Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Probability
Level: beginner
Possibility
We use may, might and could (/node/1441) to say that something is possible, but not
certain:
It can be very cold here in winter. (= It is sometimes very cold here in winter.)
You can easily get lost in this town. (= People often get lost in this town.)
Be careful!
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 1/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Be careful!
A: Where's John?
B: I'm not sure. He may/might/could be (NOT can) in his office.
Level: intermediate
We use may have, might have or could have to make guesses about the past:
I haven't received your letter. It may have got lost in the post.
It's ten o'clock. They might have arrived by now.
Where are they? They could have got lost.
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 2/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
It could be very cold there in winter. (= It was sometimes very cold there in
winter.)
You could easily get lost in that town. (= People often got lost in that town.)
Impossibility
Level: beginner
Level: intermediate
We use can't have or couldn't have to say that a past event (/node/1406) was
impossible:
They know the way here. They can't have got lost!
If Jones was at work until six, he couldn't have done the murder.
Certainty
Level: beginner
We use must to show we are sure something is true and we have reasons for our
belief:
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 3/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
We use should to suggest something is true and we have reasons for our suggestion:
Level: intermediate
They hadn't eaten all day. They must have been hungry.
You look happy. You must have heard the good news.
It's nearly eleven o'clock. They should have arrived by now.
Probability 1
Probability 2
Probability 3
Probability 4
Probability 5
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 4/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Up (/english-grammar/modal-verbs)
Ability › (/english-grammar/ability)
Online courses
Learn English online – with the world's English experts
rses?promo_id=sub01&%3Bpromo_name=subscription&%3Bpromo_creative=learning-content&
Dear Team,
1) Where are they? They could be lost in the town.
2) Where are
they? They could have lost in the town.
What is the difference? Thanks you!!!
Hello DaniWeebKage,
Lost is a transitive verb, which means it needs an object. You can lose
something (lose money, lose your wallet etc) or you can use a passive
construction (be/get lost).
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 5/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Peter
Thank You!!!
1)Where is my book? It could be in the cafe.
2)Where is
my book? It could have left in the cafe.
Among the Aforementioned two
sentences,
The former is used when we are guessing what could
happen in the present.
The latter is used when we are guessing past
action or sth( maybe affect the present). Is my summary correct? If not,
correct me.
I'm afraid your second sentence here is also incorrect for the same
reason: leave is a transitive verb in this usage so you need an
object or a passive construction. The sentences should read as
follows:
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 6/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
As far as the modal verbs go (which I think is the main focus of your
question), your explanations are correct. We use could + verb to
speculate about the present and could have + verb3 to speculate
about the past. Well done!
Peter
Hi Peter M. I see you using 'could in your comments when replying user
questions. Is 'could' used to make a suggestion and means be able to?
We can
use the definite article in several ways. When you say 'the bus' it could mean a
particular bus (Look - the bus is coming!) or it could have a general meaning
and refer to the means of transportation (I prefer the bus to the train).
Second,
can I say 'it may mean...'/'it may have'...? If so, is there any difference of
meaning?
Hello BobMux,
Peter
Hello there!
I would like to know the difference in meaning of these two
sentences:
It can be dangerous to cycle in the city.
It could/may be
dangerous to cycle in the city.
Hello BobMux,
The sentence with 'can' speaks more about cycling in the city in
general, i.e. at any time, in any situation, for any person. The
sentences with 'could' or 'may' are more often used to speak about
a more specific hypothetical time or situation in the future.
For example, let's say a friend of ours was cycling in the city and
had an accident. We could say the first sentence as a kind of
comment on how dangerous it is to cycle in the city after this
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 8/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Kirk
Hello Kirk,
It was rather useful your explanation and thanks a
lot. But i am still a bit confused. I would be really happy if you
were able to help me understand better modal verbs:
In a book
it is said that the modal verbs "might", "may" and could are used
to express both possibilty and make a guess. This words is
given " this rush might/could/may be a symptom of something
more serious". So here is it possibility or making a guess?
And
how can i distinguesh between possibilty and making a guess?
Log in (/user/login?destination=/english-grammar/probability%23comment-form) or
register (/user/register?destination=/english-grammar/probability%23comment-form) to
post comments
Hello BobMux,
Kirk
Dear teahcers,
1- Why can't we use " can have " to make guesses about the
past like may have, might have or could have ?
2- Why can't we use " couldn't "
to say that something is impossible like " can't " ?
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 10/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Hello ahmed16,
I wish that it were a bit more logical, but I'm afraid this is just the way that
English has developed as people have been speaking it over the last
several centuries. There are some technical analyses of modal verbs
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_modal_verbs) that can help
understand how they work a bit better, but I'm afraid they require a bit of
study to make sense of and are well beyond the scope of what we do here.
Best wishes,
Kirk
ok Do you mean that it is a language and its rules must be adhered to,
even if what I am saying is relatively true?
Hello ahmed16,
Kirk
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 11/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Dear teachers
can we use " can have " to make guesses about the past like
may have, might have or could have ?
A second question
can we use " couldn't
" to say that something is impossible ?
Hi ahmed16,
1. No. We can't use can have, but we can use the negative form can't
have to show that we think it's not possible that something happened.
Have a look at this page on Modals for deductions about the past
(https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/grammar/intermediate-to-upper-
intermediate/modals-deductions-about-the-past) for more examples and
explanation.
2. We can use couldn't have to say that something was impossible (in the
past), but we can't use couldn't on its own with this meaning. See this
page on can and could (https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-
grammar-reference/can-and-could) for more information.
Jonathan
Coul you help me, please? Can we use OUGHT TO instead of SHOULD in
these particular cases?
1. They insisted that we should have dinner together.
2. It is essential that everyone should be here on time.
3. It is strange that he
should be late. He is usually on time.
4. If it should rain, take an umbrella with
you.
5. It is cold outside. I should wear a coat (like advice).
Hello iamsashafierce,
Peter
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 13/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Hello IsabelTim_123,
Personally, I wouldn't use 'should' in that sentence -- I'd just say 'be'. I
wouldn't say it's wrong there, but it does strike me as redundant. If you
check example sentences in dictionaries, I doubt you will see 'should' used
in similar sentences.
Kirk
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 14/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Permalink (/comment/154740#comment-154740)
Hello Abhishek,
Your sentences are the same. I think you may have made a mistake in your
question.
Peter
Dear teahcers,
Can you explain what is difference between may have, might
have or could have? Namely, I want to know difference between them like your
explanation about ' may, might and could ' in first paragraph. Thanks a lot in
advance
Note that each of these modal verbs can be used in other situations, and in
some of those situations, they don't mean the same thing. But here in the
context of probability they do.
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 15/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Kirk
Please note that when you post a comment, it is not published right away.
Please don't post the same comment twice; we'll be able to respond more
quickly!
Kirk
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 16/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Hi teacher, I have one sentence about possibility in the past and I just want to
know if it’s right or wrong “ His math may have improved by the time the exam
came “ Thank you .
Hi Rany,
The sentence is perfectly fine. It tells us that the speaker does not know if
the person's maths improved or not, but that it was possible. The meaning
is the same as might have and could have in this context.
Peter
Dear sir We all know that modals have not indicate tenses, and they only
reflect four different aspects of simple, continoues, perfect and perfect
continoues. Base of this assumption why in some parts you keep saying this
modal use for past certainty, for example they must have practiced too much.
But at this example we can not say it is only reflect past tense, it might refer to
future or present base on the time phrase used with it , for example
For future,
they must have practiced well by tomorrow morning.
For present, they must
have practiced well by now.
For past, they must have practiced well already.
Would you please tell me if i am thinking in a right way.
Sincerely Aria
Hello Aria,
Modal verbs have a range of meanings. When 'must' is used for logical
deduction it is always a deduction following another action, so the only way
to use it in a future context is to create an future condition. You cannot say
'They must have practised well by tomorrow morning' but you could say 'If
they win the game tomorrow then they must have been practising hard'.
Note that 'must have' can also be used with other meanings. For example,
when we use 'must' for obligation we can use it with future reference. For
example, you could say 'When I get back to the office you must have
finished this project or there will be trouble!'
Peter
I couldn't care less about that. Is this the second conditional without the
condition or does it refer to the past modal for ability? Is it ambiguous? Is it the
modal for possibility rather than ability? Can it be both?
Hi sam61
Kirk
Hi,
A-do you remember me?
B-how could I forget you?
In the second sentence
'could' is used for ability or possibility and which time it refers
(present/past/future). Please explain?
Hi jitu_jaga,
I think we've already provided a lot of explanations on this point and can't
really continue explaining the same point with yet more examples. Why
don't you tell us what you think the meaning is here and we will comment
on your idea?
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 19/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Peter
Hi,
1.How could you do that to me? Here, in this sentence 'could' is used for
ability or possibility? and which time does this sentence
refer(present/past/future)?
2. What is the difference between possibility and
probability?
Hi jitu_jaga,
It's difficult to say for sure without context, but it looks to me as if 'could' is
being used to express past, or perhaps hypothetical, ability in the sentence
you ask about. If I found out that a close friend of mine planned to borrow
my car without asking my permission, for example, I might say something
like this. The idea is that a good friend wouldn't be able to hurt me in that
way.
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 20/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
'possibility (https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/possibility)'
refers to whether something could happen or not; 'probability
(https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/probability)' refers to
how likely it is that it could happen -- it's like the level of possibility of
something. The lottery is a classic example -- it's not probable that you win
the lottery, but it is possible.
Hi,
They could come by car
They might come by car
They may come by car
Can you please explain me which of the above sentence is correct/more
accurate or can be used interchangeably?
Hello QaaZee,
All of these are grammatically correct and they can all mean that there is a
chance that they will come by car. Other meanings are possible for some of
the examples. 'May' could refer to permission, for example, as in it is OK for
them to come by car, but that would depend on the context.
Peter
Thanks Peter,
Could you please provide an example with context for
'May' to further elaborate its use for permission.
Thank you once again.
Hello QaaZee,
You can find examples of this on our page dealing with modal verbs
for ability, permission, requests and advice:
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/en/english-grammar/ability-
permission-requests-and-advice
(https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/en/english-grammar/ability-
permission-requests-and-advice)
Peter
Hi,
Look at the sentence 'I consoled myself with the thought that things could
be much worse'. In this sentence how can we know 'could' is used either as
past form of 'can' or 'could' is used for past possibility. we use 'can' for general
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 22/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Hello jitu_jaga,
The modal verb does not carry a marker for this within it so we use the
context to inform us. If the context is not clear then it is ambiguous, but this
would rarely matter.
For example, the meaning of your sentence is quite clear, I think. The
speaker is looking at a bad situation and consoling themselves with the
thought that something worse is possible. It may or may not be obvious
from the context whether the worse possibility is something specific (my car
is not working but it could be worse - my car could have exploded) or
general (my car is not working but it could be worse - I could have lost my
job, got sick or suffered some family tragedy). It really does not matter,
however; what is important is the idea that things are not as bad as they
could be, and that the person's ill-fortune is not so terrible when considered
in the right way.
Peter
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 23/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Thank you Peter. You always provide good explanations. Have a nice
day.
Hi, We use may/might/could for possibility and may/might/could have for past
possibility. But we don't use 'would' for possibility. But sometimes, I find
sentence like ' You would know, Sachin Tendulkar is a great batsman'. I think
here 'would' is used for speculation if I am not wrong. In this sense, if we write
sentences like
It may/might/could rain tomorrow, could we write 'It would rain
tomorrow' or 'I would marry next month'?. If not then what would be its
meaning? I don't understand how to use use 'would' for future and past
speculation.Could you Please explain it clearly.
Hello jitu_jaga,
The sentence about Sachin Tendulkar you mention doesn't sound right to
me, at least out of context. In other words, perhaps in a specific context it
would make sense, but out of context it does not.
Your other sentences with 'would' to talk about possibility (rain or getting
married) are also not standard. At least in British or American English,
'would' isn't used to speak about possibility in this way. It can be used within
a conditional structure
(https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/en/intermediate-
grammar/conditionals-1) to speak about a possibility, but that is a different
structure, which is clearly indicated in most cases with an 'if' clause.
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 24/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Hi SonuKumar,
'She must have gone home' means the speaker has good reasons to
believe she went home, or that it is the only logical explanation they have at
hand to explain a situation.
'She can't have gone home' means the speaker has reasons to believe that
it is impossible that she went home.
'She must not have gone home' is not as strong. It means the speaker is
making a supposition -- they think she probably did not go home, but don't
have strong evidence for this.
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 25/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
1 2 (/english-grammar/probability?page=1)
(/english-
3 (/english-grammar/probability?page=2)
grammar/probability?
4 (/english-grammar/probability?page=3)
page=0)
Next
(/english-grammar/probability?page=1)
Last
(/english-grammar/probability?page=3)
Pronouns (/english-grammar/pronouns)
Possessives (/english-grammar/possessives)
Adjectives (/english-grammar/adjectives)
Adverbials (/english-grammar/adverbials)
Nouns (/english-grammar/nouns)
Verbs (/english-grammar/verbs)
Verb phrases (/english-grammar-reference/verb-phrases)
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 26/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Probability (/english-grammar/probability)
Ability (/english-grammar/ability)
Permission (/english-grammar/permission)
'to'-infinitives (/english-grammar/infinitives)
Delexical verbs: 'have', 'take', 'make', 'give', 'go' and 'do' (/english-grammar/delexical-verbs-
have-take-make-give-go-and-do)
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 27/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 28/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Our websites
Help
promo&promo_position=rightsidebar)
Home (/)
Skills (/skills)
Listening (/skills/listening)
Reading (/skills/reading)
Writing (/skills/writing)
Speaking (/skills/speaking)
Grammar (/grammar)
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 30/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
Vocabulary (/vocabulary)
Apps (/apps)
IELTS (/ielts)
Follow us
Facebook (http://www.facebook.com/LearnEnglish.BritishCouncil)
Twitter (http://twitter.com/LearnEnglish_BC)
Accessibility (https://www.britishcouncil.org/accessibility)
Newsletter (/subscribe-to-our-newsletter)
Contact us (/contact-us)
© British Council
The United Kingdom's international organisation for cultural relations and educational opportunities.
A registered charity: 209131 (England and Wales) SC037733 (Scotland).
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 31/32
22/10/21 18:10 Probability | - | LearnEnglish
A registered charity: 209131 (England and Wales) SC037733 (Scotland).
Help
https://learnenglish.britishcouncil.org/english-grammar/probability 32/32