You are on page 1of 109

SUSTAINABLE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT

AND ITS FACTORS OF CHALLENGES IN


BRGY. KAPATAGAN,
DIGOS CITY

ALCORDO, XYRIL RUBIE C.


ALGABRE, MERVIN LOWELL C.
AMARILLO, MARCO VICTORIO C.
CABASUG, CLERR JOHN P.
ESCOBARTE, JANLEX S.
PASCUA, JULLIAN ACE B.
PIA, CYRIL ANE
WATIN, APRIL JANE N.

A RESEARCH STUDY PROPOSAL SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF


THE COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY, COR JESU
COLLEGE, INC., DIGOS CITY, DAVAO DEL SUR,
IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE
REQUIREMENTS FOR
THE DEGREE OF

BACHELOR OF SCIENCE IN CIVIL ENGINEERING

June 2022
Republic of the Philippines
Cor Jesu College, Inc.
College of Engineering and Technology
Digos City, Davao del Sur

DECLARATION OF ORIGINALITY

We, ALCORDO, XYRIL RUBIE C., ALGABRE, MERVIN LOWELL C.,

AMARILLO, MARCO VICTORIO C., CABASUG, CLERR JOHN P.,

ESCOBARTE, JANLEX S., PASCUA, JULLIAN ACE B., PIA, CYRIL ANE,

WATIN, APRIL JANE N., declare under pain of sanctions of Intellectual

Property Rights (IPR) Law, that this project study is original to the best of our

knowledge we declare furth er that this activity is done by us.

ALCORDO, XYRIL RUBIE C. ALGABRE, MERVIN LOWELL C.


Researcher Researcher

AMARILLO, MARCO VICTORIO CABASUG, CLERR JOHN P.


Researcher Researcher

ESCOBARTE, JANLEX S. PASCUA, JULLIAN ACE B.


Researcher Researcher

PIA, CYRIL ANE WATIN, APRIL JANE N.


Researcher Researcher

___________________
Date

i
ABSTRACT

ALCORDO, XYRIL RUBIE C., ALGABRE, MERVIN LOWELL C., AMARILLO,


MARCO VICTORIO C., CABASUG, CLERR JOHN P., ESCOBARTE,
JANLEX S., PASCUA, JULLIAN ACE B., PIA, CYRIL ANE, WATIN, APRIL
JANE N., June 2022. Sustainable Solid Waste Management and Its Factors
of Challenges in Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City. A Research Study. College
of Engineering and Technology, Cor Jesu College, Inc., Digos City, Davao del
Sur. 108 pp.

Instructor/Adviser: ENGR. JAMES RAVEN S. SARSONA

This study is entitled “Sustainable Solid Waste Management and its

Factors of Challenges in Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City”, which aims to identify

the factors of the challenges in sustaining solid waste management and to know

the present practices of how the residents of Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City

in solid waste management. In this study, the researchers used a qualitative

research method specifically a case study design, and utilized non-probability

or non-random sampling specifically convenience sampling to choose

respondents and gather information. The questionnaires are given to the

respondents of this study which are household residents, barangay officials,

private sectors in Kapatagan, Digos City, and also CENRO Digos and Garbage

truck driver/collector. The results of the study show that there are four major

factors of the challenges in sustaining solid waste management such as;

Disposal, Collection System, Transportation, and Management of Solid Waste

which affect the solid waste management in Kapatagan, Digos City. The

researchers concluded that these factors need to be addressed to achieve

sustainable solid waste management.

ii
TRANSMITTAL SHEET

This research study entitled SUSTAINABLE SOLID WASTE


MANAGEMENT AND ITS FACTORS OF CHALLENGES IN BRGY.
KAPATAGAN, DIGOS CITY prepared and submitted by ALCORDO, XYRIL
RUBIE C., ALGABRE, MERVIN LOWELL C., AMARILLO, MARCO
VICTORIO C., CABASUG, CLERR JOHN P., ESCOBARTE, JANLEX S.,
PASCUA, JULLIAN ACE B., PIA, CYRIL ANE., and WATIN, APRIL JANE N.
in partial fulfillment of the requirements in CE 326 Methods of Research for the
degree of BACHELOR OF SCIENECE IN CIVIL ENGINEERING, is hereby
accepted and endorsed:

ENGR. JAMES RAVEN S. SARSONA


Instructor/Adviser, Methods of Research

______________
Date

ENGR. AMIE LOU G. CISNEROS, MSCE, EnP


Program Head, Civil Engineering

______________
Date

iii
APPROVAL SHEET

This research study entitled SUSTAINABLE SOLID WASTE


MANAGEMENT AND ITS FACTORS OF CHALLENGES IN BRGY.
KAPATAGAN, DIGOS CITY prepared and submitted by ALCORDO, XYRIL
RUBIE C., ALGABRE, MERVIN LOWELL C., AMARILLO, MARCO
VICTORIO C., CABASUG, CLERR JOHN P., ESCOBARTE, JANLEX S.,
PASCUA, JULLIAN ACE B., PIA, CYRIL ANE, WATIN, APRIL JANE N., in
partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of degree of BACHELOR
OF SCIENCE IN CIVIL ENGINEERING, has passed the subject course
requirements in CE 326 Methods of Research and has been successfully
defended before this panel of examiners:

ENGR. HANNY CRESELLE GRAVINO ENGR. BEJAMIN HERMOSISIMA JR.


Member, Examining Committee Member, Examining Committee

______________ ______________
Date Date

ENGR. KRISTINE MAY MATURAN ENGR. DENVER O. REGIDOR, LSP


csp..wa
Member,mo nminaw Committee
Examining
Member, Examining Committee
ky raven
______________ ______________
Date Date

RAPHSON C. ELESTERIO, LPT, MPA


Member, Examining Committee
wa ba apil c sir peter
nnu ani?
______________
Date

ENGR. AMIE LOU G. CISNEROS, MSCE, EnP


Chair, Examining Committee

_____________
Date

Accepted as partial fulfillment of the requirements in CE 326 Methods of


Research for the degree of BACHELOR OF SCIENCE IN CIVIL
ENGINEERING:

ENGR. JONAS M. PLACER, M.Eng.


Dean, College of Engineering and Technology

____________
Date

iv
ACKNOWLEDGMENT

We are really grateful because we managed to complete our Research

Paper within the given time by our lecturer Engr. James Raven Sarsona.

This study could not be completed without the effort and cooperation of

group members.

First, we want to thank Engr. James Raven Sarsona, an ideal teacher,

mentor, providing valuable guidance and feedback, and challenging us to grow

as a student.

And to our family as a whole for their continuous support and

understanding when undertaking our research and for their prayer for us was

what sustained us this far.

Finally, we would like to thank God, for letting us through all the

difficulties. We have experienced your guidance day by day. You are the one

who let us finish our Research Paper. We will keep on trusting you for our future.

v
TABLE OF CONTENTS

PRELIMINARY PAGES PAGE

Declaration of Originality i
Abstract ii
Title Page iii
Transmittal Sheet iv
Approval Sheet v
Acknowledgment vi
Table of Contents vii
List of Tables ix
List of Figures x
List of Appendices xi

CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION 1

Background of the Study 1


Statement of the Problem 2
Objectives of the Study 2
Significance of the Study 3
Scope and Delimitations of the Study 4
Operational Definition of Terms 4

CHAPTER II REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES AND 6


LITERATRUE

Sustainable Solid Waste Management 6


Importance and Benefits of Sustainable Solid Waste
Management 9
Effects of Improper Waste Disposal 10
Implementing Rules and Regulations of the Philippine
Ecological Solid Waste Management Act of 2000. 15
Factors contribute to Challenges in achieving Sustainable
Solid Waste Management. 17
Theoretical/Conceptual Framework 18
Research Assumptions 22

CHAPTER III METHODOLOGY 23

Research Design 23
Locale of the Study 23
Respondents of the Study 25
Sampling Method 25

vi
Research Instrument 26
Data Gathering Procedure 26
Method of Data Analysis 26

CHAPTER IV PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND


INTERPRETATION OF DATA 29

Residential Respondents 29
Barangay Officials as Respondents 36
Local Government Unit as Respondents 45
Garbage Collector as Respondents 47
Private Sector/Resorts as Respondents 49
Kapatagan Clinic as Respondents 52
Motorcyle Shops as Respondents 53

CHAPTER V SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND


RECOMMENDATIONS 55

Summary 55
Summary of Findings 56
Conclusions 57
Recommendations 57

REFERENCES 63
APPENDICES 68

vii
LIST OF TABLES

Table No. Title Page

1 Age and Gender of the Residential 30


Respondents

2 Number of Residential Respondent’s 30


Household Member

3 Respondents’ Residential Places in 31


Kapatagan, Digos City

4 Residential Respondents’ Responses 35


during Survey/Interview

5 Position, Committee, Age and Gender 45


of the Barangay Officials as
Respondents
6 51
Private Sectors/Resorts Respondents’
Responses during Survey/Interview

viii
LIST OF FIGURES

Figure No. Title Page

1 Research Paradigm 19

2 Topographic View 24

3 Location and Coordinates 24

ix
LIST OF APPENDICES

Appendix Title Page

A Letters 69

B Questionnaires 73

C Curriculum Vitae 82

D Documentation 90

x
CHAPTER I

INTRODUCTION

Background of the Study

The protection of the environment and the population's health are the

most significant reasons for waste collection. Garbage that is allowed to rot

emits hazardous fumes that mix with the air and can cause breathing difficulties

in individuals. Environmental protection and welfare need of a huge population

are also important concerning effective waste management. Solid waste affects

the natural environment to a great extent and poses a serious threat as these

materials remain in one particular place or for a relatively long period unless

removed, burned, or washed away (Anand, 2010).

While Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City strive for development, their

solid wastes will pose a threat to the environment if the management of their

solid waste cannot be sustained. As the Materials Recovery Facility (MRF) of

Barangay Kapatagan has been demolished due to its location that was situated

in a private lot/property. However, the residents of the said barangay are

currently relying on the garbage truck collector that the LGU Digos provide. The

garbage truck will transfer garbage from Barangay Kapatagan to Lungag, Digos

City's landfill, which is estimated 55 kilometers and 1 hour of travel. Challenges

must be identified for this community to achieve effective and long-term solid

waste management.
2

Statement of the Problem

The factors of challenges for sustaining the solid waste management in

Baranqay Kapatagan, Digos City specifically areas like Mainit, Bacoco,

Marawer, and Poblacion Kapatagan are:

• Lack of solid waste facilities as their Materials Recovery Facility (MRF)

was demolished.

• Insufficient vehicles for garbage collection; there is only one dump truck

assigned to colle ct all the waste in Kapatagan, Digos City, which is not

enough for the waste produced by the residents and private sectors.

• Difficult and far terrain for transporting garbage from Barangay

Kapatagan to Lungag, Digos City’s landfill.

• Lack of strong policies and regulations for solid waste management.

• There are areas in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City that the garbage

truck collector cannot reach.

Objectives of the Study

For a developing barangay like Kapatagan, Digos City Davao del Sur the

objectives of waste management are:

1. Determine and identify the factors that challenge sustaining solid waste

management. Specifically:

a.) Disposal

b.) Collection System


3

c.) Transportation

d.) Management

Significance of the Study

The results of the study will be beneficial to the following:

CENRO - it will serve as the urgency for Community Environment and

Natural resources Office officials to take action on the results of this study.

Through this study, they will be able to provide a solution to help the community

of Brgy. Kapatagan to have an alternative for sanitary landfills.

Barangay Officials - the result of this study will help the barangay

officials to evaluate the policies and regulations they have regarding solid waste

management and it will help them improve and sustain the solid waste

management in Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City.

Private Sectors - this study will help private sectors identify their lapses

in the solid waste they generate.

Stakeholders - the result of this study will be beneficial to the

stakeholders or the residents in Kapatagan, Digos City, to lessen the amount

of waste that can be seen in the streets of the barangay. As well as people will

have more discipline when it comes to the segregation of their waste.

Researchers - this study will provide for a further and profound

understanding of future researchers and can be a source of information and

reference for future research endeavors as well.


4

Scope and Delimitations of the Study

This study focuses on solid waste management in Barangay Kapatagan,

Digos City, Davao del Sur. Places like Mainit, Bacoco, Marawer, and Poblacion

Kapatagan are having problems regarding sustaining solid waste management

effectively. The study will focus on factors contributing to the challenges in

sustainable solid waste management such as; disposal, transportation,

collection, and management of solid waste.

Definition of Terms

In relation to this study, these are the technical terms and their

definitions:

Collection system is the process of collecting the waste for transportation from

the residents of the barangay to the disposal site.

Lack facilities an insufficient number of important things, like a shortage of

garbage facilities, abolished Materials Recovery Facility (MRF), and no

regular waste collection.

Landfill sites are designed to store garbage or the place where the garbage

should be, which is not possible in the barangay since the Department

of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) did not allow it.

Materials Recovery Facility (MRF) is a materials recycling facility that

facilitates the waste disposal of the barangay, the recyclable materials

can be sold to some manufacturers as new products. Aside from having


5

a facility that facilitates your trash, you can also help the environment by

surrendering your garbage in the facility.

Public awareness refers to the public’s understanding of the importance of

such topics, such as segregating their waste, creating a cleanup dry

program in every Purok monthly, and being a disciplined resident. Such

measures can help to improve the community of Barangay Kapatagan

to be aware of their increasing waste and can help the betterment of the

barangay.

Solid waste garbage or trash consists of the everyday items we use and then

throw away, such as cellophane, waste food, plastics, old things that are

no longer needed like empty bottles of lotion, etc.

Sustainable to maintain the good practice of the collection of their waste,

segregation of the trash, and the discipline of the community.


CHAPTER II

REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES AND LITERATURE

This chapter presents the literature background, theoretical framework,

conceptual framework, and definition of terms. Previous studies are viewed to

establish the gap in this study. In exploring the literature sources, the context is

organized around themes based on the study objectives for further analysis.

Sustainable Solid Waste Management

Every household, including business owners all around the world, must

embrace solid waste management. The issue of solid waste management is

one of the most pressing concerns for local governments in both small and

major cities, owing to the increasing generation of such trash and the financial

strain it places on municipal budgets. Solid waste management is related to a

lack of understanding of several aspects that affect the overall handling system,

in addition to the high expenses. (Mansour, m. Et al. 2018). According to

Kukreja, (2020), waste begins even before products are manufactured in our

current linear economy, and a more in-depth approach to sustainable waste

management must focus on the entire life cycle of a product to enable us to

help reduce the negative environmental, social, and financial impacts of 21st-

century consumption, so sustainable waste management is the key to reducing

waste and pollution problems because it helps to keep materials in use for as

long as possible.
7

Solid waste offers issues of both quantity and environmental impact,

particularly with the entry of elements dangerous to ecosystems, which is why

we need to understand the factors that influence the challenges in sustaining

solid waste management. Basic ideas and current improvements for handling

solid waste in an environmentally sustainable manner are described in

sustainable solid waste management (Wong, J. Et al. 2017). According to

Andrada, L. et al. (2019), the researchers found three practices used by the

Municipality of Sulop to sustain proper Waste Management. The following are,

Waste Segregation, Collection, and Redirection, which these certain practices

allow them to observe and maintain proper solid waste management. These

practices are introduced by the Municipal and Barangay Officials and were later

on adopted by the residents.

Waste Segregation

It is the process by which waste is separated into different elements. The

Municipality of Sulop is very strict in collecting the waste. The Municipality of

Sulop has this “No Segregation, No Collection” policy that makes the residents

more disciplined in segregating waste. The residents are obliged to separate

the biodegradable waste from non – biodegradable waste. Residual waste such

as candy wrappers and plastic cups are separated from the Material Recovery

Facility (MRF). Residents also separate diapers from cellophane and they will

be collected by the dump truck and bring it to the landfill.


8

Collection

It is the transfer of solid waste from the point of use and disposal to the

point of treatment or landfill. In the municipality of Sulop, the wastes are

collected in the MRF of the municipality if it is already full. The residents are the

ones who deliver the waste and if the wastes are mixed, they will not be

collected. The residents will write their names in the MRF Logbook after the

delivery waste. The Municipality of Sulop provides “multicab or bukakang”

which is used to collect waste from the house to house every day. They strictly

weigh the waste before collecting it.

Redirection

The action of assigning or directing something to a new or different place

or purpose. The Municipality of Sulop is doing its best to redirect the waste that

they collect. One of their ways of redirecting waste is bringing the biodegradable

waste to the recyclers and vermiculture the biodegradable waste. The

Municipality of Sulop has this Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) wherein the

residents bring waste there twice a month. The cellophane and plastics are

delivered to Davao City and donated there just to dispose of them. Residual

waste such as candy wrappers and plastic cups are separated from MRF and

delivered to Sasa, Davao City because it will be ground, mixed, and used in

making plastic chairs. They also grind the collected diapers and buy these

wastes into a pit and they also do a process to make use of it. Biodegradable

wastes are also used as fertilizer.


9

Importance and Benefits of Sustainable Solid Waste Management

Solid waste management is critical for supporting economic

development, human health, and a higher quality of life by reducing and

eliminating the negative environmental effects of waste products. In terms of

economics, waste management entails collecting, sorting, treating, and

recycling garbage, as well as providing a source of energy and resources when

appropriately managed. It has enormous economic potential that both public

and private entities must tap into. In terms of the social element, improved

waste management improves the quality of life for residents by increasing

hygiene and lowering health hazards associated with unlawful dumping and

inadequate rubbish collection. By enhancing air and water quality and

contributing to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, sustainable waste

management helps to decrease the impact on the environment. Furthermore,

limiting food waste reduces the high environmental cost of creating additional

food (Leblanc, R. 2020). Sustainable waste management systems, according

to SENSA Networks (2018), help minimize pollution, produce energy, and

conserve natural resources. Solid waste management is critical not only for

environmental reasons but also for the health and growth of a community. Not

only is it vital to establish a flourishing natural ecosystem that benefits human

and animal health, but it is also critical to free up precious land from landfills,

enhance energy production, create jobs, and lower transportation and logistics

costs.

Waste management also includes 3R’s which are; reducing, reusing,

and recycling your waste, it is important for the environment and can also be
10

profitable. It decreases the amount of waste in disposal, saves space in

landfills, and conserves natural resources (Faniran&Caban, 2014), using the

3R’s is indeed helpful not only in maintaining cleanliness but also in reducing

the number of waste materials and sustaining solid waste management to

improve the environment and improving the way of life. According to the Solar

Impulse Foundation (2016), reducing food waste not only helps to reduce the

high environmental cost of producing more but also helps to reduce greenhouse

gas emissions. The main benefit of sustainable waste management is to reduce

the impact on the environment by improving air and water quality and

contributing to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions.

Effects of Improper Waste Disposal

When food, plastic, paper, and other items are discarded, they must be

disposed of in some manner. Although waste is indeed anticipated to be

disposed of in landfills or recycling facilities, only a small fraction of waste is

disposed of in these locations. The majority of the wastes are spreading as well,

whether by wind, water, or humans. Some of these wastes are non –

biodegradable; they may break down into minute fragments with chemical

components and spread across the environment, but they do not disintegrate.

These techniques of distribution are harming the health of animals, people, and

the planet's biosphere (Bertoli, 2015). When waste is inadequately processed,

stored, transported, disposed of, or managed, it can constitute a risk to the

environment (Misra & Pandey, 2013). Pollution of the soil, air, and water can all

occur as a result of inappropriate waste disposal when any of them becomes


11

polluted with hazardous compounds. This not only contributes to the

development of greenhouse gas impacts but also has a considerable negative

impact on marine and wildlife life (Torres, J. 2017).

Environment

Identifying every polluted air in daily life, particularly through foul odors,

which are frequently created by decomposing and liquid waste materials (Labs,

E. 2016). To reduce the amount of waste, some people are incinerating it, but

this is not a good idea. Incineration of solid waste produces a variety of volatile

and gaseous pollutants that, if discharged into the atmosphere, can harm the

environment. Contaminants from the incineration site can be carried by fly ash

and dust, causing harm to delicate ecosystems. Environmental pollution has

been a threat to humanity since the dawn of time, and it continues to expand

as a result of unsustainable growth in emerging countries. Deteriorating soil

quality and an increase in abundance are serious repercussions of open waste

disposal, which has sparked public outrage. Due to a lack of skilled labor and

a limited budget for garbage removal, open dumpsites are frequent in poor

countries. It is also a significant threat to the soil (Alia & Yasmin, 2014).

In Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City, there is one situation where some

residents throw the garbage near the water source in Mainit, due to heavy rain

the garbage reached the water source which resulted in the contamination of

the water (Broa, N. 2022). Waste that gets up in water bodies alters the

chemical composition of the water negatively. This is technically referred to as


12

water contamination. This will have an impact on all aquatic habitats and affect

the quality of water. As a result, governments, scientists, non-governmental

groups, and members of the public all around the world are concerned about

plastic pollution and its massive effect on the environment (Seltenrich, 2015).

According to Lebreton (2018), 1.15 to 2.41 million tons of plastic enter the

world’s ocean each year through rivers. Because more than half of this plastic

is less dense than water, it will float once it reaches the sea. The negative

consequences of poor waste management are not only distasteful to look at,

but they also have an impact on a country's overall economy. Improper trash

disposal causes air and environmental pollution, which hurts the community

(Metropolitan Transfer Station, 2018). Pollution from waste enters rivers and

seeps into groundwater. Garbage obstructing drains causes flooding, and toxic

waste discharged into the atmosphere can harm the environment (Simmons,

2016).

Health

Waste is anything discarded by an individual, household, or,

organization. As a result, waste is a complex mixture of different substances

which is hazardous to health (Rushton, 2018). Poor waste disposal practices

lead to the accumulation of harmful substances that damage the environment

and affect health (Obinna, 2015). Uncontrolled hazardous wastes create

potential risks to human health. It can cause low birth weight, neurological

disease, cancer, nausea, and vomiting (Alam, 2013). According to Broa, N.

(2022), the irresponsible action of some residents in Kapatagan, Digos City,


13

resulted in contamination of water in the water source in Mainit, and it causes

diarrhea and stomach pain to the residents who have consume the water.

Improper waste disposal can have adverse health effects on humans as over

the years it has been responsible for causing several diseases and in some

cases even death (Fenton, 2018). Overflowing waste cans provide the perfect

breeding habitat for bacteria, insects, and rodents. The same flies that visit the

rubbish can also fly around your lunch buffet and drop their offspring on your

plate. It raises your chances of catching salmonella, bacteria that causes

typhoid fever, food poisoning, diarrhea, enteric fever, gastroenteritis, and other

serious infections (Labs, E. 2016). It has been established that as the world

population grows, so does the demand for food and other necessities,

increasing the amount of trash generated every day in each household. Waste

that is not properly managed especially excreta and other liquid and solid waste

from households and the community is a serious health hazard and leads to the

spread of infectious diseases (Ahmade, 2013).

There are common diseases from waste that can cause harm to our

bodies. Overflowing waste bins are an ideal breeding ground for bacteria,

insects, and vermin. According to Labs, E. (2016) stated that the flies that visit

the garbage are also the same flies that roam around your food and drop their

offspring on the plate. Doing so increases the risk of you contracting salmonella,

which can cause typhoid fever, food poisoning, fever, gastroenteritis, and other

major illness. Jacobs (2013) stated that flies are not the neatest of insects. It

visits such places as a dump, sewers, and garbage heaps. It is feed on fecal

matter, discharges from wounds and sores, sputum, and all sorts of moist

decaying matter. Flies commonly visit waste bins and when it’s transferred to
14

other places, it is transmitting bacteria from waste. Dengue fever is a disease

caused by a virus transmitted by mosquitoes. Garbage or waste are the

common reasons why humans get dengue fever, because mosquitoes and

other insects, sit in the places where there are piles of garbage and ultimately

spread various diseases in the area, according to Drumheller (2016). Dengue

is a major health problem in the Philippines and is endemic in all regions of the

country according to Shepard (2016). According to Radhakrishnan (2017),

mosquitoes can easily breed in open garbage sites, especially in plastic

containers. Saha (2009) stated that retention of water permits waste to form a

congenial biotope for the breeding of different mosquitoes that can cause

dengue outbreaks in the community. Improper waste management can help

mosquitoes breed and multiply. Open plastics that are dumped in the garbage

bins are a common breeding place for mosquitoes.

According to Manlabe, J. et al. (2022), some garbage is not collected by

the garbage collector, so the residents wait for another collection schedule,

which resulted in an overflowing of garbage. According to Boehlke, S. (2017),

overflowing garbage can cause air pollution which can lead to various

respiratory diseases and other adverse health effects as contaminants are

absorbed from the flu into other parts of the body. Every day it can be exposed

to bad odors which are usually caused by decomposing and liquid waste items

that spread through the air. Garbage pollution arises when the waste collected

in dumping sites keeps rotting, speeding up the odor and causing air pollution

in the surrounding area. Physicians for Social Responsibility (2013), stated that

exposure to air pollution caused by waste can trigger new cases of asthma and

provoke chronic illnesses including lung cancer and chronic obstructive


15

disease. Air pollutants also negatively and significantly harm lung development,

creating an additional risk for developing lung diseases later in life.

Implementing Rules and Regulations of the Philippine Ecological Solid

Waste Management Act of 2000

Rule XIV - Operations of Sanitary Landfills: Section 1. Minimum

Considerations for Siting and Designing Sanitary Landfills.

The following guidelines, standards, and criteria shall be applied in siting and

designing sanitary landfills:

a) The location of the facility shall be consistent with the overall land-use

plan of the LGU. b) The site shall be accessible from major roadways and

thoroughfares, provided that if it is not accessible, the project design shall

include means of access. c) The site shall have an adequate quantity of earth

cover material that is easily handled and compacted; as an alternative, an

offsite guaranteed source of cover material shall be identified. d) If the site is

located within two (2) kilometers of an airport runway, it shall not pose a bird

hazard to aircraft. The Owner/Operator shall institute a bird control program to

prevent hazards to aircraft if the bird population becomes significant due to the

operation of the landfill. The site shall comply with other requirements for the

safety of flying aircraft in terms of the height of structures, such as provisions

for obstruction lights if required. e) Locations of public water supply intakes

located within one (1) kilometer from the facility, including active public drinking

water supply wells, shall be shown on a facility map. f) The facility shall not be

constructed within 75 meters from a Holocene fault or known recent active fault.
16

g) If significant archaeological and cultural resources are present at the site,

such resources shall be protected and preserved. h) If the site is a habitat of

listed endangered species, mitigation measures for the protection of the

species as required by applicable laws shall be included in the project proposal.

i) The site shall be chosen for the sensitivities of the community`s residents.

The Sangguniang Bayan/Lungsod of the host LGU shall adopt a resolution

confirming compliance with the pertinent siting, design criteria, and standards.

The resolution shall be deemed as having fully satisfied the public sensitivity

requirement of this section.

According to Kagawad Adlawan, R. (2022), the barangay officials in

Kapatagan have been sending letters regarding the plan of making a sanitary

landfill in the Kapatagan area but the DENR did not give permission/permit to

make a sanitary landfill because Kapatagan, Digos City is considered as a

national/natural park and it is agricultural land. There are some endangered

fauna and flora that are still found in Kapatagan, Digos City that’s why they

should be preserved and protected. Creating a sanitary landfill in Kapatagan

Area will help in sustaining solid waste but it will cause harm to the environment,

animals, and the residents in Kapatagan, Digos City. Considering the

guidelines, standards, and criteria applied in siting and designing sanitary

landfills stated in the Ecological Solid Waste Management Act of 2000, Rule

XIV - Operations of Sanitary Landfills: Section 1. Minimum Considerations for

Siting and Designing Sanitary Landfills, the DENR/CENRO decision is ethical

for not giving permits to the barangay officials regarding making sanitary

landfills.
17

Factors contribute to Challenges in achieving Sustainable Solid Waste

Management

According to Leblanc, R. (2020) there are six Functional Elements of the

Waste Management System, which are Waste generation, Onsite handling/

storage, and processing, Waste collection, Waste transfer, and transport,

Waste processing and recovery, and last but not least are Disposal.

There are six functional components of the waste management system,

as outlined below:

• Waste generation: This encompasses any activities involved in

identifying materials that are no longer usable and are either gathered

for systematic disposal or thrown away.

• Onsite handling, storage, and processing: This relates to activities at

the point of waste generation, which facilitate easier collection. For

example, waste bins are placed at sites that generate sufficient waste.

• Waste collection: A crucial phase of waste management, this includes

activities such as placing waste collection bins, collecting waste from

those bins, and accumulating trash in the location where the collection

vehicles are emptied. Although the collection phase involves

transportation, this is typically not the main stage of waste

transportation.
18

• Waste transfer and transport: These are the activities involved in

moving the waste from the local waste collection locations to the regional

waste disposal site in large waste transport vehicles.

• Waste processing and recovery: This refers to the facilities,

equipment, and techniques employed to recover reusable or recyclable

materials from the waste stream and to improve the effectiveness of

other functional elements of waste management.

• Disposal: The final stage of waste management. It involves the

activities aimed at the systematic disposal of waste materials in locations

such as landfills or waste-to-energy facilities.

Theoretical Framework

This research is anchored on the "theory of internal and external

influential factors on waste disposal behavior and management", according to

Lui, S. (2019), low collection frequency, cleaning services, and limited facilities,

such as small dumpsters, are all possible external causes, while low

awareness, limited understanding, and low accountability for personal waste

are all possible internal variables that play a role in this issue. This theory is

related to our study because it tackles the factors contributing to the challenges

in sustainable waste management. Knowing the factors is crucial in

constructing a sustainable agenda regarding waste management.


19

Conceptual Framework

Figure 1 shows the conceptual framework of the study showing the

association between the dependent and independent variables. The

independent variables are the factors of challenges. The factors of challenges

refer to the different problems that can contribute to sustainable solid waste

management.

Figure 1.

Research Paradigm
20

Conceptual Definition

Factors contribute to the challenges of sustainable solid waste

management and it is the independent variable that researchers control during

an experiment to determine their effect on the dependent variable.

These are the 4 major factors identified by researchers during the

interview of the residents and barangay officials in Barangay Kapagatan, Digos

City, regarding sustainable solid waste management such as transportation,

disposal, collection system, and management

Disposal is the final stage of waste management. It involves the

activities aimed at the systematic disposal of waste materials in locations such

as landfills or waste-to-energy facilities.

Disposal has sub-factors such as sanitary landfill, lack of facility (MRF)

and some of the residents don’t have compost pits. Due to these factors, the

garbage or waste is not properly disposed of, some garbage is thrown at the

cliff, especially the biodegradable. Some farmers just buried the empty plastic

bottles of chemicals used on farms.

Collection System this is a crucial phase of waste management, this

includes activities such as placing waste collection bins, collecting waste from

those bins, and accumulating trash in the location where the collection vehicles

are emptied.

The Collection System has sub-factors such as collection routes, and

collection services, but the schedule is not enough. One of the biggest concerns

of the residents is the collection routes and collection services, where the waste

of some Sitio is not collected because the Garbage truck is already filled with
21

garbage from the Poblacion Kapatagan and some places are not reached due

to the high elevation. The schedule which is Tuesday and Friday is not enough

according to the residents because they produce garbage every day.

Transportation these are the activities involved in moving the waste

from the local waste collection locations to the regional waste disposal site in

large waste transport vehicles.

Transportation has sub-factors such as lack of transportation, routes/

distance, and the capacity of the garbage truck. According to the residents, the

capacity of a garbage truck or one garbage truck is not enough for all the

resident’s garbage. The distance/routes from Kapatagan to the landfill is far so

the garbage collector only collects once in every schedule.

Management is a process of planning, decision making, organizing, and

controlling the human resources, financial, physical, and information resources

of an organization to reach its goals efficiently and effectively.

Management has sub-factors such as poor waste management, lack of

policies and regulations, and poor monitoring. These are the main problem the

researcher observes when some barangay officials were interviewed. In

Barangay Kapagatan, Digos City, the management regarding waste

management is poor, barangay officials have no strong policies and regulations

regarding waste management therefore no punishment for those who will

violate the regulations and policies. No person is assigned to monitor or check

the cleanliness of their barangay regularly.

Sustainable Solid Waste Management describes basic principles and

recent advances for handling solid waste in an environmentally sustainable

way. It is the dependent variable.


22

The factors are the cause of the problems why it is not easy for the

residents and barangay officials’ in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City to

sustainable solid waste management. Therefore, identifying the factors and

their sub-factors will help in finding solutions to sustainable solid waste

management in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City.


23

Research Assumptions

If the factors contributing to the challenges and the solution to these

factors are identified, then it is possible for Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City to

sustain solid waste management in their community.


CHAPTER III

METHODOLOGY

This chapter presents and discusses the methods used in conducting

the study which the researchers have undergone. The first part explains the

research design of the study followed by the locale, then the description of the

respondents. Next is the explanation of the procedures for sampling and a

description of the measures used. It is then followed by the explanation of the

data gathering procedure and lastly with the explanation of the statistical tools

for data analysis.

Research Design

The study used a case study design. It is a research strategy and an

empirical inquiry that investigates a phenomenon in its real-life context. It is a

descriptive and exploratory analysis of a person, group, or event. The

researchers chose this design because the study is focused on identifying the

factors contributing to the challenges in sustaining solid waste management in

Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City.

Locale of the study

In the study Sustainable Solid Waste Management and its Factors of

Challenges, the researchers conducted the entire study at Barangay

Kapatagan, Digos City, Davao Del Sur, Philippines. The place was chosen
25

since one of the problems is sustainable solid waste management. The figures

below show the topographic map and coordinates of Barangay Kapatagan,

Digos City.

e lain ang tnan


figure..ibutang ug isa
ka page pra mbasa
ang mga txt ani ug
ang sa mga mu
sunod pa.

Figure 2.
Location and Coordinates

Figure 2 shows the exact location and coordinates of Barangay

Kapatagan, Digos City. It also shows garbage truck routes in collecting and

transporting the garbage.

Figure 3.

Topographic View
26

Figure 3 shows the topographic view or a detailed record of a land area,

giving geographic positions and elevations for both natural and man-made

features in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City.

Respondents of the Study

This study will be conducted in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City. The

respondents are a minimum of 100 households, 3 barangay officials, minimum

5 private sectors (resort representatives, and vulcanizing shop), clinic/hospital

(nurse) in Kapatagan, Digos City, and also LGU/Tourism (CENRO official and

Garbage Truck Driver/collector) in Digos City. The respondents are chosen

randomly based on the criteria that the respondents are certified residents of

Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City, knowledgeable enough about the resort

history and management, familiar with the clinic waste management, and

certified LGU/Tourism personnel in Digos City.

Sampling Method

Researchers use convenience sampling as a sampling method to focus

on gaining information from participants that are ‘convenient’ for the researcher

to access. Convenience sampling is a type of non-probability or non-random

sampling in which members of the target population meet certain practical

requirements, such as easy accessibility, geographic closeness, availability at

a specific time, or desire to engage in the study.


27

Research Instrument

Questionnaires were used to collect data for the study, and the

researcher use them to obtain primary data. The selection of this instrument is

guided by the research questions and objectives of this study. The researchers

prepared a separate questionnaire for the residents, barangay officials, private

sectors, clinic/hospital, and CENRO personnel, because there are questions

that are not applicable in the barangays and community setting that apply to the

municipality setting. The questionnaire was utilized in collecting the data for this

research. The researchers used voice recorders to record the actual statement

that the participants answered. The researchers should also give an informed

consent form to the participants.

Data Gathering Procedure

There are a variety of methods of data collection in qualitative research,

including observations, textual or visual analysis, and survey. However, the

researchers decided to conduct face-to-face interviews with all the

respondents.

Method of Data Analysis

This study is qualitative research, therefore the researchers used non-

statistical treatment, which uses in-depth interviews to gain a deeper


28

understanding of people’s motives, experiences, and practices of an individual

or population.

Analysis Procedure

This part of the chapter will list and describe the procedures done in

analyzing the data gathered which include:

Horizontalization – The researchers make sure to highlight all the

important phrases, sentences, quotes, or statement that is relevant to their

study.

Clustering of Meaning – The researchers, later on, would use a

thematic analysis. This is a technique where the researchers would group the

significant phrases, quotes, or statements into themes.

Textual Description/Structural Description – In the textual

description, the researchers would then write the major factors that were

identified in the interview regarding Sustainable Solid Waste Management in

Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City.

Personal Experience – The researchers would also include some of

their insights and experiences towards sustainable solid waste management.

Trustworthiness

Credibility. This refers to internal validity and ensures the correctness

of data. To be sure to make this happen, the researchers will random sampling

and iterative questioning methods.


29

Iterative Questioning

The researchers will rephrase previous questions to ensure the

credibility of the answers of the participants.

Transferability. This refers to external validity. The gathered data of

the researchers does not apply to everyone. It’s only applicable to the group

under study. The researchers will ensure a more detailed context of the study.

Dependability. This refers to the reliability of the study. The

researchers explained the methodology clearly to have a great amount of

dependability. Also, in the data gathering, the researcher’s actual event of the

interview is well-explained.

Confirmability. This refers to the objectivity of the study. The

researchers ensure to include every detail that has happened with regards to

the way the participant answered the questions in the interview to prevent bias.
CHAPTER IV

PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA

This chapter contains the result and discussions of different themes

constructed based on the responses of each participant. It also includes

the presentation of findings, analysis, interpretation of data, and supporting

details of the participant’s responses.

Residential Respondents

Table 1 shows the number of respondents belonging to the different

ranges of age and gender out of 105 residential respondents in Barangay

Kapatagan, Digos City. It shows that there are 14 males and 18 females’ a total

of 32 that belong to the age range 18 – 29 years old, which is ranked 1 and

30.48 % of the residential overall respondents. There are 10 males and 14

females’ a total of 24 that belong to the age range 30 – 39 years old, which is

ranked 2 and 22.86 % of the overall residential respondents. There are 7 males

and 10 females’ a total of 17 that belong to the age range 40 – 49 years old,

which is ranked 3 and 16.19 % of the overall residential respondents. There are

6 males and 9 females’ a total of 15 that belong to the age range 50 – 59 years

old, which is ranked 4 and 14.28 % of the overall residential respondents. There

are 4 males and 10 females’ a total of 14 that belong to the age range 60 – 69

years old, which is ranked 5 and 13.33 % of the overall residential respondents,

and lastly there are 1 male and 2 females’ a total of 3 that belong to the age
31

range 70 – 79 years old, which is ranked 6 and 2.86 % of the overall residential

respondents.

Table 1

Age and Gender of the Residential Respondents

Gender
Age F Frequency Percentage (%) Rank
M
18-29 14 18 32 30.48 % 1
30-39 10 14 24 22.86 % 2
40-49 7 10 17 16.19 % 3
50-59 6 9 15 14.28 % 4
60-69 4 10 14 13.33 % 4
70-79 1 2 3 2.86 % 6
TOTAL 42 63 105 100 %

Table 2 shows the number of residential respondent’s household

members in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City. It shows that 19 respondents

have 2 – 3 household members, which is ranked 1 and 18.10 % out of overall

residential respondents. 40 respondents have 4 – 5 household members, which

is ranked 3 and 38.09 % out of overall residential respondents. 28 respondents

have 6 – 7 household members, which is ranked 2 and 26.67 % out of overall

residential respondents and lastly, 18 respondents have 8 – above household

members, which is ranked 4 and 17.14 % out of overall residential respondents.

Table 2.

Number of Residential Respondent’s Household Member

No. of members No. of Respondents Percentage (%) Rank

2-3 19 18.10 % 3
32

4-5 40 38.09% 1
6-7 28 26.67% 2
8 above 18 17.14 % 4
TOTAL 105 100 %

The main reason for the researchers to conduct the study in this

respective Sitio is, that it is the main route for garbage truck drivers/collectors

in collecting the solid waste. Table 3 shows that 33 respondents are residents

of Poblacion, Kapatagan, Digos City, which is ranked 1 and 31.43 % of overall

residential respondents. 27 respondents are residents of Marawer, Kapatagan,

Digos City, which is ranked 2 and 25.71 % of overall residential respondents.

19 respondents are residents of Bacoco, Kapatagan, Digos City, which is

ranked 4 and 18.10 % of overall residential respondents, and lastly, 26

respondents are residents of Mainit, Kapatagan, Digos City, which is ranked 3

and 24.76 % of overall residential respondents.

Table 3.

Respondents’ Residential Places in Kapatagan, Digos City

Sitio No. of Respondents Percentage (%) Rank


Poblacion 33 31.43 % 1
Marawer 27 25.71 % 2
Bacoco 19 18.10 % 4
Mainit 26 24.76 % 3
TOTAL 105 100 %

Table 4 shows the responses of the respondents to every question of

the researcher’s interviews conducted at 4 different Sitio in Barangay

Kapatagan. Digos City.


33

Q1: 17 or 16.19 % out of overall residential respondents answered “yes”

which means they agree that there is an MRF in the barangay and they put the

garbage there. One of the respondents said “It used to be in the market but it

was demolished last year because it is a private property”, while the remaining

88 or 83.61 % out of overall residential respondents answered “no” which

means they are not aware that there is an MRF in the barangay and some

respondents don’t know what is MRF.

Q2: 74 or 70.48 % out of overall residential respondents answered “yes”

which means they created compost pit, one of the respondents said “It's in the

back of our house, we just put it in the litter”, while the remaining 31 or 29.52%

out of overall residential respondents answered “no” which means they don’t

have compost pit, one respondent said “No, because there is a collector, we

just put the sack in the truck and throw it away”.

Q3: 86 or 81.90 % out of overall residential respondents answered 1 – 2

a week which means they throw their waste once or twice a week, while the

remaining 19 or 18.10 % out of overall residential respondents answered 1 – 2

a month which means they only produce minor waste that’s why they only throw

their waste once or twice a month.

Q4: 92 or 87. 76 % out of overall residential respondents answered “yes”

which means they practice proper segregation, according to one of the

respondents “Even if the garbage collector won't accept my garbage, we will

segregate it first, that's why we will segregate it.”, while the remaining 13 or

12.38 % out of overall residential respondents answered “no” which means they

don’t segregate before putting it outside their houses.


34

Q5: 15 or 14.29 % out of overall residential respondents answered “yes”

which means there is a minimum sack of waste required per collection, one

respondent said “Yes, only two sacks per house should be able to pass them

all”, while the remaining 90 or 85.71 % out of overall residential respondents

answered “no” which means there is no minimum sack of waste required per

collection, according to some respondents “No, no matter how many they

accept as long as they can”.

Q6: 89 or 84.76 % out of overall residential respondents answered “yes”

which means there are times the garbage truck will be delayed and worst they

will not arrive that day. Some respondents said “sometimes”, one respondent

said “Yes same today, since holy week”, “If they don’t arrive or late, we will just

gather them on the side of the road”, while the remaining 16 or 15.24 % out of

overall residential respondents answered “no” which means there is no situation

that the garbage truck was delayed or will not arrive on that day, one respondent

said “They arrive on time”.

Q7: 23 or 21.90 % out of overall residential respondents answered “yes”

which means they are allowed to throw the empty chemicals bottle into the

garbage truck, some respondents said “They usually accept it”, “neither will they

be rebuked”, while the remaining 82 or 78.10 % out of overall residential

respondents answered “no” which means they are not allowed to throw the

empty chemicals bottle into the garbage truck, 59 respondents said “I don't even

know if it's possible because we don't have chemical bottles” and said

according to one of the farmers we have interviewed last March 25, 2022 said

“We are not allowed to throw a gang because it is already harmful, so we do it


35

because we just pour water and then we collect it or put it in a sack, others I

know they will bury”.

Q8: 37 or 35.24 % out of overall residential respondents answered “yes”

which means they are allowed to throw the empty cellophane used to pack

bananas or vegetables, while the remaining 68 or 64.76 % out of overall

residential respondents answered “no” which means they are not allowed to

throw the empty cellophane used to pack bananas or vegetables, according to

the same farmer we have interviewed last March 25, 2022, he said, “same as

we do with empty chemical plastic bottles we just wash with water and then we

still put the rest in a sack sad because it is bought at the packing house”.

Q9: 93 or 88.57 % out of overall residential respondents answered,

“Compost pit/Fertilizer” which means the biodegradable wastes are thrown in

the compost pit, sometimes brought to the farm, and used as a fertilizer. Some

respondents said “the vegetables and fruits that are over ripe, we give them to

the farmer and sometimes we make fertilizer for our crops.”, “we put it on the

back/side of the house/on the plant/in the field because we make fertilizer”,

while the remaining 12 or 11.43 % out of overall residential respondents

answered, “Garbage Truck” which means the biodegradable wastes are put in

the sack then thrown to the garbage truck, one respondent said “we just add it

to the other garbage”.

Q10: The suggestions and recommendations of the residential

respondents to maintain cleanliness in Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City is;

consistent garbage collection and more dump trucks to collect the waste. The

respondents also suggest that the barangay officials need to assign someone
36

to monitor the residents, proper disposal and segregation of waste, and lastly

provide more facilities (MRF).

Table 4.

Residential Respondents’ Responses during Survey/Interview

Frequency Percentage
Questions (%)
Yes No Yes No
Q1: Do you have MRF in your
barangay? If yes, do you put/throw your 17 88 16.19% 83.81%
garbage there?

Q2: Do you have a compost pit in your


backyard? If yes, what are the types of 74 31 70.48% 29.52%
garbage you throw there?

Q3: How often do you throw your 1-2 a 1-2 a 81.90% 18.10%
Garbage in a week? Week Month
86 19

Q4: Do you usually segregate your 92 13 87.62% 12.38%


garbage before putting it in the sack?

Q5: Is there a minimum sack of 15 90 14.29% 85.71%


garbage allowed per household? If yes,
what is the minimum number of sacks
are allowed?

Q6: Is there a possibility that the 89 16 84.76% 15.24%


garbage truck will arrive late or will not
arrive? If yes, what do you usually do?

Q7: Are you allowed to throw the empty 23 82 21.90% 78.10%


plastic bottle of chemicals? If not, what
do you usually do with the bottles?

Q8: Are you allowed to throw the empty 37 68 35.24% 64.76%


cellophane used to pack bananas or
vegetables? If not, what do you
usually do with it?

Q9: Where do you usually throw Compos Garbag


your biodegradable garbage such as; pit/Fertili e truck
vegetables and fruits? zer (93) (12) 88.57% 11.43%
37

Q10: What are your suggestions and Consistency of the


recommendations to maintain garbage collection.
cleanliness in your barangay or Sitio?
More dump trucks to
collect the waste.

Proper disposal and


segregation.

Disciplining the residents.

Assigned someone to
monitor Provide Facilities
(MRF).

Barangay Officials as Respondents

Table 5 shows some information about barangay officials as

respondents. It shows that B.O 2 is 61 years old and female and B.O 3 is 57

years old and male, are both barangay councilors who are assigned to the

committee for Solid Waste Management, while B.O 1 is 64 years old and

female, which is the barangay secretary of Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City.

Disposal

Q1: What are the Solid Waste Management regulations and policies you have

implemented in your barangay?

All of the barangay officials said that there are regulations and policies

that are implemented by the barangay officials, which are the “waste

segregation and collection of waste”. According to B.O 2, she said “Segregation


38

and collection of waste, it is forbidden to mix biodegradable and non-

biodegradable”, while according to B.O 3, he said “We have adopted here the

city ordinance of the solid waste management plan/ordinance which is

implemented in the whole Digos City”.

Q2: Do you have any fines or punishments for the people who violate the rules

you enforced? What do you usually do?

2 out of 3 barangay officials said that there are fines or punishments for

the people who violate the rules but are not implemented well. According to B.O

1 the supposed to be punishment for a first offense is a community service, the

second offense is 2,000 pesos’ fines, and for third offense is 5,000 pesos fines

but said to say there is still a lack of implementation in this matter, supported

by the statement of B.0 2 she said “We don’t have a proper implementation”.

While B.O 3 said “The Fines & Penalties because based on the city ordinance

how much their fines & penalties are the same as ours because we only

adopted that ordinance in the City”.

Q3. Do you require each household to make its own compost pit? If yes, why?

What waste do you allow to be thrown or put there? 2 out of 3 barangay

officials said that compost pit is not compulsory in the barangay, according to

B.0 2 “We no longer require them to make a compose pit, so it just depends on

them if they want to” and according to B.O 1 “It's okay for them to fight as long

as the only thing allowed to throw away is their vegetable and fruit skins”. The

remaining 1 barangay official, who is B.O 3 said “We required each house within

our executive order of Barangay Captain Morales to make their own compost

pit provided that they just put everything together for fertilizer”.
39

Q4. What are the rules and policies for plastic chemical bottles, and cellophane

used to wrap bananas, fruits, and vegetables?

All the barangay officials said that there are no certain rules and policies

regarding the empty plastic chemical bottles, and cellophane used to wrap

bananas, fruits, and vegetables, all of this must be kept in the safe place to

avoid pollution and health-related risks. According to B.0 2 she said “about the

cellophane in bananas, they have a policy, they have to buy so they are stored

here in the packing house of KBGC, they are collecting empty spray fertilizer

supplies instead of in the packing house”.

Q5. What alternative method or plan do you have to replace the landfill since it

is not allowed? Then when will this happen?

2 out of 3 barangay officials said that there is a plan, which is buying

Shedder/Grinder Machine but it is still a plan, according to B.O 1 “I have a plan

to buy a Shedder machine for our plastic waste, a bottle but it’s too pricy and

the same time we don’t have budget”, supported by B.0 2 she said “We have a

plan which is to buy a grinder even to grind the garbage, it's just a plan we don't

have a budget yet for any election so stop it but we have a change, hopefully it

will happen”. The remaining 1 barangay official, who is B.O 3 said “it doesn't

have, what we do is what we give in the City of Digos the collection, he just

throws it in the hole”.

Collection

Q1. Are there people or officials who are assigned/tasked with promoting and

ensuring the cleanliness of the barangay?


40

2 out of 3 barangay officials said that there are assigned personnel to

promote and ensure the cleanliness of the barangay. According to B.O 2 “Yes,

we have a sweeper in the market we have weekly monitoring to haul garbage”.

While the remaining 1, which is B.O 2 said “Sometimes barangay police are

sent but we don't have a certain person assigned to look after the garbage at

the moment.”.

Q2. Do you have MRF? if not, what is your plan? Where is the possible location

and how many would you build?

All of the barangay officials said that there is an MRF before but because

it is private property the owner of the area demolished the MRF, so since last

year until now there is no MRF. According to B.0 1 “No, but it already has a

budget in the Purok 3 in Mt. Apo area”, and B.O 2 said “It was destroyed, I don’t

know how because it seems to be involved in the lot but now, we are planning

to put it near the Petron Gas Station”.

Q3. Is it enough to collect garbage twice a week? if yes or no, what is the

reason?

1 out of 3 barangay officials said that twice a week collection is enough

to collect the waste of the Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City. B.O 1 said

“completely okay”, while the remaining 2 said it is not enough, especially

because of the growth of population and the tourist. B.O 3 said “At this moment

when most people come to this field from Friday, Saturday, and Sunday, those

tourists coming in here so no longer okay. It is not enough in twice a week now

you can see why there is garbage on the side no more dump truck sometimes

only once a week”.


41

Q4. Do you require a minimum garbage bag/sack of waste to be collected? If

yes, how many and why?

All the barangay officials said there is no minimum sack required and all

garbage’s alongside the roads are collected. According to B.0 3 “there is no

minimum as long as what we haul here because those collected in the city of

Digos were non-biodegradable” and supported by B.0 2 “they don't even have

to take out the garbage”.

Q5. Did you provide garbage bins or sacks in public places for waste?

1 out of 3 barangay officials said that they have provided garbage bins

in the public places (Public Market, Terminal), and the remaining 2 said that

there are no garbage bins now in the public places. According to B.O 2 “That's

why they always gather in the market, they have to collect this garbage regularly

for two weeks, but sometimes the dump truck breaks down and can't be

collected, so they just gather”, supported by B.O 3 he said “At first it was there

but it was ruined so it's gone now, it was donated by the bank here there is a

bank cooperative here, they gave those garbage bins some are still existing but

some are gone, so far we haven't put any again”.

Transportation

Q1. Are there areas here in Barangay Kapatagan that can’t be reached by the

dump truck when there is garbage collection?


42

All the barangay officials said that there are areas that can’t be reached

by the dump trucks because of the bumpy/rough roads. According to B.0 2

“There because it seems difficult the road here, both below Sto. Niño and

Paradise”, and B.0 3 said “those without roads are like Sabuag, Paradise,

Lutangan, Balatikan and Sto. Niño. There is a road but it’s not accessible, also

at the right of the Mt. Apo.”

Q2. What is the alternative way that is done by the residents who cannot be

reached by the dump truck?

All the barangay officials said that the alternative way that is done by the

residents is to bring the garbage/waste to the place that can be reached by the

dump truck. According to B.0 1 “Store and straighten their trash, segregate new

items in the sack”, supported by B.O 2 she said “Some of our advice is that the

sludge should be left so that there will be more garbage. If you can have

motorbikes, you can load the motorbike, then we will put it in the market.”.

Q3. Is one dump truck enough for garbage collection? If not, what is the reason?

All the barangay officials said that the one dump truck per garbage

collection is not enough for all the waste produced by all the residents in

Kapatagan, Digos City. According to B.O 1 “No, if two dump trucks per

collection and two in a week, that’s probably”, supported by B.O 2 she said “If

every day is possible but it's the same for them, if it's the second of the week

on Tuesday, they will go to the village and then to the center on Friday, it won’t

enough.” and B.O 3 said “It's not right that we're proposing now that you buy

that for us and we're going to donate again, but we still promise”.
43

Q4. Does the location of the landfill affect the transportation of garbage from

barangay Kapatagan, Digos City?

All the barangay officials said that the location really affects the

collection and transport of was because the area of the barangay Kapatagan

has a high elevation and due to its distance from the landfill, the consumption

of fuel is much larger. According to B.O 2 “it effects because of the far location

from Lungag”, B.O 1 said “Yes, because fuel is expensive” and lastly B.O 3 said

“can affect too because it’s far from Digos to Barangay Kapatagan 40

kilometers plus 10-15 kilometers from here crossing Cogon to Lungag”.

Q5. Do you have a plan to provide your own dump truck?

All the barangay officials said that the barangay has a plan to provide its

own dump truck but there is still don’t have enough budget. According to B.O 2

“Yes we have but we don’t have a budget for now, were just planning it because

garbage here is not easy to handle”.


44

Management

Q1. What are your practices in your barangay?

The practices are; proper segregation and educating the residents.

According to B.O 2 “We segregate it before they put in the sack, should be

segregated from the inside” and B.O 3 stated that “that's all IEC Information

Education Console especially the market because all resorts, packing houses

have their own practices and that sometimes they request that people have to

IEC”.

Q2. Do you have a monthly cleaning or clean-up drive in your barangay?

If yes, what is your approach/method? All the barangay officials said

there is a clean-up drive but it is not done monthly. According to B.O 1 “recently

many cleaned up drives with CAFGO trainings but only in the market”, “If the

area in totally mess, we will request a clean- up drive just like now, this coming

June we we’re having an Araw so we take this as an advantage to do a clean-

up drive in the barangay and requesting all purok leaders to attend” she added.

B.0 3 said “Yes, last week (May 2, 2022) cleaned up drive me with CAFGO

officers but that was their last.”.

Q3. Do you have programs or meetings about “Solid Waste Management” for

all residents of Barangay rgy. Kapatagan, Digos City to be aware of the right

practices? If yes, what are your platforms or plans?

All the barangay officials said there is a meeting conducted about “Solid

Waste Management” but only the “Purok president” is requested, and the

“Purok president” is the one who will disseminate the information and plans of
45

the barangay. According to B.O 2 “Yes we have, every last Friday of the month,

we have sectoral in the ward presidents so that's why we tell them Not to absent

every sectoral", "including the barangay police, BHWs (Barangay Health

Worker) so we will just take care of the garbage B.O 3 yes we conducted, we

have an IEC every end of the month, when the general assembly arrives, we

will explain these policies and our ordinance on solid waste management”.

Q4. Do you forbid residents from burning trash? What do you do to those

violators/offenders?

All the barangay officials said that they forbid the residents to burn the

waste, but there are some residents who still violate, and sad to say the only

thing they can do is to discipline or educate them because there is no

punishment created for those who violate. According to B.O 3 “We prohibit it

because there is a law about burning garbage, but we also explain it in our IE,

because so far we still don’t have any punishment for the person who's been

arrested B.O 2 said "so for now, we don't have to be strict, just reprimand those

who are burning because they are part of the DENR and they'll be angry".

Q5. What are your plans to sustain solid waste management in your barangay?

All the barangay officials said that in order to sustain solid waste

management in Kapatagan, Digos City the people must be educated and aware

of waste management, there must be strong policies and regulations

implemented in the barangay regarding waste management and the LGU must

provide more transportation/Garbage truck for garbage collection and lastly, to

find alternative for sanitary landfill to reduce the waste and provide waste

facilities. According to B. O 3 “our suggestions are for now IS it's good to add
46

some dump truck, the second one will inform the people first, the third part is

the penalties should be imposed just so that the people can learn. B.O 1 and

B.O 2 “buy a shedder/grinder machine”, “create a MRF a big one maybe big

enough for everyone”

Table 5.

Position, Committee, Age, and Gender of the Barangay Officials as

Respondents

Barangay Position Committee Age Sex


Officials
B.O 1 Barangay Secretary of 64 Female
Secretary barangay
B.O 2 Barangay Solid Waste 61 Female
Councilor Management
B.O 3 Barangay Solid Waste 57 Male
Councilor Management

Local Government Unit as Respondents

In the connection of this study, the researchers select the City

Environment and Natural Resources Office (CENRO) as one of the

respondents in local government unit. The said sector is giving a control and a

part in the solid waste management in particular area. In these following

questions will know the sector response.

Q1: Did you know that the MRF in Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City? If not, what is

your plan to resolve it?


47

The local government unit knows the condition of the Brgy. Kapatagan

MRF. According to the official represents LGU “Yes, we are aware of the

condition in the Barangay Kapatagan.

Q2: What are your platforms regarding solid waste management, specifically in

Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City?

The local government unit impose a program in terms of maintaining

solid waste management like Information Educational Campaign to the Solid

Waste Management and Segregation in order to educate a practices of solid

waste management. According to the LGU official "Yes, we provide programs

to make them aware of the condition of solid waste management, this is the

IEC to Solid Waste Management and Segregation."

Q3: What are the Solid Waste Management regulations and policies that you

have implemented in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City?

The local government unit implement a regulation and policies regarding

Solid Waste Management like a sanctions and punishment. In order to give a

management LGU officials impose a proper sanctions and fines. According to

LGU official "CENRO has policies and regulations in all barangays, they are

implemented in accordance with the law".

Q4: Are there people or officials tasked with promoting and ensuring cleanliness

in the various barangays?

In rural areas, local government unit selects a personnel or officials to

be assigned in promoting cleanliness. Their duties are to secure and check the

condition of the area in terms of solid waste management. According to the


48

LGU official "We have forest Rangers or guards stationed to observe and

monitor the situation in the area if there is someone throwing garbage

everywhere."

Q5: Do you have a budget allocated to each barangay for some waste

management programs or plans?

The local government unit gives budget in all barangay in ter of their solid

waste management. According to the LGU official "Yes, we provide a budget

for them"

Q6: What services do you provide to each barangay to help with their waste

management?

The local government unit gives a program of awareness and controls

of maintaining Solid Waste Management and a regular transportation of wastes.

According to the LGU official "Yes, we provide services in terms of

transportation of wastes and implementation of policies."

Q7: Do you have a regular visitation in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City? If yes,

what are the shortcomings you see in their waste management?

The local government unit gives a time to visit all barangay in order to

know what is need to improve the situation of their solid waste management.

According to the LGU official "Yes, we conduct regular visits to the barangays

and we see problems regarding their garbage."


49

Garbage Collector as Respondents

Q1: What time do you usually collects and travel waste?

In terms of time in collection, from the jump off point in downtown in

Digos City they travel from 5 A.M to 7 A.M in the morning. After collecting

wastes, they deliver it in the landfill located at Longag Landfill. According to the

respondent “from 5 a.m. we will leave downtown Digos until 7 a.m. to collect

waste in Kapatagan”.

Q2: Is there a possibility of delay of transportation in the area?

All garbage collector said that there is a lot of possibility of delayed

transportation because of some dump truck malfunctions. According to the

respondent “when there is something wrong in the dump truck and it needs to

be repaired that’s the reason why are delayed, but there are still times that we

can’t collect garbage”.

Q3: How many dumps truck of garbage collectors that assigned here in

Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City?

The local government unit of Digos sends only one dump truck in every

barangay to collect their wastes. According to the respondent “We are the ones

who are assigned to collect garbage in this area”.


50

Q4: What are the specifically days of collection?

In every Tuesday and Friday, the garbage collector will travel to the

Barangay Kapatagan. According to the respondent “every Tuesday and Friday

we collect garbage”

Q5: Do you have any trash that is not included?

The biodegradable and chemical wastes are prohibited in terms of the

collection of wastes, in the reason of it can cause a poison and harmful to the

health of the people. According the respondent “like vegetabales, we don’t

collect vegetable waste because it is not allowed in the dumpsite specially the

plastic bottles that have chemical fertilizers”.

Q6: What is the area of responsibility of collection in waste?

The routes of the collection are from Sitio Poblacio all the way to Sitio

Mainit. According to the respondent said “starting here in Sitio Mainit we go

down until we reach in Poblacion, Kapatagan, because Poblacion Kapatagan

is the center in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City”.

Q7: Do you segregate waste before to you transfers in landfill?

In preparing to travel wastes to the landfill, garbage collector will

segregate the wastes before the transportation of the collected wastes.

According to the respondent “We segerate the plastics and other waste so that

the waste is organized”.


51

Private Sector as Respondents

Table 6 shows the responses of the respondents to every question of

the researcher’s interviews conducted at 5 different private sector and resorts

in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City.

Q1: 3 or 60 % out of overall private sector respondents answered “yes”

which means they have a policy that implement regarding the solid waste

management. One of the respondents said “Yes we have the rules here

regarding the management of our garbage, we strictly prohibited throwing

garbage in our area specially in the garden and also we have a trash bin

already”, while the remaining 2 or 40 % out of overall private respondents

answered “no” which means they don’t have any laws. One of the respondents

said “No we don’t have, but if were trying to make it a point of our waste

management is organized. Start from the cartoon segregation (okay) and

leftover food is that supposed to be separated at the same time as well, to make

it discipline in a way of managing sanitize we make it a point, that it is being

varied in a certain with a big bin.

Q2: 3 or 60 % out of overall private sector respondents answered “yes”

which means they have a signage to orient their guest in managing solid waste.

One of the respondents said “The establishment put a signage for the guest to

be aware about the garbage and waste”, while the remaining 2 or 40% out of

overall private sector respondents answered “no” which means they don’t have

any signage in their area. One of the respondents said “Ah so far there is no

signage but we provide trash bins that guests can see where they can throw it”.
52

Q3: 5 or 100 % out of overall private sectors respondents answered “yes”

they do regular segregation on their waste and in their estimation majority of

the respondents can produce 2 to 4 sacks of garbage a week, while the

remaining 0 or 0 % out of overall private sector respondents “no”.

Q4: 1 or 20 % out of overall private sector respondents answered “yes”

which means they follow the principle of Reduce, Reuse and Recycle (3R’s).

One of the respondents said “Partly some are being insulated meaning all of

the garbage that can be reuse and recycle like bottles, cartoons, papers there

are also segregated and in nice to be sold”, while the remaining 4 or 80 % out

of overall private sector respondents answered “no” which means the

implementation of 3R’s are not present in their management. One of the

respondents said “In terms of garbage sir, not anymore since we collect our

garbage in CENRO (City Environment and Natural Resources) in terms of 3R’s,

right now we don’t have an implementation of that”.

Q5: 1 or 20 % out of overall private sector respondents answered “yes”

which means they have an existing own garbage truck to collect their garbage.

One of the respondents said “The establishment have disposable segregated

area, also separate within the bottles, all cartoons there, and all things that don’t

belong. Since we don’t have garbage collector in this area, we do our own

garbage collecting 24/7”, while the remaining 4 or 80 % out of overall residential

respondents answered “no” which means they don’t have an existing own dump

truck. One of the respondents said “Since the LGU are collecting our waste, we

don’t need to buy a dump truck”.


53

Q6: 3 or 60 % out of overall private sector respondents answered “yes”

which means they have an existing compost pit. One of the respondents said

“Yes, especially for those leftover food because it cannot be thrown anywhere

because as I’ve said we are very hygienic and health-conscious establishment,

while the remaining 2 or 40 % out of all private sector respondents answered

“no” which means they don’t have a compost pit. One of the respondents said

“Since our garbage or waste are collected by the LGU”.

Table 6.

Private Sectors/Resorts Respondents’ Responses during Survey/Interview

Frequency Percentage
Questions (%)
Yes No Yes No
Q1: Do you have any laws about
waste management? What is this law 3 2 60 % 40 %
and how can it help?
Q2: Do you already provide
signage to orient customers not to 3 2 60 % 40 %
litter? and do you provide trash
bins/sacks for tourists to pass by?
Q3: Do you segregate trash before
you put it in sacks/trash bags? How 2-4 0 100 % 0%
many bags of garbage can you sacks
produce a week? (5)
Q4: What kind of waste do you
usually produce each day? Are 0 5 0% 100 %
you applying for 3R’s for this?
Q5: Do you still have your own
garbage truck/garbage collector? and 1 4 20 % 80 %
there, where are you throwing it?
Q6: Have you ever made a compost
pit? Where do you throw the limp 33 2 84.76 15.24%
garbage? %
54

Kapatagan Clinic as Respondents

Q1. Do you have a law about waste management?

The clinic was implemented a law regarding with the solid waste

management consider that the clinic is must clean and follow the rules of

cleanliness. According to the respondents “that garbage is being segregated,

it’s already in the mud, it's not rotten and bottles, those sharp ones are there.

Q2. Where do you throw your toxic waste? Do you segregate it?

Clinics or hospitals are one of the most producer of waste, in terms of

toxic chemical they buried it. According to the respondent “Those chemical

waste is being dump in the compost pit and also as I said earlier, we do a

regular segregation of waste”.

Q3. How many times do you throw trash in a week? What is your schedule to

collect your garbage?

The schedule by the Local Government Unit 2 times a week of collection.

According to the respondent “As the collector arrives, we sent our garbage to

them’

Q4. How many sacks or trash bins will be filled in a week? How often do you

produce waste except toxic waste?

In clinic the more patient, the more waste will produce. According to the

respondent “Depending on how many patients we have, for example, if I leave

early on Friday, I will throw away three sacks on Tuesday instead of two sacks.”
55

Q5. Do you have your own garbage collector and where do you throw it?

Clinic does not have budget to produce a dump truck. According to the

respondents “As I said earlier the LGU are the one who collected our waste and

we don’t have any budget to buy some trucks”

Motorcycle Shops as Respondents

Q1. Where dispose those used-oil and used motor parts?

Those used oil and other materials like motor parts and used will be give

sell and recycle. According to the respondent “we will give the used oil to the

garbage collector for them to sell it and the other metal material in motor parts,

we collect and sell it. Those tires we will give that to the schools to be a base

on a planted plants or tree”.

Q2. Do you have a signage to orient your costumer about solid waste?

By putting a signage for the mechanic and the costumer to maintain

cleanliness. According to the respondent “Yes, we have a signage for the

customer know where is the garbage bin”

Q3. How many sacks of garbage do you produce every week?

Normally, if there is a lot of costumers the shop produces 2 to 4 sacks a

week. According to the respondents” it depends if there is a lot of costumers,

usually we produce at least 2-4 sack a week”.


56

Q4. The numbers of garbage truck are enough to cater all garbage in your area?

The numbers of dump truck that collects wastes is not enough.

According to the respondent “Barangay Kapatagan has a big area, only one

dump truck that collect so it is not enough”

Q5. Do you have a compost pit?

Motor shop is located in the Poblacion area in barangay Kapatagan it

means they don’t have a compost pit because there is assigned collector to

collect their waste. According to respondents “We don’t have compost pit

because our waste is collected by the collector”.


CHAPTER V

SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS

This chapter presents the summary of findings, conclusions, and

recommendations based on the data analyzed and interpreted in the previous

chapter.

Summary

The researchers conducted an initial survey and interview with the officials

of Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City to gather insights into what the researchers

should focus on in the topic of solid waste management. The researchers found

out that one of the problems in terms of solid waste management in Kapatagan

is sustaining and maintaining it. Therefore, the researchers aimed to identify

the factors of challenges in sustaining solid waste management and to know

the present practices of how the residents of Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City

in solid waste management. There are four major factors identified by

researchers which are; Disposal, Collection System, Transportation, and

Management of Solid Waste

In this study the researchers used qualitative research method specifically

a case study design that uses descriptive and exploratory analysis. This case

study was conducted with the main objective of identifying the factors

contributing to the challenges in sustainable solid waste management in

Kapatagan, Digos City. The respondents of this study are a minimum of 100

households, 3 barangay officials, 5 private sectors in Kapatagan, Digos City,


58

and also, CENRO Digos and Garbage truck driver/collector. The period of this

study is equivalent to at least 1 semester of the school year 2021-2022 of the

Cor Jesu College, Inc. from February to June 2022. The research instrument

used is a questionnaire that has types these are for Households, Barangay

Officials, Private Sectors, and CENRO in Digos City. The researchers used

non-probability or non-random sampling which is Convenience Sampling to

choose respondents and gather information.

Summary of Findings

The Materials Recovery Facility has been demolished because it is

situated in a private property so Barangay Kapatagan no longer have Materials

Recovery Facility that the residents can use. The schedule for collection of

waste is not enough and one garbage truck is insufficient to cater to all the

waste produced by the residents and tourists. The distance from Barangay

Kapatagan, Digos City to the landfill in Lungag which is estimated 55 km in total,

affects the transport of waste, and due difficult and far terrain it also affects the

condition and maintenance of the garbage trucks, which causes delays and

sometimes it will not arrive on the scheduled day. There are places on

Kapatagan that are not reached by the garbage trucks because of rough and

elevated roads, so the residents put the waste near the roadside which is

sometimes not collected and cause stockpiling of waste. Policies, regulations,

fines, and punishment for waste management are not strongly implemented

and there is poor monitoring of waste management based on the responses of

the respondents.
59

Conclusions

The researchers concluded that based on the summary of findings all

the results belong to the four major factors which are first Disposal, they have

no sanitary landfill, lack of waste facilities, and no compose pit. Second is

Collection system, they have difficult collection routes, insufficient collection

services, and not enough schedule for collection. Third is transportation, they

have lack of waste vehicle or garbage truck, far terrain and elevated roads, and

the garbage truck capacity is not enough for all the garbage, and lastly the

Management, their implementation of 3R’s is not strong, lack of policies and

regulations implementations, and poor monitoring. All of these reasons affect

sustaining solid waste management in Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City, and these

factors need to be addressed to achieve sustainable solid waste management.

Recommendations

To the CENRO

The researchers’ recommendations to the CENRO are; to provide

enough garbage trucks or make the schedule of collection and transporting of

waste 3 times a week (Monday, Wednesday, and Friday) to collect all the waste

in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City. To help in providing alternatives for

sanitary landfills such as; helping the barangay officials in Kapatagan to earn

enough budget to purchase a grinder/shredder machine and last but not the

least is to conduct a monthly meeting with the barangay officials in Barangay


60

Kapatagan, Digos City to discuss the problems and challenges regarding waste

management and to evaluate the changes.

The researchers recommend that the garbage truck driver/collector must

call the barangay officials if the dump truck is under maintenance or if there is

a delay, for them to be aware and to disseminate the information to all the

residents to avoid stockpiling of garbage in front of houses or establishments

and also the collector must always check the sacks of waste if it is properly

segregated to avoid collecting biodegradable and if there is a biodegradable

they should leave it behind to give space for the non – biodegradable.

Researchers’ recommendations to the barangay officials especially

those who belong to the solid waste management committee are; to strengthen

their policies and regulations regarding waste management in Barangay

Kapatagan, Digos City, and implement strict punishments and give fines to

those who violate policies and regulations. To continue policy regarding

segregation of waste before disposing of and to mandatorily implement the 3

R’s (Reuse, Reduce, and Recycle) to all the residents in the barangay to lessen

the production of waste.

To conduct livelihood programs for those unemployed or residents who

are willing to help create a masterpiece or new useful things out of solid waste

such as; kinds of cellophane, plastics bottles, etc., and sell it to all the tourists

as a souvenir, the money they will earn will be added to the budget to purchase

a grinder/shredder machine to lessen waste.

The researchers also recommend that the barangay must provide a

dump truck to help in collecting the waste in all areas in Barangay Kapatagan,
61

Digos City. To provide waste facilities like MRF in every Sitio, especially in the

areas that are not reached by the garbage collectors, so that the residents can

put the non-biodegradable waste there and to assign someone to guard the

MRF for those irresponsible individuals, or put CCTV monitors to check every

individual who did not properly segregate or put the waste in the MRF, and to

provide garbage bins/sacks in public places to help reduce the tendency of

garbage’s thrown anywhere.

Researchers’ recommendations to the resort owners/managers to

strengthen the policies and regulations concerning waste management and

create enough signage to remind the tourists to be responsible and mindful of

the garbage. To provide waste facilities outside the resort for the garbage

collector to easily collect the waste and if possible, they must provide a

collection vehicle to lessen the burden of the garbage collector provided by

LGU.

Researchers recommend to motor shops/vulcanizing shops always be

cautious about where to dispose of the used oils, tires, plastic containers, and

other harmful solid waste to avoid harming the humans and environment.

The researchers’ recommendations for the stakeholders are; to continue

the good practice of segregating the solid waste and to always follow the

policies and regulations implemented by the barangay. To raise their concerns

and suggestions regarding their problems in waste such as; the schedule is not

enough for all the waste in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City, and they need

waste facilities. Also, to participate in every program and awareness campaign


62

by barangay or LGUs regarding waste management and volunteer in every

clean-up drive.

Researchers’ recommendations to future researchers are; to conduct a

study regarding solutions to these factors to sustain solid waste management

in Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City. To use this study to assess other barangay

in Digos City regarding their solid waste management and last but not the least

is to study “what is the best alternative for sanitary landfill and is it effective and

efficient in helping a barangay to sustain solid waste management”.


63

Proposed Plan for Sustaining Solid Waste Management in Brgy.

Kapatagan, Digos City

Step 1: The barangay officials should conduct monthly meetings regarding

plans and regulations for solid waste management and encourage every

Purok/Sitio leader to attend and disseminate the information to every

household.

Step 2: The barangay officials must provide MRF in every Sitio. MRF should

consist of 3 waste classifications such as; recyclable waste, non-

biodegradable/non-recyclable waste, and toxic waste.

Step 3: Proper segregation for every household from household waste,

recyclable, toxic waste, biodegradable, and medical waste.

Step 4: All the properly segregated waste should be put in the MRF according

to its classifications.

Step 5: The different classifications of waste must undertake differently

procedure

a. All the biodegradable produce by households/private sectors should be

put in their compost pit or should be used as fertilizer

b. The barangay officials should buy a shredder/grinder machine to lessen

the burden of the garbage collector so that some of the non-

biodegradable/non-recyclable waste can be shredded/grind and used for

other purposes like creating eco-bricks and selling it to the market.

c. Barangay officials should conduct livelihood programs for all

unemployed residents or those who want to volunteer. The livelihood


64

program is transforming recyclable waste into other useful things like

plastic flowers, key chains, and souvenirs.

d. All toxic waste and medical waste should undergo treatment before

collection, to avoid pollution and biological health hazard.

Step 6: The barangay officials should encourage every store selling chemicals

to implement buy-back. Farmers should wash all the empty chemical bottles

before bringing them to the store to avoid biological health hazards.

a. In which every farmer who brings empty plastic bottles of chemicals can

earn a 2% discount on every bottle they bring.

b. Store could sell it at a higher price, for example instead of 50 pesos they

can sell it for 60 pesos but for every farmer who will bring empty plastic

bottles of chemicals can receive 10 pesos.

c. Every farmer that can bring 30 empty plastic bottles of chemicals, will

receive 1 free bottle of chemicals.

Step 7: The plastic cellophane used to wrap the bananas or cellophane

exposed to chemicals can undergo treatment, then sell it to the factory in

Barangay Kapatagan, Digos City.


65

REFERENCES

Ahmade, S. (2013); Impact of Solid Waste on Health and the

Environment; Retrieved from

https://www.researchgate.net/publication

Alam, P. (2013); Impacts of Solid Waste on Health and the Environment:

Retrieved from https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_

sdt=0%2C5&q=Impacts+of+Solid+Waste+on+Health+and+the+%09En

vironment&btnG=

Alia, M., Yasmin, A. (2014); Open Dumpling of Municipality Solid Waste

and its Hazardous Impacts on Soil and Vegetation Diversity at

Waste Dumpling Sites of Islamabad City; Retrieved from

https://doi.org/10.1016/

Andrada, L. et al. (2019). Best Practices of the Municipality of Sulop towards

Solid Waste Management. Senior Academy Department of South

Philippine Adventist College.

Bertoli, A. (2015); How are Trash Affects the Whole Planet; Retrieved from

https://https://scholar.google.com.ph

Boehlke, S. (2017); The Effects of Improper Waste Disposal; Retrieved

from https://www.livestrong.com/article/effects-improper- garbage

disposal/

Castillo, A. L., & Otoma, S. (2013). Status of solid waste management in

the Philippines. In Proceedings of the annual conference of Japan

Society of Material Cycles and Waste Management the 24th annual


66

conference of Japan Society of Material Cycles and Waste

Management (p. 677).

Drumheller, P. (2016); Diseases cause by garbage; Retrieved from

https://www.quora.com/What-diseases-are-caused-by-garbage

Caban, G. (2014); Minimizing Waste on Construction Project sites.

Engineering, Construction, and Architectural Management, Vol. 5 No.

2, pp. 182-188. Retrieved from

https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Minimizing-waste-on

construction-project-sites-FaniranCaban

Fenton, R. (2018); Improper Waste Disposal has Dangerous effect.

Retrieved from Error! Hyperlink reference not valid.

Jacobs, T. (2013); How improper waste disposal damages health; Retrieved

from https://www-vanguardngr- com.cdn.ampproject.org/v/s/

www.vanguardngr.com/2015/08/how-improper-waste-disposal-damages-

health

Kukreja, R. (2020). What is Sustainable Waste Management? RTS Retrieve

from https://www.rts.com/blog/what-is-sustainable-waste-management

Labs, E. (2016); Overflowing garbage bins: Five impacts on health and

Environment and how to Prevent; Retrieved from

https://www.ecubelabs.com/overflowing-garbage-bins-5-impacts-on-

health-and-environment-and-how-to-prevent/
67

Laurent C. M., Lebreton, et al., (2017); River Plastic Emissions to the

World’s Oceans; Nature Communication 8, no. 15611; Retrieved

from https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms15611

Leblanc, R. (2020). An Introduction to Solid Waste Management. The

balance small business. Retrieved from

https://www.thebalancesmb.com/an-introduction-to-solidwaste-

management

Lui, A. (2018); Global Waste to grow by 70 percent by 2015 unless urgent

action is taken; World Bank Report; Retrieved from

https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/press-release/

Mansour, M. et al. (2018). Solid waste issue: Sources, composition,

disposal, recycling, and valorization. Egyptian Journal of

Petroleum, Volume 27, Issue 4, Pages 1275-1290. Retrieved

fromhttps://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=

Solid+waste+issue%3A+Sources%2C+composition%2C+%09disposal

%2C+recycling%2C+and+valorization.+Egyptian+Journal+of+%09Petr

oleum%2C+Volume+27&btnG=#d=gs_cit&t=1654607199199&u=%2Fs

cholar%3Fq%3Dinfo%3AORXXDTmEEA0J%3Ascholar.google.com%2

F%26output%3Dcite%26scirp%3D0%26hl%3Den

Misra, V. Pandey, S. (2005); Hazardous Waste Impact on Health and

Environment for the Development of Better Waste Management

Strategies in Future in India; Retrieved from

https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=Haza
68

dous+Waste+Impact+on+Health+and+%09Environment+for+the+Deve

lopment+of+Better+Waste+Management+%09Strategies+in+Future+in

+India&btnG

Mohammed, D. (2016). The importance of Waste Management and

Recycling. Linked In. Retrieved from

https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=The+

mportance+of+Waste+Management+and++Recycling.&btnG

Obinna, C. (2015); How improper waste disposal damages health; Retrieved

from http://www.vanguardngr.com

Physician for social responsibility (2009); how air pollution c ontributes to

lung disease; Retrieved from https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article.

Radhakrishnan, T. (2017); Plastic waste helps mosquitoes breed;

Retrieved from: https://www.thenewsminute.com.cdn.ampproject.org/s

/www.thenewsminute.com/article/plastic-waste-helps-dengue

mosquito-breed-says-tn-health.

Rinkesh, T. (2013). What is Solid Waste Management? Conserve Energy for

Future. Retrieved from https://www.conserve- evergy

future.com/sources-effects-methods-of-solid-waste-

management.php#abh_posts

Rushton, L (2018); Health Hazards and Waste Management; Retrieved

from https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C5&q=

Health+Hazards+and+Waste+Management&btnG=
69

Saha, K. (2009); Household Wastes as Larval Habitats of Dengue Vectors:

Comparison between Urban and Rural Areas of Kolkata, India;

Retrieved from https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article.

SENSA Networks (2018). What Is Sustainable Waste Management and why it

Matter? SENSA Networks. Retrieve from

https://sensanetworks.com/blog/what-is-sustainable-waste-

management-and-why-it-matters/

Shepard, D. (2016); Disease Burden of Dengue in the Philippines: Adjusting

for Underreporting by Comparing Active and Passive Dengue

Surveillance in Punta Princesa, Cebu City; Retrieved from

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/

Solar Impulse Foundation (2016). Waste Management Solutions: How to

Shape the Future of Waste? Retrieve from

https://solarimpulse.com/waste-management-solutions#

Sujatha, S. (2018); Awareness of Solid Waste Disposal. International

Journal of Teacher Education Research (IJTER). Retrieved from

https://www.ijter.com

Torres, J. (2017); Improper Waste Disposal has Dangerous Effects:

Retrieved from https://www.junk-king.com/locations/marin/

2017/08/09/impropwer-waste-disposal-has-dangerous-effects/

Wong, J. et al. (2017) Sustainable Solid Waste Management. American

Society of Civil Engineers Library. Retrieved from

https://doi.org/10.1061/9780784414101
70

APPENDICES
71

Appendix A. Letters
72
73
74

Appendix B. Questionnaires
75

SUSTAINABLE SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT


AND ITS FACTORS OF CHALLENGES IN
BRGY. KAPATAGAN, DIGOS CITY

Residential/Household Questionnaires

COR JESU COLLEGE, INC.


COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING AND
TECHNOLOGY
Sacred Heart Avenue, Digos City,
Philippines
Tel. No.: (082) 553-2433 local 105 * Fax
No.: (082) 553-2333W
Website: www.cjc.edu.ph

Family Representative: Age:


Address: Gender:

No. member in household:

Answer the following questions based on your experiences. Use the


space provided for you corresponding answers.

Q1: Do you have MRF in your barangay? If yes, do you put/throw your

garbage there?

Q2: Do you have a compost pit in your backyard? If yes, what are the types

of garbage you throw there?

Q3: How often do you throw your Garbage in a week?

Q4: Do you usually segregate your garbage before putting it in the sack?

Q5: Is there a minimum sack of garbage allowed per household? If yes, what
76

is the minimum number of sacks are allowed?

Q6: Is there a possibility that the garbage truck will arrive late or will not

arrive? If yes, what do you usually do?

Q7: Are you allowed to throw the empty plastic bottle of chemicals? If not,

what do you usually do with the bottles?

Q8: Are you allowed to throw the empty cellophane used to pack bananas or

vegetables? If not, what do you usually do with it?

Q9: Where do you usually throw your biodegradable garbage such as;

vegetables and fruits?

Q10: What are your suggestions and recommendations to maintain

cleanliness in your barangay or Sitio?

Barangay Officials Questionnaires


77

COR JESU COLLEGE, INC.


COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING AND
TECHNOLOGY
Sacred Heart Avenue, Digos City,
Philippines
Tel. No.: (082) 553-2433 local 105 * Fax
No.: (082) 553-2333W
Website: www.cjc.edu.ph

Name: Age:
Position: Gender:

Disposal

Q1: What are the Solid Waste Management regulations and policies you have

implemented in your barangay?

Q2: Do you have any fines or punishments for the people who violate the rules

you enforced? What do you usually do?

Q3. Do you require each household to make its own compost pit? If yes, why?

Q4. What are the rules and policies for plastic chemical bottles, and cellophane

used to wrap bananas, fruits, and vegetables?

Q5. What alternative method or plan do you have to replace the landfill since it

is not allowed? Then when will this happen?

Collection

Q1. Are there people or officials who are assigned/tasked with promoting and

ensuring the cleanliness of the barangay?

Q2. Do you have MRF? if not, what is your plan? Where is the possible location

and how many would you build?


78

Q3. Is it enough to collect garbage twice a week? if yes or no, what is the

reason?

Q4. Do you require a minimum garbage bag/sack of waste to be collected? If

yes, how many and why?

Q5. Did you provide garbage bins or sacks in public places for waste?

Transportation

Q1. Are there areas here in Barangay Kapatagan that can’t be reached by the

dump truck when there is garbage collection?

Q2. What is the alternative way that is done by the residents who cannot be

reached by the dump truck?

Q3. Is one dump truck enough for garbage collection? If not, what is the reason?

Q4. Does the location of the landfill affect the transportation of garbage from

barangay Kapatagan, Digos City?

Q5. Do you have a plan to provide your own dump truck?

Management

Q1. What are your practices in your barangay?

Q2. Do you have a monthly cleaning or clean-up drive in your barangay?

Q3. Do you have programs or meetings about “Solid Waste Management” for

all residents of Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City to be aware of the right practices?

If yes, what are your platforms or plans?

Q4. Do you forbid residents from burning trash? What do you do to those

violators/offenders?

Q5. What are your plans to sustain solid waste management in your barangay?
79

CENRO Questionnaire

COR JESU COLLEGE, INC.


COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING AND
TECHNOLOGY
Sacred Heart Avenue, Digos City,
Philippines
Tel. No.: (082) 553-2433 local 105 * Fax
No.: (082) 553-2333W
Website: www.cjc.edu.ph

Name: Age:
Position: Gender:

Q1: Did you know that the MRF in Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City? If not, what is

your plan to resolve it?

Q2: What are your platforms regarding solid waste management, specifically in

Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City?

Q3: What are the Solid Waste Management regulations and policies that you

have implemented in Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City?

Q4: Are there people or officials tasked with promoting and ensuring cleanliness

in the various barangays?

Q5: Do you have a budget allocated to each barangay for some waste

management programs or plans?

Q6: What services do you provide to each barangay to help with their waste

management?

Q7: Do you have a regular visitation in Brgy. Kapatagan, Digos City? If yes,

what are the shortcomings you see in their waste management?

Garbage Truck Driver/Collector Questionnaire


80

COR JESU COLLEGE, INC.


COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING AND
TECHNOLOGY
Sacred Heart Avenue, Digos City,
Philippines
Tel. No.: (082) 553-2433 local 105 * Fax
No.: (082) 553-2333W
Website: www.cjc.edu.ph

Name:
Age:
Position: Gender:

Q1: What time do you usually collects and travel waste?

Q2: Is there a possibility of delay of transportation in the area?

Q3: How many dumps truck and garbage collectors that assigned here in Brgy.

Kapatagan, Digos City?

Q4: What are the specifically days of collection?

Q5: Do you have any trash that is not included?

Q6: What is the area of responsibility of collection in waste?

Q7: Do you segregate waste before to you transfers in landfill?

Private Sectors/Resorts in Brgy. Kapatagan Digos City


81

COR JESU COLLEGE, INC.


COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING AND
TECHNOLOGY
Sacred Heart Avenue, Digos City,
Philippines
Tel. No.: (082) 553-2433 local 105 * Fax
No.: (082) 553-2333W
Website: www.cjc.edu.ph

Resort’s Name:
Address:
Name of Representative:
Position:

Q1: Do you have any laws about waste management? What is this law and
how can it help?

Q2: Do you already provide signage to orient customers not to litter?


and do you provide trash bins/sacks for tourists to pass by

Q3: Do you segregate trash before you put it in sacks/trash bags? How many
bags of garbage can you produce a week?

Q4: What kind of waste do you usually produce each day? Are you
applying for 3R’s for this?

Q5: Do you still have your own garbage truck/garbage collector? and there,
where are you throwing it?

Q6: Have you ever made a compost pit? Where do you throw the limp
garbage?

Medical Center in in Brgy. Kapatagan Digos City


82

COR JESU COLLEGE, INC.


COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING AND
TECHNOLOGY
Sacred Heart Avenue, Digos City,
Philippines
Tel. No.: (082) 553-2433 local 105 * Fax
No.: (082) 553-2333W
Website: www.cjc.edu.ph

Establishment:
Name of Representative:
Position:
Address:

Q1. Do you have a law about waste management?

Q2. Where do you throw your toxic waste? Do you segregate it?

Q3. How many times do you throw trash in a week? What is your schedule to

collect your garbage?

Q4. How many sacks or trash bins will be filled in a week? How often do you

produce waste except toxic waste?

Q5. Do you have your own garbage collector and where do you throw it?

Motor shop/Vulcanizing Owner

COR JESU COLLEGE, INC.


83

COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING AND


TECHNOLOGY
Sacred Heart Avenue, Digos City,
Philippines
Tel. No.: (082) 553-2433 local 105 * Fax
No.: (082) 553-2333W
Website: www.cjc.edu.ph
Name: Age:

Address: Gender:

Q1. Where dispose those used-oil and used motor parts?

Q2. Do you have a signage to orient your costumer about solid waste?

Q3. How many sacks of garbage do you produce every week?

Q4. The numbers of garbage truck are enough to cater all garbage in your area?

Q5. Do you have a compost pit?

Appendix C. Curriculum Vitae

CURRICULUM VITAE
84

Contact Information
Name Xyril Rubie C. Alcordo
Address Malita, Davao Occidental
Cellphone 09666822532
Email Address xyrilrubiealcordo@gmail.com

Personal Information
Birthdate December 29, 2001
Birthplace Digos City
Citizenship Filipino
Civil Status Single
Gender Female

Educational Background
Elementary Holy Cross of Malita, Inc.
High School Holy Cross of Malita, Inc.
Senior High School Holy Cross of Malita, Inc.

Parents
Father’s Name Romy G. Alcordo
Mother’s Name Elvira C. Alcordo
Contact Number 09666822532

CURRICULUM VITAE
85

Contact Information
Name Mervin Lowell C. Algabre
Address Purok 1, San Miguel, Magsaysay, Davao Del Sur
Cellphone 09486310448
Email Address algabremervin@gmail.com

Personal Information
Birthdate September 14, 2000
Birthplace Digos City
Citizenship Filipino
Civil Status Single
Gender Male

Educational Background
Elementary San Miguel Elementary School
High School Magsaysay Academy, Inc.
Senior High School Magsaysay Academy, Inc.

Parents
Father’s Name Sabino C. Algabre Jr.
Mother’s Name Miraflor C. Algabre
Contact Number 09124509661

CURRICULUM VITAE
86

Contact Information
Name Marco Victorio C. Amarillo
Address Star Apple St., Bansalan, Davao Del Sur
Cellphone 09151871649
Email Address hynthmarco@gmail.com

Personal Information
Birthdate February 15, 2001
Birthplace Digos City
Citizenship Filipino
Civil Status Single
Gender Male

Educational Background
Elementary St. Therese School Bansalan
High School St. Therese School Bansalan
Senior High School St. Mary’s College of Bansalan

Parents
Father’s Name Marvin H. Amarillo
Mother’s Name Sherly C. Amarillo
Contact Number 09093951934

CURRICULUM VITAE
87

Contact Information
Name Clerr John P. Cabasug
Address Km 81, Sto. Nino, Bansalan, Davao Del Sur
Cellphone 09954144519
Email Address johnagility3@gmail.com

Personal Information
Birthdate June 12, 2001
Birthplace Digos City
Citizenship Filipino
Civil Status Single
Gender Male

Educational Background
Elementary V.Duterte Elementary School
High School St. Mary’s College of Bansalan
Senior High School St. Mary’s College of Bansalan.

Parents
Father’s Name Cipriano C. Cabasug
Mother’s Name Jocelyn P. Cabasug
Contact Number 09464349997

CURRICULUM VITAE
88

Contact Information
Name Janlex S. Escobarte
Address Purok Calumpang, Punta-Biao, Cogon, Digos City
Cellphone 09051511876
Email Address janlex.escobarte0109@gmail.com

Personal Information
Birthdate January 9, 2001
Birthplace Digos City
Citizenship Filipino
Civil Status Single
Gender Male

Educational Background
Elementary Casa Amazing Grace School
High School Union National High School- Mt. Diwata
HighSchool Annex
Senior High School Cor Jesu College, Inc.

Parents
Father’s Name Alex E. Escobarte
Mother’s Name Liezel S. Escobarte
Contact Number 09101668937

CURRICULUM VITAE
89

Contact Information
Name Jullian Ace B. Pascua
Address S-Ronda St., Poblacion, Hagonoy, Davao Del Sur
Cellphone 09777683103
Email Address jullianpascua08@gmail.com

Personal Information
Birthdate August 4, 2000
Birthplace Digos City
Citizenship Filipino
Civil Status Single
Gender Male

Educational Background
Elementary Hagonoy Central Elementary School
High School Cor Jesu College, Inc.
Senior High School Cor Jesu College, Inc.

Parents
Father’s Name Julius C. Pascua
Mother’s Name Juliet B. Pascua
Contact Number 09085656491

CURRICULUM VITAE
90

Contact Information
Name Cyril Ane O. Pia
Address Chapter 10-A, Aplaya, Digos City, Davao Del Sur
Cellphone 09062973131
Email Address cyrilpia0@gmail.com

Personal Information
Birthdate October 11, 2001
Birthplace Digos City
Citizenship Filipino
Civil Status Single
Gender Female

Educational Background
Elementary Bala Elementary School
High School Holy Cross Academy of Digos
Senior High School Cor Jesu College, Inc.

Parents
Father’s Name Andres Q. Pia
Mother’s Name Jean O. Pia
Contact Number 09308096900

CURRICULUM VITAE
91

Contact Information
Name April Jane N. Watin
Address Purok Bayanihan,Km 71, Matanao, Davao Del Sur
Cellphone 09558160423
Email Address apriljanewatin072617@gmail.com

Personal Information
Birthdate April 17, 2000
Birthplace Maragusan, Davao De Oro
Citizenship Filipino
Civil Status Single
Gender Female

Educational Background
Elementary Sinawilan Elementary School
High School Sinawilan National High School
Senior High School South Philippine Adventist College

Parents
Father’s Name Roberto A. Watin Jr.
Mother’s Name Juliet N. Watin
Contact Number 09383799054

Appendix D. Documentation
92

DATE: MARCH 18, 2022


LOCATION: BARANGAY HALL OF KAPATAGAN, DIGOS CITY

DATE: MARCH 25, 2022


LOCATION: BRGY. KAPATAGAN

DATE: MARCH 26, 2022


LOCATION: COR JESU COLLEGE (1ST DEFENSE)
93

DATE: APRIL 19, 2022


LOCATION: CJC LIBRARY

DATE: APRIL 24, 2022


DATE: APRIL 24, 2022
LOCATION: CJC DRAWING LAB (2ND DEFENSE)
94

DATE: APRIL 29, 2022


LOCATION: BRGY. HALL OF KAPATAGAN

DATE: APRIL 29, 2022


LOCATION: BRGY. KAPATAGAN
95

DATE: MAY 06, 2022


LOCATION: BRGY. KAPATAGAN

DATE: MAY O6, 2022


LOCATION: MONTE FRIO RESORT IN KAPATAGAN
96

DATE: MAY 10, 2022


LOCATION: CENRO OFFICE, DIGOS CITY

DATE: MAY 14, 2022


LOCATION: CJC (3RD DEFENSE)

DATE: MAY 20, 2022


LOCATION: LUNGAG LANDFILL, DIGOS CITY
97

DATE: MAY 20, 2022


LOCATION: BRY KAPATAGAN

CAMP SABROS JARDIN DE SEÑORITA

DHEN YHOS
WINE WOODS

DATE: MAY 20, 2022


LOCATION: BRGY. KAPATAGAN MEDICAL CENTER
98

DATE: MAY 20, 2022


LOCATION: KAGAWAD MANLABI’S PLACE

You might also like