Securing Smart Meters Data For AMI Using RBAC

2016 11th Asia Joint Conference on Information Security
*75GD;@9*?3DF$7F7DE3F38AD$ ,E;@9
)
L76;@3D=3%7633>GEE;7@3@6":3>76*:G3;4
A>>797A8 @8AD?3F;A@+75:@A>A9K,,
>;@,
?3;>743D=3G37G3537

*?3DF9D;6;E5A@E;67D763EF:7@7JF97@7D3F;A@ E?3DF9D;6?A@;FAD;@96;EFD;4GF767@7D9K97@7D3F;A@3@6
BAI7D 9D;6 F:3F BDA?;E7E FA ?3=7 BAI7D 97@7D3F;A@ 3@6 36H3@576?7F7D;@9;@8D3EFDG5FGD77F5
67>;H7DK?AD7D7>;34>7788;5;7@F3@67@H;DA@?7@F8D;7@6>K 6H3@576 ?7F7D;@9 ;@8D3EFDG5FGD7 $ D7BD7E7@FE F:7
+:;E 53@ 47 35:;7H76 GE;@9 F:7 6H3@576 $7F7D;@9 7@F;D7?73EGD7?7@F3@65A>>75F;A@EKEF7?;@5>G6;@9E?3DF
@8D3EFDG5FGD7 $ 3E ;F ;E A@7 A8 F:7 H;F3> E?3DF 9D;6 ?7F7DE93F7I3KE$ 5A??G@;53F;A@@7FIAD=3@6$
5A?BA@7@FE $ 835;>;F3F7E 67?3@6 D7EBA@E7 :7367@61 2+:7E7?3;@5A?BA@7@FE53@47678;@763E
?3@397?7@F4K5A>>75F;@963F38DA?E?3DF?7F7DE35DAEE 8A>>AIE
F:77@F;D79D;6AI7H7DE75GD;@9F:;E63F3;E5DG5;3>8AD %*,,*+:7E?3DF?7F7D;EF:743E;55A?BA@7@FA8
F:7AH7D3>>B7D8AD?3@57A8F:79D;6 @F:;EB3B7DI78A5GE $ ;@E?3DF9D;6 F;EGE76FA5A>>75F3@667>;H7DBAI7D
A@ E75GD;@9 E?3DF ?7F7DE 63F3 EFAD76 ;@ F:7 $7F7D 3F3 5A@EG?BF;A@ ;@8AD?3F;A@ FA D7?AF7 GF;>;F;7E ?G5: ?AD7
$3@397?7@F$$63F343E73FF:7GF;>;FK5A@FDA>57@F7D 78875F;H7>K F:3@ 3 5A@H7@F;A@3> ?7F7D E?3DF ?7F7D
A8 F:7 E?3DF 9D;6 E7DH;57 BDAH;67D .7 BDABAE7 3@ ?73EGD7E 5GEFA?7DQE >A36 BDA8;>7 3@6 67?3@6 EFAD7E
3D5:;F75FGD7FAE75GD7?7F7D63F343E76A@F:7I7>>=@AI@ :;EFAD;53> ;@8AD?3F;A@ 3@6 67>;H7DE ;@F7DH3> 63F3 8AD
)A>7 3E76 557EE A@FDA> ) ?A67> @ AGD 5GEFA?7DQE BAI7D 5A@EG?BF;A@ 3@6 6;EFD;4GF76 BAI7D
3D5:;F75FGD7I7;@F79D3F7)I;F:F:7$$EKEF7?FA @7FIAD=E3EI7>>
7@EGD7F:3FE?3DF?7F7DEQ63F3;EBDAF75F76+:DAG9:BDAB7D ,/0F:793F7I3K35FE3E3@;@F7D8357AD3557EEBA;@F
3EE;9@?7@FA8GE7DEDA>7E3@6B7D?;EE;A@E ?7F7DEQ63F3 8AD 7@7D9KD7>3F76 63F3 47FI77@ F:7 E?3DF ?7F7D 3F F:7
I;>>473557EE76A@>K4K3GF:AD;L76GE7DE 5GEFA?7DE;67ADBAI7D6;EFD;4GF;A@3@697@7D3F;A@E;67E
3@6F:7$ 5A??G@;53F;A@@7FIAD=+:;E93F7I3K53@47
%+)&,+ &%
7;F:7D67B>AK76I;F:;@F:7E?3DF?7F7DAD3E3EF3@63>A@7
+:7 5GDD7@F 7>75FD;53> BAI7D 9D;6 8357E ?3@K 5:3>>7@97E 93F7I3K
EG5: 3E D;E;@9 7@7D9K 67?3@6 39;@9 ;@8D3EFDG5FGD7 '%%-&!,!'& ,/'*# 5A??G@;53F;A@E
D7>;34;>;FK12$AD7AH7DF:7D7;E3@;@5D73E;@9>K9DAI;@9 47FI77@E?3DF?7F7DE3@6F:7$ :7367@6G@;FE;EE7FGB
3FF7@F;A@ FAI3D6 ;@F79D3F;@9 D7@7I34>7 7@7D9K D7EAGD57E GE;@9 F:7 $ 5A??G@;53F;A@ @7FIAD= ;887D7@F
I;F: F:7 7J;EF;@9 8G7>43E76 BAI7D 97@7D3F;A@ 8AD 4AF: 5A??G@;53F;A@ F75:@A>A9;7E EG5: 3E 8;47D ABF;5E #+
75A@A?;53@67@H;DA@?7@F3>5A@57D@E12,BFAF:;E7@6 .;;.;$3J3@6BAI7D>;@75A??G@;53F;A@'#3D7
F:;ED3;E7EF:7@7768ADF:7FD36;F;A@3>BAI7D9D;6FA5AB7 GE76 I;F:;@ F:;E @7FIAD= 43E76 A@ F:7 FKB7 A8 63F3 3@6
I;F: F:7E7 5:3>>7@97E 3@6 7HA>H7 FAI3D6 ;@F7>>;97@57 ;@ 3H3;>34>7D7EAGD57E
BAI7D 97@7D3F;A@ FD3@E?;EE;A@ 6;EFD;4GF;A@ 3@6 4;>>;@9 &F:;EB3DF;E>A53F763FF:75A@FDA>57@F7DA8
+:;E 53@ 47 35:;7H76 4K ?AH;@9 FA F:7 @7JF97@7D3F;A@ F:7GF;>;FK5A?B3@K3@6?3@397EF:77J5:3@97A863F33@6
BAI7D9D;6I:;5:;E=@AI@3EE?3DF9D;6 5A@FDA> 5A??3@6E 47FI77@ F:7 $7F7D 3F3 $3@397?7@F
*?3DF 9D;6 ;E 3 FIAI3K 5A??G@;53F;A@ 7@34>76 BAI7D $$EKEF7?E3@6F:7$ 5A??G@;53F;A@@7FIAD=
9D;6 ;@ I:;5: 7>75FD;53> BAI7D 97@7D3F;A@ ;E ;@F79D3F76 @3E?3DF9D;67@H;DA@?7@FE?3DF?7F7D63F3;E7J5:3@976
I;F: F:7 7?7D9;@9 F75:@A>A9;7E ;@ I;D7>7EE 7@6FA7@68DA?F:7E?3DF?7F7DFAF:7$ :7367@63FF:7
5A??G@;53F;A@ B7DH3E;H7 5A?BGF;@9 3@6 363BF;H7 GF;>;FK 5A@FDA> 57@F7D 5:;7H;@9 D7>;34>7 788;5;7@F 3@6
5A@FDA> +:;E AB7@E F:7 6AAD 8AD 6;887D7@F 3BB>;53F;A@E ;@ E75GD75A??G@;53F;A@8ADF:;E63F3;EF:75AD@7DEFA@7A83
978-1-5090-2285-4/16 $31.00 © 2016 IEEE 1

DOI 10.1109/AsiaJCIS.2016.16

EG557EE8G> E?3DF 9D;6 67B>AK?7@F AI7H7D 478AD7 EAGD57E BDAB7D AB7D3F;A@ A8 F:7E7 8G@5F;A@3>;F;7E
366D7EE;@9F:7E75GD;FKA8E?3DF?7F7DE63F3=7KE75GD;FK 67B7@6E A@ 3EEGD;@9 F:7 ;@F79D;FK A8 ?7F7D 63F3 8DA?
D7CG;D7?7@FE :3H7 FA 47 678;@76 A>>AI;@9 3D7 F:7 =7K ?3>;5;AGE ?A6;8;53F;A@ 67>7F;A@ AD D7B>357?7@F
E75GD;FKD7CG;D7?7@FE8AD?3@39;@9E?3DF?7F7DE63F3 GDF:7D?AD7+;?7>KEK@5:DA@;L76D75AD6E8AD?7F7D63F3
*!.0 '&!&,!$!,0*?3DF?7F7DEE7@663F3F:3F;E 3D7;?BADF3@FFA?3@3978;@3@5;3>FD3@E35F;A@E3@65A@FDA>
H3>G34>7 3@6 5A@8;67@F;3> 8AD 4AF: 5GEFA?7DE 3@6 GF;>;FK 5A??3@6E I;F:;@ F:7 9D;6 +:7D78AD7 F:7 $ :7367@6
5A?B3@K 3E F:;E 63F3 53DD;7E ;@8AD?3F;A@ 34AGF 7@7D9K E:AG>6 7@EGD7 F:7 355AG@F34;>;FK A8 93F:7D;@9 ?7F7D 63F3
5A@EG?BF;A@35F;H73BB>;3@57E5GEFA?7DQE@3?7 366D7EE 8DA?6;887D7@F3G6;F>A9E
3@6 B3K?7@F ;@8AD?3F;A@ +:7D78AD7 3557EE FA F:;E 63F3 ?7F7D 63F3 ?3@397?7@F $$ EKEF7? 5A>>75FE 3@6
E:AG>6 47 9D3@F76 FA 3GF:AD;L76 GE7DE A@>K I:;>7 3@K 3@3>KL7E ;@F7DH3> ?7F7D 63F3 8AD F:7 BGDBAE7E A8 ;EEG;@9
3FF7?BF A8 G@3GF:AD;L76 3557EE E:AG>6 47 67F75F76 3@6 4;>>;@93@65A@FDA>5A??3@6EEF:75AD77>7?7@FA8F:7
F7D?;@3F76 $ :7367@6 $$ EKEF7? 835;>;F3F7E + ;@F79D3F;A@ A8
.!$!$!,0 H3;>34;>;FK EF3F7E 8AD E?3DF ?7F7DE 63F3 $ 5A?BA@7@FE3@6?3@397EF:76;EFD;4GF;A@A8;@F7DH3>
47;@9 3H3;>34>7 3@6 3557EE;4>7 4K 3GF:AD;L76 GE7DE 3F F:7 63F3 D757;H76 8DA? 6;887D7@F >A53F;A@E I;F:;@ F:7 $
D;9:FF;?7I:7D7H;A>3F;@9F:73H3;>34;>;FKD7EG>FE;@7@;3> 35DAEE F:7 GF;>;FK 7@F7DBD;E7 +:7 788ADF FAI3D6 E75GD;@9
A8*7DH;57A* E?3DF?7F7DE63F3E:AG>6;@5>G67F:7$$EKEF7?EI:7D7
&,*!,0 @F79D;FKD787DEFAF:7BDAF75F;A@A8E?3DF?7F7DE ?3@39;@93@65A@FDA>>;@9F:73557EEFA63F3EFAD76I;F:;@
63F3 393;@EF G@3GF:AD;L76 ?A6;8;53F;A@ 366;F;A@ AD F:7$$63F343E7I;>>7@EGD7F:3FA@>K3GF:AD;L76GE7DE
67>7F;A@ +:;E ?73@E F:3F F:7 63F3 D757;H76 E:AG>6 47 53@ H;7I ;F 3@6 ;EEG7 35F;A@E F:3F I;>> 38875F F:7 AH7D3>>
7J35F>K3EF:3FFD3@E?;FF768DA?F:7E?3DF?7F7D $ AB7D3F;A@F75:@;53>>K3@68;@3@5;3>>K @F:;ED793D6
-, '*!1,!'&GF:AD;L3F;A@5A@FDA>EF:73557EEFAE?3DF AGD 3BBDA35: ;E ;@F79D3F;@9 F:7 I7>>=@AI@ )A>73E76
?7F7DE63F33@6BD7H7@FE;>>79;F;?3F7GE7DE8DA?35CG;D;@9 557EEA@FDA>)?A67>;@F:7GF;>;FK5A@FDA>57@F7D
63F3AD;EEG;@95A??3@6EFAF:75A@FDA>EKEF7?5:;7H;@9 3FF:7$ :7367@6FA678;@73@67@8AD573557EEBA>;5;7E
AF:7D E75GD;FK A4<75F;H7E EG5: 3E BD;H35K 3@6 ;@F79D;FK F:3FI;>>?3@397F:7AB7D3F;A@A8F:7$$EKEF7?E;@57
67B7@6EA@F:73GF:AD;L3F;A@EF397 ) :3E BDAH7@ ;FE E53>34;>;FK 3@6 788;5;7@5K 8AD
-, &,!,!'&GF:7@F;53F;A@D787DEFA67F7D?;@;@9F:7 ?3@39;@93557EE5A@FDA>;@6;887D7@F3BB>;53F;A@EEG5:3E
;67@F;FKA83@K7@F;FKGE7DAD67H;57F:3FFD;7EFA3557EE F:7.74A8+:;@9E.A+123@66A5%7FIAD=E12
E?3DF ?7F7DE 63F3 3@6 H7D;8K;@9 BDAH;676 5D767@F;3>E +:7 D7EF A8 F:7 B3B7D ;E AD93@;L76 3E 8A>>AIE *75F;A@
393;@EFI:3F;F:3E;@;FE35FG3>355AG@F BD7E7@FE34D;78AH7DH;7I34AGFF:7$$EKEF7?)
'-&,!$!,0+:;ED7CG;D7?7@FEF3F7E8ADF:73BBDAH3>E ?A67>;E6;E5GEE76;@*75F;A@ @*75F;A@ -I7BDABAE7
;EEG76 4K D757;H;@9 7@F;F;7E GBA@ D757BF;A@ A8 63F3 AD AGD3D5:;F75FGD78ADE75GD;@9?7F7D63F3EFAD7;@F:7$$
5A@FDA> 5A??3@6E 5:;7H;@9 F:;E D7CG;D7?7@F ;E 5DG5;3> 63F343E7;@3>>KF:7B3B7D5A@5>G67E;@*75F;A@-
8AD F;?7EK@5:DA@;L3F;A@ A8 63F3 35DAEE 3>> $
$+)+$%$%+$$
5A?BA@7@FE1 2
*/*+$

@ F:;E B3B7D I7 8A5GE AGD 3FF7@F;A@ A@
$$ EKEF7? 835;>;F3F7E + ;@F79D3F;A@ 47FI77@ $
E75GD;@9 E?3DF ?7F7DE 63F3 3F F:7 $ :7367@6 ?AD7
5A?BA@7@FE I:7D7 ;FE ?3;@ DA>7 ;E BDA57EE;@9 >3D97
EB75;8;53>>KI;F:;@F:7$$EKEF7?5:;7H;@9F:734AH7
HA>G?7 ;@F7DH3> 63F3 I;F:;@ E:ADF B7D;A6 A8 F;?7 3@6
?7@F;A@76 E75GD;FK D7CG;D7?7@FE 3F F:7 $ :7367@6 ;E
5A@H7DF;@9;F;@FAGE78G>3@6?3@39734>7;@8AD?3F;A@+:7
5DG5;3>8ADF:7E7H7D3>D73EA@EAD7J3?B>763F3D757;H76
?3;@ 8G@5F;A@3>;F;7E A8 F:7 $$ EKEF7? 53@ 47
3@6 EFAD76 3F F:7 $ :7367@6 ;@5>G6;@9 5GEFA?7DQE
EG??3D;L763E8A>>AIE12
B7DEA@3> ;@8AD?3F;A@ 3@6 7@7D9KD7>3F76 ;@8AD?3F;A@ ;E
• $3@39;@93@6835;>;F3F;@9F:75A>>75F;A@A8?7F7D63F3
BD;H3F7 3@6 5D;F;53> +:7D78AD7 F:;E 63F3 :3E FA 47 =7BF
8DA??G>F;B>7E?3DF?7F7DE;@F:78;7>6
5A@8;67@F;3> I:7D7 3557EE ;E 9D3@F76 A@>K8AD 3GF:AD;L76
• H3>G3F;@9 3@6 7EF;?3F;@9 7DDADE 3@6 93BE ;@
7@F;F;7E @AF:7D D73EA@ ;E F:3F 3@ $ :7367@6 93F:7DE
5A>>75F76?7F7D63F3
?7F7D 63F3 8DA? 6;887D7@F EAGD57E I;F:;@ F:7 E?3DF 9D;6
• +D3@E8AD?;@9 63F3 ;@FA 8AD?3FE 3BBDABD;3F7 8AD F:7
+:;E63F3I;>>47GE768AD4;>>;@9?A@;FAD;@95A@FDA>3@6
GF;>;FK4;>>;@9EKEF7?
5A??3@6 5A@8;9GD;@9 D7E7FF;@9 ?7F7DE
5A@@75F;@9 6;E5A@@75F;@9 >A36E 3@6 BAI7D 97@7D3F;A@

2
• *FAD;@9 3@6 6;EFD;4GF;@9 @A@4;>>;@9 63F3 3@6 *+!'&
, ,'* -7DE;A@76 63F3 EFAD397 ;E 3
?7EE39;@9 ;@5>G6;@9 AGF397 3>3D?E FIAI3K 873FGD7 F:3F 3>>AIE $$ EKEF7?E FA ?3;@F3;@ 3 5ABK A8
5A??3@6E3@667?3@6D7EBA@E77H7@FE ?7F7D63F3I;F:3F;?7D787D7@57+:;E;E5DG5;3>FA7@EGD;@9
$$ EKEF7? 43E;53>>K 35FE 3E 3 63F343E7 D7BAE;FADK 8AD ?7F7D 63F3 ;@F79D;FK 3@6 D7EA>H7 4;>>;@9 E7FF>7?7@FE 3@6
?7F7D 63F3 AI7H7D I;F: F:7 @7I 36H3@57E ;@ 6;EBGF7E*;@57?7F7D63F3;EE:3D763@66;EFD;4GF7635DAEE
@8AD?3F;A@ 3@6 A??G@;53F;A@ F75:@A>A9K + @7I ?G>F;B>7 7@F;F;7E I;F:;@ F:7 GF;>;FK 5A?B3@K EG5: 3E F:7
E7DH;57E47;@9;@FDA6G5768ADE?3DF9D;63@6F:79DAI;@9 4;>>;@9 EKEF7?E D7E73D5: E75F;A@ 3@6 67?3@6 D7EBA@E7
@G?47D A8 7@F;F;7E I;F:;@ F:7 E?3DF 9D;6 366 ?AD7 E75F;A@;F;E;?BADF3@FFA=77B357@FD3>EAGD578ADF:;E63F3
5A?B>7J;FK FA F:7 $ 3@6 53>> 8AD $$ EKEF7?E I;F: 4K5D73F;@9>A9D75AD6E8ADF:7AD;9;@3>H7DE;A@3EI7>>3E
D7>;34>7 3@6 788;5;7@F 873FGD7E FA :3@6>7 F:7 5GDD7@F 3@6 3@KAF:7DH7DE;A@?A6;8;76GE;@9F:7-8G@5F;A@
8GFGD7@776EA8F:7E?3DF9D;6?AD7EB75;8;53>>KF:7GF;>;FK /'0 '%%-&!,!'&+.;F:F:;E873FGD7$$53@
5A?B3@K A>>AI;@9 3D7 F:7 =7K 873FGD7E F:3F @776 FA 47 D7CG7EF 355GD3F7 3@6 D73>F;?7 ?7F7D 63F3 D7CG;D76 8AD
5A@E;67D76 I:7@ 3@ $$ EKEF7? ;E 5:AE7@ FA AB7D3F7 ?A@;FAD;@9 3@6 5A@FDA>>;@9 7@7D9K 5A@EG?BF;A@ ;EEG7
I;F:;@F:7$ :7367@612 5A@@75F 6;E5A@@75F 5A??3@6E D7E7F E?3DF ?7F7DE
'$$,!'& 0+,%+ &,*,!'& +:7 $ ;@F79D3F7E 3 $AD7AH7D 5GEFA?7D 4;>> 6;EBGF7E 53@ 47 D7EA>H76 4K
:G97@G?47DA8E?3DF?7F7DEI;F:?G>F;B>75A??G@;53F;A@ D7CG7EF;@9 D757@F 3@6 BD75;E7 ?7F7D 63F3 D7>3F76 FA F:3F
F75:@A>A9;7E 6;887D7@F ;@F7D8357E 3@6 D736;@9 D3F7E 5GEFA?7D3EI7>>3E35CG;D;@963F3FA8;>>F:793BEI;F:;@
+:7D78AD7 3@K $$ EKEF7? E:AG>6 47 5A?B3F;4>7 3@6 F:7 $$ 63F343E7 3H;@9 D7>;34>7 FIAI3K
E53>34>7FA:3@6>7F:;E;EEG7 @AF:7DIAD6EI:7@34;>>;@9 5A??G@;53F;A@ I;F:;@ F:7 $ ;E 7EE7@F;3> FA 9G3D3@F77
EKEF7? D7CG7EFE D736;@9E 8DA? E?3DF ?7F7DE F:3F GE7 5A@E;EF7@F8>AIA863F33@65A??3@6=77BF:7>A9D75AD6E
6;887D7@FF75:@A>A9;7EF:7$$EKEF7?E:AG>64734>7FA GBFA63F73@6D7EBA@6CG;5=>KFA7?7D97@5K3@6AGF397
BDA57EE3@64G@6>7F:7E7D736;@9E;@FAA@7G@;8;768AD?3F E;FG3F;A@E
EG;F34>78ADF:74;>>;@9EKEF7? (($!,!'&+$,'*%EF:7$ EKEF7?E7HA>H7
&,*.$
,&%&,G7FAF:7:G973?AG@FA8 3@67JB3@6?AD7E7DH;57E3D747;@9;@FDA6G5763@6?AD7
?7F7D 63F3 97@7D3F76 3@6 FD3@E87DD76 I;F:;@ F:7 $ 7@F;F;7E;@5>G6;@9E7DH;57BDAH;67DE7@7D9K?3D=7FE3@6
BADF;A@A8F:;E63F3I;>>47;@5ADD75F?;EE;@9ADD76G@63@F 5A@EG?7DE D7E;67@F;3> 5A??7D5;3> 3@6 ;@6GEFD;3> 3D7
AI7H7D FA 7@EGD7 3 BDAB7D AB7D3F;A@ A8 F:7 $ F:;E 47;@9;@HA>H76+:7D78AD7$$EKEF7?E:AG>6:3H7F:7
BDA4>7?3F;563F3E:AG>647:3@6>764KF:7$$EKEF7? 53B34;>;FK FA BDAH;67 3 B>3F8AD? 8AD 7?7D9;@9 $
GE;@9 F:7 H3>;63F;A@ 7EF;?3F;A@ 3@6 76;F;@9 - F75:@;53> 3@6 4GE;@7EE 3BB>;53F;A@E +:7E7 3BB>;53F;A@E
8G@5F;A@3>;FK @-F:7$$366D7EE7ECG3>;FK;EEG7E ;@5>G674GF3D7@AF>;?;F76FAF:78F3@3>KE;E3@6D7H7@G7
;@ F:7 BDA4>7?3F;5 63F3 GE;@9 GF;>;FKQE 47EF BD35F;57 DG>7E BDAF75F;A@ 7@65GEFA?7D 3@3>KE;E >A36 5GDF3;>?7@F 3@6
3@6 ?7F7DEB75;8;5 B3D3?7F7DE +:7 H3>;63F;A@ 3@6 67?3@6 D7EBA@E7?3@397?7@F;9GD767B;5FE397@7D3>
7EF;?3F;A@8G@5F;A@3>;F;7E;@5>G67 ?A67>A8F:7$ 3>A@9I;F:F:7$$EKEF7?3FF:7$
• EF;?3F;@9;@F7DH3>63F343E76A@?7F7DD736;@9E :7367@6 8F7D 7JB>AD;@9 F:7 =7K 873FGD7E 3@6
• )7B>35;@93>>H3>G7EI;F:35A@EF3@F 8G@5F;A@3>;F;7E A8 F:7 $$ EKEF7? I7 BD7E7@F 3 4D;78
• $A6;8K;@9 3>> H3>G7E 4K 5A@EF3@F GE;@9 AH7DH;7IA8F:7)?A67>;@F:78A>>AI;@9E75F;A@
?G>F;B>;53F;A@6;H;E;A@366;F;A@ADEG4FD35F;A@
• *>;673D3@97A8;@F7DH3>63F33:736AD435=;@F;?7AD
5A?4;@73@6EB>;F;@F7DH3>E
• '7D8AD?>;@73D;@F7DBA>3F;A@
• )7EFAD73BD7H;AGEH7DE;A@A863F3
&@F:7AF:7D:3@676;F;@98G@5F;A@3>;FK;@5>G67E
• 66ADD7B>35763F3?3@G3>>K
• $A6;8KD736EF3FGE
• ;EB>3KAD76;F?G>F;B>7D736;@9E
• ABK AD 5GF B3EF7 3 EFD;@9 A8 H3>G7E 8AD? 3
;9GD77@7D3>$A67>A8$
EBD736E:77FAD8DA?A@7?7F7DFA3@AF:7D

3
)&#***&%+)&#) 57DF3;@ 5A@@75F;A@ 53@ 5A@F;@G7 AD E:AG>6 47 F7D?;@3F76
$&# 43E76A@3E7FA8B3D3?7F7DE12
) :3E 477@ BDAH7@ FA 47 3 9AA6 3>F7D@3F;H7 FA
FD36;F;A@3>6;E5D7F;A@3DK3@6?3@63FADK3557EE5A@FDA> @
)&#
)3DA>7;E3E7?3@F;55A@EFDG5F8AD?;@9F:743E;E8AD ,*)
))/
F:73557EE5A@FDA>BA>;5K>EA;@)B7D?;EE;A@E3D7 ** %$%+

,*)* )&#*
3EEA5;3F76 I;F: DA>7E ,E7DE 3D7 ?367 ?7?47DE A8 ‫با‬ ‫با‬
')$ ** &%*

3BBDABD;3F7 DA>7E 43E76 A@ F:7;D D7EBA@E;4;>;F;7E 3@6 ')$ ** &%
** %$%+
CG3>;8;53F;A@EF:7D74K35CG;D;@9F:7B7D?;EE;A@EA8F:7E7
൐
DA>7E @)GE7DE53@73E;>K47D73EE;9@768DA?A@7

DA>7FA3@AF:7D)A>7E53@3>EA479D3@F76@7IB7D?;EE;A@E
&%*+) %+*
3E F:7 @776 3D;E7E 3@6 B7D?;EE;A@E 53@ 47 D7HA=76 3E
@77676+:;E53@E;?B>;8KF:7E75GD;FK?3@397?7@FBDA57EE
*** &%*
E;9@;8;53@F>K
97@7D3>)?A67>I3E678;@764K*3@6:G123@6
;9GD7)$A67>
EG??3D;L76;@;9GD7+:7?A67>;E43E76A@F:D77E7FE
A87@F;F;7E53>>76GE7DEDA>7E3@6B7D?;EE;A@E )EGBBADFEEA?7;?BADF3@FE75GD;FKBD;@5;B>7EEG5:3E
GE7D;E3:G?3@47;@9AD3@3GFA@A?AGE397@FDA>7;E >73EFBD;H;>797E7B3D3F;A@A86GF;7E3@663F334EFD35F;A@
3<A48G@5F;A@AD<A4F;F>7I;F:;@F:7AD93@;L3F;A@I;F:EA?7 I:;5:53@:7>B;@?;F;93F;@9F:7D;E=E3EEA5;3F76I;F:EA?7
3EEA5;3F76 E7?3@F;5E D793D6;@9 F:7 3GF:AD;FK 3@6 A8F:7F:D73FE#73EFBD;H;>797;EEGBBADF764753GE7)
D7EBA@E;4;>;FK 5A@87DD76 A@ 3 ?7?47D A8 F:7 DA>7 53@ 47 5A@8;9GD76 EG5: F:3F A@>K F:AE7 B7D?;EE;A@E 3D7
'7D?;EE;A@;E3@3BBDAH3>A83B3DF;5G>3D?A67A83557EEFA 3EE;9@76 FA F:7 DA>7 D7CG;D76 8AD F:7 F3E=E 5A@6G5F76 4K
A@7 AD ?AD7 A4<75FE ;@ F:7 EKEF7? +:7 GE7D 3EE;9@?7@F ?7?47DE A8 F:7 DA>7*7B3D3F;A@ A86GF;7E ;E 35:;7H764K
3@6B7D?;EE;A@3EE;9@?7@FD7>3F;A@EA8;9GD7 7@EGD;@9F:3F?GFG3>>K7J5>GE;H7DA>7E?GEF47;@HA=76FA
3D7 4AF: ?3@KFA?3@K D7>3F;A@E:;BE ;@6;53F76 4K F:7 5A?B>7F73E7@E;F;H7F3E=EG5:3ED7CG;D;@93@355AG@F3@F
6AG4>7:736763DDAIEGE7D53@473?7?47DA8?3@K 3@6355AG@F;@9?3@397DFA;EEG734;>>3F334EFD35F;A@;E
DA>7E3@63DA>753@473EE;9@76FA?3@KGE7DE*;?;>3D>K EGBBADF764K?73@EA834EFD35FB7D?;EE;A@EEG5:3E<A;@
3DA>753@:3H7?3@KB7D?;EE;A@E3@6F:7E3?7B7D?;EE;A@ >73H7<A;@3E3E7@67D<A;@3E3D757;H7D7F5D3F:7DF:3@
53@473EE;9@76FA6;887D7@FDA>7E <GEFD736ID;F73@67J75GF7B7D?;EE;A@EFKB;53>>KBDAH;676
)A>7 :;7D3D5:K ;@ ) ;E 3 @3FGD3> I3K A8 4KF:7AB7D3F;@9EKEF7?
AD93@;L;@9 DA>7E FA D78>75F F:7 AD93@;L3F;A@QE >;@7E A8 %7JFI7BD7E7@FAGDBDABAE763D5:;F75FGD78AD;@F79D3F;@9
3GF:AD;FK 3@6 D7EBA@E;4;>;FK +:7 :;7D3D5:K ;E B3DF;3>>K ) ;@ F:7 GF;>;FK 5A@FDA> 57@F7D 3F F:7 $ :7367@6
AD67D76 EA ;F ;E D78>7J;H7FD3@E;F;H7 3@6 3@F;EK??7FD;5 EB75;8K 3557EE 5A@FDA> BA>;5;7E FA ?3@397 F:7 3557EE FA
@:7D;F3@57 ;E D78>7J;H7 4753GE7 3 DA>7 ;@:7D;FE ;FE AI@ $$63F343E73@6678;@73557EE5A@FDA>?A67>FA7@8AD57
B7D?;EE;A@E +D3@E;F;H;FK ;E 3 @3FGD3> D7CG;D7?7@F ;@ F:;E F:7E7BA>;5;7E
5A@F7JF3@63@F;EK??7FDKDG>7EAGFDA>7EF:3F;@:7D;F8DA?
A@73@AF:7D3@63D7F:7D78AD7D76G@63@F - *,) %*$)+$+)*+
E 3@ 788;5;7@F 3557EE 5A@FDA> ?A67> ) 9G3D3@F77E &GD?3;@8A5GE;EE75GD;@9?7F7D63F3D757;H763@6EFAD76
F:3F A@>K 3GF:AD;L76 GE7DE 53@ 3557EE F:7 ?7F7D 63F3 3@6 3F F:7 $$ 63F343E7 +:;E 53@ 47 35:;7H76 F:DAG9: 3
B7D8AD?EG4E7CG7@F35F;A@E @F:;EB3B7DI7BDABAE73@ BDAB7D ?3BB;@9 47FI77@ F:7 7>7?7@FE A8 F:7 ) 3@6
;@F79D3F;A@A8F:7I7>>=@AI@)A>73E76557EEA@FDA> F:AE7A8F:7GF;>;FK5A@FDA>57@F7DA>>AI;@93D7F:7?3;@
)?A67>;@F:7$$EKEF7?3FF:7$ :7367@6FA 7>7?7@FEA8F:7)F:3F@776FA47?3BB76I;F:F:AE7
7@EGD7 BDAB7D ?3@397?7@F 3@6 3557EE BA>;5;7E A8F:7GF;>;FK5A@FDA>57@F7D
7@8AD57?7@F)53@47GE76FA5A@FDA>F:73557EEFA
• -",+ +*+ ,E7DE ;@ F:7 5A@F7JF A8 )
?7F7D 63F3 3F F:7 $$ 63F343E7 $AD7AH7D ;F 3>>AIE
D7BD7E7@FE :G?3@ 47;@9E 3@6 3GFA@A?AGE397@FE ;@
EG4E5D;47DE FA E?3DF ?7F7D E7DH;57E FA 5A@FDA> I:A 53@
F:7 GF;>;FK 5A@FDA> 57@F7D FDK;@9 FA 3557EE F:7 $$
;67@F;8K E?3DF ?7F7DE >A53F;A@E 3BBDAH7 AD 6;E3BBDAH7
EKEF7?
F:7;D EG4E7CG7@F 5A@@75F;A@E 3@6 67F7D?;@7 I:7F:7D 3

4
• ",++:75A@57BFA8A4<75FE;@)EF3F7E8AD 5 '7D?;EE;A@E'
F:7 D7EAGD57E F:3F GE7DE 3D7 FDK;@9 FA 3557EE ;@ F:7 557EEFA5GEFA?7DEQ355AG@FE5GEFA?7D
$$EKEF7? D7>3F7663F3;@5>G6;@9
3 %3?7366D7EE
• '$+ +:7 @AF;A@ A8 DA>7E ;@ ) D7BD7E7@FE F:7
4 $A@F:>K4;>>
<A48G@5F;A@EB7D8AD?764KGE7DE;@F:7GF;>;FK5A@FDA> 5 @7D9K5A@EG?BF;A@BDA8;>7
57@F7D EEG75A@FDA>5A??3@6E8AD7@7D9K5A@FDA>
• *%!++!'&+ +:;E 5A@57BF ;@ ) D78>75FE F:7 ?3@397?7@F
D;9:FE9D3@F76FAGE7DEFAB7D8AD?357DF3;@DA>7;@F:7 3 )7E7FAD5A@8;9GD7E?3DF?7F7DE
$$EKEF7? 4 A@@75F 6;E5A@@75FE?3DF?7F7DE
EEG7?A@F:>K4;>>E
• ++!'& +:;E F7D? D787DE FA F:7 F;?7 B7D;A6 AH7D
)757;H7B3K?7@FE
I:;5:57DF3;@7>7?7@FEI;F:;@F:7$$EKEF7?3D7 557EEFA?7F7D63F3>A9D75AD6E
35F;H7 557EEFA8;@3@5;3>D75AD6E
• '&+,*!&,+ +:7 @AF;A@ A8 5A@EFD3;@FE ;@ ) '7D8AD?H3>;63F;A@7EF;?3F;A@3@676;F;@9
D7BD7E7@FEF:74AG@63D;7EF:3F678;@73@65A@FDA>F:7 -8G@5F;A@3>;FK
D7EBA@E;4;>;FK3EE;9@76FAGE7DEFAB7D8AD?357DF3;@
6 &4<75FE
DA>7
*?3DF$7F7DE
$$3F343E7
&+!)+#&! #&/*+%)'('*

)"#++,) 7 A@EFD3;@FE
@F:;EE75F;A@I7;@FDA6G57AGD3D5:;F75FGD7F:3F;@F79D3F7E A>>AI;@9 3D7 7J3?B>7 A8 F:7 ) 5A@EFD3;@FE
F:3F3BB>KFAAGD3D5:;F75FGD7
) ;@ F:7 GF;>;FK 5A@FDA> 57@F7D .7 8;DEF BD7E7@F F:7
?3BB;@947FI77@)7>7?7@FE3@6F:75A?BA@7@FEA8 *F3F;5*7B3D3F;A@A8GFK** $GFG3>
F:75A@FDA>57@F7D J5>GE;H;FK;7F:78A>>AI;@9DA>7E53@@AF47
3EE;9@76FAF:7E3?7GE7D
3 )A>7E) 3 @9;@77DD7E73D5:7D
@9;@77D '>3@ ?A@;FAD AD ;@EF3>> E?3DF ?7F7DE 4 +EGBBADFEF388D7E73D5:7D
3@63557EEFAEB75;8;5?7F7D63F3>A9D75AD6E 5 55AG@F3@FF7>>7D
'DA<75F $3@397D 557EE FA 3>> ?7F7D 63F3 >A9 6 55AG@F;@9?3@397D @F7D@3>3G6;FAD
D75AD6E
K@3?;5 *7B3D3F;A@ A8 GFK * ;7 F:7
+75:@;5;3@ @EF3>>3@6?3;@F3;@E?3DF?7F7DE
8A>>AI;@9DA>7E53@@AF4735F;H3F764KF:7E3?7
55AG@F3@F @BGF 5GEFA?7DEQ FD3@E35F;A@E 3@6 GE7D6GD;@9357DF3;@E7EE;A@
97@7D3F78;@3@5;3>D75AD6E 3 55AG@F3@FGEFA?7D
+7>>7D)757;H75GEFA?7DEQB3K?7@FE 4 +7>>7DGEFA?7D
55AG@F;@9 $3@397D $A6;8K 8;@3@5;3> D75AD6E 5 @9;@77DGEFA?7D
BAEF;@9DA>7E;@366;F;A@FA355AG@F3@F8G@5F;A@E
@F7D@3> G6;FAD -7D;8K 3>> FD3@E35F;A@E 3@6 +:7 ?3J;?G? @G?47D A8 GE7DE F:3F 53@ 47
3EE;9@76FAF:75A@FDA>57@F7D6;D75FADDA>73@6
8;@3@5;3>D75AD6EBAEF;@9DA>7E
;@F7D@3>3G6;FADDA>7;E'&
+*GBBADF*F388*7FGB?A@;FAD3@65A@8;9GD7 .73>EABDABAE75>3EE;8K;@9?7F7D63F3EFAD76;@F:7$$
E7DH7DE3@693F7I3KEI;F:;@E?3DF9D;6 63F343E7 355AD6;@9 FA F:7 97A9D3B:;53> >A53F;A@ A8 F:7
)7E73D5:7D A@6G5F D7E73D5: FA EFG6K 3@6 E?3DF?7F7DE7@6;@9F:;E63F3FA?3@397F:73557EEA8GE7DE
67H7>ABE?3DF9D;6 43E76A@F:7;DDA>7E3@6F:75ADD7EBA@6;@963F353F79ADKFA

A@FDA>7@F7D;D75FAD4;>;FKFAB7D8AD?3>>F:7 I:;5:F:7E7DA>7E:3H73557EE;7?7F7D63F3D757;H763F
DA>7E ;@ 53E7 A8 7?7D97@5K 3@6 FA H;7I 3>> F:7GF;>;FK5A@FDA>57@F7D53@4753F79AD;L763E8A>>AIE
8;@3@5;3>D75AD6EFD3@E35F;A@E3@6?7F7D63F3>A9
D75AD6E • GEFA?7DD7>3F76 63F3 $7F7D 63F3 D757;H76 8DA?
E?3DF?7F7DEI;F:;@5GEFA?7D@7FIAD=ED7E;67@F;3>
5A??7D5;3>3@6;@6GEFD;3>
4 *G4<75FE ,E7DE,
• ;EFD;4GF;A@D7>3F76 63F3 $7F7D 63F3 D757;H76 8DA?
G?3@47;@9E
E?3DF ?7F7DE 5A@@75F76 FA FD3@E8AD?7DE 3@6
GFA@A?AGE397@FE
EG4EF3F;A@EI;F:;@6;EFD;4GF;A@@7FIAD=E

5
•
7@7D3F;A@D7>3F76 63F3 $7F7D 63F3 D757;H76 8DA? "
E?3DF ?7F7DE 5A@@75F76 FA BAI7D 97@7D3FAD 3@6 $%
6;EFD;4GF76 7@7D9K EAGD57E I;F:;@ 97@7D3F;A@

$!&
@7FIAD= %
$AD7AH7D 63F3 I;F:;@ 735: A8 F:7 34AH7 ?7@F;A@76

53F79AD;7E;E3>EA5>3EE;8;76;@FAFIAFKB7E

•)73>F;?7 63F3 GE76 8AD EGBB>K 67?3@6
?3@397?7@F B73= :AGD E:;8F;@9 9D;6 ?A@;FAD;@9
?3;@F7@3@573@6BAI7DAGF39767F75F;A@ # $%
• %A@D73> F;?7 63F3 GE76 8AD 4;>>;@9 BGDBAE7E

"
D7E73D5:3@667H7>AB?7@F
$%

8 )A>7;7D3D5:K ;9GD7A@57BFG3>*FDG5FGD78AD) $$
;9GD7 E:AIE F:7 :;7D3D5:3> D7>3F;A@E:;B A8 F:7 DA>7E )787D7@57$A@;FAD
I;F:;@F:7GF;>;FK5A@FDA>57@F7D+:7DA>7EA@F:7FABA8F:7
:;7D3D5:KE7@;ADDA>7E;@:7D;FBD;H;>797E3@6B7D?;EE;A@E 55AD6;@9 FA F:;E *& EF3@63D6 F:7 D787D7@57 ?A@;FAD
8DA? >AI7D DA>7E ;@ F:7 :;7D3D5:K <G@;AD DA>7E +:;E 5A@E;EFE A8 FIA 835;>;F;7E 557EE A@FDA> @8AD57?7@F
:;7D3D5:K ;E 5DG5;3> FA 678;@7 F:7 8>AI A8 3GF:AD;FK 3@6 35;>;FK3@6557EE75;E;A@35;>;FK+:7
D7EBA@E;4;>;FKI;F:;@F:75A@FDA>57@F7D 3@6F:7;@F7D35FI;F:735:AF:7D;@EG5:3I3K

F:3F7H7DKD7CG7EF4K3EG4<75FFA3557EE3@A4<75F;@F:7
EKEF7?97F;@F7D57BF764K+:7;@FGD@3E=EF:7
8AD3675;E;A@A@I:7F:7DFA3BBDAH7AD6;E3BBDAH7
)7E73D5:DAGB
#736
)7E73D5:DAGB
#736
+$3@397D 'DA<75F$3@397D 55AG@F;@9$3@397D @F7D@3>G6;FAD F:7D7CG7EF3@6EG4E7CG7@F>KF:7D7FGD@E7;F:7DPK7EQ
AD P@AQ 3E 3BBDABD;3F7 +:7 7@8AD57?7@F A8 F:;E 675;E;A@
)7E73D5:7D )7E73D5:7D
+*GBBADF*F388 $A@;FAD;@9
@9
@EF3>>3F;A@
?3;@F7@3@57
'>3@@;@9
@9
55AG@F3@F +7>>7D
F3=7EB>3573FF:7&GDD787D7@57?A@;FAD;EE;?;>3D4GF
@9
)7B3DF?7@F
6;887DE ;@ F:767F3;>E 8DA? F:3F A8 *& D787D7@57 ?A@;FAD
+7B3DF?7@F
+75:@;5;3@
55AG@F;@97B3DF?7@F
.7;@5ADBAD3F7F:7DA>743E763557EE5A@FDA>FA:3@6>7F:7
3GF:AD;L3F;A@DG>7;9GD7E:AIEF:75A@57BFG3>EFDG5FGD7
@9;@77D;@97B3DF?7@F
A8 F:7 ) $$ D787D7@57 ?A@;FAD E F:7 8;9GD7
E:AIE3@KD7CG7EFFA3557EE3@K63F3D7EAGD57?7F7D63F3
?B>AK77
>A9D75AD6AD8;@3@5;3>D75AD6;E;@F7D57BF764KF:7
;9GD7 )A>7;7D3D5:KA8F:7,F;>;FKA@FDA>7@F7D 78AD7 ?3=;@9 3@K 675;E;A@E F:7 8ADI3D6E F:7
D7CG7EF FA F:7 I:;5: ;@ FGD@ 36:7D7E FA F:7 )
& ')%&+#$#+#*
BA>;5K 675;E;A@ A8 I:7F:7D FA 9D3@F AD D7<75F F:7
@AGD3D5:;F75FGD7EB75;8;763557EEBA>;5;7E3D77@8AD576 3GF:AD;L3F;A@D7CG7EF)I;>>3>>AI3GF:AD;L3F;A@A83@
FA 5A@FDA> F:7 3557EE FA ?7F7D 63F3 EFAD76 ;@ F:7 $$ 35F;H7EG4<75F7@F;FKFA7J75GF7357DF3;@D;9:FA@3B3EE;H7
63F343E7GE;@9F:7D787D7@57?A@;FAD)$I:;5::3E477@ D7EAGD57 A4<75F7@F;FKA@>K;8F:7EG4<75F47>A@9EFA3DA>7
;@FDA6G5763@67JF7@E;H7>K6;E5GEE764KF:73557EE5A@FDA> F:3F):3EBD7H;AGE>K3EE;9@76F:3FD;9:FFA
5A??G@;FK8ADK73DE3@6:3E475A?7F:7 *&EF3@63D68AD +:7 D7EF A8 F:7 675;E;A@ BDA57EE 4K IAG>6 5A@F;@G7
3557EE5A@FDA>8D3?7IAD=12+:7)$5A@57BF:3E477@ A@>K;8)9D3@FE3GF:AD;L3F;A@&F:7DI;E7BDA57EE;E
5A@E;67D763EF:75AD75A@FDA>?75:3@;E?8AD3557EE3@6 EFABB76 3@6 D7EBA@E7 4K F:7 ;E @793F;H7 @A
GE397 A8 6;9;F3> ;@8AD?3F;A@ @ 5>3EE;53> 3557EE 5A@FDA> 3GF:AD;L3F;A@ GDF:7D?AD7 ) 3>>AI 3GF:AD;L3F;A@
EG4<75FE 53@ 3557EE 6;9;F3> A4<75FE A@>K F:DAG9: F:7 38F7D ;F F7EFE AF:7D 675;E;A@ 835FADE ?3;@>K :;7D3D5:3>
D787D7@57 ?A@;FAD I:;5: ;E 3 BDA57EE ;@E;67 3 FDGEF76 D7>3F;A@E:;BE3@65A@EFD3;@FEAD7J3?B>7;8F:75A@6;F;A@
5A?BGF7D43E7F:3F;E3>I3KEDG@@;@93@6;EF3?B7DBDAA8 8AD9D3@F;@93GF:AD;L3F;A@;E?7F;7F:7D7CG7EF;EI;F:;@
+:;E E75F;A@ 6;E5GEE7E AGD 5A@57BFG3> EFDG5FGD7 A8 F:7 D3@97 A8 F:7 3>>AI76 AB7D3F;@9 F;?7 F:7@ F:7
) $$ 3557EE 5A@FDA> 6A?3;@E 43E76 A@ F:7 D7FGD@E 3 BAE;F;H7 D7EBA@E7 NGF:AD;L7O FA F:7
D787D7@57 ?A@;FAD @ AGD 3D5:;F75FGD7 3 5GEFA?;L76 AF:7DI;E7 D7CG7EF ;E 67@;76 675;E;A@ FA 9D3@F 67@K
H7DE;A@A8F:7I7>>=@AI@ *&D787D7@57?A@;FADEF3@63D6 3557EE FA 3@ A4<75F 79 ?7F7D 63F3 4K 3 57DF3;@ EG4<75F
;EB>3576;@E;67F:7GF;>;FK5A@FDA>57@F7D GE7D;E?367355AD6;@9FAEB75;8;763557EEBA>;5;7EI;F:;@

6
F:7)GF:AD;L3F;A@$A6G>7+:7D78AD7;F;E5DG5;3>FA :;7D3D5:K 3@6 <G@;ADDA>7E EG5: 3E*&*& *&M
E7F 355GD3F7 3557EE BA>;5;7E F:DAG9: I:;5: BDAB7D 7F5;@:7D;F?7?47DE8DA?E7@;ADDA>7E
3EE;9@?7@FA8GE7DEFADA>7E3@6B7D?;EE;A@FADA>7EE:AG>6 +:76757@FD3>;L7636?;@;EFD3F;A@A8GE7DDA>73EE;9@?7@F;E
4735:;7H76,BFAF:;E7@6F:7CG7EF;A@F:3F3D;E7E;E:AI 366D7EE764KF:7,)EG4?A67>+IA?3;@3EB75FE3D7
FA 7@EGD7 BDAB7D 3EE;9@?7@F A8 ) 7@F;F;7E @ AF:7D :3@6>764K,)F:7*'$*&3@6F:7(**)-!+!,
IAD6E :AI FA ?3=7 EGD7 F:3F A@>K 3GF:AD;L76 GE7DE 3D7 *'$DA>7D3@9767E5D;47EF:75A>>75F;A@A8D79G>3DDA>7E
3EE;9@76FA367E;9@3F76DA>7+A35:;7H7F:;EF:7BDA57EE AH7DI:;5:357DF3;@36?;@;EFD3F;H7DA>7:3E5A@FDA> F;E
A8 :AI ) 3EE;9@E GE7DE FA DA>7E 3@6 B7D?;EE;A@E FA 678;@764K3<G@;ADDA>73@63E7@;ADDA>73@6;@5>G67E3>>
DA>7EE:AG>647?3@39763@65A@FDA>>76,EG3>>KF:;EF3E= F:7DA>7E47FI77@F:7E7FIA4AG@63D;7E+:7@AF3F;A@GE76
;E B7D8AD?76 4K 3 F73? A8 E75GD;FK 36?;@;EFD3FADE ;@ 3 FA678;@73DA>7D3@97;EF:74D35=7FE3@6 AD12I:7D7
57@FD3>;L76?3@@7DGFI:7@F3>=;@934AGF>3D97EKEF7?E ?73@EF:3FF:7DA>7E3FF:74AG@63D;7E3D77J5>G6768DA?
I:7D7GE7DE3D7;@:G@6D76EADF:AGE3@6EDA>7E3D7;@F7@E F:7D3@973@612;@6;53F7EF:3FF:7DA>7E3FF:74AG@63D;7E
AD:G@6D76E3@6B7D?;EE;A@E3D7;@F:AGE3@6EAD?;>>;A@E 3D7 ;@5>G676 I;F:;@ F:7 D3@97 +:7 AF:7D 3EB75F F:3F
$3@39;@9)7@F;F;7E3@6F:7;DD7>3F;A@E:;BE475A?7E ,):3@6>7E;EF:7BD7D7CG;E;F7DA>7 F;67@F;8;7EI:;5:
;?BD35F;53>3@65A?B>;53F763@653@@AF4757@FD3>;L76AD GE7D53@473EE;9@764K3@36?;@;EFD3F;H7DA>7I;F:;@F:7
F:3FD73EA@)36?;@;EFD3F;A@E:AG>6476757@FD3>;L76 EB75;8;76 DA>7 D3@97 @ AGD BDABAE76 3D5:;F75FGD7 8AD
AI7H7D 6757@FD3>;L;@9 ) 36?;@;EFD3F;A@ :3E FA 47 ;@F79D3F;@9);@$$EKEF7?3@68ADF:7D79G>3DDA>7
B7D8AD?76 53D78G>>K EA F:3F 57@FD3> 5A@FDA> 3@6 4DA36 :;7D3D5:K 3@6 36?;@;EFD3F;H7 DA>7 :;7D3D5:K 67B;5F76 ;@
BA>;5;7E3D7BD7E7DH76*3@6:G7F3>;@1
2EG997EF76FA ;9GD7 3@6;9GD7D7EB75F;H7>K3@7J3?B>7A8F:7DA>7
GE7 ) ;FE7>8 FA 835;>;F3F7 F:7 6757@FD3>;L76 D3@978ADEA?736?;@;EFD3F;H7DA>7E;EE:AI@;@+34>7
36?;@;EFD3F;A@A8)+:;E53@4735:;7H76GE;@9F:7
+34>7J3?B>7A8)A>7)3@97I;F:;@F:7,F;>;FK
36?;@;EFD3F;H7))?A67>):3E
A@FDA>7@F7D;7D3D5:K
F:D77 EG4?A67>E GE7DDA>7 36?;@;EFD3F;A@ ,)
6?;@;EFD3F;H7 'D7D7CG;E;F7 )A>7)3@97
B7D?;EE;A@DA>7 36?;@;EFD3F;A@ ') 3@6 DA>7DA>7 )A>7 )A>7
36?;@;EFD3F;A@))+IADA>7:;7D3D5:;7E3D7GE76;@ **& @9;@77D;@9 @9;@77D;@9
)D79G>3DDA>7:;7D3D5:K3@636?;@;EFD3F;H7DA>7 7B3DF?7@F 7B3DF?7@F;D75FAD2
:;7D3D5:K @ AGD BDABAE76 3D5:;F75FGD7 8AD ;@F79D3F;@9 *& @9;@77D;@9 1'DA<75F$3@397D
);@$$EKEF7?F:7D79G>3DDA>7:;7D3D5:K;EE:AI@ 7B3DF?7@F 'DA<75F$3@397D2
;@ ;9GD7 3@6 F:7 5ADD7EBA@6;@9 36?;@;EFD3F;H7 DA>7 '*& @9;@77D;@9 1+75:@;5;3@'DA<75F
:;7D3D5:K;E67B;5F76;@;9GD7 7B3DF?7@F $3@397D
ሺሻ
,)#+/ &$/*#*
ͳሺƬሻ ʹሺሻ ͵ሺሻ Ͷሺሻ
@ F:;E E75F;A@ I7 BD7E7@F EA?7 G@3GF:AD;L76 3557EE
E57@3D;AE FA E:AI F:7 788;5;7@5K A8 AGD BDABAE76

ͳ
ʹ ͳ 3D5:;F75FGD7 ;@ BDAF75F;@9 ?7F7D 63F3 EFAD76 ;@ F:7 $$
63F343E7
ǣǣ 3D>;7D;@F:;EB3B7DI75>3EE;8;76?7F7D63F3EFAD76;@F:7

ǣ
ǣ
ǣǣ 63F343E7355AD6;@9FAF:7>A53F;A@A8F:7E?3DF?7F7D8DA?

;9GD76?;@;EFD3F;H7)A>7;7D3D5:KA8F:7,F;>;FK I:;5:F:;E63F3:3E477@D757;H76$AD7AH7D63F3I;F:;@
A@FDA>7@F7D 735:53F79ADK;E5>3EE;8;76;@FAD73>F;?763F33@6@A@D73>
F;?763F3+:;E5>3EE;8;53F;A@;E;?BADF3@FFA67F7D?;@7I:A
E?7@F;A@7673D>;7DE7@;ADDA>7EFAI3D6EF:7FABA8F:7 ;E 3GF:AD;L76 FA 3557EE 735: ?7F7D 63F3 53F79ADK AD
:;7D3D5:K;@F:7D79G>3DDA>7:;7D3D5:K;@:7D;FB7D?;EE;A@E 7J3?B>7;EEG;@94;>>ED7CG;D7E3557EE4KF:7355AG@F3@FFA
8DA?<G@;ADDA>7EFAI3D6EF:74AFFA?A8F:7:;7D3D5:K3@6 @A@D73> F;?7 ?7F7D 63F3 I;F:;@ F:7 5GEFA?7DD7>3F76
<G@;ADDA>7E;@:7D;F?7?47DE8AD?E7@;ADDA>7E @F:753E7 53F79ADKFAH;7IF:7FAF3>3?AG@FA8BAI7D5A@EG?BF;A@A8
A836?;@;EFD3F;H7DA>7:;7D3D5:KE3?75A@57BF3BB>;7EAD 3 57DF3;@ 5GEFA?7D 3@6 67F7D?;@7 F:7 ?A@F:>K 4;>>
7J3?B>7 3 E7@;AD DA>7 EG5: 3E **& ;@:7D;FE B7D?;EE;A@E 355AD6;@9>K3@6366;FFAF:75GEFA?7DQE8;@3@5;3>D75AD6
8DA? <G@;AD DA>7E E:AI@ FAI3D6E F:7 4AFFA? A8 F:7 AI7H7DF:7355AG@F3@F;E@AF3>>AI76FA3557EED73>F;?7

7
5GEFA?7DD7>3F76 63F3 F:3F 53DD;7E ;@8AD?3F;A@ 34AGF F:7 ;@ F:7 $$ EKEF7? FA 7@EGD7 F:3F E?3DF ?7F7DEQ 63F3 ;E
5A@EG?BF;A@BDA8;>73@635F;H73BB>;3@57EI;F:;@5GEFA?7D BDAF75F76 +:DAG9: BDAB7D 3EE;9@?7@F A8 GE7DE FA DA>7E
:A?73D73@7FIAD=% ?7F7DEQ63F3I;>>473557EE76A@>K4K3GF:AD;L76GE7DEAD
EEG?7F:3F3GE7D;EFDK;@9FA3557EEEA?763F3AII;>> 8GFGD7 IAD= I7 I;>> 7JF7@6 AGD D7E73D5: FA 366D7EE
AGD3D5:;F75FGD7675;67FA9D3@F3557EEFAF:;EGE7DAD@AF E75GD;@95A9@;F;H7D36;A5A??G@;53F;A@I;F:;@E?3DF9D;6
)787DD;@9FAF:7) $$D787D7@57?A@;FAD;@;9GD7 7@H;DA@?7@F 3@6 I7 I;>> 6A 3 B7D8AD?3@57 3@3>KE;E FA
F:7 I;>> 8ADI3D6 F:7 3557EE D7CG7EF FA F:7 H3>;63F7AGDIAD=
I:;5:;@FGD@I;>>F3=7675;E;A@355AD6;@9FA)3557EE
BA>;5;7E;@F:7)GF:AD;L3F;A@$A6G>74K5:75=;@9 #&'/$%&,
DA>7 :;7D3D5:K 3@6 5A@EFD3;@FE EG5: 3E E7B3D3F;A@ A8 6GFK +:;E D7E73D5: ;E 8G@676 4K F:7 ,, D7E73D5: 9D3@F
EF3F;5 6K@3?;5 $AD7AH7D F:7 36?;@;EFD3F;H7 DA>7 @G?47D +

:;7D3D5:KI;>>F3=753D7A8F:73EE;9@?7@FA8BDAB7DGE7DE
FA 67E;9@3F76 DA>7E #7FQE F3=7 (*'", I;F:;@ F:7 *&+
7@9;@77D;@967B3DF?7@F3E3@7J3?B>7I:7D7F:;EBDA<75F 12 %A7>3@6$93DI3>*?3DF9D;6@7FIAD=E
EF3F7 A8 F:7 3DF D7H;7I ;@ #!&$ )'**#&!
;E;@F7@676FA:3@6>73EB75;8;5D7E;67@F;3>3D73I;F:;@F:7
& '%%,&#+#'&
&+)&+#'&$
E?3DF9D;6+:;E?73@EF:3FGE7DE3EE;9@76FADA>7E;@F:;E '& )&'&
BB
BDA<75F 53@ 3557EE D73>F;?7 ?7F7D 63F3D757;H76 8DA? 3>> 12 $ AEE3;@ % $36>AA> % )3:;? ! *7>H3D3<
E?3DF?7F7DEI;F:;@F:3FD7E;67@F;3>3D73;@AD67DFA?A@;FAD '3@67K3@6":3@)A>7A8E?3DF9D;6;@
9D;6 B7D8AD?3@57 7@7D9K 67?3@6 3@6 5GEFA?7DEQ D7@7I34>77@7D9K@AH7DH;7I&.$&
5A@EG?BF;A@ BDA8;>7 AI7H7D ;F ;E ;?BADF3@F FA 7@EGD7 ,*+#&$ &)!/ -#.* HA>
BB
F:3FF:;E63F3;E3557EE764K3GF:AD;L76GE7DEA@>K;7GE7DE

1 2 $ >7H7>3@6 K47D E75GD;FK ;EEG7E 8AD
8DA?3@AF:7DBDA<75FI;F:;@F:77@9;@77D;@967B3DF?7@FAD
36H3@576 ?7F7D;@9 ;@8D3EFFDG5FGD7 3?; ;@
7H7@GE7DE8DA?AF:7D67B3DF?7@FE6A@QF:3H73557EEFAF:;E '.) & &)!/ '#+/ &)$ +#&!
63F3 ;@ AD67D FA 9G3D3@F77 5GEFA?7DEQ BD;H35K '&-)*#'&&$#-)/' $+)#$&)!/#&
5A@8;67@F;3>;FK3@6;@F79D;FK +" *+&+,)/
BB
+:DAG9: F:7 36?;@;EFD3F;H7 DA>7 :;7D3D5:K 735: E75GD;FK 12 - G@9AD 3@6 *3:;@ A9@;F;H7 )36;A
A88;57D I;>> ?3@397 F:7 3EE;9@?7@F A8 GE7DE FA ;@F7@676 %7FIAD=E 8AD *?3DF D;6 BB>;53F;A@E
DA>7E 355AD6;@9 FA ;FE DA>7 D3@97 3@6 F:7 D7CG;D76 'DA?;E;@9 +75:@A>A9K FA &H7D5A?7 *B75FDG?
@788;5;7@5K "#,$) "&'$'!/ !0#&
BD7D7CG;E;F7DA>7E+:7D78AD73@KGE7DI;F:;@(*'",:3E
HA>BB

FA478DA?F:77@9;@77D;@967B3DF?7@FFA473EE;9@764K 12 3D=3 * * $3F:7I 3@6 / F;8 *75GD;@9
+:;E I;>> 9G3D3@F77 F:3F @A GE7D 8DA? AF:7D F:7 .74 A8 +:;@9E I;F: )A>73E76 557EE
67B3DF?7@FE I;>> :3H7 3557EE FA ?7F7D 63F3 D7>3F76 FA A@FDA>;@'*)/(+'$'!/&& ')%+#'&
(*'",&@F:7AF:7D:3@6
&!&*!&3EE;9@E ,)#+/*BD;@97D
BB
GE7DEFA*'",&*DA>7EAF:3FGE7DE8DA?AF:7D 12 +"D39:;$03?3@;$3@383@6*"
D39:;@3557EE5A@FDA>8D3?7IAD=;@3@6
BDA<75FE I;F:;@ F:7 7@9;@77D;@9 67B3DF?7@F ;FE7>8 53@@AF
A5 @7FIAD= ;@8D3EFDG5FGD7 ;@ -&
3557EE(*'",D7EAGD57E '%(,+) & '%%,&#+#'& &!#&)#&!
,BFAF:;E7@6F:73EE;9@?7@FA8GE7DEFADA>7E;E:3@6>76 "&'$'!/76*BD;@97D
BB
4KF:76757@FD3>;L7636?;@;EFD3F;H7F73?+:7@7JFEF7B;E 12 * $AAD7 "7K 73FGD7E A8 $7F7D 3F3
FA 7@EGD7 F:3F GE7DE I;F:;@ (*'", 6A@QF H;A>3F7 F:7;D $3@397?7@F*KEF7?E76

3557EE D;9:FE FA BDA<75F D7EAGD57E ?7F7D 63F3 12 )**3@6:G!AK@7#7;@EF7;@3@6
) $$ D787D7@57 ?A@;FAD I;>> F3=7 53D7 A8 F:;E 4K /AG?3@)A>743E763557EE5A@FDA>?A67>E
'%(,+)HA>BB
5:75=;@9F:3F7H7DK3557EED7CG7EF36:7D7EFA)3557EE
12 ) *3@6:G - :3?;6;B3F; 3@6 ( $G@3I7D
BA>;5;7E +:7 ) ?A67> 8AD DA>743E76
- &%#,* &%%,+,).&)" 36?;@;EFD3F;A@ A8 DA>7E )&*+#'&* '&
@F:;EB3B7DI7BDABAE763@3D5:;F75FGD7FAE75GD7?7F7D & ')%+#'& & /*+% ,)#+/ HA>
63F343E76A@F:7I7>>=@AI@)A>73E76557EEA@FDA> BB

)?A67> @F:;E3D5:;F75FGD7I7;@F79D3F76)

8

Securing Smart Meters Data For AMI Using RBAC

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Securing Smart Meters Data For AMI Using RBAC

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

2016 11th Asia Joint Conference on Information Security

978-1-5090-2285-4/16 $31.00 © 2016 IEEE 1

F:73557EE5A@FDA>BA>;5K>EA;@)B7D?;EE;A@E3D7 ** %$%+

$AD7AH7D 63F3 I;F:;@ 735: A8 F:7 34AH7 ?7@F;A@76

You might also like

Securing Smart Meters Data For AMI Using RBAC

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Securing Smart Meters Data For AMI Using RBAC

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

2016 11th Asia Joint Conference on Information Security

978-1-5090-2285-4/16 $31.00 © 2016 IEEE 1

F:73557EE5A@FDA>BA>;5K>EA;@)B7D?;EE;A@E3D7 ** %$%+ 

$AD7AH7D 63F3 I;F:;@ 735: A8 F:7 34AH7 ?7@F;A@76

You might also like

F:73557EE5A@FDA>BA>;5K>EA;@)B7D?;EE;A@E3D7 ** %$%+

$AD7AH7D 63F3 I;F:;@ 735: A8 F:7 34AH7 ?7@F;A@76