Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LBGN
LBGN
Green Nudges
x
x
40 Nudges
to Spark
Sustainable
Behaviour on
Campus
© United Nations Environment Programme and GRID- Reproduction Acknowledgements
Arendal, 2020 This publication may be reproduced in whole or in This publication was commissioned by the United
part and in any form for educational or non-profit Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) under the
ISBN: 978-82-7701-198-1 purposes without special permission from the direction of Mari Nishimura, supported by Carina
copyright holder, provided acknowledgement of the Mütschele and supervised by Sam Barratt. Jessica
Recommended citation: source is made. The United Nations Environment Barker and Toby Park of the Behavioural Insights
United Nations Environment Programme, GRID- Programme would appreciate receiving a copy of any Team were the authors. Lisa Hymas of GRID-
Arendal and Behavioural Insights Team (2020). publication that uses this publication as a source. No Arendal was an editor and project coordinator. Trista
The Little Book of Green Nudges: 40 Nudges to Spark use of this publication may be made for resale or for Patterson of GRID-Arendal was an editor. Illustrations
Sustainable Behaviour on Campus. Nairobi and any other commercial purpose whatsoever without and graphics by Studio Atlantis (Elisa Campagnaro
Arendal: UNEP and GRID-Arendal. prior permission in writing from the United Nations and Nieves López). Copy-editing by Guendalina De
Environment Programme. Luigi (GRID-Arendal). Layout by GRID-Arendal. We
thank the participants of the Behavioural Economics
Disclaimer Workshop that was held in Nairobi in 2019. We also
The designations employed and the presentation thank experts who reviewed this publication, in
of the material in this publication do not imply the particular, Michelle Fadelli (UNEP), Garrette Clark
expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part (UNEP), Melissa Goodall (Yale University), Julie
of the United Nations Environment Programme or Newman (MIT), Charlotte Bonner (SOS), Iain Patton
GRID-Arendal concerning the legal status of any (EAUC), John Robinson (University of Toronto),
country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or Vanessa Timmer (One Earth), Debra Rowe (US
concerning delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. Partnership for ESD), Tim Carter (Second Nature),
Moreover, the views expressed do not necessarily Orlando Sáenz (ARIUSA), Gloria Ordóñez (UNEP),
represent the decision or the stated policy of Suchada Chaisawadi (KMUTT), Fengting Li (CGUN/
the United Nations Environment Programme or Tongji University) and Jessica-Qian Jia (Tongji
GRID-Arendal, nor does citing of trade names or University), as well as 45 universities around the
Illustrations and icons by Studio Atlantis. commercial processes constitute endorsement. world that contributed case studies about nudging.
The Little Book of
Green Nudges
40 Nudges to Spark
Sustainable Behaviour on Campus
FOREWORD 4
WHAT ARE GREEN NUDGES? 6
WHY USE NUDGES? 7
WHO CAN USE GREEN NUDGES? 8
HOW TO NUDGE: GO EAST 9
MAKE IT EASY 10
MAKE IT ATTRACTIVE 16
MAKE IT SOCIAL 22
MAKE IT TIMELY 28
FIVE STEPS TO MAKE YOUR NUDGE A SUCCESS 34
CHECKLIST FOR SUCCESSFUL NUDGES 41
ENDNOTES 42
RESOURCES AND REFERENCES 44
GREEN NUDGES AT A GLANCE 46
WHICH GREEN NUDGES WILL YOU USE? 47
FOREWORD
Students around the world want the places applicants (or their parents) would like to Behavioural science shows that a simple
in which they study to reflect their values. take a college or university’s commitment “nudge” towards everyday greener decisions
Increasingly, that means taking a firmer stand to the environment into consideration when is a powerful spur to environmental action
on environmental issues and the climate crisis. choosing where to study.2 Calls for divestment for students and other campus community
from fossil fuels are showing how students members. Techniques such as gentle
We have seen this in a recent National Union are pushing their universities to make major persuasion, changing the framing of choices,
of Students survey that found 86 per cent of changes to address the climate crisis. And resetting default options or harnessing social
first-year students in the UK want their higher this drumbeat calling for action is only influence can all lead towards sustainable
education institutions to actively incorporate getting louder. conduct and an eco-friendly campus.
and promote sustainable development.1 This
was further reinforced in a Princeton Review Change is clearly needed, but change doesn’t Now is the perfect time for trying green
survey that found two-thirds of student have to mean radical upheaval per se. nudges, as higher education institutions are
redesigning systems and routines in the wake
of the emergence of COVID-19. This is a timely
moment when students and staff can be
encouraged to consider new behaviours and
higher education leaders can consider how to
build back better.
Many people intend to eat healthily, save Nudges are often cheap to implement, as
money or live more sustainably, but don’t follow they frequently involve changing the way
through with their intentions. This is partly choices are presented instead of rebuilding
because we prioritize our short-term desires infrastructure or buying new equipment.
(chocolate cake or a new pair of shoes) over Nudges that help to conserve resources can
long-term aspirations. It’s also partly because in fact save universities money. For example,
our behaviour is unconsciously affected by the a small university department in the UK could
physical and social context in which the easy or save more than £1,000 per year by turning
default choices are often not the most healthy, off its lights every night,5 and a nudge to help
economical or sustainable. Nudges can make achieve that goal could be very low-cost,
people’s lives easier, happier and more rewarding such as printing reminder notices to put up
because they help people align their daily at light switches.
decisions with the values they already have.
Nudges are needed now
Nudges can work better than raising
awareness With public concern about climate change
and the environment at an all-time high,
Because there is a gap between what we intend there is clearly no absence of motivation for
to do and what we actually do, it is generally sustainability. But it can be hard to move
more effective to focus, as nudging does, people from motivation to concrete action,
on changing behaviour directly, rather than especially when sustainable choices are more
simply raising awareness. Awareness and complicated or inconvenient, or require us to
intentions still matter, as they make behaviour go against defaults and established norms.
change easier, but they are rarely enough This is where you can help – your nudges
alone: although many people say they want to can remove barriers and facilitate everyday
consume more sustainably, they don’t do so sustainable behaviours.
in practice.4 This means that while a poster
campaign on campus about the environmental
impacts of driving might help people learn
about the issue, a nudge offering more bike
parking spaces and fewer car parking spaces
has a higher likelihood of reducing car usage.
Evidence that it’s effective: Defaulting customers into a renewable electricity How? At cafeterias, coffee shops and catered
tariff in Germany led to a 10-times increase in the number of people on that tariff.
7 events on campus, let people know that they are
expected to bring and use their own reusable
Why it works: People tend to stick with the default choice or the status quo. cups and cutlery. Only provide disposable cups
and cutlery if people specifically request them.
This is because we don’t engage consciously with many of our daily decisions, or
we lack the motivation to take a different course of action. Defaults are also often Who might be involved? Campus catering
perceived as a “safe bet” or an implicit recommendation. coordinators
make
the more
sustainable Make the most sustainable meal the
option, such as default choice
a plant-based
dish, the How? At catered events on campus, make the
default more sustainable option, such as a plant-based
dish, the default. If attendees want another
option, such as red meat, they must pre-order it
(the opposite of the current norm, which often
requires people to pre-order plant-based food).
Hold
free
bike repair Make it easier to cycle around campus Introduce applications for parking cars on
events on campus
campus How? Offer bike-sharing programs at convenient
locations on campus, or offer students hassle- How? Require people wishing to drive to campus
free or discounted access to municipal or private to register their cars or apply for a parking
bike-sharing schemes. Hold free bike repair permit, even if doing so is free. Increase the
events on campus. Create well-marked, safe friction further by having permits last only for a
cycling routes. Provide showers and convenient day or a week, so that people have to reapply.
cycle storage.
Who might be involved? Campus parking
Who might be involved? Students, university administration
administrators
Evidence that it’s effective: Diners were more likely to choose sustainable
food options in British and Swedish university canteens when these options
were listed at the top of the menu, made more visible, or made more available
relative to other options.11,12
CASE STUDY
At Dalhousie University, Canada, students racks, bike pumps, bus shelters and electric
helped the Office of Sustainability analyse the vehicle infrastructure. Their tips for successful
number and types of waste bins and signage implementation include consultation and Make sustainable options more prominent
on campus. Based on this research, students engagement with all parties involved, including
and staff removed 4,500 individual rubbish users; creating business cases to identify and How? Place foods that are more sustainable at
bins, added more than 3,000 recycling and secure funding; agreeing on a maintenance plan the front of fridges or counters, at eye level and
compost bins, and placed more than 4,000 with custodial staff and facilities management; near checkouts. Put recycling bins in front of
signs and stickers. In addition, the university and creating opportunities for students to rubbish bins.
used choice architecture to encourage research issues on campus and showcase
sustainable transport, by installing more bike how their findings are having a real impact. Who might be involved? Campus catering
coordinators, campus building managers
CASE STUDY
Make recycling bins eye-catching
Recycling is eye-catching at Mahidol account. The university’s IT division created
University, Thailand, where a “recyclable software for the project, and the “banks” How? Use design and cues in the physical
waste bank” project has created recycling have now been expanded beyond campus environment to draw people’s attention to
points that mimic banks’ transaction and to local elementary schools. The biggest recycling bins rather than rubbish bins, for
withdrawal systems. When people deposit barrier to implementation was raising example by painting them conspicuous colours
recyclable items, they get a bank statement awareness of the banks, so the university or placing footstep markers leading up to them.
showing the value of those items, and they puts effort into promoting them to new
can withdraw this in cash or save it in their students and staff. Who might be involved? Campus building
managers
Who might be involved? Campus building Who might be involved? Campus catering
managers, university administrators coordinators, food companies
Personalize messages
Why it works: People tend to find messages based on pride, fun and
humour more compelling than those based on guilt. People are also
driven by desires to save money, have fun, get healthy and be social.
CASE STUDY
The University of California, Davis, US, has
a green workplace certification programme
to give public recognition to sustainable
offices and labs on campus.
CASE STUDY
Karatina University, Kenya, which recently
branded itself as a “Green University”,
has established a Green Innovations
competition week, where teams of
students submit projects that address
environmental issues through social and
technological innovations, with prizes for
the winning teams.
How? When promoting positive behaviours, avoid How? In messaging campaigns, make sure How? Frame campaigns in terms of identities
terms associated with narrow identities that the sender is someone the recipient identifies that people aspire to or groups they belong
could make people feel excluded. For example, with or is likely to feel positively about. For a to. For example, the “Don’t mess with Texas!”
avoid words such as “vegetarian” or “vegan” student audience, appropriate messengers messaging campaign in the US reduced litter
to describe food on menus (try “field-grown” could be fellow students or former students, by harnessing a group identity that Texans are
instead),24 and don’t frame bicycling as an especially if they are well known. Ensuring proud of.
activity done by “cyclists”, as this may alienate that characteristics of messengers reflect the
certain groups, including some women.25 target audience (for example, in terms of gender, Who might be involved? Campus sustainability
ethnicity and age) is key to appeal to different coordinators, student sustainability groups
Who might be involved? University parts of the populace.
administrators, campus sustainability
coordinators, student sustainability groups, Who might be involved? Campus sustainability
campus catering managers coordinators, student sustainability groups
CASE STUDY
Five students at Aalto University, Finland,
set up a food-sharing group that enables
distribution of leftovers on campus,
such as from meetings and parties, for
free. They were mentored by the Aalto
Ventures Program during its flagship
“start-up experience” course, and started
their initiative by collecting and analysing
kitchen waste on campus to gain insight
Provide incentives to encourage Distribute and share into what food was being thrown away.
peer referral leftovers They set up the food-sharing group without
any funding, and all marketing happened
How? When holding sustainability events on How? Reduce food waste by tapping into via word of mouth. The founders thought
campus, build support and engagement by people’s social networks and desire to help the biggest barrier was encouraging the
giving attendees a small perk if they bring along others. Facilitate giving away leftover food by initial members to join, but now they have
a friend. setting up a campus-wide food-sharing group, or a growing membership of more than 1,000
encouraging sign-ups to an existing food-sharing people. So far, the group has prevented
Who might be involved? Campus sustainability app. Encourage campus cafeterias and food more than 7,000 kilograms of food from
coordinators, student sustainability groups shops to give away leftovers or sell them cheaply, going to waste. Their tips for success are
or use an existing app that facilitates this. to reach out to supermarkets, restaurants
and student associations on campus
Who might be involved? Campus sustainability and ask them to share leftovers, and to
coordinators, student sustainability groups, regularly seek feedback from users.
campus catering coordinators
Evidence that it’s effective: Hotel guests were more likely to reuse towels
when they committed to do so at check-in.27 Consumers were more willing to buy
energy-efficient washer-dryers when given information at the point of purchase
about the lifetime running costs, as this made the future savings more salient
in the short term, offsetting the higher immediate purchase costs of efficient
appliances.28
Why it works: The complexities of life and our limited willpower often get in the Encourage pre-ordering of catered meals
way of our good intentions. We are therefore more likely to act on those intentions
if we lock ourselves into a commitment in advance, such as signing up to run a How? In catered halls of residence and at
university events, ask attendees to choose
marathon. We feel more strongly about consequences that are more immediate,
food in advance, when immediate gratification
so we are more likely to follow through if the benefits are emphasized in the is not an issue and people tend to favour long-
present and the costs are pushed into the future. term intentions for being healthier and more
sustainable. This could be combined with other
nudges towards plant-based food.
How? Rather than pushing people to make large How? Make the financial benefits of public
changes to their behaviour, ask them to commit transport more immediate by providing interest-
to making cumulative small changes. For free loans for students and staff to buy season
example, they could start by cycling to campus passes or tickets. Once people have bought
one day per week this term, and increase to two a season pass, they will be more likely to use
days per week next term, and so on. public transport.
Evidence that it’s effective: People were four times more likely to
sign up to a new bike-sharing scheme when they had recently moved
into the area (because they were forming new routines in their lives)
compared to when existing residents just had a bike docking station
installed near their home.29
How? Provide locations or hold events where How? Arrange times for collective action, such
students can donate or sell textbooks when as an energy-tariff switching day for students
CASE STUDY
they have finished classes, or give away living in their own accommodation. Introduce
household items when they are moving out short-term campus-wide changes, such as asking The University of British Columbia, Canada,
of accommodation. The university or student people to cycle to campus one day each month, or runs a “Seasonal Shutdown” campaign,
groups could sell these items the following term. encouraging people to eat plant-based food during encouraging campus department buildings
one week, to build support for larger change. to turn off and unplug electronics during the
Who might be involved? Campus sustainability winter break. This includes the additional
coordinators, student sustainability groups, Who might be involved? Campus sustainability nudge of providing a checklist (see “Provide
campus store managers coordinators, student sustainability groups, checklists” section on the following page).
campus catering coordinators
How? Hold events at which people can get their How? As part of an energy-saving campaign to
bikes fixed for use the following term, helping encourage people to turn off computer monitors
them plan ahead and be ready to cycle in the and unplug chargers, help people follow through
future. by putting reminder messages on computers
Hold and powerstrips to highlight the costs of
events at Who might be involved? Campus sustainability wasting electricity.
which people coordinators, student sustainability groups,
can get their technical staff Who might be involved? Campus building
bikes fixed for use managers
the following
term
CASE STUDY
The University of Copenhagen, Denmark,
created a nudge to reduce heating loss
from open windows by hanging turnable
cards on them, with a red side to remind
people to close windows and a green side
to show when windows have been closed.
1 Choose your
target behaviour
Be specific: Nudges are more effective Aim for impact: Some behaviours have more
when they target a specific behaviour and of an impact on the environment than others.
a specific audience. Instead of “Promote For example, preventing unsustainable
more sustainable food choices among consumption (e.g. reducing single-use plastics)
students”, a better target could be “Reduce is generally better than trying to mitigate its
red meat consumption by students in campus effects (e.g. encouraging recycling). Try to
cafeterias”. Remember to target an action, not focus on behaviour change that will make the
an attitude or awareness. biggest difference.
The Little Book of Green Nudges explains how to implement these and other nudges, and how to create
new nudges tailored to your own campus community.