Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH ARTICLE
a
Department of Architecture, Bandar Abbas Branch, Islamic Azad University, Bandar Abbas, Iran
b
Department of Architecture, Faculty of Engineering, Golestan University, Gorgan, Golestan, Iran
Received 30 January 2017; received in revised form 31 May 2017; accepted 30 June 2017
KEYWORDS Abstract
Urban fabric; The architecture of Qeshm Island includes the specific architectural style of a warm and wet
Building form; area, which previously had a functional use aimed to reach a sustainable architecture and
Hot and humid cli- development. However, few studies on the identification of the characteristics of vernacular
mate; architecture and their roles in island stability have been performed. Thus, to understand the
Traditional architec-
vernacular architecture of the island as a sustainable pattern, we discussed it separately in
ture;
three aspects, namely, urban fabric, one-based architecture, and architectural details. To
Wind catcher
address our study, a part of the old fabric of the city with its existing buildings (42 buildings of
70 years of age) was selected and evaluated in a qualitative study. Results showed that in the
scale of the urban fabric, factors, such as the structures of the buildings, the frame of the
neighborhood spaces, and in terms of the architectural details, factors, such as bars, thickness
of the walls, and the openings, are among the vernacular features of the area, playing an
important role in the stability of Qeshm Island. In general, studies showed that vernacular
architecture of the island has focused on developing an orientation between the climate of the
region and a good understanding of the construction.
& 2017 Higher Education Press Limited Company. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. on
behalf of KeAi. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
1. Introduction
n The most important issue in today's world in which man has
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: m.pazhouhanfar@gmail.com, a critical role is the reduction of energy consumption
m.pazhouhanfar@gu.ac.ir (M. Pazhouhanfar). (Maleki, 2011). Clearly, approximately 40% of the global
Peer review under responsibility of Southeast University. energy is consumed in the construction sector (Sisson et al.,
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.foar.2017.06.006
2095-2635/& 2017 Higher Education Press Limited Company. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of KeAi. This is an open access
article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
12 H.M. Mazraeh, M. Pazhouhanfar
radiation conditions in Qeshm Island at different months of center and of the city need to be considered. The factor
the year. In addition, because the bioclimatic design is based that has played a fundamental and crucial role in the
on the physical condition of the buildings, the knowledge and emergence of powerful cities since ancient times
ability to exploit sunlight, heat, and air flow through the is the climate. Climate is known as a vital element in
building shell at the exact time needed on specific days and recognizing an architectural structure and is necessary in
months of the year can provide significant data for building building structures in Qeshm Island. The structure can be
structures in Qeshm Island (Szokolay, 2014). classified according to the warm and moist climates as
follows.
3. Method The urban tissue is semidense and semicompact, and the
Sustainable architecture in Qeshm Island consisted of a rural tissues are semiopen with semienclosed spaces.
unique style in a bioclimatic region and is built based on the Semidense tissue not only creates shade on the levels and
special conditions in urban planning and architecture. on the fronts but also provides air flow inside the tissue,
However, no serious study has been conducted to identify if necessary.
sustainable architecture in the hot and humid climate of the Expansion of towns and villages along the coast and
region (Anna-Maria, 2009; Daengbuppha et al., 2006). toward the sea provides the opportunity to take advan-
To address these issues, 42 buildings dating back over 70 tage of sea breezes.
years ago were selected to analyze the ways of preparing
the materials, the process of constructing the buildings with 4.1. Urban scale
these materials, the urban and local spatial relationships,
the morphology of the intersections, the alternative urban 4.1.1. Structure of neighborhood spaces
routes, the natural ventilation through the passages, rout- 4.1.1.1. Spatial urban and local relationships. In forming
ing, the used elements in the building exterior, and the the neighborhoods, the city was divided into several equal
central yard built in the style of vernacular architecture of parts while considering several central points for local
Qeshm Island. The present study aims to address the effects community, i.e., spaces, such as mosques, schools, and
of bioclimatic factors on the formation of architecture and business centers. In the past, this neighborhood-formation
urbanism (i.e., weather conditions, joint and periodic style was very popular in Iran that can be stated that first,
programs of buildings, materials used, and their effects on the center of the neighborhood or city was designed. Then,
the performance of the building along with the rate of with regard to the buildings with the central neighborhood,
taking advantage from the passive solar energy and the the city or the neighborhood was expanded (Figure 3).
structural performance of the building) of Qeshm Island to Essentially, four types of communication can be seen in
obtain background knowledge of the status quo of the the old tissue of Qeshm Island, namely, limited-connected
vernacular structure in three scales including urban fabric, homes, connection between the houses and the community
single-based architecture, and architectural details. centers, connection between cities, and connection
between urban spaces and exterior space of the city.
4. Architectural and urban properties of old Notably, all of these types have been influential in the
development of the functional city. Meanwhile, achieving an
tissue of Qeshm Island increased level of climatic comfort is dependent on the
Few studies have been performed on the local architecture traditional model, which can be justified by Venturi Law.
and urbanism. Significantly, the effect of climate on the The net of strengthening airflow was equally calculated
physical formation and spatial presentation of the living by the mechanical system. Thus, the use of wind energy
14 H.M. Mazraeh, M. Pazhouhanfar
would be economically effective. In the local context of the reconciliation”. The width to height ratio in these alleys is
island, the squares were placed together as dense and close often 1:5–1:10 (Figure 5).
as possible, allowing a distance of 20–75 m from each other. The neighborhoods consist of alleys with narrow openings
The large number of these squares in the differently sized and high walls, which are often in shade during the days. In
neighborhoods along with their proximity has created a the historic fabric of the island, no blind street existed, and
good urban structure and several passages for the architec- the blocks were surrounded by the streets to provide the
ture in harmony with the climate (Figure 4). maximum levels of fresh air. The communication network
4.1.1.2. Routing. Qeshm Island has a very dense texture. was affected by temperature and humidity of the environ-
In addition, most buildings were designed as the central ment, wind direction, terrain, local materials, property and
courtyard and various other forms along with several long local custom, and economic and social features (Figure 6).
streets and squares. Compared with the other regions in The passages were built in accordance with the verna-
Iran, the traditional alleys and streets in Qeshm Island were cular architecture of the island because of the sun angle.
very narrow, providing difficulty for two people passing by. Therefore, the pedestrians, exposed to harsh sunlight, did
Therefore, they were named as “the streets of not feel it in the local streets as far as possible. In other
Figure 4 (a) Positioning of squares through urban passages and their distance; (b) Morphology of city squares.
Figure 5 (a) Comparison between the width of the streets and the penetration rate; (b) Route framework.
Effects of vernacular architecture structure 15
words, vernacular architects considered the ratio of the low buildings in the central plateau of Iran is that even though
width to the height and created pathways with high thermal these buildings are introverted, their relationship with the
comfort for the pedestrians (Figure 7). outer space is not completely closed. In addition, tall and
In Qeshm Island, a city with narrow, broken, and meander high windows and wide porches facing the streets or squares
alleys to form urban passages with high thermal comfort were placed in the second and, especially, in the third floors
was attempted to be built (Figure 8). Fractures caused by of the buildings to use bilateral air inside the rooms and
the alleys have caused less exposure to the sun's rays to the reduce heat intensity. Thus, the required ventilation was
alley surfaces. Thus, the observed difference in air tem- provided by opening the windows facing the courtyard and
perature across a network of pathways would cause changes the windows facing the street because in the afternoons or
in air pressure and internal air flows of the alleys. evenings, the sun intensity is less. The family members used
to sit on the external porch facing the sea and enjoy the wind
4.2. Buildings flow blowing between the sea and the beach. In this area, the
porch was greater compared with that in mainland Iran and
was considered as a key space in the building. During hot
4.2.1. Orientation of buildings
seasons, lasting for approximately six months, daily activities
Given that most houses in the island were low lying and
were often performed within the porch because it is well
encapsulated, ventilation through the roof seemed suitable.
ventilated and in shade. Thus, large and high porches were
Meanwhile, proper orientation of the building can be useful
built both around the central courtyard and on one or two
in moving air flow for natural ventilation of the region,
sides of the exterior (Preusser et al., 2003). These porches
especially in hot and humid climate. Although the purpose
were designed for air circulation, connected the interior and
of constructing such houses was to obtain the minimum
exterior spaces to provide good performance for air condi-
solar energy during hot seasons of the year, the most
tioning in different seasons in the local buildings of the island.
appropriate orientation for the building was the north–south
In general, the vernacular architects considered the main
direction with 151 east of the south. Given the minimum and
factor, which is the form, to set up the buildings. Therefore,
maximum amounts of the solar energy received during the
the form of the buildings was considered in the wind-flow
hot and cold months of the year, respectively, 621 east to
direction (north to south) to benefit from wind breeze. As
131 west was also suitable in this regard (Figure 9).
shown in Figure 10, the form of the building also exhibited a
great effect on the determination of the position during
4.2.2. Building form winter and summer stay.
Most buildings in the island are semiintroverted with rooms To identify the surface area to volume ratio, four housing
designed around a central courtyard. The main difference styles with a central courtyard in the island were used to
between these buildings with a central courtyard and similar
16 H.M. Mazraeh, M. Pazhouhanfar
Figure 8 (a) Street fractures to provide shade. (b) Open spaces through routes and squares.
Figure 10 Table of seasonal positioning of spaces with natural ventilation performance in buildings.
Table 2 Surface area to volume (A/V) ratio in vernacular buildings of Qeshm Island.
Central court- A/V a (m) b (m) c (m) h (m) I type A/V a (m) b (m) c (m) h (m)
yard plan 0.8 15 15 3.60 6 plan 0.5 26 26 10 6
0.5 27 27 8 6 0.6 27 27 8 6
0.7 19 19 4.30 6 0.7 19 19 4.30 6
0.8 16 16 5 6 0.8 16 16 4.80 6
0.9 14 14 3.20 6 0.9 14 14 4.20 6
0.5 18 18 7 6 1 10 10 3.20 6
mounted on the ceiling used for natural ventilation within natural cooling in the building. Moreover, the grids built as
the building's internal spaces. It works through attracting the holes in the middle of the exterior walls showed
wind and circulating it in the interior spaces and finally functional and decorative uses and were used for natural
sends out hot wind through the openings of the wind catcher ventilation because of their special geometry. In other words,
from the other side (Figure 12). wind flow is heavily dependent on the geometry and the
4.2.3.3. Natural ventilation elements used in building proportions of the passages. However, the rooms with multi-
shell. According to surveys conducted for hundreds of years, ple windows (as a natural ventilation element) were placed
we can conclude that to create an atmosphere of thermal several meters above the ground in long and drawn openings
comfort, the best way is to use accessible materials and of the alleys to attract high-speed winds and lead them into
climate-responsive construction technologies (Bodach et al., the interior space of the buildings. These rooms were mostly
2014). In addition, natural ventilation can be regarded as a built in the middle openings of the buildings and in the spaces
proper cooling strategy with significant advantages to provide of the streets and along the beach (Figure 13).
18 H.M. Mazraeh, M. Pazhouhanfar
Figure 11 (a) Studied space of blocks; (b) Elongation of blocks in north–south direction.
Figure 12 Wind flow in wind catcher through breathing air. Grid influence for natural ventilation of the interior space after venting
hot air.
4.2.3.4. Combination of two elements including louver of the buildings. In addition, because of its effect on
and lattice in the building interior and wind circulation. As decoration and providing shade and its minimal water
illustrated in Figures 14 and 15, the desirable wind flows requirement and its fruit, palm tree is regarded as the
into the inner space through these two elements (louver and most important plant of the island (Figure 16).
lattice). In addition, undesirable air is pushed out in the
opposite side. Given that warm air tends to rise and cool air
tends to come down because of great density, the wind 4.2.5. Courtyard
flows into the interior through the shabak embedded in the Central courtyard in a building can be considered as a
walls and the louver in the ceiling and flows out from the passive but useful system, which can easily help in air
opposite side of the louver. The wind circulation is very circulation of the building. Studies and experience have
similar to human respiration. This method was how our proven that our ancestors’ vernacular architecture has been
ancestors can find a suitable model with the knowledge a convenient source for studying and understanding the
about adapting building design to climate and appropriate designs of the basic buildings along with a reuse of
use of elements in available spaces. architectural solutions consistent with climate (Motealleh
et al., 2016). Moreover, the combination of open and
semiopen spaces in these native homes can also create
4.2.4. Green surfaces wind flow both in the context of life and in the central
Palm trees were regarded as the main shade supplier courtyard.
because of the high density of urban fabric and to avoid The presence of the central courtyard in the main part of
any negative effect on air flow in the streets. Thus, palm a building conveys a passive system that can easily benefit
trees are known as “the green space of Qeshm Island”. from air circulation (Shahin and Takapoomanesh, 2014). The
Notably, its main application was in the central courtyards greatest area used for creating a central courtyard in the
Effects of vernacular architecture structure 19
Figure 13 Turret decoration, natural ventilation elements within, and elements of natural ventilation on external elements.
Figure 14 Wind performance in the summer and winter parts of Amir Bahador's house.
local buildings of Qeshm Island was shaped as a square or Thus, the landlady was able to cook food in the veranda for
rectangle. Thus, the streets (b and c) were narrower than its landlord and his guests or colleagues. Given that no
the central courtyard (a), mainly to enable the natural plumbing existed in the city and the underground water was
ventilation system within the urban fabric and urban devel- salty, the presence of water storages in the houses of the
opment. In addition, the narrow streets can circulate wind affluent is a vital and necessary phenomenon. During rain-
flows rapidly in the climate of the island, which has high fall, running water from the roof and the yard flows toward
moisture content. The mild breeze can enter through the the water storage built at the bottom of one of the ground
lattice similar to a space high up the walls into the central floor rooms to be used for cooking and drinking purposes
courtyard to ventilate its space naturally (Figure 17). during the year.
Figure 15 Performance of wind catcher and grids in the natural ventilation of the interior space of Amir Bahador's house.
Figure 16 (a) View of using palm trees in central courtyard of Qeshm Island; (b) irrigation chart of eight months of the year.
Figure 18 Function and interior spatial relationships of buildings with communication between the interior and exterior spaces.
Figure 19 (a) Modern building construction on island; (b) Graph and photo of single-layer pattern and opposite opening in
traditional tissue of Qeshm Island; (c) Graph and photo of the introversion and extraversion in the field.
Figure 20 Photographs and diagrams of the roof and skyline in background and shadow of casting building over the other buildings.
construction. After recognizing the constructible ground capacity. The outer walls were thick and, up to the altitude
and soil excavation, the house was built with the same soil of approximately 50–70 cm, were built with special materi-
as a combination of mortar and stone. Thick walls were also als, such as bricks and stones.
made with this material to reflect a great amount of solar
energy. Bright soil color was the best color material choice
in this hot and humid area. As expressed in Table 3, the 4.3.3. Using local materials
main frame of the building was made of materials with very In the island, the most important parts of the houses were
high thermal mass. These walls displayed high thermal extracted from sedimentary stones taken from the nearby
22 H.M. Mazraeh, M. Pazhouhanfar
Figure 21 Use of external post and shear walls to prevent landslides in areas prone to earthquakes and with a high-moisture
content.
Table 3 Thicknesses of exterior and interior walls of 48 buildings studied on the island.
Row Thickness of Thickness of Row Thickness of Thickness of Row Thickness of outer Thickness of inner
outer wall inner wall outer wall inner wall wall wall
cliffs. These pieces were sliced in large sizes of the rocks to fit lifted apart on two opposite walls. Then, they were covered
brick dimension. Then, they were used in the load-bearing with the mat. Finally, the roof level was covered with a cob
walls as fillers and separators. Materials, which were drawn layer (see Figures 22–24).
on the walls as the final plate, were prepared by the plaster The floor and the outer walls were exposed to moisture
taken from Bandar Khamīr, straw mortar from around the because of the island nature of the area and its proximity with
island. In addition, in ceilings, mangrove and predate wood high humidity. Thus, the building has been set up with certain
and cob were used as the main construction materials. In considerations. In other words, after excavation, the floor was
these beaches, using arches and domes was not common, and leveled with a straw mortar. It was covered to a depth of
most buildings had flat cob arches. First, the long wooden approximately 50 cm by the limestone riprap and concrete.
beams, approximately 30 cm in their original form, were The surface of this foundation was paved with a straw mortar,
Effects of vernacular architecture structure 23
Figure 24 Diagram analysis of formation of urban context due to weather conditions: (a) sunlight and (b) groundwater penetration.
and the walls were set up with stones and mortars at every altitudes. The slope extending from the west to the east
30 cm. The wall thickness varied from 50 cm to 70 cm. The of the land was also constructed in this manner.
best functional element in such hot and humid area was the
wooden beams with low heat capacity, e.g., plywood.
This 10 cm-diameter timber, which was placed in every 5. Conclusion
20 cm on two walls (carrying wood had a large cross section
providing large intervals), was covered by the palm leaf mat Although vernacular architecture has experienced tremendous
(Godats) or the wooden network. The mat was also covered changes during the history, it has failed to maintain its special
with desert sand and was rolled up. This sand was used for identity. Thus, it is considered as a valid certificate of the style
aligning the slope. Moreover, during the rare rainy days, of building structure in an area to illustrate itself in the
absorbing moisture from the top layer prevented its dis- functional and structural principles and cope with the climate
placement. This soil was also covered with a 5-cm straw and esthetics. Given that environment includes nature, cul-
mortar. Notably, replacing it was required every 10–15 ture, and man and their close relationship, in the vernacular
years. The rich families used to plaster their houses with architecture of Qeshm Island, providing a connection between
gypsum mortar, whereas the poor ones simply used straw the social and cultural factors is necessary to pay attention to
mortar thatch. Interestingly, in terms of structure, the roof the relationship between man and his environment and human
of such buildings was the weakest part of the house because scale, meeting the physical and emotional needs of the
no tight coupling existed between the beams and walls and residents. Native buildings of the island are of special sig-
even the beams themselves. Thus, as an unstable structure, nificance mainly because of the use of nonfossil fuels and clean
it was highly vulnerable to earthquake. This kind of mortar and renewable energy. Thus, it has been able to provide
showed no resistance against the rain. Thus, the absorbed suitable space for organic growth, designing in harmony with
moisture can easily provide discomfort for the residents and the site and climate, saving and conserving energy in construc-
gradually decay the building materials. tion and maintenance, and using local materials (mud, wood,
palm leaves, soil, etc.). In fact, based on the energy required
for the maintenance and adjustment of environmental condi-
4.3.4. Permeability of underground water tions with proper design of full and empty spaces in both micro
More distances can be seen in the west in terms of height and macro scales, proper orientation of buildings and the use
than that in the east because the western height of the of a passive system in preserving sustainability are considered
island is higher than its east one. Thus, most buildings are and are proposed as suitable patterns for modern architecture.
short in the East. In fact, a glimpse at this issue shows that To expand its orientation with the regional climate, the
the buildings of Qeshm Island are built on different vernacular architecture of Qeshm Island has focused on
24 H.M. Mazraeh, M. Pazhouhanfar
recognizing the construction process, both in architecture and Elmualim, A.A., 2006. Effect of damper and heat source on wind
in urbanism, wherein it can be used as a good model for catcher natural ventilation performance. Energy Build. 38 (8),
building construction in hot and humid climate of the island, 939–948.
especially by new architects. Moreover, this vernacular archi- Engin, N., Vural, N., Vural, S., Sumerkan, M., 2007. Climatic effect
tecture can be used as a perfect pattern of architecture and in the formation of vernacular houses in the Eastern Black Sea
urbanism in a certain region. Consequently, the aim of all these region. Build. Environ. 42 (2), 960–969.
Khan, N., Su, Y., Riffat, S.B., 2008. A review on wind driven
subjects is to familiarize the architects with the region, prior to
ventilation techniques. Energy Build. 40 (8), 1586–1604.
designing its architecture or urbanism, to achieve and use Maleki, B.A., 2011. Traditional sustainable solutions in Iranian
sustainable architecture and urbanism. desert architecture to solve the energy problem. Int. J. Tech.
Phys. Probl. Eng. 6, 84–91.
Motealleh, P., Zolfaghari, M., Parsaee, M., 2016. Investigating
References climate responsive solutions in vernacular architecture of Bush-
ehr city. HBRC J..
Allegrini, J., Dorer, V., Carmeliet, J., 2016. Impact of radiation Oikonomou, A., Bougiatioti, F., 2011. Architectural structure and
exchange between buildings in urban street canyons on space environmental performance of the traditional buildings in
cooling demands of buildings. Energy Build. 127, 1074–1084. Florina, NW Greece. Build. Environ. 46 (3), 669–689.
Anna-Maria, V., 2009. Evaluation of a sustainable Greek vernacular Preusser, F., Radtke, U., Fontugne, M., Haghipour, A., Hilgers, A.,
settlement and its landscape: architectural typology and build- Kasper, H., Pirazzoli, P., 2003. ESR dating of raised coral reefs
ing physics. Build Environ. 44 (6), 1095–1106. from Kish Island, Persian Gulf. Quat. Sci. Rev. 22 (10),
Bahadori, M., 1978. Passive cooling systems in Iranian architecture. 1317–1322.
Sci. Am. 238 (2). Shahin, A., Takapoomanesh, S., 2014. Sustainability patterns in the
Bodach, S., Lang, W., Hamhaber, J., 2014. Climate responsive old residential fabric of Bushehr. Arch. Constr. 5 (15), 130–135.
building design strategies of vernacular architecture in Nepal. Sharifi, A., Murayama, A., 2013. Changes in the traditional urban
Energy Build. 81, 227–242. form and the social sustainability of contemporary cities: a case
Bouchahm, Y., Bourbia, F., Belhamri, A., 2011. Performance analysis study of Iranian cities. Habitat Int. 38, 126–134.
and improvement of the use of wind tower in hot dry climate. Sisson, W., van-Aerschot, C., Kornevall, C., Cowe, R., Bridoux, D.,
Renew. Energy 36 (3), 898–906. Bonnaire, T.B., Fritz, J., 2009. Energy Efficiency in Buildings:
Bouyer, J., Inard, C., Musy, M., 2011. Microclimatic coupling as a Transforming the Market. World Business Council for Sustainable
solution to improve building energy simulation in an urban Development (WBCSD), Switzerland.
context. Energy Build. 43 (7), 1549–1559. Szokolay, S.V., 2014. Introduction to Architectural Science: The
Daengbuppha, J., Hemmington, N., Wilkes, K., 2006. Using Basis of Sustainable Design. Routledge.
grounded theory to model visitor experiences at heritage sites: Wang, L., Wong, N. H., & Li, S., 2010. Facade design optimization
methodological and practical issues. Qual. Mark. Res.: Int. J. 9 for naturally ventilated residential buildings in Singapore (vol
(4), 367–388. 39, pg 954, 2007). Energy Build. 42(10), pp. 1968-1968.