You are on page 1of 16

Hanoi Cohesive Soil in Salt-Affected

Conditions: Soil Properties and 2D


Consolidation Analysis

Nguyen Ngoc Truc & Lena Mihova

International Journal of Civil


Engineering

ISSN 1735-0522
Volume 18
Number 2

Int J Civ Eng (2020) 18:137-150


DOI 10.1007/s40999-019-00422-5

1 23
Your article is protected by copyright and all
rights are held exclusively by Iran University
of Science and Technology. This e-offprint is
for personal use only and shall not be self-
archived in electronic repositories. If you wish
to self-archive your article, please use the
accepted manuscript version for posting on
your own website. You may further deposit
the accepted manuscript version in any
repository, provided it is only made publicly
available 12 months after official publication
or later and provided acknowledgement is
given to the original source of publication
and a link is inserted to the published article
on Springer's website. The link must be
accompanied by the following text: "The final
publication is available at link.springer.com”.

1 23
Author's personal copy
International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150
https://doi.org/10.1007/s40999-019-00422-5

RESEARCH PAPER

Hanoi Cohesive Soil in Salt-Affected Conditions: Soil Properties and 2D


Consolidation Analysis
Nguyen Ngoc Truc1,2   · Lena Mihova3

Received: 17 December 2018 / Revised: 3 March 2019 / Accepted: 19 March 2019 / Published online: 9 April 2019
© Iran University of Science and Technology 2019

Abstract
The paper focuses on the geotechnical experiments and numerical simulation of 2D consolidation analysis for the cohesive
soils fully saturated by solutions of four salt concentrations, i.e. 0.0, 9.9, 19.8, and 33.0 g/L. The experiments were carried out
on undisturbed soil samples taken from the boreholes in Hanoi area where the subsoil has not been affected by saline intru-
sion yet. The composition and properties of the cohesive soil in salt-affected conditions were investigated with transmission
electron microscopic method and other geotechnical experiments. Consolidation analysis with finite element method was
applied to an assumed embankment on saline subsoil. The analytical results showed that swelling mineral of montlorillonite
is present in the Hanoi cohesive soils. The water content of the studied soils decreases as the salt concentration increases.
Meanwhile, the bulk density unclearly changes in the same testing conditions. The coefficient of consolidation reduces,
respectively, with the salinities, from 22 to 50% as salinities rise up to 33.0 g/L. Compressibility index increases linearly
and proportionally with the salinities. In 2D analytical model, the settlement or vertical displacement of the subsoil in HD1
site reaches 14.8% and that of GL2 site is 18.7% at saline solution of 33.0 g/L. The horizontal displacement of the subsoil
reaches 13.90% in HD1 site and 17.55% in GL2 site from the baseline. The time at primary consolidation completion is
longer as saturated solution is saltier. The prolongation of primary consolidation time gets over 30% if the subsoil is at the
most salty. These changes illustrate the degradation of soils in the saline media.

Keywords  Cohesive soil · Salt-affected soil · Saline intrusion · Soil properties · Consolidation analysis · Finite element
method

1 Introduction Global-warming-driven sea-level rise along the coastal area


of the Red River delta is, among others, one major factor
In the context of climate change, coastal low-level areas causing saline intrusion of soil strata. The Red River delta
suffer from extreme weather phenomena. One of them contains young upper Holocene sediments, most of which
is sea-level rise, which is a much concerned hazard. are part of Thai Binh formation. The sediments, dating back
to 3000 years ago, are primarily originated from shallow
sea, alluvial, or lacustrine sediments [1]. Those deposits are
* Nguyen Ngoc Truc affected by sea-level rise at various degrees. The rise of sea
trucnn@vnu.edu.vn level results in the expansion and the deeper intrusion of
Lena Mihova brackish water wedge at river mouth into land. In addition,
l_mihova@yahoo.com the freshwater lens floating above saltwater along barrier
1
VNU School of Interdisciplinary Studies, Vietnam National coasts is 40 times thicker than the elevation of the water
University, Building G7, No. 144 Xuan Thuy str., Cau Giay table above the average sea level. This means each increment
dist, Hanoi, Vietnam of the sea-level rise will cause the fall in fresh water capac-
2
VNU University of Science, Vietnam National University, ity in the lens by 40 times [2] as the sea-level rise enhances
No. 334 Nguyen Trai str., Thanh Xuan dist., Hanoi, Vietnam the permeability process of saline water into the strata [3].
3
Department of Geotechnics, Faculty of Transportation Some previous studies prove that saline intrusion may
Engineering, University of Architecture Civil Engineering change soil properties. The change can be either negative
and Geodesy, No. 1 Hristo Smirnenski Blvd., 1164 Sofia, or positive, depending on various factors such as saline
Bulgaria

13
Vol.:(0123456789)
Author's personal copy

138 International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150

concentration, types of clay mineral and temperature. For Some geotechnical perspectives of the Red River delta
example, saline intrusion into soft soils will cause the elec- soil in salt-affected conditions were investigated by Truc
trostatic interaction between cation in seawater and anion et al. In their 2012 study, Kirov and Truc pointed out that
in clay, which neutralises the charge of clay. As a result, the under the presence of seawater, the general module and shear
soil quality is degraded. In addition, the dehydration process strength of cohesive soils would decline while their permea-
in soil triggered by salt in the saturated solution may lead to bility would rise [17]. Saline intrusion also causes the larger
the alterations in soil properties [4]. Germanov and Kirov settlement in the subsoil and the longer time of secondary
carried out the one-dimensional consolidation tests apply- consolidation [3]. However, weathered soils show opposite
ing different saturated solutions to different kinds of soil. results. The interaction between the cation in seawater and
The results pointed out that saline water reduced the defor- anion in the diffuse double layer of clay minerals is consid-
mation of the saturated loess while water containing deter- ered as the cause of that change [18, 19]. The changes in soil
gents increased it [5, 6]. The carbonates contained in the properties are also expressed using an X-ray CT scanner,
soil specimens are believed to be the cause of those trends. which shows that the bulk density of soil soaked in seawater
There are reactions between ­Ca2+ in soil and ­Cl− in saline falls by 2.5–4.6% more than in the normal condition [20].
water, which makes the bond in the soil structure become It is very necessary to have detailed studies on the consol-
stronger and improve its geotechnical properties [7]. The idation of Hanoi cohesive soil under conditions of simulated
soils mainly containing smectite–clay minerals are often saline intrusion to understand more about the consolidation
heavily impacted by seawater, which has low capabilities process of the subsoil in the real cases of saline intrusion.
of water retention and liquid limit. By contrast, the soils Particularly, the studied results will play an important role in
primarily containing allophane–clay minerals prove to have the infrastructural development on the saline intrusion land
high water retention and liquid limit under the intrusion of of coastal areas. The method of 2D modelling to analyse
seawater [8]. When tested in both dry and brine-saturated the consolidation of Hanoi cohesive soil in saline condi-
conditions, pure kaolinite is more compressible than smec- tions, therefore, can contribute to dealing with the increasing
tite kaolinite while chlorite and illite mechanical compaction impact of the climate change in Vietnam.
coefficients are somewhere between those of kaolinite and
smectite [9].
There is a dramatic effect of saline intrusion on clay when 2 Materials and Methods
liquid limit, plasticity and shrinkage indices are more than
110%, 70%, and 104% respectively [10]. Permeability of an 2.1 Sample Preparation
aquifer influenced by saline intrusion varies during remedia-
tion process. As freshwater replaces seawater, the perme- The undisturbed soil samples were collected from the deep
ability decreases to 70% [11]. For stiff clays of Ypresian boreholes at the nine sites scattered around Hanoi. Figure 1
and Boom, the salt contained in pore water will enhance shows these sites, including Hoai Duc 1 (HD1), Hoai Duc
oedometric modulus, permeability and consolidation coef- 2 (HD2), Hoan Kiem (HK), Bach Mai (BM), Gia Lam 1
ficient and reduce compression slope and swelling slope as (GL1), Gia Lam 2 (GL2), Gia Lam 3 (GL3), Highway No.5
well as secondary compression coefficient. The effect of salt (D5), and Yen So (YS). Generally, the samples have not been
in pore water can be observed clearly in low-stress range as affected by salt. In other words, they have not been salinized.
physico-chemical effect keeps hydro-mechanical behaviour The samples were taken with the Japanese piston sampler at
in the upper hand [12]. the depth of between 1.5 m and 10.0 m. The medium-state
The role of saline solution is obviously exposed in sab- soil samples such as clay or silty clay, whose undrained shear
kha soils, the soils which are commonly distributed both in strength (Su) varies from 25 to 50 kPa, were chosen to study.
coastal and inland regions in southwest Asia. Sabkha soils The samples were collected, stored and transported from the
consist mostly of loosely cemented sandy silt to silty clay sites to the laboratory in compliance with the procedures and
and are highly compressible [13]. The collapse of sabkha regulations of ASTM standard. In the laboratory, they were
soils induced by permeation with saltwater is bigger than experimented to figure out their geo-technical parameters.
that produced by permeation with freshwater, because the To work out the changes that salt may cause to the prop-
concentration of Na + and Cl − ions in seawater is high [14]. erties of soil, especially those of cohesive soil, the artificial
The testing results on clayey soils taken in Al-Nahrawan, seawater was used to simulate saline intrusion process. The
Southern Iraq, which have much in common with Sabkha average water salinity of Vietnam’s East Sea (or Dong Sea)
soils showed that compressibility index (Cc) of fresh water, is recorded to be 33.0 g/L, equal to the salinity Sa = 100%.
half saline water and saline water decreased as salinity When seawater level remains stable, the salinity of inland
increase [15]. This result is well in agreement with the study groundwater is 0.0 g/L, which is equivalent to Sa = 0%. In
of Shariatmadari et al. on soil–bentonite mixtures [16]. the laboratory, the saline intrusion process was imitated by

13
Author's personal copy
International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150 139

Fig. 1  The studied sites in Hanoi area

the saturating soil samples with artificial saltwater at the four specimen is transmitted on to the upper half to occupy the
different ratios of 0.0, 9.9, 19.8, 33.0 g/L, equivalent to 0, 30, air place in the pore space in the soil. This is to simulate
60, 100% salinity of seawater, respectively. The artificial sea- the natural saline intrusion in the field. Specimens are par-
water is the solution containing pure water and salt (sodium tially expected to be naturally saturated with the capillary
chloride, NaCl). The approximate content and fundamental mechanisms.
chemical component of salt used in artificial seawater are After the capillary duration, specimens are moved to
NaCl ≥ 92%, ­SO42− ≤ 2.7%, ­Mg2+ ≤ 1.3%, ­Ca2+ ≤ 0.65%. pressure saturation. This phase is conducted on the one-
The soil samples were saturated with a two-phase process, dimensional consolidation apparatus of Oedometer. The
capillary and pressure saturation. Each phase lasts at least 5 hydrostatic head from saline water in standpipe tube, which
days to guarantee the full saline intrusion into the samples. is attached on the Oedometer equipment, creates the pres-
Firstly, the saturation process is carried out with the capil- sure on the specimen. The saline water column height in the
lary phase. The studied soil specimens are put into the con- tube is restricted at 10 cm above the upper part of the speci-
solidation rings. Two faces of specimen are covered by the men surface. This is to ensure the head would not affect the
filter papers and then two porous stones areattached to the micro-structure of the specimen. The saltwater in the stand-
outermost part. The sets of specimen are carefully put into pipe tube is in contact with the soil from the lower porous
the water containers. Each specimen set is laid in one con- stone to release gas and pore water in the void out. Loading
tainer corresponding to the saturated solutions of 0.0, 9.9, is placed on the upper part but it only touches the surface
19.8, and 33.0 g/L. Those solutions are poured into the con- of the porous stone to prevent the soil from expanding. As
tainers and the specimen is marked in correspondence with the saline water appearing on the specimen surface, the soil
the salinity. The saline solution is kept in half at the height is considered to be fully saturated by the testing solution.
of the specimen. A 500 kPa loading is directly laid on the As soon as the saturation process completed, the labora-
upper part of the porous stone to prevent the soil specimen tory experiments including grain size distribution, organic
from expansion. The saline solution in the half-submerged matter content, clay mineral composition, bulk density, and

13
Author's personal copy

140 International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150

one-dimensional consolidation are conducted on all the salt- coefficient is suitable for determining the coefficient of the
affected specimens. The experimental results are the basis permeability of the studied soils. It is the appropriate input
for analysing the 2D consolidation model of salt-affected parameter for modelling analysis. However, only the coef-
soils. ficient of permeability of the soils in the sites of GL2 and
HD1 was indirectly determined.
2.2 Methods of Study
k
Cv =
mv × 𝜌w (1)
2.2.1 Soil Properties
where k is the coefficient of permeability or hydraulic con-
Many experiments on the cohesive soil in Hanoi area were ductivities, ρw is the water density, and mv is the coefficient
carried out in the laboratory. The experimental results in of volume compressibility that is defined from the consoli-
the laboratory are the important input data for 2D consoli- dation test data.
dation analysis. The determination of soil particle size was Deformation modulus is an important parameter for
conducted in accordance with the Standard Test Method of modelling. It is controlled by the level of stress in soil. In
ASTM D 422. The particle size was analysed with hydrom- this study, the confined modulus, Eoed, is estimated from the
eter and laser particle size analyser. The organic matter pressure versus void ratio curve. The determination of Eoed
content of the studied soils was determined in accordance is expressed in Eq. (2).
with ASTM D2974–14. Meanwhile, the determination of
𝜎 2 − 𝜎1
bulk density and dry bulk density of soil specimens followed Eoed = (1 + e0 ) (2)
e1 − e2
Standard Test Method of ASTM D7263–09.
One-dimensional compression test is aimed to determine where eo, e1, and e2 are the initial void ratio, void ratio cor-
the consolidation indices of salt-affected soils, such as coef- responding to pressure stages σ1 and σ2 respectively.
ficient of consolidation, Cv, compressibility index, Cc, and The shear strength parameters of c and φ are also neces-
oedometer modulus, Eoed, which were used for assessment sary in 2D consolidation analysis. Due to the difficulty in
of soil properties and 2D analysis model. The test was per- determining the shear strength parameters of salt-affected
formed in accordance with ASTM D2435 standard. Each soils in the laboratory, the direct shear test was just applied
soil specimen was separately compressed in one compressive to the soils in GL2 and HD1 only. It means that only c and
box at the pressure stages of 25, 50, 100, 200, and 400 kPa. φ of GL2 and HD1’s soils were determined.
Each pressure stage was maintained at the constant load for
24 h. The test ended after a 6-day period.
The mineral composition of the studied soil was analysed 2.2.3 2D Consolidation Analysis
by X-ray diffraction. This has been a very common method
and introduced in many popular textbooks. Transmission In this study, the consolidation analysis of Hanoi cohesive
Electron Microscopic (TEM) method was also used in this soil under an assumed embankment was conducted to com-
study. The analysis with TEM aimed to determine the resil- prehend how saline intrusion affects the deformation process
ience of clay minerals after salinization, which is related to of the subsoil in in situ conditions. For this purpose, the
the swelling, deformation, and consolidation of the cohesive consolidation process of the assumed embankment on the
soils. This is a microscopy technique that the electron beam saline subsoil was analysed using a numerical simulation
is moved through the soil specimen to create the image of with the finite element method of Plaxis 2D program. The
particles. The soil specimen is usually an extremely thin simulation used the following assumptions:
layer. It does not exceed 100 nm in thickness. TEM images
are created by the interaction of the soil particles and elec- 1. The soil is a two-phase system. The solid phase is the
trons when the beam is moved through the particles. After- skeleton of the soil particles. The liquid phase is the
ward, the images are magnified and focused on the imaging water in the pore of soil mass. The pore water is incom-
equipment such as a fluorescent screen, a film layer, or a pressible in the fully saturated condition. If pore water
sensor. flow is unsaturated, the second phase is a compressible
mixture of air and water.
2.2.2 Determination of Additional Parameters 2. It is involved in the principle of the effective stresses of
for Modelling Terzaghi;
3. The law of Hooke is suitable for the constitutive model
To a certain extent, the hydraulic conductivity of the cohe- of the skeleton;
sive soils can be indirectly defined from the coefficient 4. The equilibrium equations meet the conditions of the
of consolidation. Equation (1) that defines consolidation stresses in soil mass;

13
Author's personal copy
International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150 141

5. Assuming the small strain theory meets the compatible 3 Results


deformation condition;
6. Darcy’s law can apply to the pore water flow; 3.1 Characteristics of Cohesive Soils in Hanoi Area
7. The reduction of volume of a soil element is equal to
the water outflowing from that volume; this obeys the 3.1.1 Particle Size
continuity principle;
8. The cohesive soil parameters such as Young’s modulus, The particle size analysis of Hanoi cohesive soils is to deter-
coefficient of Poisson, and coefficient of permeability mine soil type and grain grade. Because grain size is almost
are constant during the consolidation process; not affected by salt although the soil specimen may undergo
9. The discretization of the soil domain is conducted the flocculation process, investigating the particle size of
through triangular 15-node finite elements. soils in the saline conditions is unnecessary. The analyti-
cal result showed that the studied soils belong to clay and
The functions of settlement versus time and pore water silty clay. These are the soils containing clay minerals and
pressure versus time are considered as the horizontal exposing the sensitivity of geotechnical properties in the
displacement of the cohesive subsoil under the assumed saline conditions.
embankment and the ending time of consolidation, t = t100. To obtain the accurate result of particle size, the hydrom-
The simulation uses the basic equations of the linear eter and the laser diffraction methods were applied to analyse
elastic coupled with the consolidation analysis of cohesive the particle size. The modern method of laser analyser pro-
soil at a plane strain condition. Using the virtual work vides more explicit and reliable data. In fact, the two meth-
principle is to obtain the finite element equations for the ods both show the qualified results of this research, although
coupled consolidation analysis. the results of laser diffraction method seem to be lower with
The solutions with 2D Plaxis program are horizontal the clay particle amount in comparison with that of the
displacement, vertical displacement (settlement), time of hydrometer techniques [21]. Figure 2 shows finer percent
consolidation, and pore water pressure versus time. The
quantitative change of horizontal displacement, settlement,
and time of consolidation are determined by the following
formulas:
ux (Sa ) − ux (Sa = 0)
Δux,max = (3)
ux (Sa = 0)

uy (Sa ) − uy (Sa = 0)
Δuy,max = (4)
uy (Sa = 0)

t100 (Sa ) − t100 (Sa = 0)


Δt100 = (5)
t100 (Sa = 0)

where Δux,max, Δuy,max, and Δt100 are the quantitative change


of maximum horizontal displacement, maximum settlement,
and ending time of consolidation, respectively. ux (Sa), uy
(Sa), and t100 (Sa) are horizontal displacement, settlement,
and ending time of consolidation at a given value of salin-
ity Sa. ux (Sa = 0), uy (Sa = 0), and t100 (Sa = 0) are horizontal
displacement, settlement, and ending time of consolidation
at Sa = 0.0 g/L.

Fig. 2  Grain size distribution of Hanoi cohesive soils with hydrom-


eter method (1), and laser particle size analyser method (2)

13
Author's personal copy

142 International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150

ranging from 1.0 mm up to 9 × 10− 5 mm of the investigated no change in the mineral composition of the soil before and
soils. The accumulated curves express that the amount of after salinization (Fig. 3).
0.074 mm grain size is over 50%. These soils are grouped
into silts and clays and signed C, or M in the Unified Soil 3.1.4 Water Content and Bulk Density, ρ
Classification System (USCS).
• Water content, W: water content was studied for the
specimens saturated with saline solution. The obtained
3.1.2 Organic Matter Content
results describing the changing trend in value before and
after receiving salt were shown in Table 1. Generally, the
The organic matter content of the salt-affected soils was just
studied for non-saline soils (Sa = 0.0 g/l) because it does
not rely on the appearance of salt in the soils. The obtained
result of organic matter and the ash content of the investi-
gated soil specimens is drawn after 6 h igniting at the fur-
nace temperature of 455 ± 10 °C. Accordingly, the average
amount of organic matter in the soils is 9.11%. For example,
those in GL2, YS and D5 sites are 7.41%, 9.98%, and 9.95%,
respectively.
It can be concluded from the acquired results that the con-
tent of the organic matter in the soils takes up a noticeable
percentage. In the salt-affected conditions, the remarkable
existence of the content of organic matter in the soils may
impact the geotechnical properties of the soil, particularly
their secondary consolidation behaviours.
The results of a scientific research work on the quaternary
soil revealed that the organic matter content in these soils
was quite low, about 1–3% [22]. Thus, in comparison with
the other quaternary soils, the cohesive soils in Hanoi have
the high organic matter content of around 9%.

3.1.3 Clay Mineral Composition

The result of the soil mineral analysis showed that the pre-
dominated clay mineral in the cohesive soils in Hanoi area
is illite and chlorite, occupying from 15 to 20%, followed by
kaolinite (14–21%) and montmorillonite accounts for only
3–7%. Quartz minerals represent from 45 to 55%. Feldspar
accounts for 5–8%, followed by goethite. These character-
istics are typical of the soils originated from shallow sea,
alluvial, or lacustrine sediments [17].
Some typical clay samples in Hanoi area were also ana-
lysed by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) for the
two non-saline and complete saline samples with the salt
concentrations mentioned above. The analysis result with
TEM also indicates that there is a flocculation of clay parti-
cles in the saline samples. The higher the salt concentration,
the stronger the flocculation becomes.
The content of the soil specimens determined by TEM
analysis shows that the muscovite and illite particles are
thick, large sized plates while the montmorillonite particles
are thinner and smaller in size. The clay particles, especially
the montmorillonite mineral in the saline specimens, tend Fig. 3  TEM image of soil specimens saturated with four salt concen-
to clump together. The analysis also showed that there was trations in YS and D5 sites

13
Author's personal copy
International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150 143

Table 1  Water content and bulk density of Hanoi cohesive soils at four salt concentrations
Sign Water content (W, %) Bulk density (ρ, g/cm3)
Sa = 0.0 Sa = 9.9 Sa = 19.8 Sa = 33.0 Sa = 0.0 Sa = 9.9 Sa = 19.8 Sa = 33.0

HD1 39.15 38.25 38.37 38.46 1.820 1.812 1.795 1.808


HD2 63.62 58.48 60.12 60.13 1.45 1.47 1.46 1.46
HK 41.82 40.74 40.28 40.50 1.770 1.747 1.782 1.760
BM 47.92 46.99 46.64 46.85 1.750 1.750 1.743 1.756
GL1 39.05 36.78 37.37 37.98 1.821 1.814 1.820 1.818
GL2 38.40 36.50 37.22 37.76 1.920 1.915 1.919 1.910
GL3 35.91 35.42 35.18 35.38 1.998 1.981 1.993 1.984
D5 59.86 58.81 59.04 59.24 1.643 1.616 1.634 1.614
YS 39.45 38.32 40.72 41.98 1.731 1.730 1.726 1.734

water content of soil declined when salt concentration


increased. When the soil was in the nature state, the water
content reached the highest value. On the contrary, the
water content was at the lowest value when the soil was
saturated with the highest salt concentration solution.
• Bulk density, ρ: The experiment to determine the bulk
density of the salt-affected soils indicated that the volume
of the soil specimens remained stable. Meanwhile, the
presence of salt made the water content reduce. It means
that the bulk density of the soils was changed when the
specimens are saturated with salt water. In fact, although
the decline in the bulk density of these salt-affected soils
was verified, it did not happen in all the studied soils. In
other words, at different salt concentrations, the change
in the bulk density caused by saline intrusion in Hanoi
cohesive soil was unclear.

3.1.5 Void Ratio of Salt‑Affected Cohesive Soils

One-dimensional consolidation test was used to achieve the


settlement of the soil specimens. The void ratio of soil at
each pressure stage was calculated approximately by evalu-
ating the final value of the settlement corresponding to each
of that pressure. Calculating the void ratio for each pressure
stage of a soil specimen saturated with different salt concen-
tration solutions was carefully carried out. Figure 4 shows
the void ratio of Hanoi cohesive soils versus pressure at four
salt concentrations. It can realize that when the amount of
salt in the soil increased, the void ratio increased. This can
be compared with the soil at the same compressive pressure
stage, but at different salinity levels. The change in void
ratio will result in the changes in other geotechnical indices.

3.2 Consolidation Indices of Salt‑Affected Soils

3.2.1 Coefficient of Consolidation, Cv

Fig. 4  Void ratio of Hanoi cohesive soils versus pressure at four salt


Using the deformation data of soil specimens or the thick-
concentrations
ness changes recorded during one of the load stages in the

13
Author's personal copy

144 International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150

one-dimensional consolidation test, one can evaluate the value at the salinities of 0.0 and 33.0 g/L. The quantita-
coefficient of consolidation, Cv. The procedure to establish tive change of compressibility index is given in Fig. 6. The
Cv for a pressure stage involves plotting the changes of the compressibility index shows the largest change in the soils
soil specimen height against a function of time and then fit- at the four sites BM, GL1, GL2, and YS (from approx 20
ting to this the theoretical Tv versus Uav curve. Many meth- to 29%). Meanwhile, the soil at D5 gets the smallest change
ods can be taken to define Cv. In this study, the Square Root (5.8%). The change in compressibility index of YS is the
of Time method by of Taylor is suitable for estimating Cv of most noticeable while that of D5 is insignificant.
Hanoi cohesive soils saturated with different salt concentra-
tions. Table 2 describes the obtained results of coefficient of 3.3 2D Consolidation Analysis
consolidation at pressure stage 100–200 kPa of the investi-
gated soils. 3.3.1 Geotechnical Aspect of Embankment Subsoil
The calculation of Cv variation at different salinity lev-
els was also conducted to define the quantitative change. To analyse the consolidation of the cohesive soil in the salt-
The result of the quantitative change analysis of Cv in the affected conditions, the numerical model using finite ele-
saline soil samples compared with that at the original time is ment method (FEM) for an assumed embankment is taken
described in Fig. 5. It can be seen from this figure that when into account. Assuming that the 5-m-high embankment is
salt concentration increases, there is a significant decline in
Cv. The coefficient of consolidation of the soil specimens
at three places HD2, BM, D5 among nine sites shows the
most substantial decrease at the salinity level between Sa
= 0.0 and Sa = 33.0. The changes are at the level of 41 to
50%. The decrease in the coefficient of consolidation of the
remaining soil specimens fluctuates between 22 and 35%.
The other changes of Cv in comparison with three couples,
i.e. Sa = 9.9, Sa = 19.8, and Sa = 33.0 to Sa = 0.0, are also
given in this figure. In general, the coefficient of consolida-
tion has a reciprocal relation with the salt concentration in
the investigated soils.

3.2.2 Compressibility Index, Cc

The relation between C ­ c and the salinities was built by deter-


mining the compressibility index of the salt-affected soils.
Table 3 shows the obtained results of the experiment. One
can realize the increase in compressibility index over the
salinities of 0.0 to 9.9, 19.8, and 33.0 g/L. The largest change
of compressibility index is exposed in comparison with its Fig. 5  Quantitative change of Cv from the baseline

Table 2  Consolidation coefficient of Hanoi cohesive soils at four salt Table 3  Compressibility index of Hanoi cohesive soils at four salt
concentrations concentrations
Site Coef. of consolidation Cv ­(cm2/s) over salinity (g/L) Site Compressibility index Cc over salinity (g/L)
Sa = 0.0 Sa = 9.9 Sa = 19.8 Sa = 33.0 Sa = 0.0 Sa = 9.9 Sa = 19.8 Sa = 33.0

HD1 0.0025 0.0022 0.0021 0.0019 HD1 0.179 0.189 0.199 0.209
HD2 0.0063 0.0044 0.0035 0.0025 HD2 0.396 0.425 0.443 0.458
HK 0.0041 0.0037 0.0032 0.0027 HK 0.208 0.216 0.227 0.234
BM 0.0044 0.0035 0.0029 0.0026 BM 0.141 0.152 0.161 0.175
GL1 0.0063 0.0057 0.0052 0.0049 GL1 0.189 0.200 0.218 0.238
GL2 0.00057 0.00050 0.00048 0.00044 GL2 0.128 0.135 0.143 0.154
GL3 0.0034 0.0028 0.0025 0.0023 GL3 0.120 0.126 0.131 0.138
D5 0.0018 0.0016 0.0011 0.0009 D5 0.439 0.445 0.455 0.464
YS 0.000523 0.000451 0.000393 0.00037 YS 0.199 0.204 0.236 0.257

13
Author's personal copy
International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150 145

Table 4  Parameters of cohesive soil at HD1 used in 2D consolidation


analysis
Param- Dimen- Silty clay (HD1)
eter sion
Sa = 0.0 g/L Sa = 9.9 g/L Sa = 19.8 g/L Sa = 33.0 g/L

γ kN/m3 18.20 18.12 17.95 18.08


φ deg 12.42 11.97 11.53 10.93
c kPa 14.72 13.92 13.13 12.07
Eoed kPa 3717 3515 3390 3234
ν – 0.35 0.35 0.35 0.35
k × 10− 5 m/day 5.79 5.31 5.20 4.99

Table 5  Parameters of cohesive soil at GL2 used in 2D consolidation


analysis
Param- Dimen- Clay (GL2)
eter sion
Sa = 0.0 g/L Sa = 9.9 g/L Sa = 19.8 g/L Sa = 33.0 g/L
Fig. 6  Quantitative change of Cc from the baseline
γ kN/m3 19.20 19.15 19.19 19.10
φ deg 3.50 3.31 3.12 2.87
c kPa 32.47 31.20 29.94 28.25
Eoed kPa 4742 4495 4256 3992
ν – 0.42 0.42 0.42 0.42
k × 10− 5 m/day 1.01 0.950 0.959 0.942

3.3.2 Consolidation Analysis Models

Fig. 7  Soil layers and boundary conditions of the assumed embank- In the above figure, the scheme of embankment model
ment
including the boundary conditions of bottom layer is given.
During the consolidation process, the pore water pressure
situated on the subsoil. Figure 7 shows the soil layers and of this layer is uw = 0, the horizontal displacement is ux
boundary conditions of the numerical 2D consolidation = 0, and the vertical displacement is uy = 0. The vertical
model, including the points of interest A and B for the anal- boundaries of the subsoil model are horizontally fixed and
ysis. The embankment is built by a crushed material with impermeable. It means uw ≠ 0, ux = 0 and uy ≠ 0. Figure 8 is
the parameters of γ = 20 kN/m3, E = 85 MPa, φ = 45°, and the triangular 15-node finite element used for discretization
c = 5 kPa. The subsoil includes three layers. The top layer is of the soil domain.
sand. The middle layer of 9.0 m thick is cohesive soil. The Figures 9, 10, and 11 show the graphic results of max
base is rigid and permeable. The embankment is given as a settlement, max horizontal displacement, and initial pore
distributed load applied at time t = t0 (the beginning of the water pressure corresponding to the four salt concentra-
consolidation). The pore pressure–time and settlement–time tions, i.e. Sa = 0.0, 9.9, 19.8, and 33.0 g/L, of HD1 subsoil.
functions are considered as the horizontal displacement of Those are the same for clay of the subsoil in GL2 site and
the subsoil, the time finishing consolidation (or 100% degree not necessary to show all herein.
of consolidation) is assigned to t = t100. The consolidation analysis results obtained with FEM for
The two cases of the cohesive soil, i.e. silty clay in HD1 the assumed embankment on the subsoil to be intruded by
and clay in GL2, are involved in the analysis. Tables 4 and the four salt concentration, i.e. Sa = 0.0, 9.9, 19.8, 33.0 g/L,
5 show the soil parameters of the compressible layer in each are given in Figs. 12, 13 and Tables 6 and 7. It can be seen
case. Both cases are assumed that the subsoil is saturated by that these tables show the results of the maximum vertical
four salt concentrations, i.e. Sa = 0.0; 9.9; 19.8; and 33.0 g/L. displacement (or maximum settlement, uy,max); the quantita-
tive change of the maximum settlement, Δuy,max; the maxi-
mum horizontal displacement of the subsoil, ux,max; the quan-
titative change of the maximum horizontal displacement of

13
Author's personal copy

146 International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150

to the maximum settlement. Δux,max, Δuy,max, and Δt100 are


determined from the baseline in accordance with those val-
ues at Sa = 0.0 g/L as given in Eqs. (3), (4), and (5).
The obtained results of consolidation analysis with FEM
lead to the following comments.
The vertical and horizontal displacements of the subsoil
are proportional to the salinity in the soil. The higher the
Fig. 8  Finite element mesh model of embankment subsoil
salinity of soil, the larger the displacements of subsoil get.
The subsoil has the largest settlement when the consoli-
the subsoil, Δux,max; the ending time of consolidation, t100; dation process is completed, i.e. the time of consolidation
and the quantitative change of the ending time of consolida- t = t100. The largest horizontal displacement occurs at the
tion, Δt100. The beginning time of consolidation, time t = t0, beginning of the consolidation, i.e. the time of consolida-
is corresponding to maximum horizontal displacement. The tion t = t0.
ending time of consolidation, time t = t100, is corresponding

Fig. 9  Maximum settlement of HD1 subsoil at t = t100; a Sa = 0.0 g/L, b Sa = 9.9 g/L, c Sa = 19.8 g/L, and d Sa = 33.0 g/L

Fig. 10  Maximum horizontal displacement of HD1 subsoil at t = t0; a Sa = 0.0 g/L, b Sa = 9.9 g/L, c Sa = 9.8 g/L, and d Sa = 33.0 g/L

13
Author's personal copy
International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150 147

Fig. 11  Initial pore water pressure of HD1 subsoil at t = t0; a Sa = 0.0 g/L, b Sa = 9.9 g/L, c Sa = 19.8 g/L, and d Sa = 33.0 g/L

Fig. 13  Pore pressure versus time curves of silty clay—HD1 site (a),


Fig. 12  Settlement versus time curves of silty clay—HD1 site (a),
and clay—GL2 site (b) at point B of the assumed embankment; 1 Sa
and clay—GL2 site (b) at point A of the assumed embankment; 1 Sa
= 0.0, 2 Sa = 9.9, 3 Sa = 19.8, and 4 Sa = 33.0 g/L
= 0.0, 2 Sa = 9.9, 3 Sa = 19.8, and 4 Sa = 33.0 g/L

The salinity of the soil influences remarkably the settle- of GL2 site increases up to 18.7%. The maximum value of
ment of the silty clay subsoil in HD1 and the clay subsoil in settlement is determined at the point A on the finite element
GL2 site. As the salinity increases from 0.0 to 33.0 g/L, the mesh of the assumed embankment. The maximum settle-
settlement value in HD1 rises by 14.8%. Meanwhile, that ment point of the embankment subsoil in HD1 site tends to

13
Author's personal copy

148 International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150

Table 6  The results from 2D consolidation analysis of saline cohesive soil in HD1 site
Sa (g/L) t = t0 t = t100
ux,max (cm) uy,max (cm) t100 (day) Δt100 (%) ux,max (cm) Δux,max (%) uy,max (cm) Δuy,max (%)

0.0 9.06 − 8.32 2251 – 6.16 – − 26.79 –


9.9 9.55 − 8.76 2733 21.41 6.51 5.68 − 28.30 5.64
19.8 9.88 − 9.05 2876 27.77 6.75 9.58 − 29.33 9.48
33.0 10.32 − 9.45 3076 36.65 7.07 14.77 − 30.75 14.78

Table 7  The results from 2D consolidation analysis of saline cohesive soil in GL2 site
Sa (g/L) t = t0 t = t100
ux,max (cm) uy,max (cm) t100 (day) Δt100 (%) ux,max (cm) Δux,max (%) uy,max (cm) Δuy,max (%)

0.0 11.68 − 10.66 10,142 – 9.57 – − 24.63 –


9.9 12.28 − 11.20 12,073 19.04 10.08 5.33 − 25.97 5.44
19.8 12.93 − 11.78 12,384 22.11 10.62 10.97 − 27.41 11.29
33.0 13.73 − 12.50 13,319 31.32 11.28 17.87 − 29.23 18.68

move towards the edges. This trend is clearer when the salt conditions is the cause of the changes in settlement, hori-
concentration in the subsoil is higher. zontal displacement, and pore water pressure over time in
The horizontal displacement gets maximum at the high- 2D consolidation analysis model. The discussion will clarify
est salinity, reaching 13.90% in HD1 and 17.55% in GL2 the above relations to explain the change of soil properties.
from the baseline. The maximum horizontal displacement The chemical reactions happen when soil contains dis-
zones are located under the edges of the embankment. Those solved salt. The dehydrated reactions of newly generated
zones are no deeper than half of the thickness of the cohe- salt occur, which leads to the increase in the pH degree of
sive soil layer. Especially, at the salinity of Sa = 33.0 g/L, soil solution. The gelatinized substances in the viscous state
the horizontal displacements at GL2 increase by 13.73 cm. are also the product of those reactions. As saltwater is kept
This result is a significant indicator of the soil state in the supplying, there will be an increase in the content of dis-
trend toward failure. solved salt in the soil solution. This makes the interactive
The initial excess pore pressure is uniformly distributed in processes between the gelatinized substance and the clay
the space of the cohesive soil layer. The influence of salinity particles continue. The colloidal substance is considered as
on the initial excess pore water pressure is negligible. Its a lubrication factor. Once the chemical reactions continue,
difference before and after the presence of saline solutions the new gelatinized substance continues to be born. The tex-
is not over 3%, which shows up in the subsoil of HD1 site. ture of the old gelatinized substance is destroyed due to the
The ending time of the primary consolidation, t100, is also redundancy of positively charged ions in the saline solution.
longer with an increase in salinity. In other words, the saline The positively charged ions in the soil solution are supplied
intrusion into the subsoil retards the process of consolida- progressively. The remarkable neutralization of negatively
tion. This regards to soil properties are changed in saline charged ions degrades the electrical static force of adherence
medium. The salinity of the subsoil, which increases from among clay particles. Therefore, the cohesive property of
0.0 to 33.0 g/L, results in the ending time of consolidation, soil is attenuated. These processes occur at a certain level
t100, increasing over 30% longer in all the analyses. that the negatively charged ions are almost neutralized and
positively charged ions become excessive. Then, the crys-
tallization occurs and the crystals adhesive to clay particles
4 Discussion are newly generated. The pH degree of soil solution reaches
over 9.0, which leads to the dispersion of soil solution. Soil
The properties of the studied soils were changed as salt texture is broken and it is so-called unstructured. In other
appeared. The change is attributed to the physico-chemical words, the soil becomes degraded. This is one of the causes
interactions occurring in the diffuse double layer of clay of the changes in the soil properties given above [23].
particle and the chemical reactions among clay minerals in The cohesive soil in Hanoi has a significant amount of
the soil with dissolved salt in the saturated solution. The organic matter. The role of organic matter content with
change of geotechnical parameters of soil in the salt-affected respect to salt-affected soil is a question. There have not been

13
Author's personal copy
International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150 149

any in-depth studies till now, especially with the cohesive of the soils in HD1 and GL2 sites, which were used in 2D
soil in Hanoi, on the relationship of soil, salt, and organic consolidation analysis as the input data of the model, are
matter. Almost the previous studies agree that the organic also changed in the corresponding saline conditions. Once
matter has a definite influence on the consolidation process, the input data for modelling vary with the salt concentra-
particularly the secondary consolidation. This makes the tions in the saline solution, the analysis results with FEM are
soil have a larger deformation, a longer time of consolida- also changed. The analysis with FEM, which is based on 2D
tion, and a greater settlement [18]. In the studied soils, the Plaxis program, gave the results of the graphic, plot, and the
organic matter content occupies from 7.4 to 9.9%. In the quantitative results of settlement, horizontal displacement
saline intrusion media, the significant presence of organic and pore water pressure over time accurately and visually.
matter content may affect the geotechnical properties of the
studied soils, which include the secondary consolidation.
This paper focuses on the primary consolidation rather than 5 Conclusions
the secondary one. However, the obtained result is not suf-
ficient to evaluate the organic matter’s role with the salt- This study investigated the properties of Hanoi cohesive soil
affected soil. This question needs to be investigated in other in the saline intrusion conditions in the laboratory and 2D
subsequent studies. consolidation analysis with an assumed embankment. The
In the mineralogical aspects, the previous studies of the study results bring about the following conclusions:
authors show that illite is the predominated clay mineral
in Hanoi cohesive soil. The subsequent ones are kaolinite 1. The studied soils with the grain size passing 0.074 mm
and chlorite. Montmorillonite is an expandable clay min- sieve are over 50% and classified into group C or M in
eral, which may enlarge the surface area and cation exchange the Unified Soil Classification System (USCS). They are
capacity (CEC) intensively, but it appears in a small rate, treated by saline solution with 4 salt concentrations, i.e.
but insignificant in some studied sites. The inert minerals 0.0, 9.9, 19.8 and 33.0 g/L, prior to laboratory experi-
in the soil with an important amount are quartz and goe- ments. In Hanoi cohesive soil, the organic matter con-
thite. They are not involved in chemical reactions in the soil tent is quite high, ranging from 7.4 to 9.9%. Illite and
[17]. The role of kaolinite with respect to the change of soil chlorite are the clay minerals dominated in the soils. The
properties is unclear. It is not swollen in normal media [24]. expandable clay mineral of montmorillonite occupies
The obtained results of TEM analysis did not recognize the around 3 to 7% or less. The soluble salts in the saturated
change in clay mineral composition. However, the mixed- solution do not cause the change in clay mineral com-
layer clay mineral was also found in the soils. This is in position of the studied soils. However, the presence of
good agreement with previous studies of Career et al. [25]. illite, mixed-layer clay mineral and swelling mineral of
The predominance of illite in the studied soil facilitates the montmorillonite significantly diversified the soil proper-
physico-chemical interaction in the diffuse double layer of ties in the saline media.
the colloid. It contributes to the change in soil properties in 2. The obtained results of the basic geotechnical experi-
the saline intrusion media [22]. ments showed that water content of Hanoi cohesive soils
The previous studies showed that type of clay minerals decreases as the salt concentration increases. Mean-
affects the soil properties in the salt-affected conditions [8, while, the bulk density is unclearly changed in the same
26, 27]. The soils predominated by clay minerals of allo- testing conditions. In the one-dimensional consolida-
phane group, weathering-originated clay minerals like kao- tion test, the coefficient of consolidation, Cv, decreases,
linite, or carbonate-related minerals (e.g. C ­ a2+ and M
­ g2+) respectively, with the salinities. Its reduction remains at
always express better properties in the saline media. Con- the level of 22 to 50% in the soil of the whole studied
versely, the soils that are predominated by clay minerals of sites when salinities grow up to 33.0 g/L. The compress-
montmorillonite, illite, and chlorite are usually degraded in ibility index, Cc, increases linearly and proportionally to
the similar saline media [5, 7, 28]. The studied soils in Hanoi the salinities. That growth of Cc keeps at 29.2% when
area has expanded the clay mineral of montmorillonite. the soil is saturated with the highest salt concentration
The chemical interaction between the clay minerals in solution.
the studied soils and the salts in the saturated solution along 3. The modelling of 2D consolidation analysis for an
with the presence of expandable clay minerals and mixed- assumed embankment on the saline subsoil is conducted
layer clay minerals is considered as the cause of the changes with finite element method on the basis of the Plaxis
in soil properties. In other words, the process of saline intru- program. The analytical results showed that vertical dis-
sion results in the coefficient of consolidation decrease with placement or settlement of the embankment in HD1 site
salinity. Meanwhile, the compressibility index increases remains at 14.8% and that of GL2 site is 18.7% when the
proportionally with salinity. Similarly, the other properties salinity rises from 0.0 to 33.0 g/L. The horizontal dis-

13
Author's personal copy

150 International Journal of Civil Engineering (2020) 18:137–150

placement of the embankment reaches 13.90% in HD1 a laboratory column study. J Hydrol 376(3):557–566. https​://doi.
site and 17.55% in GL2 site from the baseline. Particu- org/10.1016/j.jhydr​ol.2009.07.067
12. Nguyen XP, Cui YJ, Tang AM, Deng YF, Li XL, Wouters L
larly, the horizontal displacement in GL2 increases by (2013) Effects of pore water chemical composition on the hydro-
13.73 cm and in the trend toward failure as the salinity mechanical behavior of natural stiff clays. Eng Geol 166:52–64.
gets maximum. Meanwhile, salinity has an insignificant https​://doi.org/10.1016/j.engge​o.2013.08.009
impact on the initial excess pore water pressure. The 13. Al-Shamrani MA, Dhowian AW (1997) Preloading for reduction
of compressibility characteristics of sabkha soil profiles. Eng Geol
time at the primary consolidation completion, t100, in 2D 48(1–2):19–41. https​://doi.org/10.1016/S0013​-7952(97)81912​-6
models is longer as the saturated solution is saltier. The 14. Azam S (2000) Collapse and compressibility behavior of arid cal-
prolongation of primary consolidation time gets over careous soil formations. Bull Eng Geol Environ 59(3):211–217.
30% if the subsoil is at the saltiest, i.e. 33.0 g/L. The https​://doi.org/10.1007/s1006​40000​060
15. Al-Obaidi A, Ihssan A, Allawi H (2018) Studying of the combined
above changes illustrate the degradation of soils in the salts effect on the engineering properties of clayey soil. In: The
salt-affected conditions. 3rd international conference on buildings, construction and envi-
ronmental engineering, BCEE3-2017, MATEC Web Conference,
Vol 162, https​://doi.org/10.1051/matec​conf/20181​62010​11
Acknowledgements  This research was funded by the Vietnam National 16. Shariatmadari N, Salami M, Fard MK (2011) Effect of inorganic
Foundation for Science and Technology Development (NAFOSTED) salt solutions on some geotechnical properties of soil–bentonite
under Grant Number 105.08-2014.45. mixtures as barriers. Int J Civil Eng 2:9
17. Kirov BL, Truc NN (2012) A study on the relationship between
geotechnical properties and clay mineral composition of Hanoi
soft soils in saline media. Int J Civil Eng 10(2):87–92
18. Truc NN (2017) Consolidation properties of cohesive soils
References in the Red river delta in salt-affected conditions. In: The 17th
international multidisciplinary scientific geoconference, Albena,
1. Ky HN (1978) Main features of Quaternary geology in the Bac Bulgaria, Issue 12, Vol 17, pp 143–150. https​://doi.org/10.5593/
Bo plain: Geological map, Hanoi Geological Mapping Division, sgem2​017/12/S02.019
No. 37, 14–22 (in Vietnamese) 19. Truc NN, Kirov B (2014) Hanoi soft soils in salt—affected media,
2. Gornitz V (1991) Global coastal hazards from future sea level rise. In: Yoo C, Kim P, Ban (eds.) The 8th international symposium on
Palaeogeogr Palaeoclimatol Palaeoecol 89:379–398 geotechnical aspects of underground construction in soft ground,
3. Truc NN, Kirov B (2013) Secondary consolidation of Hanoi soft TC204 ISSMGE, IS-SEOUL, Korea
soil in saline saturated media related to climate change induced 20. Toan DT, Truc NN (2010) The impact of seawater on soil proper-
sealevel rise. Annual of the University of Architecture Civil Engi- ties in the Red River Delta. J Sci Technol Vietnam 48(1):215–223
neering abd Geodesy No 4, vol 45, pp 2011–2013 (in Vietnamese)
4. Mihova LA, Truc NN (2015) Study of deformation of salt-affected 21. Linda PM, Bittelli P, Pisa R (2006) Laser diffraction, transmission
soils by FEM, a case study of soft soil in the Red River delta, electron microscopy and image analysis to evaluate a bimodal
Vietnam, In: Winter MG, Smith DM, Eldred PJL, Toll DG (Eds.), Gaussian model for particle size distribution in soils. Geoderma
The 16th european conference on soil mechanics and geotechni- 135:118–132. https​://doi.org/10.1016/j.geode​rma.2005.11.009
cal engineering, Scotland, Publishing ICE, Edinburgh. https:​ //doi. 22. Nu NT (2014) The geological characteristics of the clayey soft soil
org/10.1680/ecsmg​e.60678​.vol7.634 type ­amQ22–3 distributed in the coastal provinces of the Mekong
5. Germanov TS, Kirov BL (1985) Influence of waste waters on soil Delta for the treatment of road embankment, Doctoral thesis,
consolidation. In: Proceedings of the XIth ICSMFE, Balkema AA, Hanoi University of Mining and Geology, Hanoi, Vietnam, (in
San Francisco, USA, pp 2407–2409 Vietnamese)
6. Kirov BL (1989) Influence of waste waters on soil deforma- 23. Lan TV (2002) Influence of Saline Environment and Saline Intru-
tion. In: Proceedings of XII ICSMFE, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, sion on Stability and Deformation of Foundation of Construc-
pp 1881–1882 tion, Doctoral thesis, Thuy Loi University, Hanoi, Vietnam, (in
7. Gbenga MA, Oluwole AA, Shodolapo OF (2009) Influence of Vietnamese)
calcium sulphate on subsoil cohesion and angle of friction. J Appl 24. Kleven R, Alstad J (1996) Interaction of alkali, alkalineearth and
Sci Res 5(3:297–304 sulphate ions with clay minerals and sedimentary rocks. J Petrol
8. Komine H (2007) Vulnerability of riverbank material by sea- Sci Eng I5:181–200
level rising due to global warming in Japan. In: Proceedings 25. Carretero MI, Pozo M, Sánchez C, García FJ, Medina JA, Bernabé
of the 2nd Malaysia-Japan symposium on Geohazards and JM (2007) Comparison of saponite and montmorillonite behav-
geoenvironmental engineering, City Bayview Hotel, Langkawi, iour during staticand stirring maturation with seawater for pelo-
Malaysia therapy. Appl Clay Sci 1–2(36):161–173
9. Nazmul HM, Knut B, Jens J, Kaare H (2007) Experimental 26. Mitchell JK, Kenichi S (2005) Fundamentals of soil behavior,
mechanical compaction of clay mineral aggregates—changes 3rd edn. Wiley, Hoboken
in physical properties of mudstones during burial. Mar Pet Geol 27. Komine H (2007) Changes of fundamental properties of riverbank
24:289–311. https​://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpe​tgeo.2007.03.006 material by sea-level rising due to global warming. In: Proceed-
10. Yukselen-Aksoy Y, Kaya A, Ören AH (2008) Seawater effect on ings of the 1st international symposyum on Mitigation and adapta-
consistency limits and compressibility characteristics of clays. tion of climate-change-induce natural disasters, Hue city, Vietnam
Eng Geol 102(1–2):54–61. https ​ : //doi.org/10.1016/j.engge​ 28. Eggestad A, Sem H (1976) Stability of excavations improved by
o.2008.07.005 salt diffusion from deep wells. In: Proceedings of the 6th Euro-
11. Zhou J, Zheng X, Flury M, Lin G (2009) Permeability changes pean conference on soil mechanics and foundation engineer-
during remediation of an aquifer affected by seawater intrusion: ing, ISSMFE Austrian National Committee, Vienna, Austria,
pp 211–216

13

You might also like