You are on page 1of 4

THE

YOU CAN'T BUILD


SPORTPLANE
AN AIRPLANE BUILDER
WITHOUT NUTS By Antoni I Tony) Bingelis
EAA Designee Program Advisor
AND BOLTS
8509 Greenflint Lane
Austin, Texas 78759

a COURSE, YOU will use nuts and bolts. But, un-


less you use aircraft quality bolts and install them prop-
erly, you might as well try to build without them for
making inroads and in the process, complicating things
for maintenance and supply folks and the homebuilders
in particular. Some of the complexity stems from the
you will never be quite sure that they will hold things hardware manufactured under Military Standards (MS),
together under the flight conditions you will encounter. National Aerospace Standards (NAS) and others. But
Hardware stores and discount stores don't sell air- fear not. The AN standard hardware still meets most
craft quality bolts or nuts. Common steel bolts obtained homebuilt requirements and unless you want to use MS
from these sources must never be used in aircraft for or NAS standard hardware extensively, you shouldn't
structural purposes. Made of a low carbon (mild) steel experience much difficulty. Most supply sources for the
and having a rather low tensile strength (about 55,000 homebuilder stock the better known AN standard
psi), they lack the reliability needed in aircraft struc- hardware exclusively. Should they also have other types,
tures. they will most likely have it cross-referenced in their
These bolts are weak! They bend easily and are very catalogs.
susceptible to corrosion! You can recognize these AN bolts are made from a nickel alloy, corrosion-
hardware store bolts by their square, or hex heads, resistant steel and are heat treated to a minimum of
which are usually devoid of any identification markings. 125,000 pounds per square inch (psi). On the other hand,
Also, for the most part, these bolts have coarse threads similar NAS or MS standard steel bolts are rated at as
and are ordinarily used with plain nuts having no self- high (or higher) a tensile strength, with 160,000 psi
locking capability. being most prevelant.
Common steel bolts might be all right to use in mak- AN bolts range in diameter from the AN3, which is a
ing picnic benches and portable barbeque grills but not 3/16" or (1032) bolt, up through the AN20 d'/i" diame-
for use in making airplanes . . . not if you value your ter) bolts. In supply catalogs, and on plans, aircraft bolts
life! Even go-cart builders use aircraft hardware and are normally listed by their AN number. The AN
they don't fly (not high, at any rate). Yes, most ul- number is usually followed by a dash and other number
tralight builders use aircraft bolts, too. And I would like and/or letters to denote the bolt length and whether or
to believe that all builders are informed enough to insist not the head and shank are drilled for safetying pur-
on using aircraft bolts and aircraft quality hardware poses. No need to memorize these dash numbers . . .
throughout their aircraft. simply refer to any homebuilt supply catalog and it will
Would you believe it? In this weird economy of ours all be listed for you . . . including the price, of course.
you can often purchase aircraft bolts less expensively
than some of the hardware store variety! So, indeed, Bolt Selection and Use Tips
contemplating the use of common hardware store bolts The AN3 bolt is the smallest diameter steel bolt ac-
is totally without merit. ceptable for use in the primary structure of your air-
craft. That is any structure, the failure of which could
Bolt Identification and Standards result in disastrous consequences. Wing attachment
There is no easy method for a part-time builder to bolts, landing gear bolts, propeller bolts, engine mount
become familiar with the various classes and types of bolts, etc., are examples of primary structure. Other
aircraft bolts because they are manufactured in count- areas, although less visible, may be equally important.
less shapes and with all kinds of markings. It is poor practice to cut additional threads on a
Aircraft bolt heads are code marked for identification longer bolt and then to hacksaw it to the required
with embossed symbols. These markings indicate the length. For one thing, the cadmium plated protection
material from which the bolt is made . . . and often the against corrosion would be lost. In addition, workshop
manufacturer who made it. Sometimes the head displays threading seems to weaken a bolt at the point where the
only an asterisk or a simple X to identify it as a stan- thread ends . . . so, don't use these modified bolts in
dard corrosion-resistant steel aircraft bolt. Several of the highly stressed locations.
more commonly used bolt types are illustrated in Figure There may be a time when a bolt fits just a bit too
1. loosely to suit you. Did you know that there is a toler-
At one time there was only one general standard for ance in the standard bolt diameters of the same AN
aircraft bolts. Because the military aviation was the number? Take as an example an AN3 bolt. It is a 3/16"
biggest user, the Army (Air Corps) and Navy decided to bolt and its diameter will mike out to .189" plus .000" to
establish a series of special bolts to be known as the AN minus .003". So you see, because of that leeway, one bolt
series. The AN bolt standard is still very much the one could fit snugly while another might be a bit loose. If
used in general aviation although other standards are you have a situation like that you might sort through
14 NOVEMBER 1979
STANDARD AN AIRFRAME BOLTS COMMON COMMERCIAL BOLTS

LOOK FOR AN X" OR A '-(-"OR AN * ON THE HEAD


(MANUFACTURER'S NAME NOT ALWAYS SHOWN)

FINE THREAD
(NF) USUALLY NO
HEAD MARKINGS DON'T USE THEM I

HIGH
TEMPERATURE
ELASTIC NUTS
STOP NUT

AN 960 WASHERS __-


O.K. USE ANY OF THESE BOLTS (STANDARD USE) AN 970 WOOD WASHERS

SELF-LOCKING NUTS
(MANY VARIETIES)
CLOSE TOLERANCE'BOLT

ALUMINUM ALLOY BOLT / STANDARD NUT


(62,000 PSI TENSILE STRENGTH
CASTLE NUTS A STANDARDIZED BOLT
4 \ INSTALLATIONS
1 I AS ILLUSTRATED

THG BOLT IS s~s\


IF THE NUT TOO LONG ...

i <^j hj) nil1


IB ^ /^^v
C
°ME. rr-m.

MvJH
f
, — ...._«._.„

'

HEAD UP
HEAD FORWARD
f C i lOCT^HTAU

FOR YOU)
UV\Di/C

-TOO MANY THREADS


SHOWING
(GfUMTY WORKS FOR YOU)
USE A SHORTER BOLT OR
ADD WASHER(S)

AVOID CANTILEVER BOLT INSTALLATIONS


USE DRILLED BOLTS AND
IF THE NUTS COME OFF-
CASTLE NUTS WITH COTTER
PINS IN MOUNTING ENGINE

^^x
IMBEDDED WASHER
(TOO MUCH TORQUE ON NUT)"

AN BOLT

- THIS TAIL SPRING WOULD -


FALL OFF- DIAMETER.
(PLUS.OOO -.OOJ )

(WHETHER THE BOLTS


TYPICAL SPRING GEAR
ARE INSTALLED HEAOS-UP
INSTALLATION
OR AS SHOWN)

THREAD LENGTH-
AN 3 - J/s"
AN 4 - r/'t~
AN 5 - 7//«"
AN 6 - I/It'

EXHAUST MANIFOLD NUTS


(BRASS)
(DO MOT SUBSTITUTE STEEL NUTS) SOMETIMES BOLTS MUST BE
INSTALLED HEAD DOWN DUE TO
LACK OF ACCESS

SPORT AVIATION 15
your bolts to find the best fitting one. stems from the premise that if, in the most unlikely
As you let your fingers sweep across your favorite event a nut comes off, the bolt will not fall out and the
supply catalog you may learn that you still have a bit of assembly will not come apart. Logical enough but it will
a problem in determining the exact length bolt you not always work. Sometimes the bolt can only be in-
need. A lot of catalogs list only the total length from the serted from one direction and if it happens to be from
bottom of the bolt head to the end of the bolt. Since the the bottom . . . well, so be it. In other instances, should
threaded portion must not bear in the structure or fit- the nut come off some assemblies would still come apart
ting . . . how long must the bolt be to provide the needed (fail) even though the bolt was installed in the classical
grip length? Maybe this will help. head-up position. Indeed, if you can, do insert the bolt
Aircraft bolts have a relatively short threaded por- head up and/or forward if at all practical. If not, you will
tion which makes up approximately •%" of an AN3 bolt . not be violating regulations or inviting dire consequ-
.. 7/16" of an AN4 or AN5 bolt and about 9/16" of the ences.
larger bolts. This severely limits the use of any bolt Here is another one most builders accept as gospel:
lengths to a very narrow range because only the shank "Never use an elastic stop nut with a drilled bolt."
(grip) portion is designed to carry shear loads. When you The edges of the bolt hole, supposedly, will tear the
install a bolt, its shank must be long enough that the fiber locking feature and destroy its self-locking provi-
threads are not used in bearing. To put that another sion. Again, this is not so. Of course, if there is a burr
way . . . not more than one thread of the bolt should be around the cotter pin hole (most unlikely), it could do
permitted to bear inside a fitting. If it does, use the next some damage . . . but to destroy the elastic stop nut's
size longer bolt. You may have noticed from catalogs self-locking capability, most unlikely!
that bolts are obtainable in graduated lengths of '/»" in- How about this one?
crements. Sometimes the next size longer bolt will be a "Never, never re-use an elastic self-locking nut."
bit too long but you can use up to two standard washers Wrong again. These nuts can be re-used any number
to fill in. of times . . . perhaps as many as 50 times without reduc-
It has already been pointed out that AN bolts, for ing the self-locking feature. The obvious check for most
any particular diameter, vary by approximately .003". If any self-locking nut is that it should not be possible to
you need a very snug fit in a metal-to-metal bolt instal- spin on the nut completely without your fingers. If it
lation you should drill the hole slightly undersized and goes on that easily, the self-locking feature is "kaput".
ream it to size. When such a tight fit is required you However, here I am falling into the same trap of making
should use close tolerance bolts. These bolts are iden- a sweeping generalization. There are self-locking nuts
tified by an embossed triangle on the bolt head. Close which spin onto the bolt all the way with the fingers
tolerance bolts are accurately machined after cadmium and the self-locking feature does not engage until the
plating. This results in very uniform diameters between nut is torqued.
bolts. The manufactured tolerance is listed as .0005" or And speaking of torque. How about this one:
less. "All nuts and bolts in aircraft work must be tor-
qued with a calibrated torque wrench."
Aluminum Alloy Bolts Not bad advice at all, really, but in real life it is
With builders becoming more weight conscious and often impractical and sometimes ineffective. Most buil-
with more and more ultralight aircraft making the ders and mechanics don't use a torque wrench except for
scene, I expect the use of aluminum alloy bolts will in- engine work. To reduce the risk of overtorquing use a
crease. The rule for conventional aircraft has been to short handled wrench. This is important because I doubt
never use aluminum bolts in the primary structure in that any homebuilder will ever be guilty of under-
diameters of less than 1A", Aluminum bolts are normally torquing a nut . . . if he does, it will most likely be be-
used in shear applications — never in tension. Install cause he forgot to tighten it in the first place. Most
aluminum bolts with aluminum nuts. Although there is builders apply too much torque to nuts and bolts . . .
no prohibition against the use of an aluminum nut on a especially to the small AN3 bolts. AN3 bolts can be
steel bolt, I don't like that practice. Mixing aluminum snapped off because the nuts are designed not to strip.
and steel nuts and bolts is an undesirable practice par- Bolts in wood structures can rarely be torqued to the
ticularly when the assembly is one in a seaplane. The ideal chart value without crushing some of the soft wood
potential for serious corrosion is great any time unpro- fibers. Here's a useful tip for torquing nuts and bolts
tected dissimilar metals, in close contact, are exposed to used in wood structures. Tighten the nut until you see
salt water or spray. the washer slightly emboss itself into the wood. Stop
Aluminum alloy bolts and nuts are not suitable for right there. Do not continue to tighten the nut until the
use in locations where they must be frequently removed washer sinks all the way into the wood surface!
for maintenance or inspection because they do not toler- I'm sure you heard this one before:
"Never turn the bolt head . . . always torque the
ate repeated removal and reinstallation.
You can identify an aluminum bolt from its head nut."
markings, two raised dashes, and a comparatively light
Again, a dreamer's ideal. Well, if you can't do it any
weight. They are quite strong for their weight and are
other way, obviously, the bolt head will have to be
rated at a tensile strength of approximately 65,000 psi. turned with the wrench. The need to do this arises in lo-
cations where nutplates are installed and you may even
find it necessary to do the same thing in other as-
Always Do It This Way . . . Sometimes semblies. But logic will tell you that turning the bolt
There is a lot of what you might call folklore passed should be avoided normally as there is a tendency for
around about aircraft bolts and how and where they the cadmium to rub off the bolt and for the hole to be-
should be used. Most of these revelations are based on come enlarged, however slightly.
logic, certainly, but in making their rounds, the truth
tends to become a bit bent. For example: Aircraft Washers
"It is mandatory for bolts to be installed with their The standard washer is 1/16" thick and is available
heads up or forward facing the slipstream." in two types for each of the most commonly used bolt
Not so really. It is a good customary practice but diameters. The smaller diameter washer is known as the
that is far from being a governmental edict. The origin AN960, and the larger diameter washer, the AN970.
16 NOVEMBER 1979
The larger washer is often called a wood washer because The two types of self-locking nuts (all-metal type and
it is used most frequently against wood surfaces to pro- fiber-lock type) are interchangeable except that the
vide a larger bearing surface. fiber-locking type may not be used in locations where
Plain washers are used in bolt installations to pre- the temperatures exceed 250°F. Metal self-locking nuts
sent a smooth level bearing surface for either the bolt are used in places where temperatures exceed 250°F and
head or nut . . . sometimes both. Use a washer under the may run as high as 400°F.
part to be torqued, be it the nut or bolt head or under Elastic stop nuts may be reused many times, cer-
both if you deem it necessary. Any place a bolt is not tainly until the fiber has lost its locking friction or has
perpendicular to the surface may require the use of a become brittle with age. If you can turn the nut up all
tapered shim or specially made tapered washer. the way with your fingers, replace it.
Since bolt lengths are made in '/&" increments,
washers may sometimes be necessary to obtain the cor-
rect grip length for a bolt that is a little too long. A
maximum of two standard 1/16" thick washers are suffi- Shear Nuts
cient to correct for a slightly long bolt. If not, use the Shear nuts, either the self-locking or castle types, are
next size shorter bolt. easily recognized. They are those thin looking nuts and
Steel lock washers may be used as a locking feature they are used most often with clevis bolts. Never use
for plain nuts but do not place a steel lock washer shear nuts where the installation is subjected to tension
against an aluminum alloy nut or aluminum fitting. loading.

TORQUE TABLE DRILL SIZES

TORQUE PILOT HOLE FINAL DRILL


(Inch pounds) (drill size) (or ream size)
AN 3 (1032 or 3(16) 20-25 No. 21 (.159) No. 11 (.191)
AN 4 (1/4) 50-85 7/32 (.2187) 1/4 (250)
AN 5(5/16) 100- 160 9/32 (.2812) 5/16 (.3125)
AN 6 (3/8) 160 - 220 11/32 (.3437) 3/8 (.375)
AN 7 (7/16) 430 - 580 13/32 (.4062) 7/16 (.4375)
AN 8 (1/2) 480 • 690 15/32 (.4687) 1/2 (.500)
AN 9 (9/16) 800 - 1000 17/32 (.531) 9/16 (.5625)
AN 10 (5/8) 1100- 1400 19/32 (.594) 5/8 (625)

FIGURE 2

Nuts Castle Nuts


If you are a newcomer to the realm of homebuilt air- These nuts have no self-locking provision so they
craft and aircraft maintenance, you may be surprised to must be secured to the bolt mechanically with a cotter
learn that aircraft bolts do not come with nuts. Each nut pin or safety wire or some sort of clip, otherwise they
and bolt is bought separately. Primarily, I suppose, be- might loosen under vibration.
cause of the very large variety of nuts which are availa- The castle nut is slotted and requires a bolt with a
ble for specific aircraft requirements. drilled hole to accept a cotter pin. Regular castle nuts
Aircraft nuts have no identifying markings or letter- are rugged and capable of withstanding high tension
ing on them but they are made of the same material as loads.
the bolts. Be careful when using a castle nut on a clevis bolt in
All nuts can be started with the fingers. If a nut the control system where rudder pedals or other linkage
gives you trouble in this regard, better recheck the might interfere with other parts. Cotter pins have a way
threads . . . they may be coarse instead of fine. Aircraft of snagging.
nuts and bolts do sometimes have coarse threads al-
though they are rarely used by homebuilders. Torquing
Except as a last resort, do not torque a bolt by turn-
Self-Locking Nuts and Nut Safetying Features ing it.
All nut/bolt installations in your aircraft should have Tighten or torque castellated nuts as you would any
some safety features to prevent their loosening in ser- other standard nut. If the slots and cotter pin hole in the
vice. Methods employed include the self-locking nuts, bolt will not line up for safetying, tighten the nut to the
cotter-key combinations, jam nuts, lockwashers, palnuts, next slot even though the recommended torque values
and still found in primitive areas, peening of the bolt will be exceeded. This overtorquing leeway applies only
end with a hammer. to castle nuts and not others.
Self-locking nuts are, by far, the most commonly Cotter pins when used should fit snugly but not so
used type of nuts as they require no external help for tight you have to hammer them into the bolt hole. Bend
safetying. The nuts feature an integral safetying provi- the ends so that one end is over the end of the bolt
sion as part of their construction. reaching to its center or slightly beyond. The other leg
Self-locking nuts are used because they provide tight is bent snugly against the nut.
shake-proof installations which can withstand continued Coarse threads require slightly less torque and so do
severe vibration. They must not, however, be used in shear nuts. Actually, about Vi the amount of torque is
any joint or connection where either the nut or bolt is sufficient for them.
subject to rotation. Self-locking nuts may be used with And, finally, even if you don't use a torque wrench .
any antifriction bearings (rod ends) or control pulleys . no self-respecting homebuilder will ever allow himself
but only if the inner race of the bearing is clamped to a to be caught using a pair of pliers to tighten a nut. (Oh,
fitting (or part of the structure) by a bolt and nut. the shame of it all!)
SPORT AVIATION 17

You might also like