Professional Documents
Culture Documents
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10924-021-02169-4
REVIEW
Abstract
The need to provide a better and stronger protection against various kinds of ballistic impacts and threats has necessitated the
continuous exploration and utilization of high-performance fibres, especially those that are derived from renewable sources
for ballistic applications. The development of ballistic protection materials with improved performance and low weight has
received much concerns in the past few decades due to the rising cases of threats and insurgencies. Owing to the necessity
of improving the ballistic performance of body armour and protective wears especially for military personnel, with a huge
consideration for eco-friendly requirement, a review of relevant studies in this area is necessary. Present review article
aims to present an overview of the progress and the outstanding advances that have been witnessed in the development of
natural-based anti-ballistic composites in the past few years. The article covers the type and selection of the fibre/matrix,
failure modes, Impact energy absorption and ballistic simulation of NFRCs. It also highlights the economic cost analysis of
replacing synthetic fibres with natural ones in a ballistic composite, and the methods of enhancing the composites for high
performance and greater ballistic efficiency. The utilization of natural fibres in PMCs have shown their great potentials as
substitutes to the existing advanced fibrous materials that are mostly dominated by synthetic fibres.
Keywords Natural fibres · Polymer Matrix Composites · Synthetic fibres · Ballistic applications
Introduction
13
Vol.:(0123456789)
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
Previous studies have shown that commercial fibres, such as past few years on the applications of plant fibres for ballistic
aramid are commonly utilized for various purposes which purposes. Although, there is a great similarity between the
range from engineering and industrial applications to materi- method of processing adopted for the fabrication of NFRCs
als used in personal protective devices [9]. However, these and the ones used for the production of composites that are
products are fairly expensive to produce because of the com- reinforced with conventional fibres [30], it is necessary for
plexity of their manufacturing processes. Currently, continu- the equipment to be modified when manufacturing NFRCs,
ous efforts on the substitution or decrease of the contents of especially for high impact and ballistic applications. In
synthetic fibre in natural composites for various applications addition, the general knowledge and understanding of these
and the conservation of the environment are strongly being modifications’ principles is of great importance/value to
investigated by researchers. Wambua et al. [10]. studied the researchers.
application of the combined usage of conventional and natu-
ral fibres for high impact resistance [11, 12]. The importance
of natural fibre as a promising material for reinforcement in Commonly Used Fibres of Natural Origin
ballistic impact performance (such as personal protective
wears) in order to considerably lessen the use of synthetic Generally, some of the mostly utilized natural fibres in com-
fibres, and the benefits of its availability and abundant quan- posites are coir, pineapple leaf fibre (PALF), kenaf, hemp,
tity in nature was exhibited. flax, sisal, sugar cane, jute, oil palm and wood. The annual
In recent times, attention of researchers is being drawn production rates of these fibres are presented in Table 1.
to the processing and characterization of ballistic protection They are commonly used as support in PMCs [31–33].
composite materials that are commonly obtainable and less Naveen et al. [34] worked on hybrid laminated composite,
expensive, so that it can be readily available as suitable pro- they used analytical hierarchy process (AHP) in selecting
tective wears for the safety of military and vulnerable civil- the types of natural fibres that are suitable for the study.
ians that are susceptible to attacks from terrorists. This is They recommended cocos nucifera sheath as an appropriate
why natural-based materials are necessary for the reduction candidate to be used as reinforcement alongside Kevlar in
of dependency on synthetic fibres. In addition, core knowl- the development of Personal body armour. More works on
edge of some features such as ballistic and impact charac- ballistic application of NFRCs are Ramie-Epoxide compos-
teristics should be given much attention so as to be techni- ite [35], Natural curaua fibre-reinforced composites [36],
cally and economically established. Utmost consideration Epoxy composite reinforced with sisal fibres [37], wood
will be given to the protection strength and manufacturing plastic composite [38]. Recent researches include sugarcane
cost during the selection of materials for the development bagasse, curaua, fique, cocos nucifera, guaruman, kenaf,
of anti-ballistic systems. These are regarded as the main fac- jute and others [25, 26, 39–45]. Actually, the attraction of
tors, therefore, a more abundant and cheaper ballistic protec- researchers towards this development is not new, it was dated
tion panel will be produced, thereby lowering the integral back to 1923 when Basalt fibre was discovered. This led to
impacts of petroleum-based devices without undermining its adoption as a replacement and was later categorized as a
the efficiency of ballistic outcome. choice component for armour and protective devices. It was
Although, there are reports from several articles on the majorly utilized during world war II [29, 46].
ballistic studies of NFRCs [11, 13–21]; some of them with In a recent research, an abundant, recyclable, renewable,
emphasis on the damage assessment and energy absorp- bio-degradable and less expensive material which is also
tion capacity of these fibres [19, 20, 22–27]. Quintero et al. regarded as environmentally friendly was used as reinforc-
[28] investigated the response of Manicaria saccifera/PLA ing material by Rohen et al. [37] In that study, sisal fibre
to ballistic impacts, they discovered that the resistance of was inserted as intermediate layer in an epoxy resin plate.
the ballistic composite to penetration is not dependent on The results of ballistic performance showed that the fibre is
the layering sequence of the constituent materials. Benzait more effective compared to aramid fibres. Monteiro et al.
and Trabzon [29] also carried out a review on components [47] also replaced aramid fibre with curaua natural fibre in
of polymer matrix composites (PMCs) used for personal a multilayered armour that is comprised of polyester matri-
body armour, they reported some novel materials that are ces, ceramic tiles and aluminium alloy as a backing plate.
promising. Although, some natural composites were men- The result of ballistic tests confirmed the efficiency of the
tioned in the previous reviews, but greater emphasis was curaua fibre as an armour component. Monteiro et al. [39]
made on the synthetic ones. Nevertheless, considering the used sugarcane bagasse in the development of a multilay-
huge significance of developing NFRCs for high-velocity ered ballistic composite. The bagasse is a residue or waste
impacts, it is expected that the research gap in these areas generated after the production of juice, sugar and ethanol
can be filled. Therefore, this review is aimed at bringing from sugarcane. The report from their study indicates that
to the fore, the progress that has been made so far, in the the ballistic performance of the bagasse-based composite
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
Table 1 Annual production of Fibre source World produc- Origin Ref Fibre source World produc- Origin Ref
natural fibres and their sources tion (10,000 tion (10,000
Tons) Tons)
satisfied the National Institute of Justice (NIJ) test stand- considerably with proper bio-filler selection and surface
ard, with clay being made the fourth layer in the multilayer modification. Environmental surface coating has also shown
armour system (MAS). Filho et al. [48, 49] also investigated encouraging results in reducing degradation and aging from
the use of piassava fibre as a second layer in a MAS, their natural, thermal and mechanical sources on biocomposites
results showed that the ballistic behaviour of the piassava [61].
composite is similar to the ones possessed by commercial
aramid fibres, with 70 and 80% lower in cost than Dyneema
and Kevlar, respectively. Matrix and its Role in Energy Dissipation
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
[69] by incorporating graphene platelets to the epoxy matrix. of intrinsic energy dissipation from the study of Mohammed
The dynamic/ballistic response of some of the effects of this et al. [73] indicates that the released energy was the highest
adhesion was demonstrated by Costa et al. [68], Ahmed et al. at 30 kJ/m and amplitude of 0.1, but the energy range of
[70] and Luz et al. [71]. 2–16 kJ/m3 have an amplitude of 0.3, and 0.5 for 2–5 kJ/m3
The impact behaviour of ballistic composites may be released energy range. The ability of ceramics to offer bal-
enhanced by using matrices with degraded properties. Liu listic protection depends on both physical and mechanical
et al. [72] developed a dynamic model to analyze the energy properties such as hardness, elastic modulus, density, poros-
dissipation through viscid matrix materials in NFRCs. Due ity, mechanical strength and fracture toughness. There is no
to the uncertain nature of the transient process of energy single property that correlates with ballistic performance due
dissipation in high impact composites subjected to high to the interaction of various stress factors during impact and
velocity loading, and its relationship with the geometries the short time associated with the initiation and propagation
and features of other constituents, they suggested that shear of cracks [74]. The relationship between specific absorption
modulus and viscosity of a matrix should be adjusted to energy of the hybrid and non-hybrid kenaf/kevlar compos-
enhance its energy dissipation capacity in order to protect ites as observed by Yahaya et al. [75] is shown in Fig. 1. The
its material integrity. change in energy absorption recorded is between 15.05 and
The way and manner at which Matrices absorb the kinetic 30.18% for the hybrid and non-hybrid kenaf composites,
energy of projectiles differ in terms of mechanisms. Ductile respectively. The schematic diagram of the different layering
materials exhibit plastic deformation during absorption of sequence is presented in Fig. 2.
energy. Dissipation of energy by ceramics are done through Haro et al. [76] studied the effects of arrangement, lay-
fracture mechanisms. This includes initiation of small cracks ering and combination of materials by hybridization on
and deformation of the projectile, leading to expansion of dissipation of energy during ballistic impacts. In a bid to
crack and fragmentation of the material. In most cases, identify the level of protection achieved by hybrid lami-
matrix deformation begins with propagation of cracks until nates, the initial impact energy of low calibre weapons
load is completely transferred to the length of fibre. In the was compared with the energy dissipation capability of the
second stage, the fibres are under strain and the cracks are composite targets. The results of penetration and deforma-
formed with slower growth than before. The debonding tion analysis behaviour of the targets at different stages i.e.
between the matrix and the fibres occur steadily starting the initial (front target), intermediate (cross-section), and
from the fibres. Lastly, catastrophic failure of the material final stages (rear target) indicated that the laminate fulfil
occurs when the cracks spread quickly due to breakage of the the NIJ standard requirement for level II, IIA and IIIA
fibres [73]. The result of basic quantitative characterization protective devices.
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
Fig. 1 Energy absorption
capacity of the kenaf laminates
[75]. Material specifications:
9A: Kevlar, with 9 layers [ A9].
9B: Kenaf/Kevlar with layering
sequence of [ A3, k1, A3, k1, A3].
15A: Kevlar, with 15 layers
[A15]. 15B: Kenaf/Kevlar with
layering sequence of [A5, k1,
A5, k1, A5]. 21A: Kevlar, with
21 layers [ A21]. 21B: Kenaf/
Kevlar with layering sequence
of [A7, k1, A7, k1, A7]. Type A
consist of Kevlar/epoxy layers
and type B consist of Kevlar/
epoxy with additional layers of
woven kenaf. Type A consist
of 9, 15 and 21 layers Kevlar/
epoxy composites while the
type B consists of Kevlar hybrid
layers with additional 2 layers
of woven kenaf
Fig. 2 The layering sequences of the hybrid and Kevlar in different form [78]
Rajole et al. [77] investigated the ballistic impact of Jute/ the impact velocity and the energy absorbed. The study shows
Rubber and glass/Epoxy sandwich. The ballistic properties; that for minimum impact velocities of 80 and 100 m/s, an
such as material thickness, and impact velocities, energy absorbed energy of 400 J was recorded. Also, for maximum
absorption, fracture behavior and ballistic limit are predicted values of 180 and 200 m/s impact velocities, absorbed energies
using finite element analysis. The results of the simulation of 500 and 600 J were recorded for the hybrid and non-hybrid
when compared to the analytical showed better correlation. kenaf composites, respectively.
Also, better energy absorption of the Jute/Rubber sandwich
was recorded when compared to other simulated composites.
The effect of velocity impact on the absorbed energy of some
laminates reported by Yahaya et al. [75] is shown in Fig. 3. In
their report, they demonstrated the direct relationship between
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
Composites and Hybrid Composites hybridization on properties coir fibre [86]; study of kevlar/
kenaf laminated yarn for high impact performance [15].
Hybridization of Composites The major challenge that is being experienced in hybridi-
zation is the “hybrid effect”. This is the resultant effect of
Functionalization of fibre, such as chemical modifica- the synergy between the components of the composite. It
tion, selection of proper manufacturing technique, fibre involves the hybrid ratio, mode and fibre type. The moisture
volume ratio and matrix fibre orientation are some of the absorption and aspect ratio depends largely on the over-
processes of enhancing natural fibre-reinforced compos- all mechanical features of hybrid natural composites [87,
ites for greater performance.[67]. All of these have been 88]. Furthermore, the process is still faced with issues of
discussed in previous literatures [79–81]. Another good interface and manufacturing techniques. From a wider per-
method of improving the ballistic performance of NFRCs spective, some challenges in relation to composite design,
is hybridization [75]. It is strategically used to improve fracture and strength of materials are still required to be
the toughness of composite materials. This strategy offers resolved. In recent years, composite materials of lower cost
better features in terms of mechanical strength compared and multiple applications manufactured from the combina-
to non-hybrid composites [82]. Apart from maintaining the tion of different fibres of different proportion were success-
major features of the main constituents, the composite also fully developed. This, to an extent is an indication of a sig-
exhibits new features which are not possessed by any of nificant development towards hybrid composites.
the individual component [83]. The combined advantages
that are derived from the synergy of different types of fibre Failure Modes of Composites
as a result of their individual properties, and at the same
time reducing their less desirable properties is referred to The kinetic energy of the projectile is dissipated through
as Hybridization [75]. The development of hybrid com- several ways during ballistic impact. The mechanism for
posites and related researches have been witnessed with absorption of energy in composites under high and small
tremendous improvements over the past few decades [83]. impact energy are; kinetic energy applied to the material,
Results from recent studies indicated that hybridization is namely; spall formation, cone formation on the side of the
promising in NFRCs [8]. various studies on hybrid NFRCs laminate and absorption of energy due to failure of the fibre
include investigation of flax/basalt laminate and fracture and shear plugging of the primary yarns [89]. Impact dam-
toughness of the composite structure [84]; influence of age may lead to several types of failure. Some of the targets
layering sequence on hybrid flax/jute [85]; impact of will be penetrated by high velocity material and some of
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
them will only receive minor damage at the surface area. In Table 3 Ballistic Performance of different natural fibre-reinforced
the case of damage; several failure modes must occur, such composites [26]
as; cracking of matrix and breakage, fibre breakage or pull Natural fibre polymer composites Depth of indenta- Ref.
out and delamination. The failure modes of the composites tion (mm)
will depend on the material properties, matrix properties,
20% fique fabric/polyester 15 ± 3 [95]
impact velocity, project nose shape and target geometry.
30% jute fabric/polyester 17 ± 2 [24]
Delamination is a crack that occurs in the matrix area
30% non-woven mat/polyester 24 ± 7 [39]
between resin and the fibre layers of different fibre orienta-
30% sisal fibre/polyester 22 ± 3 [96]
tion. Matrix failure is the first failure that occurs before the
30% curaua non-woven fabric/epoxy 28 ± 3 [99]
failure of the fibre. The cracks in the matrices occur due to
30% aligned mallow fibre/epoxy 22 ± 1 [22]
inadequate matches between the fibre and the matrices, and
30% curaua fibre/polyester 22 ± 2 [97]
core micro-cracks may be formed due to the presence of
30% curaua cross-grid fibre/polyester 18 ± 3 [97]
openings in the matrix, or the de-bonding between the fibre
30% ramie fabric/epoxy 17 ± 1 [98]
and the matrix owing to manufacturing defects and residual
30% sugarcane bagasse fibre/epoxy 21 ± 1 [98]
stress [90]. Their orientation is usually in uni-directional
Kevlar laminate 23 ± 3 [39]
layer arranged parallel to the fibre-direction. The failure of
fibres (natural and synthetic) generally occur after the matrix
failure and delamination due to high stress impact which
may lead to catastrophic penetration modes [91]. [98] and sugarcane bagasse [39] displayed highly competi-
Hajer et al. [92] examined the mechanical behavior of tive and encouraging results when compared with the Kevlar
flax fibre composites with and without an interleaved natu- laminate. Figure 4 also presents some pictorial images of
ral visco-elastic layer in static and fatigue. They performed hybrid and non-hybrid kenaf/Kevlar composites after bal-
uni-axial static loading tests on the composite with different listic performance tests.
stacking sequence. The results of AE analysis obtained from
the different damage mechanisms shows the various classes
of damage according to the stacking sequence of elastic and Ballistic Energy Absorption of NFRCS
visco-elastic laminates, and the effect of the later on the
heterogeneity of the material. Reports from previous literatures showed that the fibre
The development of NFRC laminates may exhibit high properties, their number of layers, the structure of fabric,
degree of plasticity, especially in high performance cases. areal density, features of the projectile and impact are the
A study by David-west et al. [93] revealed that the ballis- major factors in energy absorption and ballistic protection
tic response of the combination of sisal and flax fibres to composite systems [28]. The parameters of the projectiles
nominal strikes and higher impact energies depend on many include target material properties and geometry, density
factors, including the stacking sequence, thickness of the and strike velocity [100]. Alternate hybrid layers of kenaf
laminate, degree to which the material is supported against and Kevlar, was reported to have shown low energy absorp-
bending, the shape and the kinetic energy of the impactor. tion when compared to other hybrid laminates of the same
In a situation where different modes of energy dissipation amount of layers and thickness. Although, higher delamina-
are desired, it is preferable to reduce the brittleness of the tion was seen at the surface of alternate Kevlar/kenaf layers
composite. This can be achieved by modifying the mode of when both laminates bulged out. In the study of Cruz v60,
failure of the laminate by introducing other fibres. Although the bamboo-reinforced composite was observed to display
the preventive measures of the properties of the hybrid from more delamination and fragments compared to aramid fab-
those of the originating laminates may not always be obvi- ric composite (Fig. 5). Also, Randjbaran et al. [101] exam-
ous. This can be determined in studies involving impact ined the impact of alternate layering and its sequence on the
damage by accidental events or ballistic application [94]. absorption capacity of Kevlar/carbon/glass ballistic compos-
The performance of different natural fibres in polymer ites. Their results show that the rate at which the composites
composites as reported by previous researchers is presented dissipate energy increased with rising depth of material and
in Table 3. Their performance in terms of depth of indenta- the projectile diameter.
tion was compared with Kevlar laminate. The results of their Rajole et al. [77] carried out a study on energy impact
mode of failure showed that most of the natural fibres are analysis of a natural fibre sandwich composite. They com-
promising; with fique/polyester indicating an outstanding pared the ballistic behaviour of Jute/Epoxy and Glass/
performance, a depth of indentation of 15 ± 3 mm at a vol- Epoxy composites to that of Jute-Rubber-Epoxy composite
ume ratio of 20% in the composite [95]. Other fibres, such (JREC). The results of the absorption energy capability of
as Jute [24], Sisal [96], Mallow [22], curaua [97], ramie the composites showed that the JREC has better ballistic
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
Fig. 4 Images of failure modes of hybrid and non-hybrid Kenaf/Kev- aramid 29 layers. c presents the hybrid composite consisting of alter-
lar composites after ballistic tests [11]. a shows failure of Aramid nating layers of kenaf and aramid layers showing a combination of
fibre in the damaged surfaces of the aramid 29 composite. b depicts delamination and bulging out of the kenaf layers
the damaged surfaces of the hybrid composite of woven kenaf and
Fig. 5 The image of ballistic fracture of (a) bamboo fibre-reinforced and (b) aramid fibre under scan electron microscopy (SEM)60
efficiency, but has a poor response to fracture which is In the study of Elias et al. [103], an increment of 20%
followed by delamination and de-bonding. in the specific absorption energy was observed when the
Roy et al. [102] demonstrated in their study that a con- combination of woven flax, hemp and kenaf fibres were used
siderable improvement in the impact energy absorption as reinforcing fibres in composites comprising of high den-
of a natural rubber reinforced composite was achieved by sity polyethylene (HDPE) and polylactic acid (PLA) matri-
increasing the rubber coatings on a high strength and high ces differently. The effect of weave configuration was also
modulus fibre. Greater impact performance were recorded observed to be more stable against the influence of buckling
when compared to a Kevlar/UHMWPE (Ultra High Weight at loading rates of 10% higher than the values of the specific
Polyethylene) fabric composite. absorption energy. The PLA-matrix based composite was
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
reported to record about 72% increase in specific energy emission (AE) method. An AE technique is used to iden-
absorption when compared to HDPE matrix. Although, PLA tify the type of mechanisms of damage that exists in a
is a brittle polymer, while HDPE is expected to exhibit better material, after which the contributed destruction of each
toughness behaviour than PLA, and by implication possess a mechanism can be estimated [106–108]. The microscopic
higher energy absorption upon impact than the PLA-matrix. inspection combined with classification method were
This could be as a result of the differences in material con- used in the identification of the first set of material failure
figuration of the reinforcing fibre and that of the layering properties from the AE signals, namely; matrix cracking,
technique. The effect of different material properties on fibre failure, and fibre-matrix de-bonding. The involve-
the energy absorption behaviour of natural fibre reinforced ment of each material failure property in the total damage
composites (Fig. 6) indicates an energy absorption range of was determined from the AE energy and the number of
23–38 kJ/g for different material combination of flax, hemp impacts. The results of AE indicated that each impact that
and kenaf, with HDPE and PLA, respectively [103]. is associated with the damage of fibre was regarded as the
smallest, although their involvement in the total damage of
Assessment of Damage Mechanism of nfrcs the composites was based mainly on the summation of all
energy of the AE (Fig. 7). An optimal value of 32 dB was
One of the significant roles of the ballistic performance of recorded which matches with the optimum point where
NFRCs is the assessment of damage part of the composites. most of the noise signals were absorbed as shown in Fig. 8
The reason for conducting damage assessment is to exam- [105].
ine the influence of hybridization and the failure modes of The different damage mechanisms that occurred on the
the laminates under high loading [75]. Ramakrishna et al. specimen of NFRCs under tensile loading are well known
[104] used ultrasonic scan, visual inspection and NDI (Non- i.e. delamination, fibre/matrix interfacial de-bonding, matrix
destructive inspection) techniques to evaluate the impact crack, and fibre breakage. Figure 8 shows the impact of
damage assessment of NFRC made of flax fibre and poly- amplitude on the features of material failure of some hybrid
propylene. The results of real-time scan show that there is composites, while the waveform of the acoustic emission is
correlation between the force–displacement data obtained displayed in Fig. 9. Report from Saidane et al. [105] shows
from the imaging sensor and the transient failure crack. The that the matrix cracking caused by AE signals is about 35 dB
loss of stiffness and the subsequent fall in the force history and was also characterized by low amplitude, while the sig-
is as a result of macro-cracks initiation that occur during nals that caused de-bonding between the fibre and matrix is
the impact. However, it was shown by the imaging device 40 db, for aged and unaged materials. The frequency of the
that the creation of damage is not always common and so a signal that caused fibre failure is between 60 and 70 db for
less sophisticated method was suggested for the assessment the unaged materials only (Fig. 8). The values of the param-
of damage. eters HLT (Hit Lockout Time), HDT (Hit Definition Time)
Saidane et al. [105] investigated a hybrid flax-glass fibre and PDT (Peak Definition Time) obtained, as displayed in
composites and its damage mechanisms, using acoustic Fig. 9 are 300, 200, and 30 µs, respectively.
Fig. 6 Evaluation of Specific
energy Absorption on different
fibre/matrix combination [103].
Material configuration: V5 &
V6 denotes (flax twill/PLA) and
(flax Hopsack/PLA) respec-
tively, while a, b and c denotes
the index for different strain
rates; namely low, intermedi-
ate and the highest crash speed
employed
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
Fig. 9 Waveform of the AE
[105]
Liang et al. [109] studied the damage assessment Ballistic Simulation of NFRCs
and Quasi-static behaviour of flax fibre/epoxy compos-
ites. Fracture of brittle matrix and de-bonding of fibres The cost of experiment for evaluating the extent of damage
from the matrix were the main failure modes observed. that occurred on targets during ballistic impacts can be
Although, the interlayer matrix cracking that occurred very high. However, performance evaluation and behavior
in between the layers is the main cause of damage as of ballistic protection composites under different impact
a result of reduction in stiffness of cross-ply laminates loading can be predicted by applying new technologies in
under tensile loading. the field of numerical simulation [89]. For the develop-
Sarasini et al. [110] examined the damage tolerance ment of new advanced defence systems, it is suggested
of carbon/Flax hybrid composites. He used a barely vis- that better analytical models and numerical simulations
ible impact damage (BVID) device and a 4-point bending be used, followed by experimental evaluation to provide
apparatus to compare the impact damage tolerance and material and structural solutions. To capture the perfor-
flexural performance, respectively between a Flax/car- mance of NFRCs accurately, good simulation models and
bon/Flax (FCF) and a Carbon/Flax/Carbon (CFC) lami- software tools must be utilized [30].
nate. The results showed that the CFC laminate possess Although, there are different methods of analysis,
better flexural properties, while the FCF showed higher namely; experimental, Numerical and experimental anal-
impact damage tolerance. Part of their observation was ysis. Numerical methods are mostly preferred because of
that the arrangement of flax fibre on the outer layer of their organized and established models that can offer sig-
the laminate acted as hinderance to propagation of crack. nificant and valuable information regarding the longitu-
Petrucci et al. [111] investigated the damage charac- dinal and the transverse distribution of stress during high
terization of hybrid composite. The laminate is comprised impact . The method also helps to save time, energy and
of Basalt fibre combined with other natural and synthetic cost compared to experimental analysis. Some researchers
fibres such as hemp, flax and glass fibres. The results of have used some commercial softwares, such as LSDYNA,
performance between the basalt fibre and flax/hemp fibre DYNA, ANSYS & ABACUS, etc [112–120].
reinforced laminate placed the previous laminate on the
high side, and the later on the low side.
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
[124]
[125]
[126]
[127]
[123]
[128]
Refs. ballistic behaviour of synthetic fibre reinforced composites
[121, 122], but natural fibre reinforced composites are sel-
ventional impeller
Wound Ballistics
less than 8%
Observation
velocities
back-spatter [132].
The study of back-spatter offers a lot of information on
a real event that might have occurred in cranial wounds by
linking the surrounding objects to the materials as a result
of a gunshot. Das et al. [131] studied the technique of back-
Solid works and CCM+
Explicit
Cost Analysis
Jute/Epoxy/rubber
fibre, Bronze fill
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
fibre-based products to industries that will produce bal- 15. Jambari S, Yahya MY, Abdullah MR, Jawaid M (2017) Woven
listic protection materials of higher quality in the future. Kenaf/Kevlar hybrid yarn as potential fiber reinforced for anti-
ballistic composite material. Fibers Polym 18(3):563–568
16. Luz FSD, Monteiro SN, Lima ES, Júnior L, Pereira É (2017)
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank University of Ballistic Application of coir fiber reinforced epoxy composite
Malaya for providing financial support via Faculty Research Grant in multilayered armor. Mater Res (AHEAD) 0–0
(GPF017A-2018). 17. Nascimento LFC, Holanda LIF, Louro LHL, Monteiro SN,
Gomes AV, Lima EP (2017) Natural mallow fiber-reinforced
Declarations epoxy composite for ballistic armor against class III-A
ammunition. Metall Mater Transact a-Phys Metall Mater Sci
Conflict of interest The authors declared no potential conflict of inter- 48A(10):4425–4431
est. 18. Wambua P, Vangrimde B, Lomov S, Verpoest I (2007) The
response of natural fibre composites to ballistic impact by frag-
ment simulating projectiles. Compos Struct 77(2):232–240
19. Nurazzi NM, Asyraf MRM, Khalina A, Abdullah N, Aisyah
HA, Rafiqah SA, Sabaruddin FA, Kamarudin SH, Norrrahim
References MNF, Ilyas RA, Sapuan SM (2021) A review on natural fiber
reinforced polymer composite for bullet proof and ballistic
applications. Polymers. https://doi.org/10.3390/polym13040
1. Sanjay MR, Arpitha GR, Naik LL, Gopalakrishna K, Yogesha 646
B (2016) Applications of natural fibers and its composites: an 20. Ribeiro MP, Neuba LDM, da Silveira PHPM, da Luz FS,
overview. Nat Resour 7(03):108–108 -H.d.S. Figueiredo AB, Monteiro SN, Moreira MO (2021)
2. Taj S, Munawar MA, Khan S (2007) Natural fiber-rein- Mechanical, thermal and ballistic performance of epoxy com-
forced polymer composites. Proceed-Pakistan Acad Sci posites reinforced with Cannabis sativa hemp fabric. J Mater
44(2):129–129 Res Technol 12:221–233
3. Varvani-Farahani A (2010) Composite materials: characteriza- 21. Nayak SY, Sultan MTH, Shenoy SB, Kini CR, Samant R, Shah
tion, fabrication and application-research challenges and direc- AUM, Amuthakkannan P (2020) Potential of Natural Fibers in
tions. Appl Compos Mater 17(2):63–67 Composites for Ballistic Applications – A Review. J Nat Fib-
4. Belaadi A, Bezazi A, Maache M, Scarpa F (2014) Fatigue ers. https://doi.org/10.1080/15440478.2020.1787919
in sisal fiber reinforced polyester composites: hysteresis and 22. Nascimento LFC, Louro LHL, Monteiro SN, Lima EP, Luz
energy dissipation. Procedia Eng 74:325–328 FS (2017) Mallow fiber-reinforced epoxy composites in
5. Zaidi BM, Zhang J, Magniez K, Gu H, Miao M (2018) Opti- multilayered armor for personal ballistic protection. Jom
mizing twisted yarn structure for natural fiber-reinforced poly- 69(10):2052–2056
meric composites. J Compos Mater 52(3):373–381 23. da Silva AO, de Castro Monsores KG, Oliveira SDSA, Weber
6. L. Mohammed, M.N.M. Ansari, G. Pua, M. Jawaid, M.S. Islam RP, Monteiro SN (2018) Ballistic behavior of a hybrid composite
(2015) A review on natural fiber reinforced polymer composite reinforced with curaua and aramid fabric subjected to ultraviolet
and its applications. Int J Polym Sci 2015 radiation. J Mater Res Technol 7(4):584–591
7. Xiong X, Shen SZ, Hua L, Li X, Wan X, Miao M (2018) Pre- 24. Monteiro SN, Pereira AC, Ferreira CL, Pereira Júnior É, Weber
dicting tensile behaviors of short flax fiber-reinforced polymer– RP, Assis FSD (2018) Performance of plain woven jute fabric-
matrix composites using a modified shear-lag model. J Compos reinforced polyester matrix composite in multilayered ballistic
Mater 52(27):3701–3713 system. Polymers 10(3):230
8. Pickering KL, Efendy MGA, Le TM (2016) A review of recent 25. de Oliveira Braga F, Lopes PHL, Oliveira MS, Monteiro SN,
developments in natural fibre composites and their mechanical Lima ÉP Jr (2019) Thickness assessment and statistical optimiza-
performance. Compos A Appl Sci Manuf 83:98–112 tion of a 3-layered armor system with ceramic front and curaua
9. Sanborn B, DiLeonardi AM, Weerasooriya T (2015) Tensile fabric composite/aluminum alloy backing. Comp Part B: Eng
properties of Dyneema SK76 single fibers at multiple loading 166:48–55
rates using a direct gripping method. J Dynamic Behav Mater 26. Pereira AC, de Assis FS, da Costa Garcia F, Oliveira MS, da Cruz
1(1):4–14 Demosthenes HAC, Lopera HAC, Monteiro SN (2019) Ballistic
10. Wambua P, Ivens J, Verpoest I (2003) Natural fibres: can they performance of multilayered armor with intermediate polyester
replace glass in fibre reinforced plastics. Comp Sci Technol composite reinforced with fique natural fabric and fibers. J Mater
63(9):1259–1264 Res Technol 8(5):4221–4226
11. Salman SD, Leman Z, Sultan MTH, Ishak MR, Cardona F 27. Oliveira MS, da Costa GarciaFilho F, Pereira AC, da Nunes LF,
(2016) Ballistic impact resistance of plain woven kenaf/ara- de Luz F, Oliveira Braga HA, Colorado HA, Monterio SN (2019)
mid reinforced polyvinyl butyral laminated hybrid composite. Ballistic performance and statistical evaluation of multilayered
BioResources 11(3):7282–7295 armor with epoxy-fique fabric composites using the Weibull
12. Ali A, Shaker ZR, Khalina A, Sapuan SM (2011) Development analysis. J Mater Res Technol 8(6):5899–5908
of anti-ballistic board from ramie fiber. Polym-Plast Technol 28. Quintero S, Porras A, Hernandez C, Maranon A (2018) The
Eng 50(6):622–634 Response of Manicaria saccifera Natural Fabric Reinforced
13. Bandaru AK, Ahmad S, Bhatnagar N (2017) Ballistic perfor- PLA Composites to Impact by Fragment Simulating Projectiles.
mance of hybrid thermoplastic composite armors reinforced Advances in Natural Fibre Composites pp. 89–98.
with Kevlar and basalt fabrics. Compos Part a-Appl Sci Manu- 29. Benzait Z, Trabzon L (2018) A review of recent research on
fact 97:151–165 materials used in polymer–matrix composites for body armor
14. Braga FD, Bolzan LT, Lima EP, Monteiro SN (2017) Perfor- application. J Compos Mater 52(23):3241–3263
mance of natural curaua fiber-reinforced polyester composites 30. Rahman MA, Parvin F, Hasan M, Hoque ME (2015) Introduction
under 7.62 mm bullet impact as a stand-alone ballistic armor. to manufacturing of natural fibre-reinforced polymer composites,
J Mater Res Technol-Jmr&T 6(4):323–328 Springer pp. 17–43.
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
31. Nurazzi NM, Khalina A, Sapuan SM, Laila A, Rahmah M, Hana- 46. Dhand V, Mittal G, Rhee KY, Park S-J, Hui D (2015) A short
fee Z, Review A (2017) Fibres, Polymer Matrices and Compos- review on basalt fiber reinforced polymer composites. Compos
ites, Pertanika. J Sci Technol 25(4):1085–1102 B Eng 73:166–180
32. Abidin NM, Sultan MT, Hua LS, Basri AA, Md Shah AU, Safri 47. Monteiro SN, Louro LHL, Trindade W, Elias CN, Ferreira CL,
SN (2019) A brief review of computational analysis and experi- de Sousa Lima E, Weber RP, Suarez JCM, da Silva Figueiredo
mental models of composite materials for aerospace applications. AB-H, Pinheiro WA (2015) Natural curaua fiber-reinforced com-
J Reinforced Plastics Comp 38:1031–1039 posites in multilayered ballistic armor. Metall Mater Trans A
33. Adebayo G, Hassan A, Yahya R, Muhamad Sarih N, Odesanya 46(10):4567–4577
KO (2019) Impact of water saturation on the tensile and thermal 48. Garcia Filho FDC, Oliveira MS, Pereira AC, Nascimento LFC,
properties of heat-treated mangrove/high-density polyethylene Matheus JRG, Monteiro SN (2019) Ballistic behavior of epoxy
composites. J Thermoplastic Comp Mater 0892705719847238. matrix composites reinforced with piassava fiber against high
34. Naveen J, Jawaid, Zainudin E, Sultan MT, Yahaya RB (2018) energy ammunition. J Mater Res Technol (2019).
Selection of natural fiber for hybrid Kevlar/natural fiber rein- 49. Garcia Filho FDC, Monteiro SN (2019) Piassava fiber as an
forced polymer composites for personal body armour by using epoxy matrix composite reinforcement for ballistic armor appli-
analytical hierarchy process. Front Mater 5 cations. JOM 71(2):801–808
35. Anggoro DD, Kristiana N (2015) Combination of Natural 50. Faruk O, Bledzki AK, Fink H-P, Sain M (2012) Biocompos-
Fiber Boehmeria nivea (Ramie) with Matrix Epoxide for Bullet ites reinforced with natural fibers: 2000–2010. Prog Polym Sci
Proof Vest Body Armor, in: Hadiyanto, H. Nur, A. Budiman, F. 37(11):1552–1596
Iskandar, S. Ismadji (Eds.), Amer Inst Physics, [Anggoro, Didi 51. Muhammad SA, Ab Kadir MO, Rodhi AM, Hassan HM (2017)
Dwi; Kristiana, Nunung] Diponegoro Univ, Chem Engn, Fac Variations of δ13C and δ15N in oil palm tree organs: an insight
Engn, Jln Prof Sudharto, Tembalang 50239, Semarang, Indo- into C and N distribution. J Oil Palm Res 29(2):242–250
nesia. Anggoro, DD (reprint author), Diponegoro Univ, Chem 52. Krpan AP, Tomašić Ž, Bašić Palković P (2011) Biopotential of
Engn, Fac Engn, Jln Prof Sudharto, Tembalang 50239, Sema- indigobusch (Amorpha fruticosa L)–second year of investigation.
rang, Indones Šumarski list 135(13):103–112
36. Monteiro SN, Lima ÉP, Louro LHL, Da Silva LC, Drelich JW 53. Jung DS, Ryou M-H, Sung YJ, Park SB, Choi JW (2013) Recy-
(2015) Unlocking function of aramid fibers in multilayered bal- cling rice husks for high-capacity lithium battery anodes. Proc
listic armor. Metall Mater Trans A 46(1):37–40 Natl Acad Sci 110(30):12229–12234
37. Rohen LA, Margem FM, Monteiro SN, Vieira CMF, Madeira de 54. Suramaythangkoor T, Gheewala SH (2008) Potential of practical
Araujo B, Lima ES (2015) Ballistic efficiency of an individual implementation of rice straw-based power generation in Thai-
epoxy composite reinforced with sisal fibers in multilayered land. Energy Policy 36(8):3193–3197
armor. Mater Res 18:55–62 55. Francis JK (2004) Wildland shrubs of the United States and its
38. Haro EE, Szpunar JA, Odeshi AG (2018) Dynamic and ballistic territories: Thamnic descriptions, Volume 1, Gen. Tech. Rep.
impact behavior of biocomposite armors made of HDPE rein- IITF-GTR-26. San Juan, PR: US Department of Agriculture, For-
forced with chonta palm wood (Bactris gasipaes) microparticles. est Service, International Institute of Tropical Forestry; Fort Col-
Defence Technol 14(3):238–249 lins, CO: US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky
39. Monteiro SN, Candido VS, Braga FO, Bolzan LT, Weber RP, Mountain Research Station. 830: 26
Drelich JW (2016) Sugarcane bagasse waste in composites for 56. Hejcman M, Kunzová E, Šrek P (2012) Sustainability of winter
multilayered armor. Eur Polymer J 78:173–185 wheat production over 50 years of crop rotation and N, P and K
40. Naveen J, Jawaid M, Zainudin E, Sultan MT, Yahaya R (2019) fertilizer application on illimerized luvisol in the Czech Repub-
Evaluation of ballistic performance of hybrid Kevlar®/Cocos lic. Field Crop Res 139:30–38
nucifera sheath reinforced epoxy composites. J Textile Instit 57. Asim M, Abdan K, Jawaid M, Nasir M, Dashtizadeh Z, Ishak
110(8):1179–1189 MR, Hoque ME (2015) A review on pineapple leaves fibre and
41. Pinheiro MA, Gomes LG, Silva ACRD, Candido VS, Reis RHM, its composites. Int J Polym Sci 2015
Monteiro SN (2019) Guaruman: a Natural Amazonian Fiber with 58. Anbukarasi K, Anbukarasi K, Kalaiselvam S, Kalaiselvam S
Potential for Polymer Composite Reinforcement. Mater Res 22 (2017) Thermal and Mechanical Behaviors of Biorenewable
42. Azmi AMR, Sultan MTH, Hamdan A (2017) Design and devel- Fibers‐Based Polymer Composites, Handbook of Comp Renew
opment of bulletproof vest using kenaf fibre embedded with Mater
X-ray films, Centre Advanced Research Energy-Care, [Azmi, 59. Naveen J, Jayakrishna K, Hameed Sultan MTB, Amir SMM
A. M. R.; Sultan, M. T. H.; Hamdan, A.] Univ Putra Malaysia, (2020) Ballistic performance of natural fiber based soft and hard
Aerosp Mfg Res Ctr, Upm Serdang 43400, Selangor, Malaysia. body armour-a mini review. Fron Mater 7:440
[Azmi, A. M. R.; Sultan, M. T. H.; Hamdan, A.] Univ Putra 60. Bhatnagar N, Asija N (2016) Durability of high-performance
Malaysia, Fac Engn, Dept Aerosp Engn, Upm Serdang 43400, ballistic composites. Elsevier, Lightweight ballistic composites,
Selangor, Mal pp 231–283
43. Candido VS, da Silva ACR, Simonassi NT, da Luz FS, Monteiro 61. Chang BP, Mohanty AK, Misra M (2020) Studies on durabil-
SN (2017) Toughness of polyester matrix composites reinforced ity of sustainable biobased composites: a review. RSC Adv
with sugarcane bagasse fibers evaluated by Charpy impact tests. 10(31):17955–17999
J Mater Res Technol-Jmr&T 6(4):334–338 62. Dittenber DB, GangaRao HVS (2012) Critical review of recent
44. Pereira AC, Monteiro SN, de Assis FS, Margem FM, da Luz FS, publications on use of natural composites in infrastructure. Com-
Braga FD (2017) Charpy impact tenacity of epoxy matrix com- pos A Appl Sci Manuf 43(8):1419–1429
posites reinforced with aligned jute fibers. J Mater Res Technol- 63. Jawaid M, Khalil HPSA (2011) Cellulosic/synthetic fibre rein-
Jmr&T 6(4):312–316 forced polymer hybrid composites: A review. Carbohyd Polym
45. Salman SD, Leman Z, Sultan M, Ishak M, Cardona F (2017) 86(1):1–18
Effect of kenaf fibers on trauma penetration depth and bal- 64. Biswas S, Ahsan Q, Cenna A, Hasan M, Hassan A (2013) Physi-
listic impact resistance for laminated composites. Text Res J cal and mechanical properties of jute, bamboo and coir natural
87(17):2051–2065 fiber. Fibers Polymers 14(10):1762–1767
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
65. Chen H, Cheng H, Wang G, Yu Z, Shi SQ (2015) Tensile proper- 85. Karaduman Y, Onal L, Rawal A (2015) Effect of stacking
ties of bamboo in different sizes. J Wood Sci 61(6):552–561 sequence on mechanical properties of hybrid flax/jute fib-
66. Cruz RBD, Lima Junior EP, Monteiro SN, Louro LHL (2015) ers reinforced thermoplastic composites. Polym Compos
Giant bamboo fiber reinforced epoxy composite in multilayered 36(12):2167–2173
ballistic armor. Mater Res 18:70–75 86. Prasad N, Agarwal VK, Sinha S (2018) Hybridization effect of
67. Mohammed L, Ansari MN, Pua G, Jawaid M, Islam MS (2015) coir fiber on physico-mechanical properties of polyethylene-
A review on natural fiber reinforced polymer composite and its banana/coir fiber hybrid composites. Sci Eng Compos Mater
applications. Int J Polym Sci 2015 25(1):133–141
68. Costa UO, Nascimento LFC, Garcia JM, Monteiro SN, Luz 87. Sanjay MR, Arpitha GR, Yogesha B (2015) Study on mechani-
FSD, Pinheiro WA, Garcia Filho FDC (2019) Effect of graphene cal properties of natural-glass fibre reinforced polymer hybrid
oxide coating on natural fiber composite for multilayered ballistic composites: a review. Mater Today: Procee 2(4–5):2959–2967
armor. Polymers 11(8):1356 88. Alkbir MFM, Sapuan SM, Nuraini AA, Ishak MR (2016) Fibre
69. Naveen J, Jawaid M, Zainudin E, Sultan MT, Yahaya R (2019) properties and crashworthiness parameters of natural fibre-rein-
Effect of graphene nanoplatelets on the ballistic performance of forced composite structure: a literature review. Compos Struct
hybrid Kevlar/Cocos nucifera sheath-reinforced epoxy compos- 148:59–73
ites. Text Res J 89(21–22):4349–4362 89. Deka L, Bartus S, Vaidya U (2006) Damage evolution and energy
70. Ahmed A, Chouhan H, Kartikeya K, Bhatnagar N (2019) Study absorption of FRP plates subjected to ballistic impact using a
on low and high strain rate behaviour of the adhesive bonds for numerical model, 9th International LS-DYNA Users Conference,
armour application. J Adhesion 1–14 Dearborn, MI
71. da Luz FS, Ramos FJHTV, Nascimento LFC, da Silva Figue- 90. Tian K, Zhou S, Yang C, Zhang J, Zhou C (2019) Tension fail-
iredo AB-H, Monteiro SN (2018) Critical length and interfa- ure simulation of notched composite laminate using floating
cial strength of PALF and coir fiber incorporated in epoxy resin node method combined with In-Situ effect theory. J Market Res
matrix. J Mater Res Technol 7(4):528–534 8(3):2494–2507
72. Liu J, Zhu W, Yu Z, Wei X (2018) Dynamic shear-lag model for 91. Razali N, Sultan MTH, Jawaid M (2017) A review on detecting
understanding the role of matrix in energy dissipation in fiber- and characterizing damage mechanisms of synthetic and natural
reinforced composites. Acta Biomater 74:270–279 fiber based composites. BioResources 12(4):9502–9519
73. Mohamed S, Zainudin E, Sapuan S, Azaman M, Arifin A (2020) 92. Hajer D, Jean-Luc R, Charfeddin M, Mohamed T, Mohamed H
Energy behavior assessment of rice husk fibres reinforced poly- (2018) Experimental analysis of the linear and nonlinear vibra-
mer composite. J Market Res 9(1):383–393 tion behavior of flax fibre reinforced composites with an inter-
74. Schuldies J, Nageswaran R (2010) Ceramic matrix composites leaved natural viscoelastic layer. Compos B Eng 151:201–214
for ballistic protection of vehicles and personnel. Elsevier, Blast 93. David-West O, Banks W, Pethrick R (2011) A study of the effect
Protection of Civil Infrastructures and Vehicles Using Compos- of strain rate and temperature on the characteristics of quasi-
ites, pp 235–243 unidirectional natural fibre-reinforced composites. Proceed Instit
75. Yahaya R, Sapuan SM, Jawaid M, Leman Z, Zainudin ES (2016) Mech Eng Part L: J Mater: Design Appl 225(3):133–148
Investigating ballistic impact properties of woven kenaf-aramid 94. Santulli C (2019) Mechanical and impact damage analysis on
hybrid composites. Fibers Polym 17(2):275–281 carbon/natural fibers hybrid composites: a review. Materials
76. Haro EE, Szpunar JA, Odeshi AG (2016) Ballistic impact 12(3):517
response of laminated hybrid materials made of 5086–H32 alu- 95. Neves Monteiro S, Salgado de Assis F, Ferreira CL, Tonini
minum alloy, epoxy and Kevlar® fabrics impregnated with shear Simonassi N, Pondé Weber R, Souza Oliveira M, Colorado HA
thickening fluid. Compos A Appl Sci Manuf 87:54–65 (2018) Camposo Pereira, Fique fabric: a promising reinforcement
77. Rajole S, Ravishankar K, Kulkarni S (2018) Study on Ballistic for polymer composites. Polymers 10(3):246
Energy Absorption Capability of Glass-Epoxy and Jute-Epoxy- 96. Braga FDO, Bolzan LT, Ramos FJHTV, Monteiro SN, Lima
Rubber Sandwich Composites. Trans Tech Publ, Materials Sci- ÉP Jr, Silva LCD (2017) Ballistic efficiency of multilayered
ence Forum, pp 14–19 armor systems with sisal fiber polyester composites. Mater Res
78. Yahaya R, Sapuan S, Jawaid M, Leman Z, Zainudin E (2014) 20:767–774
Quasi-static penetration and ballistic properties of kenaf–aramid 97. Neves Monteiro S, de Oliveira Braga F, Pereira Lima E, Henrique
hybrid composites. Mater Des 63:775–782 Leme Louro L, Wieslaw Drelich J (2017) Promising curaua fiber-
79. Shalwan A, Yousif B (2013) In state of art: mechanical and tri- reinforced polyester composite for high-impact ballistic multi-
bological behaviour of polymeric composites based on natural layered armor. Polymer Eng Sci 57(9):947–954
fibres. Mater Des 48:14–24 98. Monteiro SN, Milanezi TL, Louro LHL, Lima ÉP Jr, Braga FO,
80. Shinoj S, Visvanathan R, Panigrahi S, Kochubabu M (2011) Oil Gomes AV, Drelich JW (2016) Novel ballistic ramie fabric com-
palm fiber (OPF) and its composites: A review. Ind Crops Prod posite competing with KevlarTM fabric in multilayered armor.
33(1):7–22 Mater Des 96:263–269
81. Bénézet J-C, Stanojlovic-Davidovic A, Bergeret A, Ferry 99. de Oliveira Braga F, Bolzan LT, da Luz FS, Lopes PHLM, Lima
L, Crespy A (2012) Mechanical and physical properties of ÉP Jr, Monteiro SN (2017) High energy ballistic and fracture
expanded starch, reinforced by natural fibres. Ind Crops Prod comparison between multilayered armor systems using non-
37(1):435–440 woven curaua fabric composites and aramid laminates. J Mater
82. Swolfs Y, Gorbatikh L, Verpoest I (2014) Fibre hybridisation Res Technol 6(4):417–422
in polymer composites: a review. Compos A Appl Sci Manuf 100. Park JL, Chi Y-S, Kang TJ (2013) Ballistic performance of
67:181–200 hybrid panels composed of unidirectional/woven fabrics. Text
83. Wang R-M, Zheng S-R, Zheng YG (2011) Polymer matrix com- Res J 83(5):471–486
posites and technology, Elsevier 101. Randjbaran E, Zahari R, Jalil A, Aswan N, Majid AA, Laila D
84. Cicala G, Pergolizzi E, Piscopo F, Carbone D, Recca G (2018) (2014) Hybrid composite laminates reinforced with kevlar/car-
Hybrid composites manufactured by resin infusion with a fully bon/glass woven fabrics for ballistic impact testing. Sci World J
recyclable bioepoxy resin. Compos B Eng 132:69–76 2014
13
Journal of Polymers and the Environment
102. Roy R, Laha A, Awasthi N, Majumdar A, Butola BS (2018) Multi 123. Ravishankar K, Kulkarni S (2018) Ballistic impact study on jute-
layered natural rubber coated woven P-aramid and UHMWPE fab- epoxy and natural rubber sandwich composites. Mater Today: Pro-
ric composites for soft body armor application. Polym Compos ceed 5(2):6916–6923
39(10):3636–3644 124. Kumar GR, Vijayanandh R, Kumar MS, Kumar SS (2018) Experi-
103. López-Alba E, Schmeer S, Díaz F (2018) Energy absorption capac- mental testing and numerical simulation on natural composite for
ity in natural fiber reinforcement composites structures. Materials aerospace applications. AIP Conf Proceed 090045
11(3):418 125. Bari K (2017) Experimental and simulation performance for fan
104. Ramakrishnan KR, Corn S, Le Moigne N, Ienny P, Leger R, Slan- extraction system. Global J Res Eng
gen PR (2017) High speed imaging for assessment of impact dam- 126. Abu Seman SAH, Ahmad R, Md Akil H (2019) Experimental and
age in natural fibre biocomposites. International Society for Optics numerical investigations of kenaf natural fiber reinforced composite
and Photonics, Optical Measurement Systems for Industrial Inspec- subjected to impact loading. Polymer Comp 40(3):909–915
tion X, p 103290P 127. Sangamesh R, Ravishankar K, Kulkarni S (2018) Study on Ballis-
105. Saidane EH, Scida D, Assarar M, Ayad R (2017) Damage mecha- tic Energy Absorption Capability of Glass-Epoxy and Jute-Epoxy-
nisms assessment of hybrid flax-glass fibre composites using acous- Rubber Sandwich Composites. Trans Tech Publ, Materials Science
tic emission. Compos Struct 174:1–11 Forum, pp 14–19
106. Akil HM, Santulli C, Sarasini F, Tirillò J, Valente T (2014) Envi- 128. Miranda P, Pajares A, Meyers MA (2019) Bioinspired compos-
ronmental effects on the mechanical behaviour of pultruded jute/ ite segmented armour: Numerical simulations. J Market Res
glass fibre-reinforced polyester hybrid composites. Compos Sci 8(1):1274–1287
Technol 94:62–70 129. Coupland RM, Thali MJ, Kneubuehl BP (2011) Introduction to
107. De Rosa IM, Santulli C, Sarasini F, Valente M (2009) Effect of wound ballistics. In: Wound Ballistics
loading-unloading cycles on impact-damaged jute/glass hybrid 130. Karger B, Nüsse R, Bajanowski T (2002) Backspatter on the fire-
laminates. Polym Compos 30(12):1879–1887 arm and hand in experimental close-range gunshots to the head.
108. De Rosa IM, Santulli C, Sarasini F (2009) Acoustic emission for Am J Forensic Med Pathol 23(3):211–213
monitoring the mechanical behaviour of natural fibre composites: 131. Das R, Collins A, Verma A, Fernandez J, Taylor M (2015) Evaluat-
A literature review. Compos A Appl Sci Manuf 40(9):1456–1469 ing simulant materials for understanding cranial backspatter from
109. Liang S, Gning P-B, Guillaumat L (2015) Quasi-static behaviour a ballistic projectile. J Forensic Sci 60(3):627–637
and damage assessment of flax/epoxy composites. Mater Des 132. Davidson PL, Taylor MC, Wilson SJ, Walsh KA, Kieser JA (2012)
67:344–353 Physical components of soft-tissue ballistic wounding and their
110. Sarasini F, Tirillò J, Sergi C, Seghini MC, Cozzarini L, Graupner involvement in the generation of blood backspatter. J Forensic Sci
N (2018) Effect of basalt fibre hybridisation and sizing removal on 57(5):1339–1342
mechanical and thermal properties of hemp fibre reinforced HDPE 133. Braga FD, Bolzan LT, Ramos F, Monteiro SN, Lima EP, da Silva
composites. Comp Struct LC (2017) Ballistic Efficiency of Multilayered Armor Systems with
111. Petrucci R, Santulli C, Puglia D, Nisini E, Sarasini F, Tirillò J, Sisal Fiber Polyester Composites. Mater Res-Ibero-Am J Mater
Torre L, Minak G, Kenny J (2015) Impact and post-impact dam- 20:767–774
age characterisation of hybrid composite laminates based on basalt 134. Nascimento LFC, Louro LHL, Monteiro SN, Gomes AV, Marçal
fibres in combination with flax, hemp and glass fibres manufactured RLSB, Júnior L, Pereira É, Margem JI (2017) Ballistic performance
by vacuum infusion. Compos B Eng 69:507–515 of mallow and jute natural fabrics reinforced epoxy composites in
112. Haque R, Saxena M, Shit SC, Asokan P (2015) Fibre-matrix Adhe- multilayered armor. Mater Res 20:399–403
sion and Properties Evaluation of Sisal Polymer Composite. Fibers 135. Braga FD, Bolzan LT, da Luz FS, Lopes P, Lima EP, Monteiro SN
and Polymers 16(1):146–152 (2017) High energy ballistic and fracture comparison between mul-
113. Tarfaoui M, Akesbi S (2001) A finite element model of mechanical tilayered armor systems using non-woven curaua fabric composites
properties of plain weave. Colloids Surf, A 187:439–448 and aramid laminates. J Mater Res Technol-Jmr&T 6(4):417–422
114. Kumar S, Gupta DS, Singh I, Sharma A (2010) Behavior of kevlar/ 136. Cooper G, Gotts P (2005) Ballistic protection, Springer pp. 67–90
epoxy composite plates under ballistic impact. J Reinf Plast Com- 137. Medvedovski E (2010) Ballistic performance of armour
pos 29(13):2048–2064 ceramics: Influence of design and structure Part 1. Ceram Int
115. Simons J, Erlich D, Shockey D (2001),Finite element design model 36(7):2103–2115
for ballistic response of woven fabrics. SRI Int 9 138. Shokrieh MM, Javadpour GH (2008) Penetration analysis of a pro-
116. D’Amato E (2001) Finite element modeling of textile composites. jectile in ceramic composite armor. Compos Struct 82(2):269–276
Compos Struct 54(4):467–475 139. Monteiro SN, Braga FD, Lima E, Louro LHL, Drelich JW (2017)
117. Lim C, Shim V, Ng Y (2003) Finite-element modeling of the bal- Promising curaua fiber-reinforced polyester composite for high-
listic impact of fabric armor. Int J Impact Eng 28(1):13–31 impact ballistic multilayered armor. Polym Eng Sci 57(9):947–954
118. D’Amato E (2005) Nonlinearities in mechanical behavior of textile 140. de Assis FS, Pereira AC, da Costa Garcia F, Lima Filho ÉP, Mon-
composites. Compos Struct 71(1):61–67 terio SN, Weber RP (2018) Performance of jute non-woven mat
119. Abtew MA, Boussu F, Bruniaux P, Loghin C, Cristian I (2019) Bal- reinforced polyester matrix composite in multilayered armor. J
listic impact mechanisms-A review on textiles and fibre-reinforced Mater Res Technol 7(4):535–540
composites impact responses. Comp Struct 110966. 141. de Oliveira Braga F, Milanezi TL, Monteiro SN, Louro LHL,
120. Rodríguez Millán M, Moreno CE, Marco M, Santiuste C, Miguélez Gomes AV, Lima ÉP Jr (2018) Ballistic comparison between
H (2016) Numerical analysis of the ballistic behaviour of Kevlar® epoxy-ramie and epoxy-aramid composites in Multilayered Armor
composite under impact of double-nosed stepped cylindrical pro- Systems. J Mater Res Technol 7(4):541–549
jectiles. J Reinforced Plastics Comp 35(2):124–137
121. Soydan AM, Tunaboylu B, Elsabagh AG, Sarı AK, Akdeniz R Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
(2018) Simulation and experimental tests of ballistic impact on jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
composite laminate armor. Adv Mater Sci Eng 2018
122. Ramezani A, Rothe H. Investigating different ballistic threats to
validate the simulation model of fiber-reinforced plastics.
13