Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INSHIRA DANSAL M.
July 2021
POVERTY AND THE FILIPINO MINDSET
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
There are possible conditionings why poverty are prevalent in the Philippines.
The
mindset is instilled in the subconscious of the poor, and they have learned to live with it.
The songs being taught and sang in elementary schools lines such as “Bahay Kubo,
kahit munti, ang halaman doon ay sari-sari,” (My nipa hut is small, but it has a variety of
plants)
“ Magtanim ay di biro,” (Planting is never fun..) and “I have two hands clean little hands
are good to see “ are indications that social conditioning which aligns with poverty is
very evident. A small nipa house of a poor farmer represents a simple yet happy home.
Bill Gates, Microsoft co-founder and Forbes’ richest man in the world, also
shared,
“if you’re born poor, it is not your mistake. But if you die poor, it’s your mistake.” To him,
to be poor is a choice, but one can change that. However, this conditioning of being
poor is inculcated in the subculture of the society, and many are poor because they
benefit from it as they are under welfare program from government and non-government
because it is not completely understood in the context of the poor. The general aim of
the study was to distill the mindset of the participants along poverty situation in
with happiness is what keeps them mired in chronic poverty. “Such as expression is
very ironic considering the fact that happiness is usually associated with material
abundance or prosperity.
According to Benigno (2014), “One wonders why the poor Filipinos continue to
fail
Because Filipinos have been led to believe that simply being “happy” makes them
“winners”. That is a nice philosophy to live with, when you are happy being a loser for
the rest of your existence, and that is, so to speak a kind of mentality that one wishes to
One reason why the people need to do research more is to prevent them
from
thinking ridiculous ideas about how to live life. And the only thing such an experience
reveals is that the researcher has to immerse himself in a concrete situation in order to
Theoretical Framework
There are many reasons why Filipinos are poor. We can attribute poverty with
the
rapid population growth that our economy cannot cope with. We can blame it to
unemployment, inflation, inequality and corruption as a direct cause of why Filipinos are
poor. However, if we wish to simplify the problem, we may say that the most Filipinos
Percent in the Visayas, and 71 percent in the Mindanao. Needless to say, many
Filipinos are in dire poverty even before they can even spell “happiness”. Filipino
children are poor even before they have tested a little comfort with bits of simple
happiness manifestly shown thru their faces. As these children grow up they come to
realize that they are poor and star wondering, even yet during their tender years, why
they are in such a situation and not in the same way they saw with some children who
are clean, well dressed, weel feed and being taken-cared of their nannies off to school
and back home. And so they grow older, poor children started to thinking about why and
what makes them poor and so begins to feel discriminated, bullied, deprived and etc. by
Psychologically, children who grew up poor suffer from negative emotions when
Researchers found that test subjects who had lower family incomes at age 9
exhibited, as adults, greater activity in the amygdala, an area in the brain
known for its role in fear and other negative emotions. These individuals
showed less activity in areas of the prefrontal cortex, an area in the brain
thought to regulate negative emotion.
What it means is that a person who experienced chronic stress from childhood to
fact according to surveys, 1/6 of people raised in poverty developed mental disorders.
The psychological consequences of childhood poverty and stress are the same
psychological barriers that may prevent a person from becoming more successful in
also affect a child’s ability to learn, making it more difficult to compete with children who
The researcher aims to analyze and interpret the Filipino mindset in the context
of
understanding the real meaning of poverty in the Philippines situation. By analyzing the
said title, the study proceeds to show the real causes or causes of poverty inherent in
1) What is poverty?
In one of the few studies on poverty in the Philippines, 200 low-income Filipinos
social and political conditions in the country; but with little sense of resignation or apathy
(Guerrero, 1973). This lack of resignation was due to a belief in their power to change
conditions in the country using peaceful means (Guerrero, 1973). Finding showed that
people who are poor have few aspirations for themselves but hold high hopes for their
psychological traits and attitudes are a sense of life being unfavorable; dissatisfaction
due to the discrepancy between expectation and attainment; high work orientation;
reliance on chance or luck; the magical role of education; being half optimistic and half
hopeless; and disillusionment with social, economic and political conditions in the
Philippines. However, Guerrero’s study was conducted more than 30 years ago, and
although a low income sample population was investigated, nothing is known about the
origins of the participants’ poverty, including whether the participants had always been
poor. Knowledge of its origins is part of understanding poverty: this study investigates
experiences
understanding how people raised in poverty have evolved to lead different lives.
According to Harrison (2000), the crucial elements in explaining poverty’s persistence
are the culture, values, and attitudes in society that obstruct progress. Those who stay
indigent may have different experiences of struggle; prejudice, power, and privilege in
their society may work to keep them impoverished. Filipinos who move out of poverty
2000). It is with this perspective that the present study seeks to understand the
among
poor Filipinos in the context of their observational behavior that causes them to remain
in poverty for the rest of their life. The areas of inquiry cover only communities
Balindong Lanao del sur among the 32 barangays under the 4P’s program of the MSSD
as the primary respondents for this research, specifically respondents who are residents
of Cadayonan, Balindong Lanad del Sur. Other topics relevant to this research study
under discussion shall likewise be treated secondarily upon the researcher’s evaluation
of their applicability. The range that this study may take will depend upon certain topics
under discussion; hence, other references may be quoted for that matter. Sources
relevant to the Filipino understanding of poverty and other sources on Filipino mentality
of some well-known Filipino authors will be employed to expound such research topic.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The theme “Poverty and the Filipino Mindset”, as a research problem could well
understood by employing analysis and interpretation based upon the data offered by the
interpreting the problem under discussion, hence, reference and use of these materials
are indispensable in this research. And in order to analyze the problem, an objective
employed in the entire presentation, analysis and interpretation of this research study.
Chapter II
LITERATURE REVIEW
the
South China Sea northeast of Malaysia. The annual population growth rate is 1.87%
while its current population is approximately more than 100 million people (CIA
Factbook, 2006). Since 1986, the Philippine economy has grown modestly. The country
is well endowed with mineral and non-oil energy resources; and its economy is buoyed
deficit, and massive external debt. The industrial sector is concentrated in urban areas.
foreign
and domestic investment and by restoring free-market forces. The Philippines faces
severe economic challenges; stability when approximately 52% of the population suffers
from debilitating poverty; and job creation for a rapidly expanding work force.
Unemployment and underemployment exceeds 30%. The nation must try to reverse the
ecological deterioration of its heavily populated rural sector while paying of its foreign
Among the basic concerns of Filipinos, health and nutrition, housing, utilities, and
the environment, and income and consumption stand most in relation to the study
conducted by the researchers (Mangahas, 1976). These concerns reflect the individual
aspiration to obtain a better quality of human life through improved welfare defined by
Filipinos desire to live long with the absence of infirmity, malnourishment, and
mental disability. They posses an unquestionable, natural need to satisfy their wants
through the sufficient purchase of products and services, which may only be adequately
done through the acquisition of pecuniary gains. It is vital for Filipinos to obtain
and unpolluted surroundings. The procurement of such basic physical needs will assist
people to become free from poverty and allow them to create a amore open society with
basic
food in terms of calorie intake and shelter increased from 36.8% of the population in
1997 to more than 40% in 2002. Thirty-eight percent of Filipino families do not have a
solid-structure shelter. Access to safe drinking water declined from 81.4% of families in
1999 to 80% in 2002. Twenty-one percent of all families and 44% of families in lower
40% income group have no electricity. Special effort must be made that the citizens of
the less developed regions take an active part in so far as circumstances allow, in their
As postcolonial theory indicates, many people today are still feeling the effects of
consequence of colonialism, which is the idea that one has been conditioned to attach
more importance to the values of the dominant culture over one’s own (David &
group’s attitude, beliefs and values while devaluing one’s own attitudes, beliefs and
values. In essence, “the dominant group has the power to define and name reality,
determining what is normal, real and correct and in effect, ignores, discounts,
misrepresents, or eradicate the target group’s culture, language and history (Speight,
2007, p.130). Speight (2007) prompted for further research to be done on the
injury. That internalized racial oppression exists and racial incidents happen are
important to note, but calling for a closer look into the effects of psychological injury is
especially important. My study looked into how these incidents are experienced and
how they shaped one’s mental health. How to prevent these psychological injuries and
how to cope will be noteworthy to uncover in further research as well (Speight, 2007).
handful of empirical studies (Felipe, 2010; Ferrera, 2011; Murillo, 2009), which I will
Colonial Mentality
David and Okazaki (2006b) constructed the colonial mentality scale (CMS) in
order
Measure it in quantifiable way. They broke down colonial mentality into four different
parts. The first is the idea of denigrating the Filipino self, second, denigrating the Filipino
culture or body, third, discriminating against less Filipinos, and finally, tolerating
historical and contemporary oppression of Filipinos. The authors identified five different
ways that colonial mentality manifested which were: internalized cultural and ethnic
characteristics, and colonial debt, which is this idea that Filipino should be grateful to
the colonizers who came to “save” the Filipinos. David (2008) used this same scale to
measure the rate of depression and how colonial mentality might be related to this
mental illness. This has brought some attention to how colonial mentality might be
mentality
and parenting style of Filipinos. The author discovered that a relationship exists
between ethnic identity and parenting style and that no relationship exist between
colonial mentality and ethnic identity (Murillo, 2009). I thought it was interesting that this
researcher did not find a relationship between colonial mentality and ethnic identity,
and my study addressed these concept further. Additionally, Murillo (2009) found that
Filipino do experience colonial mentality, but it does not have a significant relationship
with one’s parenting style, and colonial mentality may develop independent of one’s
values and beliefs about parenting. Murillo acknowledged mental health and included a
style develops.
These studies underscored the importance of empirical support that bolsters the
Idea that the Filipino immigration experience “need to be understood in the context of
colonialism and its most insidious psychological legacy” (David & Nadal, 2013, p.298).
here, David & Nadal (2013) acknowledged colonial mentality and the continued effects
of mental health but focused on the second generation Filipino American experiences
the mind, which is a process of reconnecting with the past to understand the present
and strengthens the cultural connection to the Filipino indigenous culture as a source of
grounding. She followed a group of eight Filipinos in Northern California who immigrated
after 1965 for over a year. She proposed that “critical consciousness is facilitated by the
process of decolonization. She had the group participate in-depth group dialogues and
interviews to discuss and then write about their decolonization experiences. Her
where participants felt need to reconnect or rediscover their ethnic roots, what
participants did to decolonize, and the role of Filipino community, the education system,
Chapter III
METHODS OF RESEARCH
interpretation
of the given information gathered from the respondents responses. The process is done
through survey research by way of collecting and analyzing the responses of small
samples of a particular group of poor people in the urban areas of Balindong, Lanao del
sur classified under the 4P’s (Pantawid Pamilyang Pililpino) of the DSWD to questions
designed to elicit their opinions, attitudes, and sentiments about the topic “Poverty and
information about a certain group. On the other hand, the sample survey allows the
researcher to secure uniform but superficial information about some portion of the
population.
Participants
The participants of this research study are thirty seven (37) residents of
Balindong,
Lanao del sur from the different barangays and are identified to be members of
DSWD’s 4P’s program who were specifically screened and selected for this purpose.
Materials
The instrument used in this experiment to measure the reliability of the research
is
the Convenience Sampling Formula for the purpose of determining the probability of
understanding the mindset of poor Filipinos in the urban areas of the Municipality of
Balindong, Lanao del sur. Survey questionnaire are to be distributed to each of the
respondents for purposes of eliciting answers from them conveniently designed in the
Procedure
answer is to be done by checking the appropriate boxes provided for in the enumerated
answers of the said questionnaires. The questions are so simple that it can immediately
be answered from even an ordinary person without formal education. The respondent’s
Chapter IV
data
gathered through a survey questionnaires conducted at Municipality of Balindong,
Lanao del sur coming from different barangays and who are classified as urban poor
under the criteria set upon by the Department of Social Welfare and Development
This qualitative study entitled: Poverty and the Filipino Mindset has stemmed
from
the personal concern of the researcher to identify the problems among the most
marginalized poor people in the Municipality of Balindong with an income bracket of less
than ten (10 thousand) pesos monthly, with no permanent jobs and who does not own
The study involves thirty seven (37) key informants. Adopting the Survey
Questionnaires Method, this study focuses on the following specific areas of concern.
sur from the Thirty-two (32) barangays and classified as members of the 4P’s
poverty and whose mentality dispossesses them the ability to overcome their
economic conditions such as property ownership (if they have any), education
mention a few.
The following tables below shows the total number of participants who
are
also illustrates the various respondents regarding the questions drawn out for them in
the questionnaires.
Table 1
No. of
respondent
%
Question Response Option Rank s
4 4 11.4
I am poor because I was born poor
I am poor because my parents
couldn't find better jobs to support
our daily needs 11 11 31.4
Total
35 35 100%
them to strive harder.” Although followed by group level 11 respondent who also
manifested the answer “they are poor because their parents could not find a good job to
These data clearly indicates that there exist in the minds among the poor people
consciously or unconsciously led to belief that fate has something to do with their
situation and so yielding up to the mentality that there are no compelling reasons for
them not to strive harder in life. Perhaps, this mentality is likely the effects of the so
internalization of the dominant group’s attitudes, beliefs and attitudes, and values while
devaluing one’s own attitudes, beliefs and values. This study looked into how these
incidents are experienced and how they shaped one’s mental health.
Table 2
No. of
Question Response Option Rank respondents %
Lack of education 7 7 20
lack of opportunities 13 13 37.1
Low self-esteem ( no self confidence) 1 1 2.8
Poor mentality 1 1 2.8
What are some
Timid, not ingenious (walang diskarte) 9 9 25.7
factors that hinder
poor people from No ambition/ low aspiration 4 4 11.4
changing their lives No aspiration or innate desire to change for
for the better the better 0 0 0
lives for the better. This is followed by 9 out of the 35 respondents who said that being
timid or not ingenious (walang diskarte) was their answer to the same question elicited.
Clearly, this indicates that lack of education is still the common ground why poor people
are timid and they find it hard to look for better opportunities to improve their lives.
Lacked of education grounds the very character of poor individuals from exerting
ingenious effort to better themselves in life. Lack of education and lack of opportunities
are closely interrelated since education is the getaway for all kinds or opportunities to
open to the individuals seeking for means of survival. Aside from educating the mind,
mind, which as Strobel (1997) expressly enunciated, “a process of reconnecting with the
past to understand the present and strengthens the cultural connection to the Filipino
indigenous culture as the source of grounding. “The decolonization of the mind is the
best anti-dot to liberate the spirit of the people who have long been victimized and
Table 3
No. of
Question Response Option Rank Respondents %
doesn’t
have faith in government’s effort in helping them alleviate their economic condition.
Despite the programs initiated by the government such as 4P’s program of the DSWD,
many are not convicted that these initiatives are genuinely meant for them and it won’t
improve their lives because it is done for temporary consolation only on the part of
government. In effect, some of the so-called beneficiaries would just take the advantage
in getting the money and use it for capital. Some parents do not even encourage their
children to go to school because they simply wanted them to start working and earn a
living to help augment their financial need. This reality is commonly existing in the rural
communities were the poverty index is higher than those in the urban areas.
The 2015 survey also found that 12.1 percent of the population- roughly 12.18
million Filipinos are living in subsistence or extreme poverty, meaning their earnings are
According to PSA, the national poverty threshold in 2015 stood ate P10,969 per
month, meaning a family of five needed to earn that much to be able to eat, have
Based on the evidence gathered from multiple reliable sources, we can make
the
1. Filipinos are poor not because they have an “obsession with happiness”. In
fact,
There is no evidence that suggests that “contentment” can cause poverty. Through
inferences made from reading the evidence, we can say that it’s possible many Filipinos
are poor simply because they are born poor. Their experiences of poverty in the crucial
years of their mental development negatively affected their capacity to learn and their
ability to regulate negative emotions- factors that may impede their economic progress
as adults. Furthermore, poverty itself impedes their cognitive function, making them
2. Some poor Filipinos are happy not because they have a loser mentality. Some
Poor Filipinos are happy simply because nothing is preventing them from feeling
otherwise. Although depression is twice as common among the poor, poor people who
don’t have depression are not much less happy than rich people themselves. In fact, a
study suggests that, “one’s life circumstances, unless they are very bad indeed, do not
seem to have lasting effects on one’s mood, “implying that there are genetic factors to
harder. If a person thinks that the problem of poverty is due to a poor person’s lack of
productivity, the scientifically correct thing to do is help them recover their self-esteem
and encourage them to be happy, to improve their cognitive function and increase their
productivity. In any case, one should not call poor people losers because by doing so
will only reinforce the psychological barriers that impede their cognitive functioning.
Based on the same evidence, we can also conclude that Benigno’s article
entitled
“Filipino Obsession with Happiness”, is what keeps them mired in chronic poverty, is
wrong about a lot of things. The debilitating mindset of every Filipino, be they affluent or
lacking is the main cause of poverty in this country. It is in the thinking and believing that
nothing else can be done for one to prosper and have a good life. It is about thinking
only of the self and believing only for the self when one has too much of anything and
not sharing the ‘extras’ to those who are lacking. It is what we all nurture in our mind
that causes poverty and not the government or anybody else. What we think, we act,
and we feel are all the result of an improper mindset with too much religion.
People with a culture of poverty have very little sense of history. They are a
marginal
people who know only their own troubles, their own local conditions, their own
neighborhood, their own way of life. Usually neither have the knowledge, the vision, nor
the ideology to see the similarities between their problems and those of others like
themselves elsewhere in the world. In other words, they are not class conscious,
although they are very sensitive indeed to status distinctions. When the poor become
class conscious or members of the trade union organizations, or when they adopt an
internationalist outlook of the world, they are, in the researcher’s view, no longer part of
This researcher would not delve much of the accuracy of the measures of
poverty
but he wish to discuss a very fundamental truth about poverty. Poverty is a mindset. It is
not so much about not having food, clothing and shelter but a debilitating hopelessness
to improve one’s financial condition. And he finds it alarming that more than half of our
countrymen are in this situation because he knew how powerful the mind is: whether
So what’s the harsh truth about poverty? It is a mindset as much as reality. That
is
many people feel that they are poor and in need of money without knowing that they
already have what they need. Such is the state of sheer mendicant mindset.
Recommendations:
In poverty studies, education has been considered to be the fulcrum that tips and
Breaks the poverty cycle, the relatively high percentage (38.5%) of families below the
poverty threshold. For Municipality of Balindong, Lanao del sur, this proportion of the
total population is about 32,573. The municipal’s master plan should review the anti-
poverty programs and other related measures being implemented based on the premise
that human development and alleviation of poverty are best achieved through the direct
and combined efforts of people themselves. Human capabilities are best expanded
through their direct exercise. Sectoral biases to addressing poverty should be checked
and more converging efforts and activities should be done in responding to the needs of
Economic growth did not translate into poverty reduction in recent years. While
the
Country experienced moderate economic growth in recent years, poverty reduction has
been slow. The quality of growth matters and persistent inequality mitigates the positive
impact of growth on poverty reduction. Chronic poverty is concern, and poverty become
a major constraint on the attainment of high levels of sustained growth and the overall
development of the country. The solution to the poverty is thus of public interest.
Benefits will not only accrue to those who get out of poverty but also to society as at
large.
Poverty remains mainly a rural phenomenon through urban poverty is on the rise.
The majority of the poor are still found in rural areas and in the agriculture sector. They
are mostly farmers and fishers. However, there are an increasing number of poor
Poverty levels are strongly linked to educational attainment. The heads of the two
of three people households have only reached elementary education and below. The
poor have large families, with six or more members. Population management will be
Many Filipino households remain vulnerable to shocks and risks. This is the highlighted
by the escalating conflict in Mindanao and the current global financial crisis. An effective
poverty reduction programs. Effective delivery of basic social services and poverty-
unreliable,
inaccurate, and ultimately poverty information, especially at the local level, and partly
problem
involve multiple stakeholders. Convergences has been the right approach and this must
Further research on chronic poverty is needed. There are very few micro studies
that examine chronic poverty and how the poor escape poverty traps. these studies are
Benigno. (2014). “Filipino Obsession with Happiness” is what keeps them mired in
chronic
poverty.
Speight, S.L. Internalized racism: One more piece of the piece of the puzzle. The
October 1, 2014.