Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/51546611
CITATIONS READS
54 2,210
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Formative study to evaluate period poverty among impoverished women in North-west England View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Floor Christie on 28 May 2019.
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Abstract
Background: Vitamin D deficiency is associated with numerous chronic diseases including cancer, heart
disease and diabetes type 1 and 2. It is currently estimated that one billion people suffer from vitamin D
deficiency worldwide. A major cause is lack of sun exposure, and this is evident even in countries at mid and
low latitudes. Although a high prevalence has been found in Saudi Arabia, little is known to date about the
reasons for this and, consequently about, reduction methodologies. The study’s aim was to investigate the
knowledge, attitude and practice (KAP) towards vitamin D deficiency, sun exposure, supplementation and
fortification in a sample of female Saudi Arabian students.
Methods: A focus group and eight in depth one-to-one semi-structured interviews were conducted and analy-
sed using thematic analysis.
Results: Participants were limited in their knowledge about vitamin D and vitamin D deficiency. They
reported limited sun exposure due to intense heat, cultural reasons for covering the body, and an infrastruc-
ture that makes sun exposure difficult.
Conclusion: Important barriers for the prevention of vitamin D deficiency in Saudi Arabia were highlighted.
Recommendations for more research in specific areas including the prevalence of vitamin D deficiency and
recommended daily allowances of supplementation are made. Governmental actions including increasing
awareness of the importance of vitamin D and guidelines on how to obtain it are necessary. Creating areas
where women, particularly those of lower socio-economic status, can enjoy sun exposure as well as fortifying
more foods would go some way towards tackling this problem.
Key words: attitude and practice, cultural, qualitative, Saudi Arabia, vitamin D deficiency.
hypertension, and Alzheimer’s.1,9 Mental health it is clear that there currently is a dearth of litera-
has also been shown to be affected by vitamin D ture looking at socio-cultural reasons for vitamin D
deficiency.9 deficiency both, generally in the Middle East and
Studies worldwide identify lack of sun exposure as specifically in relation to Saudi Arabia.
the main cause of vitamin D deficiency.10,12 In regions The Ottawa Charter22 indicates that health promo-
at higher latitude UV rays are less intense9 and obtain- tion interventions should reflect both local needs and
ing vitamin D from sun exposure becomes more diffi- potential of individual countries. Significant barriers
cult. Yet, even in sunny climates such as Saudi Arabia and enablers for the reduction of vitamin D deficiency
or India, high prevalence of vitamin D deficiency has need to be ascertained in the Saudi Arabian popula-
been found.1,9,13–15 Prolonged breastfeeding without tion as vitamin D deficiency seems to be a significant
vitamin D supplementation and lack of dietary intake problem.
have also been identified as causes of vitamin D
deficiency.13,16
There is evidence that the prevalence of rickets and
METHODOLOGY
vitamin D deficiency is greater across the Middle East This descriptive, socio-cultural study was of an explor-
than in Western populations,13 with a large meta- atory design and produced qualitative data. The study
analysis concluding that 20–80% of apparently explored knowledge, attitudes and practice of vitamin
healthy individuals suffer from vitamin D deficiency. D deficiency, sun exposure, supplementation, and for-
Two studies conducted in Saudi Arabia reported preva- tification. One in-depth focus group and 8 one-to-one
lence of 81% in an all female population,17 and 83% interviews were used to collect data.
in a predominantly female sample of participants with Questions were developed according to the founda-
low back pain. tions of KAP studies (Table 1). Aspects that were cov-
Few studies have looked at socio-cultural reasons ered were knowledge or understanding of the topics:
for vitamin D deficiency. However, it has been linked vitamin D deficiency, supplementation, fortification,
to socio-economic status, with avoidance of body sun exposure; attitude referring to feelings towards the
exposure to the sun being stronger in lower socio- topic and practice referring to how knowledge and
economic groups in Saudi Arabia17 and Muslim immi- attitude are demonstrated through their actions.23
grant communities.18 In the Middle East an indoors Questions were adapted from those used in the Brand
lifestyle, partly because of the heat, has been identified and Kung & Lee studies and a study on validated
as a factor for the lack of sun exposure.1 Another sunlight questionnaires.24
factor is assumed to be lack of sun exposure due to
cultural traditions whereby Muslim communities Table 1 Example questions used in the semi-structured
avoid body exposure.17,19 According to one of the interviews
leading experts in the field, Holick (2001),20 Arab Have you heard of vitamin D? If you have, where did you
women who cover their skin are often vitamin D defi- hear about this?
cient. Unfortunately, this statement is evidenced solely Have you ever been offered any advice about preventing
with an early study,21 although Siddiqui (2007) postu- vitamin D deficiency?
lates that in Saudi Arabia sun exposure is limited What factors would you consider important when buying
because women wear a black abaya [burka] covering vitamin supplements?
Have you heard of fortification?
them completely from head to toe.17,21 This study also
Can you tell me how often you are exposed to the sun? At
points to other potential reasons, such as, women
what times of the day?
choosing not to expose themselves to the sun for for In the past week, how much time have you spent being
cosmetic purposes, as they believe it is harmful to exposed to the sun?
their skin. In addition a lack of awareness of the Which parts of your body do you expose to the sun?
importance of vitamin D is noted by Siddiqui. How- How do you feel about sun exposure? Do you like going
ever, empirical evidence is needed to confirm or refute into the sun?
these opinions. Brand’s qualitative study (2008)18 Where would you sunbathe, could you do that in Saudi
among veiled women in Australia found that cultural Arabia?
issues around sun exposure as well as financial con- Can you tell me what things would help you, or your fam-
straints in accessing supplementation were important ily, to follow suggestions about how to prevent vitamin D
deficiency?
contributory factors to vitamin D deficiency. However,
I know it’s good for the bones and we get it from the sun. Cultural reasons that require women to cover their
body fully, including their faces, were a significant bar-
However, none were really aware of any other health rier for all participants. They explained that because
benefits, the risks of vitamin D deficiency or of a rela- their bodies have to be covered in Saudi Arabia their
tionship between breastfeeding and vitamin D. sun exposure is limited.
Participants identified the sources of their knowl-
edge as schools, parents, or television. Exceptions were It is because you have to stay covered here in Saudi,
two students who had been found to be vitamin D even if you go outside you have to stay covered. So it’s
deficient and had been provided with some informa- kind of difficult to pull up your sleeves and get some
tion on the importance of sun exposure and linking sun.
[Participant talking about walking in the sun every day for Cosmetic reasons for avoiding sun exposure were only
half an hour]What body parts would be exposed then? mentioned by one student.
[laughs] yes, with the abaya just the face and hands.
Because I’m dark skinned and most people I hang out
Maybe your hands get exposed here [Saudi Arabia], only with also have dark complexion we don’t like the idea
the hands. People who don’t cover their faces get sun in of going out in the sun because we’re scared of getting
their faces but not your whole body. darker.
On the other hand, despite limited exposure in public,
Although most students had heard of vitamin supple-
many participants expressed that there was enough
mentation, only a minority were taking supplements.
opportunity for them to uncover in private as most of
All students believed it to be essential to consult a
their houses have gardens, balconies, or roof gardens.
health-care professional before taking these and great
No, it’s not hard at all. Because you have roofs or gardens. trust was attributed to health-care professionals in this
There are a lot of fitness clubs with pools [just for women]. respect. Most students had the intention to start taking
vitamin supplements at some stage in the future
Only a minority spontaneously expressed the lack of because they believed this to be beneficial.
opportunity for women to uncover freely to be a barrier.
I think we have to because sometimes we don’t have time
It’s basically only at home, we don’t have outside space.
to eat healthy, it’s all fast food.
We don’t have places to go and just take of the hijab
[headscarf].
Maybe because we are here always in enclosed spaces, we
need it [supplementation].
Several students voiced that Saudi Arabian culture
revolves around an indoor lifestyle and the infrastruc- Costs were not voluntarily mentioned as a reason for
ture is completely geared towards transportation by not taking supplementation. When asked whether
car. There are few areas to walk and no possibility to they would consider costs, all students denied that this
move from one place to the other by foot, which does would be important.
not lend itself as an enabler to prevention of vitamin
D deficiency. When it comes to health I don’t care about costs.
In Saudi Arabia we are not exposed enough by the sun, Similarly, none of the students had heard of fortifi-
we don’t walk anywhere; we go in the car to the place
cation, but most believed this to be useful when
and then back in the car.
introduced to the concept.
When we travel abroad we get exposed more to the sun
than here because we’re walking. We go from place to I think it’s a good idea, you make people take something
place by walking, here that’s not possible. It’s from place that is good for them without the being aware, or forcing
to place by car. them.
generally of higher socio-economic status, especially at Lack of awareness about the amount of exposure
a private university. It is possible that an awareness of needed was demonstrated in our sample through the
vitamin D benefits might be higher in this group. Sun high number who believed they were getting enough
exposure could also be different for this group as edu- sun exposure, unaware that having just their face, and
cational levels have been linked to sun exposure.13 sometimes only hands, exposed would probably not
This group comes into greater contact with Western suffice. Covering skin with clothing prevents skin from
societies where it is more accepted for Muslims to coming into contact with UV-B rays essential for pro-
expose more body parts and where a more outdoor- duction of vitamin D.9,20 Most students seemed to
orientated lifestyle lends itself further to sun exposure. think that exposing face and hands to the sun a few
Many have the means to travel and some students times a week for 10 min in the early or late sun would
reported to be somewhat more exposed to the sun suffice. For a white woman 12 min of summer midday
abroad. Therefore the generalizability of the study is sun with bare arms and legs would produce approxi-
limited, however, as a qualitative exploration some mately 3000 IU of vitamin D.9 In contrast, a similarly
interesting issues are raised. dressed woman with black skin would need 2 hours
The background of the researcher as a Westerner and of sun exposure to produce the same. Many partici-
non-Muslim should also be highlighted. These differ- pants had slightly darker skin complexion, as numer-
ences can be an obstacle in research and limit rapport ous inhabitants of Saudi Arabia do. Therefore, it is
building. However, some studies have found that dis- essential that more parts of the body are exposed,
tance can also facilitate a level of trust and rapport.25 ideally for longer and at different times of day, and
This seemed to occur in the present study where partic- that women are made aware of this.
ipants were very open in sharing their experiences. Women in Muslim communities are affected by the
Gaps in basic knowledge around vitamin D and its tradition of avoiding body exposure.19 This can limit
benefits became apparent in this study. The need for the opportunities women have to uncover and experi-
more health education is highlighted by the conclu- ence sun exposure. Only a minority of participants
sion that participants were unaware of any health ben- spontaneously expressed a need for more areas to
efits of vitamin D other than musculoskeletal health. uncover. Therefore, this may not be a priority for this
This is also urged for in the literature.2,13,15 Although group. However, it has to be remembered that not all
the multiple findings that vitamin D is related to groups of women have the opportunity to uncover.
many aspects of health other than musculoskeletal Many women from lower socio-economic status do
health are still very recent, the research evidence is not live in houses that have outside areas where one
very convincing and shows its vast importance to can uncover. Siddiqui17 found that many of the girls
public health.2,9,10 However, there may be a need to in his Saudi Arabian study who were found to be vita-
inform health-care professionals as well of these new min D deficient lived in smaller, crowded houses
findings. According to Khalsa9 many health-care pro- where sunlight does not penetrate. Indeed, socio-
fessionals are not fully aware of the benefits of vitamin economic status has been linked to vitamin D defi-
D to public health. Brand’s18 study also evidenced the ciency in the Middle East.13 For Middle Eastern and
need for actively increasing awareness amongst health- Muslim women generally there are very few opportu-
care professionals. nities to uncover their faces or their bodies and to
Awareness of the benefits of sunlight needs to be expose themselves to sun. Creating more areas where
increased by provision of specific guidelines about women can uncover freely may have to be part of the
how often sun exposure is required, the duration, and strategy of preventing vitamin D deficiency.
how much of the body should be exposed for optimal The lack of knowledge regarding vitamin D was fur-
vitamin D uptake. All of these aspects were deficient ther demonstrated in the use of sun protection by our
in the knowledge of our participants, in contrast to participants. Of course for years many health cam-
Brand et al.18 who found extremely high levels of paigns have quite successfully promoted the use of
awareness amongst females in Australia. An explana- sun protection with high skin protection factor (SPF)
tion for this may be that Brand’s study was done as a to prevent skin cancer.12,20 However, the use of sun
response to a health promotion campaign. This may protection products prevents UV-B rays from being
well be an encouraging sign for health promotion absorbed by the body and therefore vitamin D cannot
campaigns to be able to achieve the desired effect of be produced.9 Research has shown that sun exposure
informing the population. is beneficial to the human body, whereas excessive
sun exposure is known to cause erythema, skin aging, Saudi Arabian climate. Although also reported by Al
skin cancer and sun-related eye disorders.26 In order Faraj and Al Mutairi19 this is not usually cited as a
to reach a balance between the harmful effects and barrier in the wider literature. More emphasis is put
benefits of sun exposure, public education about the on the cultural tradition of covering skin with clothes.
beneficial effects of some limited sun exposure should Considering that the summer months can range from
be implemented.1 Although more research is needed, March until November, climate may be an important
the current advice seems to be to spend about 10– barrier, too. The combination of the two barriers
15 min in the sun before applying sunscreen prod- together seems to have an unfortunate effect on pre-
ucts.9 Our study participants were unaware of this. vention of vitamin D deficiency. It seems essential to
Considering the barriers identified in this study, establish how much vitamin D the skin can produce
supplementation might be an important enabler for both, in summer months and in winter, at what times
this population to prevent vitamin D deficiency12,13 of day, in the shade or in the sun, and how much of
and with this, knowledge of vitamin supplementation the body should be exposed. Research into this area
should also be increased. Little research has been has been carried out in some locations,30,31 for exam-
undertaken regarding individuals’ knowledge of sup- ple in Boston, but these observations are very different
plementation.9 Again, our results would indicate the at higher latitude. Therefore research would have to be
importance of the role of health-care professionals, as done in the Middle East to determine exact recom-
none of the participants were comfortable taking sup- mendations for the population here.
plements without consulting their physician. It is cru- Furthermore the Saudi Arabian indoors lifestyle,
cial that physicians are informed of the evidence that whether influenced by climate or culture, also became
current recommended daily allowance (RDA) for vita- apparent as a barrier. Several students mentioned that
min D intake seems too low.4,27 It would be helpful if because of the infrastructure, the lifestyle is generally
clarity could be reached on what the specific RDA restricted to indoor activities. There is virtually no
should be.12,13 Thus, more research into this is movement outside. People move from their homes to
urgently needed. the car to another building, it is impossible to walk.
Interestingly, one of Brand’s (2008) findings was There are no pavements and if one wanted to spend
that cost of vitamin supplements was a barrier to par- any time outside one would have to be driven to a
ticipants’ use. Although none of the participants in designated area, of which there are very few, especially
our study expressed concern about cost, it is quite pos- for women. This has severe implications for public
sible that this was due to the high socio-economic sta- health, not only in terms of sun exposure but also
tus of our participants. This may well prove to be a decreased physical exercise. This barrier has not been
barrier for individuals of lower socio-economic status. described in the literature to date, but does need
Considering that there is a strong link between mater- consideration.
nal vitamin D levels and breastfeeding,13,16 it is vital Considering the limited sun exposure fortifying
that women are properly informed about this. Rates of more foods might have to be deemed as part of a pub-
women starting to breastfeed in Saudi Arabia are high lic health strategy in preventing vitamin D deficiency.
(96%) and cultural importance of breastfeeding is sig- Fortification is urged for in the literature.2,13 Currently
nificant as it is encouraged by their religion.28 Therefore bread and milk are fortified in Saudi Arabia;17 rice
it is disappointing that none of the participants, not would qualify as a staple food in Saudi Arabia and
even the two mothers amongst the participants, had may need to be fortified in addition. Encouragingly,
been informed about this aspect of vitamin D. our participants displayed a positive attitude to this
Although cosmetic reasons have been cited as a bar- suggestion, although more research into this is also
rier to sun exposure in other studies, Siddiqui’s,17,29 urgently needed.
this was not viewed as a barrier amongst our partici- The prevalence of vitamin D deficiency in the Mid-
pants, with only one mentioning this as her reason for dle East has been described as alarming,13 and world-
keeping out of the sun. The difference may be a result wide as epidemic.1,9 The major cause of this epidemic
of different study groups but suggests that cosmetic is lack of sun exposure.10,12 The threat to public
reasons may not be specifically important to women health has been demonstrated by highlighting the vast
living in Saudi Arabia. amount of literature linking vitamin D to chronic dis-
The other major barrier for the prevention of vita- eases. This study has emphasised cultural, gender
min D deficiency found in the present study was the and socio-economic health inequalities in relation to
beliefs among dark skinned and veiled people. Int J 27 Holick M (2006) Calcium plus vitamin D and the risk
Rheum Dis 11, 15–23. of colorecteral cancer. N Engl J Med 354, 2287–8.
19 Al Faraj S, Al Mutairi K (2003) Vitamin D deficiency and 28 Al-Jassir M, El-Bashir B, Moizuddin S, Abu-Nayan A
chronic low back Pain in Saudi Arabia. Spine 28, 177–9. (2006) Infant feeding in Saudi Arabia: mothers’ attitudes
20 Holick M (2001) Sunlight ‘‘D’’ ilemma: risk of cancer or and practices. East Mediterr Health J 12, 6–13.
bone disease and muscle weakness. Lancet 357, 4–6. 29 Kung A, Lee K (2006) Knowledge of vitamin D and per-
21 Sedrani S (1984) Vitamin D status of Saudi men. Trop ceptions and attitudes toward sunlight among Chinese
Geogr Med 36, 181–7. middle-aged and elderly women: a population survey in
22 WHO (1986) Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion Hong Kong. BMC Public Health 6, 226.
[Accessed on 6 Sept 2009.] Available from: http:// 30 Holick M (2007) Vitamin D and skin physiology: a
www.who.int/hpr/NPH/docs/ottawa_charter_hp.pdf D-Lightful story. J Bone Miner Res 22, 28–33.
23 Kaliyaperumal K (2004) Guideline for conducting a 31 Webb A, Kline L, Holick M (1988) Influence of season
knowledge, attitude and practice (KAP) study. AECS Illu- and latitude on the cutaneous synthesis of vitamin D3:
mination 4, 7–9. exposure to winter sunlight in boston and edmonton will
24 McCarty C (2008) Sunlight exposure assessment: can we not promote vitamin D3 synthesis in human skin. J Clin
accurately assess vitamin D exposure from sunlight ques- Endocrinol Metab 67, 373–8.
tionnaires? Am J Clin Nutr 87, 1097–101. 32 Naidoo J, Wills J (2006) Health Promotion, Foundations for
25 Green J, Thorogood N (2006) Qualitative Methods for Practice. Elsevier, Bailliere Tindall.
Health Research. Sage Publications, London.
26 Turnbull DJ, Parisi AV, Kimlin MG (2005) Vitamin D
effective ultraviolet wavelengths due to scattering in
shade. J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol 96, 431–6.