian entrance exams. This makes it
inconvenient for students appearing for them. Majority of the students tend to appear for SATs,
where the overall number of students appearing is quite less in India. This has been one of the
Reservation in India is a fairly controversial topic, but the controversy has only been
restricted to the caste-based reservation and only for higher studies. The Indian educational
boards have fairly lesser reservation compared to colleges offering higher studies.
The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Act of 2009 was passed to ensure the education
of the underprivileged groups. Children between the age groups of 6 and 14 cannot be denied
admission to any school supported by the appropriate government. The law makes it mandatory
for the schools to reserve 25% of the seats for the underprivileged children.
This act has been exclusively reserved to the CBSE boards and the other boards do not have any
However, sports-based reservation does not exist in any of the Indian boards and IB. There have
been instances of sportsperson being awarded grant marks in the state board exams conducted by
the Maharashtra State Board of Secondary and Higher Secondary Education and also 25 marks
Figure 5.5
Figure 5.4
28 | P a g e
Figure 5.6
29 | P a g e
Reservation largely being prevalent to government run institutions for higher education, the
popular opinion suggest that even though the reservations had been established for a good cause,
they have largely been misused leading to a generally negative air surrounding it.
6. Recommended changes
Over all, analyzing the responses we got from our survey, it is evident that although the structure
on which the boards are built on is sturdy and complete, the implementation of various clauses is
ineffective. The quality of syllabus has to be increased by CBSE and state boards. The
curriculum of CBSE and some state boards don’t prepare the students for NEET and JEE, the
most competitive exams of the country. Hence the quality of syllabus of these boards have to be
increased. The competitive nature should be increased in state boards and central board but the
competitive nature should be healthy. The evaluation scheme should be modified by CBSE and
state boards and more weightage should be given to internals and co-curricular activities.
Practical applications should be increased in state boards similar to IB and CISCE. Boards, other
than IB don’t give weightage to a person’s overall character development and critical thinking
30 | P a g e
skills, which should be considered by other boards as well. One more change that we would like
to suggest is that the boards should have some concession for the differently abled people and
adopt various methods and modified curriculum for them. State boards provide free education for
the poor. This practice should be adopted by other boards as well. Many people have also
recommended a centralized board for the whole county that accommodates regional diversities
7. Conclusion
After analyzing the data collected in the survey, we observed that ICSE had an edge over CBSE
and State Boards in many aspects, such as, curriculum quality, flexibility in choosing subjects
and balance in theoretical practical learning. At the same time, the difficulty of the board was
very highly rated which could deter prospective students from joining the board. Though the
majority of students giving the survey were from CBSE, the majority of them said they’d join
ICSE given another chance. The evaluation pattern of ICSE is designed in such a way that the
students get performance-appropriate grades. CBSE and State Boards fall behind in aspects of
the evaluation and the balance between theoretical and practical learning. With a clear majority
of students showing discontent with their board. From our survey, we can conclude that most of
the students feel that there should be a centralized education system. This is a result of unequal
31 | P a g e
weightage given to various topics and different evaluation schemes in the different boards
present in India.
All in all the overall education systems in India should be altered for the better of the students
8. Questionnaire
32 | P a g e
9. Appendix
Graphs of some other questions
1. No boards (except IB and Cambridge) teach critical thinking skills. Yes, people learn
science, but never even learn the scientific method. That is just an example. They
shouldn't just learn what to think, but also how to think it. Original research should be
valued; since plagiarism is the norm. I feel that if critical thinking skills, rather than trade
skills or mugging up are taught at school, we'll have a much mentally healthier
2. Everyone suffers the same board and thus has no advantage what so ever based on their
board and syllabus. This makes everyone equal when preparing for entrance exams.
33 | P a g e
10. Glossary
Montessori system, 10
MHRD, 11
Non-governmental, 11, 12
Guru Kul, 13
Administration, 13
Amend, 13
Comprehensive, 16
CCE, 10, 13
Theory, 20
Surpass, 22
Implementation, 22, 28
Competition, 21
SAT, 25
Underprivileged, 26
34 | P a g e
11. Bibliography
Dr. Kumar, V. Sasi “The Education System in India” GNU, 31 December 2017,
www.britishcouncil.in/sites/default/files/indian_school_education_system_-
www.britishcouncil.in/sites/default/files/indian_school_education_system_-
www.thehindu.com/features/education/college-and-university/ib-decoded/
Choudhari, Abhishek. “CBSE Students Count on Sports Marks to Breach SSC High
timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nagpur/cbse-students-count-on-sports-marks-to-breach-