Gmail - Budgetary Estimate for Turbo-generator unit https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=6b9e58b942&view=pt&search=al...

HPC WBSEDCL <wbsedclhpc@gmail.com>

Budgetary Estimate for Turbo-generator unit

6 messages

HPC WBSEDCL <wbsedclhpc@gmail.com> Tue, Jan 19, 2021 at 12:35 PM

To: Dibyendu.Dhara@voith.com
Cc: Director Generation <directorgen2019@gmail.com>

Sir,

As discussed over telephone, please find the attachment for your kind perusal and
needful action.

Regards,
Amitava Sen
Chief Engineer
Planning Investigation & Design Department

Balasun HEP.docx
13K

HPC WBSEDCL <wbsedclhpc@gmail.com> Tue, Jan 19, 2021 at 5:38 PM

To: Dibyendu.Dhara@voith.com
Cc: Director Generation <directorgen2019@gmail.com>

Sir,

In continuation to the previous email, you may consider a rated head of 250 - 260 m
(keeping the machine size same as mentioned) instead of 212 m for selection of
machines and budgetary estimate.

Regards,
Amitava Sen
Chief Engineer
Planning Investigation & Design Department

[Quoted text hidden]

Dhara, Dibyendu <Dibyendu.Dhara@voith.com> Mon, Feb 1, 2021 at 8:10 PM

To: HPC WBSEDCL <wbsedclhpc@gmail.com>
Cc: Director Generation <directorgen2019@gmail.com>

Dear Sir,

1 of 5 27-06-2022, 11:39
Gmail - Budgetary Estimate for Turbo-generator unit https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=6b9e58b942&view=pt&search=al...

We sincerely thank you for your consideration.

With reference to the discharge curve shared, we as OEM propose the most economical solution as 2x16 MW, 6
-jet Vertical Pelton units for Balasun HEP. This configuration of PH will run perfectly fine up to at 0.95 m3/s
discharge (with good efficiency, operating at single jet). Therefore, in our opinion there is no need to have a 6 MW
smaller unit. This smaller unit will not serve any purpose (as Pelton turbine has relatively constant efficiency
throughout the operating range, even in minimum part load limit of 10-15%.

Also having two different size of units will cause increase in engineering cost, will require two sets of spares (one
set for big unit, one set for smaller unit), longer execution time, bigger powerhouse for 3 units and also not good
from plant aesthetics point of view. In economic terms E&M equipment for 2 x13 MW + 1 x 6 MW configuration will
be higher by 8-10% (than 2x16 MW configuration). Apart from that there will have additional civil cost for larger
power house size for 2 x13 MW + 1 x 6 MW configuration.

Regarding selection of turbine type, Specific Speed is more in range of Pelton turbine, no good Francis hydraulics
available. Therefore, the unit setting shall be much deeper for Francis turbine which means deeper excavation-at
least 6m deeper. Also Francis turbine will have very poor part load efficiencies and it cannot operate below 40%
part load.

Therefore, based on preliminary calculation & experience, Voith strongly recommend 2x16MW, 6-jet Vertical
Pelton with 428 rpm (instead of 2x13MW+1x6MW).

The approximate value for E&M equipment will be INR 80 Crore.

Best regards
Dibyendu Dhara
Voith Group

Senior Manager - Eastern Region

Marketing & Business Development
Group Division Hydro
Division VH Other
__________________________________________

Voith Hydro Private Limited

AMP Baishakhi, 7th Floor, Unit No. 701, AG - 112, Sector - II,
Salt Lake City, Kolkata – 700 091, West Bengal, India.

Phone +91 33 2358 7641

Fax +91 33 2359 2356
Mobile +91 9811365302

Dibyendu.Dhara@Voith.com
www.voith.com

Follow Voith on Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, Twitter and YouTube!

Follow Voith Hydro on LinkedIn and Twitter!

A Voith and Siemens Company

__________________________________________

[Quoted text hidden]

Dhara, Dibyendu <Dibyendu.Dhara@voith.com> Thu, Feb 18, 2021 at 8:03 PM

2 of 5 27-06-2022, 11:39
Gmail - Budgetary Estimate for Turbo-generator unit https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=6b9e58b942&view=pt&search=al...

To: HPC WBSEDCL <wbsedclhpc@gmail.com>

Cc: Director Generation <directorgen2019@gmail.com>, "prolay1965@gmail.com" <prolay1965@gmail.com>

Dear Sir,

Please find attached herewith our budgetary offer.

[Quoted text hidden]

Sir,
[Quoted text hidden]
[Quoted text hidden]

Balasun_Techno-Commercial_Offer.pdf
2375K

Dhara, Dibyendu <Dibyendu.Dhara@voith.com>

To: HPC WBSEDCL <wbsedclhpc@gmail.com>
Cc: Director Generation <directorgen2019@gmail.com>, "prolay1965@gmail.com" <prolay1965@gmail.com>

Dear Sir,

With reference to today’s discussion please find below some of Voith’s Pelton turbine references.

India/Nepal- Voith Pelton references:

Year of New or
Project name Country Customer
contract Mod

Sorang 2009 India Himachal Sorang Power New

Sainj 2011 India Himachal Pradesh Power Corporation New

Thapakhola 2013 India Mount Kailash Energy Company Pvt LTD New

Binwa 2015 India HPSEB Ltd. Mod

Misti Khola 2016 Nepal Robust Energy Ltd. New

Shanan 2017 India Punjab State Power Corporation Ltd. Mod

Pallivasal 2019 India Kerala State Electricity Board Ltd. Mod

3 of 5 27-06-2022, 11:39
Gmail - Budgetary Estimate for Turbo-generator unit https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=6b9e58b942&view=pt&search=al...

Bhaba 2019 India HPSEB Ltd. Mod

Binwa 2019 India HPSEB Ltd. Mod

Solu Khola 2019 Nepal SAHAS URJA Ltd. New

Recent Voith SH References – Global (4/5/6 Jet Pelton Turbines)

Power House Name Rated Power Rated Head Speed No of Nozzles Country of Installatio

Rutherford Creek 25485 327.49 450 6 Canada

Tecate 20058 564.46 720 4 Mexico

Pinalito 25600 535.3 720 5 Dominican Republic

Aksu 14523 300.25 500 5 Turkey

Yedigöl 11223 233.31 428.6 5 Turkey

Arakli 1.2 10359 585 1000 6 Turkey

Kokish River 11287 203.59 360 6 Canada

Cambasi 22643 257.8 375 6 Turkey

Jimmie Creek 31294 448.1 514.27 6 Canada

Tosdalen 19300 524.63 750 5 Norway

Mistri Khola 14400 285 500 6 Nepal

Kovanlik 19500 327.4 500 6 Turkey

Solu Khola 33487 599.33 750 6 Nepal

Tochio 16400 292 333.33 / 400 4 Japan

4 of 5 27-06-2022, 11:39
Gmail - Budgetary Estimate for Turbo-generator unit https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?ik=6b9e58b942&view=pt&search=al...

Best regards

Dibyendu Dhara
Voith Group

Senior Manager - Eastern Region

Marketing & Business Development
Group Division Hydro
Division VH Other
__________________________________________

Voith Hydro Private Limited

AMP Baishakhi, 7th Floor, Unit No. 701, AG - 112, Sector - II,
Salt Lake City, Kolkata – 700 091, West Bengal, India.

Phone +91 33 2358 7641

Fax +91 33 2359 2356
Mobile +91 9811365302

Dibyendu.Dhara@Voith.com
www.voith.com

Follow Voith on Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, Twitter and YouTube!

Follow Voith Hydro on LinkedIn and Twitter!

A Voith and Siemens Company

__________________________________________

[Quoted text hidden]

Sir,
[Quoted text hidden]
[Quoted text hidden]

HPC WBSEDCL <wbsedclhpc@gmail.com> Tue, Jun 7, 2022 at 1:56 PM

To: "Dhara, Dibyendu" <Dibyendu.Dhara@voith.com>

Sir,
WBSEDCL is going to implement 38 MW Balason HEP in Darjeeling district of West Bengal. In this regard, a
techno-commercial budgetary offer dated 18 Feb 2021 was submitted from your end, wherein, 02 nos. 16 MW, 6 Jet ,
428 rpm vertical pelton generator and 01 no. 6 MW, 3 Jet, 500 rpm vertical pelton generator were proposed.

We are now preparing Detailed Project Report (DPR) for the said project. Hence, considering your earlier budgetary
offer, you are requested to provide preferably CAD drawings i.r.t. Longitudinal Section of Power House and Cross
Section of Power House depicting necessary dimensions for finalization of DPR.

We are eagerly waiting for your early reply please.

Regards,
DivisionalEngineer (E)
Planning, Investigation & Design Department
WBSEDCL

[Quoted text hidden]

5 of 5 27-06-2022, 11:39