Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract-A six-phase six-step voltage-fed induction motor is pre- 3) Rotor harmonic losses are reduced from the level
sented. The inverter is a transistorized six-step voltage source inverter, produced in three-phase six-step systems.
while the motor is a modified standard three-phase squirrel-cage motor. 4) The total system reliability is improved by providing for
The stator is rewound with two three-phase winding sets displaced from
each other by 30 electrical degrees. A model for the system is developed to continued system operation with degraded performance fol-
simulate the drive and predict its performance. The simulation results for lowing loss of excitation to one of the machine stator phases.
steady-state conditions and experimental measurements show very good Previous multiphase investigations have been conducted to
correlation. It is shown that this winding configuration results in the explore the merits of multiphase motor drive systems and to
elimination of all air-gap flux time harmonics of the order (6v ± 1, v = develop mathematical models for analyzing the performance
13,5,* Consequently, all rotor copper losses produced by these
harmonics as well as all torque harmonics of the order (6v, v = 1,3,5, ) of these systems. For the case of voltage excitation, Ward and
are eliminated. A comparison between-the measured instantaneous torque Harer [3] investigated the performance of a five-phase ten-step
of both three-phase and six-phase six-step voltage-fed induction machines voltage-fed induction motor drive system. The dominant
shows the advantage of the six-phase system over the three-phase system torque ripple in this system was the tenth harmonic with
in eliminating the sixth harmonic dominant torque ripple.
amplitude of one-third of the sixth harmonic produced in
similar three-phase system. However, the line current was rich
I. INTRODUCTION in third and higher order harmonics which resulted in higher
DURING THE PAST decade, interest in multiphase motor losses. Analog computer simulation of a six-step
systems with more than three phases has increased for voltage-fed six-phase motor with two three-phase stator
various reasons. For power system applications, the high winding sets in [4] predicted that 30 electrical degrees
phase order (HPO) transmission system has been investigated displacement between the two sets eliminates the sixth
as a means of increasing the capacity of overhead electric harmonic pulsating torque component. Simulation results for
power transmission rights of way [1], [2]. For motor drive this case predicted torque ripple amplitudes of only 20 percent
applications, multiphase system could potentially meet the of the comparable three-phase system values along with
demand for high-power electric drive systems which are both substantial reductions of the rotor current harmonic compo-
rugged and energy-efficient. Key advantages of multiphase nents.
induction motor drive systems over conventional three-phase The steady-state torque-speed characteristics with (n) and
systems are summarized as follows. (n - 1)-phase sinusoidal excitation for three-, six-, and nine-
1) Reduction of the required inverter phase current permits phase motors were presented by Klingshirn [5], [6]. The
the use of a single power device for each inverter switch effects of the coil pitch on the harmonic content of the stator
instead of a group of devices connected in parallel. Problems current were pointed out. A six-phase induction generator has
of static and dynamic current sharing among parallel devices, been reported [7].
such as bipolar transistors, are therby eliminated in large drive For the current excitation case, Jaschke [8] analyzed the
systems. effect of the number of stator phases on the torque pulsation in
2) The sixth harmonic pulsating torque associated wih current source inverter (CSI) induction motor drive systems.
conventional three-phase six-step voltage-fed induction motor Lipo [9] developed a d-q model for the six-phase induction
drives is eliminated by the appropriate choice of a multiphase machine including the effects of slot leakage coupling. The
motor winding configuration. resulting model was simulated on an analog computer to
investigate the influence of this coupling on the performance
Paper IPCSD 83-63, approved by the Industrial Drive's Committee of the
of a CSI-fed machine. Andersen and Bieniek [10], [11]
IEEE Industry Applications Society for presentation at the 1983 Industry described the performance of a six-phase CSI-fed induction
Applications Society Annual Meeting, Mexico City, Mexico, October 3-7. A motor and its advantages over three-phase machines fed by
version of this paper was first published in the Conference Record IEEE-LAS- either single or double current source inverters. An extensive
1983 Annual Meeting. Manuscript released for present publication December
17, 1983. investigation of the steady-state and transient characteristics of
M. A. Abbas and R. Christen are with Gould Inc., Gould Research Center, n-phase induction motor drive systems with (n - 1)-phase
40 Gould Center, Rolling Meadows, IL 60008. excitation for both voltage and current source invetters was
T. M. Jahns is with the General Electric Company, Research and
Development Center, Building 37-325, P.O. Box 43, Schenectady, NY presented in [12].
12301. This paper presents the steady-state characteristics of a six-
0093-9994/84/0900-1 2511$1 .00 © 1984 IEEE
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DELHI. Downloaded on December 12,2021 at 14:31:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1252 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. IA-20, NO. 5, SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 1984
E C
phase squirrel-cage induction motor excited by a voltage distribution during balanced excitation would be the same as
source inverter. The transistorized inverter delivers six-step for a single three-phase winding; in;this case, motor perform-
voltage excitation to the motor, which is a modified industrial ance would be indistinguishable for the three- and six-phase
three-phase machine rewound with a six-phase stator winding. configurations.
The stator windings consist of two three-phase winding sets In the laboratory system, the six-phase inverter consists of
displaced by 30 electrical degrees. A model is presented for 12 power transistor switches arranged in two three-phase full-
the six-phase induction machine based on the generalized two- bridge modules. During balanced six-phase excitation, these
phase real component tranformation. This model has been inverter switches are controlled to deliver standard six-step
used to simulate the drive performance during steady-state voltage waveforms to each of the three-phase sets of stator
operation and provide results to compare with experimental windings. The two three-phase sets of excitation waveforms
measurements. Measured instantaneous torque waveforms for are separated in time phase by 30 electrical degrees, consistent
both six-phase and three-phase systems are presented and with the space separation of the stator winding sets for
compared. balanced excitation. Motor terminal volts/hertz is held nearly
II. SYSTEM DESCRIPTION constant by deriving the excitation frequency from measure-
ments of the dc link voltage. Power transistor base drive
The system investigated in this work consists of a six-phase
circuits and all other low power control circuits are of
squirrel-cage induction motor excited by a full-bridge voltage
conventional design and require no additional discussion to be
source inverter as shown in Fig. 1. A phase-controlled
rectifier provides a variable dc voltage for the dc link inverter devoted to these parts of the experimental system.
input.
At the heart of this system is an industrial-grade 20-hp SYSTEM MODEL
III.
squirrel-cage induction motor modified for this program. The In order to gain a fuller understanding of system behavior,
stator of this machine has been rewound in such a way that the an analytical model of the multiphase motor-inverter system
windings can be connected in either a three-phase or six-phase has been developed for system simulation on a digital
configuration. As illustrated in Fig. 2, -the six-phase configura- computer. Considering the limited amount of technical litera-
tion consists of two three-phase;sets separated by 30 electrical ture describing the detailed operation of such systems,
degrees. Note that the neutrals of these two sets are not availability of this type of model is invaluable for investigating
connected. By setting the separation angle at 30 degrees, all of the effects of individual motor and excitation parameters on
the air-gap flux components of orders (6v + 1, v = system performance. The following assumptions and approxi-
1,3,5,***) contributed by the six stator phases cancel each mations have been adopted in the process of developing this
other during balanced excitation. As a result, the air-gap flux model.
.is inherently free of several potentially troublesome time
harmonic components, such as the fifth and seventh harmon- 1) The machine air gap is uniform.
ics, regardless of the harmonic contents of the stator phase 2) Motor stator and rotor windings are sinusoidally distrib-
excitation waveforms. Note also that if the separation angle uted.
had been set at 60 electrical degrees, the air-gap flux 3) Magnetic saturation of the machine iron is neglected.
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DELHI. Downloaded on December 12,2021 at 14:31:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
ABBAS et al.: SIX-PHASE VOLTAGE SOURCE INVERTER DRIVEN INDUCTION MOTOR I1253
4) Eddy current, friction, and windage losses are ne- a A
glected. 1B
5) Inverter switching devices are ideal (zero impedance
when on, infinite impedance when off). i F
6) The dc link power supply is an ideal voltage source.
The first four assumptions are often adopted in this type of D
induction machine analysis in order to neglect air-gap space 9
harmonics and magnetic nonlinearities which complicate the Fig. 3. Winding axes for 12-phase and six-phase windings.
use of linear analysis techniques. The last two assumptions
eliminate the effects of power supply and inverter impedance as follows:
from the analysis, resulting in ideal voltage excitation wave- Va = -Vg .a = g
forms at the motor stator terminals. Taken together, these
assumptions simplify the analysis and are consistent with the Ub = - Vh lb = h
-Vs; RRs+LsP 0 0 0 MP 0
VS3 0 R+LsP 0 0 MP
is-v
VS-v 0 0 Rs+Ls5P 0 0 0
VS6 0 0 0 Rs+LLsP 0 0
-corLr
-
crM MP 0 O Rr+LrP
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DELHI. Downloaded on December 12,2021 at 14:31:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1 254 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. IA-20, NO. 5, SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 1984
M= (6\l/k/2)Lsr. +
rMIsa
M -
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DELHI. Downloaded on December 12,2021 at 14:31:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
ABBAS et al.: SIX-PHASE VOLTAGE SOURCE INVERTER DRIVEN INDUCTION MOTOR 1255
20.00- -
0
i 0.00-
- 20.00 -
110.00 114.00 118.00
NORMALIZED TIME (rad)
(a)
setup for six-phase induction motor-drive system.
40.00 -
'a E
E Ul
-
z
Z 0.00 -
Lu wr
C).l
cc,
-40.00 _
110.00 114.00 118.00
110.00 114.00 118.00 NORMALIZED TIME (rad)
NORMALIZED TIME (rad)
(a)
(a)
(b) (b)
Fig. 7. Phase current waveform at light load. (a) Simulated. (b) Measured, Fig. 8. Phase current waveform at 0.7 pu rated torque. (a) Simulated. (b)
10 A/div, 2 ms/div. Measured, 10 A/div, 2 ms/div.
frequencies the presence of sixth harmonic pulsating torque tolerable levels, provided that the multiphase induction motor
component is clearly apparent only in the torque waveforms is properly designed and excited.
recorded with three-phase excitation. The amplitude of the
torque ripple in Fig. 9 for the three-phase cases is roughly 11 V. CONCLUSION
percent of the average torque, while the detectable torque This paper presents a summary of several key analytical and
ripple for the six-phase torque waveforms is only 3.5 percent. experimental results gathered during a recent investigation of
Even though such quantitative comparisons must be treated multiphase (in excess of three) induction motors excited by
carefully, the qualitative advantage of the six-phase configura- voltage source inverters. Specifically, a six-phase squirrel-
tion in reducing torque ripple amplitude is clearly evident in cage induction motor consisting of two three-phase stator
the empirical results. winding sets separated by 30 electrical degrees is studied in
During the course of this empirical testing, motor phase this work. In the laboratory prototype system, the motor is
current waveforms in the three-phase and six-phase stator excited by a transistorized voltage-controlled inverter.
winding configurations were observed and compared. Similar- An analytical model for the multiphase motor system has
ities between the current waveshapes for three-phase and six- been presented based on the generalized two-phase real
phase excitation are quite apparent in the waveforms provided component transformation of motor equations. It has been
in Fig. 11 for similar lightly loaded test conditions at 10-Hz shown that this transformation leads to. the generation of four
excitation frequency. It has been observed that the peak independent machine equivalent circuits, only two of which
normalized phase currents measured under similar test condi- involve coupling between the stator and rotor quantities and
tions during three-phase and six-phase excitation are not hence, torque production. Similarities between these equiva-
significantly different in the prototype system, although no lent circuits for the six-phase motor and the familiar d-q-o
far-reaching conclusion on this point is attempted here. circuits associated with a three-phase machine have been
Nevertheless, these comparisons suggest that it is possible to pointed out.
limit peak stator phase current in the six-phase system to These transformed machine equivalent circuits also indicate
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DELHI. Downloaded on December 12,2021 at 14:31:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
ABBAS et al.: SIX-PHASE VOLTAGE SOURCE INVERTER DRIVEN INDUCTION MOTOR 1257
40.00 -
E
uJ
3 20.00- = 20.00-
0
cc00
rs
I-
I
110.00 114.00 118.00 110.00 114.00 118.00
NORMALIZED TIME (rad) NORMALIZED TIME (rad)
(a) (b)
Fig. 9. Developed torque waveforms. (a) Light load. (b) 0.7 pu rated
torque.
10 Hz. 10 ms
(c) (d)
Fig. 10.Instantaneous shaft torque for both three-phase and six-phase six-
step voltage-fed induction motor. (a) 3 o, 250 r/min. (b) 6 X, 248 r/min.
(c) 3 o, 586 r/min. (d) 6 X, 589 r/min.
(a) (b)
Fig. 11. Phase current waveform at 10-Hz fundamental frequency. (a)
Three-phase. (b) Six-phase.
uthorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DELHI. Downloaded on December 12,2021 at 14:31:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply
1258 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. IA-20, NO. 5, SEPTEMBER/OCTOBER 1984
that current harmonics in the six-phase motor of orders (6v + q Number of pole pairs.
1, V = 1,3,5, - do not contribute to the air-gap flux and J Moment of inertia.
thus do not participate in pulsating torque or rotor copper loss T Torque.
production. However, the amplitudes of these current harmon- P Differential operator.
ics are a matter of concern in the voltage source system, being n,k Number of stator, rotor phases.
limited only by the stator resistance and leakage inductances
between the stator phases. Additional investigation into Subscripts
techniques for controlling the amplitudes of these undesirable A,B,- Six-phase variable in alphabetical order.
- -
dominant pulsating torque component in a three-phase system, two phase component variables vector. The transformation
matrix is
A -i This column
n exists
only if n
is even
i/1.2 cos (n-l)ct cos2(n-1)a . 1/12 *.
** sin 2(n - I)a sin (n - l)cr
has been empirically verified. Results from the six-phase .X=-- [Xa, Xb,9 , Xz],
prototype system also demonstrate that it is possible to design phase variables vector,
the system such that the peak normalized stator phase currents
are not significantly higher than in an equivalent three-phase 2r=
a- =
system with basic six-step voltage excitation waveforms. n
Taken together, these results encourage further development A -1 -At.
of the multiphase induction motor concept for specialized high
power drive applications. APPENDIX II
VI. NONENCLATURE PHASE VARIABLE MACHINE MODEL
Variables The phase variable mathematical model for n-phase stator
i.v Instantaneous current, voltage. and k-phase rotor induction machine in matrix form is
X Instantaneous angular velocity.
R,L Resistance, inductance.
M Mutual inductance. Lv J L PL' Rrr+ PLrr] [i]
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DELHI. Downloaded on December 12,2021 at 14:31:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
ABBAS et al.: SIX-PHASE VOLTAGE SOURCE INVERTER DRIVEN INDUCTION MOTOR 1259
where [11] "Der Asynchronmotor mit drei und sechs Wicklungs-strangen
,
Authorized licensed use limited to: INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY DELHI. Downloaded on December 12,2021 at 14:31:16 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply