Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CLAT MOCK – 11
Answer and explanation
Section - I: English resources and proximity to water bodies. So,
‘solely’ makes this incorrect.
1. Option (B).
Option C – This is correct. It’s directly mentioned
This is a main idea question. The author in the in the second paragraph.
2
passage traces the evolution of the modern
bathroom. There are a lot of facts presented in the Option D – This is not true for all the civilisations.
passage to support the narration. And one point is The Egyptians controlled the flow of the river, not
02
repeated – the ancient societies treated sanitation as the river itself.
a public health issue. It was side-lined after the fall 4. Option (D).
of the Roman Empire. The result was unsavoury.
We need to remember this and act accordingly. Refer to the lines: “On the other hand, there is still
Let’s use the method of elimination to arrive at the a large part of the world's population that does not
answer:
00
Option A – This is too generic. The mistakes could
mean issues other than the decline in the standard
of sanitary conditions.
have access to toilets and basic sanitation on a
regular basis, a situation that has worsened after the
Covid-19 pandemic. This reflects the uneven
development around the world, which ends up
marginalizing entire populations.” So, option D is
95
Option B – This is repeated throughout the passage. clearly the correct answer.
So, it’s the correct answer. Option A – This is not an unequal development.
Option C – This is vague. The passage doesn’t state Option B – This is the result of this unequal
what should be the sole focus when it comes to the development.
issue of private bathrooms. It’s also not the main
1
(1)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India
CLAT MOCK–11 Answer and explanation
Prejudice, which famously featured Darcy, played Options B, C, and D are irrelevant to the context.
by the inimitable Colin Firth, emerging from his
11. Option (B).
private lake in a clinging wet shirt.” Only option C
is close to this. So, it is the correct answer. The main message of the passage is that Instagram
and other such social media networks promote an
Options A and B – Wrong. She was already popular
idea of beauty which is neither realistic nor healthy
as per the first paragraph.
to follow. The entire passage revolves around this
Option D – ‘Revival’ is a term that can’t be defined point.
by the data given in the passage.
Option A – The author is not talking about
8. Option (C). technology (too generic), but a specific part of the
2
technology (social media). So, this is too broad.
Refer to the lines: “Jane Austen has become a
feminist icon for lots of young women. Her novels Option B – This is correct. ‘Can be’ – makes the
02
portray heroines that stray from generalized female option logical.
stereotypes, and it is just as difficult for young
Option C – This is partly correct. But ‘the beauty
women today to stray from societal expectations
industry’ is not the main focus of the passage, it’s
and conventions.” So, option C is the correct
social media.
answer.
(2)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India
CLAT MOCK–11 Answer and explanation
Refer to the line: “More often than not, their looks Option D – This is mentioned as an imagination of
are a combination of gym, plastic surgery and a the narrator. Whether it’s true or false can’t be
generous amount of retouching.” So, option D is the determined from the passage.
correct answer.
20. Option (A).
15. Option (C).
‘Perdition’ means ‘hell’ or ‘a place for
The author continues to maintain that what we see punishment’. So, option A is the correct answer.
on social media is fake. This point is repeated
Option B – too neutral. Option C – can’t be
throughout the passage. The last sentence is, thus, a
determined. Option D – Irrelevant.
repetition.
2
21. Option (D).
There is no anti-climax (less exciting event than
expected), paradox, or irony. The sentence is quite The first paragraph refers to this problem. The
02
straightforward. author clearly explains that it refers to the income
gap between the different classes of the Indian
16. Option (C).
society. So, option D is the correct answer.
‘Heart missed a beat’ refers to being surprised or
Option A – It’s part of the problem. ‘developing
nervous. Option A talks about old memories which
nation’ – ‘billionaire’ – this topic has not been
00
can’t be verified by the passage. It’s clear that the
passengers in the train knew of Auschwitz and its
reputation. So, option C is the best choice. Option
D is vague. It doesn’t answer the question. Option
B says they were travelling to some other place. But
discussed in the passage.
Option B – It can’t be factually verified. It seems
India has had this problem for a long time.
Option C – Can’t be factually verified. The
95
the passage clearly states that they didn’t know economy surely saw one of its worst days after the
where they were being taken. So, option C is the pandemic. But it can’t be equated with the problem
correct answer. of income inequality.
17. Option (A). 22. Option (D).
1
It’s an easy question. This is a first person narrative. This can be answered by the method of elimination.
So, option A is the correct choice. The other options
can be easily eliminated. Option A – Refer to the first sentence of the
21
2
Option D – The reverse is true. The phrase From the line, only option D makes sense. The line
‘inequality doesn’t matter’ is mentioned in a basically states that true freedom doesn’t depend
different connotation (as something the author upon an individual or any surrounding.
02
rejects) in the passage.
Option A – ‘Impossible’ is too extreme a word.
25. Option (D).
Option B – ‘Dichotomous’ is contradictory. There
Economic contraction refers to a cycle of economic is no such contrasting nature mentioned here.
decline. It’s also clear from the first paragraph. So,
26.
option D is the correct choice.
Option (C). 00
This is mentioned in the last paragraph. The author
basically says that “Only an understanding of
Option C – We are talking about individual
freedom here. So, it has to relate to the individual.
‘Depend’ and ‘relate’ are not synonyms.
Option D is the best choice.
95
30. Option (C).
freedom as a person's potential ability to freely
choose an alternative, as an opportunity to think In the second paragraph, the author talks about how
and act following ideas and desires, and not difficult it is to have a universal definition of
because of internal or external coercion, gives the freedom due the inherent nature of the concept.
person the opportunity to acquire spiritual freedom, Dahl’s use of the term ‘settlement’ further
1
the acquiring of a person by himself.” So, option C emphasises this point. So, option C is the correct
is the essence of this statement. choice.
21
Option A – It’s a distortion. Freedom to be spiritual Option A – This is not a counter point.
is a freedom. It’s not the same as ‘spiritual (true) Option B – There is no challenge in framing his
freedom’. argument. The challenge is to define freedom.
Option B – ‘Always go for the alternative’ may be Option D – He is not talking about the relevance of
the choice of a truly free person. But it’s not the his argument. This is not his intention.
meaning of being truly free.
Section – II: Current Affairs including GK
Option D – When you act according to a ‘diktat’ or
according to the will of anyone, you are not truly 31. Option (B). 32. Option (B).
free. So, this can’t be the meaning of the phrase.
33. Option (A). 34. Option (D).
27. Option (A).
35. Option (C). 36. Option (A).
At the end of the first paragraph, the author says,
37. Option (B). 38. Option (D).
‘But the category of freedom itself is not subjected
to sufficiently serious analysis.’ So, option A is the 39. Option (C). 40. Option (A).
correct answer. 41. Option (D). 42. Option (B).
Options B and C – The paragraph mentions that 43. Option (C). 44. Option (A).
these are in the limelight. The question of analysing
them has not been raised. 45. Option (D). 46. Option (C).
Option D – This is not mentioned in the passage. 47. Option (D). 48. Option (A).
28. Option (D). 49. Option (B). 50. Option (B).
Refer to the line, “Today in modern society, we are 51. Option (C). 52. Option (A).
trying to restore the value of individual freedom…” 53. Option (C). 54. Option (B).
in the first paragraph. So, option D is the correct
answer. 55. Option (D). 56. Option (D).
(4)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India
CLAT MOCK–11 Answer and explanation
57. Option (C). 58. Option (B). B has committed theft, in as much as he takes it
dishonestly. The element of dishonest intention is
59. Option (B). 60. Option (A).
important in a case of theft and this was present in
61. Option (C). 62. Option (D). this case. Although B had taken his own car, but he
63. Option (C). 64. Option (B). had not done so with the dishonest intention of
causing loss to A. Hence, D is the correct answer.
65. Option (C). 66. Option (A).
73. Option (A).
Section – III: Legal Reasoning
Laila and Birju are liable for theft since they
67. Option (C). severed the merry-go-round wheel at night which
2
was still in the possession of Shamsher. The act of
Right to property is not a fundamental right and
severing it from the ground was performed with a
only a constitutional right under Article 300A of the
dishonest intention. Hence, A is the correct answer.
02
constitution. A petition under Article 32 can be
D is correct as well, but A is a more detailed
filed if there is a violation of a fundamental right
answer.
only. Hence, option C is correct. Option D is
incorrect since right to property is a constitutional 74. Option (B).
right.
Otis is liable for theft since he took the bike from
68. Option (B).
00
Rekha can file a writ of habeas corpus in this case
since Rashmi’s father had restrained her liberty
unreasonably. The writ of habeas corpus can be
Laila’s possession without her consent and it was
clearly a dishonest act. Also, it has been stated in
the second paragraph of the passage that temporary
deprivation is also considered to be theft. Hence,
option B and C are incorrect and B is the correct
95
used to order her father to present her body before
answer.
the court. Since, Rashmi and Rekha are adults, they
can make the choice and decision to live together. 75. Option (B).
69. Option (C). Maeve is liable for theft since she took the three
jewels from Jackson’s possession without his
1
(5)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India
CLAT MOCK–11 Answer and explanation
on the case of Binayak Sen v. the State of 86. Option (B).
Chhattisgarh.
Same explanation as that in Q. 4. The continuation
79. Option (C). period cannot change or be altered once it has
started.
Here, X talks of out voting the incumbent
government through a democratic process. Further 87. Option (D).
the statement made is not causing any disaffection
Here, A by mistake of fact felt that Z was
towards the Indian state either and is casual in
committing a murder and thus acting in good faith
nature.
and feeling justified by the law to do so,
80. Option (A). apprehended Z. A has committed no offence, and
2
can take the defence of S. 79 of the IPC.
Here, X is openly causing disaffection towards the
Indian state by calling on his supporters to oust the 88. Option (B).
02
elected government with the help of arms. X shall
No, A will not be guilty of any offence, as he was
thus be liable for Sedition.
acting in conformity with the orders given by his
81. Option (D). superiors, who gave him a free hand to do whatever
it takes to dispel the crowd. Additionally, since
According to the passage: “The United Kingdom,
New Zealand and Ghana have already passed
legislation repealing sedition, while the Law
Commissions of Canada, Ireland and Australia
have recommended repeal to their respective
parliaments. In both Uganda and Nigeria sedition
00 89.
petrol bombs were being hurled, A’s actions were
also proportional in nature. A thus has committed
no offence, and can take the defence of S. 76 of the
IPC
Option (B).
95
has been declared unconstitutional.”
Same explanation as in Q. 3. A has committed no
82. Option (B). offence and enjoys immunity under S. 76 of the
IPC.
S. 5 of the Limitation Act is only applicable on
Applications and not suits. In the given question, it 90. Option (A).
1
(6)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India
CLAT MOCK–11 Answer and explanation
object of Divine displeasure or of spiritual censure, of the IPC. Case- Abdul Ise Suleman v. State of
shall be deemed to interfere with the free exercise Gujarat.
of the electoral right of such candidate or voter,
102. Option (C).
within the meaning of sub-section (1).”
The principle of injuria sine damno i.e. violation of
95. Option (A).
legal right with no actual damage caused, is
The court in this case held that “Even if this were applicable in this case. Nominal damages are
in the form of a whip it is immaterial, so long as awarded when the plaintiff’s legal right has been
there is no compulsion on the electorate to vote in infringed but no real damage has been caused to
the manner indicated”, as stated in the passage. him. Therefore, A should be entitled to nominal
2
damages.
96. Option (D).
103. Option (C).
All the aforementioned were held to be not
02
amounting to Undue Influence on the case of In the present case, it is clear from the facts that the
Baburao Patel v Dr Zakir Hussain. chemist was unaware about the contents of the hair
conditioner. Moreover, no damages were cased to
97. Option (D).
her. Hence, the chemist is not liable.
In the present case, it can be reasonably construed
00
that the accused had the intention and knowledge,
to kill the policeman, by shooting him in the head.
The accused can thus be prosecuted under S. 307 of
the IPC.
104. Option (D).
Even though the legal right of B was infringed, A
may not be liable because the wrong is of a trivial
nature, as the paper merely touched the hands of B.
Contact of the file with B’s hands was incidental to
95
98. Option (C).
the act done by A.
X despite knowing that an arrest warrant had been
105. Option (D).
issued against the accused Pathan, tried concealing
him, with the intention of preventing him from Even though the legal right of B was infringed, A
being apprehended. X shall therefore be liable may not be liable because the wrong is of a trivial
1
The three ingredients of muder are fulfilled in this Solution for questions 106-110:
case:
It is known that the average of price per unit sold by the
1. Causing death, with the intention of doing so 4 companies is Rs.200 and so the total must be Rs.800.
2. Intention to cause such bodily injury that is likely A+B+C+D = 800
to cause death
150+B+175+225 = 800
3. The knowledge that the act is likely to cause the
death of another. B = Rs. 250/ unit
The accused shall thus be held guilty of muder. It is also known that average revenue generated by the 4
companies together is Rs.293750.
100. Option (C).
Total Revenue = Rs.293750 x 4 = Rs.1175000
Shooting a police officer with a double barrel at a
close distance would have in all probability caused A+B+C+D = 1175000
such a bodily injury as is likely to cause death. The 225000+375000+C+225000 = 1175000
accused shall thus be liable for culpable homicide
C = Rs.350000
as defined under S. 299 of the IPC.
Number of units sold by company B = 375000/250 = 1500
101. Option (B).
Number of units sold by company C = 350000/175 = 2000
The accused fired at the police officer with the
intention of causing death, and that it was only 106. Option (D).
incidental that the gun malfunctioned and thereby
Required value = [(2000-1500)/1500] x 100 =
killed a passerby. Thus, even though the person
33.33% more
who died was not the intended target, it can be
reasonably construed that the accused had planned 107. Option (D).
to murder the cop in in furtheracne of doing so, 108. Option (C).
killed the passerby, making him guilty under S. 301
(7)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India
CLAT MOCK–11 Answer and explanation
If the price per unit of a product is less than the Work done by B and C together = 2+1/3 = 7/3 units
average market price, then the market share on
Time taken to complete the work = 45/(7/3)
volume basis is more than the market share on value
basis. = 45x3 / 7
Based on the above, there are 2 companies A and C = 135/7 days
where the product price per unit is lower than the = 19 and 2/7 days
average market price.
115. Option (D).
109. Option (A).
Required value = 45 / (2/3)
Sales of company D in the next year = 1.15 x
2
225000 = 45 x 3 / 2
Sales of company A in the next year = 0.93 x = 135/2
02
225000 = 67 and 1/2 days
Required difference = (1.15-0.93) x 225000 Solution for questions 116-120:
= 0.22 x 225000 Prepaid users Postpaid users
Colleges
= Rs.49500
110. Option (B).
Required value = [(293750-375000) / 375000] x
100
00 X
Y
Total
1600x 5/2
= 4000
288x12/1
= 3456
Male
2490
1408
Female
=1510
3456-1408
= 2048
Total
= 2400
3456+288
=3744
Male
4000-2490 4000-1600 2400-760
=1640
Female
760
95
= -21.66% Z 822 572
116. Option (C).
= 21% approximately
Total Female users in college Y= 5000(Given);
Solution for questions 111-115:
and Female prepaid users in college Y= 2048;
1
45 units
Therefore, Female postpaid users in college Y=
A+B+C: 15 days: 3 units/day
5000- 2048= 2952,
21
Required ratio = A:B:C = 2/3 : 2 : 1/3 Total male users in college Z= 2250 (Given)
And Male prepaid users in the same college= 822,
=2:6:1
112. Option (A). So, Male postpaid users= 2250- 822= 1428;
Per day efficiency of C = 1/3 units Therefore, total postpaid users= 1428 + 572= 2000;
Required % = [(2-1/3)/(1/3)] x 100 Now, total prepaid users= 2000 x 7/5 = 2800,
Female postpaid users= 2800 – 822= 1978;
= 500%
113. Option (C). So, the difference between the male postpaid users
and female prepaid users
C will complete the work alone in 45 / (1/3) = 45 x
3 = 135 days = 1978 – 1428
= 550;
Required answer = 135-15 = 120 days
114. Option (A).
(8)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India
CLAT MOCK–11 Answer and explanation
118. Option (D). mysterious of all the objects that make up, and
thicken, the environment we recognize as
Female postpaid users in college Z= 572;
modern.”
Total female users in college X= 1510 + 760 (Refer
123. Option (B).
table)
Reasoning: Option (b) is the correct answer. It can
= 2270;
be inferred from the story of the two peasants who
So, the answer would be= (572/2270) x 100; bring home photographs instead of treasure. Option
= 25% approx. (a) is incorrect an simply not the point of the second
paragraph. Option (c) is incorrect because the
2
119. Option (B). second paragraph is not a comment on the quality
Female postpaid users in college X= 760(Refer of the movie. Option (d) is incorrect because the
peasants did not think the photographs would have
02
table);
greater monetary value, but they only meant more
Total male users in the same college= 2490 + to them because of the magical nature of
1640(Refer table) photographs, which make the collector feel like
= 4130; they are holding a part of the world.
7/2
= 1400; cannot really be inferred from the passage.
Female prepaid users= 1400 – 822 Moreover, the prompt speaks of “print”, not
21
= 578; photographs.
and total postpaid users in college Z= 1400 – 400= 125. Option (A).
1000;
so, Male postpaid users= 1000-572= 428; 126. Option (B).
the answer would be = 578 -428= 150; Reasoning: Option (b) can be inferred from the line
Section – V: Logical Reasoning “Monday’s mutinous coup was… was a direct
result of this growing instability which the
121. Option (A). government failed miserably to tackle” Option (a)
Reasoning: Plato’s cave is a metaphor to denote the is incorrect because the jihadist violence is not a
world, as can be inferred from the line “This very “temporary schism” at all, as inferred from the last
insatiability of the photographing eye changes the few lines of the passage about a “terrorist
terms of confinement in the cave, our world.” machinery spread across Sahel”. Option (c) is
Hence, Option (a) is correct. incorrect because Kabore was elected when the
terrorists had overrun Niger and Mali, not Burkina
122. Option (D). Faso. Option (d) is incorrect as inferred from the
Reasoning: Option (d) is the correct option. That line “The military and large sections of civilians
photographs are “potentially damaging” cannot be saw the Kaboré government as ineffective, corrupt
inferred from anything given in the passage. Option and out of touch with the ground reality.”
(a) can be inferred from the line “In teaching us a 127. Option (C).
new visual code, photographs alter and enlarge our
notions of what is worth looking at and what we Reasoning: Option (c) is correct, and inferred from
have a right to observe. They are a grammar and, the line “Over the last seven years, at least 2,000
even more importantly, an ethics of seeing.” Option people have been killed and over one million
(b) can be inferred from the line “To collect displaced in this country of 22 million people.”
photographs is to collect the world.” Option (c) can Option (a) is incorrect because the pandemic is not
be inferred from “Photographs are perhaps the most aiding jihadists, it is only making things worse for
the people and the govt. Option (b) is incorrect
(9)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India
CLAT MOCK–11 Answer and explanation
because the army participated in the coup, not the few lines. Option (c) is simply false and hence
jihadist violence. Option (d) is incorrect because incorrect.
the capital city fell to the coup, and the coup was
131. Option (C).
welcomed by the people of the city, as per the
passage. Reasoning: Option (c) is correct and can be inferred
from the line “It does not communicate a feeling of
128. Option (B).
respect and political assertion.” Option (a) is
Reasoning: Option (b) is correct because it is an incorrect as the author indicates that they were once
overbroad inference from the passage which only unproblematic and their usage was normal, as
speaks of Burkina Faso in particular and the West indicated in the line “There are problems in using
2
African region in general. This answer can best be the same concepts now.” Option (b) is incorrect
reached by elimination. Option (a) can be inferred because Mahatma Jyotirao Phulle coined the terms,
from the first few lines of both the first and second they are not of Brahmanical origin. Option (d) is
02
paragraphs. Option (c) can be inferred from the line simply not drawn from the passage.
“Rather, the juntas, which lack political legitimacy,
132. Option (D).
end up making them worse.” Option (d) can be
inferred from the line “In Mali, the military staged Reasoning: Option (d) is the correct answer. The
a coup for the second time in less than a year, in author’s claim is that “In their day-to-day lives the
May 2021.”
129. Option (A). 00
Reasoning: Option (a) is correct. This is a cannot
be true question, which means that some options
OBCs are as oppressed as are the Scheduled
Castes”, and they should not be included with other
Hindu castes. We need an option that strengthens
this claim. Option (d) does that. Options (a) and (b)
do not make any difference to that claim. Option (c)
95
may be uncertain, but the option which is also fails to have any impact on the author’s claim
absolutely and directly contradictory to the because it says nothing about OBCs are as
information in the passage will be our answer. oppressed as SCs.
Option (a) is clearly false as inferred from the lines
133. Option (B).
“While taking power, all these military leaders
1
promised elections, but soon their focus shifted to Reasoning: Option (b) is correct. This is a fairly
tightening their grip on power rather than resolving simple inference, given that the passage begins with
21
the crises that they used to justify their power grab “I would like to say a word about the terms and
or allowing a transition to a legitimate government. concepts that I use later in this book.” “Later”
The story of Burkina Faso is not different.” Option suggests this is not an epilogue. Glossary is like a
(b) can be loosely inferred form the line where the brief dictionary, so (c) is out. Option (a) is also out
author warns other nations of the continent to take because the author does not thank anyone.
warning from coups in West Africa. Option (c) can 134. Option (A).
also be loosely inferred as the author mentions
“economic woes” caused the coronavirus 135. Option (B).
pandemic. Option (d) can be inferred as the Reasoning: Option (b) is the correct option. It is an
protesters in the capital welcomed the coup, as assumption implicit in the first two lines where the
mentioned towards the end of the passage. author says that because Brahminical writers have
130. Option (D). used the term Sudra in a derogatory sense, it “does
not communicate a feeling of respect and political
Reasoning: Although option (a) comes close, assertion.” This implies that the way a word is used
option (d) is the correct answer because the author in a social context has an impact on it’s meaning.
says that “Coups are hardly a solution to the many Option (a) is incorrect because the author only says
crises these countries face. Rather, the juntas, that they are preferrable to Brahminical terms, not
which lack political legitimacy, end up making entirely acceptable. Option (c) is not an
them worse.” The author shows not just distrust of assumption, though it may be an inference. An
juntas, but asserts that they generally worsen the assumption is something without which the
situation instead of solving any problems. Option argument cannot stand. Option (d) is simply
(b) is incorrect because the author mentions other incorrect.
nations only to give better context of the situation.
They do not say that Burkina Faso fell because the 136. Option (A).
other West African countries fell too. These are Reasoning: Option (a) is the correct answer.
independent event, not cause-effect. Moreover, it is Implementation of the NHRC directive has been
not the main point, which is mentioned in the last the main concern of the author from the start to the
(10)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India
CLAT MOCK–11 Answer and explanation
end of the passage. This answer can best be reached Mizoram, not about “undocumented people in the
by elimination. Option (b) is wrong because the northeast” or “local fears about a demographic
passage doesn’t talk about “the refugee problem in hijack”. Option (a) can be inferred from the first
the northeast” but specifically about the sentence of the second paragraph. Option (b) can be
Chakma/Hajong communities and their inferred from “Special rights guaranteed in the
resettlement. Option (c) is incorrect because the Indian Constitution… have been misinterpreted as
directive is not a move by the State Government. favouring tribal nativism with overblown
Option (d) is incorrect because is does not mention demographic fears fanning hatred for communities
the directive and is overbroad and too general as it such as the Chakma/Hajong in Arunachal Pradesh
talks about refugees, not the Chakma/Hajong and Mizoram.” Option (d) can be inferred from the
2
communities. passage at large.
137. Option (D). 141. Option (B).
02
Reasoning: Option (d) is correct. Option (c) is a Reasoning: Option (b) is correct. When Phule says
tempting option because it seems exhaustive. that the upper castes are descendants of the Aryans
However, all the given options are false negatives. who were an invading race, and the Hindu
Just because the three given conditions- the Court’s Nationalists say that the upper castes are native to
backing, the native-by-birth and the peaceful India, both the groups are assuming that being
living- make the Minister’s remarks unwarranted
does not mean that their absence would make the
statement warranted. The reasons mentioned are 00
sufficient, but may not be exhaustive. There may be
other similar reasons that make his communal
indigenous to the Indian land gives them rights to it
the land that others do not have. Option (a) is
incorrect because the ancestral lineage is relevant,
the birth of their forefathers is relevant, not their
own. Option (c) and (d) are not mentioned in the
95
remarks unwarranted. This is a logical fallacy. passage at all and can easily be eliminated.
138. Option (A). 142. Option (A).
Reasoning: Option (a) is the correct answer. It Reasoning: Option (a) is correct. Phule argues that
negates one of the premises the author provides in because the upper castes belong to the Aryan race
1
support of his argument, i.e., the community is who are not native to the land, they do not have
peaceful. Although this is not sufficient for the rights to the land like Dalits do, who are indigenous
21
reasoning to fall entirely; this definitely weakens to it. Option (a) falsifies the invasion theory itself
the author’s argument to some degree. Option (b) is hence his argument falls. Option (b) and (c) are
inconsequential to the author’s argument, which irrelevant to Phule’s argument. Option (d) supports
advocates for the grant of citizenship. The fact the Phule’s argument about the inherent conflict
remains that the directives of the Supreme Court between the invader (Aryan) and invaded (dalit)
have still not been followed through. Option (c) and the origin of caste in invasion and oppression.
does not weaken the author’s argument, because the
143. Option (D).
effect of Mr Rijuju’s statement remains harmful,
whatever the motivations of his statement be. Reasoning: Option (d) is the correct option. The
Option (d) strengthens the author’s argument. upper castes agree with historians that they belong
to the Aryan race, which was an invasive race, and
139. Option (B).
hence cling to ideas of racial superiority and a
Reasoning: Option (b) can be inferred from the line single lineage of upper caste Hindus. The Hindu
“…ensuring implementation of the judgement of Nationalists reject the invasion theory and stress
2015 would go a long way in addressing concerns that all Hindus are native to the Indian land.
of these communities.” Option (a) is against what Clearly, there is fundamental disagreement on both
the author wants. Option (c) is incorrect because the sides.
author calls for implementation of the directive, not
144. Option (C).
debate on it. Option (d) is incorrect because the
author does not call for ground research. Reasoning: Option (c) is correct. Historians
“accepted the theory of an invasion, with the
140. Option (C).
introduction of Indo-Aryan and its speakers as the
Reasoning: Option (c) is correct. The author is foundation of Indian history.” There is no academic
against the idea of a census, and the option is disagreement. Option (a) is clear from the first few
overbroad and cannot be drawn from the passage. lines of the passage. Option (b) and (d) is inferred
The passage specifically talks about the from the last few lines of the passage.
Hajong/Chakma community in Arunachal and
145. Option (D).
(11)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India
CLAT MOCK–11 Answer and explanation
Reasoning: Although options (a) and (d) might Reasoning: Option (a) is the correct answer, and
seem close, option (d) is the correct answer. The can be best reached by elimination. The passage is
passage is not analytical because analytical not satirical, it is factual and straight forward, so
passages typically have advantages and option (b) is out. Option (c) is out because the
disadvantages, statistics and several arguments author does not attempt to persuade the readers to
about a particular topic. It is more inclined to assess any one opinion or ideology, but only explains his
and evaluate. Expository passages explain a topic point of view on a policy decision. Option (d) is
as it is. incorrect because acerbic means excessively angry
and vile, which is simply not the tone of the author.
146. Option (C).
The author is critical of the amendments to Rule 6
2
Reasoning: Option (c) is the correct answer. This and suggests alternatives. They also say that the
can be inferred from the first line of the passage as policy is a blow to federalism and does not rectify
well as the line “But does this necessitate the rule top-down culture. Hence, (a) is correct.
02
changes proposed by the DoPT, which include
150. Option (D).
acquiring overriding powers for the Union
government that will do away with seeking Reasoning: Option (d) is the correct answer. Option
approval from the States for transferring IAS and (a) is correct because if top-down culture cannot be
IPS officers?” The author does not merely set out solved until the shortage of deputations is solved,
to evaluate the policy decision as a whole, but
begins with saying that the remedy will do more
harm than good, and then gives reasons why. This00
is why option (c) is correct and option (b) is not.
Option (d) is only a secondary concern and not the
the author’s suggestion in the line “there is clearly
a need for a more qualitative approach that tackles
such work culture issues” fails logically. Option (b)
is correct because it negates the suggestion of a
system of disincentives by saying that the UPSC is
95
main one. Option (a) is incorrect because that is not constitutionally bound to listen to the State
something that the author will assess, that is a fact, government, and hence cannot work against them.
as clear from the lines “Some states have not Option (c) is incorrect because the author makes no
nominates officers… This has led to vacancies suggestion regarding the salaries of bureaucrats at
across Union government ministries.” all.
1
(12)
© Possible education Pvt. Ltd.: All rights reserved. Unauthorized copying, sale, distribution or
circulation of any of the contents of this work is a punishable offence under laws of India