Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Zhao et al.
Chest CT Findings in COVID-19 Pneumonia
Cardiopulmonary Imaging
Original Research
I
Province, National Natural Science Foundation of China
(grant no. 81671671), and the Key R & D projects in Hunan es of pneumonia of unknown South Korea, and the United States [5–8]. On
Province (grant no. 2019SK2131). causation emerged in Wuhan, January 31, 2020, the World Health Organi-
1
Department of Radiology, The Second Xiangya Hospital,
Hubei, China, and quickly raised zation [9] declared the outbreak of coronavi-
Central South University, No. 139 Middle Remin Rd, intense attention around the world [1]. A nov- rus disease (COVID-19) a Public Health
Changsha, Hunan, 410011, P.R. China. Address el bat-origin coronavirus, 2019 novel corona- Emergency of International Concern. Given
correspondence to J. Liu (junliu123@csu.edu.cn). virus, was identified by means of deep se- the striking speed of virus transmission, the
2 quencing analysis [2]. The virus, named ongoing COVID-19 outbreak has undoubted-
Department of Radiology, First Hospital of Changsha,
Hunan, P.R. China. severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavi- ly been linked to panicked memories of two
rus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) [3], is phylogenetically previous betacoronavirus outbreaks in the
3
Changsha Public Health Treatment Center, Hunan, closest to bat SARS-like coronavirus but in a 21st century: SARS-CoV [10, 11] and Middle
P.R. China. separate clade, which means that a novel East respiratory syndrome coronavirus
4
Department of Radiology, Quality Control Center,
coronavirus is spreading [2]. As of February (MERS-CoV) [12, 13].
Changsha, Hunan, P.R. China. 17, 2020, 72,436 laboratory-confirmed cases SARS-CoV-2 proved to have the ability
were consecutively reported in 31 provinces for efficient human-to-human transmission
AJR 2020; 215:1–6 (municipalities and regions) in China, in- [14–16]. The explosion of confirmed cases
ISSN-L 0361–803X/20/2154–1
cluding 11,741 severe cases, 1868 fatal cases, of COVID-19 has been overwhelming, even
and 6242 suspected cases [4]. After the first though the mortality of COVID-19 is low-
© American Roentgen Ray Society reported case in Wuhan, several exported er than that of SARS-CoV and MERS-CoV
infections [17]. A curative vaccine has not formed consent was waived in accordance with cavitation, tree-in-bud, bronchial wall thicken-
yet been developed. Early detection and ef- Council for International Organizations of Medi- ing, reticulation, subpleural bands, traction bron-
ficient control of the route of transmission cal Sciences guidelines. chiectasis, intrathoracic lymph node enlargement,
(i.e., isolation of suspected cases, disinfec- vascular enlargement in the lesion, and pleural ef-
tion) are still the most effective way to fight Patients fusions. We described four distributions: cranio-
the COVID-19 outbreak. The epidemiolog- We retrospectively collected the records of pa- caudal, transverse, lung region, and scattered. A
Downloaded from www.ajronline.org by 175.176.24.108 on 03/12/20 from IP address 175.176.24.108. Copyright ARRS. For personal use only; all rights reserved
ic, laboratory, and clinical features of CO- tients with laboratory-confirmed COVID-19 in the CT score system was used to evaluate the extent of
VID-19 pneumonia have been described [2, database of the Radiology Quality Control Cen- disease. The details of the imaging interpretation
14, 17, 18]. A specific epidemiologic history ter, Hunan. The diagnosis of COVID-19 was deter- were described in our previous study [21].
(e.g., exposure to the Huanan seafood mar- mined with following methods: isolation of SARS-
ket in Wuhan) and a prodrome of fever and CoV-2 or at least two positive results of real-time Statistical Analysis
dry cough are highly indicative of infection RT-PCR assay for SARS-CoV-2 or a genetic se- Continuous variables were presented as medians
with SARS-CoV-2 [18]. However, infections quence matched with SARS-CoV-2. A total of 101 and compared by Mann-Whitney U test. Categoric
by other viruses, such as influenza A and in- patients with consecutively laboratory-confirmed variables were presented as numbers and percent-
fluenza B, can cause the same clinical symp- COVID-19 (45 women, 56 men; mean age, 44.44 ± ages and were compared by chi-square or Fisher
toms as COVID-19, which makes the clinical 12.32 [SD] years; median, 43 years; range, 17–75 exact test between emergency and nonemergency
diagnosis of COVID-19 pneumonia difficult, years) who underwent CT in four cities in Hunan, groups. Two-sided p < 0.05 was considered statis-
especially during flu season. For the large China, were included in this study. The numbers of tically significant. All statistical analyses were per-
number of cases of suspected COVID-19, confirmed cases were as follows: 74 in Changsha, formed with SPSS software (version 24.0, IBM).
laboratory detection is time-consuming and seven in YueYang, 10 in ChangDe, and 10 in Xiang-
may not be available for all people with sus- Tan. All available clinical, laboratory, and epidemi- Results
pected infection owing to the shortage of test ologic data were collected for all patients. Accord- Clinical Characteristics
kits for SARS-CoV-2. These challenges in- ing to the guideline on COVID-19 (trial version 5) Among the 101 included patients, 87 (48
crease the risk of spread by free movement [19] issued by the China National Health Commis- men, 39 women) were in the nonemergency
of people with highly suspected disease. In sion, patients were divided into four groups: those group, and 14 (eight men, six women) were in
addition, the laboratory test can have false- with mild-type, common-type, severe-type, and fa- the emergency group. The age distribution is
negative results. tal-type disease. Because treatment regimens vary shown in Table 1; 70.2% of the patients were
Imaging plays an important role in the by disease type, we regrouped patients into non- 21–50 years old. Seventeen (16.8%) patients
diagnosis and management of COVID-19 emergency (mild and common types) and emer- denied any direct exposure history to Wuhan
pneumonia. CT is considered the first-line gency (severe and fatal types) groups. All patients or to people who had a direct exposure his-
imaging modality in highly suspected cases underwent CT after admission. The mean interval tory to Wuhan (i.e., long-term exposure his-
and is helpful for monitoring imaging chang- between admission and CT examination was 1 day tory to Wuhan, traveling in Wuhan before di-
es during treatment. Therefore, CT has been (range, 0–7 days; median, 1 day). agnosis). Among the 17 patients, 12 had an
identified as an efficient clinical diagnostic exposure history to patients with confirmed
tool for people with suspected COVID-19 Imaging Technique disease, and five denied any direct or indirect
[19]. It has potential for identifying people All patients underwent scanning with the fol-
with negative results of a reverse transcrip- lowing four scanners: Anatom 16HD (Anke Med- TABLE 1: Basic Clinical and Epidemic
tion–polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) ical Solutions), HiSpeed-Dual (GE Healthcare), Features
assay but in whom COVID-19 is highly sus- 64-MDCT LightSpeed VCT (GE Healthcare), and
All Patients
pected [20, 21]. COVID-19 pneumonia is Somatom Emotion (Siemens Healthcare). The ac-
Feature (n = 101)
the most common clinical presentation of quisition parameters were set at 120 kVp; 100–
COVID-19. The findings on CT images may 200 mAs; pitch, 0.75–1.5; and collimation, 0.625– Sex
reflect the severity of disease. Previous stud- 5 mm. All imaging data were reconstructed by use Male 56 (55.4)
ies [18, 22–24] have shown imaging features of a medium sharp reconstruction algorithm with Female 45 (44.6)
in small sample sizes. The detailed imaging a slice thickness of 0.625–5 mm. CT images were
Age (y)
features and differences in imaging features acquired at full inspiration with the patient in the
between the four clinical types (mild, com- supine position. Mean 44.44
mon, severe, fatal) [19] have not been well Range 17–75
studied for this disease. Imaging Interpretation Age group (y)
The purpose of this study was to clari- Two radiologists (5 and 15 years of experience)
≤ 20 1 (1.0)
fy the chest CT features in laboratory-con- reviewed chest CT scans blindly and independent-
firmed cases of COVID-19 to further help ly in consensus. All images were viewed with both 21–40 44 (43.6)
clinicians screen for suspected COVID-19 lung (width, 1500 HU; level, −700 HU) and medi- 41–50 27 (26.6)
cases and evaluate the confirmed cases. astinal (width, 350 HU; level, 40 HU) settings. We 51–60 14 (13.9)
evaluated 14 imaging features defined in a previ-
61–70 14 (13.9)
Materials and Methods ous study [25]: ground-glass opacities (GGO),
This study received medical ethical commit- consolidation, mixed GGO and consolidation, ≥ 70 1 (1.0)
tee approval, and the requirement for patient in- centrilobular nodules, architectural distortion, (Table 1 continues on next page)
(55 [54.5%]). Other evaluated imaging fea- common (78.6%) in the emergency group.
exposure to patients with confirmed disease. tures are shown in Table 2. The mean lung The result was indirectly proved in the ex-
Five (5.0%) patients had disease associated involvement score was 6.39. Cavitation and tent score analysis, which showed that the ex-
with a family outbreak (more than two cases tree-in-bud were not present on the images in tent score was higher in the emergency group
confirmed in one family). Fever was the on- our study. Eight patients had no obvious ab- than in the nonemergency group (p = 0.000).
set symptom for 78.2% of patients. The rates normality on CT images.
of other onset symptoms—cough, myalgia or Discussion
fatigue, sore throat, dyspnea, diarrhea, and Comparison of Basic Clinical Characteristics We comprehensively evaluated and ana-
nausea and vomiting—are shown in Table 1. and CT Findings in Nonemergency and lyzed the radiographic characteristics of 101
Two patients had no onset symptoms. Emergency Groups patients with COVID-19 pneumonia from
Patients in the emergency group were old- the Radiology Quality Control Center, Hu-
CT Findings er than those in the nonemergency group; nan. The basic epidemiologic and clinical
Most patients with COVID-19 had typ- nine (64.3%) patients in the emergency group features were reported. Patients with dis-
ical imaging features, such as GGO (87 were older than 50 years. Regarding under- ease associated with human-to-human trans-
[86.1%]), mixed GGO and consolidation (65 lying disease, no significant difference was mission or a family outbreak need medical
[64.4%]), vascular enlargement in the lesion found between the two groups. Four of the 14 attention. Typical CT findings can help in
(72 [71.3%]), and traction bronchiectasis (53 imaging features—architectural distortion, early screening of patients with suspected
[52.5%]) (Figs. 1 and 2). Several lesion distri- traction bronchiectasis, intrathoracic lymph disease and efficiently evaluate the extent of
bution patterns were identified (Table 2). Le- node enlargement, and pleural effusions— COVID-19 acute respiratory disease.
sions present on CT images of patients with were more likely to be found in the emergen- The increasing frequency of confirmed
COVID-19 were more likely to have a pe- cy group (p < 0.05) (Table 2). The craniocau- COVID-19 cases is striking, and the number
ripheral distribution (88 [87.1%]), have bilat- dal, transverse, and lung region distributions of cases has risen over the number of SARS
eral involvement (83 [82.2%]), be lower lung were not significantly different between the cases [17]. Because the origin and biologic
predominant (55 [54.5%]), and be multifocal two groups, but diffuse lesions were more characteristics of COVID-19 have not been
and five patients had a specific epidemic his- imaging features of patients with negative re- suspected cases and in evaluating the sever-
tory in Wuhan. It once again reminded phy- sults and other virus infections may help us ity and extent of the disease.
sicians of the importance of inquiring about to differentiate COVID-19 pneumonia from
details of epidemic exposure history when other lung infections and then to screen pa- References
seeing patients in an outpatient clinic. There- tients with highly suspected cases. Second, 1. World Health Organization website. Novel coro-
fore, the combination of chest CT and PCR we did not evaluate follow-up CT findings navirus: China. www.who.int/csr/don/12-january-
screening is necessary for early diagnosis. in our study. Exploring the CT changes and 2020-novel-coronavirus-china/en/. Published January
One of the eight patients had abnormal fol- comparing them with the clinical parame- 12, 2020. Accessed January 19, 2020
low-up CT findings that necessitated addi- ters may help us monitor and predict outcome 2. Ren LL, Wang YM, Wu ZQ, et al. Identification of
tional scanning. [28] and support clinical decision making. a novel coronavirus causing severe pneumonia in
The study had several limitations. First, human: a descriptive study. Chin Med J 2020 Feb
only 101 patients with confirmed COVID-19 Conclusion 11 [Epub ahead of print]
were included; negative results and infections Patients with confirmed COVID-19 pneu- 3. World Health Organization website. Naming the
with other viruses were not included in the monia have typical imaging features that coronavirus disease (COVID-2019) and the virus
analyses. Comprehensive investigation of the may be helpful in early screening of highly that causes it. www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/