Professional Documents
Culture Documents
For
BIO 4212
Review Essay and Research
Methodology
By
Muhammad A. Said
Department of Biological Sciences
College of Natural and Applied Sciences
Permission is granted free of charge to print or photocopy all pages of this lecture
note for educational, not-for-profit use
2021
Outlines
RESEARCH
Research is the way in which we acquire dependable and useful information about everyday life process.
Research may be broadly described as any systematic endeavors or striving towards the understanding, on
perceiving certain complex situational problem of more than immediate personal concern and stated in a
problematic form. Research can otherwise also be described as the systematic process of collecting and
analyzing information (data) in order to increase our understanding of the phenomenon with which we are
concerned or interested.
CHARACTERISTICS OF RESEARCH.
The major characteristics of any research are; Objectivity, precision, design and verifiability.
1. Objectivity: An ideal research should be objective and free of all personal preferences.
2. Precision
Every research should use a technical language in order to convey the exact meaning to the readers. Such
research languages include validity, reliability, random sampling variables etc.
3. Design: An ideal research, should have a very good and systematic design. For example; Definition of
the problem, Statement of the hypothesis, Collection and analysis of data, Testing / confirmation or
rejection of hypothesis and Reporting of the results.
4. Verifiability
TYPES OF RESEARCH
Research in general can be classified in many different ways base on the criteria taking into consideration.
1. Fundamental Research: The main purpose of these types of research is to obtain empirical data which
can be used to formulate, expand or evaluate a theory.
2
2. Applied Research: This type of research is directed towards the solution to an immediate, specific and
practical problem. It is the type of research conducted in relation to actual problems and under the
conditions in which they are found in practice.
3. Quantitative Research: This is a type of research involving social or human problem, based on testing
a theory composed of variables measured with numbers or figures and analyzed with statistical procedures
in order to determine whether the predictive generalizations of the theory hold true.
4. Qualitative research: This is a type of research involving understanding a social or human problem,
based on building a complex, holistic picture formed with words reporting detailed views of information,
and conducted in a natural setting. The qualitative research is sometimes referred to as the interpretative,
the naturalistic, the constructivist or the postpositive approach.
5. Correlational research: - A statistical investigation of the relationship between one factor and one or
more other factors. It considers the surface relationship but does not necessarily probe for casual
reasons underlying them
6. Descriptive or Normative Survey: - A survey method used to describe the incidence, frequency and
distribution of certain characteristics of a population.
7. Historical research: - A type of research that attempts to solve certain problems arising out of historical
context through gathering and examining of relevant data.
Data can be regarded as information that can be given out or taken for the purpose of making interferences
in research. In this case, it may include numerical or statistical results or figures such as percentages. It
may also include verbal materials like newspaper accounts, scholastic essay etc. Data can also be define
as any collection of verbal or numerical information from which inferences or conclusions can be drawn
or analyzed.
Data can be quantitative or qualitative. Any information which comes in numbers, figures, or measures
or is said to be quantitative. Whereas any information which comes as a verbal description of attribute or
characteristics is regarded as qualitative.
TYPES OF DATA
There are basically two categories of data collected and used in research. These are Primary data and
Secondary data.
Primary data
These are information, facts or statistical materials originated for the purpose of the inquiry. This is
sometimes popularly called the “First-hand information” or “information from the horses mouth”. They
are referred to as eye witness account of an event or phenomenon. Such information is extracted from the
3
actual participants themselves. It may be through oral interviews or discussions or through written diaries,
minutes, proceedings, pictures, objects etc.
For instance, supposing you want to conduct an inquiry on the cost of living of people in two different
societies. You will see that all the facts pertaining to this inquiry may be collected directly from the
members of the societies themselves. Such information or data collected would be called Primary data.
Secondary data
These refer to information, facts or statistical materials which are not originated by the researcher or
investigator. These are materials from someone else‟s records or other documents like books, journals,
newspaper reports and other research works that may be got from the libraries. In the simplest form,
secondary data are not first-hand information.
They are reported information if you refer to the inquiry and comparism of the cost of living in the two
different societies above, you will notice that instead of going to the people themselves to obtain
information as in primary data, you may depend on research reports from journals, newspapers and
magazines: you may also resort to obtaining other records showing the peoples expenditure on living.
These data are called Secondary data
RESEARCH HYPOTHESIS
A hypothesis as tentative but intelligent guess posited to direct your thinking toward the solution of the
problem. It is a tentative proposition set forth a possible explanation for an occurrence or a provisional
conjecture to assist in guiding the investigation of a problem. Hypotheses and research questions are very
helpful in research because you need some points around which to orient the research in searching for
relevant data and in establishing tentative goals against which to project the data.
Hypotheses can be stated in two different forms. These are the null hypothesis, H0 and the
4
EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN
Experimental design provides the structure and strategy for controlling the investigation and get to arrived
at dependable answers to the questions raised in the problem or hypothesis.
TYPES OF SAMPLING
They are classified into two: Probability and Non-probability sampling techniques
Probability Sampling
In this technique, the components of the samples are chosen from the larger population by a process known
as randomization. The principle of randomization ensures that all the individual subjects of the larger
population have equal chances of being selected and included to be members of the drawn samples. This
generates valid samples that are truly representative of the larger populations. This will also permit you to
estimate precisely the likelihood of a sample differing from the true population by a given amount. It can
be calculated as sampling error. This is an estimate of the extent to which the values of the sample differ
from those of the population from which it is drawn.
Non-Probability Sampling
This is a type of sampling where you do not know the probability of each population element being
included in the sample. They are known to generate biased samples that are not truly representative of the
target population from which they are drawn. Any sample that is non-valid can encourage errors in
findings that cannot be generalized to the total population.
SAMPLING TECHNIQUES
1 Simple random sampling
This is based on the principle that individuals are chosen from a target population such that each has an
equal chance of being selected, and each choice is independent of the other. Assuming you have a need to
select one hundred customers of a hotel or bank from a list of five thousand 137 customers of the bank or
hotel. What you will do is to assign numbers from one to five thousand to all the customers. Fold these
numbers and put them in a container like basket. Shuffle them well and start picking and shuffling from
5
the basket, until you get the 100 customers. You will notice that all the customers have equal chance of
being selected.
Another and more convenient method of doing the same thing is to use a table of random numbers. This
is mostly used these days in lotteries and try your luck games. You can get it in texts.
2 Systematic Sampling
If your target population can be accurately listed, then this method can be used to get what approximates
a random sample. It consists of the selection of a Kth number from the list. For instance, if you have 100
customers and you want select 10 out of the 100 as your sample. You will divide 100 by 10 to get 10.
From a list containing 1-10 select any number at random. Let us say 8. In this method all the numbers
connected to 8 are automatically selected. So you will have 8, 18, 28, 38, 48, 58, 68, 78, 88, and 98, as
your samples.
4 Cluster sampling
When the population is spread across a large area, it becomes difficult to make a list to select samples for
study through the normal simple random process. The large area has to be subdivided into sub-units for
effective handling. For instance a state could be sub divided into zones, local governments or wards and
a series of cluster sampling is done from each of these sub units to get the sample which will be truly
representative of the target population.
Accident or Continuance Sampling: This takes the subjects as they come to the scene or as they are
presented to you by mere happenstance. There is no attempt to control biases.
Quota Sampling: This selects the respondents in the same ratio as they appear or are found in the target
population. It is also an unregulated type of sampling. This is because you have no probability of
how the subjects will be selected. Others in this category are Availability Sampling, Purposive
Sampling, and Dimensional Sampling etc.
SAMPLING SIZE
An ideal sample should be large enough to serve as an adequate representative of the population about
which the researcher wishes to generalize and small enough to be selected economically in terms of subject
availability, expenses in both time and money, the complexity of data analysis etc.
6
In other-words there is no fixed number or percentage of subjects that determines the size of an
adequate sample. The size may depend on the nature of the population of interest or the data to be collected
and analyzed. Samples of 30 and above are considered large samples and less than 30 are considered small
samples. However, it is important that care must be taken in the selection of the samples. Emphasis
should be on representativeness rather than sample size.
Random sampling or letting chance or law of probability determine which members of the target
population are to be selected is the ideal thing to do.
Data analysis refers to those techniques whereby the investigator extracts from data, information that was
not apparently there before and which would enable a summary description of the subject being studied,
whether human or material, to be made. To Kerlinger (1971) data analysis is the categorizing, ordering,
manipulating and summarizing of data, adding that its purpose is to reduce large quantities of raw data to
manageable and interpretable form so that characteristics of situations, events and people can be
succulently described and the relations among variable studied and interpreted.
STATISTICS
Statistics is a body of mathematical technique or processes for gathering, organizing analyzing and
interpreting numerical data. You know that most research yields such quantitative data. Therefore statistics
is a basic tool of measurement, evaluation and research. The concept statistics is sometimes used to
describe the numerical data that are collected. Statistical data describe group behaviour or group
characteristics abstracted from a number of individual observations that are combined to make
generalizations possible.
According to Kerlinger (1971) statistics is considered the theory and method of analyzing data obtained
from samples of observations in order to describe population, to study and compare sources of variances,
to help make decisions to accept or reject relations among phenomena, and to aid the process of making
reliable relations among empirical observations. The point is that unless abstract and concrete phenomena
are quantified and represented by figures are numerals, their nature relations and dynamics will not be
understood.
7
Non Parametric Data: These are data which are either counted or ranked. They are sometimes known
as distribution free tests. They do not depend on the assumption of normally distributed
populations.
Descriptive Analysis: In this type of statistical analysis, generalizations are limited to the particular group
of individuals observed. The conclusions are not extended beyond the group. Similarity to those
outside the group cannot be assumed. So the data can only describe one group and that group only.
Most of the simple action researches you conduct involve descriptive analysis and provide
valuable information about the nature of a particular group of individuals.
Inferential Analysis: This type of statistical analysis involves the process of sampling and the selection
of a small group that is assumed to be representative of the population from which it is drawn. So
drawing conclusions about population based on observation of the samples is the purpose of
inferential analysis. We shall briefly touch on both descriptive and inferential statistics which you
will be using in your research projects.
Mean
This is the arithmetic average of the values in a distribution. It is obtained by adding up all the values in
the distribution or group of scores and dividing by the total number o values. It is the most useful of all
statistical measures, because, in addition to the information that it provides, it is the base from which many
other important measures are computed. For instance if
X = 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
Then ∑X = 2+3+4+5+6+7+8 = 35
N=7
X = 35/7 = 5
Depending on the type of data distribution of scores, the mean can be computed in different ways. There
is a method for calculating the mean for grouped frequency distributions and a method for calculating the
mean using the assumed mean method.
The Median
This is a point or value that divides the distribution of values into two equal groups with as many cases
above it as below it. It is a measure of position rather than of magnitude.
8
It can be found by both inspection and calculation. When we have single values we use inspection. But if
the values are grouped we use calculation. For instance if
X = 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. You can see that the middle number is 5. It is the median. But if we have see 2, 3,
4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9. The middle number is added and divided by 2. In this distribution 5 + 6 = 11 ÷ 2 = 5.5. The
median is 5.5
Mode
This is the value which is characterized as the highest number of frequencies in a frequency distribution
of values. It is the value that occurs most frequently in a distribution.
It can be located by inspection when values are listed or by calculation when values are grouped.
For instance:
2, 3, 3, 4, 4, 4, 5, 6, 6, 7, 8, 9. You can see that the highest occurring number in this set of number is 4. It
is the mode.
ACTIVITY 1:
A group of 9 students had a test in Mathematics. They have the following scores: Ade = 70, Femi = 65,
Hassan = 60, Musa = 55, Effiong = 75, Obi = 80, Uche = 85, Wale = 90, Emeka = 95. Find the mean and
median.
Solution 1:
= 75
For the median, arrange the scores in ascending or descending order of magnitude. The middle number
is 75.
The range
9
This is the difference between the highest value and the lowest value in a set of data. It is the difference
between the two extreme values in a distribution of figures. It is an unreliable measure, because it does
not guarantee the researcher a fair and dependable index of variability.
This is because of the use of the two extreme values. If you look at the mathematics test in activity 1, you
will see the highest number is 95 and the lowest number is 55. Therefore the range is
95 – 55 = 40. There are two types of range but we can not go to that now.
Mean Deviation
This is the average distance away from the mean in which the measure lies. It is used by the researcher to
determine the power of representativeness of the mean as a measure standing in for other measures in the
same distribution. A value expressed as its distance from the mean is called a deviation value. It is given
by the formula X = (X – X). For the mean deviation it will be X. (X
Variance (δ2)
You will note that the value of the sum of the deviations from the mean is always zero. So when you
square the deviations around the mean and sum up the value and divide by N what you get is the variance.
It will give you a positive value.
It is give n by δ2 = ∑(X –X) 2. The variance is a value that describe how all the
values in a distribution are dispersed to spread about the
mean. It is very useful in describing the characteristics of a distribution and will be employed in a number
of very important statistical tests.
Standard Deviation
This is the square root of the variance. It is the most frequently used measure of variability or spread in a
distribution.
According to Cohen (1976) it is the most reliable of all the available measures of dispersion.
The Level of Significance
When you propose a hypothesis for your problem, you have a direction as to how to collect your data.
You analyze the data collected in order to test the hypothesis. Based on stronger test of
logic and evidence before you, you can accept or reject the null hypothesis. Of course, when you reject a
null hypothesis, you accept the alternative and vise versa. The acceptance or rejection of a null hypothesis
is based on some level of significance otherwise called alpha (α) level of significance.
When you choose the 5% or 0.05 alpha levels, it shows that out of 100 replications of your experiment
sampling error will account for 5% of the results. In other words 95% probability that any difference
between the experimental treatment. This is to say that if you conduct the experiment 100 times 95 of
them will be correct while 5% will have error due to chance or sampling error. A more rigorous test of
significance is the 1% (0.01) alpha level.
10
WRITING RESEARCH REPORTS
In all applied research studies, these basic stages of activities are mechanically followed in the process of
investigating problems peculiar to the various specific areas of life. In writing the research report, the
impersonal mode is preferred for communication. Instead of stating that “I did this” or “I did that”, you
can say “the study was carried out……, the samples are…….,” the
research report will depend on the research philosophy and the culture of the institution, organization or
the department in control.
The arrangement of different parts of the report should make it possible for a reader to easily locate any
section of particular interest to him. To provide a guideline, a conventional format for arranging research
reports in these/dissertations is explained. A particular thesis need not have all the sections therefore;
relevant sections would be used in the appropriate order. The format is as follows:
11
COMPONENTS OF REVIEW ESSAY
A. Preliminary pages
Title page
Declaration
Certification
Approval page
Acknowledgements
Dedication
Table of contents
Abstract
B. Main Body
The main body of the report should comprise of the following chapters:
Chapter One (Introduction, aim and objectives, justification, research
significance and any other relevant information)
Chapter Two (Review of Literature on the topic)
Chapter Three (Summary, Conclusions, Recommendations and References)
COMPONENTS OF PROJECT
C.
Preliminar
y pages
Fly leaf
Title page
Declaration
Certification
Approval page
Acknowledgements
Dedication
Table of contents
List of Appendices
List of Tables List of Plates
List of Figures
Abstract
12
D. Main
Body
The main body of the project should com prise the following chapters:
Chapter One (Introduction, aim and objectives, justification, research
significance, research problems, research hypothesis and any other relevant
information)
Chapter Two (Literature Review)
Chapter Three (Materials and methods)
Chapter Four (Results)
Chapter Five (Discussion, Conclusion and Recommendations)
Terminal part
References - APA
Glossary – if available
Appendices- if available
Typing format
The project should be typed in double line spacing, Times New Roman, font size 12.
Pages in the main body should be numbered in Arabic numerals while preliminary
The headings of the first line of each chapter shall appear capitalized as “CHAPTER”
and centralized, followed by the chapter number in words e.g “CHAPTER TWO”. The
Chapter title shall appear on the second line and directly below the first.
Example:
13
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
Fly leaf: This shall be the front page and shall be blank
Title page: This shall bear the approved title of the project and all shall be
capitalized, at the top of the page. Full name of the student shall all be capitalized
followed by the Degree for which the Review Essay/Project was submitted in the
following words:
Biology”.
Then followed by the month and year of submission at the bottom (centralized)
of the page.
Declaration:
This page shall contain the following statement of declaration by the candidate:
Certification:
14
This page shall bear a signed statement by the candidate’s supervisor(s) certifying that the
research work and preparation of thesis were carried out under his/her/their supervision. The
format shall be: “This is to certify that the research/review work titled
“…………………………..” by …. (name of the candidate with registration number in
parentheses) was carried out under my/our supervision”. The initials and surname(s) of the
supervisor(s), and the Head of
Department shall appear above their respective signatures.
Approval:
This page shall bear a statement certifying that the thesis has been examined and approved for the
specialization)”.
The statement shall be signed (with their names and dates clearly given) by the following, namely:
the External Examiner, Supervisor(s), Head of Department. Example “This is to certify that this
Review Essay/Project titled
“………………………” prepared and submitted by
……………(NAS/BIO/17/…. has been examined and approved in partial fulfillment of the
requirements for the award of degree of BSc. Biology.
____________________ _______________________
Supervisor Sign and Date
____________________ _______________________
Project Coordinator Sign and Date
____________________ _______________________
Head of Department Sign and Date
____________________ _______________________
External Examiner Sign and Date
15
• Acknowledgements:
The author shall acknowledge in his/her own words the assistance given by others
The author may, if he/she deems it fit, dedicate his/her work to any person(s) or
corporate bodies.
• Table of Content:
This shall contain a list of all the major component parts of the thesis listed in Section A
and the respective pages on which they begin, starting with report. The headings of the
major component parts of the thesis shall have all letters capitalized as in the thesis. Only
the first letter of all words in the major section headings shall be capitalized. For subjection
Abstract
The purpose of this section is to provide a brief and comprehensive summary of the study. It
should be accurate, self-contained, concise and specific not more than 250 words. Avoid citing
references in the abstract, use past tense for methodology and present
(i.e., do not use indentation). It is of good idea to write this section last (after all of the
• Background, which includes information about the problem (brief outline of the statement
of the problem)
• Purpose of the study (aim (s) and objective(s))
• Methods
The introduction is a brief section, which addresses the relevance of your research and includes a
short history or relevant background that leads to a statement of the problem that is being
investigated. Introductions usually follow a funnel style, starting from broadly and then moving
to narrowing. The funnel goes from something known to something unknown, i.e. the introduction
should start out broad and becomes more and more specific. For instance, you might begin by
defining any relevant terms. Then, go on to review the relevant literature. One should avoid an
exhaustive and historic review. The literature should make a clear connection between previous
research and the present one. You might include any hypothesis and the rationale for it. The final
section in the introduction should contain a statement which clearly and explicitly states why
the
It is good for one to familiarize oneself on how to retrieve relevant literature for the
2. Annual reviews
Google; www.google.com
Bing: www.bing,com
CHAPTER THREE
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The purpose of this section is to describe in detail how you performed the study. Someone should
be able to replicate your study based on the information you provided in this section. Therefore,
make it sound professional that is do not make it sound like a class project. Methods are written
as a process description in a reported speech, not a laboratory manual procedure. When writing
this section, you should be precise, complete, and concise: Include only relevant information, no
unnecessary details, excuses, or confessions. The following points should be taken into
Detailed experimental procedures (in reported speech)
Describe techniques tracking variables such as timing, temperature, humidity etc and the
rationale for tracking those variables
Explain the analytical techniques used (not forgetting the sources of those techniques i.e.
references).
CHAPTER FOUR
RESULTS
The results section DESCRIBES but does not INTERPRET the major findings of your research.
Present the data using graphs and tables to show any trends that you found and describe these
Vertical and horizontal lines are not acceptable in tables presentation as shown below:
A B C D
MA 20 13 18
MB 25 17 20
MC 15 23 21
MD 11 27 20
However, it is only the two upper and one terminal horizontal lines that are acceptable,
as shown below:
A B C D
MA 20 13 18
MB 25 17 20
MC 15 23 21
MD 11 27 20
Or:
Replications
Levels
1 2 3
MA 20 13 18
MB 25 17 20
MC 15 23 21
MD 11 27 20
Note that as a rule, only one Table of results should be presented per page.
As a rule, all tables must be preceded with description in words and with
CHAPTER FIVE
DISCUSSION, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
This section offers your interpretation and conclusion about your findings. How do your results
relate to the aim of the study, as stated in your introduction, and how do they relate to the results
that might have been expected from background information obtained in lectures, textbooks or
outside readings. It is expected of you to demonstrate your ability to synthesize, analyze, evaluate,
interpret and reason effectively. You need to think carefully about your findings in order to draw
Interpret your results: evaluate, analyze, and explain the significance and implications of
your work. And further include, generalization that you can draw
from your results, principles that you support/disprove, and conclusion about
theoretical and / or practical implications.
Explain key limitations: questions left unanswered, major experimental constraints, lack
of correlation and negative results
Discuss agreement or contrast with previously published work(s)
State your conclusion clearly. Conclusion should only be drawn from the findings in
the results or statistical inference and not from theoretical notes conclusion should
relate to the objectives.
When drawing conclusion, it is important to note that tables of results should be put into
consideration. There must be conclusion for each table of result, separated in sentences,
Recommendations should only be made based on the challenges encountered in the course
of carrying out the project or based on some very important observations, and not from
theoretical notes.
REFERENCES
Any citations made in the manuscripts must be presented in this section
Authors/ date system should be used in this section as recommended by American
Psychological Association (APA) style and not numbering system
Multiple authors should be separated with comma and the last author with “and”
For each author, give the last name followed by comma and then initials List of authors must
be arranged alphabetically.
Numbering or use of bullets is not recommended in APA style of referencing.
FOR JOURNAL ARTICLES - Names and initials of all authors, year of publication, title of
the article, title of the journal (to be written in italics), volume, and numbers of first and last
pages should be clearly written eg.
Muhammad, A. S., Ibrahim, B. S. and Aminu, S. A. (2014) A novel biosynthesis,
characterization, and microbial activity of silver nanoparticles using aqueous leaves extract of
10-16.
FOR TEXT BOOKS: Names and initials of the author, title of the book (in italics), publisher,
town or country of publication and number of pages in the whole book should be clearly
written e.g.
February, 2016.
publication, title of the article, website and the date retrieved e.g.
WHO (2007). Guidelines on standard operating procedures for the laboratory diagnosis of HIV
2007.
GLOSSARY
The glossary in any case, shall contain a list and explanations of foreign, indigenous, obsolete or
technical words used in the text. For science based disciplines internationally accepted standard
abbreviation of scientific names not spelt out in the text may be explained here. All other
APPENDICES
(i) Matters related to data collection e.g. sample of questionnaires and other test
instruments.
(iv) Computer program, especially if it was written or modified by the candidate, and the
output.
TABLE
Tables shall be numbered consecutively in Arabic numerals in the order in which they are
mentioned in the text. A table shall have a descriptive heading typed above it, starting from the
left hand side. Only the first letters of the major words of the heading shall be capitalized. eg.
Table 4. Variation of Magnetic Field With Latitude. A table heading shall not be underlined. The
FIGURES
Graphs, charts, maps histograms and other line diagrams shall be drawn neatly. Charts and maps
shall be clearly labeled. Keys and scales should be included in the figures where appropriate. The
Figures in each chapter shall be numbered consecutively in Arabic numerals in the order in which
they are cited in the text. Each figure shall have a descriptive title, which shall be typed
immediately below the figure. Only the first letter of the major words shall be
Plates, as a rule are photoprints, but herein also include scanned images. They may be direct
by use of a special equipment, e.g. electron microscope. Plate shall be used only where they best
You have to distinguish between data stored for institutional monitoring and confidential strictly and those
meant for public use. When you want to use any data belonging to an institution, professional ethics require
that you seek prior consent from such institution before utilizing such data for purpose of research and
publication of publication of findings.
According to Evans and Jakupee (1996); Every research should not expose individuals to risks of course
unjustified political, personal, economic, physical, emotional, moral and psychological harm. No researcher
should undertake any researcher should undertake any research which violates principles of free informed
content. You should be truthful, honest and objective in caring out your research investigations.