Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ms. Sijia LI
E-mail: sijiali@connect.hku.hk
COURSE DESCRIPTION
1. Rationale
Very much alike that of economic and social development, the population of Hong Kong has
undergone substantial changes. The population growth of Hong Kong was initially the result of
largescale refugee migration from Mainland China since the 1930s until the 1950s affected
mostly by political upheavals and the additions through excess of births over deaths associated with
relatively high fertility and low mortality. By the second half of the twentieth century, the size and
composition of the population of Hong Kong have dramatically restructured due to firstly the
settlement of Chinese immigrants into Hong Kong and the wave of the population locally born, then
later the quota system of migration control, rapid declining fertility, and increasing life
expectancy. Today, several important demographic concerns are still pronounced such as the
persistence of low fertility, cross-border marriage, shrinking workforce, and population ageing.
Its demographic characteristics and processes are much influenced by social and political
developments in Mainland China and economic growth and modernization in Hong Kong.
These population dynamics can compound and magnify, if not create, a wide variety of social,
economic and political problems. These changes have significant impacts on our daily lives and
values, education, employment, housing, physical environment, social welfare services, medical
and health care, and old age support, more importantly, economic sustainability. It is of prime
importance to understand the causes and consequences of demographic processes not only from a
historical perspective, but multidisciplinary approaches.
This course is geared towards introducing the various population theories, concepts, facts and general
techniques to enable students to develop a broader and critical thinking of the inter- relatedness of
the demographic, social, cultural, economic and political issues among Hong Kong, Mainland
China and the world. Based on a variety of proactive teaching and learning activities, students are
encouraged to play an active role to use demographic data and information to analyze and
characterize the linkages between population patterns and trends and the socioeconomic, political
and policy issues that associate with Hong Kong and Mainland China and replicate the analysis
to international settings. We shall perform a critical analysis of how the rapid demographic
changes will act upon the community as a whole in terms of manpower planning, healthcare and
social welfare provisions. Population policies specific to Hong Kong will also be discussed.
Three main demographic processes: fertility, mortality and migration will be surveyed to enhance
the understanding of current population, social, economic, cultural and political issues and of
its interconnectedness with particular emphasis on the experiences of Hong Kong and Mainland
China.
Hong Kong’s population had been characterized by its transitionary nature in the past. The greater
part of the population came to Hong Kong mainly for trade and employment without the aim of
settling permanently. Many of those who came from China did not bring their wives and families,
but commuted to and from their places of origin. The 30 year period between 1930 and 1960
was one of the political and economic turmoil for both China and Hong Kong – the World War
II in 1937 for China and the Communist victory over the Nationalists in 1949. Since 1980s,
Hong Kong has grown in a highly industrialized city. With limited natural resources, we are largely
dependent on the deep harbor in favor of export and import trades. By the end of 20th century,
the economy of Hong Kong has transformed quickly and now it becomes one of the world-class
hubs.
From a tiny fishing village to a knowledge-based world city, the transformation and modernization
of Hong Kong is not contingency. Most people in Hong Kong today are themselves immigrants
2
or are the children or grandchildren of immigrants, primarily from China. Their demographic
behaviors have changed prominently, from a high level of fertility, 5 children per woman in a post-
World War II period to an ultra-low level of fertility, less than 1 child per woman by the beginning
of the 21st century. The tendency of childlessness becomes considerably commonplace at present.
The trends of marriage, spinsterhood and divorce have dramatically changed over time. The mean
age at marriage and childbearing has been postponed more than 10 years since 1960s.
Curbing undesired babies and birth control has been one of the most significant
accomplishments in human history. As explicated from the Malthusian perspective, the ultimate
check of population growth is due to limited resources such as food, land and water. As one of the
most dense world cities, Hong Kong has undergone this transformation to minimize a fear of
population explosion. However, the consequences of the rapid decline in fertility are of extremely
profound. The effect of modernization on fertility is very complex.
Questions posed to these newly emerging demographic phenomena are numerous but always ill-
solved, such as how the process of modernization results in the decline of fertility; is it due to a rapid
secularization and westernization or theories of rational choice and wealth flow? Why fertility
could not be risen today up to the replacement level as if every family has nearly two children
to replace their parents; what are the childbearing barriers to Hong Kong couples facing with? Apart
from incentives and disincentives to childbirth, how the policies of birth planning are in place to
check the population growth such as the establishment of the Family Planning Association in Hong
Kong? What are the impacts of declining childbirth to individuals, family and society? How did
the values of family and marriage dissolve in exchange of a family moving towards a nuclear
type and pattern of power relations between husband and wife changing from that of paternalistic to
more equalitarian? When and how do cross-border marriages and births to Mainland women occur
in Hong Kong? And what are its impacts affecting Hong Kong’s social, educational and welfare
systems?
Mortality in Hong Kong was rather high before World War II and extremely high during the
Japanese occupation, but it declined very rapidly after WWII. The first era of great mortality decline
can be attributed to the spread of public health campaigns such as immunizations, antibiotics,
effective public health services, public education, improving water supplies and sewage systems.
The success of medical technology and public health schemes realizes greatly today the lowest
infant mortality, 1.7 per 1 000 registered live births and highest life expectancy at birth, 79.3 years
to male and 85.4 years to female in Hong Kong. An avalanche of new technologies improves the
living environment and simultaneously enhances human lifetime. Hong Kong, like other
developed countries, is undergoing the fourth stage of epidemiological transition in which
most deaths occur at older ages dominated by degenerative organ diseases, chiefly coronary
heart disease, stroke, and cancer, as so called – “modern social diseases”.
A prolonged low fertility and declining mortality exacerbate a noticeable population age shift towards
the older end of the age spectrum. The proportion of elderly people such as age 65 and over
increases significantly from 1 in 15 persons in 1981 to 1 in 8 in 2008 and will double to 1 in 4
by 2036. The oldest old (aged 80 and over) will also increase rapidly from 1 in 29 in 2008 to 1 in
13 by 2036. How and when does the process of modernization result in the occurrence of mortality
and health transitions in Hong Kong? What are the inevitable and possible consequences of these
transitions for our society in future? Does this success transform to “the failure of success” making
more people living longer but in a poor health? Could the dissolution of marriage and family
solidarity provide a sustainable support for the long-term care of the elderly people? Do we have
sufficient working age people to support non-productive population? The fundamentally important
question is: how can Hong Kong society adequately sustain our development and competitiveness
and face the challenges of population ageing?
3
III) The Impact of Modernization on Migration
Hong Kong has been essentially a “migrant metropolis”. This modernity is marked by successive
flows of population changes and revolutions, prominently inter-related mainly with the political
instability of Mainland China in the pre-1949 years. Since 1950s, the size and composition of the
population of Hong Kong has considerably changed due to firstly the settlement of Chinese
immigrants into Hong Kong and secondly the wave of the population locally born – post-war baby
boomers. Migration and its policy still play an increasingly important role in affecting the
population structure and characteristics of Hong Kong.
From a shift of an influx of Shanghai capitalists and Vietnam refugees to Hong Kong in the early
period to a more recent realization from “brain drain” – intellectuals emigrating to Canada,
Australia or the United States in a pre-1997 period to “brain dearth and return” – returned
migrants back to Hong Kong in a post-1997 period. The complexities and the interrelationship
of the migration, socioeconomic and political issues are of deeply sophisticated, including such
as an earlier introduction to the quota system of migration control and touch-base policy, and
a later formation of one-way permit scheme, old age retirement scheme to Hong Kong elderly
in China and Hong Kong residents work and reside in China and elite program to attract outstanding
Chinese Mainlanders to stay in Hong Kong. Those demographic movements are highly related to
the quest for modernization during the different historical periods. Why do people from Mainland
China migrate to Hong Kong? Could the “push and pull” theory solely explain the process of
migration? What are the roles played by those capitalists and intellectuals contributing to Hong
Kong’s modernization? How did political and social forces shape and accelerate the mechanism
of migration in the different historical eras? What are the characteristics of the different paths of
modernization and the stages of migration in Hong Kong? What are the challenges of governance
confronting the Hong Kong government today? More importantly, will Chinese immigrants
alleviate the population ageing of Hong Kong in future?
8. Course topics
Nine topics are introduced in this course. Each topic comprises specific issues and contents as
follows:
Topic 2: Mortality
• Components and measurements of mortality; age, gender and social status
differentials in mortality;
• Causes of death, products of the social and economic environment; data sources and
limitations;
• Epidemiological transition: from the Roman era to the present;
• Mortality and health transitions: causes and consequences;
• The case of Hong Kong and overseas experience.
4
Topic 3: Fertility Transition
• Fertility concepts and measurements;
• Fertility trends, levels, and explanations; data source and limitations;
• High-fertility and low-fertility countries;
• The studies of the Hong Kong Family Planning Association (KAP) and One-child Policy
in China;
• Explanations for the fertility transition: the supply-demand framework, the
innovation/diffusion and “cultural perspective”, preconditions for a fertility decline.
Topic 4: Migration
• Defining and measuring migration;
• Why do people migrate? The push-pull theory; migration selectivity; theories of
international migration; which theories are best?
• Demographic components of urbanward migration; modernization theory and theories built on
the core-periphery model;
• The history of the migration of Hong Kong: causes and consequences
• Hong Kong residents working in Mainland China; the impact of cross-border
marriage; aspiration of Hong Kong elderly retire in China and elite program.
Topic 9: Poverty
• What is poverty and why measure it?
• How to measure poverty? How to define a poverty line?
• Poverty, inequality, and social exclusion
• Describing poverty: the case of Hong Kong and international comparisons
• Understanding poverty from a demographic perspective
• Determinants of poverty
• Poverty reduction policies
• Public housing and poverty
• Retirement protection and poverty
Each class consists of lectures. In-class participation and group discussions will be held on specific
dates during tutorials. For the course to be successful, students must complete all required readings
prior to class. They are highly encouraged to read the supplementary readings for more information,
but it is optional. All reading materials will be on reserve and available on the Moodle course website.
The course notes will be posted on Moodle before the class, but they are not substitutes for class
attendance. Selected relevant DVD and/or videos will be shown to the class for some specific topics.
Useful links of websites for demographic data, analysis and research will be available on Moodle.
Some guidelines and suggestions for preparing a group debate and paper will also be uploaded on
Moodle at the beginning of the course.
Tutorial attendance is compulsory. Students are expected to prepare for class and attend all lectures
and tutorials. As 100% attendance is required for tutorials, there will be mark penalty (25% out of
tutorial participation per session) for your absence. If you are late for more the 15 minutes, you will
be considered late. If you are late for class for more than 15 minutes, you will also be considered
absent.
Absence may only be granted upon provision of reasons and proof/evidence. Students may be able to
write a 500-word essay based on a topic provided by their tutor to compensate for the absence. Absence
without reason and/or evidence will directly lead to a mark penalty.
Tutorial participation refers to active involvement in the class, including discussion participation, asking
question, giving feedback on presentations and teaching, expressing reflections, etc.
Tutorial Registration
Tutorial registration in the SIS will open at 12pm, 30th January, 2023 to 11:59pm, 3rd February,
2023. Please select your tutorial slot via Tutorial Sign-up App or Tutorial Sign-up System under
eLearning Tab. Students are required to observe the following:
1. Please choose only one group. The selected group cannot be changed after registration.
2. You will be attending 9 (6 tutorials, 1.5 hours each) hours of tutorials in total on a weekly
basis
3. Availability of tutorial groups is on a first-come-first-served basis.
4. Please select your preference well ahead of time, to avoid any technical issues which may erupt
at the last minute.
Please refer to point 15 of the course outline for tutorial dates and times.
In tutorials, we will be looking at recent news articles on each of the six project topics below. In groups
of 3, you will be given time to prepare and have 5 mins to share your views on the articles in relation
to course material and lead a 10-mins discussion. All students will participate and join in the 10 min
discussion. Further details will be announced in class.
7
3) Group Presentation
8
4) Screening and Reflection Paper
Students are required to watch a selected short film/documentary (to be announced on Moodle)
during reading week and write a short reflection paper (800-1000 words) on it to be submitted by
6pm, 13 March, 2023. The reflection paper should show student’s observations and understanding
of the video’s themes/messages and discuss them in a critical manner in relation to theories
introduced in lectures and readings. Students are also encouraged to give their own thoughts,
perspectives and arguments of the issues introduced in the video in an organized and logical manner
that demonstrates analytical skills. Further details will be announced on Moodle and in tutorials.
5) Individual Essay
The paper should include some literature review, historical development, current structure, cross
cultural information and local data to back up your claims and suggestions. The length of the paper
will be in the range of 2500-3000 words, exclusive of appendices, the reference list, tables, figures,
photos etc. The group paper must be submitted by 6pm, 5 th May, 2023. A coversheet including
self-assessed workloads for each student will be available on the Moodle course website.
Students will be required to apply appropriate concepts and measures to analyze population
dynamics of Hong Kong. Students are advised to go through recommended chapters in the
textbook, some news and histories about Hong Kong society, as well as lecture slides to prepare for
their in-class test.
The following is the current marking scale for undergraduate programmes used by the Department of
Social Work and Social Administration.
1) Grade Descriptors
The University Regulations on academic dishonesty will be strictly enforced! Please check the
University Statement on plagiarism on the web: http://www.hku.hk/plagiarism/.
10
14. Course Schedule
Date Lectures Required Readings
11
15. Tutorial Arrangement
Time/Day Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Time/Day
12:30-13:30 12:30-13:30
CCCH9015 CCCH9015 CCCH9015 CCCH9015 CCCH9015
Group 1 Group 3 Group 5 Group 8 Group 10
13:30-14:00 13:30-14:30
14:30-15:30 14:30-15:30
CCCH9015
Group 6
15:30-16:00 15:30-16:30
16:30-17:30 16:30-17:30
CCCH9015 CCCH 9015 CCCH9015
Group 4 (LECT) Group 9
17:30-18:00 17:30-18:30
Group 1 Mon Group 2 Tue Group 3 Tue Group 4 Tue Group 5 Wed
12
16. Important dates
Tutorial Registration 12pm, 30th Jan, 2023 to 11:59pm, 3rd Feb, 2023
News Report Discussion In tutorials
Reflection Paper 6pm, 13th March, 2023
Progress Report Submission 6pm, 24th March, 2023
Group Presentations In lecture 19th Apr, 2023 and 29th Apr, 2023
Individual Essay 6pm, 5th May, 2023
Topic 2: Mortality
Weeks, John R. Chapter 4, p. 139-184
Topic 4: Migration
Weeks, John R. Chapter 6, p. 241-284.
Topic 9: Poverty
Lister, R. (2004). Poverty. Cambridge: Polity Press. Chapter 1-4, p. 12-98
13
18. Recommended Readings (optional)
Topic 1: A Demographic Perspective
Chen, M., & Yip, P. S. (2018). A study on population dynamics in “Belt & Road” countries and
their implications. China Population and Development Studies, 2(2), 158-172.
Livi-Bacci, Massimo. (2007). A Concise History of World Population. (4th ed.) (pp. 112-
158 and
pp.159-214). Oxford, UK: Blackwell.
McFalls, Joseph A., Jr. (2007). Population: A lively introduction (5th ed.). Population Bulletin.
62(1). Washington, D.C.: Population Reference Bureau.
Topic 2: Mortality
Caldwell, J. C. (1992). Old and new factors in health transitions. Health Transition Review.
Vol. Supplementary Issue (2), 205-215.
Cheung, S L Karen, J-M. Robine, E. J-C. Tu, and G. Caselli. (2005). Three dimensions of the
survival curve: Horizontalization, verticalization, and longevity extension. Demography, 42
(2), 243-258.
Feigin, V., Nichols, E., Alam, T., Bannick, M., Beghi, E., Blake, N., ...Yip, P., ... (2019). Global,
regional, and national burden of neurological disorders, 1990–2016: A systematic analysis for
the Global Burden of Disease Study 2016. The Lancet Neurology, 18(5), 459-480.
Fogel, R. (1994). The relevance of Malthus for the study of mortality today: Long-run influences
on health, mortality, labor force participation, and population growth. In K. Lindahl-
Kiessling & H. Landberg (Eds.). Population, Economic Development, and the Environment
(pp. 231-294). Oxford University Press.
James, S.L., & Geleijnse, J.M. (2018). Global, regional, and national incidence, prevalence, and
years lived with disability for 354 diseases and injuries for 195 countries and territories, 1990–
2017: A systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. The Lancet,
392(10159), 1789-1858.
Kyu, H., Abate, D., Abay, K., Abbafati, S., Abbasi, C., Abbastabar, N., … Yip, P., ... (2018). Global,
regional, and national disability-adjusted life-years (DALYs) for 359 diseases and injuries and
healthy life expectancy (HALE) for 195 countries and territories, 1990–2017: A systematic
analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. The Lancet, 392(10159), 1859-1922.
Rau, R., Soroko, E., Jasilionis, D., & Vaupel J.W. (2008). Continued reductions in
mortality
at advanced ages. Population and Development Review, 34(4), 747-768.
Tulijapurkar, S., Nan, Li and Carl, B. (2000). A universal pattern of mortality decline in the G7
countries. Nature, 405, 89-792.
Zheng, Y. S., Chang, Q., & Yip, P. (2019). Understanding the increase in life expectancy in Hong
Kong: Contributions of changes in age- and cause-specific mortality. International Journal of
Environmental Research and Public Health, 16(11).
14
Topic 3: Fertility Transition
Bryant, J. (2007). Theories of fertility decline and the evidence from development
indicators.
Population and Development Review, 33(1), 101-127.
Chen, M., & Yip, P. (2018). Decomposing the crude divorce rate in five countries:
Singapore,
Taiwan, South Korea, the UK, and Australia. Asian Population Studies, 14(2), 137-152.
Law, Y. W., Chan, M., Zhang, H., Tai, L., Tsang, S., Chu, P., & Yip, P. (2019). Divorce in
Hong
Kong SAR, 1999–2011: A review of 1,208 family court cases. Journal of Divorce &
Remarriage, 1-15.
Kohler, Hans-Peter, Billari, F.C., Ortega, J. A. (2006). Low fertility in Europe: Causes,
implications, and policy options. In F. Harris (Ed.). The baby bust: Who will do the
work? Who will pay the taxes? (pp. 48-109). Rowman & Littlefield Publisher.
Tu, J-C. (2005). Patterns of low fertility in Hong Kong and Taiwan. Journal of National
Development Studies, 4(1).
Yip, P., Law, C.K., and Cheung, S.L.K. (2009). Ultra-low fertility in Hong Kong: A
review
of related demographic transitions, social issues, and polices to encourage childbirth.
In G.
Jones, P. Straughan & A. Chan (Eds.). Ultra-low fertility in Pacific Asia: Trends,
causes and policy issues (pp. 132- 159). Routledge.
Yip, P. S. F., Lee, J . , Chan, B . , & Au, J. (2001). A study of demographic changes
under
sustained below-replacement fertility in Hong Kong SAR. Social Science & Medicine,
53,1003-1009.
Topic 4: Migration
Cheung, K. S. L., & Yip, P. S. F. (2010). Hong Kong and the Pearl River Delta: Cross- boundary
demographic dynamics and policy implications. Journal of Youth Studies, 13(1): 3-21.
Massey, D. S., Arango, J., Hugo, G., Kouaouci, A., Pellegrino, A. & Taylor, J. E. (1993). Theories
of international migration: A review and appraisal. Population and Development Review, 19(3),
431-466.
Shen, J. (2006). Population growth, fertility decline, and ageing in Hong Kong: The
perceived and
real demographic effects of migration. Shanghai-Hong Kong Development Institute,
Hong Kong Institute of Asia-Pacific Studies.
Yip, P.S.F. and Lee, J. (2000). The effects of migration on the population distribution in
Hong Kong.
Asian Journal of Public Administration, 22(1): 90-104.
15
Topic 5: Population Structure and Characteristics
Bloom, D. E., Canning, D. and Sevilla, J. (2003). The demographic dividend: A new
perspective on
the economic consequences of population change. Rand Corporation.
Bloom, D.E., Canning, D., Fink G., & Finlay, J.E. (2007). Fertility, female labor force
participation, and the demographic dividend. Journal of Economic Growth, 14(2), 79-
101.
Martin, L. (1990). Changing intergenerational family relations in East Asia. Annals of the
American
Academy of Political and Social Science, 510, 102-114.
Mulvey, T. (2005). Hong Kong families in the twenty-first century. In R. Estes, Social
welfare in
Hong Kong (pp. 225-236). Oxford University Press.
Cheung, S. L. K. and Yip, S. F. P. (2010). Trends in healthy life expectancy in Hong Kong SAR,
1996-2008. European Journal of Ageing, 7,257-269.
Haub, C. (2007). Global aging and demographic divide. Public Policy and Ageing Report,
17(4).
Population Reference Bureau.
Jagger, C. (2006). Can we live longer, healthier live? In Z. Yi, E. M. Crimmins, Y. Carrière,
and J-M. Robine (Eds). Longer life and healthy aging (pp.7-22). Springer.
Kojima, H. (2003). aging societies with fewer children in East Asia and changes in social
structure. Economic and Social Research Institute.
Kwok, C. L., Lloyd, C. J., & Yip, P. S. F. (2013). Aging population scenarios: An Australian
experience. Journal of Population Research. 30(4), 335-345.
Yip, P. S. F., Cheung, K. S. L., Law, S. C. K., Chi, I., & Robine, J. M. (2010). The demographic
window and economic dependency ratio in the Hong Kong SAR. Asian Population Studies,
6(2), 241-260.
Chen, M., Kwok, C., Shan, H., & Yip, P. (2018). Decomposing and predicting china's
GDP
growth: Past, present, and future. Population and Development Review, 44(1), 143-
157.
16
Lutz, W., Sanderson, W. C., & Scherbov, C. (Eds). (2004). The end of world population
growth in
The 21st century: New challenges for Human Capital Formation and Sustainable
Development. Earthscan.
The Canadian Chamber of Commerce in Hong Kong, & The City University of Hong Kong.
(2003).
Hong Kong Sustainable Development Index (HKSDI) 2003.
United Nations. (2008). World population policy 2007. Department of Economic and
Social
Affairs, Population Division.
Topic 9: Poverty
Citron, C F., & Michael, R. T. (1995). Measuring poverty: A new Approach. National
Academy Press. http://www.bls.gov/pir/spm/nasrpt.htm
Guo, Y., Chang, S., Chen, M., & Yip, P. (2018). Do poorer areas have poorer access to services
in Hong Kong? A small-area analysis based on multiple spatial accessibility indicators.
Social Indicators Research, 138(1), 1-21.
Haughton, J. & Khandker, S. R. (2009). Handbook on poverty and inequality. The World Bank.
http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/TOPICS/EXTPOVERTY/EXTPA/0
,,contentMDK:22405907~pagePK:148956~piPK:216618~theSitePK:430367,00.html
Hong Kong Census and Statistics Department. (2013). Hong Kong poverty situation report 2012.
http://www.povertyrelief.gov.hk/pdf/2012_Poverty_Situation_Eng.pdf
Peng, C., Fang, L., Wang, J., Law, S., Zhang, Y., & Yip, P. (2019). Determinants of poverty
and their variation across the poverty spectrum: Evidence from hong kong, a high-income
society with a high poverty level. Social Indicators Research, 144(1), 219-250.
Peng, C., Kwok, C., Law, Y., Yip, P., & Cheng, Q. (2019). Intergenerational support,
satisfaction with parent-child relationship and elderly parents' life satisfaction in Hong
Kong. Aging & Mental Health, 23(4), 428-438.
Yip, P., Chan, M., So, B. K., Wat, K. P., & Lam, K. F. (2020). A decomposition analysis to
examine the change in the number of recipients in the comprehensive social security
assistance (CSSA) system. China Population and Development Studies.
18
Grade Descriptors for Individual Essay
Grade A Grade B Grade C Grade D Grade F
Conceptualization Identifies and addresses clearly the Identifies and addresses the Identifies and addresses the main Identifies part of the main Lacks an understanding of what
(30%) main question(s) and the main question(s) and some question(s) but does not address question(s) and only addresses the the question requires or responds
subsidiary, embedded, or implicit but not all of the subsidiary, the subsidiary, embedded or question(s) partially. inappropriately or tangentially to
aspects, addressing their embedded or implicit implicit aspects. Very limited critical engagement the task or topic.
relationships to each other. aspects. Occasional perceptive and with key issues and themes No critical engagement with
Consistent perceptive and critical Generally perceptive and critical engagement with issues issues, and themes. Essay
engagement with issues and critical engagement with and themes, but essay tends characterized by serious
themes based on comprehensive issues and themes; some toward rather superficial inaccuracies and
understanding of relevant concepts shortcomings in understanding of relevant misunderstandings.
and theories understanding of relevant concepts and theories
concepts and theories
Critical analysis Examines the question/ Examines the question/ Some important perspectives or Examines things from a single Arguments are confused and
(30%) issue/problem from all important issue/problem from most of issues are not recognized. Not all perspective. Only minimal illogical. Student fails to present
perspectives. Overall logic is the important perspectives. relevant arguments and counter examination of relevant arguments and defend a coherent position.
clear. Premises or evidence Expresses own position, and arguments are fully examined. and counterarguments. Offers own position, but
strongly support conclusions. argumentative structure is Offers own position but Offers own position, but the arguments are flawed,
Counter-evidence or rival clear and logical, but some reasoning is sometimes impaired arguments are not put forward disorganized, or difficult to
positions addressed. Arguments fit arguments underdeveloped or by weak, emotive, or inconsistent explicitly and not well supported. identify or understand.
together and build a compelling some considerations argumentation. Some Or, rarely goes beyond
case. The analysis, synthesis and overlooked. The analysis, inaccuracies in the analysis, reproduction of relevant concepts
application of knowledge is synthesis and application of synthesis and application of and theories, impaired in parts by
consistently clear and effective. knowledge is mostly clear knowledge. considerable inaccuracies.
and effective.
Structure/ Introduction states clearly writer’s Introduction states writer’s Introduction and conclusion are Topic is not properly introduced Introduction and conclusion are
Organization thesis or position, and conclusion thesis or position, and included but do not fully capture and conclusion insufficiently unclear, lack detail or missing
(20%) clearly summarizes main conclusion summarizes main the essence of the topic and summarizes the ideas. Ability to altogether. Very little evidence
arguments. Paragraphing is arguments. Paragraphing is discussion. Evidence of ability to construct a paragraph with a central of an ability to organize the
appropriate at all times with each appropriate, but some paragraph, but some paragraphs idea and supporting details is essay into paragraphs with one
paragraph containing a central paragraphs lack supporting lack a central idea or supporting somewhat limited. central idea and supporting
idea which is developed detail or contain unrelated detail details.
throughout the paragraph with details.
supporting details.
Mechanics (20%) The language contains very few, if The language is mostly The language is sometimes The language contains frequent Errors in language and
any, errors in grammar and accurate but contains a few inaccurate, although errors, when errors in simple and complex vocabulary are so frequent and
vocabulary. If slips are present, the systematic errors in complex they occur, are more often in grammar and vocabulary. Errors distracting that the essay is
meaning is still grammar and complex grammar and are distracting and effort has to be largely incomprehensible. Does
clear. Conventions of academic vocabulary. Conventions of vocabulary. Errors when they made to understand the main not adhere to the conventions of
writing (e.g. citation, references, academic writing (e.g. occur are distracting but the arguments. Conventions of academic writing (e.g. citation,
footnotes, etc.) are followed citation, references, footnotes, overall meaning is still academic writing (e.g. citation, references, footnotes, etc.).
meticulously. etc.) are mostly followed. intelligible. Conventions of references, footnotes, etc.) show
academic writing (e.g. citation, significant inconsistencies and may
references, footnotes, etc.) show contain errors.
some inconsistencies.
Grade Descriptors for Reflective Paper
Grade Descriptors for News Article Discussions
A- Excellent B – Proficient C - Average D – Poor F - Fail
Addressing the Identifies and articulates clearly Identifies and clearly Summarizes basic content of Summarizes some content of Unable to identify and
topic the key contents of the article, articulates most key contents of the article but some key ideas the article but unable to summarize content of the
(30%) summarized and presented in a the article, summarized and not clearly highlighted, and articulate key messages article. Presentation is
clear coherent manner. presented in a mostly clear articulated in a mostly clear across in a coherent manner. unclear and incoherent.
coherent manner. and coherent manner.
Argumentation Able to analyse, reflect and Able to analyse, reflect and Attempt to analyse, reflect and Lacking in analysis, No analysis, reflection and
(30%) integrate course learnings with integrate some course learnings integrate some course learnings reflection and integration of integration of course
article. Thoughtful and original with article. Thoughtful and with article but weak in course learnings with article. learnings with article. No
ideas that explore the issue in all original ideas that explore the cohesion. More original ideas Ideas introduced lacked ideas or perspectives shared.
important perspectives issue in most important can be presented and explored originality and needs more Overall logic is confusing
highlighted with solid examples. perspectives but can be in a more elaborated manner. exploration into different and poorly narrated.
Overall logic is clear and shows elaborated on. Overall logic is Overall logic is relatively clear perspectives. Overall logic is
critical analysis throughout the clear and shows critical but lacks critical analysis unclear and presentation
presentation. analysis throughout most of the throughout most of the lacks coherency.
presentation. presentation.
Delivery (20%) Presentation and storytelling Presentation and storytelling
Presentation and storytelling Poor attempt in presentation Lacking in presentation and
skills including eye contact, skills including eye contact,
skills are present but can be skills with limited eye storytelling skills with little
stage presence and intonation stage presence and intonation
improved on with more eye contact, monotone/ unclear to no eye contact and unclear
were excellent. Great interaction were good. Some interaction
contact and variety in speech speech delivery. Little to no deliverance of presentation.
and engagement with audience and engagement with audience
deliverance. Questions asked attempt in facilitating and No attempt at facilitation of
through thoughtful questions. through thoughtful questions.
but audience interaction and maintaining discussion discussion and no questions
Able to facilitate and maintain Good attempt in facilitating
engagement limited. session and questions from posed. Questions from the
discussion session and clearly and maintaining discussionAssistance required in the floor were ill-addressed. floor unanswered.
address questions from the floor. session. Addresses questions
facilitating and maintaining
from the floor well. discussion session. Questions
from floor answered but needs
elaboration.
Overall Presenter(s) adhere strictly to Presenter(s) adhere strictly to Presenter(s) adhere more or Presenter(s) may be Presenter(s) do not adhere to
performance time limits set. Presentation is time limits set. Presentation is less to the time limits set. significantly off the time the time limits set.
(Structure, time very skilfully structured and generally well structured and Structure and organisation are limits set. Presentation is Presentation is very well
management, organised. Teamwork is evident organised. Some evidence of unsound in places. Teamwork poorly structured and structured and organised.
effectiveness, and division of labour is well- teamwork and division of and division of labour could be organised. Teamwork and No teamwork and division of
teamwork) arranged. labour. better arranged. division of labour are poorly labour is evident.
(20%) arranged.
(END)