Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Course/Block: BSA-2A
Activity 1
Fill in the table below. Minimum of 5 sentences, maximum of 7 sentences.
1. There are only 10 spaces in the lifeboat, but there are 11 passengers on the sinking
ship. A decision must be made. Who will stay behind?
If there will be a volunteer among the passengers, then he/she can stay behind. If one is a
small child or a baby, then she/he can share a space with an adult so no one will be left behind.
In a case where no one will volunteer, and everyone needs a space each that can’t be share then
they should just all die. If I’m one of the passengers with the same case with the last possible
scenario then I’ll stay behind to let the other ten leave, my conscience can not bear if I’ll leave an
unwilling person, there’s no guarantee if I’ll die or survive (another lifeboat may arrive) but this
is the option I’ll choose with the character and moral I’m holding.
2. A train with broken brakes is speeding towards a fork in the tracks. On the left,
there is a woman crossing with her two children; on the right, there is a man doing
routine maintenance on the tracks. If you are an engineer, which side will you
choose?
I’ll choose the right, the man is a maintenance worker in train tracks so he should know
what to do in situations like this, he’ll know if a train will come so he should know how to
survive unlike that woman. I don’t think she’ll survive with two children. She’ll have to take
more time to get out of the tracks because she’ll still mind the two children, but the man can just
think about his own survival. The answer I just gave is with the fact that there are passengers
inside the train, if I’m the only one there then I should just go forward and take the crash, if I’m
the engineer and the train is my work then I’ll make sure I’ll have something built inside the train
for impacts meant for this situation; because if I continue with the right, the man might survive
but since the problem won’t be over after that maintenance man survival, I have to proceed to the
track in right and might encounter another fork then deal with harder option so I might just well
take the crash and stop the train.
If it’s in the Philippines, then it is unethical. Our current justice system isn’t capable
enough to be trusted to handle this sensitive punishment involving human lives. However, in my
point of view, it is ethical to those with heinous crimes to die. They took one or more lives with
their own hands, but I think death penalty will make it easy for them so why not build a prison
inspired with nine levels of inferno then let them leave like that until they die. I think it’s more
ethical to let them live a hellish life, suffer and repent, wanting to die but they can’t. In this way
we won’t be taking lives on our own hands and make it impossible for them to escape. In any
case that one might be successfully escaped then just grant its death. The existence of this prison
can also lessen the crime rate. There’s no second chance to live happily for those who took others’
infinite chances.
4. What do you choose: Stay living unhappily or Commit suicide and await
uncertainty after life? Why?
Stay living unhappily. I appreciate sadness, it makes me feel alive and thankful to every
comfort I receive. Life ahead is also uncertain as well as death itself, I might as well explore the
uncertainty of life rather than suicide as a gamble when one of the options is hell. There’s no
guarantee that my whole life will be unhappy if I live, but in this way, I can do something more
than just a mere gamble. Soon, I’ll die anyway. I’ll know the uncertainty after I live so I’m more
curious in life ahead. If my memory will remain in my soul after I die then I’ll live a life that’s
worth remembering off and maybe in that way I’ll smile for the happiness I’m able to make.