Professional Documents
Culture Documents
org/ at CAPES-UNIVERSIDADE DE
SAO PAULO on August 21, 2020
M A R I A A. M A N G E - R A J E T Z K Y
Department of Earth Sciences, Oxford University, Parks Road, Oxford, OX1 3PR, UK
Abstract: The subdivision and correlation of monotonous siliciclastic sequences with poor
biostratigraphic control and few lithostratigraphic markers has long been a problem. The
need to find an efficient approach is even greater for subsurface sequences where
information from cores and wireline logs has proved inadequate. In this short paper a
novel approach, high-resolution heavy minerals analysis (HRHMA), is introduced, which is
particularly suitable for the subdivision of problematical clastic sediments where other
techniques are inconclusive. A full paper, which will present the technique in more detail,
will be published shortly.
High-resolution heavy mineral analysis colour, internal structure, etc. The measurement
(HRHMA) is based on the recognition that the of grain shape (degree of roundness and
majority of rock-forming and accessory minerals sphericity) is a standard sediment petrological
show a wide diversity of size, habit, colour, procedure and is an important part in the
internal structure, chemistry and optical proper- description of sedimentary textures. It has been
ties, controlled principally by specific conditions in general use since the 1930s (Wadell 1935;
during crystallization. Since a wide range of Cailleux 1947, 1952; Powers 1953, 1982; Pryor
lithologies provide detritus to siliciclastic sedi- 1971; Pettijohn et al. 1973). Colour varieties,
ments, their heavy mineral assemblages are especially those of zircon, can be provenance-
complex and an individual heavy mineral species diagnostic; for example, Mackie (1923) and
may comprise several kinds of varieties, each Tomita (1954) successfully traced sediments to
preserving a different genetic and/or sedimento- respective parent lithologies by using purple
logical history. zircon varieties. Structural types of zircon
(showing either euhedral zoning or overgrowth,
The technique etc.) are significant since they are linked to
specific parageneses (Speer 1980).
Principles and practice In the present case, zircon, tourmaline and
apatite varieties were distinguished. The most
HRHMA records diagnostic varieties of indivi- informative morphological categories range
dual heavy minerals, thus the number of from sharp euhedral (such as zircon) or pris-
variables is significantly higher compared to matic crystals with sharp terminations (e.g.
those of a simple, species-level, analysis. Distin- tourmaline, apatite) through rounded prisms,
guishing the varietal types of the chemically subrounded morphologies to well-rounded and
highly resistant minerals, such as zircon, spherical grains. Zircons exhibiting zoning or
tourmaline and, when suitable, apatite prove overgrowth were recorded separately. The col-
most rewarding since they are ubiquitous and ourless and pink to purple zircon types were also
remain stable during diagenesis. Therefore, allocated into separate categories. During ana-
HRHMA is especially useful in the study of lysis the total of 100 varietal grains for each
sediments from which the diagnostic but species were point counted and then recalculated
chemically unstable species were eliminated by into relative percentages.
post-depositional dissolution, leaving a residue
of ultrastable zircon + tourmaline + rutile + Application
apatite (Mange & Maurer 1992). An important
advantage of this technique is that, because it The Triassic continental red beds of the Central
deals with each particular species, the influence Graben of the North Sea - Quadrants 22 and
of modifying factors [especially hydraulic and 29, UK, and Quadrants 6 and 7, Norway (Fig. 1)
diagenetic (Morton 1985)] is considerably - a r e lithologically monotonous and comprise
reduced. In addition to core samples, HRHMA alternations of dominantly red mudstones,
can be successfully applied to cuttings. siltstones and sandstones, representative of
Variables are based on grain morphology, alluvial fan, fluvial, sabkha and lacustrine
From Dunay, R. E. & Hailwood, E. A. (eds), 1995, Non-biostratigraphical Methods of Dating and Correlation 23
Geological Society Special Publication No. 89, pp. 23-30
Downloaded from http://sp.lyellcollection.org/ at CAPES-UNIVERSIDADE DE
SAO PAULO on August 21, 2020
24 M.A. MANGE-RAJETZKY
W
In
- :.....................~ ........
:i:i:i:i:!:i:iii:i:i:i:"
Q.22
: !!ii!i!i::..
~,
iiii iii6 ii !
iiiiii;i~i~:~?ii!i})ilil)ilililiiiiiii)iiii)il;iii~
::i:i:i: ii~:i:i:ili!i:i:i:i:i:i!ili:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i::~
=========================
~ :!:!:i::i:i:i:i:,. t~ ::: ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
........................................
::!i~i~i~iiiii!~[ : ::~i!iiiii~i!iiiiiiii:..
~ , :::!ililililili!i~ii!ii~i::.
........................ i~!i!!!i!i!!!!!!i~i!i!i!!!!!!!i ....!.i.!!!!!i ...!.i!.i!.i.!i!
t~ :!i[iliiii!!i[~!"ii!ii?i?[i~ii!!?i)i]i?i!ii!iiii?~i!ilili[i:i:i:!iii::
:'
~::~:~....:~:~::~,r ~eii!
)':~i:~:ii:~..
~i?ii)iii?iiii:e~
.~ ~l:~i?i i?i~`:i i~?ii~)ii~::)i!i!i?i?i?i?i?i!1~~)i..!.i)~i~?ii)i;~)~)i?i!i?i~?iii!iii!ii~i~:~~
' ~ ':! ~ :iiiiiii: ::i~i~i~i iiiii:~:i:ii:i:i::i:i:~:i:i:i:i::i:ii:i:~:!:i ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::
,~ '~~~~:.:.i~i~i~i~"I',,,'"
i~i~i~i~: ~iiii~ii:
~iiiiii!i~~!ii;i~iiiiii~)i1iii)i~iiiii;)iii~i;iliiliiii~iii;iiii!iiii~
a~ ....~!iiil;iii;iiiiiiiii~ , ::!iiiiigi
ii~iii
......~iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!i!;iiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiii;!iiii;?
iiiiii?i?iiiii iiiiii N
i?ii)i}?il}?i;ii?i)iiiili!?)iii?i?iii)il}iil}ii)i: N
~ \ X~ I
[-TO
7/,~
,iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii 57~
iii[iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiiiiiiiil-r / ~i!!
:!:i:!:[:!:!:ii!i!:!:i:i:!:?:?:?:!:!:!:!:!:!:i:i:!:):?:!:i:!:):?:!:?~
iiiiii?iiiiiiiiii:iiiii
iiiiiiiiiiiii:iiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
9"a-
i:ii
ii....i.i.....,i,
.i:i!ili:i:i!!!ii i :iSi:i:i:!:S:i.............................
:i:i!i:i!i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i2i:i:!:i:5:i:i :!:i:i•i:i•i:i:i:iSi2!•i:i•S:iSi•i:i:i:i:•:i:i:S•••i:i:i:iSi:S:i:i:i•i:i:i:2:i•!:5•i•i:2:i:i:2•!:?Si:2:i:?S!•i:i:i:•:iSiiiiiii!iii!!i•iii•i
~i:i:i:i:[:i:i:i:!:i:i:i:!:!:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:!:i:i:i:i:i:i:i
i:):!:i:i:i1:i:i:i:~:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:i:~:~:i:i:i:!:i:~:~:i:i:i:i:i:~:i:~:):i:i:i:ii~:ii[i~:i:iiiiiii:i:i:!:i1iiiiiii~
!iii:~iil!:i:ii~!iiiii:!:!:iiiiii:ii:i
i:i:i:::ili:i?i::iii:itilt:i:il;tili:;iilti:ii....................................................................
ili:ii:iti:ili: ::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: \
iiiiiiiiiii~iiiiiiiiiiii~ii}iiii?iii~iai~i}i!i}ii}ii!i;i~ii?i)?!iiiii!iii!
Fig. 1. Map of study area, showing major structural elements of the Central Graben and generalized location of
the analysed wells.
environments, with occasional marine incursions have long been a problem, compounded by their
near to the base. The succession is rarely poor biostratigraphic record.
complete and thickness is extremely variable. Triassic stratigraphy of the central and north-
This is due both to variation in the initial ern North Sea is based on the lithostratigraphy
depositional thickness as a result of accommo- established for geographical areas (Deagan &
dation space available at a particular location, Skull 1977) and subsequently modified by well
controlled by salt-related tectonics (Hodgson et data (Vollset & Dor6 1984; Lervik et al. 1989;
al. 1992), and to erosion due to extensive middle Fisher & Mudge 1990; Cameron 1993). Dating
Jurassic uplift. Their subdivision and correlation the sequences still involves a great deal of
Downloaded from http://sp.lyellcollection.org/ at CAPES-UNIVERSIDADE DE
SAO PAULO on August 21, 2020
Subdivisions
26 M.A. MANGE-RAJETZKY
HIGH R E S O L U T I O N H E A V Y M I N E R A L A N A L Y S I S
REFERENCE WELL
22/24b-5
VARIETIES OF RATIOS OF
TOURMALINE ZIRCON APATITE ZIRCON/TOURMALINE APATITE MORPHOLOGICAL TYPES
Rounded&S pberlcall/ itounckd/
APATITE/ZIRCON ZIRCON/RUTILE RdcLprlsm~&~ubrdd.Spherical
4O m tO |to~.O 20 40 ~0 Io ioo,l,o :m ~ m toloo~ 20 4O 2 4 :1 4 s o 1o 20 t o o 1 4 6
1111111111
A iiiiiii
IH .iiii
111111111ii!iiiiiii iii',iiii,,:
NI$1111111iiii!!!!!!iiii!N ~!:!!:!-!~::"::'
i"':':':":" "
~
llllllllllttlllll
giiiiiiiiiiiiig
qllllllllrlll i!iiHi!iiiiiiiii
llltllllllltlll
I sB iiiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiii
M H Marker Horizon L E G E N D
Tourmalines Zircons
AngularI P r i ~ t i c ~LXXXX.~prxsrnR~ ~ Subromadcd[ ~ Roundedl E ~ b ~ &-~ A n h e ~ a l ~ R~adlCXlms[~pR?n~l~rp~ [ ~ Z ~
Apatites
~ Prismatic l r-'r".".".".'~
& .toundcdlSub~oundr : : :: ] Roundcd~[~ Sphcrical
prtsms ~ i. 9 i ,~ ~ -
Fig. 3. Results of HRHMA, reference Well 22/24b-5, indicating heavy mineral zones and subzones and the
position of the Marker Horizon.
27
=
z
i
I
o
~I~ cr
o
%
=
o
NOIIYI~IOJ NV~I~I~DV~IS ~ |
Downloaded from http://sp.lyellcollection.org/ at CAPES-UNIVERSIDADE DE
SAO PAULO on August 21, 2020
28 M.A. MANGE-RAJETZKY
Whereas in the south Central Graben the menced with limited internal drainage
Skagerrak Formation is subdivided into widely which progressively evolved into a higher
correlatable sandstone and mudstone members energy fluvial regime. This is deduced from
(Goldsmith et al. 1995), this has not been the upwards increase in mineralogical
possible in the north Central Graben. As diversity and enhanced spatial variations.
recounted above, however, results of H R H M A In the lower part of the sequence the main
now provide a framework within which subdivi- source of the detritus was intrabasinal,
sions can be made and this is particularly probably derived from fault scarps, intra-
important for the thick Zone M. Until H R H M A basinal highs and, occasionally, from mar-
has been carried out in the south Central Graben ginal areas such as the East Shetland
the provenance and lithostratigraphic relation- Platform and adjacent contemporary ex-
ships of the two groups of Skagerrak Formation posures (containing pre-Triassic sediments,
sediments are unlikely to be resolved. metasediments and ophiolites of the Cale-
donides). The variations observed in the
Correlation different wells can be interpreted in terms
of separate systems with varying energies
Well-to-well correlation of particular zones was operating at different periods, frequent
achieved by comparing the varietal patterns and intrabasinal reworking and local tectonic
changes in the distributional trends of particular movements. Mineral signatures of subzone
heavy mineral ratios with the wireline log motifs. b (Fig. 4) and its broader spatial extent
An example for confident correlation using point to an expanding drainage network,
heavy mineral varieties is shown by the tourma- reaching distant primary lithologies. This
line patterns in Fig. 4. stage is seen as being the precursor of an
Two distinct correlations are evident; the first event that caused widespread modifications
relates to the upper zone (Zone A) whereas the in palaeogeography.
second connects the underlying intervals: (1) (3) The dramatic change at the MH and the
Zone A has been recognized in the majority of broad basin-wide continuity of Zone A
wells and forms a mineralogically fully-con- represent an event which occurred on a
strained interval. It can be correlated basin- regional scale. By the late Triassic the
wide. In Quadrant 22 and in Well 6/3-1 subzone northward drift of continents caused a
q of Zone M (evolving from Zone SB) and change from a semi-arid to a semi-humid
subzone b (underlying the MH) can be corre- climate. Tectonic pulses initiated uplift in
lated across several wells. Other subzones (e.g. c Scandinavia and Greenland (Ziegler 1978;
and d) have a more limited extent. (2) The lower Jacobsen & van Veen 1984). Prior to these
zones in Quadrant 22 and in Well 6/3-1 differ changes transport of material from Scan-
from those in Quadrant 29 and Quadrant 7 dinavia was inhibited by low energy con-
(Norwegian sector), and consequently cannot be ditions, the existence of intrabasinal highs
correlated with them. and marginal sub-basins adjacent to the
Fenno-Skandian Shield. By Zone A time,
Evolution and provenance increased run-off and basin configuration
permitted the expansion of transport paths
The threefold character of the most complete as far as the Fenno-Scandian complexes,
sequences in Quadrant 22 indicates three phases thereby diluting the previously dominant
of sedimentation: intrabasinal polycyclic suites with abun-
dant first-cycle minerals. The broad spatial
(1) The Smith Bank Formation was deposited dispersal of the first-cycle detritus, shown
in a low energy environment. The wide by the lateral continuity of Zone A, was
spatial distribution and homogenization of promoted by a well-established fluvial
the fine to very fine grained detritus system.
suggests occasional distal sheet floods. Its
polycyclic aspect indicates reworking of Sand provenance in the lower zones in Quadrant
mature pre-existing sediments. High spheri- 29 and Quadrant 7 (Norwegian sector) share
city of the grains, many with a 'frosted' common characteristics, indicated by the fre-
appearance, signal that aeolian (probably quent presence of first-cycle material. However,
marginal Permian) deposits could be im- there is a dissimilarity between Quadrants
portant contributors. 29 + Norwegian sector 7 and Q u a d r a n t s
(2) In the lower subzones of Zone M of the 22 + Well 6/3-1 in the interval below the MH,
Skagerrak Formation sedimentation corn- which suggests that the two groups of sediments
Downloaded from http://sp.lyellcollection.org/ at CAPES-UNIVERSIDADE DE
SAO PAULO on August 21, 2020
30 M.A. MANGE-RAJETZKY
ness and sphericity. AGI Data Sheet 18. American WADELL, H. A. 1935. Volume, shape, and roundness
Geological Institute. of quartz particles. Journal of Geology, 43, 250-
PRYOR, W. A. 1971. Grain Shape. In: CARVER, R. E. 280.
(ed.) Procedures in Sedimentary Petrology. Wiley- VOLLSET, J. & DORE, A. G. (eds) 1984. A revised
Interscience, New York, 131-150. Triassic and Jurassic lithostratigraphic nomencla-
TOMITA, T. 1954. Geologic significance of the colour of ture for the Norwegian North Sea. Norwegian
granite zircon and the discovery of the Precam- Petroleum Directorate, Bulletin 3.
brian in Japan. Kyushu University Memoir, ZIEGLER, P. A. 1978. North-western Europe: Tectonics
Faculty of Science, Series D, Geology, 4, 135-161. and basin development. Geologie en Mijnbouw, 57,
SPEER, J. A. 1980. Zircon. In." RmBE, P. H. (ed.) 509-626.
Reviews in Mineralogy. Vol. 5. Orthosilicates.
Mineralogical Society of America, Washington
DC, 67-112.