Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Whatever you do, whatever you eat, whatever you offer in worship,
and whatever you give away in charity;
Whichever sacrifices you perform and difficulties undergo – O son of
Kunti – do them all as offerings to me. Bhagavad Gita 9:27
The earliest available inquiries of such type hark back to the days
of the timeless Rig Ved (ऋग्वेद). In the 14-line hymn (Book 10, Hymn
1291) known as the Naasadiya Sookt (the Principle of न असत ् – ‘Not
even Non-Existence’), Shlok 6 asks questions, as follows,
को अद्धा वेद क इह प्रवोचत्कुत आजाता कुत इयां ववसषृ ्टिः।
अवापग्दे वा अस्य ववसजपनेनाथा को वेद यत आबभव
ू ।।6।।
Variously attributed to Prajapati Parmeshthi, the following questions
are posed:
(i) Who knows and who can say...
(ii) …from where Creation has originated?
(iii) Whether the Creator designed it or whether HE did not?
(iv) Whether even the Creator knows it or even HE does not?
1
ओ३म ् नासदासीन्नो सदासीत्तदानीां नासीद्रजो नो व्योमा परो यत ्। ककमावरीविः कुह कस्य शमपन्नम्भिः ककमासीद्गहनां गभीरम।् ।1।।
न मत्ृ युरासीदमत
ृ ां न तर्हप न रात्र्या अन्ह आसीत्प्रकेतिः। आनीदवातां स्वधया तदे कां तस्माद्धान्यन्न परिः ककां चनास।।2।।
तम आसीत्तमसा गूळहमग्रेऽप्रके तां सलििां सवप मा इदम।् तुच्छय्येनाभ्ववपर्हतां यदासीत्तपसस्तन्मर्हनाजायतैकम।् ।3।।
कामस्तदग्रे समवतप ताधध मनसो रे तिः प्रथमां यदासीत ्। सतो बन्धुमसतत तनरववन्दन ् हृर्द प्रती्या कवयो मनीषा।।4।।
ततरश्चीनो ववततो रषश्मरे षामधिः षस्वदासी३दुपरर षस्वदासी३त।् रे तोधा आसन्मर्हमान आसन्त्स्वधा अवस्तात्प्रयततिः परस्तात।् ।5।।
को अद्धा वेद क इह प्रवोचत्कुत आजाता कुत इयां ववसषृ ्टिः। अवापग्दे वा अस्य ववसजपनेनाथा को वेद यत आबभूव।।6।।
इयां ववसषृ ्टयपत आबभूव यर्द वा दधे यर्द वा न। यो अस्याध्यक्षिः परमे व्योमन्त्सो अांग वे द यर्द वा न वे द।।7।।
A translation is available at Appendix 1
Similarly, the Brahma Sutra of Baadaraayan begins with the subject
of Brahm - अथातो ब्रह्म जजज्ञासा – ‘Now, therefore, an Inquiry into
the nature of Everything’, and जन्माद्यस्य यतः – ‘From where has
come the origin, etc. of this Universe?’.
4
Indic Knowledge Tradition (IKT): According to this tradition, ‘rishis’ or seers composed Vedic hymns and
mantras out of their extra-sensory perception. These verses have existed forever and will remain always –
unchanging – beyond our commonly seen world of change. It’s no wonder then that these mantras are called
‘nitya’, i.e., eternal and ‘apaurusheya’, i.e., not composed by humans.
समपपण
जो कुछ तुम करते हो, जो कुछ तुम खाते हो, जो कुछ तुम पूजा में
चढाते हो, और जो कुछ तुम दान में दे ते हो;
हे कुन्तीपत्र
ु - तम
ु जो भी यज्ञ करते हो और जो कठिनाइयााँ करते हो,
वह सब मुझे भें ट के रूप में करो। भगवद गीता 9:27
The Backdrop
It’s the strangest of tales – a story to end all stories! Raja Bharat
was one of our earliest forefathers and this country of Bhaarat, that is
India (and certainly not the other way round5), is named after him and
we are all his children (‘भारत’ meaning the descendants of ‘भरत’6).
5 THE CONSTITUTION of INDIA: Article 1. Name and territory of the Union — (1) India, that is Bharat, shall be a
Union of States.
Bharat continued to roam around the country till one day he was
found by servants of the king of Sindhu-Sauvir region, King Rahugan.
Rahugan happened to be proceeding on pilgrimage to the holy estuary
of Gangaa-Saagar in Bengal to visit the ancient ashram of Kapil Muni.
He was being carried on a palanquin by four bearers but one of them
took ill. The king’s soldiers had been looking for a replacement bearer
and when they found Bharat, they at once forced him to join them.
But while carrying the palanquin, Bharat could not walk in step
with the other bearers because he kept trying to avoid stepping on
insects which could by chance come under foot. The resulting jerky
ride annoyed the king considerably who then threatened Bharat with
physical punishment.
Bharat replied that he was not a body but a soul and the king could
not even touch his soul let alone punish it. Following some more
exchanges, it dawned upon the king at last that Bharat was no ordinary
person and fell at his feet seeking his forgiveness and guidance.
Having advised Rahugan suitably, Bharat carried on with his
wanderings and, ultimately achieved moksh मोक्ष or freedom from
rebirth.
The story is incredibly old being placed in the Swayambhu
Manvantar7. Bharat’s genealogy is as follows: Swayambhu
Manu→Priyavrat→Agnidhra→Naabhi→Rishabhdev→Bharat. Each
Manvantar consists of 306.72 million years or Mega Annum (Ma). As
per the Vedic reckoning of time periods 8, six Manvantars have passed,
the present one being the seventh. Hence, 306.72 x 6 = 1,840 Ma
approximately. Even though the Earth’s revolution around the sun may
have slowed down by about 17% since then, that’s still a very long time
ago!
So, what is it that is so unique and unforgettable about these few
incidents which took place so long ago that we still use this story as a
lodestar for drawing inspiration in our lives today?
A few features definitely stand out:
(1) The importance of understanding the true nature of reality
and the purpose of our life on this planet;
(2) The importance also of progress at every stage of life and
renunciation at the right time;
(3) the seriously adverse effects of atavism, i.e., going back to
familiar and comfortable experiences of one’s past; and
(4) the innumerable innocuous-looking hurdles and difficulties
on the long and lonely spiritual path.
-x-
Methodology
Like all good scientists, let us start with methodology. How do
we understand anything? Should we rely solely on scientific
discoveries? What is the role of mental speculation or direct revelation?
Saints and philosophers down the ages – from the Upanishadic to the
present – have used methods in different combinations. The broadest
classification of such methods is the ancient Indian distinction between
Shruti - श्रनु त and Smriti - स्मनृ त, including their rules of logic for
establishing Pramaan - प्रमाण or proof.
Shruti & Smriti
Reams have been written about shruti and smriti by ancient
Indian philosophers as well as modern ones such as Shri Aurobindo 9
and Indologists like Friedrich Max Müller 10.
Speaking for myself, I was first introduced to this classification
during the course of my undergraduate studies in ancient Indian history
but it remained completely opaque to me. I used to get totally stumped
when I tried to explain Shruti and Smriti – even to myself. They
remained mysterious and confusing abstractions. The main difficulty,
as I realised later, was on account of the fact that later commentators
had conflated too many ideas and interpretations into them without
sufficient appreciation of the overall spirit of Indian thought at its core.
Now, 45 years later, I appreciate much better the fineness of the great
thought which went into such broad divisions of learning and
realisation through Shruti and Smriti.
The problem with later commentators, especially those brought
up in western environments, was two-fold. One, they approached
9 Aurobindo Ghose (15-8-1872 to 5-12-1950), author of The Life Divine
10 Friedrich Max Müller (6-12-1823 to 28-10-1900), best known for his University of Cambridge lectures on
India: What can it Teach Us? (1883) and Six Systems of Indian Philosophy (1899).
Indian philosophy as some sort of an impenetrable or opaque mystery
– some even terming several of its aspects as ‘mysticism’.
Philosophy is like being in a dark room and looking for a black cat. Metaphysics is like
being in a dark room and looking for a black cat that isn't there. Theology is like being in a
dark room looking for a black cat that isn't there and shouting "I found it!"
OR
Ernest Gellner’s take on Science, Philosophy, and Marxism is another twist on the aphorism
about looking for a cat in a dark room with various consequences as follows: with science the
cat is present, with philosophy absent, and with Marxism absent but found.
11 The Eight-Step Path recommended by him consists of Yam, Niyam, Aasan, Praanaayaam, Pratyaahaar,
Dhaaran, Dhyaan and Samaadhi.
12 The Shambhala Dictionary of Buddhism and Zen by Diener, Erhard and Fischer-Schreiber (1991)
Epistemology (ज्ञान-मीमांसा) can be defined simply as the study
of ‘knowledge’. Its three main questions are: what’s the difference
between knowledge and opinion, is it possible to have real knowledge
and what is the process whereby we can reach such knowledge.
Hence, he says:
जरामरणमोक्षाय मामाचश्रत्य यतजन्त ये ।
ते ब्रह्म तद्षवदःु कृत्स्नमध्यात्मं कमम चाखखिम ् ॥Bh..G. 7.29॥
To obtain freedom from old age and death, such learned persons
surrender unto Me in order to try and understand Me; they are
actually Brahm, the Knower of ‘tat’, about spirituality and Karm in its
totality.
Only through surrender and complete mindfulness, then, can He
be known and understood.
Again, in the Bhagvad Gita, he says to Arjun:
-x-
Chapter 2
The Banyan Tree (a.k.a. The Matrix)
In Verses 1-3 of Chapter 15 of his revelations to Arjun (श्रीमद्
भगवद्गीता), Shri Krishn describes the unified nature of His Creation
under His supreme control in the following words:
ऊध्वपमि
ू मध:शाखमश्वत्थां प्राहुरव्ययम ् |
छन्दाांलस यस्य पणापतन यस्तां वेद स वेदववत ् ॥Bh..G. 15.11॥
“With its roots above and branches below, there is an invisible
Banyan Tree without end, with leaves that consist of certain systems
that work in harmony. Whoever understands this, comprehends the
actual Reality.”
Often have I experienced the real existence of this ‘Banyan
Matrix’ in my life. More so after watching the 1999 movie, ‘The
Matrix’, which presents its own version of a simulated reality
developed from their studies of Vedantic philosophy.
One unforgettable incident which always springs to mind,
unfolded as follows. In the summer of 1996 (around 10th July), I was
driving down the German Autobahn 19 from the Baltic port of Rostock
to Berlin.
In several stretches, the road was under repairs – with diversions into
the last two lanes on the right. I was driving a Volvo 740.
दश एक शाखः त्रद्व सुपर्ण नीडः त्रि वल्कलः त्रद्व फलः अकणम् प्रत्रवष्टः ॥SmBh.11:12:22॥
अदन्ति च एकम् फलम् अस्य गृध्ाः ग्रामे चराः एकम् अरण्य वासाः ।
-x-
16 See Chapter 1.
Chapter 3
17 A Parsec (pc) is the distance at which the radius of Earth’s orbit around the Sun subtends
an angle of one second of arc. Thus, a star at a distance of one parsec would have a parallax of one second,
and the distance of an object in parsecs is the reciprocal of its parallax in seconds of arc. For example, the
nearest star, Proxima Centauri, which is part of the Alpha Centauri triple-star system, has a parallax of 0.769
second of arc, and, hence, its distance from the Sun and Earth is 1.30 parsec. One parsec equals 3.26 light-
years.
faster they are receding, as the light coming from them is considerably
‘Red-Shifted’. The almost constant ratio between their receding speed
and their distance became known as the Hubble Constant – ‘H’. The
best model for understanding this is a household one – a baking Raisin
Cake – where raisins are taken to represent galaxies. Just as a Raisin
Cake rises slowly when being baked in an oven, Einstein’s Space-Time
medium is continuously expanding or rather growing itself and the
Raisins/Galaxies in it are moving away – both from the centre as well
as from each other.
18 The KBC Void (or Local Hole) is an immense, comparatively empty region of space named after astronomers
Ryan Keenan, Amy Barger, and Lennox Cowie, who studied it in 2013.
Our Local Group
Similarly, our ’Local Group’ is a group of more than 20
galaxies in which our Milky Way galaxy is situated. About half are
elliptical galaxies, the remainder being spiral or irregular. As in other
clusters of galaxies, the constituents are probably kept together by their
mutual gravitational attraction. The Milky Way system is near one end
of the volume of space occupied by the Local Group, while the great
Andromeda Galaxy (M31) is at the other, only about 2 million light-
years away.
Push-Pull Lines of Force acting on our Local Group
Our Local Group, moreover is not moving in a uniform way.
The gravitational waves mapped above give us some idea about the
pushes and pulls on our local group that results in it moving at speeds
almost twice as fast as that predicted by the Hubble Constant.
Obviously, for our purposes, this model does not work. Then
there’s the length of a single Brahm Day-Night – the Kalp ककप – that
covers 8.64 billion years, i.e. out of the last 8.64 billion years, half of
them have been in darkness. This requirement brings up the classical
imagery of either the Earth-Moon system or the Sun-Earth system.
23 The ‘Big Bang Theory’ is the currently accepted cosmological model of the observable universe from the
earliest knowable periods to the present. The model describes how the universe expanded from an initial
state of a Singularity of extremely high density and temperature, and offers a reasonable explanation for a
broad range of observed phenomena, including the abundance of light elements, the Cosmic Microwave
Background (CMB) radiation, and large-scale structures.
What if…! What if the visible universe – our ब्रह्मांड – has actually
existed for the last 155 trillion years, rotating around a powerful light
source (its own star) once every 3.1 trillion years, and spinning on its
axis once every 8.64 billion years – half of it in the light of its own star
and the other half turned away from it, much like the Earth-Sun system?
Such a model would continue to fulfil all our requirements and
validate the astronomical laws and scientific rules, including that of the
continuous expansion of Space-Time – provided we take it to be akin
to normal growth rather than a sudden expansion.
The Multiverse
A Divinely Controlled Multiverse
A Quasi-Steady State Multiverse
"How often have I said to you, my dear Watson, that when you
have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however
improbable, must be the truth?” The fictional Sherlock Holmes had laid
down this ineluctable logic, yet, never a truer word was said!
Days before the latter died, Belgian Physicist Thomas Hertog said
of Stephen Hawking, "This was very much on the top of his mind.
Hawking did not like the multiverse. But on the other hand, he realized
it's very hard to avoid. Pretty much any reasonable model of the Big
Bang which we could come up with led us to a multiverse24."
-x-