Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/23473690
CITATIONS READS
9 1,625
5 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Two decades of treatment for Gaucher disease - Emerging challenges View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Maurizio Setti on 14 October 2014.
CASE REPORT
Received: 31 August 2006 / Accepted: 4 June 2007 / Published online: 14 November 2008
Ó Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2008
Erythropoietic protoporphyria (EPP) is an uncommon A 60-year-old man was admitted to our hospital on January
genetic disorder of heme metabolism caused by the defi- 18, 2005, complaining of upper abdominal pain and jaun-
ciency of mitochondrial ferrochelatase, an enzyme that dice of some days’ duration.
catalyzes the chelation of iron to protoporphyrin (PP) [1– On questioning him, the patient reported mild photo-
3]. Skin involvement is the most typical feature of this sensitivity since he was 3 years old, characterized by skin
disease. It is characterized by light-sensitive dermatitis swelling and erithema associated with itching and pruritus
(usually developing during childhood). Erosions on the after sun exposure. These lesions used to remit spontane-
face, healing with scars, or waxy thickening of the skin of ously with no medications and without leaving any
the nose and knuckles may ensue [4–6]. permanent modification of the skin. Although these epi-
Hepatic dysfunction is the most serious and potentially sodes were sometimes accompanied by brown-red colored
life-threatening complication of EPP, but only a small urine emission, they were interpreted as solar urticaria, so
fraction of EPP patients develop liver abnormalities that they were not further investigated. No other member of his
seldom can lead to cirrhosis or liver failure [7–9]. Paralytic family suffered from these symptoms. The patient reported
ileus, typical of other forms of porphyria, has rarely been that, in concomitance with routine examinations, a mild
reported in EPP patients, and is probably caused by pro- cholestathic parameters elevation (GGT, ALP, bilirubin)
toporphyrin accumulation in autonomic nerves [4, 10–12]. was observed; however it was not associated with any
Here we describe a patient with EPP associated with clinical manifestation and so additional studies were never
severe liver disease and paralytic ileus, in whom eri- performed. Apart from the above-mentioned information,
throplasma exchanges, hematin infusion, as well as his clinical history was unremarkable until December 2001,
administration of cholestyramine, charcoal, and ursodes- when he suddenly complained of upper abdominal colicky
oxicholic acid improved abdominal symptoms and liver pain, nausea, and vomiting; on this occasion, ultrasonog-
function. We discuss the clinical course and outcome in the raphy showed small gallstones. These symptoms quickly
context of the literature. disappeared spontaneously.
In the following 2 years, the patient referred three other
abdominal pain episodes like the previous one. In March
2004, he experienced a more severe abdominal pain attack;
S. Negrini (&) G. Zoppoli M. Setti F. Indiveri
Department of Internal Medicine, University of Genoa, V.le
for this reason, hospitalization was required and laparo-
Benedetto XV, 6, 16132 Genoa, Italy scopic cholecistectomy was planned. During laparoscopic
e-mail: negrini@unige.it exploration the surgeon noticed an abnormal liver appear-
ance (see Fig. 1), therefore an intraoperatory liver biopsy
M. D. Cappellini
Department of Internal Medicine, Centro Anemie Congenite,
was performed. The histological section showed micro-
Maggiore Policlinico Hospital IRCCS , University of Milan, and macrovescicular steatosis with no other pathologic
Milan, Italy
123
412 Dig Dis Sci (2009) 54:411–415
123
Dig Dis Sci (2009) 54:411–415 413
123
414 Dig Dis Sci (2009) 54:411–415
In most patients, this additional reduction results from A more likely possibility that could have justified the
inheritance of a low-expression FECH allele trans to a acute abdomen and the pain symptoms is an autonomic
severe mutation [9, 16, 26]. It’s worth noting that no other neurological syndrome, that closely resembles the one seen
member of our patient’s family suffered from photosensi- in acute porphyria. This condition has been observed by
tivity, but genetic analysis performed on his two brothers various authors in EPP patients with advanced liver failure
revealed the presence of the low-expression allele (SNP; [4, 9–12, 29, 33].
IVS3–48 C/T) with no other mutation. When hepatocellular damage progresses to a critical
On the contrary, the causes of liver disease in people stage, PP accumulation is markedly accelerated, since
affected by EPP are still incompletely explained. Liver biliary excretion is impaired. Under these conditions,
dysfunction seems to be associated with very low levels of plasma PP itself may act as a neurotoxin, because of its
FECH activity but not with specific FECH gene mutation [9, lipophilic nature [9, 25, 31, 33].
16, 26]. However, a significant genotype-phenotype corre- The absence of any other evident cause of paralytic ileus
lation between ‘‘null allele’’ mutations and protoporphyrin and the gradual improvement from the patient’s acute
related liver disease has been found [22, 24]. Also recessive symptoms was concomitant with the EPP therapy, strongly
inheritance seems to carry a higher risk of liver disease [26] suggesting that porphyric neurotoxicity was the main cause
as well as other genetic and acquired factors, such as alcohol of the acute abdomen observed in this patient.
abuse or chronic HCV infection [9, 16, 20, 21]. In a recent Unfortunately, we did not perform tests to clarify the role
report, male gender, anemia, total erythrocyte protopor- of autonomic neuropathy (such as histological examination
phyrin, and low serum ferritin are all independently of peripheral nerves or electrophysiologic studies) because
significantly associated with abnormal liver function [27]. of the initially severe conditions of the patient and the fast
The first three factors were all present in our patient’s case. symptomatic answer to the therapeutic strategies we applied.
Noticeably the skin symptoms he referred had always Cholestyramine and activated charcoal were adminis-
been mild and moreover chronic changes, like scarring, tered as biliary adsorbents in order to interrupt the
anomalous pigmentation, or thickening of the skin, com- enterohepatic circulation of protoporphyrin. Ursodesoxi-
monly described in EPP, had never developed; this could cholic acid was given to promote biliary fluid excretion [1,
explain why diagnosis was delayed for so many years. As 4–6, 30].
liver function markedly declined, photosensitivity became Erithroplasma exchange was performed to suppress
invalidating due to protoporphyrin accumulation, to the erythropoiesis and to facilitate the elimination of toxic
point that before admission the patient reported a severe protoporphyrins. This procedure has recently been reported
sunburn even after a mild sun exposure, previously toler- to be more effective than plasmapheresis plus i.v. hematin
ated with no particular consequences [12, 28–30]. or plasmapheresis alone for the treatment of EPP [34–36].
Various mechanisms were considered in the differential RBC transfusions were adopted to avoid severe anemia,
diagnosis of abdominal pain and paralytic ileus. which can increase heme synthesis by a positive feedback
The first was choledocholithiasis, which is a well-known mechanism and thereby enhance the production of harmful
complication of EPP [7, 25, 31, 32]. However, in our protoporphyrins [25, 36–38]. Intravenous hematin therapy,
patient, the gallbladder had been previously removed. In usually used for acute porphyria attacks, was administered
addition, extrahepatic bile duct appeared normal on various to suppress protoporphyrin production [34–36, 38].
imaging modalities, further negating the causal role of The therapies applied in this patient rapidly ameliorated
biliary stones for the episode. his abdominal symptoms and markedly improved his liver
Another cause of abdominal pain could have been acute function with different mechanisms. The dramatic response
pancreatitis, which has been advocated in at least one case observed is probably due to the simultaneous effect of the
report as cause of abdominal pain and ileus in end stage EPP drugs both on porphyrins elimination and porphyrins syn-
and in other forms of porphyria [6, 21]. We excluded the thesis inhibition. Obviously, along with the specific therapy
diagnosis of pancreatitis, because no well-known risk factors aimed to lower the porphyrins levels also support therapy
such as the presence of bile duct gallstones, alcohol, or drug was administered in order to manage the complications of
abuse were present. Moreover in our patient, the serum the severe liver failure. Nevertheless, in EPP patients with
amylase and lipase were not increased, whereas AST, ALT, hepatic complications, once jaundice develops, there is
ALP, GGT, and bilirubin were dramatically elevated. nearly always a rapid decline in liver function [7, 9, 20, 21]
Also acute cholangitis could have explained the clinical and truly effective agents for the treatment of EPP
situation we observed, but once again it was ruled out for are unavailable at present. Therefore OLT should be con-
the absence of fever, the lack of benefit of antibiotic sidered the only life-saving treatment, although even this
therapy and the normal bile duct appearance on different approach is not curative and disease may recur in the graft
imaging techniques. [9, 20, 39, 40].
123
Dig Dis Sci (2009) 54:411–415 415
123