Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/361736491
CITATIONS READS
0 129
1 author:
Muluneh Shiferaw
Wolkite University
2 PUBLICATIONS 0 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Muluneh Shiferaw on 04 July 2022.
July 2022
I
Table of Contents
1. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ...................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Acronyms .......................................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... IV
CHAPTER ONE .............................................................................................................................. 1
1. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................... 1
1.1 Background of study .......................................................................................................... 1
1.2 Background of the organization ......................................................................................... 3
1.3. Statement of the problem .................................................................................................. 3
1.4 research questions .............................................................................................................. 5
1.5. Objective of the study ....................................................................................................... 6
1.6 Significance of the study ........................................................................................................ 6
1.7 scope of the study................................................................................................................... 7
1.8 Limitation of the study ........................................................................................................... 7
1.9. Organization of the paper...................................................................................................... 7
CHAPTER TWO ............................................................................................................................. 8
2. LITERATURE REVIEW ........................................................................................................ 8
2.1. Definition of management information system................................................................. 8
2.2. Information system resource and products ....................................................................... 8
2.3 Features of management information system .................................................................... 9
2.4 Information requirement of an organization ................................................................. 10
2.5 information requirement of manager ............................................................................... 11
2.6 Decision making and quality of information ................................................................... 12
2.7 The nature of decision making ......................................................................................... 13
2.8 Types of information system............................................................................................ 14
2.9 Importance of Information System .................................................................................. 19
2.10 Banking Information System (BIS) ............................................................................... 19
2.11 Empirical Review of the study ........................................................................................... 20
CHAPTER THREE ....................................................................................................................... 22
3. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY ............................................................. 22
3.1 Research design ............................................................................................................... 22
II
3.2. Population and sampling technique ................................................................................ 23
3.3. Types of data collected and collection method ............................................................... 23
3.4. Data analysis methods..................................................................................................... 23
CHAPTER FOUR.......................................................................................................................... 24
4. PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS OF DATA ................................................................ 24
4.1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................... 24
Table 4.1 demographic characteristics and the respondents .................................................. 24
Table 4.2 shortage of skilled man power in MIS, performance of managing information
system and current MIS. ........................................................................................................ 26
Table 4.3 the information development project ..................................................................... 28
Table 4.4 MIS delivery .......................................................................................................... 29
Table 4.5 the relationship between IT expert and other unit.................................................. 30
Table 4.6 five elements of MIS .............................................................................................. 31
Table 4.7 Error encountered while running the system ......................................................... 34
Table 4.8 information for decision making ............................................................................ 35
Table 4.9 management information system (MIS) problème ................................................ 36
Table 4.10 the consideration of employees to MIS................................................................ 37
Table 4.11 employee’s knowledge about MIS....................................................................... 38
Table 4.12 the commitment of top management about MIS .................................................. 39
The response for open ended questionnaires ............................................................................. 40
The respondents mention the basic obstacles are:- .................................................................... 40
The respondents mention the roles of MIS are:- ........................................................................ 40
The respondents mentioned how can they increase their knowledge of MIS ............................ 41
CHAPTER FIVE ........................................................................................................................... 42
5. CONCLUSON AND RECOMMANDATION ...................................................................... 42
Summary .................................................................................................................................... 42
5.1 Conclusions ...................................................................................................................... 42
5.2 Recommendation ............................................................................................................. 45
Reference ....................................................................................................................................... 46
APPENDIX 1 .................................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
III
Abstract
Banking industry plays a key role in investment and growth for the development of
different industries in our glob. Because MIS play a key role in determining the degree of
success and affect the competition position of commercial banks in the world, which has
connection with globalization, and thus, this issue needs investigation. Therefore , the main
purpose of this study was to examine the role Management information system enhancing
banking service in case of commercial bank of Ethiopia under Bure Damot branch in Bure
town.
In order to meet the objectives of the study, different statistical techniques were employed
on the basis of the basic questions stated and on the nature of the data collected.
Consequently, the data collected from the respondents were analyzed quantitatively and
qualitatively.
Finally, this study recommend some solutions to the problem identified in the study.
IV
CHAPTER ONE
1. INTRODUCTION
The main motivation for this paper is based on the fact that many organizations are trying
to adopt Management Information Systems to increase their efficiency and improve their
decision making. Three factors named organization, management, and technological
factors affect the successful execution of MIS. This paper aims to make discussion on these
factors, and it demonstrates how they are interrelated with each other. Recently, due to a
significant decline in the cost of information technology (IT) and greatly improved speed
and power of computers, MIS moved from its traditional role as an application of back
office support to one offering opportunities for gaining significant competitive advantage.
It is being increasingly viewed as having the capability to alter core organizational
directions, reorient corporate strategy, and redefine industry structure.
1
In recent years, there has been increased awareness among organizations of the potential
of IT and use of MIS to exploit its potential and use it effectively. Many successful local
financial institutions like Eastern Bank Ltd., The City Bank Ltd, Brac Bank have clearly
demonstrated that information systems and technologies can be a powerful competitive
weapon that can be used to capture market share, improve customer service, reduce
operating costs, and create new products and services. Currently, organizations are in the
race for enhancing their capability in order to survive in the competitions of the new
century global market. Therefore, organizations are attempting to advance their agility
level by improving the decision making process to be more efficient and highly effective
to meet the successive fluctuations of the market. In an effort to achieve this, many modern
organizations, either mid or large sized, have concerned with a cycle of progressive
investments in and adopted new management information system components.
During last decade, a high percentage of financial organizations frequently used
Management Information Systems to facilitate the provision of services; and that the speed
of the adoption is expected to grow further as the technology expands. In a Bank’s
information system, there is always a potential crisis which makes the bank endure an
insufficiency; thus, an advanced information system supported by a superior mechanism
control is required to make certain that an information system has achieved the required
processes. If the relevant information required in a decision-making process or an
organization planning is not available at the appropriate time, then there is a good change
to be a poor organization planning, inappropriate decision-making, poor priority of needs,
and defective programming or scheduling of activities (Adebayo, 2007).Information is
essential for the endurance of a financial organization in the global and competitive market.
The nature of globalization and competitiveness in the market stress on the importance of
developing an organization capability through better enhancing MIS. Accordingly, the
stored information must then be recalled and distributed for the use of an organization
leadership and top management as well as mid-level managers to take effective long term
(strategic) and short term (Tactical) decision-making. MIS is deemed to be a system which
provides organizations top management and, even lower level management, with
appropriate information based on data from both internal and external sources, to allow
2
them to make effective and timely decisions that best achieve their organization goals and
satisfy stakeholder requirements (Argyris, 1971).
The trade liberalization and globalization have resulted in keen competition among firms
and industries. The Ethiopian banking industry is not exempted especially with the
proliferation of banking and financial institutions in the country. With the availability of
goods and services, organizations need proactive strategies, the absence of which can lead
to a steady decline of market share (Collier, 2006).Before the developments of modern
3
information system, traditional decision making processes had been under taken in the
forms of haphazard management technique. Such kind of decision making which was
random selective alternative did not bring solution for management decision and identified
organization problems. This try and error activity in the past had resulted in bankruptcy to
organizational performances.
Now days, MIS provide regular information to managers to allow them to make decisions
based on data rather than guesses. Currently, in developed countries the way of doing
works and the managers‟ decision making processes has changed dramatically. As MIS
has developed, the availability and utilization of information for decision making processes
will increase efficiency and effectiveness of banking operation.
The information technology simplifies the use of decision making to integrate the
functional units of the organization and disseminate the information among each unit. The
concept of electronic banking services was benefited associated with electronic
transactions between banks and their clients, or, realizations of electronic system of
payment are developed specially in well developed countries. This is because bank
managers daily have to take job-related decisions in order to provide value-added services
to their clients. The development and uses of MIS is a modern phenomenon concerned with
the accessible and appropriate information that leads to better planning, better decision
making and better results in developing countries like Ethiopia. In spite of the management
information systems development, it is not well accepted due to different resistance which
arises from different factors. But it is not an exaggeration to state that MIS is the lifeblood
of management. Ajayi and Omirin (2007) investigated the use of MIS in decision-making
on longterm planning, short term planning and budgeting in the commercial banks of
Nigerian. The authors said that, “the use of management information systems has a great
importance in improving business operations in terms of reducing time and cost as well as
increasing competitiveness.” In the same way, in case of Commercial bank of Ethiopia, the
utilization of MIS in management decision making process has also great importance if
well available and utilized effectively and efficiently. But as current practice shows, there
is a gap in the availability and utilization of MIS in management decision making process
in Commercial Bank of Ethiopia. MIS has been viewed by its practitioners as playing only
4
a supportive role. Thus commercial bank of Ethiopia would have a lot of advantages if they
use management information systems effectively and efficiently. The Study of ( Karim,
2011) Title is " The Significance of Management Information Systems for Enhancing
Strategic And Tactical Planning ", this study investigates the contribution of management
information systems (MIS) only for decision making. the rest role of MIS has been missed
in the study. The gap of the study has initiated the researcher to assess how management
information systems availability and utilization affect management decisions making and
enhancing banking service.
Based on this, the rationale of this study was to find out the role of management information
systems in commercial bank of Ethiopia Bure Damot branch, which has tremendous
importance since they are blood vessels of the country’s economy and the use of
management information systems effectively and efficiently boost their performance. to
some lesser extent the study used to support researchers to address service excellence and
business growth problems.
How is the smooth relation with information technology and other department in
commercial bank of Ethiopia, Bure Damot branch?
5
1.5. Objective of the study
To assess the relationship between management information system and the bank
To assess the consideration given for management information system by banking industry
Firstly it creates know how in such that, using management information system an
organization is able to establish its hierarchical structure and work flow chart. Secondly,
the companies operating procedures would be listed by management information system
and the preparation of audit also get simplified.
6
Thirdly every employee in the organization would know the employee he/she has the
authority over and to whom he is responsible for work and workers then progress without
interruption.
The finding of the research helps initial insight for other researchers who are interested to
go through a detailed study for the future.
The second chapter contains literature reviews related to the study. In this chapter various
theoretical concept that related with management information system would be discussed.
The third chapter would be about research methodology.
Analysis of collected data interpretation of the analyzed data would be presented in the
fourth chapter. And finally, the fifth chapter would presents summaries of major findings,
conclusion and the possible recommendations.
7
CHAPTER TWO
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
Some writers prefer alternative terminology for management information system such as
information processing system, information decision system, organizational information
system, information system which support the operations management and decision
making function of an organization. (Govdon B.davis and H.Olson 2010)
Management information system is an integrated computer based user machine system that
provides information for supporting operation and decision making (Walton, 1987)
Specialists: - system analyst, software developers, and system operator those are peoples
who develop and operate information system. The specialist design information system
based on the requirement end users.
8
End users: - are people who use information system or the information it produces. They
can be customers, sales persons, engineers, clerks, accountants or managers.
2. Hard ware resources: - include all physical devices and materials used in information
processing
Machines: - computers, video monitors, magnetic disk drivers, printers, optical scanners
Media: - floppy disk, magnetic tape, optical disks, plastic cards paper forms
Programs: - operating system program, spread sheet program, word processing programs,
payroll programs.
Information products: - are manager’s reports and business documents using text and
graphic displays, audio responses and paper forms that are easily visualize or display on
customers and employees that support the provision of service. (James A.0 Brien 2004)
9
Provision of non-line cases to the transaction processing system of the organization to give
summarizes information on the performance of the organization.
Use of relatively simples to produce summaries and computations rather than more detailed
mathematical model, over static calculation techniques found in a decision support system
(Kothari, 2004)
Information for planning process incorporates several strategies all at which require
information that means organization mission setting background, situation analysis
objective setting strategy information tactic setting implementing and control uses
information. Information for decision making manager were need information to help
10
decides what occurs of action is must like to bring a situation under control the decision
making process usually needs some information about the triples an event a piece of
information that participate the need for decision the better the information follow the
sooner the need for a decision is indicated and the more times the decision information is
called to help in making the right decision. If the nature of the decision that a manager is
like to face can be predicated then information can be controlled in absence, this is speed
up the decision making process and enable the manager to bring situation under control
faster(Mohamed Said, 1995).
11
change in the leisure industry, which is considers to be expanding strategic decision
involves the formulation of the new objectives and deciding on the manner in which the
new are already industry. Although strategic planning is concerned with long term goals,
it often involves the long term actions, for example the age is city on of a new company in
the leisure industries in made in order to fulfill a long term objective but, it refuse short
term planning control action all of which is classified under the head of strategic planners
(Evanston, 2005).
12
Reliability it is dependable, that means free from error or pies faithful poor
trays events and activities
Accessibility you can get it when you needed it and information you can
use (Mesfin 2008).
13
would be sold high price low volume or low volume /high price. Effort is often made to
turn unstructured decision in to structure one by setting hard and fast criteria. This practice
is ginning ground in such filed as requirement and granting credit facilities. (Claudio,
Vcibora, 1998).
Management levels: - the management level with an organization is designed to assist with
the monitoring and control of other system they are tend to provide report on an
examination basis to support the decision making of more senior manager. Decision
support system (DSS) is used to provide summaries information, while management
information system provides summaries of the transaction data from the transaction
processing system (TPS).
Strategic level:- the strategic levels system help management address more long term issues
and problems such as the overall strategic direction and product, like the production of five
14
year plans, the executive support system provide management with the summarized
strategic information needed to make decision (Walton,1987).
While the image of senior executive is that of people concerned with the longer strategic
issue, the reality is that they are often very concerned about the short term performance of
the organization. It is monitoring of this kind of information which executive information
system are typically put to the nature of the war in which an executive may every system
particularly suits this kind of reporting need if sale are down lost month, he or she can
quickly find out the area which require action. This help the executive keep the
organization within budget.
15
make model from which the best decision can be taken. DSS give the decision maker the
access to this type of model but, the intelligent intuition and judgment of the decision
making are integral part of the system. A good DSS should have balance among the three
capabilities. It should be easy to use, to support the interaction with non-technical user. It
should have access to avoid variety of data and it should provide modeling and analysis in
many ways. In summary DSS is not concerned with the routine processing of transaction
recording keep or reporting (O, Kendie and S. Yusuf, 2002).
Broad base approach to supporting decision making those help to identify important
further trained, obtaining the organization to changing condition.
Decision making retain control over the decision making. It allowed the
capability of restrictive manipulate present and store data.
16
works themselves perform many essential taken within an organization including ,Keeping
the organization up to date with new knowledge as it develops outside the company, area
such technology science and humanities ,Providing advice inside the organization, acting
as change agent by actually recommending and implementing changes within an
organization(Kothari ,2005).
After the data has been computer by TPS, the MIS and other strategic system can then use
it. There is often be directed links from the TPS to the MIS. With the later effectively
summarizing from the TPS to show totals for a week’s month or even years the
summarization process allows trend to be established and helps with strategic planning.
17
expert system store the knowledge and experience of the number of expert in structured
data base known as knowledge often on line or by frequently up grade. Expert system can
be used at variety of different levels at the simplest level they can give factual answer to
technical question and at more complex level they can suggest how decision should be
recommending course of action( Atikson,2007)
Support of business operation by processing data with more speed and more capacity
generated by and used in business operation. They recorded and process data resulting from
business transaction. Update database and produce various documents and reports to speed
up business operation and hence decision making would be on time. Information system
plays a great role by providing reports and critical information to mangers. They also give
advice and interaction support for manager. It are achieves this role by improving
operational efficiency of the organization, promoting business information and building
strategic information.
18
2.9 Importance of Information System
It would be repetitive to say that IS or information technology (IT) are playing vital and
expanding role in business. However, making a short last of the benefit is enable to better
demonstrate the significance of IS.
19
2.11 Empirical Review of the study
Through the following presentation, the researcher arranged previous studies related to the
subject of study in descending order.
The Study of ( Reddy..et..al, 2009) Title is " Management Information system to help
managers for providing decision making in all organization " ,this study investigate in
provides management information system (MIS) information on the administrative
activities of the organization. The main purpose of this research is, MIS provides accurate
and timely information necessary to facilitate decision-making and enable organizations
planning and control the executive and the tasks to be carried out effectively process.
Management Information System (MIS) is mainly concerned with the processing of data
into information and then is transferred to different departments in the organization to take
the appropriate decision. MIS is a subset of the overall planning and monitoring, which
covers the application of human beings, techniques, and procedures of the organization's
activities.
Study of ( Karim, 2011) Title is " The Significance of Management Information Systems
for Enhancing Strategic And Tactical Planning ", this study investigate in management
information systems (MIS) is a key factor to facilitate the achievement of the efficiency of
decision-making in the organization. This paper explores the extent to implement systems
to make successful decisions in two of the selected financial organizations and
administrative information. Research examined whether the selected financial institutions
in Bahrain vary regarding the use of the leadership of management information systems
for the purposes of making strategic and tactical planning decision. Conditioning research
and quantitative research designed to examine two hypotheses. It was distributed to a total
of 190 questionnaires equally to those who work in the various administrative levels in the
selected organizations. Search Results showed that the MIS was used primarily to enhance
the strategic planning in the financial institutions. Regression analysis revealed that the
tactical planning and found to have no effect on the decision-making, while the strategic
planning have a clear impact on the effectiveness of decision making in both organizations
and the study showed no differences in terms of gender and experience variable.
20
Study (Jane..et..al, 2013) entitled " Management Information System as a Technique in the
Administration of Secondary Schools in ABA Zone South East Nigeria", this paper has
investigation information management system as a tool in secondary schools in the ABA
Education Management District, southeast Nigeria. The descriptive study to determine the
extent of the official high school use of management information systems management tool.
21
CHAPTER THREE
Research methodology defines the systematic and scientific procedures used to arrive at
the results and findings for a study against which claims for knowledge are evaluated
(Cooper & Schindler, 2006; Saunders, 2000). A methodology is therefore shaped by the
perspectives the researcher chooses to approach a study.
(Cress well, 2003). Based on this research is a systematic inquiry aimed at providing
information to solve problems. So that, In order to solve the problem or answer the research
questions appropriate methodology should be designed in order to show how research
questions will be answered in the most rigorous method.
22
The study was conducted in commercial bank of Ethiopia, Bure Damot branch in order to
get the required data appropriate source of data was employed. The study would employed
descriptive survey research design to carry out the research to describe the issue and came
up with the relevant solution. The main purpose of such research is to describe the state of
nature and affairs as if it exists at present to report what would happen or would be
happening.
After collection of all questionnaires from the respondents using the above method of data
collection and census method data analysis would be done. The data gained from the study
or collected from the respondent would be analyzed using descriptive analysis which uses
tabulation, percentage and statements.
23
CHAPTER FOUR
4.1 INTRODUCTION
This chapter deals with the description of the sample population, presentation, analysis and
interpretation of the data based on the information obtained from the questionnaire,
interview, and documents. The primary focused of this study is to assess the role of
management information system in enhancing the effectiveness of commercial bank of
Ethiopia Bure Damot branch. Out of 39 questionnaires distributed to the respondent of
commercial bank of Ethiopia, the complete responses were returned from the bank
employees.
No %
1 Sex Male 34 87
Female 5 13
Total 39 100
26-33 14 36
34-41 8 21
42-49 1 2
Above 40 - -
Total 39 100
24
Educational Diploma 4 10
status
Degree 19 49
Master 16 41
PHD - -
Other - -
Total 39 100
2-5 years 7 18
6-9 year 18 46
Above 10 years 10 26
Total 39 100
Source:-questionnaires 2022
As it is clearly indicated in table 4.1, the number of male respondents are 34(87%) whereas
the numbers of female’s respondent is 5(13%) out of the total respondents 39(100%). This
implies that most of the respondents are male.
The second items of the table 4.1 shows the age distribution in the bank out of the total
respondents 16(41%) are found between the age interval of 18-25 years,14(36%)
respondents found between 26-33 years and 8(21%) respondents are found between the
age of 34-41 years and 1(2%)is found between age of 42-49.
The educational status of respondents of the above table shows that 19 (49%) are first
degree holder, 16(41%) are master degree holders and 4 (10%) is diploma. This indicated
25
that most of the bank employees are educated and they can easily understand the
management information system.
As the above table has depicted with regard to work experience of the employees, 4(10%)
of the respondents serve the organization for less than 2 years, 7(18%) of the respondents
serve the organization for 2-5 years, 18(46%) respondents have 6-9 work experience and
the last who have more than 10 years’ work experience is 10(26%). This implies that the
majority of employees are experienced.
No %
No 20 51
Total 39 100
Medium 16 41
Need 8 21
improvement
Total 39 100
Good 12 31
26
Medium 7 18
Poor - -
Total 39 100
As the above table has depicted with regard to shortage of manpower on processing of
information system out of the total respondents 19(49%) said yes, and 20(51%)
respondents said no. This implies that there is shortage of skilled man power in MIS on
process information system. The manager of the bank should give appropriate training.
As indicated in the table 4.2, out of 39 respondents 20(51%) said very good about the
current management information system of the bank is 12(31%) said good and 7(18%)
respondents said medium. This implies that the current management information system
performance of CBE Bure Damot branch is very good, good and medium; it is also needs
some improvement.
27
Table 4.3 the information development project
S. No item Measurement Respondents
No %
Both 17 44
Total 39 100
As shown in table 4.3, 22(56%) of the respondent said that the information development
project is conducted by internal staff and 17 (44%) said conducted by both internal and
external staff. This implies that majority of Information development project is conducted
by known and skilled man Power which is related to the activities from the organization
and outside staff or both.
28
Table 4.4 MIS delivery
S No Item Measurement Respondents
No %
Good 18 46
Medium 6 15
Poor 1 3
Very poor - -
Total 39 100
As indicated in table 4.4, employees were asked about the service delivery of commercial
bank of Ethiopia at the right time to the right people. From the entire respondents, 14(36%)
said very good service delivery, 18(46%) said good service delivery, 6(15%) medium
service delivery of the bank and 1(3%) of the respondents said at the right time to the right
people is poor. This implies that the service delivery of the bank at the right time to the
right people is good.
29
Table 4.5 the relationship between IT expert and other unit
S No Item Measurement Respondent
No %
Positive related 13 33
satisfactory related 9 23
Poor related - -
Total 39 100
Source:-quaternaries 2022
Information technology experts should have relation with other unites. As shown in the
table 4.5 the relationship between IT expert and other unit, out of the total respondent
17(44%) said very high positive relationship,13(33%) said positive relationship and 9(23%)
said satisfactory related. This implies that information technology and other units have
highly positive relationship.
30
Table 4.6 five elements of MIS
NO Item Measurement Respondents
No %
Good 18 46
Medium 10 22666
Poor -- --
Very poor - -
Total 39 100
Good 15 39
Medium 20 51
Poor -- --
Very poor - -
Total 39 100
Good 18 46
Medium 16 41
31
Poor 2 5
Very poor - -
Total 39 100
Very good 5 13
Consistency
Good 20 51
Medium 14 36
Poor -- --
Very poor - -
Total 39 100
Good 22 56
Medium 12 31
Poor -- --
Very poor - -
Total 39 100
Source:-questionnaires 2022
Employees of the bank were asked about the practice of Management information system
elements. As shown in the table 4.6, item 1, with related to timely practice of management
information system, out of the total respondents 11(28%) said very good, 18(46%) said
good and 10(26%) said medium. This implies that the majority of timely practices of
management information system perform at good and very good level. This indicates that
the managing and processing of information based on time value is in good level. The
32
commercial bank of Ethiopia, Bure Damot branch should improve timely practice of
information to support the planning, controlling and operation function of the organization
furnishing uniform in the prepare time frame to assist the decision makers.
Accordingly to the above table out of 39 respondents, 4(10%) said very good, 15(39%)
said good and 20(51%) said medium practice of management information system. This
implies that the bank has medium accuracy practice of management information system
but, it needs improvement.
With regard to the completeness practice of management information system out of the
total respondents, 3(8%) said very good, 18(46%) said good, 16(41%) said medium and
2(5%) said poor practice for completeness but, it need improvement as I can see from the
table the performance of completeness also similar to the above time and accuracy MIS is
performed in complete manner to support other.
With regard to consistency practice of management information system out of the total
respondent, 5(13%) said very good, 20(51%) said good and 14(36%) said medium level.
The finding of the study shows consistency shows good and needs some improvement.
With regard to relevance 5(13%) said very good, 22(56%) said good and 12(31%) said
medium level. This indicates that the relevant practice of MIS is good in Bure Damot
branch and it needs improvement. This impels that the consistency and relevance practice
of management information system performed at good and medium level, but it needs some
improvement. The CBE, Bure Damot branch should improve the performance of each
element of management information system to in enhancing managerial decision making
by maintain high degree of accuracy and timely reports and work group collaboration.
33
Table 4.7 Error encountered while running the system
No %
Often 14 36
Sometimes 22 56
Never 2 5
Total 39 100
Source:-questionnaires 2022
As it is shown in table 4.7 above out of the total respondents 1(3%) said always, 14(36%)
said often, 22(56%) said sometimes and 2(5%) said never in running the system. The
researchers conclude that most of the bank employees face difficulty in running the system
due to in adequate training the managers of the bank should improve the development and
training program effectively, so as to address main useful and update information for
employees and develop well linked information system within employees.
34
Table 4.8 information for decision making
NO Item Measurement Respondents
No %
High 18 46
Medium 16 41
Low 2 5
Very low - -
Total 39 100
Source:-questionnaires 2022
35
Table 4.9 management information system (MIS) problème
NO Item Measurements Respondents
No %
Delay in 8 21
communication
Often redundancy 6 15
Inconsistency 5 13
Total 39 100
Source:-questionnaires 2022
36
Table 4.10 the consideration of employees to MIS
NO Item Measurement Respondents
No %
High 22 56
Medium 7 18
Poor 3 8
Very poor - -
Total 39 100
Source:-questionnaires 2022
As the above table has depicted with regard to consideration of employees for
management information system, out of the total respondents 7(18%) said very high,
22(56%) said high,7(18%)said medium 3(8%) said poor. This implies that the majority of
employees have high consideration of management information system. This indicates that
employees are understand the role of management information system in support the
planning, controlling and operation function of organization furnishing uniform
information in the proper time frame to assist decision making.
37
Table 4.11 employee’s knowledge about MIS
NO Item Measurement Respondents
No %
High 12 31
Medium 15 38
Poor 5 13
Very poor - -
Total 39 100
Good knowledge of employee’s about MIS plays a vital role for good decision making
through providing relevant, accurate and consistence information. The knowledge of
management information system is important for providing information inside the
organization and keeping the organization up to date with as it develops outside the
company.
As the above table has depicted with regard to the knowledge of employees about MIS are,
7(18%) of the respondent said very high, 12(31%) of the respondent said high, 15(38%)
said medium and 5(13%) said poor. This implies that the knowledge of employees about
MIS is medium and it needs some improvement to have high knowledge. MIS plays a vital
role for good decision making through providing relevant, accurate and consistence
information to the managers.
38
Table 4.12 the commitment of top management about MIS
NO Item Measurement Respondents
No %
High 18 46
Medium 8 21
Poor 5 12
Very good - -
Total 39 100
Source:-quaternaries 2022
The bank manager should have often an intuitive understanding of the power and potential
of information system, those propelling many companies’ institutional system and
information technology. As indicated in table 4.12, out of 39 respondents 8(21%) said very
high about the commitment of top management in MIS, 18(46%) said high, 8(21%) said
medium and 5(12%) said poor. This implies that the commitment of top management
towards management information system is high.
39
The response for open ended questionnaires
Mention any possible obstacle for the successful implementation of MIS in commercial
bank of Ethiopia, Bure Damot branch?
lack of materials
Mention the role of management information system in enhancing the effectiveness of the
bank industry service delivery?
Facilitate planning
it brings coordination
40
it assembles, processes, stores, retrieves, evaluates and disseminates
information
41
CHAPTER FIVE
Summary
The main objective of the study was to analyze the role of MIS in enhancing the
effectiveness of banking industry in commercial bank of Ethiopia, Bure Damot branch in
this regard primary data such as questionnaires and secondary data been intensively
reviewed.
In making analysis of the data, simple statistical measures such as percentage, frequency
and table have been used. Based on data analysis and findings the following conclusions
and recommendations are forwarded.
Based on Analysis and interpretations made at the previous chapter the following
conclusion and recommendation are made.
5.1 Conclusions
The achievement of the organizational goals largely depends on the managers’ ability to
plan, organize, direct and control both the human and material resources as efficiently as
possible. Besides, special attention shall be given to the role of management information
system for it is an engine to all other elements of a system to function properly. Based on
the findings the following conclusions are made to achieve the objectives of the study.
From this study the researchers conclude that, there is a shortage of skilled man power in
management information system on processing and organizing of information system
The current management information system performance of CBE Bure Damot branch
needs some improvement.
Information development project is conducted by known and skilled man Power which is
related to the activities from the organization and outside staff
42
The overall problems of MIS are lack of skilled man power, problem of decision making,
delay of fast response, lack of materials, data redundancy, delaying of data processing, and
delay in communication, inconsistency and improper management of information.
The organization is not give much emphasis regarding to employee training about how to
use the system, because MIS as a current emerging system of tool, so it requires an
intensive training about how to use and operate the system.
MIS plays a vital role for good decision making through providing relevant, accurate timely
and consistence information to the managers.
The information technology experts and other units have positive relationship.
The five elements of management information systems practiced s nearly at good level.
The employees of the bank faced difficulty or error in running the system.
Employees get information at medium level for their own day to day operation and decision
making.
Data redundancy
43
lack of materials
Facilitate planning
it brings coordination
44
Employees of the bank increase their knowledge through;
by training given by the office through ongoing and off going training
discussions
learning MIS formally or informally
by using MIS in day to day activity
5.2 Recommendation
Based on the above conclusion the following possible solution for the problems which were
raised by respondents of the commercial bank of Ethiopia, Bure Damot branch employees
are forwarded as follows:
The existing problems delaying in processing data redundancy, data inconsistency should
be solved as soon as possible by design specific procedure and using advanced technology.
The organization should established MIS department for developing new system not only
requested basis for assessing and acquiring new technology, for assessing corporate
information need and the like.
The organization should be designed well organized and develop MIS to make appropriate
decision which is better than the current decision-making process.
The Bank should adjust its, policy in order to provide opportunities like further education
and training, and the Bank needs to be sensitive in designing and revision jobs to maximize
skill variety, task significance, opportunities for learning and growing.
45
Reference
Lederer, A.L and Medelow, A.L, ( 1988 ) convincing top management of the strategy
potential of information system, management information system, quartis.erly,
December,525-34
Kenneth C.laudon and jane Plaudon,( 2007 ) management information systems 11th
edition New York
Robert G. Murdick Joel E.ross and James R.claggett,(2005), information system for
modern management 3rd edition Hakk of india-New Delhi
Davis G.B and Olson, M.H, (1985) management information systems. Conceptual
foundation, structure and development. New York McGraw hill
Robert G. Murdick Joel E.ross and James R.claggett,(2005), information system for
modern management 3rd edition Hakk of india-New Delhi
Wasten, HJ, carol A.B and Mna R.I (1990), information system for management.
Plano TX: business
Lucas, H.C, Jr, (1990) information system concepts for management. New York
McGraw hill
O.Brien James, (1990) , management information system ,2nd edition, Burr Ridges:
Irwin
Walton James, (1987), management information system, 1st edition, Burr Ridges:
Irwin.
46
47