Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hugo Guillen
Week Four
One of our main tasks as evaluators is to make sure teachers are following the district
expectations for student learning and addressing student needs. During the preconference I would
start by asking the teacher to, “Please describe the student in your class and what IEP
accommodations they have in their IEP’s.” I would expect the teacher to be able to readily describe
the unique student needs of their class. Afterwards, I would ask, “What the objectives are for the
lesson and how are you going be able to measure successful outcomes?” I would expect the teacher
to have a clearly defined outcome that is student centered. A proficient teacher should be able to
detail what a “successful” lesson will look like in an objective manner and communicate that to the
students as well.
Next, I would ask, “What district and state standards are being addressed in this lesson?”
The teacher should be clearly able to bring up the standards that are driving their instruction
according to concrete standards. Having asked these questions, I would be able to determine if the
lesson was a worthy use of instructional time. This would then lead to asking the teacher, “What
activities and strategies will you be using to achieve your stated outcomes and how the will the
activities enhance student learning?” I would expect the teacher to be able to show connection
between the lesson objectives, activities, strategies, and desired outcomes as one cohesive lesson.
Many teachers often struggle with showing how a learning would be explicitly measured and this
would need to be specifically articulated for the benefit of the students and the teacher alike.
Differentiated Instruction
Because of the unique needs of a special education support classes, I would ask the teacher,
“What are some student needs that you need to account for in your lesson?” I would expect the
teacher to be able to clearly identify student needs in accordance with their IEP accommodations
but also based on the behaviors the students exhibit that are unique to the class. Next, I would like
to ask the teacher what strategies and activities they have planned for to differentiate for the unique
student needs?” I would expect a special education teacher to identify a variety of strategies that are
simple, yet effective to address their individual needs in an equitable manner that allows all students
to have the services they need to be successful. Example of strategies might include a “flipped
classroom” model where students are able to individually, with partners and with direct-teacher
instruction be able to engage in learning. As noted by Altemueller & Lindquist (2017), “The
self-pacing lessons and mastery learning, increased collaboration and instant feedback for formative
assessment.” This would show the teacher is aware that there are unique student needs but also time
Struggling Students
Having had the teacher identify the unique student needs of the class, I would then proceed
to ask, “What are some struggles that you anticipate the students having in this lesson?” I would
expect that teacher will have a good understanding of the students who are struggling and what their
struggles are. With that in mind I would proceed to ask, “What strategies in the lesson will be used
to help those students that you have identified as struggling students?” I would expect the teacher to
have some research-based strategies that they hope to employ. Mastropieri et al. (2003) suggest,
facilitate comprehension.” While there are many strategies that could be given, these will
demonstrate teacher understanding of the need to address struggling student needs in their
instruction.
Prior Knowledge
It would be important to me as the observer to try to gauge where the students were in their
learning prior to my observation to provide context to my observations. With this is in mind I would
ask the teacher, “What prior learning has occurred prior to this lesson that support the lesson that is
being observed? Learning is not static and so I would expect the teacher to explain what skills
development have occurred leading up to the lesson and it should show a natural progression of
skills and learning development. I would ask “What gaps in knowledge do you foresee might
become apparent and how will you address these to ensure student have a fair opportunity to
achieve the stated objective?” I would expect that the teacher would also have understood this
reality in planning this lesson and they would be able to discuss how they will conduct some sort of
review and/or reteaching activity of essential concepts to make sure the students are ready to
Classroom Management
Like all middle school age student, special education classrooms will face behavior
challenges that need to be successfully addressed. I would ask the teacher, “What are some
challenging classroom behaviors that you have seen with this class in the past and/or anticipate you
might experience during the lesson?” I would expect the teacher to identify student behaviors that
they know are challenges. This would how me that they have a good “pulse” for the students and
understand the challenges they might face. Next, I would ask, “What steps in your classroom have
you taken to reduce these incidents I before they escalate?” Ideally, I would hear the teacher
describe to key components, PBIS and progressive discipline. Especially regarding PBIS, I would
like to see what system the teacher has in place for rewarding and promoting positive behaviors
rather than only being reactionary to negative behaviors. As noted by Sugai & Horner (2020),
“studies have examined the effects of implementing Tier 1 PBIS and found these practices
functionally related to significant reductions in problem behavior and improvement in social skills.”
References
Altemueller, L., & Lindquist, C. (2017). Flipped classroom instruction for inclusive learning. British
https://doi-org.lopes.idm.oclc.org/10.1111/1467-8578.12177
Mastropieri, M. A., Scruggs, T. E., & Graetz, J. E. (2003). Reading Comprehension Instruction for
Secondary Students: Challenges for Struggling Students and Teachers. Learning Disability
Sugai, G., & Horner, R. H. (2020). Sustaining and Scaling Positive Behavioral Interventions and