Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Drying Technology
Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information:
http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title~content=t713597247
To cite this Article Bajgai, Tirtha R. , Raghavan, G. S. Vijaya , Hashinaga, Fumio and Ngadi, Michael O.(2006)
'Electrohydrodynamic Drying—A Concise Overview', Drying Technology, 24: 7, 905 — 910
To link to this Article: DOI: 10.1080/07373930600734091
URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/07373930600734091
This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or
systematic reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan or sub-licensing, systematic supply or
distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden.
The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents
will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses
should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss,
actions, claims, proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly
or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material.
Drying Technology, 24: 905–910, 2006
Copyright # 2006 Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
ISSN: 0737-3937 print/1532-2300 online
DOI: 10.1080/07373930600734091
905
906 BAJGAI ET AL.
interaction of electric fields with dielectric materials. The drying. Compared to oven (convective) drying, EHD-
effects of air ions on biological material is the area of inves- drying lowers the cost of drying food and results in
tigation that has gathered the most interest.[12] superior food physiochemical properties such as nutrient
Krueger et al.[13] observed corona effects, namely an content, flavor, shrinkage, and color. Multiple electrode
ionic wind occurring within an electric field, by applying system in EHD drying shows a high potential for industrial
air ions to microorganisms. Evaporation phenomena of drying given their simplicity of design and lesser energy
air ions with various liquid substances such as saline sol- consumption compared to oven (convective) and freeze-
ution, ethyl alcohol, n-heptane, and water have been stud- drying. The non-thermal nature of EHD-drying may
ied by Hart and Bachman.[14] Carlon and Latham[15] present a wide range of applications in industrial drying,
observed that an increase in electric field strength increased given its capacity to produce high-quality processed
the drying rate of paper discs moistened with water. Chen products.[21,22]
and Barthakur[16] and Chen et al.[17] studied drying of In light of above discussion, this article seeks to examine
potato (Solanum tuberosum L.) slabs with air ions using a review the scope and prospects of EHD drying, considering
standard frequency electric field. Shigemitsu et al.[18] the need for new technologies of non-thermal processing of
showed the evaporation rate of distilled water to be directly biological materials.
proportional to the discharge potential. It is postulated
that the large ion current and ionic wind velocity were
responsible for the faster evaporation rate. Barthakur
and Arnold[19] showed the evaporation rate of water due EHD DRYING METHODS
to negative air ions to be greater than that associated with Electrohydrodynamic (EHD) drying consists of a verti-
positive air ions. Xue et al.[20] observed that increasing air cally moveable electrode with a sharply pointed needle pro-
flow during drying of radish (Raphanus sativus L.) slices in jected to a fixed horizontal grounded metallic plate on
a corona discharge decreased the drying rate. Isobe et al.[2] which the material to be dried is placed. The point elec-
Downloaded At: 03:31 21 January 2011
observed accelerated drying and enhanced sublimation of trode is connected to an AC or DC high-voltage trans-
agar gel under a DC-powered electric field–generating sys- former. The DC high-voltage transformer supplies either
tem. The evaporative effects of an electric field of standard negative or positive high-voltage. In order to set the desired
frequency (60 Hz) were found to be directly proportional to high-voltage parameters for EHD drying, the transformer
the electric field strength and to the duration of its appli- is connected to a voltage regulator. The input to the volt-
cation, but inversely proportional to the electrode gap. A age regulator is supplied from a 60-Hz, 110-V, AC source.
two-point electrode under an optimized electrode gap The electrode gap can be adjusted to the desired distance
allowed faster drying of an apple (Malus domestica Borkh. by moving the pointed electrode up and down (Fig. 1)[21].
cv. Fuji) slice than did a single-point electrode system.[11] The greater the voltage applied under EHD drying, the
Drying rates obtained for radish and spinach (Spinacia greater the drying rate; however, the voltage is maintained
oleracea L.) under a multi-needle emitting electrode system until the occurrence of sparkover. Optimum electrode gap
were as high as those achieved by oven drying.[21,22] How- and sharpness of the corona-generating needles are impor-
ever, the chlorophyll and ascorbic acid contents of the tant in achieving faster drying.
EHD-dried spinach were greater than those of oven-dried
spinach. The EHD-dried radish slices also showed better
color, greater subsequent water reabsorption, less shrink-
age, and less loss of solids in rehydration than oven-dried
radish slices.
Single and multiple needle EHD configurations enhanced
drying compared to convective drying. The resulting negative
or positive corona-associated winds vary linearly with the
applied electric field strength.[23–26]. In further studies on
EHD-drying, Jumah et al.[27] demonstrated the effectiveness
of electro-osmosis under an AC current for dewatering of
tomato paste. Energy losses from coronal discharge during
the drying of agricultural materials was found to be lesser
than under conventional drying techniques.[20,23,28]
In EHD drying, either AC or DC high voltage of ordi-
nary frequency (60 Hz) can be used. Multiple point-to-plate
electrode systems are efficient in accelerating drying of fruit
and vegetables and present significant prospects for bulk FIG. 1. Diagram of electrohydrodynamic (EHD) drying.
ELECTROHYDRODYNAMIC DRYING—AN OVERVIEW 907
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION carried out by Hashinaga et al.[11] and Bajgai and
Drying rates (moisture loss) under EHD, oven (convec- Hashinaga[21,22] showed the higher drying efficiency of
tive), and ambient air drying methods are shown in Fig. 2. sharp needles. Thus, the intra-electrode separation, elec-
The rate of drying with a five-needle electrode under ambi- trode gap, electric field strength, and electrode sharpness
ent condition (25C and 65% RH) demonstrates the effec- were determinant factors for EHD drying.
tiveness of EHD drying compared to ambient air (25C) More studies on the drying characteristics of wire and
and convective (60C) drying.[21] Lai and Wong[23] needle electrodes in EHD-drying are needed to understand
observed a similar drying rate by corona discharge from their influence on the drying mechanism. Various studies in
a needle electrode under ambient conditions and with air- this area show that both AC and DC currents are
flow. Under ambient conditions, until the occurrence of employed with high voltages. Figure 2 shows the EHD
sparking, as the applied voltage increased the drying due (25C and RH 65%), oven (convective) (60C) and ambient
to the corona effect was enhanced, but at high air flow air (25C) drying pattern of radish slices dried in an ordi-
velocities drying was independent of the applied voltage. nary fluorescent tube lighted chamber. The EHD drying
Barthakur and Arnold[19] showed ionic current and electric was more effective compared to convective and ambient
wind velocities to be greater for negative air ions than for air drying. A good agreement in slope was found between
positive air ions. Under 5.25 kV applied voltage with elec- the EHD and convective drying pattern of radish slice.
trode gaps of 5, 10, and 20 mm, the electric wind velocities However, further studies on AC and DC high-voltage mul-
for negative and positive air ions were 2.5, 1.7, and 0.8 m s 1 tiple needle electrode–to–plate electrode system with air
and 2.1, 1.5, and 0.7 m s 1, respectively. Under identical flow or reduced atmospheric conditions would be required
conditions ionic currents for the negative and positive air to fully assess the superior EHD drying protocol.
ions were 16.2, 7.8, and 2.4 mA and 9.0, 5.0, and 1.9 mA, As consumers prefer foods with greater nutrient content,
respectively. natural color, texture, and flavor, a demand for develop-
Downloaded At: 03:31 21 January 2011
After the introduction of a certain number of pointed ment of new technologies is obvious. Food quality is one
electrodes for a fixed drying area, the rate of drying did of the main preoccupations in food research. To address
not increase with the addition of further pointed electrodes, these issues, the relevant data on the effects of EHD drying
indicating the importance of intra-electrode separation.[21] on food quality were compiled and examined in view of
Hashinaga et al.[11] observed maximum drying under a assessing its future potential from an energy and environ-
13-mm electrode gap. The optimum electric field strengths mental prospective.
they noted for sharp and blunt needles in the experiment Conventional hot air drying of fruits and vegetables
were 4.4 105 and 4.7 05 V m 1, respectively. In previous leads to irreversible textural damage due to high shrinkage
studies on evaporating water and alcohol, Hashinaga which is related to the water volume removed during the
et al.[29] used a wire electrode instead of a needle electrode. process.[30] Figure 3 shows the shrinkage pattern under
Wire electrodes are blunt at their ion emitting ends, EHD (25C) and oven (60C) drying of radish slices. After
whereas needle electrodes are sharper. Further studies 7 h of drying, EHD and oven drying caused 55 and 80%
shrinkage, respectively.[21] These results are comparable
FIG. 2. EHD, oven (convective), and ambient drying pattern of radish FIG. 3. Shrinkage pattern for EHD- and oven (convective)-dried radish
slices. slices.
908 BAJGAI ET AL.
to those obtained for apple slice shrinkage under EHD dry- Color is an important attribute of dried fruit and vege-
ing.[11] Many dehydrated products in the market with
Downloaded At: 03:31 21 January 2011
TABLE 1
Hunter color value ‘‘a’’ for EHD (5C), oven (convective) (60C) and ambient air–dried (25C) spinach
Drying time (h)
Drying methods 0 3 5 7
EHD 20.5 1.9 18.5 2.1 17.5 2.1 16.3 2.2
oven (convective) 20.5 1.9 17.2 2.4 14.7 2.2 08.5 2.4
Ambient air 20.5 1.9 18.4 1.7 17.6 2.2 16.1 1.7
ELECTROHYDRODYNAMIC DRYING—AN OVERVIEW 909
TABLE 2
HPLC profile for organic acids and sugar for EHD and oven (convective)-dried spinach samples
Retention time (min) Peak area (relative)
Organic compounds EHD dried Oven (convective) dried EHD dried Oven (convective) dried
a
Organic acids
Citric 13.664 13.624 5472 1479
L:Malic 15.798 15.802 12,322 19,607
Succinic 18.676 18.638 3438 11,449
Fumaric 21.128 21.024 29,672 79,662
Propionic 25.275 25.244 17,671 29,913
Sugarsb
Fructose 6.924 6.806 1,791,548 1,506,103
a
Shimadzu LC-10AS chromatograph equipped with a Shodex SC-125S column, size, 4.6 mm 500 mm; mobile phase, 0.1% H3PO4,
flow rate, 0.3 ml=min; column temperature, 55C; detector, Shimadzu SPD-6A at 210 nm; recorder, Shimadzu Chromatopack C-R4A.
b
Shimadzu SCL-10 chromatograph equipped with a Shim-pack CLC-NH2(M) column; size, 6.0 mm 150 mm; mobile phase, 70%
CH3CN; flow rate, 0.3 ml=min; column temperature, 40C, detector, Shimadzu SPD-6A at 192 nm; recorder, Shimadzu Chromatopack
C-R8A.
indicating that EHD drying did not generate new undesir- of air ions, energy dissipation, post-dried food quality, and
able substances compared to convective drying. scale-up–related problems are needed.
The currents and voltage measured in various EHD dry-
Downloaded At: 03:31 21 January 2011
10. Cohen, J.S.; Yang, C.S. Progress in food dehydration. Trends in Food 22. Bajgai, T.R.; Hashinaga, F. Drying of spinach with a high electric
Science and Technology 1995, 6, 20–25. field. Drying Technology 2001, 19 (9), 2331–2341.
11. Hashinaga, F.; Bajgai, T.R.; Isobe, S.; Barthakur, N.N. EHD-drying 23. Lai, F.C.; Wong, D.S. EHD enhanced drying with needle electrode.
of apple slices. Drying Technology 1999, 17 (3), 479–495. Drying Technology 2003, 21 (7), 1291–1306.
12. Bracken, D.T. Small air ion properties. In Air Ions Physical and Bio- 24. Lai, F.C.; Huang, M.; Wong, D.S. EHD-enhanced water evaporation.
logical Aspects; Jonatthan, M.J.M.; Kavet, R., Eds.; CRC Press: Boca Drying Technology 2004, 22 (3), 597–608.
Raton, FL, 1987; 1–11. 25. Alem-Rajabi, A.; Lai, F.C. EHD-enhanced drying of partially wetted
13. Krueger, A.P.; Hicks, W.W.; Beckett, J.C. Effect of unipolar air ions glass beads. Drying Technology 2005, 23 (3), 597–609.
on microorganisms and on evaporation. Journal of the Franklin Insti- 26. Balcer, B.E.; Lai, F.C. EHD-enhanced drying with multiple-wire elec-
tute 1958, 266, 9–19. trode. Drying Technology 2004, 22 (4), 821–836.
14. Hart, F.X.; Bachman, Ch.H. The effect of air ions on liquid evaporation 27. Jumah, R.; Al-Asheh, S.; Banat, F.; Al-Zoubi, K. Electro-osmotic
rates. International Journal of Biometeorology 1968, 12, 251–261. dewatering of tomato paste suspension under AC electric field. Drying
15. Carlon, H.R.; Latham, J. Enhanced drying rates of wetted materials in Technology 2005, 23 (7), 1465–1475.
electrical fields. Journal of Atmospheric and Terrestrial Physics 1992, 28. Li, F.; Li, L.; Sun, J.; Tatsumi, E. Electrohydrodynamic (EHD) drying
54 (2), 117–118. characteristics of okara cake. Drying Technology 2005, 23 (3), 565–580.
16. Chen, Y.H.; Barthakur, N.N. Potato slab dehydration by air ions 29. Hashinaga, F.; Kharel, G.P.; Shintani, R. Effect of ordinary frequency
from corona discharge. International Journal of Biometerology high electric fields on evaporation and drying. Food Science and
1991, 35, 67–70. Technology 1995, 1 (2), 77–81.
17. Chen, Y.; Barthakur, N.N.; Arnold, N.P. Electrohydrodynamic 30. Kechaou, N.; Roques, M.A. A variable diffusivity model for drying of
(EHD) drying of potato slabs. Journal of Food Engineering 1994, highly deformable materials. In Drying ‘89, Mujumdar, A.S.; Roques,
23, 107–119. M.A., Eds.; Hemisphere: New York, 1989; 332–338.
18. Shigemitsu, T.; Watanabe, Y.; Hasuike, K. The effect of corona dis- 31. Jayaraman, K.S.; Gupta, D.K.D. Drying of fruits and vegetables. In
charge on water evaporation. Biology Laboratory, Abiko, Chiba, Handbook of Industrial Drying; Mujumdar, A.S., Ed.; Marcel Dekker:
Japan, 1994, Rep., No. 486011 (in Japanese). New York, 1995; 643–690.
19. Barthakur, N.N.; Arnold, N.P. Evaporation rate enhancement of 32. Rahman, M.S. Toward prediction of porosity in foods during drying:
water with air ions from a corona discharge. International Journal a brief review. Drying Technology 2001, 19 (1), 1–13.
of Biometerology 1995, 39, 29–33. 33. Bellows, J.R.; King, C.J. Product collapse during freeze-drying of
Downloaded At: 03:31 21 January 2011
20. Xue, G-R.; Uchino, T.; Matsuo, M. Drying promotion of radish using liquid foods. AICHE Symposium Series 1973, 132, 33–41.
corona discharge. Nougyou Kishou Gakkai Si 1994, 56 (5), 35–42 (in 34. Yi, W.; Joan, F.; Gerard, K.; Casimir, C.A. Phenolic compounds from
Japanese). blueberries can inhibit colon cancer cell proliferation and induce
21. Bajgai, T.R.; Hashinaga, F. High electric field drying of Japanese rad- apoptosis. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 2005, 53
ish. Drying Technology 2001, 19 (9), 2291–2301. (18), 7320–7329.