Professional Documents
Culture Documents
N
egotiations leading up to and machine operators working effects of some practices in improved
an international climate without the aid of detailed maps or forest management (improved road
change agreement to replace supervision (Protocol S1). Numerous planning, bridge construction, stream
the Kyoto Protocol in 2012 have studies have demonstrated that with protection). Also, our estimate of the
included consideration of reduced appropriate harvest planning of log production forest area most likely
emissions due to deforestation and extraction paths, coupled with worker under-represents the actual area where
degradation (REDD). This option training in directional felling, 50% or logging takes place.
has figured prominently in the “road more of this collateral damage can be Use of improved timber harvesting
map” toward such an agreement that avoided (Protocol S1). Implementing practices in the tropical forests
was agreed upon during the 13th these basic reduced-impact logging designated for logging would retain
Conference of Parties to the United techniques, as we show below, could at least 0.16 gigatons of carbon per
Nations Framework Convention substantially reduce global carbon year (Gt C y −1) (Figure 2). Most of the
on Climate Change held in Bali in emissions from forest degradation. emission reductions from improved
December 2007 (http://www.unfccc. We illustrate the carbon benefits of forestry will be from the more
int/). Most ongoing discussions of improved forest management with a intensively logged forests in Asia, where
REDD focus on tropical deforestation, large-scale, long-term study in Malaysia emissions are largest. This reduced
while the potential carbon saving (Protocol S1). In forests subjected to annual rate of carbon emissions is
from reduced forest degradation is conventional logging, carbon emissions substantial. For comparison, the total
mostly disregarded [1,2]. Given that were over 100 tons per hectare (t ha−1) amount of carbon emitted due to
carbon losses due to degradation could (Figure 1). In contrast, where improved tropical deforestation is estimated
be of the same magnitude as those harvesting practices were used, these to be 1.5 Gt y −1 (or 20% of global
from deforestation, this disregard is initial losses were much lower, mainly anthropogenic emissions [1]). Thus,
worrisome [3,4]. We show here that due to reduced collateral damage. After the potential for emission reductions
substantial reductions of global CO2 30 years, the typical period after which through improved forest management
emissions can be achieved by improving loggers are allowed to return to an area is at least 10% of that obtainable by
forest management in the tropics, and for the next harvest, carbon stocks in curbing tropical deforestation.
argue that this cost-effective approach forests with improved management
to mitigation should be included in the are predicted to be at least 30 t ha-1 Citation: Putz FE, Zuidema PA, Pinard MA, Boot
RGA, Sayer JA, et al. (2008) Improved tropical forest
new climate change agreement. higher than those in conventionally management for carbon retention. PLoS Biol 6(7):
Worldwide, a total area of 350 logged forests [7], and are probably e166. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.0060166
million hectares of tropical moist much higher in practice. In a similar Copyright: © 2008 Putz et al. This is an open-access
forests is designated as production study in Amazonian Brazil, where article distributed under the terms of the Creative
forest [5], about a quarter of which is forests are logged much less intensively Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in
managed by rural communities and [8], the benefit of improved timber any medium, provided the original author and source
indigenous people [6]. These forests harvesting practices was estimated to are credited.
are mainly exploited for timber, and be 7 t C ha−1. In both cases, improved
Abbreviations: Gt C y −1, gigatons of carbon per year;
given growing timber demand and management reduced carbon emissions REDD, reduced emissions due to deforestation and
increased forest access, logging is likely by approximately 30%, relative to degradation; t C ha −1, tons of carbon per hectare
to expand. Due to the high diversity conventional logging. Francis E. Putz is with the University of Florida,
of natural forests and limited markets The potential global contribution of Gainesville, Florida, United States of America and
for the timber of most tree species, improved tropical forest management with Pieter A. Zuidema and Rene G. A. Boot at Utrecht
University, Utrecht, The Netherlands. Michelle A.
loggers usually harvest only one to to carbon retention is substantial. Pinard is with the University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen,
20 trees per hectare. Unfortunately, Using information on intensities and Scotland, United Kingdom. Jeffrey. A. Sayer is with
for every tree logged in this selective intervals of logging, area of production IUCN World Conservation Union, Gland, Switzerland.
Douglas Sheil is with the Center for International
manner, some ten to 20 others are forest [5], and the above figures on Forestry Research, Bogor, Indonesia. Plinio Sist is with
severely damaged by untrained fellers carbon loss, we estimated the global CIRAD, the French Agricultural Research Centre for
International Development, Brasilia, Brazil. Elias is
consequences of improved tropical with Bogor Agricultural University, Bogor, Indonesia.
forest management (Protocol S1). We Jerome K. Vanclay is with Southern Cross University,
The Perspective section provides experts with a stress that this estimate is conservative, Lismore, New South Wales, Australia.
forum to comment on topical or controversial issues insofar as we lacked information * To whom correspondence should be addressed.
of broad interest. to scale up the carbon-retention E-mail: fep@botany.ufl.edu