Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Premjit Pv, BTech Civil Engineering, Cochin University Of Science and What is the difference between a beam and a
Technology (2000) column?
Answered Aug 27
In a hospital building, can I have a span of 15 meters
Column size and beam depth cannot be decided based on span alone.
between two columns? If yes, what would the column
size and beam depth required be?
It depends on many aspects including its position in the structure,loads and many
other parameters.If it was so easy to decide the size based on span,there was no need Is it possible to have a beam spanning 21 metres? If
so, what would be the size of that beam?
of civil & structural engineers! Having said this minimum depth of beam can be
decided based on the deflection requirement that is based on span/depth ratio. The How should I assume the initial size of RCC columns
ration is 7,20 and 26 for cantelever,simply supported and continuous beams and beams of a building by the thumb rule?
respectively.Note that this ratio What is the beam depth and column diameter for a 10
metre span between the columns?
is before considering the benefit of rebars controlling deflections. For more info and
for structural design courses,visit www.civilera.com /ETABS Trainers in What should be the column size and beam depth for a
span of 10 metres between two columns?
Bangalore/Learn from
1 the leaders
Home Answer Notifications Search Quora Ask Question
What is the structural difference between a beam and
or www.design-dimension.com a column?
1. Beam Design
Question Stats
In beams generally,we start with deflection criteria, as the beam resist load in form of
11 Public Followers
bending moment by deflection. So the first criteria is always deflection criteria.
13,116 Views
Edits
For Simply supported= 20
where the numerical values represents the (span/effective depth) ratio. Above values
are valid only when span is less than or equal to 10m. From this criteria you will get a
trial value of depth, from there assuming a proper grade of concrete and steel, you can
calculate Moment of Resistance of the beam. But remember for comparing MOR, you
should know either the overburden load along with dead load of structure or the gross
moment acting on the beam.
As a trial value you will get an effective depth of 400mm, but i can bet you that will
fail in the first trial only, you will need a effective depth of around 600–800mm for
the span of 8m. Moreover it may be singly or doubly reinforced beam depending upon
the total bending moment need to be resisted.
2.Column
It is a most complex component of a building, you need a lot of data, tables, curves
and checks then only you can design a column, because it need to carry a large axial
load, and the loading may be eccentric or may not, so for that we have to counter-
check, axial bending and biaxial bending. You will also need SPD curves. I’ll
generalise the procedure.
Calculate the total axial load need to be transferred through one column.
As per the required length of column, check for type of member, i.e.
Strut,Short column, or long column. Try adopting short column.
Find effective length of the column, check for unsupported length of the
column.
Check slenderness ratio, it should be less than 12, for short column.
If biaxial bending also exists, then either design for it or try to nullify the
biaxial bending by increasing the size of column so that tension core
broadens.
Upvote 3 Downvote
Promoted by Matmatch
Find, evaluate, and source the best metals for your projects.
Explore a free database with thousands of metals and properties, including
aluminum, copper, and steel.
Beam
Initial assumption for deciding the section of the beam is based on deflection control
criteria.
As per IS:456 for a continuous beam, the span to effective depth ratio should be less
than 20.
Beam depth>span/20
thus for 8 m span you would need a beam at least of 400 mm effective depth.
Considering main reinforcement dia. of 20 mm and cover to main reinforcement to be
20 mm.
This is just an initial estimate. Now you would have to check the beam for
Bending moment and Shear Force.
Column
For column the process is much more complex as it starts with deciding the shape of
the column based on the structural configuration, number of beams supported by the
column etc.
4.8k Views · Answer requested by Shashank Saxena
Upvote Downvote
1.1k Views
Upvote Downvote