You are on page 1of 142

Lean Six Sigma Yellow Belt

Certification Training
Online Mode

Yellow Belt

Krishnan P M
Principal Counsellor-
Business Excellence & Lean Six Sigma
Confederation of Indian Industry,
Institute of Quality, Bangalore.
© Confederation of Indian Industry
© Confederation of Indian Industry
V1.0 Feb 2021 1
This material is shared with the participants of the Online Training of this
program only. The material should not be shared with any other person
and is strictly to be used for this training purpose only.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 2


Introductions & Expectations

… … … …
… …
… …
© Confederation of Indian Industry 3
Content
1. Overview, Lean & Six Sigma
Introduction
2. Managing Change
3. Six Sigma Methodology-DMAIC
✓ Define Phase
✓ Measure Phase
✓ Analysis Phase
✓ Improve Phase
✓ Control Phase
4. Evaluation
5. Conclusion

© Confederation of Indian Industry 4


About CII

CII over the years has forged a strong nationwide network working beyond facilitating
growth and development of industry to address economic and societal challenges.

CII has been a lead player in Indian industry’s trajectory. With its origins in 1895, it has
assumed a key position at the forefront of development, especially since liberalization
in 1991. Committed to working closely with Government on policy issues, it is the
interface between Government and industry for enhancing competitiveness and
strategic global linkages.

Partnerships with civil society organizations carry forward corporate initiatives for
integrated and inclusive development across diverse domains including affirmative
action, healthcare, education, livelihood, diversity management, skill development,
empowerment of women, and water, to name a few. These are areas where CII has
pioneered industry engagement and is setting the pace for industry-community
partnerships.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 5


About CII - IQ

CII Institute of Quality is the leading authority


in Quality Enhancement among organisations
and industries. Over the past century, CII has
provided Indian Industry with the support,
systems and tools to make a mark in the
competitive world. CII IQ aims to enhance an
organisation’s competitiveness is through the
quality route.

Verticals of CII-IQ are: The CII Institute of Quality has been awarded
‘GOLD’ level of certification under the ‘IGBC Green
• Business Excellence Existing Buildings’ rating system on 25th November
• Quality Management Systems 2017 during the 25th Silver Jubilee National Quality
Summit celebrations in Bangalore
• Lean Six Sigma
• Total Productive Maintenance
© Confederation of Indian Industry 6 6
HIGHLIGHTS ➢ 1988 - CII set up the TQM Division with the objective of
supporting Indian Industry – Opening of Economy-
Competition

➢ 2001 – Formal Inauguration of CII-Institute of Quality focusing


on Quality and Competitiveness of industry

➢ First Centre of Excellence on Quality –nodal and reference


point for Quality – Pioneer for Quality Movement in India

➢ Initial Focus - Created consciousness in Industry and Society


on Quality.

➢ Brought significant changes in India on how Quality was


perceived – Inspection to Quality Assurance to Operational
& Business Excellence

© Confederation of Indian Industry 7


Certification Criteria-Yellow Belt

• 100 % Attendance of All Modules


• Continuous Evaluation of Group works
• Min 70% marks in Qualifying Exam(will be conducted on
final day)- Note: Candidate fail to score the required level,
can take a re-test later as announced by CII.
• Online, Open Book Test

© Confederation of Indian Industry 8


1. Overview

© Confederation of Indian Industry 9


100% Inspection/Verification…...

………………..what’s the reality??

© Confederation of Indian Industry 10


Market Leaders “Then”

………..Market Leaders “Today” ????

-----
What has changed over time?

© Confederation of Indian Industry 11


Transformation- The Need

Technology changes
are faster, superior

Example- changes in
the last three decades

12

© Confederation of Indian Industry 12


Do you have issues related to

Process Variation

© Confederation of Indian Industry 13


If your answer is YES to any those…
Opportunity
Identification
Then you need a
structured improvement
Solution
program Periodic Analysis
Review &Implement
One of the solution is ation

Adapting
Lean Six Sigma Methodology Improvement

© Confederation of Indian Industry 14


What is Sigma and Six Sigma?

Sigma is

A uniform measurement

Six Sigma is
is a uniform improvement method

15Indian Industry
© Confederation of 15
History : Change

❑ 1850 – Interchangeble parts


– Eli Whitney

❑ 1920 – Time and motion


study – Frederick Taylor
❑ Ford : Mass production - 1920

❑ 1940 – TQM – Dr. Deming


❑ Toyoto : Focus on “flow”,
elimination of waste time &
material – 1950

❑ Motorola : Six Sigma –1986

© Confederation of Indian Industry 16


What is Lean

• Lean manufacturing is a methodology that focuses on minimizing waste within


manufacturing systems while simultaneously maximizing productivity.

• Lean manufacturing is based on a number of specific principles, such as Kaizen, or


continuous improvement.

WORK FOR
MAP VALUE ESTABLISH FLOW IMPLEMENT PULL PERFECTION
SPECIFY VALUE STREAM

Define value from Draw the AS-IS Identify the flow Demand from Strive towards
customer’s process flow that of material and customer to be providing best
perspective; create value-add, information known to customer
define non-value add to across the supply implement pull. satisfaction ; focus
products/service customer chain[end-to- Pull system works
end] on kaizen to
when customer
continuous
signals the need
for the product / remove waste
service from processes

PRINCIPLES OF LEAN

© Confederation of Indian Industry 17


What is Lean

The 7 Wastes of Lean Production


• Defects, which require effort and cost for corrections.
• Over-production of a product;
• Waiting, whether it is people waiting or idle equipment
• Unnecessary Transportation;
• Excess Inventory;

• Unnecessary Motion of people, equipment or machinery;

• Excess-processing or putting more time into a product than a customer needs, such as
designs that require high-tech machinery for unnecessary features;

8th Waste..?

© Confederation of Indian Industry 18


Lean Manufacturing Tools and Concepts

Heijunka: production leveling or smoothing that seeks to produce a continuous flow of production, releasing work to
the plant at the required rate and avoiding interruptions.

Kanban: A signal -- either physical, such as tag or empty bin, or electronically sent through a system -- used to
streamline processes and create just-in-time delivery.

Jidoka: A method of providing machines and humans with the ability to detect an abnormality and stop work until it can
be corrected.

Andon: A visual aid, such as a flashing light, that alerts workers to a problem.

Poka-yoke: A mechanism that safeguards against human error, such as an indicator light that turns on if a necessary
step was missed, a sign given when a bolt was tightened the correct number of times or a system that blocks a next step
until all the previous steps are completed.

5S: A set of practices for organizing workspaces to create efficient, effective and safe areas for workers and which
prevent wasted effort and time. 5S emphasizes organization and cleanliness.

SMED/QCT: A method to instantly change the tool/die to reduce setup time of a machine/press.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 19


Lean Manufacturing Tools and Concepts- 5S

© Confederation of Indian Industry 20


Lean Manufacturing Tools and Concepts- 5S

© Confederation of Indian Industry 21


5S

© Confederation of Indian Industry 22


Lean thinking…

Lean Thinking is all about…

• Rethinking every aspect of jobs, careers, functions and firms in order to correctly
specify value as defined by the customer.

• Consider the customers investment in time and effort to be able to receive the
service.

• Putting the entire Value Stream for specific products relentlessly in the foreground

• Making value flow continuously along the whole length of Value stream

• Ensuring this flow is pulled by the customer in pursuit of perfection

© Confederation of Indian Industry 23


House of Lean

HOUSE OF LEAN

Achieve Highest Quality, Lowest Cost, Shortest Lead Time


JIT Jidoka
• Stop, Correct,
• Continuous Flow Proceed
• Takt time • QCT/SMED
• Pull system • Less Human-
• Kanban Machine
interaction

Heijunka Standardized work Kaizen

Stable and Enhanced Production

© Confederation of Indian Industry 24


Six Sigma

© Confederation of Indian Industry 25


Reduce the Variation – Rewards Are High…..

• 68.26% of the data will fall within +/- 1s from the mean
• 95.46% of the data will fall within +/- 2s from the mean
• 99.73% of the data will fall within +/- 3s from the mean
• 99.9937% of the data will fall within +/- 4s from the mean
• 99.999943% of the data will fall within +/- 5s from the mean
• 99.9999998% of the data will fall within +/- 6s from the mean

68.26 %

95.46%

99.73%

-4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
© Confederation of Indian Industry 26
Statistical Meaning of Six Sigma
Lower Upper
Specification Limit Mean / Target Specification Limit

High
Probability
of Failure
1

3 1 3 1

Much Lower
Probability
1 of Failure

6 2

© Confederation of Indian Industry 27


Sources of Inefficiencies

• Use of resources beyond what is needed


to meet customer requirements
1.

Waste

2.
3. • Inability of the process to deliver
• Any deviation from
Variability and meet customer requirements
performance standards Inflexibility

© Confederation of Indian Industry 28


Lean Six Sigma
Typical primary Lean entry point: Typical primary Six-Sigma entry point:
Reduce waste Reduce variability

Overproduction
1 Sample distribution
Unnecessar Waiting "Voice of
y 7 2 the
movements Transportation
customer"
WASTE LSL USL
6 3
Rework and
rejections
+
5 44 Over-
LCL UCL
"Voice of the process"
processing
Inventory

• Waste
• Waste

© Confederation of Indian Industry 29


Lean Six Sigma

Lean
Six
Lean Six
Sigma
Sigma
Reduce waste by Eliminate defects and Serve customers with faster
reorganizing reduce variation in the and reliable
the process process products/services

▪ Remove waste ▪ Remove variation ▪ Reduce defect rate


▪ Increase speed ▪ Increase quality ▪ Prevent problem from
▪ Remove non-value ▪ Detect and recurrence
added steps eliminate errors ▪ Add value to customer
▪ Focus on customer ▪ Focus on customer ▪ Retain customer

© Confederation of Indian Industry 30


2. Managing Change

© Confederation of Indian Industry 31


Stages of Change

Contentment Renewal
➢Provide a Vision ➢Leverage Enthusiasm
➢Paint a Picture ➢Keep Them Involved
➢Raise Awareness

Denial Confusion
➢Listen to Views ➢Provide a Plan
➢Focus on Process ➢Pilot and Deploy
➢Gather Data ➢Follow Methodology

© Confederation of Indian Industry 32


Breakthrough Need New Approach

© Confederation of Indian Industry 33


What prevents us to make dramatic changes ?
• Barriers
– subject matters
– process deficiency
– relying on experience (paradigms)
Finish
– Company culture
– Individual resistance Finish

Start

Start

© Confederation of Indian Industry 34


Group Work

© Confederation of Indian Industry 35


3. Lean Six Sigma
Methodology

© Confederation of Indian Industry 36


DMAIC & DFSS
DMAIC DFSS
Define Define

the Requirement
characterisation

Understanding
Process
Y’s Measure Measure

Analyse Analyse

Optimisation
Design
optimisation

Improve
Process

Optimise

Design
X’s
Control Validate

© Confederation of Indian Industry 37


Levels of Lean Six Sigma Certification
• Awareness of Learn Six Sigma methodology and tools
Green Belt
• Participate in improvement projects with some mentoring
(GB)
• Continuous improvement focus

• Learn Six Sigma methodology and tools


Green Belt
• Apply Six Sigma to projects in current job scope
(GB)
• Lead improvement projects with some mentoring

• Lead multiple Six Sigma projects


Black Belt
• Apply Six Sigma to individual projects working independently
(BB)
• Mentor Green Belts

Master • Train others in Six Sigma


Black Belt • Mentor Black Belts and Green Belts
(MBB) • Cultural change agent for Six Sigma

© Confederation of Indian Industry 38


3a. DMAIC Approach

© Confederation of Indian Industry 39


Introduction to Six Sigma: DMAIC

Define Where is the Gap and How Much is the Gap

Measure What are the Current Performance

Analyse
What are the potential root causes of &
improvement opportunities?

What are the solutions and how do we


Improve
implement them?

Control How do we maintain the gains?

© Confederation of Indian Industry 40


DMAIC Approach

3b. DEFINE PHASE

© Confederation of Indian Industry 41


Introduction to Six Sigma

Define Where is the Gap and How Much is


the Gap

Measure What are the Current Performance

Analyse What are the potential root causes of & improvement


opportunities?

Improve What are the solutions and how do we implement


them?

Control How do we maintain the gains?

© Confederation of Indian Industry 42


Define
1. Project Charter

Define 2. Stakeholder Analysis

3. Process Mapping
Key Deliverables :
➢ Develop Team Charter (Business case, Goal Statements, Scope,
Milestone, Team..)
➢ Stakeholder Analysis
➢ Detailed Process Map
Applicable Tools :
➢ Charter Stakeholder Analysis, Kano Model
➢ Process Mapping – SIPOC, VSM

© Confederation of Indian Industry 43


Approach to Project Selection

Identify Opportunities

Prioritise – Impact v/s Feasibility

Identify Team

Stakeholder Buy-In

Charter

© Confederation of Indian Industry 44


Project Prioritization

▪ Impact
▪ Success Elements
✓ Critical to customer
✓ Critical to business ✓ Dedicated resource that possesses
✓ The problem must be solved process / product expertise
✓ Project meets expectations
✓ Completed in a short timeframe
3-6 months
▪ Feasibility
✓ Clear sponsorship and process
ownership
✓ Solution unknown or ✓ Adhering to a structured, well
unproven communicated improvement plan
✓ Additional analysis &
validation required

© Confederation of Indian Industry 45


Project charter
• A project charter explains what is the project, the approach to solve it, who are the
team members
• It is a living document & must be revisited on need basis.

Along with the basic project details Project charter answers 7 main questions

1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Why should What
we do this exactly is What are By when & What are Who will What are
the what will be project be part of the start &
project the
expected the boundari the end dates?
problem?
benefits? outcome? es? project?

Business Problem Expected Goal Team roles Project


Project
Case statement benefits statement timeline
scope

© Confederation of Indian Industry 46


Project charter
Business problem Risk

Project milestones & schedule


Goals Phase Milestone Target Review Remark
completion dates

Define Project Charter


Stakeholder Analysis
Process Mapping

Measure Validate Measurement System


Collect Data
Establish Baseline

Scope (IN & OUT bonds) Team Members


Analysis Identify Sources of Variation
Funnel Causes
Validate Root Cause

Improve Generate Solution Ideas


Customers/Stakeholders Constraints & Assumptions Select Best Fit Solution
Test Solution & Confirm Results

Control Implement Solution


Monitor Process & Results
Replicate & Share Best Practices
Financial benefits

Resources

© Confederation of Indian Industry 47


Project charter – Example
Business problem Risk
• In-ability to make changes in the system
The bank currently is ramping up its Credit Operations at the rate of • Getting full support from field staff
15-20% per year. At this stage it is essential to improve the Turn
Around Time to the Benchmark Levels in industry and ensure Right
the First Time. Project milestones & schedule
Phase Milestone Target Revie Remar
Goals complet
ion
w
dates
k

Define Project Charter


•Reduce of TAT from current level of 1-7 Days to 75% within 1 Day Stakeholder Analysis
by Dec 2015 Process Mapping

•Establish the measurement for First Time Right/Rolled throughput Measure Validate Measurement System
Collect Data
Yield by Sep 2015 and reduce the gap between current level and Establish Baseline
100% by one third Analysis Identify Sources of Variation
Funnel Causes
Scope (IN & OUT bonds) Team Members Validate Root Cause
Home Loans to Salaried • Team Leader: AS, Improve Generate Solution Ideas
Customers in southern region • Team Members: VP, MSA, AYS, Select Best Fit Solution
Test Solution & Confirm Results
excluding Chennai Circle
Control Implement Solution
Customers/Stakeholders Constraints & Assumptions Monitor Process & Results
Replicate & Share Best Practices
Regional Heads, Branch •Availability of system data
Managers •Ability to change over the forms
Resources
Financial benefits •Field and branch staff
• Opportunity gain by early on-boarding (To be estimated) •IT
• Achieve benchmark level to enable increase in market share

© Confederation of Indian Industry 48


DMAIC Approach

3c. MEASURE PHASE

© Confederation of Indian Industry 49


Define Where is the Gap and How Much is the Gap

Measure What are the Current Performance

Analyse
What are the potential root causes of &
improvement opportunities?

What are the solutions and how do we


Improve
implement them?

Control How do we maintain the gains?

© Confederation of Indian Industry 50


Measure
4. Validate Measurement System

Measure 5. Collect Data

6. Establish Baseline

Key Deliverables :
➢ Measurement system for Ys and Xs
➢ Data Collection Plan & Compilation of Past Data
➢ Quantification of current performance level
Applicable Tools :
➢ Measurement System Analysis – Attribute and Variable
➢ Types of Data, Sampling, Simple Seven QC Tools
➢ Descriptive Statistics, Run Chart, Process Capability Analysis, Normality
Plot

© Confederation of Indian Industry 51


Why do Errors Occur?

▪ Incorrect procedures ▪ Unclear or undocumented


processes
▪ Excessive variation in the
process ▪ Unclear or incomplete
specifications
▪ Excessive variation in the raw
materials ▪ Human error

▪ Inaccurate measuring devices ▪ Inadequate Skill

© Confederation of Indian Industry 52


Detecting Errors

Traditional approach . . .
FEEDBACK

Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Inspection

Mistake Proofing provides immediate feedback so that action can


be taken

FEEDBACK FEEDBACK FEEDBACK

Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4

© Confederation of Indian Industry 53


Kano Model

multiple dimensions of quality Vs customer satisfaction

Dissatisfiers:
Basic needs - Presence of these features or
functions does not produce satisfaction,
but their absence creates strong
dissatisfaction.

Performance:
Satisfiers - Increasing these features or
functions leads to higher satisfaction.

Excitement:
Delighter - Presence of these unexpected
features or functions leads to "delight“ or
customers being "pleasantly surprised".

© Confederation of Indian Industry 54


Defining CTQ

A CTQ is a Product or Service characteristic that satisfies a


Customer Requirement OR a Process Requirement
• Customer CTQs are often hazy & they must be converted into meaningful internal
goals that are assignable to functions
• Some functions in the organization may also need to look at internal customers. In this
case, Business CTQs may mingle with Customer CTQs
• Internal CTQs are internal organizational deliverables that characterize a
customer CTQ

Some of the tools used to convert Customer CTQs / Business CTQs into internal CTQs
• CTQ Drill-down
• Quality Function Deployment (QFD / House of Quality)

© Confederation of Indian Industry 55


CTQ Drilldown tree

© Confederation of Indian Industry 56


Process Mapping - SIPOC

Process: Loan Processing


Supplier Input Process Output Customer
Loan Application
Processed Loan
Customer Credit rating Loan Processing Customer
in time

© Confederation of Indian Industry 57


Process Mapping Nomenclature

Process Decision Data

Pre-defined Document Terminator


Process

Manual Manual
Delay
Operation Input

© Confederation of Indian Industry 58


Process Map Example – Online Order and Delivery

No
Enter
Call Yes customer details
Customer calls
Answered?
in the system

Take Confirm Take


Yes
card Credit card? payment order
details type details

No
Deliver &
Despatch collect money,
order if non-credit card
customer
However, in this step, emphasis is on creating a micro-level process map. The team can go to
micro level or detailed process maps in Measure and Analyze phase
© Confederation of Indian Industry 59
Cross Functional Process Maps
Cross Functional Process Maps are also effective when the process moves
across different functions

Step
Function 1 Step 5
4

Step 3

Function 2
Step 2

Step 1 Step 8 End


Function 3

Step 6 Step 7
Function 4

© Confederation of Indian Industry 60


3c1. Data Collection

© Confederation of Indian Industry 61


Types Of Data
Data

Variable / Attribute /
Continuous Discrete
 Measurable  Countable
 Endlessly Divisible  Indivisible

© Confederation of Indian Industry 62


Basic Statistics – Numeric Representation

Project data can be numerically represented in two forms:

Mean Range
Median Variance
Mode Standard Deviation

Measures of central tendency Measures of variation

Location Spread

© Confederation of Indian Industry 63


Measures Of Location In Data

• Mean
• Arithmetic mean represents the simple average of observations in a sample

• Median
• Value at which at least 50% of observations are above and at least 50% of the data are
below
• For even number of observations the average of the two central values is often called the
Median

• p-Quartile
• Value at which at least p(100)% of observations are below and at least (1-p) 100% of the
data are above
• 25% Quartile: 25% of data (one quarter) are below and 75% are above
• 75% Quartile: 75% of data (three quarters) are below and 25% are above
© Confederation of Indian Industry 64
Measures Of Spread In Data
• Variance
• Obtained by averaging the squared deviations of observations around the
mean. Because its units are the square of the variable Y, it is a measure that is
not used directly but used to calculate standard deviations

• Standard Deviation
• Obtained by taking the square root of the variance and measures the spread
around the Mean. The interpretation in asymmetric sample distribution is not
always clear cut
• Range
• Obtained by subtracting the smallest observation (minimum) from the largest
observation (maximum)

• Coefficient of Variation (CV)


• The CV is the Standard Deviation divided by the Mean
© Confederation of Indian Industry 65
Data Collection Plan (DCP)

Once we complete Measurement System Analysis, we need to collect new set of data

Why we need to collect a new set of data to ensure the data we are collecting is
• Precise & Accurate
• Representative
• Stable

Key points to keep in mind


✓ What is the data type you want to collect
✓ Determine What kind of data that is available
✓ Determine how much data is needed
✓ Determine how to measure the data
✓ Decide who is going to collect the data
✓ Determine where the data will be collected from
✓ Decide whether to measure a sample or the whole
population
© Confederation of Indian Industry 66
Data Collection Template

Who
Sampling
What (is Being Measured) How (Is It Being Measured) (is
Frequency
measuring)
Sl.
No
Operational Operator Frequency of
Parameter To Data Environ Measuring
X or Y Definition of the Machine Material Method Name, the
Be Measured type ment Equipment
parameter Designation measurement

© Confederation of Indian Industry 67


DPU, DPO,DPMO Definitions

Defect (D)

Anything that results in customer dissatisfaction.


Anything that results in a non-conformance,

- 9 defects

© Confederation of Indian Industry 68


DPU, DPO,DPMO Formula

No of Units (U) = 4 Defects per Opportunity (DPO)


No of Defects (D) = 9 DPO =Defects(D)/ Total
Opportunities
Defects per Unit
= 9/20
DPU = D/U
= 0.45
9/4 = 2.25

DPMO = DPO*1,000,000
Total Opportunities = No of Units * No of
opportunities = 0.45*1,000,000
= 4*5=20 = 450000

© Confederation of Indian Industry 69


Defects per Million Opportunities → Sigma

SIGMA LEVEL WITHOUT SHIFT WITH SHIFT

1 3,17,400 6,97,700
2 45,400 3,08,537
3 2,700 66,807
4 63 6,201
5 0.57 233
6 0.002 3.4

© Confederation of Indian Industry 70


3c2. Standard
Deviation

© Confederation of Indian Industry 71


Causes of Variation

Common Causes
- Many small sources
- Stable
- Relatively predictable
- Permanent -unless action taken.

Special Causes
- One or few major sources
- May be irregular
- Unpredictable
- May reappear unless action taken

© Confederation of Indian Industry 72


Standard Deviation - Sample

The Sample Standard Deviation is Denoted by s. The formula has following


2 differences

1. Sample Average REPLACES Population Average


2. n-1 REPLACES N

= σ𝑁 (X − X ) 2
s 𝑖=1 i
n−1

Xi – Individual Observations

X – Average of the Sample


n – Sample Size
© Confederation of Indian Industry 73
3c3. Sampling plan

© Confederation of Indian Industry 74


Types of Sampling

Probability Samples

Simple Systematic
Random Random Stratified Cluster

Non-probability Samples

Quota Convenient Judgmental Snowball

© Confederation of Indian Industry 75


Random Sampling

xxxx x
xxxx x x
xx
xxxx
----
……..

Population Sample
N=2000 N=50

© Confederation of Indian Industry 76


Sample Size
Data

Variable / Continuous Attribute / Discrete


2 2
1.96s 1.96
n= n= [p(1-p)]
d d

n = sample size
s = standard deviation
d = precision
p = proportion defective
1.96 implies 95% Confidence

© Confederation of Indian Industry 77


3c4. Measurement System
Analysis (MSA)

© Confederation of Indian Industry 78


Gauge R & R

Gage R&R (Gage Repeatability and Reproducibility) is the amount of


measurement variation introduced by a measurement system, which consists
of the measuring instrument itself and the individuals using the instrument.

Purpose:
• Determine how much variability is due to the gage or instrument
• Isolate the components of variability of the measurement system
• Assess whether the instrument or gage is capable (suitable for
intended application)

© Confederation of Indian Industry 79


Key Concepts

▪ Accuracy and Precision


▪ Repeatability
▪ Reproducibility
▪ Stability
▪ Linearity
▪ Measurement System Analysis – Variable Data
▪ Measurement System Analysis – Attribute

© Confederation of Indian Industry 80


Accuracy & Precision

Accuracy refers to the closeness of a measured


value to a standard or known value

Precision refers to the closeness of two or more


measurements to each other.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 81


Repeatability

Repeatability is the variation in


measurements obtained with one
measurement instrument when used
several times by one appraiser while
measuring the identical characteristic on
Repeatability
the same part.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 82


Reproducibility

Operator B
Reproducibility is the variation in the
average of the measurements made by
Operator C
different appraisers using the same
measuring instrument when measuring Operator A
the identical characteristic on the same Reproducibility

part.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 83


Simple Seven Problem Solving Tools

1. Check Sheet

2. Histogram

3. Pareto Analysis

4. Cause and Effect Diagram

5. Stratification

6. Scatter Diagram
➢ Flow charting (Supplementary tool)
➢ Brain storming (Supplementary tool)
7. Control Charts
➢ Why Why Analysis

© Confederation of Indian Industry 84


What are QC Tools

QC Tools are techniques used in QC Activities for

➢Discovering problems (Check sheets, Graphs,charts)


➢Organizing information (Charts & Graphs)
➢Generating Ideas (Brain storming, cause & effect diagrams)
➢Analyzing causes (Pareto)
➢Taking Action
➢Effecting Improvements
➢Establishing Controls (Control charts)

© Confederation of Indian Industry 85


DMAIC Approach

3d. ANALYSE PHASE

© Confederation of Indian Industry 86


Introduction to Six Sigma: DMAIC

Define Where is the Gap and How Much is the Gap

Measure What are the Current Performance

What are the potential root causes of &


Analyse improvement opportunities?
What are the solutions and how do we
Improve implement them?

Control How do we maintain the gains?

© Confederation of Indian Industry 87


© Confederation of Indian Industry 88
Funneling

All ‘X’ s 30

Categorization

25 Data Available Data Not Available 5

Data Gemba Significance


Analysis Investigation Test

5 Real ‘X’ s Real ‘X’ s 3

Counter Measures/Actions 8
© Confederation of Indian Industry 89
Process capability

➢ What is difference Process Condition-A

between Process A,
B and C?
➢ Which is most
desirable?
L Mean U

Process Condition-B
Process Condition-C

U L Mean U
L Mean

© Confederation of Indian Industry 90


Process capability
Process 1 Process 2
LSL X=20, SD=1
X=22, SD=1
=16
USL LSL USL
=24 =16 =24

Process 3 Process 4
X=25, SD=1
LSL X=17, SD=1
=16 USL LSL USL
=24 =16 =24

© Confederation of Indian Industry 91


Calculation of Cpk index

Cpk = Minimum of ( CPU and CPL)

USL – X X - LSL
CPU = ----------- , CPL = -------------
3 SD 3 SD

Also, CPU = ZU / 3, and CPL = ZL/3

Calculate Cp and Cpk for the four processes depicted earlier.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 92


Chance causes / Common causes of
variation
➢Are Large in number
➢Each cause small variation
➢Can’t be easily identified
➢May not be always economical to eliminate

Assignable Causes or Special cuases of Variation


➢Are Small in number
➢Each causes large variation
➢Can be easily identified
➢It is always economical to eliminate

© Confederation of Indian Industry 93


Failure Mode and Effect Analysis

© Confederation of Indian Industry 94


Failure Mode Effect Analysis

FMEA is systematized and analytical technique intended to:

❑ Identify and evaluate potential failure modes and causes associated with
product and process design
❑ Identify actions that will eliminate or minimize the Risk associated with
potential product and process design failures
❑ Document the processes of due care and problem closure to positively define
what the design must do to satisfy the customer
❑ Be a tool for building and refining - not simply completed then tossed

© Confederation of Indian Industry 95


Risk Priority Number (RPN)

❑ SEVERITY ( Of Effect) - Importance of effect on customer requirement -


Could also be concerned with safety and other risks if failure occurs.

❑ OCCURRENCE ( Of Cause ) - Frequency with which a given cause occurs


and creates failure mode.

❑ DETECTION (Capability of Current Controls) - Ability of current control


scheme to detect:

▪ All three use a scale of 1- 10 ,with 1 being Best or lowest risk,


▪ 10 being worst or highest risk

RPN = Severity X Occurrence X Detection

Effects Causes Controls

© Confederation of Indian Industry 96


CURRENT CONTROLS :
The mechanisms that prevent or detect the failure mode before it reaches the
customer. Current controls include SPC, Inspections, Monitoring, Training,
Preventive Maintenance.

RECOMMENDED ACTION :
Corrective actions to reduce occurrence, and / or Detection rankings. Directed
at the highest RPN and critical severity items.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 97


FMEA worksheet
Using your Process Map, enter the process steps in the
Process Function (Step) column
Process Potential Potential S Potential O Current D R
function (step) failure modes failure effects E causes of C process E P
(process (Y’s) V failure (X’s) C control T N
defects)

© Confederation of Indian Industry 98


The Rating Scale
Use the following guide line for assigning ratings to Severity, Occurrence and Detection
Scores. Occurrence scores can be assigned based on probability or time period.
Severity Scale Occurrence Scale Detection Scale
Rating
Definition Time Period Probability Definition

10 Injure a customer or employee More than once per day > 30% Defect caused by failure is not detectable

9 Be illegal Once every 3-4 days ≤ 30% Occasional units are checked for defect

Units are systematically sampled and


8 Render product or service unfit for use Once per week ≤ 5% inspected

7 Cause extreme customer dissatisfaction Once per month ≤ 1% All units are manually inspected
Units are manually inspected with mistake-
6 Result in partial malfunction Once every 3 months ≤ .03% proofing modifications

Cause a loss of performance which is likely Process is monitored (SPC) and manually
5 to result in a complaint Once every 6 months ≤ 1 Per 10,000 inspected
SPC is used with an immediate reaction to
4 Cause minor performance loss Once per year ≤ 6 Per 100,000 out-of-control conditions

Cause a minor nuisance, but can be SPC as above with 100% inspection
3 overcome with no performance loss Once every 1-3 years ≤ 6 Per Million surrounding out -of-control conditions

Be unnoticed and have only minor effect on


2 performance Once every 3-6 years ≤ 3 Per 10 Million All units are automatically inspected

Be unnoticed and not affect the Defect is obvious and can be kept from
1 performance Once every 6-100 years ≤ 2 Per Billion affecting the customer

© Confederation of Indian Industry 99


FMEA Action Guide

❑ Take actions on the items having high RPN scores


❑ Besides the high RPN score items use the following guide to
identify the items which needs attention

© Confederation of Indian Industry 100


FMEA New Standard

Note – The details of FMEA given in the


earlier slides are based on previous version
of the standard, presented for understanding
the process of FMEA

While doing FMEA, you may refer to the new


standard guidelines for arriving at the
solution.

However, earlier standard also will provide


the necessary inputs for you to proceed with
the project effectively

© Confederation of Indian Industry 101


FMEA New Standard

© Confederation of Indian Industry 102


FMEA New Standard

© Confederation of Indian Industry 103


Validation Tools

© Confederation of Indian Industry 104


Overall Approach

Practical Problem Statistical Problem

Practical Solution Statistical Solution

© Confederation of Indian Industry 105


Method’s To Identify ALL Possible
Factors Affecting Variation……

Process Map Analysis Cause and Effect

Xs Ys

Suspected
ALL POTENTIAL Xs
Causes
Graphical Analysis
Pareto Analysis

© Confederation of Indian Industry 106


Funneling

All ‘X’ s 30

Categorization

25 Data Available Data Not Available 5

Data Gemba Significance


Analysis Investigation Test

5 Real ‘X’ s Real ‘X’ s 3

Counter Measures/Actions 8
© Confederation of Indian Industry 107
Funneling (Application of Tools)
Data Characterization
Brainstorming &
Partitioning

FMEA
x1 x7 = 38%
x2 x6 = 27% Vital X’s
x3 x2 = 12%
x4
x5 Exploration x9 = 4%
x6 of the y-x x10= 4%
x7 relationship x5 = 2%
x8 x1
x9 x3
Trivial X’s σ error
x10 x4
x11 x8 = 13%
x12 x11
x12
Fishbone

© Confederation of Indian Industry 108


Hypothesis Testing
• Real Life Hypothesis: The newly modified machine
will increase output.
• This is called the Alternative Hypothesis (Ha)
• There is no difference in output between the old
machines and the improved one.
• This is called the Null Hypothesis (Ho)

➢ It is the null hypothesis that is always tested in an attempt to ‘disprove’ it &


support the alternative hypothesis.
➢Generally, the null hypothesis would state that ‘null’ condition exists, i.e.
there is nothing new happening, the old theory is still true.
➢The alternative hypothesis, on the other hand, would state that the new
theory is true, there are new standards, etc.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 109


Probability Value or P-value of the Test Statistics

➢ P-value is the probability of null hypothesis being true

• This probability value is used to draw conclusion whether to

reject or not to reject Null hypothesis

• When P-value is low (below α level, usually 5% or 0.05 as rule

of thumb), there is evidence to reject Null hypothesis

© Confederation of Indian Industry 110


Correlation and Regression
Black Belt Training

© Confederation of Indian Industry 111


Correlation and Regression - Objective

❑ To see how the performance variable is influenced or


related to an input variable
❑ To ascertain how changes in the input variable affect
the performance variable
❑ To predict performance using input values
❑ To understand the relationship between performance
and input.
❑Correlation describesIsthe
it strength
linear, ofcurvilinear, S-shaped?
a linear relationship Does
between two it
variables
have saturation levels?
❑Regression tells us how to draw the straight line described by the correlation

© Confederation of Indian Industry 112


Correlation Analysis using Scatter Plot
Y Y Y

X X X

Strong Positive Correlation Moderate Positive Correlation No Correlation

Y Y Y

X X

Strong Negative Correlation


X
Moderate Negative Correlation Other Pattern -
No Linear Correlation

© Confederation of Indian Industry 113


Scatter Plot

Scatter Plot
Shows the Relationship Between X and Y

A scatter plots show how an output


(Y) changes in relationship to an
input (X). If there is no relationship,
the points will scatter randomly on
the plot.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 114


Regression

➢ Regression analysis generates a line that quantifies the


relationship between X and Y.
➢ Quantifies the Relationship Between X and Y

Y (output)
8

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

X (input)

© Confederation of Indian Industry 115


DMAIC Approach

3e. IMPROVE PHASE

© Confederation of Indian Industry 116


Introduction to Lean Six Sigma DMAIL

Define Where is the Gap and How Much is the Gap

Measure What are the Current Performance

Analyse What are the potential root causes of & improvement opportunities?

Improve What are the solutions and how do we


implement them?

Control How do we maintain the gains?

© Confederation of Indian Industry 117


10. Generate Solution Ideas

Improve 11. Select Best Fit Solution

12. Test Solution & Confirm


Results

Key Deliverables :
➢ Potential Solutions
➢ Best Fit solution based on feasibility and impact
➢ Validation of results
Applicable Tools :
➢ Value Stream Mapping
➢ PUGH Matrix
➢ TOH, ANOVA, Regression

© Confederation of Indian Industry 118


Objective of Improve Phase

❑ Develop, test and implement solutions to improve


the process by reducing variation in the critical output
variables caused by the vital few input variables

❑ Demonstrate with data that the solutions work

© Confederation of Indian Industry 119


Improve Phase – Steps

➢ Generate ideas for improving the process,


➢ analyze and evaluate those ideas,
➢ select and test the best potential solutions,
➢ plan and implement the solutions, and
➢ validate the results with data and statistical
analysis

© Confederation of Indian Industry 120


Failure Mode and Effect
Analysis
(FMEA)

© Confederation of Indian Industry 121


Improvement
Planning

© Confederation of Indian Industry 122


Selection techniques

• Brainstorming

• Ranking method

• Rating method

• Decision Matrix

© Confederation of Indian Industry 123


Idea Selection

© Confederation of Indian Industry 124


DMAIC Approach

3f. CONTROL PHASE

© Confederation of Indian Industry 125


Introduction to Lean Six Sigma DMAIL

Define Where is the Gap and How Much is the Gap

Measure What are the Current Performance

Analyse What are the potential root causes of & improvement opportunities?

Improve What are the solutions and how do we implement them?

Control How do we maintain the gains?

© Confederation of Indian Industry 126


13. Implement Solutions
Control
14. Monitor Process & Results

15. Replicate and Share Best


Practices

Key Deliverables :
➢ Work Instructions and SOPs
➢ Control Plans
➢ Required communication and training

Applicable Tools :
➢ Control Plans, SOPs
➢ Control Charts
➢ Poka Yoke

© Confederation of Indian Industry 127


Control Plan & Process Control

Objectives

• Articulate the need for standardization.

• Carry out an approach to standardization.

• Recognize barriers to standardization.

• See how standardization fits into the strategy for process improvement.

• Understand that standardization must be balanced with creativity, empowerment,


ownership, and leadership.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 128


Different ways to implement time-monitored changes

HUMAN PARTIAL FULL


INTERVENTION AUTOMATION AUTOMATION

SOP + audit Automatic Automatic


warning corrective
+ audit action

SPC of results Dual automatic


warning

SPC of Automatic warning + automatic shut


process down
variables

© Confederation of Indian Industry 129


Control Plan

© Confederation of Indian Industry 130


Control Charts

• A Control chart is a time ordered plot of the data with control limits.
• Control limits identify the expected range of variation of the data.
• Control charts identify the presence of special cause of variation within a
process.

© Confederation of Indian Industry 131


Mistake Proofing
[Poka-Yoke]

© Confederation of Indian Industry 132


Objectives of Mistake Proofing

• What is “Mistake Proofing”


• What are Errors and how do we
detect them
• Mistake Proofing Techniques
• Mistake Proofing Examples

© Confederation of Indian Industry 133


How do I change the process and keep it
in control forever?

Operational Method
Written Instructions
Verbal Instructions

(Mistake Proofing)
Sheets (OMS)

Poka - Yoke

DFSS
SPC
AMOUNT OF CONTROL

Amount of Effort Expended by the Process

© Confederation of Indian Industry 134


Mistake Proofing Techniques

When can we find mistakes?


•Before they occur (PREVENTION or PREDICTION)
•After they occur (DETECTION)

Technique Prevention / Prediction Detection

When a mistake is about to When a mistake or defect


SHUTDOWN
be made has already been made

Defective items can’t move


CONTROL Errors are impossible
on to the next step

That something is about to Immediately when


WARNING
go wrong something goes wrong

© Confederation of Indian Industry 135


4. Project Closure

© Confederation of Indian Industry 136


Project Closure

• Goal : Plan Vs Actual


Sigma Level
• (Base Line Vs Current)
4.2 4

2.3

Sigma Level
Base Line 2.3
Goal 4.2
current
Base Line Goal current
4

© Confederation of Indian Industry 137


Project Closure

Documentation, Review and Approval

Document the Project Management Review and Communication Recognition


steps and findings as per Approval
the format/templates
covering
DMAIC Steps
Project review comments
Financial saving approval
Project Learning
Sustenance Plan
Horizontal Deployment
process/suggestions

© Confederation of Indian Industry 138


© Confederation of Indian Industry 139
Benefits of Lean Six Sigma

Customer
Productivity Quality Complaint
Improvement Improvement Reduction

Product
Development Customer
Material Waste
Improvement Audit Score
Reduction
Improvement

Energy Saving Cost &


Inventory Improve
Reduction Safety

© Confederation of Indian Industry 140


Journey Begins

© Confederation of Indian Industry 141


Wish You All The Best

Krishnan P M
Principal Counsellor-

Thank You
Business Excellence & Lean Six Sigma

Krishnan.pm@cii.in

© Confederation of Indian Industry 142

You might also like