You are on page 1of 65

BATANGAS COLLEGE OF

ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Taro Stem (ColocasiaEsculenta)


As an Alternative Source
of Packaging Paper

A Science Investigatory Project

Presented to
Batangas College of Arts and Sciences, Inc.
Lipa City

In Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for Completion/Graduation in
JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL

BAUTISTA, JOHN BENEDICT M.


JAPLOS, ANGELO RAFAEL M.
MARUNDAN, MAXINE H.
UMALI, REYNALDO P.

April 2019

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 1
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. ABSTRACT. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5

II. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

III. CHAPTER 1 (The Problem)

1.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .8

1.2 Statement of the Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10

1.3 Conceptual Framework . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11

1.4 Significance of the Study . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11

1.5 Scope and Limitations of the Study . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13

1.6 Definition of Terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

14

IV. CHAPTER 2 (Review of Related Literature)

2.1 Conceptual Literature . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16

2.2 Research Literature. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24

V. CHAPTER 3 (Research Methodology)

3.1 Research Design. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38

3.2 Ingredients and Materials. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .38

3.3 Methods and Procedures. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .40

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 2
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

3.4 Data Analysis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .42

VI. CHAPTER 4 (Presentation, Analysis and Interpretation of Data)

4.1 Components of taro stem. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

44

4.2 Effectiveness of taro stem in terms of:

Strength. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .44

Resistivity to Heat. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45

Resistivity to Liquids. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .47

4.3 Significant Differences of:

Strength . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51

VII. CHAPTER 5 (Summary of Findings, Conclusions, and Recommendations)

5.1 Summary of Findings. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52

5.2 Conclusions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .53

5.3 Recommendations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 53

VIII. REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .54

IX. APPENDICES. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .57

X. PROFILE OF THE RESEARCHERS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .60

XI. LIST OF FIGURES

F.1. Conceptual

Framework. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .11

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 3
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

F.2. Methods and Procedures . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .40

F.3. Strength. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .44

XII. LIST OF TABLES

T.1 Ingredients. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

39

T.2 Materials. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .39

T.3 Resistivity to

heat. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .46

T.4 Resistivity to water. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .47

T.5 Resistivity to acid. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .48

T.6 Resistivity to

base. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .50

T.7. Strength. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .51

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 4
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

ABSTRACT

Pollution and increased taxes are some of the contemporary problems

experiences on our country and one of the causes are wasted plastic bags and

materials. Plastics was used often on our daily lives as consumers. However,

once the plastic material was consumed or used it was thrown away. The

researchers find a better product to lessen the use of decomposable plastic.

As another alternative, the researchers sought a common plant that was

beneficial, cost efficient and easily obtained. ColocasiaEsculenta, also known as

taro, contains starch and fibers which was used in making the packaging paper.

The experimental design was the two group design in which is particularly used

to determine the capabilities and durability of the paper made out of taro. The

researcher used spring balance to determine the strength, and used water,

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 5
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

vinegar and baking soda to test the resistivity to liquid, and an oven to

determine the heat resistivity. T-test was applied to determine the significant

difference among the used taro paper. Based on the results, taro stem can be

used as an alternative source of packaging paper. Furthermore, compared to the

commercialized packaging paper in terms of its tensile strength the experimental

product was stronger and more durable.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The researchers would like to give thanks and give their deepest gratitude to the

respective people who have cooperated and supported to the success of the

completion and submission of the study.

First and foremost, our Lord Almighty, whom enlightened the researchers and

gave protection, knowledge and inspiration for the completion of this study.

To Ms. Leah Lina, the researchers’ thesis adviser, whom supported, guided,

and gave important lessons in which the researchers used all throughout the

study’s development.

The researcher’s parents, whom gave their full financial and moral support

that was greatly beneficial for the researcher’s study.

To the class adviser, Ms. Nerish Joy Uri, whom gave courage, hope, advice

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 6
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

and especially her full outmost support to the researchers to finish this study.

To the class of 10 Selenite, for all the help, support, trust, comfort, faith and

belief in the researchers that they can accomplish something this significant and

the encouragement they gave to the researchers. They gave their support and

help in missed activities in case of excused absences.

And finally, to themselves, for cooperating and helping each other out on

finishing the study.

The researchers owe of the people with all their respect and gratitude for

without them, this paper would not be possible.

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 7
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

CHAPTER 1

THE PROBLEM

This chapter includes the statement of the problem, its objectives,

significance of the study, scope and limitations, and definition of terms that

present in the study with clarity to facilitate the understanding of the topic.

1.1 Introduction

Too much use of plastics has resulted to the clogging of drainage, flash

floods, waste pollution and water pollution. Plastics affects human health. Toxic

chemicals reach out of plastics and are found in the blood and tissue of nearly all

of us. Exposure to plastics is linked to cancers, birth defects, impaired immunity,

innovative disruption and other ailments.

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 8
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

The purpose of the study is to contribute an alternative packaging paper in

the society to gain or produce a more durable and safer packaging paper made

out of taro stem. It aims to reduce the cutting of trees by suggesting the use of

taro stem as an alternative source of packaging paper.

A polluted country like the Philippines, plastic bags are used by everyone.

Plastic bags has been a big part to the people. However, the usage of this has

been out of which results in killing our environment. Every year same problem

gets worse and it liters the bays. Streets, parks, beaches and if they burned it,

they infuse the air with toxic fumes. About 60,000 animals are killed every year

due to this plastic wastes. Many animals ingested plastic bags remains intact

even after the death and compositions of animals. Plastic bags are not capable

of being decomposed by bacteria or other living organisms and it gives bad

effects on our environment.(G. Thompson, 2008)

Packaging paper can be defined as “All the activities of designing and

producing the container or wrapper of a product.” Packaging paper is a structure

designed to make it easier and safer to transport, to protect against

contamination or less degradation or damage and to produce a convenient way

to dispense the product. Packaging also pertains as a container or wrapper for a

consumer product that serves a number of purposes. Including protection and

description of the contents, their difference an product promotion. Packaging

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 9
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

paper constitutes the largest person of packaging material even more than glass,

metal or plastic. It is multi-purpose, clean and flexible. Most consumer used

packaging paper for safer and less damage of the product.

This study has provided an alternative packaging to plastic with the use of

taro stem to lessen the problem of plastic waste that cause much environmental

problems.

1.2 Statement of the Problem

This study determined the quality of taro stem as an alternative source of

packaging paper in terms of its strength, heat and water resistivity.

Specifically answered the following questions:

1. What are the components of taro stem that can use to make packaging

paper?

2. How effective is the taro stem as packaging paper in terms of:

2.1 Strength/Durability

2.2 Resistivity to heat

2.3 Resistivity to liquids

3. Is there any significant difference between the commercially used

packaging paper and taro stem packaging paper?

Hypothesis:

HO: There is no significant difference between the commercially used packaging

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 10
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
T
d
q
L
H
y
v
i
R
f
n
u
A
m
e
t
s
o
r
a BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

paper and taro stem packaging paper in terms of its strength, resistivity to heat

and liquids.

1.3 ConceptualFramework

Fig. 1. Conceptual framework of the Study

Independent variable is the stimulus variable which is chosen by the researchers

to determine its relationship to an observed phenomenon. The independent

variable of this study was taro stem since it is the one being tested as an

alternative source of packaging paper in terms of its strength, resistivity to heat

and liquids that serves as the dependent variable. Dependent variable acts as the

response variable which is observed and measured to determine the effect of the

independent variable. The intervening variable interferes with the independent

and dependent variables, but its effects can either strengthen or weaken the

independent and dependent variables. The intervening variable in this study is

the amount of taro stem since this factor can affect the effectiveness of taro

stem as an alternative source of packaging paper.

1.4 Significance of the Study

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
11
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

This study would be beneficial to the following:

Consumers -these include those who usually buy in stores and markets, which

uses single-use plastic as a packaging of their products. They would know that

there is an eco-friendly, reusable and even cheaper packaging. The risks of

having diseases because of the chemical contained in making plastics would be

lessen. Moreover, they will also be aware that the taro stem that are usually just

planted on their backyard can be very useful and they can even use it as a start-

up business.

Vendors - the vendors of the market and stores in our country will have a

cheaper packaging and the usage of plastic will be avoided. Once the taro stem

packaging paper became a product in the market, the vendors would be less

problematic because they will have fewer expenses on their packaging material.

Future Researchers - these include those who will improve and develop our

study. As we provide an initial research idea for the future researchers, they will

have an idea and know the components of taro stem that can be used as an

alternative source of packaging paper.

Environment - the environment in the Philippines is suffering a lot. As of now,

plastic waste is the main cause of flooding. Having an alternative source of

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 12
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

packaging this problem will be lessen since it disintegrated easily as compare to

plastics and it lessen the clogging of drainage since the product is an eco-friendly

material.

Country - this study can facilitate a lot within the different aspects of the

country. The primary factor is its economy growth. Having its own supply of

packaging, the citizens and government will not depend upon the plastic

materials any more. Other countries might have an interest in this product and

improve the country’s economy standing. It will conjointly increase the people’s

satisfaction rate which is good for a growing country, like the Philippines.

Furthermore, it will improve its international standing and be well known for

being an inventive and innovative country.

1.5 Scope and Limitations of the Study

This scientific research has utilized taro stem as an alternative source of

packaging paper. This study determined the components of taro stem that made

it an alternative packaging paper. The experimental design used by the

researchers was the two group design.

The source of the taro stem was gathered in MataasnaKahoy and the

strength, resistivity to heat and liquids of taro stem as packaging paper was

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 13
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

tested in Lipa City. This study started last August 2018 and has ended on April

2019.

1.6 Definition of Terms

Strength – the power to resist force. (Merriam-Webster, 2018)

Packaging – the enclosing of something in a container or covering. (Merriam-

Webster, 2018)

Taro – an herbaceous perennial, mostly cultivated as an annual. (Feedipedia,

2018)

Base –  any of substance typically water-soluble and bitter tasting compounds

that in solution have a pH greater than 7. (Merriam-Webster, 2018)

Acid – any of various typically water-soluble and sour compounds that in

solution are capable of reacting with a base to form a salt and have a pH less

than 7. (Wikipedia, 2018)

Silk Screen – a screen of fine mesh used in screen-printing and was used on

the experiment as a molder for the paper. (Merriam-Webster, 2018)

Contaminants – something that makes place or a substance such as water, air

or food no longer suitable for use. (Merriam-Webster, 2018)

Disintegrated – break up into small parts, typically as the result of impact or

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 14
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

decay. (Merriam-Webster, 2018)

Waste – any substance which is discarded after primary use, or is worthless,

defective and of no use. (Wikipedia, 2018)

Sodium Hydroxide - also known as NaOH, a highly caustic base and alkali that

decomposes proteins at ordinary ambient temperatures and may cause severe

chemical burns. (Wikipedia, 2018)

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 15
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

CHAPTER 2

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

This chapter includes the conceptual literature and review of literature,

which the researchers have pursued to shed light on the topic under the study.

2.1 Conceptual Literature

Plastic Waste: Ecological and Human Health Impacts.

Plastic waste is a growing concern and the drivers behind it look set to

continue. Although recently there has been a slight decrease in plastic

production, this is unlikely to be maintained. Plastic is a highly useful material

and its applications are expected to increase as more new products and plastics

are developed to meet demands. The increased use and production of plastic in

developing and emerging countries is a particular concern, as the sophistication

of their waste management infrastructure may not be developing at an

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 16
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

appropriate rate to deal with their increasing levels of plastic waste.

Plastic waste also has the ability to attract contaminants, such as persistent

organic pollutants (POPs). This is particularly so in the marine environment since

many of these contaminants are hydrophobic, which means they do not mix or

bind with water. Again, the role of plastic waste in the impact of these toxic

chemicals is unclear. Plastic could potentially transport these chemicals to

otherwise clean environments and, when ingested by wildlife, plastic could cause

the transfer of chemicals into the organism’s system. However, in some

conditions plastic could potentially act as a sink for contaminants, making them

less available to wildlife, particularly if they are buried on the seafloor. With their

large surface area-to-volume ratio, micro-plastics may have the capacity to make

chemicals more available to wildlife and the environment in comparison to larger

sized plastics. However, once ingested, micro-plastics may pass through the

digestive system more quickly than larger plastics, potentially providing less

opportunity for chemicals to be absorbed into the circulatory system. Although

plastic waste may not always cause detectable harm or death as an isolated

factor, when combined with other impacts, such as uncontrolled fishing or oil

spills, it may contribute cumulatively to serious impacts. These sub-lethal effects

are difficult to monitor, but are nonetheless important to recognize. Research has

indicated that some species or developmental stages are more vulnerable to

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 17
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

ingestion of plastic waste and the toxic effects of the chemicals associated with

it. Policy responses to plastic waste come in many forms and work on many

levels, ranging from beach clean-ups to bans on plastic waste disposal at sea, to

targets for waste management and recycling. Several market-based instruments

have been explored such as deposit schemes to encourage the return and multi-

user of plastics, and taxation on single-use plastics that do not fit into deposit

return systems. However, there has been little widespread application of these

instruments and more research is needed to maximize their effectiveness and

ensure they do not have secondary effects other than those intended.

(Unknown, 2011)

Plastic Pollution.

Plastic bags harm us, by polluting the environment, and killing animals as

well as aquatic life. About a hundred billion plastic bags are used every year in

the US alone. If one considers the huge economies and population of India,

China, Europe,and other parts of the world’s numberscan be staggering.

A polluted country like the Philippines, plastic bags are used by

everyone. Plastic bags has been a big part to the people. However, the usage of

this has been out of which results in killing our environment. Every year same

problem gets worse and it liters the bays. Streets, parks, beaches and if they

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 18
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

burned it, they infuse the air with toxic fumes. About 60,000 animals are killed

every year due to this plastic wastes. Many animals ingested plastic bags

remains intact even after the death and compositions of animals. Plastic bags are

not capable of being decomposed by bacteria or other living organisms and it

gives bad effects on our environment. (R. Putatunda, 2011)

ColocasiaEsculenta.

Taro, Colocasiaesculenta, is a perennial tropical plant of the ARUM family,

Aracae. It's large, starchy, tuberous roots are a staple food in Polynesia and East

Asia. Roots from the wetland taro are heated to destroy their bitter taste, then

ground and fermented into an edible paste called "poi", an important food on

many Polynesian islands.

Taro is also called eddo or dasheen, herbaceous plant of the family

Araceae. Probably native to southeastern Asia, whence it spread to Pacific

islands, it became a staple crop, cultivated for its large, starchy, spherical

underground tubers, which are consumed as cooked vegetables, made into

puddings and breads, and also made into the Polynesian poi, a thin, pasty, highly

digestible mass of fermented taro starch. The large leaves of the taro are

commonly stewed. The upland(dry) taro, or dasheen, produces corms that are

eaten like potatoes in Japan, China and West Indies. The dasheen is sometimes

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 19
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

grown as an ornamental houseplant called "elephant ear" because of its large

heart shaped leaves. (Unknown, 2012)

Thermal and Base Properties.

As the development and application areas of papers increase, the thermal

properties of papers are also getting more attention. Important thermal

properties of paper are specific heat, thermal conduction, thermal expansion,

combustion and thermal decomposition. The specific heat of paper is similar to

natural cellulosic fiber. Moisture content of paper affects these properties

significantly. Thermal conductivity of paper depends on apparent density and

absorbed moisture. Temperature and moisture changes affect paper extension

and shrinkage significantly. Of the two, moisture has more effect than

temperature.

Moisture Affects tensile strength. Maximum tensile is obtained between

20%-30% relative h umidity (RH). Below this range stress intensification and

above this range plastification make the paper weaker. At complete saturation,

the tensile strength of paper becomes practically zero. Sizing provides temporary

wet strength due to their applications.

Paper and paperboard has a high flammability. This is an advantage for

disposal by burning. However, flammability is a disadvantage for paper for

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 20
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

applications where fire hazard is critical such as interior decoration. (Adanur, Ph

D., 1997)

Packaging Paper.

Packaging is packing of various objects and substances in suitable

containers for shipping and sale. A large part of the merchandise consumers buy

is packaged in various kinds of containers – boxes, bags, bottles and cans.

Proper packaging protects the content and makes the easier to handle and sell.

The packaging maybe done by the manufacturer or grower, by the whole sale, or

by the retailer.

Good packages should be inexpensive, to avoid adding too much to the

cost of their contents. At the same time, they must be able to withstand

whatever rough treatment they might receive in transit. Package must protect

their contents against possible damage form such things as fumes, moisture,

dirt, and fungus. They must be also attractive if they are to help rather than

hinder sales. Large sums are spent to design packages that will attract attention

and appears to buyers. Many kinds of packaging developed since 1940, then as

aerosol cans and plastic bottles, were designed to make their container safer and

more convenient to use. (Unknown, 2010)

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 21
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Tensile Properties.

The most fundamental and informative physical evaluation for paper is

probably that of the tensile test. It provides the elastic properties of paper which

are directly related to fiber quality and the level of fiber bonding is most aptly

described in the 1982 paper by Page and Seth. To a large extent, most of what

is required to be known about a paper sample can be gleaned from a tensile test

provided it is interpreted correctly. Therefore, tensile testing is routinely used in

manufacturing operations for quality control.

Simply stated, the tensile test is a strip of paper clamped at both ends and

pulled at a constant rate until failure. The load at failure is the tensile strength

(St), which is satisfactory for many purposes but much more can be gleaned

from consideration of what happens while the strip is pulled to fracture. (Roman

E. Popil, Ph.D., 2006)

The Environmental Impacts of Packaging.

The need for packaging and the development of packaging was caused by

the fact that the production and the consumption took place at separate places

and times, and the produced goods had to be distributed and transported.

Packaging became a connecting link between production and consumption, and

the importance of this link is growing in urbanized societies. More than 150,000

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 22
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

people are being added to urban population in developing countries every day.

In the mid-twentieth century, only one-third of the world’s population was urban.

The prediction is that by 2025, two-third of the world’s people will live in cities.

This means thatmore people will live in cities than occupied the whole planet in

the 1980s. In such level of urbanization, distribution of goods, especially food, is

crucial, and the role of packaging is enormous.

The package is not noticed during purchase, transport, and use of the

product—infact, it is not noticed until the minute the product is consumed and

the package had fulfilled its function and turns into waste. At that minute, the

package is already seen as an environmental burden, wasting resources. Those

concerned about the state of the environment can take part in reducing this

burden through packaging recovery programs. Packaging has positive and

negative impacts on the environment. The negative impacts include resources

use and the effects of packaging-related wastes and emissions. The positive

impact is that packaging consumer goods facilitates their distribution, and thus

makes it possible to obtain goods otherwise not accessible. Environmentally

conscious packaging enables satisfying human needs in an effective way.

(Pongrácz, E, 2007)

Resistivity to water.

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 23
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Water resistance is desirable since it decreases the strength-reducing effects of

moisture but it can also make paper harder to glue and print, since the glue and

ink must be partly absorbed by the paper. Sizing agents, added to the pulp or to

the paper surface, as well as wet strength resins, increase water resistance.

Water resistance can be measured by directly using the “soaking method”. It

involves pouring water over it and letting it soak for a certain period of time, and

then comparing its weight to that if the dry sample. Water immersion test of

paperboard also evaluates wicking through the board’s cut edges. (D. Twede,

Susan E. M. Selke)

2.2 Research Literature

In the study of Rorisang 'Maphoka entitled “Taro (ColocasiaEsculenta) yield

and quality in response to planting date and organic fertilization” ,despite the

importance of taro (ColocasiaEsculenta) as a food security crop, scientific

research on it is scanty in South Africa. Production site, planting date and

fertiliser regime affect crop performance and quality, particularly that of cultivars,

because they tend to be adapted to specific localities. Storage temperature and

packaging method on the other hand affect the shelf-life. To investigate

performance and quality of three taro cultivar in response to planting date and

fertilization, a study was carried out at two sites in KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 24
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

(Ukulinga and Umbumbulu), during the 2007/2008 growing seasons. The effect

of two storage temperatures (12oC and ambient temperature) and three

packaging methods (polyethylene bags, mesh bags and open boxes) on cormel

quality following storage was also investigated for three cultivars. Delayed

planting negatively affected the number of cormels plant-1 and fresh cormel

mass plant-1. Fertilization and cultivar affected the number of cormels plant-1

and fresh cormel mass plant-1 only when planting was done in October and

November at both sites. Fertilization increased the number of cormels plant-1 for

all cultivars except Dumbe-dumbe. Dumbe-dumbe had the lowest number of

cormels plant-1 but the highest number of marketable cormels plant-1. Dumbe-

dumbe showed the lowest fresh cormel mass plant-1 in October and the highest

in November at Ukulinga. Fertisation increased fresh cormel mass plant-1 in

October at Umbumbulu. Dry matter content was negatively affected by

fertilisation at Ukulinga. The response of dry matter content, specific gravity,

protein, minerals, reducing sugars and starch content was variable depending on

cultivar. Delayed planting negatively affected starch content for Dumbe-dumbe

and Pitshi at Ukulinga. Fertilization decreased starch content of Pitshi, while

delayed planting increased sugar content for Dumbe-dumbe and decreased it for

Mgingqeni and Pitshi at Umbumbulu. Dumbe-dumbe had higher starch content

and higher reducing sugars. Considering all growth and quality parameters, it is

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 25
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

recommended that Dumbe-dumbe is the best taro cultivar for crisping and the

best time to plant it is October with 160 kg N ha-1 of organic fertilizer and

November with 320 kg N ha-1 at Ukulinga whereas at Umbumbulu the best time

to plant Dumbe-dumbe is October with 320 kg N ha-1 of the fertilizer. Starch

granules degradation, alpha-amylase activity and sprouting increased with

storage time and storage temperature. Cormels of Mgingqeni stored in

polyethylene bags showed highest alpha-amylase activity and sprouting.

Reducing sugar content increased and starch content decreased with time in

storage and decline in storage temperature. It is recommended that taro cormels

be stored in mesh bags at 12oC. The chapters of this thesis represent different

studies presented as different papers. Chapter 1 is a general introduction to

explain the study background and hypothesis. Chapter 2 is a general review of

literature. Chapter 3 is on growth, development and yield of taro in response to

planting date and fertilization. Chapter 4 is on the influence of planting date and

organic fertilizer on crisping quality of taro cormels. Chapter 5 is on changes in

the surface morphology of starch granules and alpha-amylase activity of taro

during storage. Chapter 6 is on the effects of pre and post-harvest practices on

starch and reducing sugars of taro. (Mare, Rorisang 'Maphoka, 2009)

In the study of Maninder Kaur, PragatiKaushal, and Kawaljit Singh Sandhu

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 26
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

entitled “Studies on physicochemical and pasting properties of Taro

(Colocasiaesculenta) flour in comparison with a cereal, tuber and legume flour” ,

the physicochemical and pasting properties of taro (Colocasiaesculenta) flour

were investigated and compared with flours from other botanical sources.

Proximate composition, color parameters, water and oil absorption, foaming

characteristics and pasting properties (measured using Rapid visco analyzer) of

flours were related to each other using Pearson correlation and principal

component analysis (PCA). Taro flour was significantly (P < 0.05) different from

other flours in exhibiting highest carbohydrate, water absorption, and lower

protein, foaming capacity and setback viscosity. Peak viscosity of taro flour was

lower in comparison to potato flour but higher than that of soya and corn flours.

Several significant correlations between functional and pasting properties were

revealed both by PCA and Pearson correlation. PCA showed that taro and potato

flours were located at the left of the score plot with a negative score, while

soybean and corn flours had a large positive score in the first principal

component.

Root and tuber crops are grown throughout the world in hot and humid

regions and contain starch as the major carbohydrate in them. Tubers have a

short-shelf life because of their high moisture content and start rotting as early

as 2 weeks post-harvesting. In order to minimize tuber losses, they must be

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 27
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

converted from perishable to non-perishable through food processing operations

(Aboubakar et al. 2008). One of the best ways to preserve them is by processing

them into flour and/or starch (Perez et al. 2005). Taro (Colocasiaesculenta L.) is

a tropical tuber crop largely produced for its underground corms and consumed

in tropical and subtropical areas of the world (Aboubakar et al. 2008). Protein

and fat content of taro are low but it is high in carbohydrates, fibre and minerals

(Del Rosario and Lorenz 1999) and has been reported to have 70% to 80%

starch (Jane et al. 1992). Even though taro is not an industrial crop, its starch

has numerous applications for use in several food products due to its small

particle size which offer improved binding and may offer additional health

promoting benefits. The high viscosity of taro starches makes them very useful in

food applications where high thickening power is desired as well as the small

particle size being useful for bread or noodle production (Aprianita et al. 2009).

It has been reported that flour from taro corms, dried and milled contains easy

digestion starch and therefore is widely used as infant food (Del Rosario and

Lorenz 1999). Successful performance of flours as food ingredients depend upon

the functional characteristics and sensory qualities they impart to the end

product (Kaur and Singh 2007). The functional properties of the flours are

provided not only by proteins, but also by the complex carbohydrates and other

components such as pectins and mucilages (Kaur and Singh 2005). Literature on

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 28
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

taro has been reviewed by some authors (Mega 1992; Tagodoe and Nip 1994;

Mbofung et al. 2006; Njintang and Mbofung 2006; Njintang et al. 2007).

Attempts have been made to characterize taro starches and flours of Hawaiian

and Cameroonian varieties but no such studies have been reported on Indian

taro. The main objective of the present work was to study the functional and

pasting properties of taro flour in comparison to other tuber (potato), cereal

(corn) and legume (soyabean) flours. An acquisition of understanding of

properties of taro flour may demonstrate its further potential uses in the food

industry as an alternative source to conventional forms of carbohydrates or in

production of new food products. Also the correlations between different flour

properties were established using Pearson correlation and principal component

analysis. (Maninder Kaur, PragatiKaushal, and Kawaljit Singh Sandhu

In the study of AlirezaAshori entitled “Nonwood fibers—A potential source

of raw material in papermaking”,world demand for paper has increased at an

average annual rate of 4.7% over the past 40 years. Although future growth will

reduce to 2–3% the existing wood resources may be inadequate to meet this

growing demand for paper especially in the Asia-Pacific region and Eastern

Europe.

In addition, logging is coming under increasing pressure from

environmentalists concerned about habitat destruction and other longer-term

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 29
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

impacts of forest harvesting. It is, therefore, necessary to consider alternative

fiber sources to meet the possible shortfall of wood fiber for papermaking.

Suitable non-wood fibers are abundantly available in many countries and are the

major source of fiber for papermaking in some developing nations.

(AlirezaAshori, 2006)

In the study of Faith Faustine J. Sapupoentitled “Banana Penducles as a

potential source of paper”, packaging papers constitutes the largest portion of

packaging material, even more than glass, metal, or plastic. It is multi-purpose

clean and flexible. Among the types of packaging paper are all kinds of

corrugated cardboard, kraft paper for paper bags and classic brown packaging

paper, as well as the cover layers for plaster board. As a rule, a high portion of

recovered papers is common to all of them. They perform important functions in

merchandise management protection for damage during transport and storage,

as form carriers or purely for image enhancement.

Banana penducles from Musa cavendishii was studied for its components

and its utilization into high value added products. Fiber and juices were found to

be main components and these were extracted by means of retting and by

mechanical press, respectively. The cell length of penducle fiber is longer than

those from other non-wood materials and classifies it a linger fiber. Dried fibers

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 30
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

was utilized for dietary fiber enrichments of meat products. In addition, to some

identified functional properties, for manufacture of fiberboards, for pulp and

paper. (Faith Faustine J. Sapupo, 2016)

In the study of Kimberly Del Agua and KylaAlorroentitled “Taro

(ColocasiaEsculenta) as an Alternative Source of Biodegradable Plastic” , the

government are working out to lessen the impact of plastic bags on the

environment. Each of us should shoulder some of the responsibility for this

problem which ultimately harms us. It must be understood the risk of the

harmful effects of plastic bags on the environment. They are not only non-

biodegradable, but are one of the pollutants of the bodies of water.

Plastic bags are very popular with both retailers as well as consumers

because there are cheap, strong, lightweight, and functional. A hygienic means

of carrying food as well as other goods. Even though they are one of the modern

conveniences that we seem to be unable to do without. They are responsible for

causing pollution, killing wildlife, and causing up the precious resources of the

Earth. According to Sriroth K. et. al(2009) starch foam is one of the major

starch-based packaging materials. It is produced by extrusion or

compression/explosion technology. Their product has been developed as a

replacement for polystyrene w/c is used to produce loose filters and other

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 31
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

expanded items. It was found cut in their research that in biodegradable plastics,

granular starch can be directly blended w/ polymer or its granular structure can

be destructurized before being incorporated into the polymer matrix. (Kimberly

Del Agua and Kyla Alorro, 2015)

In the study of T. Kasemsuwan, and W. K. Nip entitled “Physical and

Chemical Studies of Taro Starches and Flours” , taro (Colocasiaesculenta) is a

tropical tuber crop and is cultivated widely in many countries, including the

United States. Taro is a major crop of the islands of Hawaii and Samoa. In

Hawaii, taro is cultivated in both wetland and dryland conditions. Native

Hawaiians grow taro in wetland for the preparation of poi (taro paste).

Taro also has been used in baby food, taro chips, taro bread (Moy and Nip

1983), and taro sorbet (Hong and Nip 1990). Taro has been reported to have 70-

80% starch (dry starch basis, dsb) (Payne et al 1938, Tu et al 1979) with small

granules (diameters between 1.4 and 5 ttm) (Amin 1955, Sugimoto et al 1986).

Taro also is rich in gums (mucilages). Up to 10.7% crude taro mucilages can be

extracted from taro corms and tubers with boiling water (Gaind et al 1968).

Purified gums (100 g) also are isolated from fresh taro corms (1 kg) (Taki et al

1972). Drumdrying properties and storage stability of tropical fruit-taro mixtures

were reported by Nip (1979a,b). The use of crude taro gums as binding and

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 32
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

emulsifying agents has been studied by Gaind et al (1968, 1969). Because of its

small granular size, taro starch has been considered a good filling agent for

biodegradable polyethylene film (Griffin and Wang 1983, Lim et al 1992) and as

a fat substitute. Some chemical and physical properties of several varieties of

taro starch, such as Dasheen, Bun-long, Engler, Ishikawa-wase, and

Takenokoimo, have been reported (Goering and DeHaas 1972, Higashihara et al

1975, Sugimoto et al 1986). Higher pasting and gelatinization temperatures of

taro starches compared with those of other small granular starches, such as cow

cockle, catchfly, and pigweed starch, were reported by Goering and DeHaas

(1972). Amylose contents of Ishikawa-wase and Takenokoimo taro starch were

reported as 13.5 and 10.8%, respectively (Sugimoto et al 1986). Developmental

changes in starch properties of taro starches were reported by Sugimoto et al

(1987). Taro starch was found more susceptible to pancreatin hydrolysis than

other tuber and root starches (Sugimoto et al 1979). In this study, five varieties

of taro flours, Bun-long, Dasheen, Hawaii Red (Lehua), Hawaii White, and Niu'e,

were investigated. Chemical structures and physical properties of the flours and

starches, including the starch contents and starch yields of the flours, amylose

contents and molecular sizes, amylopectin branch chain lengths, lipid and

phosphorus contents, morphology, Xray diffraction patterns of the starches,

protein contents (as nitrogen), thermal properties, retrogradation rates, and

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 33
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

pasting. (T. Kasemsuwan, and W. K. Nip, 2002)

In the study of E.V.Suresh Kumar and B.K.K.Vanientitled “Impact of Plastic

Leading Environmental Pollution”, we know that a living organism cannot live by

itself. Organisms interact among themselves. Hence, all organisms, such as

plants, animals and human beings, as well as the physical surroundings with

whom we interact, form a part of our environment. All these constituents of the

environment are dependent upon each other. Thus, they maintain a balance in

nature. As we are the only organisms try to modify the environment to fulfill our

needs; it is our responsibility to take necessary steps to control the

environmental imbalances. Environmental pollution is defined as the undesirable

change in physical, chemical and biological characteristics of our air, land and

water. As a result of over-population, rapid industrializations, and other human

activities like agriculture and deforestation etc., earth became loaded with

diverse pollutants that were released as byproducts

Plastic is now a regular material that is being used on a daily basis. Plastic

is everywhere either in the form of food containers, financial transactions

(Debit/Credit cards, plastic money), storage, baggage, stationary items,

electronic and electrical products and every foreseeable item that a human being

can think of. Plastic as a product is now like a regular feature of manufacturing,

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 34
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

consumption, and service activities. Plastic waste is a growing concern and the

drivers behind it look set to continue. Although recently there has been a slight

decrease in plastic production, this is unlikely to be maintained. Plastic is a highly

useful material and its applications are expected to increase as more new

products and plastics are developed to meet demands. The increased use and

production of plastic in developing and emerging countries is a particular

concern, as the sophistication of their waste management infrastructure may not

be developing at an appropriate rate to deal with their increasing levels of plastic

waste. Plastic pollution is defined as the accumulation of the different types of

plastic material on land, as well as in water bodies like rivers, oceans, canals,

lakes, etc. As a commodity, it is used on a large scale all around the world.

Basically, it is a synthetic polymer that consists of many organic and inorganic

compounds, and is mostly derived from petrochemicals like olefins. Plastic

generally degrades in about 500 - 1000 years, though we may never know its

actual degradation time, as this material has been in long-term use only since

the last century. During its manufacture, many hazardous chemicals are emitted

that can lead to dreadful diseases in humans as well as other animals. Ethylene

oxide, xylene, and benzene are some of the chemical toxins present in plastic,

which can have hazardous effects on the environment. It is not easy to dispose it

off, and it can cause permanent harm to living beings. Several additives found in

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 35
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

plastic such as phthalates, adipates, and even alkyl phenols have been

recognized as toxic materials. Vinyl chloride, which is used in the manufacturing

of PVC pipes, is classified as a carcinogen. (E.V.Suresh Kumar and B.K.K.Vani,

2014)

In the study of Rafael Auras, Bruce Harte, and Susan Selkeentitled

“Polylactides as Packaging Materials” , polylactide (PLA), a polymer derived from

lactic acid (2- hydroxy propionic acid), has been widely studied for use in medical

applications because of its bioresorbable and biocompatible properties in the

human body. Due to its higher cost, the initial focus of PLA as a packaging

material has been in high value films, rigid thermoforms, food and beverage

containers and coated papers. PLA may have packaging applications for a

broader array of products as modern and emerging production technologies

lower its production costs.

The production of PLA presents numerous advantages: it can be obtained

from a renewable agricultural source (corn); its production consumes quantities

of carbon dioxide; it provides significant energy savings; it is recyclable and

compostable; it can help improve farm economies and the physical and

mechanical properties can be manipulated through the polymer architecture.

Figure 1 shows a life cycle model for polylactide polymers. Early economic

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 36
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

studies showed that PLA is an economically feasible material to use as a

packaging polymer. Medical studies have shown that the level of lactic acid (LA)

that migrates to food from packaging containers is much lower than the amount

of LA used in common food ingredients. Therefore, polymers derived from lactic

acid may be good candidates for packaging applications. By providing consumers

with extra end-use benefits, such as avoiding paying a ‘‘green tax’’ in Germany or

meeting environmental regulations in Japan, PLA has become a growing

alternative as a packaging material for demanding markets. Currently, PLA is

being used as a food packaging polymer for short shelf life products with

common applications such as containers, drinking cups, sundae and salad cups,

overwrap and lamination films and blister packages. Moreover, new applications

include thermoformed PLA containers being used in retail markets for fresh fruit

and vegetables. (Rafael Auras, Bruce Harte, and Susan Selke, 2004)

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 37
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

CHAPTER 3

METHODS AND PROCEDURE

This chapter presents the method used in the study. It also describes the subject

of the study, the instrument used, the procedures, data gathered and the

statistical treatment of the data.

3.1 Research Design

The researchers utilized experimental research particularly the two group design,

which involves two comparable groups are employed as experimental and control

groups or two comparable groups are both experimental. The packaging paper

out of taro stem serves as the experimental group and the control group as the

packaging paper. The two groups were tested through its durability and

resistivity to heat and liquids.

3.2 Ingredients & Materials

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 38
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

The ingredients used in this study was taro stem. The following table shows the

ingredients and materials that was used in this experimental research.

Ingredients Quantity per Sample

Taro Stem 600 grams

Sodium Hydroxide
60 grams

Water
½ liter

Table 1. List of Ingredients used in the experiment.

Materials/Equipment Units

Basin 2

Pot 1

10x14 Silk Screen 1

Strainer 1

Blender 1

Table 2. List of Materials used in the experiment.

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 39
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
3.3
.ExbPupFhSdTg
Colectinfarsm
Methods & Procedures
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Figure 2. Methods used in making this experiment.

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
40
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Collection of taro stem

The full grown taro plant was abundantly, easily obtainable near roads and

woods. Using a machete or knife, the researchers cut off the stem to smaller

pieces. Moreover, the taros stem were washed rinsed so the latex of the sap

would be removed.

Extraction of taro fibers

It was started by heating the stove in high heat filled with a good amount of

water. The water was boiled for 10 minutes. Afterwards, 600 grams of taro stem

and 60 grams of sodium hydroxide were added. The color and the appearance of

the mixture suddenly changed after 20 minutes.

Purification of the paper

The taro stems were set aside for about 10 minutes. Subsequently, the mixture

was strained and rinsed. The taro stems were purified using a blender.

Formation and Solidification of the paper

The taro stem mixture was formed and flattened on a silk screen. Moreover, it

was dried for 3 days laying down on a flat surface.

Testing of Parameters

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 41
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

The durability was tested using a spring balance. The paper was hanged on the

hook of the spring balance. Therefore, once the paper got teared apart the

calibrated measurement was recorded. Resistivity to heat was tested using an

oven. Resistivity to liquids was tested using different substance such as base,

acid and water. For base substance, 1 part of baking soda and 1 part of water

was used. However, vinegar was used for the resistivity to acid.

3.4 Data Analysis

The following numerical value were used in interpreting the data based on its

resistivity to heat and liquids, guided with a scale of 1-4, 4 being the highest and

1 being the lowest. The following are the verbal interpretation for it: 4 – highly

damaged, 3 – moderately damaged, 2 – slightly damaged, 1 – not damaged.

T-test was used to determine the significant difference of the packaging

paper out of taro stem in terms of its durability.

If the computed value is greater than the tabular value at 0.05 margin of

error at 95% level of confidence there is a significant difference in the

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 42
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

treatments applied, hence null hypothesis is rejected.

If the computed value is less than the tabular value at 0.05 margin of error at

95% level of confidence there is no significant difference in the treatments

applied, hence null hypothesis is accepted.

The formula used was as follows:

x 1−x 2
√¿ ¿ ¿ ¿

Where in:

n – sample size

X1 – mean of sample

SD1 – standard deviation of sample 1

X2 – mean of sample 2

SD2 – standard deviation of sample 2

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 43
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

CHAPTER 4

PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA

This chapter contains the presentation, analysis and interpretation of data in

the study.

4.1 Components of taro stem

The taro stem has a rich deposit of starch which were used for the

construction of paper. The starch found inside the taro stem are dependable and

reliable when it comes to its durability. The taro stem also contains non-wood

fiber that is the most important ingredient in papermaking. (G.N. Agrios, 2005)

4.2 Effectiveness of taro stem packaging paper in terms of:

1. Strength/Durability

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 44
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
Replication 1 Replication 2 Replication 3 Replication 4 Replication 5

Taro Stem Commercialized

Fig. 3. Breaking point of packaging paper.

According to Roman E. Popil, Ph.D, The most fundamental and informative

physical evaluation for paper is probably that of the tensile test. Tensile testing is

useful to describe the elastomercity which are related to the fiber quality and

fiber bonding of the sample and is a combination of the sample failure strength

and stretch or strain to failure or breakage

The 2x2 samples were each tested by using a spring balance until breakage. The

results were recorded in the unit of Newton. The tensile strength of packaging

paper made out taro has obtained a result of 2.1N, 3N, 1.5N, 4N. 3.8N,

respectively while the commercialized packaging paper has obtained a result of

1.2N, 1.3N, 2N, 1.5N, 2.3N. The packaging paper made out of taro stem has

achieved its highest tensile strength test result of 4N, while the commercialized

packaging paper has attained 2.3N as its highest tensile strength result.

From the results, the packaging paper made out of taro stem is more

durable than the commercialized packaging paper.

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 45
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

2. Resistivity to Heat

Treatment (Control)

Weighted Mean Verbal Interpretation

100°C 2 Slightly Damaged


150°C 2 Slightly Damaged
200°C 3 Moderately Damaged
Treatment

(Experimental) Weighted Mean Verbal Interpretation

100°C 2 Slightly Damaged


150°C 2 Slightly Damaged
200°C 3 Moderately Damaged
Table. 3. Heat resistivity of experimental group in different treatments.

Sabit Adanur, Ph.D (1997) states that the moisture content of paper affect the

thermal properties like thermal conduction, combustion, and thermal

decomposition. The temperature and moisture can greatly affect paper

expansion and shrinkage significantly. While, thermal conductivity of paper

depends on appearance, density and absorbed moisture. Off the two, moisture

has more effect than temperature.

The resistivity to heat varies between 1-4, 4 as highly damaged and 1 as not

damaged. The experimental and the control group are tested in which variated

on different temperatures which were 100°C, 150°C and 200°C. It resulted that

both the control and experimental groups tested in temperature 100°C and

150°C obtained a weighted mean of 2 with a verbal interpretation of slightly

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 46
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

damaged. However, both the control and experimental groups tested in

temperature 200°C obtained a weighted mean of 3 which mean moderately

damaged.

Based on the results, the control groups and experimental were the same on

quality in terms of its resistivity to heat.

3. Resistivity to Liquids

Resistivity to water

Treatment (Control)

Weighted Mean Verbal Interpretation

1 hour 1 Not Damaged


2 hours 2 Slightly Damaged
3 hours 2 Slightly Damaged
Treatment

(Experimental) Weighted Mean Verbal Interpretation

1 hour 1 Not Damaged


2 hours 2 Slightly Damaged
3 hours 2 Slightly Damaged
Table. 4. Water resistivity of packaging paper in different soaking period.

D. Twede, Susan E. M. Selke (2014) states that water resistance is desirable

since it decreases the strength-reducing effects of moisture. Water resistance

can be measured by directly using the “soaking method”. It involves pouring

water over it and letting it soak for a certain period of time, and then comparing

its weight to that if the dry sample.

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 47
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Table 4 shows the water resistivity of the taro stem as packaging paper and the

commercialized packaging paper. Resistivity in water is the measure of the ability

of the material to resist on water. Water resistivity of the packaging paper was

determined by soaking the sample replication in the water for different time

periods. For the first hour, the results obtained by the packaging paper made out

of taro stem and commercialized packaging paper was 1 with a verbal

interpretation of not damaged. Moreover, the results obtained by the and

commercialized packaging paper packaging paper made out of taro stem was 2

which is determined as slightly damaged.

Based on the results, packaging paper made out taro stem and commercialized

packaging paper has no differences in terms of its resistivity to water.

Resistivity to acid.

Treatment (Control)

Weighted Mean Verbal Interpretation

1 hour 1 Not Damaged


2 hours 2 Slightly Damaged
Treatment

(Experimental) Weighted Mean Verbal Interpretation

1 hour 1 Not Damaged


2 hours 2 Slightly Damaged
Table. 5. Damage after submersion in acid.

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 48
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

According to L. Usher (2006) Using different solution in acids may progress in

good product, it may strengthen the paper or resize it.Any acid compound that is

added to a paper may easily help to make it a better and wiser product.

The table 5 shows the acidity of taro stem packaging paper. Acidity is the level of

acid in substance such as water, oil and wine. Acidity was determined by soaking

the packaging paper in vinegar. The experimental and control packaging paper

which was measured for 1 hour has resulted to a weighted mean of 1 and a

verbal interpretation of not damaged. As for the 2 hours of soaking period, it has

resulted to a weighted mean of 2 and a verbal interpretation of slightly

damaged.

Based on the results, packaging paper made out taro stem and commercialized

packaging paper has no differences in terms of its resistivity to acid.

Resistivity to base

Treatment (Control)

Weighted Mean Verbal Interpretation

1 hour 1 Not Damaged


2 hours 1 Not Damaged
Treatment

(Experimental) Weighted Mean Verbal Interpretation

1 hour 1 Not Damaged


2 hours 1 Not Damaged
Table. 6. Damage after submersion in base.

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 49
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Sabit Adnur, Ph. D (1997) stated that moisture affects its strength in terms of

tension. His study stated that making the paper’s texture more humid, makes it

more susceptible to breakage. In his study, he has shown that as the paper was

exposed in complete saturation, its strength drops to zero, thus it is important to

know for its applications such as packaging paper.

From the figure 6, it was shown that from the scale of 1-4 in whereas 1 is highly

damaged and whereas 1 is equal to no damage. Both the control group and the

experimental group are tested to be submerged with baking soda in which will

test its ability to remain its strength and its resistivity for 1 and 2 hours and in

these both test, both of the control and experimental group scored the weighted

mean of 1 which can be verbally translated into no damage.

From the results, in terms of its resistivity and quality, the experimental group

have met the standard or the same quality as the same as the control group.

4.3 Significant Differences

1. Strength

Samples Mean Mean Computed t- Tabular Decision

Difference value t-value

Control 8.3 Accept

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 50
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

6.1 0.971 2.306 Null

Hypothesis

Experimental 14.4

Table. 7. Data for t-value of strength.

Figure 7 shows the computed data for the t-value of strength. x₁ consists of the

data from the experimental group while the values of x₂ are from the control

group. The value of SD₁² is 141 while SD₂² is 55.26. The degrees of freedom is

8.

The tabular t-value is greater than the computed t-value with 5% level of

significance.

Therefore, null hypothesis is accepted. There is no significant difference

between the tensile strength of taro stem packaging paper and commercialized

packaging paper.

CHAPTER 5

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

This chapter contains the summary of findings, conclusions and

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 51
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

recommendations of the study.

5.1 Summary of Findings

1. Taro stem are known to be a great source of calcium and fiber that helps

to form the packaging paper and it also contains vitamins A and B6 and

minerals such as thiamin, copper, potassium, niacin, zinc, and iron.

2. Strength vary from the experimental with a weighted mean of 8.3 and

control with weighted mean of 14.4 that results in Accept Null Hypothesis.

3. Based on heat resistivity test, 1 as the highly damaged and 4 as the not

damaged. The experimental and control packaging paper on 100°C and

150°C, resulted to a weighted mean of 3 and verbal interpretation of

slightly damaged. Furthermore, 200°C has resulted to a weighted mean of

2 which is determined as moderately damaged. Based on the results, both

the experimental and control packaging paper can resist heat.

Resistivity to water vary from experimental and control packaging

paper which was measured for 1 hour, 2 hours and 3 hours. Based on the

results found, experimental and control packaging paper has no

differences in terms of its water resistivity.

5.2 Conclusions

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 52
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

1. Taro stem can be used as an alternative source of packaging

paper.

2. Sodium hydroxide can cook the fibers of the taro stem and it helps

bind the fibers to make a packaging paper.

3. In terms of its tensile strength, it shows that the experimental

product is way more substantial and durable than the control product.

There is a significant difference between control and experimental product.

5.3 Recommendations

1. The researchers recommend the consumers and vendors to use taro

stem as an alternative source of packaging paper.

2. The researchers recommend to consider the physical characteristics

aside from strength, heat resistivity and water resistivity in determining

the parameters of packaging paper.

3. The researchers recommend the future researchers to more develop

and enhance this study.

REFERENCES

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 53
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Literature

Plastic Waste: Ecological and Human Health Impacts. (2011) Retrieved from
http://ec.europa.eu/environment/integration/research/newsalert/pdf/
IR1_en.pdf

G. Thompson. (2008) Pollution and Toxins: Oceans. Retrieved from


http://www.worldcentric.org/about-compostables/traditional-plastic/
ocean-pollution

Sabit Adanur. (1997) Retrieved from Paper Machine Clothing:Key to the Paper
Making Process; Page 303, 406

Pollution Problems. (1917) Retrieved from Encyclopedia-World; Page 226-227

Packaging Paper. (2004) Retrieved from New Standard Encyclopedia, Volume 1;


Page 9-10

Roman E. Popil, Ph.D. (2006). Retrieved from Physical Testing of Paper; Page 23

Pongrácz, E. (2007) The Environmental Impacts of Packaging Retrieved from


https://www.researchgate.net/publication/229796182_The_Environmental
Impacts_of_Packaging

Diana Twede, Susan E. M. Selke. (2014) Retrieved from Cartons, Crates and
Corrugated Board, Second Edition; Page 263-264.

Thesis

Mare, Rorisang 'Maphoka (2009). Taro (colocasiaesculenta) yield and quality in


response to planting date and organic fertilisation . University of Kwazulu-
Natal, Durban, South Africa. Retrieved from
https://researchspace.ukzn.ac.za/handle/10413/2624

Maninder Kaur, PragatiKaushal, and Kawaljit Singh Sandhu. (2011). Studies on


physicochemical and pasting properties of Taro (Colocasiaesculenta) flour
in comparison with a cereal, tuber and legume flour. Retrieved from
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3550941/

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 54
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

AlirezaAshori. (2006). Nonwood fibers—A potential source of raw material in


papermaking. Retrieved from https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/10.1080/

Faith Faustine J. Sapupo. (2016). Banana Penducles as a potential source of


paper. Rosario National High School, Rosario, Batangas. Retrieved from
https://www.academia.edu/28955485/
_BANANA_PEDUNCLES_AS_POTENTIAL_SOURCE_OF

JercelRaro, Kimberly Del Agua, Kyla Alorro, Joel Rustom. (2015 ). Taro (Colocasia
Esculenta) as an Alternative Source of Biodegradable Plastic . Basud
National Highschool, Basud, Camarines Norte. Retrieved from
https://www.academia.edu/18133315/TARO_COLOCASIA_ESCULENTA_AS
_AN_ALTERNATIVE_SOURCE_OF_BIODEGRADABLE_PLASTIC

J. Jane, L. Shen, J. Chen, S. Lim, T. Kasemsuwan, and W. K. Nip. (2002).


Physical
and Chemical Studies of Taro Starches and Flours. Retrieved from
http://www.aaccnet.org/publications/cc/backissues/1992/documents/
69_528.pdf

N. M. dana Gopal, P.Phebe, E.V.Suresh Kumar, B.K.K.Vani. (2014). Impact of


Plastic Leading Environmental Pollution. Retrieved from
https://www.jchps.com/specialissues/Special%20issue3/20%20jchps
%20si3%20N.%20M.%20dana%20Gopal%2096-99.pdf

Rafael Auras, Bruce Harte, Susan Selke. (2004). Polylactides as Packaging


Materials. Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan. Retrieved
from
https://s3.amazonaws.com/academia.edu.documents/48864463/mabi.200
40004320160915-25472-1xgq85s.pdf?
AWSAccessKeyId=AKIAIWOWYYGZ2Y53UL3A&Expires=1539531081&Sign
ature=jr4Hq%2FcvLWtVII6N3SHoxRV5TTo%3D&response-content-
disposition=inline%3B%20filename
%3DAn_Overview_of_Polylactides_as_Packaging.pdf

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 55
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

APPENDICES

Appendix A

1st Trial

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 56
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

2nd Trial

3rd Trial

4th Trial

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 57
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Appendix B

Testing of Parameters

Water Resistivity

Experimental Control

Acidity

Experimental Control
Based

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 58
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Experimental Control

Heat Resistance

100 ֯C 150 ֯C

200 ֯C

PROFILE OF THE RESEARCHERS

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 59
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Full Name JOHN BENIDECT M. BAUTISTA

Email Address jbbautista03@gmail.com

Educational Attainment

Junior High School Batangas College of Arts and Sciences, Inc.


Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City
2015-Present

Grade School Batangas College of Arts and Sciences, Inc.


Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City
2012-2015

Academic and Non-Academic Achievements

Title/Description of the Achievement Third Honor


School Year SY 2013-2015

Scholarship/s Received

Title/Description of Scholarship ESC Grantee


School Year SY 2015-Present

Affiliation in School/Civic Organizations

Name of Organization YES-O Club


Position Member
School Year SY 2015-Present

Full Name ANGELO RAFAEL M. JAPLOS

Email Address angelomagpantay1015@gmail.com

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 60
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Educational Attainment

Junior High School Batangas College of Arts and Sciences, Inc.


Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City
2015-Present

Grade School Batangas College of Arts and Sciences, Inc.


Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City
2009-2015

Academic and Non-Academic Achievements

Title/Description of the Achievement Second Placer (BCAS Hip-Hop)


School Year SY 2009-2010

Title/Description of the Achievement Third Honor


School Year SY 2009-2015

Title/Description of the Achievement Third Placer (Swimming, Backstroke)


School Year SY 2016-2017

Title/Description of the Achievement With Honors


School Year SY 2017-2018

Title/Description of the Achievement Third Placer (Sci-Math Camp, Fusion)


School Year SY 2018-2019

Title/Description of the Achievement Third Placer (Battle of the Bands)


School Year SY 2018-2019

Scholarship/s Received

Title/Description of Scholarship ESC Grantee


School Year SY 2015-Present

Affiliation in School/Civic Organizations

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 61
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Name of Organization YES-O Club


Position Member
School Year SY 2015-Present

Name of Organization Junior Math Wizards Club


Position Member
School Year SY 2015-Present

Name of Organization Varsity Club


Position Member
School Year SY 2015-Present

Full Name MAXINE H. MARUNDAN

Email Address maxinemarundan135@gmail.com

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 62
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Educational Attainment

Junior High School Batangas College of Arts and Sciences, Inc.


Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City
2015-Present

Grade School Batangas College of Arts and Sciences, Inc.


Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City
2009-2015

Academic and Non-Academic Achievements

Title/Description of the Achievement Third Honor


School Year SY 2009-2015

Title/Description of the Achievement With Honors


School Year SY 2017-2018

Title/Description of the Achievement Third Placer (Swimming, Medley Relay)


School Year SY 2015-2016

Scholarship/s Received

Title/Description of Scholarship ESC Grantee


School Year SY 2015-Present

Affiliation in School/Civic Organizations

Name of Organization Varsity Club


Position Member
School Year SY 2015-2016

Name of Organization YES-O Club


Position Member
School Year SY 2015-Present

Name of Organization Junior Math Wizards Club


Position Member

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 63
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

School Year SY 2015-Present

Name of Organization Mabikas


Position Layout Artist
School Year SY 2017-Present

Full Name REYNALDO P. UMALI III

Email Address reinarudoumariru@gmail.com

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 64
Website: www.bcas.edu.p
BATANGAS COLLEGE OF
ARTS AND SCIENCES, INC.

Educational Attainment

Junior High School Batangas College of Arts and Sciences, Inc.


Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City
2015-Present

Grade School Batangas College of Arts and Sciences, Inc.


Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City
2009-2015

Academic and Non-Academic Achievements

Title/Description of the Achievement Third placer (On the spot ballpoint


drawing)
School Year SY 2009-2015; 2017-2018

Scholarship/s Received

Title/Description of Scholarship ESC Grantee


School Year SY 2015-Present

Affiliation in School/Civic Organizations

Name of Organization YES-O Club


Position Member
School Year SY 2015-Present

Name of Organization English Speakers club


Position Member
School Year SY 2015-Present

Name of Organization Bakas Arts club


Position Member
School Year SY 2018-Present

Banaybanay Concepcion, Lipa City, Batangas 4217


Contact #: (043)756-1232 main / (043)784-6071 annex 65
Website: www.bcas.edu.p

You might also like