Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A supply chain is the alignment of firms that bring products or services to market
– Lambert, Stock, and Ellram.
A supply chain consists of all stages involved, directly or indirectly, in fulfilling a customer
request. The supply chain not only includes the manufacturer and suppliers, but also
transporters, warehouses, retailers, and customers themselves
– Chopra and Meindl
A supply chain is a network of facilities and distribution options that performs the functions
of procurement of materials, transformation of these materials into intermediate and
finished products, and the distribution of these finished products to customers
– Ganeshan and Harrison
5
Supply Chain Management
Supply Demand
Supply Chain Management is the
design and management of processes
across organizational boundaries with the
goal of matching supply and demand in
the most cost-effective way.
6
Milestones in Supply Chain
7
Milestones in Supply Chain
1970s – 1980s :
i. Manufacturing Resource Planning (MRPII) and Distribution
Requirements Planning (DRP) introduced
ii. Tracking of consignments introduced by FedEx
1980s – 1990s :
i. ERP introduced
ii. The concept of Continuous Replenishment introduced
iii. Cross-docking introduced by Walmart
iv. The make-to-order fulfillment model introduced by Dell
1990s – 2000s :
i. Direct order fulfillment from manufacturers introduced by Amazon
ii. The Toyota Production System (TPS) introduced to the western world
in the form of LEAN
iii. Concept of third-party logistics providers introduced
8
Recent Developments in Supply Chain
9
Evolution of Supply Chain
10
Evolution of Supply Chain
EVOLVING TOTAL
FRAGMENTATION
INTEGRATION INTEGRATION
Prior to 1960
1960 to 2000 2000+
Demand forecasting
Purchasing
Requirements planning
Production planning Materials Management
Manufacturing inventory
Warehousing Logistics
Materials handling
Industrial packaging
Finished goods inventory
Distribution planning Physical Distribution
Order processing
Transportation
Customer service
11
Materials Management
i. Materials Management involved all activities related to the supplies of all materials and
services into the organisation for consumption.
ii. Materials Management included the following:
i. Materials and inventory planning
ii. Procurement
iii. Transportation (in-bound)
iv. Storage
v. Inventory Management
vi. Production planning and control
iii. Materials management therefore, was primarily concerned with the input phase of the
supply chain
12
Physical Distribution
i. Physical distribution involved all activities related to the transfer of finished goods from
the producer to the end customer, typically through a set of intermediaries viz.
distributors, wholesalers and retailers.
ii. Physical distribution included the following:
a. Storage of finished goods
b. Inventory management of finished goods
c. Distribution planning
d. Transportation (out-bound)
iii. Physical distribution was therefore primarily concerned with the output phase of the
supply chain
13
Order fulfillment
14
Logistics
Logistics
Sources of
supply Plants/operations Customers
15
Supply Chain
Logistics management
16
Logistics vs. Supply Chain
Logistics refers to activities that occur within the boundaries of a single organization
and supply chains refer to networks of companies that work together and coordinate
their actions to deliver a product to market. In other words, Logistics is confined to a
single organization whereas Supply Chain Management encompasses multiple
organizations
Logistics is involved with the flow and storage of goods and services. The ambit of
Supply Chain Management is wider and involves procurement, conversion and delivery
to the end customers. Therefore, Logistics is a part of Supply Chain Management.
Supply Chain Management includes all of traditional logistics functions and also
covers activities such as marketing, new product development, finance and customer
service.
17
Supply Chain Stakeholders
Intermediate
Raw material End product
product
suppliers manufacturers
manufacturers
18
Flows in a Supply Chain
Upstream
Suppliers’ Customers’
Supplier Fund Customer
Suppliers’ Customers’
Supplier Manufacturer Distributor Retailer Customer
Supplier Customer
Downstream
19
Cost versus Responsiveness
20
Objectives of Supply Chain Management
21
Major Challenges in a Supply Chain
Inaccurate
forecasts and Poor end-to-end
uncertainties of visibility of the supply
demand and supply chain
22
Aligning Supply Chain with Business Strategy
Understand the
market
Develop that the company
needed serves
supply chain
capabilities
Define core
competencies
of the company
23
Evolving Structure of Supply Chains
24
Understanding markets
25
Critical Considerations in a Supply Chain
i. Demand planning
ii. Dependent and independent demand systems
iii. MRP, MRP-II, ERP
iv. Demand patterns – random, trend and seasonality
components
v. Qualitative forecasting techniques
vi. Quantitative forecasting techniques
vii. Accuracy of forecasting models
29
Supply Chain Planning
Objective of Supply Chain Planning is to generate a demand plan and develop a supply plan to
meet that demand in the best possible manner
Supply Chain
Planning
Supply
Demand
Planning
Planning
30
Demand Planning
i. The objective of demand planning is to estimate the market demand and fulfil
the demand by producing and delivering the necessary goods and services
31
Factors which influence demand
32
Prioritizing demand
Prioritizing production or
changing the product mix to
fulfil the demand
Prioritizing or altering
distribution to warehouses or
retailers
Prioritizing customers
based on profile and
segmentation
33
Integration of demand and supply plans
Strategic business
Demand plan
plans
Capacity
Sales and Operations
(Resource)
Plan (S & OP)
Plan
Production Plan
34
Synchronizing demand and supply plans
i. Once the demand plan is finalized, it serves as an input to Sales and Operational Plan
(S & OP).
ii. The S & OP is also influenced by the strategic business plans which relate to the
organizational goals
iii. The S & OP is a consensus reached between the demand and supply teams based on
iv. The S & OP commits the sales team to sell and the production team to produce
v. The S & OP then triggers off Production Planning and Capacity Planning
35
Capacity Planning
36
Master Scheduling
i. The Master schedule is a format which takes into account the demand, the
production plan, backlogs, availability of material and capacity
ii. The Master Schedule is used to create the Master Production Schedule (MPS)
iii. The Master Production Schedule (MPS) is a weekly plan which details the
product mix to be produced with the quantities and dates
37
Material Requirements Planning
ii. The system calculates the requirements of materials and schedules supply to
meet the demand
38
Dependent and Independent Demand
i. Independent demand
a. Demand for an item carried in inventory is independent of the demand for any
other item in inventory
b. Demand for finished goods and spares is independent
c. Demands are estimated from forecasts and/or customer orders
39
Material Requirements Planning
ii. Bill of Materials (BOM) – The BOM details the configuration of the product by
showing the relationship between the components and sub-assemblies.
iv. The MPS, BOM and Inventory are the main components of the MRP system
40
Material Requirements Planning
X = (A X B) – C where
A = MPS quantities
B = BOM quantities
C = Inventory quantities
X = Action needed
41
Material Requirements Planning
MRP system
‘explodes’ requirements
Bill of materials (BOM) Inventory data
Includes lead times
Produces net requirements
Management reports
What should be ordered
What should be expedited
Which orders should be cancelled
42
Material Requirements Planning
a. Requirements
b. Coverage of requirements
c. Exceptions
43
Manufacturing Resource Planning (MRP-II)
44
Distribution Requirements Planning (DRP)
45
Push and Pull Distribution Strategies
ii. In the push system, the distribution is planned centrally and pushed to the
downstream warehouses. The volumes are worked out mainly based on
forecasts
iii. In the Pull system, the downstream partners place their orders upstream to
‘pull’ the volume
46
Distribution Requirements Planning (DRP)
iii. Once the distribution volume requirements are worked out, DRP provides
an input to the Master Schedule to plan for production
47
Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP)
ii. ERP extends the capabilities of MRP and MRP-II to all functions of the enterprise
48
Forecasting
Forecasting
i. Forecasting is the method of estimating or predicting the future trend or a future event
iv. However, forecasts are never accurate and are always associated with some errors.
v. We should be able to forecast the average within some given band of variation (with a
certain level of confidence)
50
Qualitative Forecasting
i. Usually based on judgments about causal factors that affect the variable of
interest
ii. Do not require a demand history for the product or service, therefore such
methods are useful for new products/services
iii. Approaches vary in sophistication from scientifically conducted surveys to
intuitive hunches about future events
iv. Most common Qualitative Methods are:
a. Executive committee consensus
b. Survey of sales force
c. Survey of customers
d. Delphi method
51
Delphi Method
effect.
iv. The panel members revise their forecasts in each round (taking the logic of the
vi. The process ends on convergence or after a certain number of rounds and the
52
Quantitative Forecasting
i. Based on the assumption that the “forces” which generated the past demand
will also generate the future demand
ii. Analysis of the past demand pattern provides a good basis for forecasting
future demand
iii. Majority of quantitative approaches fall in the category of time series analysis
iv. Causal Models (Regression) are used when the future values of the data do
not depend on time but on some other factors
53
Time Series
iii. Once the patterns are identified, they can be used to develop a forecast
54
Quantitative Forecasting Methods
i. Naïve Method
55
Random Demand Pattern
2350
Random Demand (No Trend or Seasonality)
2300
2250
2200
2150
2100
Jan Feb Mar Apr May June Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Demand Level
56
Random Pattern with Trend
700
Demand with Increasing Trend
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Demand Linear (Demand)
57
Demand Pattern – Random with
Trend and Seasonality
800
Demand with Trend and Seasonality
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Demand Linear (Demand)
58
Quantitative Methods
i. Naïve Method – In this method, the last period’s demand is projected as the
forecast for the next period.
ii. Simple Average – In this method, the simple average (sum of all the past data
divided by the number of data points) of the past data is used as an estimate of the
future.
iii. Moving Average – In this method, the moving average of the last ‘p’ periods is used
to forecast the future. Usually, the 3-month or 5-month moving averages are used.
The rationale in using this method is to consider only the recent data (last 3 or 5
months) and ignore the historical data.
iv. In Weighted Average Method, higher weights are attached to the recent-most data
and progressively lower and lower weights are attached to the data as we move
back into the past.
59
Simple Exponential Smoothing
Ft = aYt-1 + (1-a)Ft-1
60
Choice of the Smoothing Constant
iii. However, for stable markets, low values of a (0.1, 0.2 or max
0.25) are normally used
61
Forecasting with Trend and Seasonality
62
Outliers in Forecasting
Unusually high or unusually low demand should not be considered during forecasting as
these may be due to certain factors which are likely not to recur under normal circumstances
The corresponding data points should be eliminated from the time series
60 20
Exceptionally
40 High Demand
Demand
Demand
10
20
0
0 Unusually
1 5 9 131721 Low Demand
1 5 9 13 17 21
Period
Period
63
Forecast Error
i. Even with the highly sophisticated methods, forecasts are always associated
64
Accuracy of Forecasting Models
iii. Any one of the above measures may be used to compare one or more models
iv. Lower the value of MAD, MSE or MAPE, better is the forecasting model
65
Procurement in Supply
Chain
Module 3
Contents
i. Principles of procurement
ii. Objectives of procurement
iii. The procurement process
iv. The sourcing strategy
v. Negotiation
vi. Total Cost of Ownership
68
Procurement
69
Principles of Procurement
Right Quality Right Quantity Right Place Right Time Right Price Right Sources Right Process
70
Objectives of Procurement
A B C D
71
The Procurement Process
Identifying and
defining the
needs
Make or Buy
Contract / Analysis
Supplier
Management
Negotiation
Supplier
Tendering and pre-qualification
tender
evaluation
72
Identification of the need and developing specifications
ii. For works and services detailed Statement of Work (SoW) need to be
framed.
iii. The specifications need to be weighed and considered and not just
accepted as-is
73
Make or Buy Analysis
a. If the product or service is core to the organization and there is a need for in-
house control
ii. The benefits of ‘Make’ include higher control, improved quality control, workforce
remains stable, continuity of supply is assured, reduced risk, easier to amend
volumes/specification
74
Make or Buy Analysis
d. Cheaper to buy
75
The Sourcing Strategy
76
Supplier Pre-qualification
77
Supplier Pre-qualification Process
78
Supplier Pre-qualification Criteria
1 2 3 4 5
6 7 8 9 10
79
Tendering
The type, value and complexity of the procurement determine the nature of solicitation viz.-
i. Invitation to Tender (ITT) - this is a rather formal process used to solicit tenders from
suppliers and used mostly for projects, construction works or long-term contracts where
the value involved is high
ii. Request for Quotation (RFQ) – an informal process used to solicit price quotes (bids)
from potential suppliers mainly for low value purchases with well-defined specifications
or requirements
iii. Request for Proposal (RFP) – used to solicit proposals typically for performance type
specifications (technical, commercial or techno-commercial). The onus of defining the
scope of work is transferred to the supplier to a great degree.
80
Tendering types
i. Open Tendering – published in open media and any supplier can bid
ii. Closed Tendering – only selected and pre-qualified suppliers are invited to bid
iii. Negotiated Procedure – the buyer negotiates directly with one or more
suppliers when other tendering procedures have not yielded results, or there is
81
Tender Evaluation
82
Negotiation
83
Phases of Negotiation
Pre-Negotiation Phase
Conference or Meeting
Phase
Post-Negotiation Phase
84
Planning Phase of Negotiation
85
Negotiation approaches
i. Distributive :
a. Where each party tries to ‘claim’ maximum value of the ‘pie’ (tries to
claim a larger share of the fixed resources)
86
Negotiation approaches
i. Integrative:
a. A collaborative approach where the parties try to ‘create’ additional value and
attempt to reach a mutually beneficial agreement.
87
The Conference Phase of Negotiation
i. The Conference or Meeting Phase is the stage where the two parties exchange
ii. The meeting begins with the introduction, during which rapport is developed.
iii. Thereafter, the parties try to test the validity of assumptions made during planning.
iv. In the distributive approach, the parties then engage in bargaining where concessions
are exchanged. In the integrative approach, the parties try to innovate solutions which
88
The Post- Negotiation Phase
i. The Post-Negotiation Phase is the stage for final documentation and follow-up.
ii. This phase also helps to improve the relationship between the parties.
iii. Internal reviews are also held to share the learnings from the previous negotiation to
discuss which strategies worked and which did not.
89
Awarding
i. Once the price, terms and conditions are agreed upon and the purchase
authorized, the contract (or the purchase order as the case may be) is then
awarded.
ii. It is important that the purchase order is acknowledged by the supplier
iii. Purchase order could be for a one-off purchase or for a delivery against a
framework agreement
90
Supplier Management
91
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
Purchase Cost
Installation
Maintenance Operation
92
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
i. Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) involves a paradigm shift in the way assets are
procured (capital expenditure)
ii. The concept goes beyond price
iii. It involves determination of the total costs incurred throughout the life of the asset
or equipment. Hence, it is often referred to as Life Cycle Cost (LCC)
iv. It is estimated that the purchase price is only a small component of TCO ( often as
low as 25%). Hence, procurement decisions based on TCO are holistic and
economical in the long run
93
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
94
Value-added role of Procurement
In addition to achieving the ‘Rights’, Procurement has to add value to the
organization through:
i. Cost Reduction
v. Innovation
95
Transportation Planning
and Management
Module 4
Contents
98
Transportation
Transportation, a key
supply chain driver, is
the backbone of
logistics !
99
Transportation
ii. Transportation bridges various supply chain partners and links the
company with its suppliers and customers
iii. Transportation allows the flow of inventory in supply chain, both forward
and reverse
iv. Transportation provides place-utility by ensuring that the goods reach the
specific location timely and safely.
100
Parties involved in transportation
i. The Shipper – the party who wants to transport the product from one location to
another. The shipper wants to minimize the cost of transportation while providing a
certain level of responsiveness to customers
ii. The Carrier - the party or company which transports the product. The carrier makes
investment decisions regarding the transportation equipment (trucks, airplanes etc.) and
in some cases transportation infrastructure and then aims to maximize the return from
these assets.
iii. Besides the shipper and the carrier, the owners and operators of transportation
infrastructure such as roads, airports, ports etc. and the bodies that set transportation
policy worldwide are also important parties in transportation.
101
Modes of transportation
i. Road (Trucks)
ii. Railways
iii. Water
iv. Air
v. Pipeline
vi. Intermodal
102
Trucks
A truck is a vehicle
used to transport
goods by road.
Trucks vary in size,
power and carrying
capacity
103
Trucks
i. Trucks use the wide network of roads and can therefore transport goods from virtually
any point of origin to any point of destination, thus providing high flexibility
ii. Trucks can carry loads of varying shape, size and weight, thus providing high versatility
iii. Trucks can be used for point-to-point shipment, without the help of any other mode of
transport
iv. Truck carriers compete with air carriers for smaller distances ( less than 500 kms) and
compete with railways for longer distances. However, railways are preferred for long
distances if the load is higher (more than 25 MT).
104
Trucks
i. Smaller shipments [ 150 lbs (approx. 68kgs) to 20,000 lbs (approx. 9070 kgs)]
transported by trucks are called less-than-truckload(LTL) shipments.
ii. Shipments larger than 20,000 lbs (approx. 9MT) and up to 45,000 lbs (approx. 20
MT) are referred to as truck-load (TL) shipments since the shipment is expected to fill
up a full truck. However, with different configurations of truck (multi –axle, or multi-
trailers), the TL shipment size can go as high as 50 MT or even more.
iii. Shipments smaller than 150 lbs usually do not quality as LTL and are treated as
parcels. However, the actual choice of the mode of transport, (parcel or LTL) depends
not only on the weight but also on the dimension of the cargo.
105
Railways
106
Railways
ii. Railways incur high fixed costs in terms of tracks, locomotives, cars and yards. Thus,
asset utilization is an important performance criteria for railways.
iii. Operational issues like scheduling and maintenance, disruptions and delays lead to
poor on-time performance. However, the cost is low per unit of load for long distance
hauls
iv. Therefore, railway transportation is preferred for heavy, low-value and bulk shipments
that are not time-sensitive
107
Air transport
Most airlines
worldwide provide
passenger as well as
cargo services
108
Air transport
ii. Airlines also have high fixed costs and important objectives are to maximize the utilization of
aircrafts and to maximize revenue generated per flight
iii. Air transport is most suited for high-value, lightweight and time-sensitive nature of goods. It is
the preferred mode only when response time is more important than price considerations.
iv. For shorter distances, the total transit time often increases due to delays/congestion in
terminals.
109
Water transport
Water transport comprises inland waterways (such as rivers, lakes and canals); coastal
and intercoastal oceans; and international deep sea
110
Water transport
i. Water transport is widely used for international long-distance hauls where speed is
not critical.
ii. It is the cheapest mode of transport for low-value, high-bulk commodities but the
voyage time is a limitation which is often worsened by delays in ports due to
congestion or other factors.
iii. In water transport, both container ships and bulk carriers operate. The introduction of
very large crude carriers (VLCCs) and ultra large crude carriers (ULCCs) has played an
important role in redefining the way crude oil is transported from oil producing to oil
consuming countries
iv. Water carriers often tie up with other ocean carriers to enhance their coverage. Such
networks operate through large intermodal hubs such as Rotterdam or Hamburg.
111
Pipeline
112
Pipeline
i. Pipelines offer high dependability but can operate only in fixed routes
ii. They need high initial investment , but have low operating costs and are highly
economical when transporting large and constant volumes
iii. Pipelines are stationary carriers, that is, they don’t move. Instead, the cargo moves
iv. They can operate continuously 365 days a year and are not affected by seasons
113
Intermodal Transportation
114
Intermodal Transportation
TOFC COFC
Truck trailers or containers are placed on rail flatcars. Axles can be placed
under the containers so that they can be delivered by a truck
115
Intermodal Transportation
116
Intermodal Transportation
117
Intermodal Transportation
i. Land Bridge – land bridge is another form of intermodal transportation which uses a
combination of sea and rail/land transportation
ii. In the land bridge mode, containerized cargo is brought to a port, unloaded and
transported to another port by rail (or truck) and then loaded on to another vessel for
the second leg of sea transport.
iii. The advantages are:
a. The freight is carried in a single container for the whole journey
b. A single carrier (or freight forwarder) is responsible for the whole journey and
therefore a single bill of lading is used
c. The land leg of the journey reduces transit time compared to a continuous
voyage through the sea
118
Intermodal Transportation
119
The Intermodal Container
120
The Intermodal Container
ii. Mostly these are 20-foot or 40-foot long (although other sizes like 45-foot, 48-foot and
53-foot are also in use)
iii. The standard containers are 8-foot wide and 8-ft 6 inches high. The ‘high cube” units are
taller and are 9-ft 6 inches in height
iv. The intermodal containers are standardized. The basic dimensions and permissible
gross weights are determined by two ISO standards (ISO 668: 2013 and ISO 1496 :
2013). This is why the intermodal containers are also referred to as ISO containers.
121
The Intermodal Container
i. The intermodal containers use an identification system. ISO 6346 : 1995 is the
international standard which covers the coding, identification and marking used in these
containers. The standard is managed by International Container Bureau (BIC)
ii. The BIC coding system includes a combination of owner, country codes, size, type and
equipment category and a unique serial number with check digit.
iii. Other than general purpose containers, there are other types of containers like
temperature-controlled containers, insulated containers, ventilated containers, open top
and open side containers and platform-based containers.
122
The Intermodal Container
ii. However, containers need ports or terminals with container facilities which may not be
available in certain places. Sometimes, these facilities may be present but are
overburdened causing delays.
123
FCL, LCL, TEU and FEU
i. FCL stands for Full Container Load, which means the shipment occupies the full container
without the need to share container space with others
ii. LCL stands for Less than Container Load, refers to shipments that occupy only a portion of
the container load and is shipped with merchandise from other shippers in the same
container
iii. TEU stands for Twenty-foot equivalent unit. It refers to the volume of a standard container 20
feet long X 8 feet wide and 8 feet 6 inches in height. It has become a unit of cargo capacity
and is used to define the capacity of container ships and terminals. One TEU can
accommodate between 9 to 11 pallets depending on whether they are regular or EUR pallets
iv. FEU or Forty-foot equivalent unit is the measure of a 40 feet long container which can
accommodate between 20 to 24 pallets. One FEU is equivalent to 2 TEUs
124
Package carriers
ii. Package carriers provide the last-mile delivery and are becoming increasingly
important due to growing e-commerce. They are suitable for transportation of
items like electronics, cosmetics, textbooks to the customer.
iii. Package carriers may deliver heavy loads ( usually less than 150 lbs) like furniture
or large appliances
iv. Small package carriers deliver smaller shipments which are time-sensitive.
v. The services are provided by postal services or companies like UPS, Federal
Express, DHL etc.
125
White-glove delivery
126
Freight forwarding
127
Freight forwarding
i. The recognized freight forwarders belong to FIATA and their liabilities are set out by
FIATA
ii. International Freight forwarders also prepare, and process documents related to
customs clearance and other formalities required for export/import
iii. Some large freight forwarders offer additional value-added services like warehousing
and logistics consultancy to their clients
128
Non vessel operating common carriers (NVOCCs)
129
Transportation Planning
130
Components of transportation cost
131
Optimization of transportation cost
i. Transportation cost depends on several factors like the mode of transport used, the
weight or volume to be carried, the distance and the route depending on the design of
the network
ii. However, it must be noted that lower transportation costs do not necessarily lead to
lower overall supply chain costs.
iii. Cheaper modes of transport usually have longer lead times and larger minimum
shipment quantities, both of which lead to higher levels of inventory. Therefore, total
costs comprising transportation costs and inventory costs must be optimized
iv. The choice of the mode of transport should be made on the basis of its impact on
overall costs of supply chain and responsiveness to customer requirements.
132
Optimization of transportation cost
iv. Using backhaul (carrying back cargo when the vehicle returns)
133
Transportation risks
i. Disruption – may occur due to natural disasters or man-made events. The risk can be
mitigated by designing alternative routings into the transportation network
iii. Hazardous material – The objective is to minimize exposure and the impact, in the
event of exposure. Use of modified containers, use of low-risk transportation modes
and using routes which have less population can reduce the risk.
134
Impact of Transportation on the Environment
vi. Setting up distribution centres at critical locations would also minimize the need
for transportation
135
Effective Transportation Strategy
i. Selection of the mode – The choice of mode should not be based on cost alone. It
should be aligned to the organization strategy balancing customer responsiveness and
total costs
ii. Combination of in-house and outsourced transportation – an organization should
consider owing in-house transportation capabilities for large shipments. However,
outsourcing is a better option if shipment sizes are small and customer responsiveness
is important
iii. Use of technology – Information technology should be used for transportation planning,
mode selection, route selection and scheduling deliveries. Technology should also be
used to get visibility of shipments, get information on any impending disruption in the
route and make real time decisions
136
Effective Transportation Strategy
i. Creating a strong partnership with external carriers – Such partnerships enable win-win
relationships
ii. Flexibility in transportation network – Incorporating flexibility into the transportation
network by considering alternative modes and alternative routes helps to cope with
demand uncertainties and crisis situations
iii. Minimize the environmental impact - Efforts should be made to make transportation as
sustainable as possible with minimum impact on the environment
iv. Performance measurement and continuous improvement – Key performance metrics
for transportation should be instituted, measured and monitored on a regular basis. Big
data analytics has proved useful in this regard.
137
Warehousing Strategies
Module 5
Contents
140
Warehousing
i. The warehouse is a planned space for the storage and handling of goods.
ii. Warehouses are large scale storage facilities and could be ‘stand alone’ or
‘integrated’
iii. Stores are smaller storage facilities for immediate local use items
iv. Stockyards are open or semi-covered areas that are used to store bulky items,
materials that require specialised loading and unloading or equipment suitable for
outside storage
141
Basic objectives of warehousing
142
Types of Warehousing
i. Centralised
ii. Decentralised
iii. Private
iv. Public
v. Outsourced
143
Factors which influence storage locations
i. Cost of location
ii. Availability and suitability of the building
iii. Availability and suitability of staff
iv. Nature of items to be stored (items with low shelf life need to be stored close to usage
location)
v. Access to transport infrastructure
vi. Closeness to suppliers
vii. Closeness to customers
144
Warehouse design and layout
145
Objectives of Warehousing
146
The ‘Flow’
i. Flow consideration means identifying the potential for delays caused by bottlenecks.
ii. An effective flow will avoid congestion and is often linked to ‘one way’ system or
simply clarity in the direction of movement.
iii. A faster flow is achieved if the time to locate items is minimised.
iv. Proper labelling and rack identification systems can help.
v. Different functions like receiving, storage, picking, packaging and despatch should
not interfere with one another.
vi. Redesigning the warehouse layout or rack locations can improve flow.
viii. Storage layouts in the form of I ( a through layout) or U (goods in and goods out at
the same end, lifting equipment that is used for receiving can be moved a short
distance to service despatch), have better flows.
147
U-shaped flow
148
I-shaped flow
Receiving Despatch
Area Area
149
Different roles of warehouses
150
Consolidation (inbound)
Supplier A
Supplier B
Warehouse
Supplier C
Supplier D
151
Warehouse role – Consolidation (outbound)
Plant A
Customer
Plant B
Customer
Plant C Consolidation Warehouse
Customer
Plant D
152
Product Mixing
Customer X
1 2 3 4
Plant A, Product 1
Customer Y
Plant B, Product 2
1 2 3 4
Plant C, Product 3
Customer Z
Plant D, Product 4 Mixing Warehouse
1 2 3 4
153
Breakbulk
Plant
Breakbulk Warehouse
154
Cross-docking
iii. This is becoming more popular among retailers who can order full truckload and
then remix the same and ship it to various store locations
155
Cross-docking
Stores
B • Receiving
• Staging (<24hr)
Suppliers • Shipping
156
Distribution Centers
iv. Unlike warehouses where the focus is long-term storage, the focus of distribution
centers is temporary storage and quick distribution.
v. Distribution centers are designed for fast in-warding and rapid shipping.
157
Warehouse functions
i. Receive goods
v. Pick goods
158
Packaging
Packaging is the process of enclosing or protecting products for distribution, storage, sale
and use.
159
Objectives of Packaging
i. Protect the product from damage in transit through to the final use
160
Void Filling
If there is void space left in a box after the products are filled, then the products
inside can move around and could be damaged. Hence, it is necessary to fill up
the voids. Common items used for filling voids include:
161
Material Handling
The function of moving goods or materials within short distances in a storage area or
between a building and a transportation vehicle, is known as material handling. This
may include loading, unloading, palletizing and de-palletizing etc.
162
Manual Material Handling Equipment
163
Forklift Trucks
164
Block-grab, Drum lifter, Vacuum lifter
165
Cranes and Conveyors
Jib Crane
Bridge Crane
Roller Conveyor
Belt Conveyor
166
Pallets and Palletization
ii. Pallets are made of timber, plastic/resin, cardboard, composite materials or even
steel. All have maximum weight load ratings
iii. Common pallet types include Block pallets (4 way) and Stringer pallets (2 way)
iv. Skids: are pallets with no bottom-deck. They are useful as permanent foundation for
heavy machinery
167
Pallets and skids
4-way pallet
2-way pallet
Skid
168
Unitisation
Tote Box
Slip Sheets
i. Unitisation : Unit load is a term to describe the grouping of different items into a
convenient stack or stacks which make them easier to handle and store.
ii. Standardisation is an important theme of unit load system design.
iii. Use of tote boxes and slip sheets facilitate unitisation
169
Space utilization and flexibility
i. Space - Aisle width and rack heights are important considerations. Aisle width depends
on size of items stored and the material handling equipment used. Typical aisle widths –
Convention racking (2.5 to 4.5m), narrow-aisled ( 2m), Very narrow aisled (1.4m) and for
access to items that do not require material handling equipment (1 m). Double-deep
storage racks and carousels improve space utilisation.
ii. Flexibility of storage – Fixed, random or semi-random storage locations. Flexibility to meet
additional demand through temporary storage on site or other buildings, arrangements like
Consignment inventory etc.
170
Improving space utilization in warehouses
ii. Reduction of aisle width just bare enough to accommodate safe material handling
vi. Increase in pallet storage density – use of double-deep storage, push-back rack,
drive-in racks , carton flow and pallet flow racks etc.
171
Use of automation in warehouses
172
Automated Guided Vehicles
173
Warehouse Automation
174
Warehouse Automation
A vertical Carousel
175
Strategic Warehousing
ii. Modern warehouses often postpone final product configuration by completing functions
like kitting, labelling, specialty packaging etc. Such ‘postponement’ avoids customized
products or packaging in anticipation to customer orders. In addition, postponement
results in reduction in inventory because the base inventory can be used to support
multiple customer requirements.
iii. Warehouses also enable reverse logistics by supporting activities like returns
management, repair, recycling etc.
176
Strategic Warehousing
ii. Warehouses are now more focused towards distribution and assortment. Strategically
located distribution centers are central to modern retailing.
iii. Strategic location of warehouses also offers the benefit of consolidated transportation.
177
Inventory Management
Module 6
Contents
i. Fundamentals of Inventory
Management
ii. Types of Inventory
iii. Costs Associated with Inventory
iv. Economic Order Quantity (EOQ)
v. Selective Inventory Control
Techniques like ABC, VED, FSN etc.
vi. Inventory costing techniques – FIFO,
LIFO, Weighted Average etc.
180
What is Inventory?
i. Inventory is the stock of goods and materials that a business holds for the
ii. It is an idle resource of money awaiting future use, transformation or sale. Thus,
iii. Investment in inventories need to be managed well to improve cash flow and
maximize profits
181
Why inventory?
Balancing Supply and Demand –
a) To ensure availability of raw materials and components
for smooth production
b) To ensure availability of ready stock to support sales
c) To meet increased demand due to seasonality, fashion
trends , festivals, events or promotions.
Economies of Scale –
a) Improves economies of scale by enabling purchasing,
transportation and storage in bulk
Protection from uncertainties –
a) Provides a buffer against unanticipated variations in demand
b) Provides a buffer against delay in lead time (or time lag in any part of the supply chain)
c) By decoupling inter-dependent processes in manufacturing or assembly
182
Managing Conflicts
Sales & Marketing
(Full warehouse)
Production
(Surplus Finance
inventory) (Zero inventory)
Stock
Customers
(Timely fulfilment Purchase
of demand) (Trying to balance)
183
The Two Fundamental Inventory Decisions
184
Classification of Inventory
185
Types of Inventory
Inventory
Pipeline
(In Transit) In Stores
Work-in- Stock in
Production
Progress Trade
Consumables Spares
186
Types of Inventory
i. Pipeline Inventory (Goods in Transit) - All materials which are in the company’s supply
chain but yet to reach their final destination. These include materials which have been
paid for but not yet received or finished goods shipped but not yet paid for by the
customers.
ii. In Stores Inventory – Includes all materials physically held in stores. These include
production inventories, work-in-progress inventories and stock-in-trade.
iii. Production Inventory – Includes all materials which are used directly in production and
go into making the final product. These are the raw materials, parts or bought-out
components.
187
Types of Inventory
188
Economic Order Quantity (EOQ)
189
Costs Associated with Inventory
Ordering Costs – These are sum of all costs associated with ordering and
payment etc.
iii. Set up Costs - include the costs incurred for machine set up during production
190
Costs Associated with Inventory
Holding Costs (Carrying Costs) – These are sum of all costs for storing inventory.
These include:
i. Capital Costs – The cost of lost opportunity due to investments tied up in inventory
ii. Inventory Service Costs – Costs of taxes paid on inventory and cost of insuring inventory
against theft, fire etc.
iii. Storage Costs – All costs associated with warehousing viz. rent, depreciation, maintenance,
illumination, air-conditioning, material handling, salaries and wages of stores staff etc.
iv. Cost of Inventory Risks- Cost of damage, obsolescence, shrinkage, pilferage and relocation
It is estimated that cost of carrying inventory in most industries varies between 25 to 30% of the
annual average inventory value
191
Costs Associated with Inventory
Shortage Costs (Under stocking Costs) – These are sum of all costs for not
storing adequate inventory. These include:
i. Loss of Production
v. Loss of goodwill
192
Economic Order Quantity (EOQ)
193
Economic Order Quantity (EOQ)
194
EOQ
iii. Let ‘Cc’ denote the inventory carrying cost (expressed as a percentage of
average annual inventory value)
2 x D x Co
q* =
p x Cc
195
Limitations of EOQ
i. The EOQ formula does not take care of price changes and changes in
transportation costs due to changing volumes.
ii. The EOQ assumes that the demand is constant and uniform throughout the
year
iii. It is very difficult to precisely estimate the ordering and carrying costs.
iv. Often EOQ can not be strictly followed due to the following constraints:
a) Manufacturing requirements of fixed batch size
b) Packing size
c) Transportation capacity
d) Storage capacity
e) Shelf life
196
Selective Inventory Control
197
Selective Inventory Control
i. It is practically not possible to control each and individual item held in inventory nor
each item merits the same focus and control. Items are therefore categorized into
different groups based on various facets of the item and controlled selectively with
varying degrees of attention.
ii. Such selective inventory control helps in achieving the overall objective of inventory
management which is optimizing investment on inventory while minimizing stock-
outs.
iii. There are various ways of classifying materials for selective inventory control viz.
ABC, VED, FSN etc.
iv. At times, a combination of two or more such classifications are used simultaneously
to devise the control strategy. In MUSIC-3D (Multi Unit Selective Inventory Control –
the 3 dimensional approach) a grid is formed with a combination of three selective
techniques and strategy formulated for each cell of the grid.
198
ABC Analysis
i. ABC Analysis – This is based on Pareto’s Principle of ‘Vital Few’ and ‘Trivial Many’. It is
seen that only a small number of items account for a major portion of the total
expenditure (or revenue in case of finished goods). As a rule of thumb, about 10% of
the top items account for about 70% of the consumption value or expenditure. These
are called ‘A’ class items. The bottom 70% of items account for about 10% of the total
consumption value. These are called ‘C’ class items. The remaining are called ‘B’ class
items. It may be noted that ABC analysis is based on the annual usage value (or annual
consumption value) which is the total quantity consumed during the year multiplied by
unit price of the items.
ii. ‘A’ class items require constant monitoring and strict control while ‘C’ class items can
be reviewed only at periodic intervals. Procurement policy of A class items may include
‘small lots with frequent deliveries’ whereas that for ‘C’ class items may be ‘large lots
with infrequent deliveries’
199
ABC Analysis
200
VED Analysis
201
FSN Analysis
FSN Analysis – Items are classified as fast moving (F), slow moving (S) or non-moving (N)
based on the pattern of usage (frequency of issue from stores). Items which are consumed
regularly, say every week, are categorized as ‘F’. The items which have no consumption at all
during a particular year are categorized as ‘N’. The items which are consumed only once in a
while are termed ‘S’. The actual time frequencies for such classification vary from
202
Reasons for Excess / Obsolete Inventory
Changes in production
B structure/nature E Bullwhip effect
Technological changes -
C Original equipment obsolete
leading to obsolescence of F Expiry of shelf life
related spares
203
Managing Obsolescence
Holding on to excess or obsolete inventory uses up investments. The idea is to eliminate the excess
/ obsolete stocks promptly and use the freed up resources more gainfully. The following are useful
in managing excess/obsolete inventory:
i. Establish a system of identifying obsolescence
ii. Strict review on the top non-moving items
iii. Practicing First-in-First-out (FIFO) as far as practicable
iv. Sharing the list of non-moving items with relevant users highlighting the value of the stock
and periodic review with the users
v. Create accountability for usage
vi. Divert inventory to other plants
vii. Explore return to supplier for a credit
viii. Liquidate through sale / auction
ix. Put embargo on new purchases till the old stock is not used up/liquidated
x. Try Vendor Managed Inventory techniques like consignment inventory
204
Managing Uncertainties
205
Service Level
i. Service level may be defined as the ability to meet customer demand. In Inventory
Management, Service Level is defined in the following ways:
ii. Fill Rate- The percentage of demand fulfilled without backorders or lost sales. Fill rate is
again categorized as:
i. Product Fill Rate – Percentage of total demand met from existing inventory
(measured in terms of quantity)
ii. Order Fill Rate – It is defined as the percentage of orders fulfilled from available
inventory. In a single product scenario, there is no significant difference between
product fill rate and order fill rate. However, for multiproduct scenarios, the order
fill rate tends to be lower than product fill rate.
206
Service Level
Cycle Service Level- The percentage of replenishment cycles without any stock out. In
other words, Cycle Service Level defines the probability of not hitting a stock out during an
inventory replenishment cycle.
Higher the targeted service level, higher should be the stock. In fact, theoretically, a 100%
service level should require infinite stocks. It is also seen that the cost of increasing
service level is not linear, i.e. the cost of increasing service level from 98% to 99% is far
more costly than increasing it from 90% to 91%.
Achieving a target service level should therefore involve a trade off between inventory
investments and stock out costs.
207
Service Level Vs. Safety Stock
Service Level
208
Re-order Level
i. The Re-order Level (ROL) or the Re-order Point (ROP) is defined as that level of
inventory which should trigger a replenishment action. When the stock level falls to
ROL, actions should be initiated for stock replenishment. In other words, ROL is the
answer to “When to Order?”
ii. The ROL has to take care of both the Demand Uncertainty as well as the Supply
Uncertainty. Therefore, it is essential to estimate the following:
a. Demand variability - Demand forecasts are always associated with errors. From
past data, estimates should be made for maximum demand and average
demand over a period of time.
b. Lead Time variability – Lead time may fluctuate due to uncertainties associated
with the supplier, the market or the supply chain. From past data, estimates
should be made regarding average lead time and maximum lead time.
209
Re-order Level
210
Inventory Accounting and Valuation
i. Inventory value = Number of items held X cost per unit
ii. Cost of Goods Sold (COGS) = Opening inventory + purchases (or value of goods
manufactured) – Closing inventory
iii. COGS has a direct bearing on the company’s profit calculations. Thus, inventory
valuations influence the company’s profits
211
Inventory Accounting and Valuation - FIFO
First in First Out (FIFO) – In this method, the earliest or oldest inventories are to be issued
first and priced at the cost at which the consignments were received in stores.
i. Advantages:
a. Physical practice of FIFO would minimize expiry of materials
b. Easy to understand since it assumed that the goods are issued in order of receipt
c. Materials issued at purchase price
d. The closing stock closely reflects current market prices
ii. Disadvantages:
a. Costs at which goods are issued do not reflect current prices
b. Difficult to maintain records of prices of past purchases
c. During rising prices, this method would result in higher profits resulting in higher
tax burdens
212
Inventory Accounting and Valuation - LIFO
i. Last in First Out (LIFO) – In this method, the inventories from the latest consignments
are to be issued first and priced at the cost at which the latest consignments were
received in stores.
ii. Advantages:
a. Materials issued at current market prices
b. During increasing price trends, the cost of goods sold is increased thereby
lowering profits which helps to keep the tax burden low.
iii. Disadvantages:
a. It is unrealistic and counter intuitive
b. Physically some groups of items may remain unused (or unsold) for prolonged
periods leading to obsolescence
c. Accounting is difficult due to maintenance of several cost layers
d. Is not permitted many international Accounting Standards
213
Inventory Accounting and Valuation– Average Cost
Average Cost (AVCO) – In this method, the issue price is an average price. In some cases,
the simple average of the purchase prices of previous lots is used. However, the most
common practice is to use a weighted average price which is calculated by dividing the
total cost of stock by the total quantity in that stock.
i. Advantages:
a. Fluctuations in purchase prices are smoothed out and issue prices vary less
b. Does not increase or decrease profits like in FIFO or LIFO
c. Calculations are amenable to computerization
ii. Disadvantages:
a. After every receipt the new weighted average has to be calculated
b. Actual issue prices or inventory values may never match exact purchase prices
burdens
214
Stock Taking
i. Stock taking or stock verification is the physical verification of the quantities and condition
of the items held in a warehouse.
ii. It involves physical counting, measuring or weighing of items and comparing the physical
balance with the quantity in the records
215
Stock Taking
a. Periodic Count – This involves stock taking on a periodic basis where the
periodicity could be annual or half-yearly, quarterly etc. Annual stock taking is
usually undertaken at the end of the fiscal year which enables the valuation of the
closing inventory value which in turn helps the preparation of the financial
statements.
b. Cycle Count - This involves stock taking on a continual or perpetual basis
without disrupting daily operations. Cycle counts can be used for high-value or
critical items. Dedicated teams are deployed for cycle counts. Usually each item
is verified at least once a year in this method.
216
Managing discrepancies
217
Incoterms 2020
Module 7
Contents
of Commerce
INCOTERMS rule
Waterway Incoterms
220
International Chamber of Commerce (ICC)
ICC is a non-profit, private international organization that works to promote and support
ICC has direct access to national governments worldwide through its national committees
among others.
The ICC International Court of Arbitration is a body which hears and resolves private
221
What are Incoterms ?
v. Is not a contract, but it indicates what has been contractually agreed to into a contract!
vi. They closely correspond to the U.N. Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of
Goods(CISG)
222
What do Incoterms Convey?
Task Ownership
Cost Ownership
Risks and Liabilities
223
Evolution of Incoterms
i. First set of 6 Incoterms published in 1936 viz. FAS, FOB, C & F, CIF, Ex Ship and Ex
Quay.
ii. Revision in 1953 – Introduction of trade terms for non-maritime transport viz. DCP
(Delivered Costs Paid), FOR (Free on Rail) and FOT (Free on Truck) introduced.
iii. Revision in 1967 – Some misinterpretations of the previous version were addressed
and two new terms introduced viz. DAF (Delivery at Frontier) and DDP ( Delivery at
Destination)
iv. Revision in 1976 – FOB Airport (Free on Board Airport) introduced to keep pace with
increased air transportation and aimed to allay confusion around the term FOB (Free
on Board) by signifying the exact “vessel” used
224
Evolution of Incoterms
i. Revision in 1980 – FRC (Free carrier….at named point) – which provided for goods not
received at ship’s side but at a reception point on shore, such as container yard . This
was necessary to keep pace with the increased use of containers.
ii. Revision in 1990 – Simplified the Free Carrier term. FOT, FOR, FOB Airport were replaced
by FCA
iii. Revision in 2000 – Changes introduced in FAS and DEQ Incoterms to facilitate
compliance to Customs Practices
iv. Revision in 2010- The D family of rules (DAF, DES, DEQ and DDU) were consolidated into
two terms viz. DAT and DAP. Other modifications included an increased obligation for
buyer and seller to cooperate on information sharing and changes to accommodate
“string sales.”
225
Evolution of Incoterms
i. Revision in 2020 – The new revision was published in September 2019 and is effective
from 1st January 2020 . The new edition is available in 29 languages
ii. There are a total of 11 trade terms in 2020 with DAT (Delivered at Terminal) replaced
by DPU (Delivered at Place Unloaded)
a. Provision for Bill of ladings with on-board notification for the FCA rule even when
the delivery is made to a carrier before shipment.
b. Aligns different levels of insurance coverage for CIP and CIF rules
c. Arrangements for carriage with own means of transport in FCA, DAP, DPU and
DDP
226
What the Incoterms do not do
e. Relief from obligations and exemptions from liability in case of force majeure
227
What Incoterms are not
228
INCOTERMS 2020 – how to incorporate
229
The Articles of Incoterms 2020
i. The sequence of the obligations of the seller and buyer have been radically
changed in the new revision 2020.
a. Sections A1/B1: General obligations
b. Sections A2/B2: Delivery/taking delivery
c. Sections A3/B3 : Transfer of risks
d. Sections A4/B4 : Carriage
e. Sections A5/B5 : Insurance
f. Sections A6/B6 : Delivery / transport document
g. Sections A7/B7 : Export / import clearance
h. Sections A8/B8 : Checking / packaging / marking
i. Sections A9/B9 : Allocation of costs
j. Sections A10/B10 : Notices
ii. Delivery and transfer of risks have been prominently placed in sections 2 and 3.
Sections 4 and 5 relate to ancillary contracts
230
Focus of the Incoterms 2020
The most important initiative behind the Incoterms 2020 rules has been the
focus on the correct usage through:
ii. Clearer explanation of the demarcation between the sale contract and
ancillary contracts
iii. Re-ordering of the rules giving delivery and risk more prominence
231
The importance of ‘Delivery’
232
Reasons for premature transfer of risks
233
The traditional grouping
Buyer obligation
E EXW increasing
234
Incoterms 2020 Rules based on Mode of Transport
Sea / Inland
Multimodal
waterway
EXW FAS
FCA FOB
CPT CFR
CIP CIF
DAP
DPU
DDP
235
Multimodal Incoterms
236
EXW – Ex Works
ii. Delivery: The seller delivers when it places the goods at the disposal of the buyer at
a named place, which may or may not be the seller’s premises. For delivery to occur,
the seller has no obligation to load or clear the goods for export.
iii. Loading: The seller has no obligation to load. However, even if the seller loads the
goods (which is a common trade practice) the risk lies with the buyer unless
mutually agreed otherwise.
iv. Export/ Import clearance: The buyer has the obligation to clear both for export and
import, however, the seller must fulfill obligations in accordance with A7.
237
FCA – Free Carrier
b. When the named place is another place, the goods are delivered when they are
loaded on the seller’s means of transport and it reaches the named other place
and are ready for unloading and are at the disposal of the buyer or another
person nominated by the buyer
iii. The risk transfers at the place or point of delivery. The risk may transfer prematurely
when the buyer fails to provide notice or nominate a carrier or fails to take delivery.
238
FCA – Free Carrier
i. Place or point of delivery : The parties are advised to specify as clearly as possible the
precise point within the named place of delivery. This precise point makes allocation of
costs and risks clear to both parties. If no precise point is specified, then the seller has the
right to select the point that best suits its purpose. The buyer should therefore avoid this
loose end by precisely specifying the point of delivery.
ii. The seller may deliver by procuring the goods. The reference to ‘procure’ caters to
multiple sales down a chain (string sales), particularly common in commodity sales
239
FCA – Free Carrier
i. Bills of lading with an on-board notation – The seller may sometimes need a bill of lading with
an on-board notation typically because of a bank collection or letter of credit. However, the
carrier (which may be the buyer’s road hauler) is not obliged to issue a B/L with on-board
notation since the place where the carrier receives the goods is different from the port of
shipment and the on-board notation implies that the goods have been loaded on board the
vessel. The Incoterms 2020 rules provide an option that the buyer may instruct the carrier to
issue a B/L with on-board notation to the seller. If and when the B/L with on-board notation is
issued to the seller by the carrier at the buyer’s cost and risk, the seller must provide the
document to the buyer to enable the buyer to obtain discharge of the goods from the carrier.
The seller, however, is under no obligation to the buyer as to the terms of the carriage. When
this option is adopted, then the dates of inland delivery and loading on board may be different
which may create difficulties for the seller under a letter of credit.
240
CPT – Carriage Paid To
ii. Delivery:
a. The seller delivers by handling them over to the carrier contracted by the seller
or by procuring the goods so delivered. The seller may do so by giving the
carrier physical possession of the goods in the manner and at the place
appropriate to the means of transport used.
b. Once the goods have been delivered to the buyer in this way, the seller does not
guarantee that the goods will reach the place of destination in sound condition,
in the stated quantity or indeed at all.
241
CPT – Carriage Paid To
i. Transfer of risk : The risk transfers to the buyer from the point of delivery in the place
of origin. The parties are advised to precisely agree on the point of delivery especially
when several carriers are engaged each for different legs of transport from delivery to
destination. When this happens and the parties do not agree on a specific place or
point of delivery, the default position is that risk transfers when the goods have been
delivered to the first carrier at a point entirely of the seller’s choosing and over which
the buyer has no control.
ii. Should the parties wish the risk to transfer at some later stage (or earlier), then the
parties should specify this in the contract of sale after considering the consequences
of doing so especially in case the goods are lost or damaged.
242
CPT – Carriage Paid To
i. Costs to be paid by the seller: All costs including the costs of goods for packing,
checking, weighing etc. required for delivery, costs of loading, transport-related security
costs and carriage till the point of destination including any costs of transit that were
for the seller’s account under the contract of carriage.
ii. Costs of unloading at destination: If the seller incurs costs under its carriage related to
unloading at the named place of destination, the seller is not entitled to recover such
costs from the buyer unless otherwise agreed between the parties.
iii. Contract of carriage: The seller must contract (or procure a contract) for carriage from
the agreed point of delivery to the named place of destination. The contract must be
made by the usual route in a customary manner of the type normally used for the type
of goods sold. If the point of delivery in the destination is not precisely agreed, the seller
may select the point that best suits its purpose
243
CPT – Carriage Paid To
ii. The buyer must, whenever it is entitled to determine the time for dispatching the
goods and/or the named place of destination or the point of receiving the goods
within that place, give the seller sufficient notice thereof.
244
CIP– Carriage and Insurance Paid To
245
CIP– Carriage and Insurance Paid To
i. Obligations of the seller are same as those of the CPT Incoterm except for the seller
also has to contract for insurance against the buyer’s risk of loss or damage to the
goods. However, if the destination country requires insurance to be procured locally,
then the parties should consider using the CPT rule instead of CIP.
ii. The seller must obtain at its own expense, extensive cargo insurance complying with
Institute Cargo Clauses (A) or similar clause, rather than with the more limited cover
under the Institute Cargo Clauses (C). However, it is still open to the parties to agree
on a lower level of cover.
iii. The insurance shall cover, at a minimum, the price provided in the contract plus 10%
(i.e., 110%) and shall be in the currency of the contract.
246
CIP– Carriage and Insurance Paid To
i. The seller will also arrange for additional insurance at the request and expense of the
buyer, provided such additional insurance cover is procurable
ii. The insurance shall cover the goods from the point of delivery to at least the named
place of destination.
iii. The seller must provide the buyer with the insurance policy or other evidence of
insurance cover.
iv. Moreover, the seller must provide the buyer, at the buyer’s request, risk, and expense (if
any), with information that the buyer needs to procure any additional insurance.
247
DAP – Delivered at Place
ii. Delivery:
a. The seller delivers the goods and transfers the risk to the buyer when the goods
are placed at the disposal of the buyer on the arriving means of transport ready
for unloading at the named place of destination or at the agreed point within that
place, if any such point is agreed
b. The seller bears all risks involved in bringing the goods to the named place of
destination or to the agreed point within that place. Delivery and arrival at
destination are the same.
248
DAP – Delivered at Place
249
DAP – Delivered at Place
ii. The buyer has no obligation to the seller to make a contract of carriage
iii. The buyer has no obligation to the seller to make a contract of insurance. However,
the buyer must provide the seller, upon request, with the necessary information for
obtaining insurance
iv. The buyer must take delivery of the goods when they have been delivered
v. The buyer must, whenever it is entitled to determine the time within an agreed period
and/or the point of taking delivery at the named terminal, give the seller sufficient
notice thereof.
250
DAP – Delivered at Place
ii. The buyer must pay for all costs from the time they have been delivered
iii. The buyer must also pay for any additional costs that the seller had to incur due to
failure on part of the buyer to fulfill obligations related to import clearance or failure
to provide notice, provided the goods have been identified as the contract goods
iv. Risk may be transferred pre-maturely to the buyer if the buyer fails to fulfill
obligations related to import clearance or when the seller is unable to fulfill its
obligations for delivery due to failure on part of the buyer to provide notice to the
251
DPU – Delivered at Place Unloaded
252
DPU – Delivered at Place Unloaded
ii. This is the only Incoterms rule that requires the seller to
unload goods at destination. The seller should therefore
ensure that it is in a position to organize unloading at the
named place. Should the parties intend the seller not to
bear the risk and cost of unloading, the DPU rule should be
avoided and DAP rule should be used instead
253
DDP – Delivered Duty Paid
ii. Delivery:
a) The seller delivers the goods when the goods are placed at the disposal of the buyer,
cleared for import on the arriving means of transport ready for unloading at the
named place of destination, or at the agreed point within that place, if any such point
is agreed.
b) The seller bears all risks involved in bringing the goods to the named place of
destination or to the agreed point within that place. Delivery and arrival at destination
are the same.
254
DDP – Delivered Duty Paid
i. The obligations of the buyer and those of the seller are similar to those of
the DAP Incoterm except for the major difference that the seller has to clear
the goods for import as well
ii. The seller has to arrange both export and import clearances and complete
customs formalities at its own risk and cost
iii. If the seller is unable to obtain import clearance and would rather leave it to
the buyer, then the seller should consider choosing DAP or DPU.
255
Sea/Inland Waterway Incoterms
256
FAS – Free Alongside Ship
ii. Delivery:
a. The seller must deliver the goods either by placing them alongside the ship
nominated by the buyer at the loading point, if any, indicated by the buyer at the
named port of shipment or by procuring the goods so delivered.
b. The risk of loss or damage to the goods transfers when the goods are alongside the
ship and the buyer bears all costs from that moment onwards.
iii. The FAS rule is not appropriate where goods are handed over to the carrier before they are
alongside the vessel, for example, where the goods are handed over to a carrier at a
container terminal. In such cases, parties should consider using the FCA rule rather than
the FAS rule.
257
FAS – Free Alongside Ship
258
FAS – Free Alongside Ship
259
FOB – Free on Board
260
FOB – Free on Board
Loading and Risk Transfer Point : Under Incoterms 2000 rules, the risk of goods would pass
to the buyer when the goods crossed the ship’s rail . However, it was not practical to imagine
that a hypothetical line exists to demarcate as to when the goods would pass the ship’s rail.
In the 2010 revision, however, it was clarified that the risk passes when the goods are ‘on
board’ the vessel. However, problem still remains with respect to the exact point for the
division of the risk, which depends on the type of goods and the method used to bring the
goods on board the ship.
Moreover, it has been mentioned that the goods are to be delivered “as per customary
practices in the port”. However, the commercial practices are not consistent across all ports.
Usually the task of loading is performed by stevedoring companies, and the practical
problem normally lies in deciding who should bear the costs of their services.
261
CFR – Cost and Freight
262
CFR – Cost and Freight
i. While the contract will always specify a destination port, it might not specify the port
of shipment, which is where the risk passes to the buyer. If the shipment port is of
particular interest to the buyer, the parties should identify it as precisely as possible
in the contract
ii. The seller must contract or procure a contract for the carriage of the goods from the
agreed point of delivery, if any, at the place of delivery and bear costs of carriage to
the named port of destination or, if agreed, any point at that port. The contract of
carriage must be made on usual terms at the seller’s expense and provide for
carriage by the usual route in a vessel of the type normally used for the transport of
the type of goods sold.
iii. The seller has to bear the costs of loading on the vessel.
263
CFR – Cost and Freight
i. The seller owes no obligation to the buyer to purchase insurance cover. The buyer should
purchase its own insurance cover.
ii. The unloading cost (including lighterage and wharfage charges) at the port of destination
is usually on the buyer. If the seller incurs costs under its contract of carriage related to
unloading at the specified point at the port of destination, the seller is not entitled to
recover such costs from the buyer unless otherwise agreed between the parties.
iii. The buyer has to bear all costs and charges relating to the goods while in transit until their
arrival at the port of destination, unless such costs and charges were for the seller’s
account under the contract of carriage.
iv. The CFR may not be appropriate where goods are handed over to the carrier before they
are on board the vessel. In such circumstances, the CPT rule should be used.
264
CIF – Cost, Insurance and Freight
ii. Delivery:
a. The seller delivers the goods on board the vessel or procures the goods already
so delivered. The seller must contract for and pay the costs and freight necessary
to bring the goods to the named port of destination.
b. The risk or loss of damage to goods transfers when the goods are on board the
vessel, such that the seller is taken to have performed its obligation to deliver the
goods whether or not the goods actually arrive at the destination in sound
condition, in the stated quantity, or indeed, at all.
c. If multiple carriers are used ( e.g. a feeder vessel and an ocean vessel), then by
default the risk passes when the goods are delivered to the first carrier unless
agreed otherwise in the contract of sale.
265
CIF – Cost, Insurance and Freight
i. The obligations of the buyer and those of the seller are similar to those of the CFR rule
except for the seller must contract for insurance cover against the buyer’s risk of loss or
damage to the goods from the point of delivery to at least the point of destination. If the
destination country requires insurance to be procured locally, then the parties should
consider using the CFR rule instead of CIF.
ii. The rules for contract of insurance cover are same as those in the CIP rule except the
seller is required to obtain limited insurance cover complying with Institute Cargo Clauses
(C) instead of the more extensive cover under the Institute Cargo Clauses (A). However,
the parties can mutually agree on a higher level of cover.
iii. CIF may not be appropriate where goods are handed over to the carrier before they are on
board the vessel In such circumstances, the CIP rule should be used.
266
Guidelines on Using Incoterms
i. When completing documents we should ensure that we are using the correct format
of a term (CFR / C+F)
ii. We should draw up a check list of our duties and rights under the selected term and
check that every intended or completed transaction conforms to this list, and that
nothing is omitted. We should request our trading partner to do same and exchange
information.
iii. We should never instruct the carriers or any third party to do or omit anything on the
basis of the Incoterms which do not apply to them at all
iv. We should inform our bank and insurance company which Incoterm(s) have been
selected for our business, so that they can determine exactly what our duties and
rights are with regard to a transaction in which they may have a role to play.
267
Trade Payment
Methods
Module 8
Contents
270
International Payment Methods
Clean Payments
Letters of Credit
271
Clean Payments
i. Clean Payments are characterized by trust. Either the exporter ships the goods and
trusts the Importer to pay once the goods have been received, or the Importer
trusts the exporter to dispatch the goods after payment is effected
ii. There are two types of Clean Payments: Open Account & Payment in Advance
a) Open Account : The Importer is trusted to pay the exporter after receipt of the
goods
272
Payment through Documentary Collections
iii. Collections are subject to the Uniform Rules for Collections published by the
International Chamber of Commerce. The last revision of these rules came into
effect on January 1, 1996 and is referred to as the URC 522
273
Types of Documentary Collections
i. Documents Against Payment (D/P) : Documents are released to the importer only
against payment. Also known as a Sight Collection or Cash Against Documents
(CAD)
ii. Documents Against Acceptance (D/A) : Documents are released to the importer
only against acceptance of a draft. Also known as a Term Collection
a) Flow of Goods
b) Flow of Documents
c) Flow of Payment
274
Documentary Collection- Flow of Goods
i. After the Importer and the Exporter have established a sales contract and agree on a
Documentary Collection as the method of payment, the exporter ships the goods
ii. In a Documentary Collection, the importer is known as the “drawee” and the exporter
as the “drawer”.
Exporter/ Importer/
Goods
Drawer Drawee
275
Documentary Collection – Flow of Documents
Documents
Exporter/ Remitting
2
Drawer bank
Documents
Goods
3
1
Importer/ Collecting/
4
Drawee Presenting Bank
Documents
276
Documentary Collection – Flow of Documents
i. After the goods are shipped, documents originating with the exporter (e.g.,
commercial invoice) and the transport company (e.g., bill of lading) are delivered to
a bank, called the Remitting Bank in the collection process
ii. The role of the Remitting Bank is to send these documents accompanied by a
collection instruction giving complete and precise instructions to a bank in the
importer’s country, referred to as the Collecting/ Presenting Bank in the collection
process.
iii. The Collecting/ Presenting Bank acts in accordance with the instructions given in
the collection instruction and releases the documents to the Importer against
payment or acceptance, according to the Remitting Bank’s collection instructions.
277
Documentary Collection- Flow of Payment
Exporter/ Remitting
3
Drawer Goods bank
Importer/ Collecting/
1
Drawee Presenting Bank
Documents
Payment is forwarded to the Remitting Bank for the exporter’s account. The importer can now
present the transport document to the carrier in exchange for the goods.
278
UCP 600
ICC Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits (UCP 600)
i. The Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits, 2007 Revision, ICC
Publication no. 600 ("UCP") are rules that apply to any documentary credit when the text
ii. The last revision was effective from 1st July 2007
iii. The 39 articles of UCP 600 are a comprehensive and practical working aid to bankers,
lawyers, importers, and exporters, transport executives, educators, and everyone involved
iv. UCP 600 has to be clearly mentioned in the Letter of Credit in order to be applicable
279
Letter of Credit
280
Elements of a Letter of Credit
Documents must conform to terms and conditions set out in the letter of credit
281
Fundamental Principles of Letter of Credit
ii. Banks are not bound by the Sale Contract even if the Letter of Credit bears reference
to the Contract
iii. The concerned parties deal with documents and not in goods, services or
iv. Banks bear no responsibility of the genuineness of the documents, for the goods or
282
Entities in a Letter of Credit
iii. Issuing Bank – the bank that issues a credit at the request of an applicant or on its
own behalf
iv. Advising Bank – the Issuing Bank normally sends the LC through a bank located in
the country of the beneficiary. This bank is known as the Advising Bank since its
role is limited to checking the authenticity of the LC and advise the beneficiary that
the LC has been opened.
v. Confirming Bank - the bank that adds its own undertaking to pay the LC
beneficiary if all terms and conditions of the credit are complied with. Such
undertaking is in addition to that given by the Issuing Bank at the request of the
Issuing Bank.
283
Entities in a Letter of Credit
i. Nominated Bank - a bank authorised by the Issuing bank to pay, negotiate, issue a
deferred payment undertaking or accept drafts under the LC. If the LC does not
specify a Nominated Bank, the LC is deemed as freely negotiable and any bank that
receive documents from the LC beneficiary is qualified to be a Nominated Bank
ii. Negotiating Bank - the bank that examines the drafts and/or documents presented
by the LC beneficiary and gives values to such drafts and/or documents.
Negotiation could be in the form of purchasing or agreeing to purchase the drafts
and/or documents presented.
iii. Reimbursing Bank - is the paying agent appointed by the Issuing Bank to honour
claims submitted by the nominated or negotiating bank.
284
Important Terms Related to Letter of Credit
i. Credit- means any arrangement, however named or described, that is irrevocable and
thereby constitutes a definite undertaking of the issuing bank to honor a complying
presentation
ii. Honor - to pay at sight or to incur a deferred payment according to credit availability
iii. Confirmation - means a definite undertaking of the confirming bank, in addition to that
of the issuing bank, to honor or negotiate a complying presentation
iv. Presentation - means either the delivery of documents under a credit to the issuing
bank or nominated bank or the documents so delivered
v. Negotiation - means the purchase by the nominated bank of drafts (drawn on a bank
other than the nominated bank) and/or documents under a complying presentation, by
advancing or agreeing to advance funds to the beneficiary on or before the banking
day on which reimbursement is due to the nominated bank
285
Letter of Credit - Issuance
Advice/
Confirmation of the
Letter of Credit
4
Exporter/ Advising/
Beneficiary Confirming
Bank
Request to advise
1 Contract 3 & possibly confirm
Negotiations the Letter of Credit
286
Letter of Credit - Issuance
i. After the trading parties agree on a sale of goods where payment is made by
Letter of Credit, the Importer requests that its bank (the Issuing Bank) issue a
Letter of Credit in favor of the Exporter (Beneficiary).
ii. The Issuing Bank then sends the Letter of Credit to the Advising Bank. A request
may be included for the Advising Bank to add its confirmation. The Advising Bank
is usually located in the country where the exporter does business and may be the
exporter’s bank but does not have to be.
iii. Next, the Advising/Confirming Bank verifies the Letter of Credit for authenticity
and sends it to the exporter.
287
LC -Confirmation
i. If the beneficiary of the credit has some doubt about the ability of the LC-Opening bank
to arrange reimbursement, then he may request the opener to arrange for the LC to be
‘confirmed ‘ by the advising bank.
ii. If the opener agrees, the opening bank will ask the advising bank to add its ‘confirmation’
to the LC.
iii. Confirmation of an LC constitutes a definite undertaking by the advising bank to assume
the obligations and liabilities of the opening bank under the credit.
iv. Branches should restrict all negotiations to the confirming bank.
v. If negotiations are effected through another bank the beneficiary will lose the rights and
benefits of having a confirmed LC.
288
Letter of Credit – Flow of Documents and Payment
Advising/
Exporter/ 2 Confirming
Beneficiary
Bank
Documents
Documents
3 6
Goods
Documents
4
5
Importer/ Issuing Bank
Applicant
289
Letter of Credit – Flow of Documents and Payment
i. After the goods are shipped, the exporter presents the documents specified in the
Letter of Credit to the Advising/ Confirming Bank
ii. Once the documents are checked and found to comply with the Letter of Credit (i.e.,
without discrepancies), the Advising/ Confirming Bank forwards these documents to
the Issuing Bank. The drawing is negotiated, paid or accepted as the case may be.
iii. In turn, the Issuing Bank examines the documents to ensure they comply with the
Letter of Credit. If the documents are in order, the Issuing Bank will obtain payment
from the Importer for payment already made to the Confirming Bank
iv. Documents are delivered to the importer to allow it to take possession of the goods
290
Types of Letters of Credit
i. Irrevocable Letter of Credit - cannot be canceled or amended without the consent of all
parties including the exporter. All Letters of Credit are Irrevocable in UCP600
ii. Sight and Term Letters of Credit – If payment is to be made at the time that documents are
presented, this is referred to as a Sight Letter of Credit. If payment is to be made at a future
fixed time from the presentation of documents, this is referred to as a Term Letter of Credit.
iii. Confirmed Letter of Credit - Under a Confirmed Letter of Credit, a bank, called the
Confirming Bank, adds its commitment to that of the Issuing Bank to pay the exporter under
the Letter of Credit provided all terms and conditions of the Letter of Credit are met. The
Confirming Bank is usually located in the same country as the Exporter. An Exporter would
request a Confirmed Letter of Credit if it does not consider the financial strength of the
Issuing Bank or the country in which it is located to be acceptable risks.
291
Types of Letters of Credit
i. Revolving Letter of Credit - the amount available on the credit is reinstated usually without
any specific amendment. The amount of credit revolves upon shipment and/or presentation
of documents.
ii. Transferable Letter of Credit - The credit issued in favor of a trader (beneficiary) can be
used as a means of paying the sources from which the trader obtains goods. A Transferable
L/C allows transfer of the credit undertaking to another beneficiary.
iii. Red Clause Letter of Credit - Under this arrangement the buyer agrees to make a part of the
purchase price available to the seller as a pre-shipment advance and further agree that such
advance should be made from with the credit issued. The arrangement provides for the
amount of the advance to be deducted from the amount to be paid to the seller upon
presentation of documents
292
Types of Letters of Credit
i. Green Clause Letter of Credit – It is an extension of the Red Clause in that it envisages grant
of further facilities for storage and insurance at the port in addition to pre-shipment payment
to beneficiary. This enables the shipper to warehouse and insure goods when immediate
shipping space is not available.
ii. Standby Letter of Credit- A Standby Letter of Credit operates in a manner similar to a bank
guarantee. When the buyer fails to pay or the contract is not performed to the satisfaction of
the seller then the beneficiary (seller) may invoke the terms of the credit and make the claim
on the Issuing Bank with supporting documents as per the terms of the Letter of Credit. The
rules of the Standby Letter of Credit are furnished in the ICC Publication number ISP98.
293
Common Discrepancies in LC
294
International Payment Risk Spectrum
295
Documents in International Trade- Financial
i. Draft- All letters of credit require the beneficiary to present a draft and specified
documents in order to receive payment. A draft is a written order by which the party
creating it, orders another party to pay money to a third party. A draft is also called a bill of
exchange.
ii. The Draft is the “Financial Claim”. It is a negotiable instrument similar to cheque.
iv. A sight draft is payable as soon as it is presented for payment. The bank is allowed a
reasonable time to review the documents before making payment. A time draft is not
payable until the lapse of a particular time period stated on the draft.
296
Documents in International Trade- Commercial
297
Documents in International Trade- Commercial
i. Proforma Invoice - A pro forma invoice is presented in the place of a commercial invoice
when there is no sale yet between the sender and the importer, or if the terms of the sale
between the seller and the buyer are such that a commercial invoice is not available at
that time.
ii. A pro forma invoice is required to state the same facts that the commercial invoice
would specially if it is to be used to obtain a Letter of Credit.
iii. Export License -Export license is the express authorization by a country’s government to
export a specific product before it is shipped
298
Documents in International Trade- Commercial
i. Certificate of Origin – It is a document certifying the country in which the product was
manufactured, and in certain cases may include such information as the local material
and labor contents of the product. The manufactured goods must have been
substantially transformed in the exporting country as the country of origin, to their
present form ready for export. Certain operations such as packaging, splitting and
sorting may not be considered as sufficient operations to confer origin. It is often used
by importing country to determine tariff of goods
ii. Import License - A document issued by the importing country and designed to prevent
import of non-essential or overly luxurious products in developing countries short of
foreign currency supply.
iii. Certificate of Insurance - Some Incoterms (CIF, CIP) require that the exporter provide
insurance. A certificate of insurance offers proof of coverage
299
Documents in International Trade- Commercial
300
Documents in International Trade- Transport
i. Bill of Lading
ii. A generic term used to describe a document issued by the carrier to the shipper
301
Documents in International Trade- Transport
302
Documents in International Trade- Transport
x. On board date
303
Documents in International Trade- Transport
304
Documents in International Trade- Transport
i. A bill of lading that certifies that the goods were received by the carrier in good
condition
ii. No annotation are made on the BOL, other than a signature for receipt of the
goods
iii. All Letters of Credit and Documentary Collections require a clean BOL
i. A bill of lading that reflects the fact that the carrier received the goods in
anything other than good condition
305
Documents in International Trade- Transport
ii. Non-negotiable- Ownership cannot be transferred and the consignee need to clear the
goods on arrival.
vi. Stale B/L – A bill of lading presented after 21 days after the date of shipment.
306
Documents in International Trade- Transport
307
Documents in International Trade- Transport
Packing List
i. It documents what each shipment contains: how the goods are packaged, marked, what
merchandise is in each container, and their respective weight and dimensions
Manifest
i. Shipping document that is internal to the carrier, but is often examined by government
entities
ii. A list of the entire cargo that a vessel, aircraft or container transports, as well as the
ownership, port of origin, port of destination, specific handling instructions of that cargo
308
Documents in International Trade- Transport
Dangerous Goods
The shipment of dangerous goods is regulated by a number of organizations and rules
iii. Local shipment codes, such as the United States' Code of Federal Regulations, Title 49
(abbreviated 49CFR)
Notify Party (ies) The notify party is the party that the carrier must notify when the goods arrive
at the port of destination. The carrier issues an Arrival Notice informing the notify party about
the cargo discharge point, number of packages and other information. The letter of credit (L/C)
may require that the carrier notifies a party in addition to the notify party, usually using the
words "also notify".
309
Letter of Credit – Buyers Beware !
i. The Letter of Credit is skewed towards the seller in the sense that it offers high degree
of protection to the seller
ii. The Buyer must gather as much information about the seller as possible before
opening the Letter of Credit
iii. The Letter of Credit application form must be filled up with utmost care and must
contain clear and unambiguous description of goods/services, rate, quantity etc. As
far as practicable, minimum reference to the Sale Contract should be made
iv. The Letter of Credit does not offer any protection to the buyer from Quality point of
view. Hence, it is advisable to have a recognized, mutually acceptable third-party
agency to have the goods inspected and certified.
310
Write A Google Review
Visit the below URL (Make sure you are logged into
your Google account).
https://g.page/BlueOceanAcademy/review
Or