Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH PAPER
HANOI, 2022
1
ABSTRACT
When the anti-abortion law was passed, there were recent protests and movements
in the United States seeking the fundamental rights of women. We kept up with the
situation after hearing this news and made the decision to do some joint research. In order
to better comprehend the impact of this law on American women, public perception of it,
and some pertinent research on other countries, the purpose of this study is to present an
overview of the current situation of American anti-abortion legislation.
This law not only affects the health, honor, and finances of women but also shown
that anti-abortion has a more negative effect on women than positive. In the long run, this
law will not only have a negative effect on women, but also on families and society.
For anti-abortion laws, we divide American opinions into two sides – supporting
and protesting to research. According to the data gathered (by Pew Research Center), the
number of abortion advocates outnumbers the number of people who oppose abortion.
But the outstanding picture is the vast majority of women take to the streets to protest,
whether in the state in favor or in the state against.
The expectation for the paper is to make clear that Anti-abortion legislation have
negative impact American women on various aspects, and the opinions of American
about this law. We focus on the discussion divided into 2 parts as Personal perspective
and Assumption in Vietnam as the authors of this study, students and women in general.
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABSTRACT ...........................................................................................................................2
1. Conclusion ...................................................................................................................22
2. Discussion ....................................................................................................................22
3
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION
1. Statement of the problem and rationale for the study
On Friday, June 24th, 2022, the Supreme Court overturned the historic Roe v.
Wade decision that secured the right to abortion in the United States, overturning decades
of legal precedent and clearing the door for about half of all states to outlaw the
procedure. Protests were conducted around the country on that Saturday in response to
the Supreme Court's decision to overturn the landmark (The Washington Post, 2022).
The repeal of Roe v. Wade affects not just Americans, but especially American
women. This not only shook the whole country, but also the world community, with a
decision that has a significant impact on human rights for a developed country while still
upholding human rights. In order to gain a better understanding of the situation as well as
the impact that the decision has on American women, we have decided to conduct
additional research into the situation that the decision occurred in and the impact that the
decision has on American women in order to gain a deeper understanding of the current
issue. As a result, the title of this research is "The Effect of New Anti-Abortion
Legislation on American Women."
The issue is not new, but has persisted for many years and has now been pushed to
the climax as a result of the abortion ban in the U.S. Utilizing the secondary approach, we
mostly collect existing data from the internet, summarize its effectiveness, and organize it
to improve the overall quality of the study. As a result, at the end of the paper, we reach a
conclusion about the discussion and express our own viewpoints on the topic.
4
The Research Questions
1. What are the effects of abortion legislation on U.S. women?
2. What are the opinions of Americans toward the situation?
5
CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW
1. The overturned Roe v. Wade legislation
1.1. The Roe v. Wade legislation
Roe v. Wade is a legal decision in the United States Supreme Court held on
January 22, 1973. This landmark ruling legalized abortion nationwide but has been under
attack ever since.
The case was filed by Norma McCorvey, who went by the anonymous name "Jane
Roe" in court documents. McCorvey (1947 - 2017) was 22 years old, resided in Texas,
was single, and trying to end an unwanted pregnancy in 1969. But she couldn't since
abortion was illegal in Texas unless a woman's life was in danger. At the time, practically
every other state had similar legislation.
In 1970, McCorvey sued Henry Wade, the Dallas county district attorney, in order
to safely and legally terminate her pregnancy. The matter was heard by the Supreme
Court. On January 22, 1973, the Supreme Court issued a landmark judgment stating that
a woman's freedom to make her own medical decisions, including the option to have an
abortion, is guaranteed by the 14th Amendment.
Prior to the decision, there were few abortion clinics because abortion was illegal
in the majority of the United States. The 7-2 judgment of the Supreme Court had an
influence on legislation in 46 states. While it authorized abortion throughout the
pregnancy, it specified that states might determine whether abortions were permitted in
the second and third trimesters (Chuck, 2018).
6
Biden that will dramatically change life for millions of women in America and intensify
growing tensions in a deeply polarized country.
7
2. Effect on American women
2.1. Health and physical wellbeing
Restrictive abortion laws extend the time it takes to get abortion services and can
cause severe delays in seeking care. This raises the health dangers for women. Forcing
pregnant women to postpone abortions endangers their physical health, as abortions in
the second trimester have a higher risk of hemorrhage and other consequences such as
uterine perforation (Intrabartola, 2022).
The study also discovered that being denied abortion has major consequences for
both the children born of an unwanted pregnancy and the existing children in the family
(ANSIRH, 2022).
8
2.2. Lack of safe abortion rights
Restrictive legislation that restricts women access to safe abortion is one of the
most harmful ways of instrumentalizing their bodies and a serious violation of their
human rights. The implications for women are harsh, with women paying with their lives
in some cases. Prohibition does not lower the necessity for or the number of abortions;
rather, it raises the risks to the health and lives of women and girls who seek hazardous
and illegal treatments (OHCHR, 2022).
Limits on abortion may further increase U.S. maternal morbidity and mortality.
Studies reveal that in areas where abortion is prohibited or unavailable, women seek
unsafe or illegal abortions or attempt to induce abortion by eating herbs or inflicting
stomach damage. Up to 13% of maternal deaths worldwide are caused by illegal or
unsafe abortions, which increase the risk of complications such as hemorrhage, infection,
sepsis, trauma, and death (Zolot, 2022).
According to the World Health Organization, 23,000 women die each year as a
result of unsafe abortions, and tens of thousands more suffer major health problems
worldwide. According to a recent study, prohibiting abortion in the United States would
result in a 21% rise in the overall number of pregnancy-related deaths and a 33% increase
among Black women, simply because remaining pregnant is more harmful than getting
an abortion. Increased abortion-related mortality or attempted abortions would be in
addition to these figures.
If the current trend in the United States continues, "back alley" (unsafe) abortions
will be the only option for women who do not have access to safe and legal services, and
the horrific consequences of such abortions will become a major cause of death and
severe health complications for some of the country's most vulnerable women (Langer,
2021).
9
FIGO, the International Federation of Gynecology and Obstetrics, released a
statement that, like the UNFPA comment, issued a statement emphasizing the toll of
unsafe abortions: "Lack of access to safe abortion care is one of the leading causes of
preventable maternal death and disability. Each year, 47,000 women in the world die as a
result of unsafe abortion and an estimated 5 million are hospitalized for the treatment of
serious complications such as bleeding or infection." (Gharib, 2022).
2.3. Financial
Overturning Roe v. Wade would force some women to carry unexpected
pregnancies to term, risking their education, job progression, earning power, and
potential to build wealth.
According to the survey, the amount of past-due debt incurred by the "turned
away" women increased by 78% compared to the average they owing before giving birth.
The number of negative incidences on the women's credit reports, such as bankruptcies
and evictions, increased by 81%.
Miller's research also discovered that women who were denied abortions struggled
five years later, owing in large part to the compounding impact of unexpected
pregnancies on women's ability to complete their educations and establish employment.
When women quit the workforce to have children, they lose opportunities to accumulate
wealth, which many will never be able to get back (White, 2022).
10
2.4. Relationship and honor of pregnant women
Abortion is necessary for situations including rape, unintended pregnancies, and
life-threatening pregnancies. According to the Center of Reproductive Rights, treaty
monitoring bodies have long recognized the link between restrictive abortion laws and
have determined that restrictive abortion laws violate a variety of human rights, including
the rights to health, life, privacy, freedom from gender discrimination, or stereotyping,
and freedom from ill-treatment.
The Center for Reproductive Rights has filed complaints with the United Nations
Human Rights Committee ("the Committee"). These incidents are representative of a
regional trend of sexual and reproductive rights abuses against girls, as well as a lack of
judicial remedies for sexual abuse victims. The treaty monitoring agencies have
recognized that denial of abortion access may be based on gender stereotypes about
women's traditional responsibilities as mothers and caretakers, which may constitute or
worsen gender discrimination and impede gender equality (UN Human Rights Office,
2022).
11
3. Americans' opinions about abortion
After the Supreme Court reversed Roe v. Wade, abortion access in about half of
the country altered dramatically. Providers, patients, attorneys, and state officials are
rushing to understand a slew of contradictory anti-abortion legislation, some of which
dates back a century (Kitchener et al., 2022).
12
Has a full abortion ban from 2019 that went into
Banned or effect when a federal judge lifted an injunction on
Alabama mostly June 24.
banned Prohibited after: Conception
Exception: Life endangerment, Medical emergencies
Legal and
Alaska likely to be Has abortion protections in place.
protected
13
Prohibited after: 22 weeks
Exception: Life endangerment, Medical emergencies
14
Thirteen states had "trigger bans" that went into effect immediately after Roe was
overturned. On the day the judgment was issued, at least eight states prohibited the
procedure. Several other states with anti-abortion legislation that has been blocked by the
courts are anticipated to move, with legislators seeking to activate dormant legislation. A
few states have pre-Roe abortion laws that might be reinstated, while others have moved
quickly to draft new legislation. Some state restrictions have been temporarily halted by
judges (Kitchener et al., 2022).
15
3.1. The reasoning of abortion supporters
The majority of Americans oppose the Supreme Court's decision to repeal Roe.
According to the summer survey, about six-in-ten adults (57%) disapprove of the court's
judgment that the U.S. Constitution does not guarantee a right to abortion and that
abortion restrictions can be determined by states, with 43% strongly disapproving. About
four in ten (41%) agree, with 25% strongly agreeing (The Pew Research, 2022).
The majority of Americans do not want the Supreme Court to reverse its landmark
Roe v. Wade decision, which established a woman's constitutional right to abortion
nearly five decades ago. The majority of people (67%) believe that state restrictions on
abortion providers or women seeking abortions are intended to make abortion more
difficult to get rather than to safeguard women's health and safety (32%).
16
According to the study, abortion should be legal if the patient's life is in danger
(82%), if rape or incest is suspected (80%), if the fetus is not anticipated to survive
(75%), or if the fetus is suspected of having major birth abnormalities (71%). A smaller
majority (55%) agreed that abortion should be legal for women who do not want to get
pregnant (Kirzinger et al., 2020).
17
Extended discussion
Carole Joffe, a sociologist and professor at the Bixby Center for Global
Reproductive Health at the University of California - San Francisco who studies abortion
policy, stated that, despite popular opinion, most anti-abortion bills introduced in recent
years have not included exceptions for rape or incest. "I believe what Texas highlights is
our contempt for the needs of women and girls, or those who can get pregnant even if
they don't identify as feminine," she added (Lopez, 2021).
18
4. Case studies - Abortion law in countries around the world
The United States is not alone in its fierce debate over abortion, and legislation on
the practice varies from country to country. No two countries have the same abortion
history, and no portion of the world has identical laws: women seeking abortions must
navigate various restrictions in a range of health care systems if access is accessible at
all. While not exhaustive, the following examples demonstrate the range of those laws —
and how they are changing.
Mexico - Prior to a court judgment last year, abortion was largely restricted, with
just Mexico City and three of 31 states allowing it up to 12 weeks of fetal gestation.
However, the Supreme Court unanimously declared in the autumn that punishing women
who have abortions was unconstitutional, and five additional states moved to
decriminalize abortions in the months after. The judges did not define how long into a
pregnancy abortion might be conducted, instead leaving it up to the states. Legislators in
states that still prohibit abortion will need to amend their laws to allow the operation (The
NewYork Times, 2022).
Britain - Abortions have been legalized in England, Scotland, and Wales for more
than 50 years, according to the 1967 Abortion Act. Abortions are permitted up to the 24th
week of pregnancy, but they must be medically authorized by two doctors (The NewYork
Times, 2022).
19
China - China liberalized its abortion legislation in the 1950s and encouraged it as
part of its one-child policy, which was implemented in 1979 in an effort to limit
population increase by limiting families to one child. To discourage illegal births, the
program, which made abortion services publicly available, included extreme coercive
measures such as penalties, compulsory sterilization, and abortion. China increased the
long-standing two-child restriction in 2016, coupled with additional incentives to
stimulate population growth in the face of a rapidly aging population. It raised the limit to
three children in 2021, and China's State Council released women's development
guidelines calling for a reduction in "non-medically required abortions." (Women and
Foreign Policy Program Staff, 2022).
Poland - Soviet-era Poland had some of Europe's most extensive abortion access,
and it became a popular destination for women seeking abortions. However, with the fall
of the Soviet Union and under the influence of the Catholic Church, the Polish Parliament
established one of Europe's harshest prohibitions in 1993, declaring that "every human
being should have an intrinsic right to life from the time of conception".
20
It permitted three exceptions: danger to the mother's health or life; rape or incest;
and serious fetal deformities. Despite widespread opposition, the nationalist Law and
Justice Party strengthened the prohibition last year, eliminating the most often used
exceptions – fetal abnormalities — which accounted for nearly all of the roughly 1,000
legal abortions performed each year. Every year, between 100,000 and 150,000 illegal
abortions are performed (The NewYork Times, 2022).
21
CHAPTER 3: CONCLUSION & DISCUSSION
1. Conclusion
When this law first became known, the reaction of women was fierce, especially
in states considering passing this law. Except for the humanitarians who think the law is
right and support it, the vast majority of women take to the streets to protest, whether in
the state in favor or in the state against. This act not only affects the health, honor, and
finances of women but also shows human rights and feminism in the US. Through this
report, we can see that anti-abortion has a more negative effect on women than positive.
In the long run, this law will not only have a negative effect on women but also on
families and society. Therefore, to protect the rights of women in general and pregnant
women in particular, the law should be legal and protect the right to abortion reasonably
and safely.
2. Discussion
2.1. Personal perspective
In our opinion, as a student who is studying this topic as well as women, we do not
support this legislation. First of all, as this report has analyzed, the most negative and
most directly influenced people are women in general and pregnant women in particular.
Looking at the positive side, this act can contribute to reducing the rate of innocent
abortion and the population ratio, but this leads to another negative - abortion. Therefore,
the negative things that this law brings are a lot more than positive things. Not only the
women were influenced, but the family, society, and even the baby were also born
without an expectation from their parents to be influenced. Families with pregnant
women who cannot abortion will take a reputation, shocked by others. The relationship
and reputation of the family will have certain harm. For the social part, people will have
to pay more taxes and the government will have to spend more money because the
number of children increases. For the kids, here we have to recognize that they are the
most innocent people. But compared to not being born, it was born without a person who
loved care of care, even hated and treated with silver worse. Try to think about the
22
perspective of children because of the lack of emotional and continuous violence both
mentally and physically will grow up, they will most likely have negative thoughts, and
become very dangerous people to society. Increasing social evils, the rate of crime, and
violations of the law also increased, so why did they have to suffer all of this just because
of a law like a century a thousand years ago? In order to prevent tragedy, abortion rights
need to be legalized and protected by law and morality.
23
LIST OF REFERENCES
ANSIRH. (2022). The Turnaway study.
https://www.ansirh.org/research/ongoing/turnaway-study
Blazina, C. (2022). Key facts about the abortion debate in America. Pew Research
Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2022/07/15/key-facts-about-the-
abortion-debate-in-america/
Chuck, E. (2018). What is Roe v. Wade? Everything you need to know. NBC News.
https://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/smart-facts/what-roe-v-wade-everything-you-
need-know-n856891
Gharib, M. (2022). Global reproductive and women's rights groups react to overturn of
Roe v. Wade. NPR.org.
https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2022/06/24/1107370547/global-
reproductive-and-womens-rights-groups-react-to-overturn-of-roe-v-wade
Kitchener, C., Schaul, K., Kirkpatrick, N., Santamariña, D., & Tierney, L. (2022).
Abortion is now banned in these states. See where laws have changed. The
Washington Post. https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/06/24/abortion-
state-laws-criminalization-roe/
Kirzinger, A., Muñana, C., Kearney, A., Brodie, M., Weigel, G., Frederiksen, B., Ranji,
U., & Salganicoff, A. (2020). Abortion knowledge and attitudes: KFF polling and
24
policy insights. KFF. https://www.kff.org/womens-health-policy/poll-
finding/abortion-knowledge-and-attitudes-kff-polling-and-policy-insights/
Langer, A. (2021). The negative health implications of restricting abortion access. News.
https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/features/abortion-restrictions-health-
implications/
Lopez, A. (2021). How the Texas ban on most abortions is harming survivors of rape and
incest. NPR.org. https://www.npr.org/sections/health-
shots/2021/11/15/1054710917/texas-abortion-law-harm-sexual-assault-survivors
Lopez, A. (2021). Texas abortion law harms survivors of rape and incest, activists say.
Kaiser Health News. https://khn.org/news/article/texas-abortion-law-rape-incest-
survivors/
Molla, R. (2022). 5 ways abortion bans could hurt women in the workforce. Vox.
https://www.vox.com/recode/23074696/abortion-illegal-supereme-court-women-
work
OHCHR. (2022). ―Unsafe abortion is still killing tens of thousands women around the
world‖ – UN rights experts warn. https://www.ohchr.org/en/2016/09/unsafe-
abortion-still-killing-tens-thousands-women-around-world-un-rights-experts-warn
Prior, K. (2021). Texas’ abortion law should force America to change its ways. The New
York Times - Breaking News, US News, World News and Videos.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/09/opinion/texas-abortion-pro-life.html
25
The New York Times. (2022). Abortion laws around the world. The New York Times -
Breaking News, US News, World News and Videos.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/03/world/abortion-laws-international.html
The Pew Research. (2022). 2. Social and moral considerations on abortion. Pew
Research Center's Religion & Public Life Project.
https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2022/05/06/social-and-moral-considerations-
on-abortion/#CHAPTER-h-In-their-own-words-How-Americans-feel-about-
abortion-
The Pew Research. (2022). America's abortion quandary. Pew Research Center's
Religion & Public Life Project.
https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2022/05/06/americas-abortion-quandary/
White, M. (2022). How limiting abortion access hurts women financially. NBC News.
https://www.nbcnews.com/business/business-news/limiting-abortion-access-hurts-
women-financially-roe-v-wade-rcna27291
Women and Foreign Policy Program Staff. (2022). Abortion law: Global comparisons.
Council on Foreign Relations. https://www.cfr.org/article/abortion-law-global-
comparisons
Zolot, J. (2022). How will recent abortion legislation affect women's health? : AJN the
American Journal of nursing. LWW.
https://journals.lww.com/ajnonline/Fulltext/2019/08000/How_Will_Recent_Abortio
n_Legislation_Affect.12.aspx
26