1

Theory of Mind

Student’s Name

Institution

Course

Instructor

Date
 2

Theory of Mind

Meaning of Theory of Mind

Theory of mind (TOM), which includes the capacity to ruminate both your own and other

people's mental processes, is a fundamental social-cognitive ability in psychology. It includes the

capacity to assign psychological conditions, such as emotions, desires, philosophies, and

knowledge, and the understanding that other individuals may hold opinions that are different

from one person to another (Cuzzolin et al., 2020). When people have a theory of mind, it allows

them to perceive that others have unique concepts and goals that are distinctive from their own,

which allows them to partake in routine human connection as they decipher the cognitive states

and predict the conduct of those around them. The knowledge of the mind must mature in the

formative period. Young children are more inconsiderate and normally unable to evaluate the

psychological states of others. As individuals get older, their philosophy of thoughts matures and

changes. In order to understand human cognition, predict human behavior, communicate with

others, and settle interpersonal conflicts, people need to have a strong theory of mind.

Individuals are only sometimes birth awareness of the diversity of people's beliefs and

ambitions from themselves. Infants need several developmental antecedents to develop their

theory of mind. Individuals must first acquire specific skills in order to stand on the theory of

mind's platform, such as comprehending the idea of being seen, comprehending others'

motivations, and imitating them (Bjorklund, 2022). The preschool years, between 3 and 5, are

considered the key developmental period for this capacity to associate mental states. However,

the formation of a theory of mind is thought to be influenced by various variables. Theory of

mind propagates as a child gains more societal communication understanding. Youngsters can

have a profound appreciation of how different people's outlooks might contrast through
 3

performance, make-believe play, fictions, and associations with close relative and peers.

Children learn more about how thinking affects behavior through social encounters as well.

The False Belief Task and how it relates to Theory of Mind Development

False belief tasks (FBT) are employed in most studies to gauge the theory of mind. Most

theory of mind investigations are conducted on newborns and toddlers. Since this model

developed, scholars have been attentive in the age at which individuals commence to embrace a

theory of mind. The false belief tasks assess how individuals contemplate about their judgements

and those of others. In the tasks, the kids must guess that someone else does not know something

they do (Kano et al., 2019). For example, children are asked what they expect to find in a candy

box after being shown that it contains pennies instead of candy. These activities are designed to

help kids conclude what others have done or are thinking when those conclusions disagree with

what they already know. In other words, even while kids may know something to be true, they

must also be conscious that others could not be aware of it.

The Sally-Anne test, in which children are shown two dolls with the names Sally and

Anne; Sally has a basket, and Anne has a box, is one of the most popular false belief tests. After

putting a stone in her basket, Sally exits the room. Anne takes out the stone from the basket and

puts it in the carton while she is gone. After seeing this scene, we ask kids where they think Sally

will seek for the stone when she comes back (Brauner et al., 2018). The children's responses

reveal information about their mental models. If a child answers, "Sally will look in the basket,"

they have passed the exam. It shows that these kids know Sally's misconception regarding the

marble's actual location. Children must be able to consider what Sally believes and thinks in

order to pass the test. However, kids who claim the marble is in the box fail the test. They do not

show that they realize Sally knows distinct from their own. The false belief task is important to
 4

TOM research because it demonstrates that kids understand that someone can be wrong about

something they understand. It is because the theory of mind involves the understanding that

every individual does not think and feel the same way as others. It enables people to anticipate

and analyze other people's actions.

Results from False Belief Task Studies from Across the World

According to researchers, diverse longings, diverse views, information admittance, false

opinions, and concealed emotions are the five fundamental constituents of the theory of mind

that all children between the ages of three and five should develop sequentially (Brauner et al.,

2018). While the foundation for the development of the theory of mind appears to be laid by

these phases of development across demographic groups, diverse cultures place wavering

amounts of prominence on each of the five abilities, making some cultivate later than others. In

other words, the sequence in which these five developmental indicators are ingrained in a child's

memory depends on their cultural significance. Individuals who are valued more often advance

before those who are less valued. For instance, in individualistic countries like the U.S., the

capacity to acknowledge that people hold diverse perspectives and beliefs is given more weight.

This skill, however, is less valued in more collectivistic societies like China; therefore, it might

only develop later.

According to research by Ruhl (2020), Iranian children comprehended knowledge access

before different views. In contrast, information access was comprehended by participants from

Australia, who come from a more individualist society. Researchers theorize that this change in

the developmental order is due to the collectivism-based cultures in Iran and China, which

emphasize interdependence and mutual knowledge, as opposed to the individualism-based

cultures in Western nations, which encourage individuality and respect diverse viewpoints. Due
 5

to these disparate cultural norms, Iranian and Chinese children may need more time to

comprehend that others hold diverse thoughts and perspectives (Ruhl, 2020). It implies that

social and cultural factors and natural brain processes might influence the development of the

theory of mind. Markedly, the academics learned that the entire degrees of the theory of mind

mastery did not significantly vary between cultures, demonstrating that people from all cultures

may master this talent while using various developmental pathways.

Criticisms of the FBT as a Measure of TOM Development

The study by Bloom and German (2000) critiques and recommends deserting the FBT as

an assessment of the TOM. They explain that the capacity to think rationally about incorrect

beliefs is not required for the theory of mind to pass the FBT. The most challenging issue is that

tasks involving erroneous beliefs are inherently challenging. It is so that the youngster can at

least reason about a false belief, which is required for any task involving false beliefs.

Additionally, children struggle with common false belief activities even when not required to use

reasoning to evaluate false beliefs. The researchers found that the theory of mind is more than

just passing the FBT (Bloom & German, 2000). Children can alter their behavior in response to

other people's knowledge states, and they may also have a tacit understanding of the

circumstances in which beliefs are formed. They conclude that success in a false belief task

indicates a child's intellectual ability more than failure. The task can be used to locate and study

adults, older children, and those with language and mental impairments..

Conclusion

Theory of mind involves a person's ability to take into account both their own and other

people's mental states. The investigation on the theory of mind uses false belief tasks to assess
 6

how individuals deliberate about their views and those of others. The false belief task is

important to TOM research because it demonstrates that children understand that someone can

be wrong about something they understand. While the foundation for the development of the

theory of mind appears to be laid by these phases of development across demographic groups,

altered cultures put fluctuating amounts of importance on each of the abilities, making some

cultivate later than others. However, researchers found that the general degrees of the theory of

mind knwledge did not significantly change between cultures, demonstrating that people from all

cultures may master this talent using various developmental pathways.

 7

References

Bjorklund, D. F. (2022). Children’s evolved learning abilities and their implications for

education. Educational Psychology Review, 1-31.

Bloom, P., & German, T. P. (2000). Two reasons to abandon the false belief task as a test of theory of

mind. Cognition, 77(1), B25–B31. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0010-0277(00)00096-2

Braüner, T., Polyanskaya, I., & Blackburn, P. (2018). A logical investigation of false-belief tasks.

In CogSci.

Cuzzolin, F., Morelli, A., Cirstea, B., & Sahakian, B. J. (2020). Knowing me, knowing you: theory of

mind in AI. Psychological medicine, 50(7), 1057-1061.

Kano, F., Krupenye, C., Hirata, S., Tomonaga, M., & Call, J. (2019). Great apes use self-experience to

anticipate an agent’s action in a false-belief test. Proceedings of the National Academy of

Sciences, 116(42), 20904-20909.

Ruhl, C. (2020). Theory of mind. Simply Psychology, 2020, August 7.