Professional Documents
Culture Documents
*
Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, CINEC,
Millennium Drive, IT Park, Malabe, Sri Lanka
2
Yasantha.samarawickrama@cinec.edu
Abstract— Since recent past world researchers are in a quest to achieve sustainable development.
find the best possible alternative fuel to cater for the uprising It is very much eminent from Fig. 1 since 1990, the
global energy demand and to find a solution for the most demand for natural gas is growing at a much faster rate when
threatening issue of 21st century, Global warming. In these compared to the other two main competitors, oil & coal.
circumstances, natural gas can play a vital role since it is
considered as the cleanest fossil fuel which consists of high
When considering the global energy demand by 2030, gas
energy conversion efficiencies. This paper will investigate demand grows by 2% while the total energy demand grows
extensively, the usage of natural gas as an alternative fuel in only by 1.2% making it the fastest growing primary energy
both spark-ignition and compressed-ignition engines and will source in the future [1]. Therefore, it is obvious that natural
further discuss, why it is a promising alternative fuel for gas is an ideal alternative.
automotive applications in Sri Lanka.
II. NATURAL GAS AS AN ALTERNATIVE FUEL
Keywords— Natural Gas, Engine Performance, Alternative Natural gas is a fossil fuel which is obtained from gas
Fuel, Sri Lanka. wells or extracted together with crude oil production.
Natural gas composition is mostly of Methane (88.9 % CH4)
I. INTRODUCTION [2]. Other hydrocarbons such as ethane, propane and smaller
Today we live in an era where the global energy demand quantities of nitrogen, oxygen, carbon dioxide, helium,
is skyrocketing due to increased growth of population, sulphur compounds, water vapour may also be present when
advancement of industries and continuous increment in delivering through pipeline systems. Composition may vary
transportation needs. As a result, planet earth has been the according to the source of natural gas. Due to the high-
ultimate victim due to adverse effects of burning fossil fuel octane number of natural gas, engine operates smoothly
to generate required power in various industries including without any knocking. This is one of the safest and cleanest
transportation. Therefore, for developing countries like Sri transport fuels available and it is lighter than air. Natural gas
Lanka, it is high time to find alternative fuel, invest in requires 5 – 15 % concentration in air for combustion to
developing proper infrastructure and bring up relevant occur and its ignition temperature is about 6000 C. Not only
regulations which could reduce environmental hazards and the tail pipe emissions but also the emissions during
production are very low.
There are two methods to store natural gas as a fuel in
automobiles.
• Compressed Natural Gas (CNG)
• Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG)
Compressed Natural Gas is the most common method of
storing natural gas in automobiles (NGV – Natural Gas
Vehicle). It is normally stored in high pressure metal
cylinders [3] at about 20 – 25 MPa (200 – 250 bar).
Different types of metal cylinders are available with full or
partiall wrappings made of glass, aramid or carbon to suit
different vehicles. CNG is measured and sold in kilograms
or cubic meters. They are also measured in Gasoline per
gallon equivalent (GGE) or Diesel per gallon equivalent
(DGE). One cubic meter of CNG approximately contains
38.3 MJ/m3 [4] which is almost similar to the energy content
of diesel per litre, i.e. 38.3 MJ/L. If the fuel tank capacity is
as same as in a diesel, due to the lesser energy density NGVs
will have to refuel much often.
Liquefied Natural Gas is natural gas stored at cryogenic
temperatures. These are stored in metal cylinders with
Fig. 1 World energy demand with respect to the type of fuel [1] substantial insulation that will maintain relevant cryogenic
conditions. Typical cryogenic temperatures are -1200 to - • According to a report outlining a strategy for the
1700 C (-1840 to -2740 F) but this can vary depending on the development of a natural gas industry in Sri Lanka
precise composition. The advantage of liquefaction over by the Sri Lanka Carbon Fund (Pvt) Ltd, NG could
compression is that the fuel is at a higher energy density. be sold to vehicles at a very competitive price, the
Therefore, LNG offers an energy density of approximately cost per Mega Joule of NG will be only LKR 1.85.
25 MJ/L [4] which is comparable with diesel and petrol fuels. Even after taxes, profit margins, transport and
Also, NGVs with LNG fuel will have an extended range infrastructure costs are added in, it is still cheaper
than CNG fuel reducing refuelling intervals. than gasoline [5].
Refuelling of natural gas vehicles can be done at a • CNG is a safe fuel and therefore it can even be used
dispenser similar to diesel or petrol fuel. This will also take as a bi-fuel as shown in Fig. 2.
the same amount of refuelling time as a gasoline or petrol
vehicle. Only disadvantage of LNG is that it’s higher cost on
producing cylinders to store liquefied natural gas and
maintaining cryogenic conditions. Another reason for
limited popularity of LNG usage is that, companies or
governments have to invest a higher capital on building
stations for dispensing, transportation and other
infrastructure.
B. Cylinder Temperature
ODE
14.5 DE
ODE
CNG
14.5 DE
CNG
Fig. 3 Cylinder pressure of diesel engine convert to natural gas engine [7]
December 2017
October 2017 The CINEC
The CINEC Journal 2017
Journal 2017
24
Investigation into Natural Gas as an Alternative Fuel for Automotive Applications in Sri Lanka 4
C. Torque Performance
The maximum friction torque, Fig. 7 Brake torque of NG engine compared to diesel engine [7]
D. Power Performance of diesel engine to natural gas engine could decrease the
friction power up to 1500 rpm and increase at higher engine
speeds. This is mainly due to specific properties of the two
fuels. Natural gas as a fuel, exhibits less lubrication
properties when compared to diesel. Diesel as a liquid fuel,
performs well as a lubrication to reduce friction at high
speeds.
The maximum indicated power of diesel engine converted The maximum brake power,
to natural gas engine was reduced by 40.7%. The percentage • Original diesel engine – 6.6 kW at 3500 rpm
deviation of indicated power of natural gas engine compared
• Modified diesel engine – 6.54 kW at 3500 rpm
to diesel engine was increased with increasing engine speed.
• Natural gas engine – 3.87 kW at 2500 rpm
Therefore, it was concluded that the natural gas engines are
not suitable to run at high engine speeds, but its power
The maximum brake power of diesel engine converted to
performance is very good at medium engine speeds.
natural gas engine was reduced by 41.374%. This deviation
percentage was increased with increasing engine speed and it
is mainly due to the reduction of brake torque with
increasing speed (Fig. 7). Therefore, it was concluded that
conversion of diesel engine to natural gas engine could
reduce the overall brake power.
December 2017
October 2017 The CINEC
The CINEC Journal 2017
Journal 2017
26
Investigation into Natural Gas as an Alternative Fuel for Automotive Applications in Sri Lanka 6
December 2017
October 2017 The CINEC
The CINEC Journal 2017
Journal 2017
28
Investigation into Natural Gas as an Alternative Fuel for Automotive Applications in Sri Lanka 8
REFERENCES
[1] Amir-Hasan Kakaee, Amin Paykani, “Research and Development of
Natural-gas Fueled Engines in Iran,” Renewable and Sustainable
Energy Reviews, 2013, pp. 805–821.
[2] O. S. Abianeh, M. Mirsalim, F Ommi, “Combustion Development of
a Bi-Fuel Engine,” International Journal of Automotive Technology,
2009, vol. 10(1), pp. 17–25.
Alternative fuel systems Inc. (2015). What’s the difference between
CNG, LNG, LPG and Hydrogen? [Online], Available:
http://www.afsglobal.com/faq/gas-comparisons.html
[3] NGV Global (2015). Natural Gas [online],
Available: http://www.iangv.org/natural-gas-vehicles/natural-gas/
[4] Sri Lanka Carbon Fund (Pvt) Ltd (2014). Natural Gas – New Energy
Resource in Sri Lanka [online], Available:
Fig. 19 Consumption of fuel under NG2 scenario [5] http://www.prdssrilanka.com/pdfs/InitialNaturalGasUtilizationRoad
Map-SriLanka.20151005.pdf
[5] P. Lucas (2011), Mercedes starts sales of natural gas vehicle [online],
Contact Hire and Leasing, Available:
V. CONCLUSIONS http://www.contracthireandleasing.com/car-leasing-news/mercedes-
From the above analysis and review, it is very clear that starts-sales-of-natural-gas-vehicle-3/
natural gas is a viable, greener, cheaper alternative fuel that [6] R.A. Bakar, K. Kadirgama, M. M. Rahman, K. V. Sharma,
“Application of Natural Gas for Internal Combustion Engines”
can be effectively utilized in transport sector in Sri Lanka. Advances in Natural Gas Technology, Dr. Hamid Al-Megren (Ed.),
Further, analyzing the engine performance data it can be ISBN: 978-953-51-0507-7, In Tech, 2012, Available:
concluded that, conversion of diesel operated engines into http://www.intechopen.com/books/advances-in-natural-
natural gas engines showcase promising results in low to gastechnology/application-of-natural-gas-for-internal-combustion-
engines
medium speeds while having some compromises at high [7] M. M. Movahed, B. H. Tabrizi, M. Mirsalim, “Experimental
speeds. But it must be thoroughly understood that, investigation of the concomitant injection of gasoline and CNG in a
commercial vehicles and public transportation vehicles only turbocharged spark ignition engine,” Energy Conversion and
Management, 2014, pp. 126 – 136.
require adequate performance in low – medium speed range.
[8] M. Jha, A. Singh, R. K. Tyagi, M. K. Verma, “Comparative Study of
Therefore, it is eminent that, with the adoption of proper Exhaust Emission of Commonly Used Fuel in an Internal
conversion accessories, natural gas engines can achieve Combustion Engine,” Journal of Environmental Science, Computer
good performance, low emissions and significant reliability. Science and Engineering Technology, 2013, vol. 2(1), pp. 52-56.
[9] T. L. Gunaruwan, “Energy and Environment: Transport Policy
It should be also noted that, current researchers have already
Perspective. Seminar on Energy and Environment Sustenance,”
proven the fact that, not only the conversion of diesel Energy Forum and The Centre for Policy Analysis, Colombo, 2014
vehicles but also natural gas can be used in spark ignition
engines effectively.
Sri Lanka as a developing country, should invest now to
develop infrastructure necessary for storage and distribution
of natural gas and fortify infrastructure relevant to extraction
of natural gas from deep sea off Kalpitiya Peninsula while
expanding the exploration activities in search for other
available gas pockets. The government should also enhance
research capacity in this specific area since this can make a
huge impact on the economic development of the country in
the foreseeable future by saving billions of rupees invested
on importing petroleum oil. Furthermore, due to reduction of
emission of polluting gases such as NOx, CO2, CH4, N2O
and particulate matter, it will eventually reduce health
hazards on general public caused by these dangerous
emissions.
If current plans are to be applied without any delay, Sri
Lanka will sooner be able to provide natural gas at a very
low-price tag comparable to diesel fuel. This will surely
encourage both the consumers and vehicle importers to bring
down brand-new natural gas vehicles and increase the
popularity of these vehicles in Sri Lanka. The government
can introduce easy payment schemes or VAT reductions to
promote the usage of natural gas vehicles. In the meantime,
Sri Lanka will be able to achieve sustainable development
by reducing the carbon foot print on this beautiful planet
earth.