Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER THREE
Arjuna said:
If you believe that cultivation of Intellect
is superior to action,
then why do you impel me
to this horrific action, Krishna? (3.1)
1Of course, the whole point of the Gita is that Krishna can't tell him "one thing." Or, as
the commentator Samkara states, there are different paths for different people at
different stages of their lives. See also 5.1.
[Draft translation; not for quotation, citation or attribution
outside of classroom use except by permission of the translator]
3The action involved in sacrifice is considered pure according to the Vedic ritual theory
because it is done primarily for the sake of the injunction itself, and only secondarily for
the result that might gained from it.
[Draft translation; not for quotation, citation or attribution
outside of classroom use except by permission of the translator]
4Both commentators agree that there is a break here; Krishna has been speaking of those
who are in the path of knowledge, whereas Arjuna is in the path of action. But the
perspective of this verse teaches that those engaged in action should also be unattached.
[Draft translation; not for quotation, citation or attribution
outside of classroom use except by permission of the translator]
6This could either mean "by action alone," i.e. without attachment, or as the
commentators want to understand it, without renouncing worldly responsibilities,
including Vedic sacrifice, and without recourse to the other path, that of pure
knowledge.
8This is the culmination of the idea begun in 3.26, that those knowing the true nature of
action are obliged not to confuse those incapable of understanding it, those who think
that human agency is real, that they really perform actions.
9 Or conviction.
[Draft translation; not for quotation, citation or attribution
outside of classroom use except by permission of the translator]
Arjuna said:
Then what drives this man
that he commits evil.
Even without desiring it, Krishna,
he is compelled as if by force? (3.36)
That is, people act according to the proportional amount of each of the Gunas in their
10
makeup.
12 That is, they arise from the Guna of rajas, "passionate energy."
[Draft translation; not for quotation, citation or attribution
outside of classroom use except by permission of the translator]
CHAPTER FOUR
The Lord said:
I proclaimed this imperishable yoga
to Vivasvan, the sun.
Vivasvan transmitted it to Manu, his son,
and Manu taught the discipline
to his son Iksvaku, founder of the solar dynasty. (4.1)
13This is the same "That" which is taught in the great dictum of the Upanisads, "That
thou art." In other words, the Supreme Self which is identified with Brahman.
[Draft translation; not for quotation, citation or attribution
outside of classroom use except by permission of the translator]
Arjuna said:
Your birth was recent;
the birth of Vivasvan was long ago.
How should I understand that you proclaimed this yoga
"in the beginning"? (4.4)
14In the Vedas, maya means the conjurings of a magician (as when Indra destroyed the
"tricks" of the dragon Vrtra). In the later Vedanta philosophy, somewhat under the
influence of Buddhist (Yogacara) ideas, the term comes to refer to the notion that the
phenomenal world is "illusion," because only Brahman is real. Here, however, maya
describes the exuberance and energy of the divine creative activity that Lord Krishna
works through prakrti, Material Nature. Though not illusory, its dynamic, playful
quality makes it less "ultimate" than purusa (=atman = Brahman).
Those who desire that their actions will have successful results
sacrifice to the gods here on earth,
for in the human world success from ritual action
is quickly produced. (4.12)
There are those who sacrifice with the things they have,
and those whose sacrifice is austerities.
Still others sacrifice by means of yoga,
and ascetics with harsh vows make their sacrifice
with Vedic study and transcendent knowledge. (4.28)
16 The primary of the five vital breaths in the traditional Indian physiology.
CHAPTER FIVE
Arjuna said:
First you praise renunciation of actions, Krishna,
then their mastery in disciplined practice.
Tell me between these two
which one is better for certain.18 (5.1)
18 See also 3.2, where Arjuna also asks for "one thing."
21 Literally, "yoked."
23Thecommentators understand this to refer to the "lord of the body," or atman, but the
author of the Gita probably intended a more straightforward meaning.
25nirdhuta;
the image is definitely that of the dhobi cleaning clothes, so "washed clean,"
"cleansing" are appropriate translations.
[Draft translation; not for quotation, citation or attribution
outside of classroom use except by permission of the translator]
CHAPTER SIX
The Lord said:
The person who performs actions which must be done--
the required ritual duties--
26Cf. 2.72.
[Draft translation; not for quotation, citation or attribution
outside of classroom use except by permission of the translator]
In a pure spot,
he solidly grounds a seat for himself,
neither too high or too low,
with a covering of cloth, deerskin and kusa grass. (6.11)
27Thecommentator Samkara makes a point of saying this does not mean that he is
concentrating on the tip of his nose, but withdrawn from the external objects of sense
and directed inwards towards the self.
28But not extinction itself, for this would constitute a Buddhistic (early Buddhist) denial
of its shape as real divinity.
[Draft translation; not for quotation, citation or attribution
outside of classroom use except by permission of the translator]
is called Yoga.
Practice this Yoga with resolve,
your consciousness free from despair. (6.23)
Little by little,
Intellect armed with fortitude,
the yogi comes to rest.
His mind should be made to take the form of the self,
and he should think of nothing else. (6.25)
however he is living,
he lives in me. (6.31)
Arjuna said:
This yoga which you declare to be "sameness," Krishna--
I don't see how its existence can be firmly maintained,
because of fickleness. (6.33)
Arjuna said:
If a person does not have self-control,
if his mind wavers from this yoga, this discipline,
but he has faith in it--
since he doesn't attain perfection in yoga,
where does he go, Krishna? (6.37)
29AsV. Panoli mentions in his notes to the commentary of Samkara, the comparison is
with horses and relates to the Katha Upanisad III.3-4; also a most apt comparison for
Arjuna, the great chariot warrior.
[Draft translation; not for quotation, citation or attribution
outside of classroom use except by permission of the translator]