Professional Documents
Culture Documents
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Journal of the Fantastic
in the Arts
Farah Mendlesohn
his bravery, wh
ond narrative
demonstrates h
on the essentia
first place. On
Wynne Jones
Ingary...it is qu
you are the one
your fortune"
McKinley and
ern genre fant
More importan
shift from fair
ing provided th
and the provin
the soldier's jo
but the advent
the adventure
place at the en
played out, bit
the focus of th
a hero. While m
sumptions, it h
of blood right
ments the assum
narrative powe
structure in w
the structures
rather heated d
Potter is a Ret
mtics"(Fiction
ter as a blow f
entire articulat
ridiculousness
The main plot
that of the ret
tions of a usurp
age of happine
manipulating a
modern fanta
heroes and her
century have
with any othe
presentations.
the naval offic
ries, Journey I
status but seco
and he generally
hero's decisions
ably fits this r
ally of margin
distinctly lowe
group (he is a h
friend. If we lo
Digby or to Je
and Digby, he
egregious portr
tence can be tr
intelligence. Mo
from which Ha
where, is conti
what Hagrid w
learned there, f
in smoothing o
an accent rather more than a few social notches below that of his
school-mates, his ex-school mates, and the teachers around whom he has
spent over twenty five years. Whatever his social origins, association with the
school would have changed that to some degree, at the very least, removing
the most obvious class markers, but it is more in keeping with the structures of
the novel that Hagrid's social origins (and the focus of much prejudice) are
demonstrated with every word he speaks, that his lack of intelligence and self
control actually fulfill the stereotypes associated with his ethnicity, thus per-
mitting Harry and his friends to demonstrate their "tolerance" and to show
Harry as a "good chap".
J.K. Rowling's books have received praise precisely because they are
compounded of anachronisms. The old Englishness of wizardry is a source of
humour, from Mr. Weasley's obsession with newfangled Muggle inventions
to the befuddled wizard of Book Four in his mismatched clothes: it is a form
of humour that ranges from the affectionate to the derisory. In terms of the
authoritarian structures of the book, however, this old Englishness places
Rowling in the company of Tolkien and of Lewis in constructing their fantasy
worlds as a lament for old England, for the values of the shires and for a
"greener" and simpler world. Rowling's wizards, anxious to preserve the
power of magic over a rather more competent non-magical world, reiterate
Tolkien and Lewis' clarion cry for "resistance against secular, industrial soci-
ety" (Veldman, 37-38).
finally, is wher
thority structu
The visibly art
magical family
acter. Potter, t
we are invited
puncture the s
"squib" we mee
have over-rate
measurement o
and un-magical
hart, understand
to better himse
The role of the
has been discus
heart of the sch
of fairness, pla
himself honour
understands th
malevolence, is
according to th
Quidditch game
miscarriages of
The Philospher
should be their
Harry, Ron and
points have usu
and tens; this i
for releasing a
221). And frank
Harry by the w
ents. A very p
here, requiring
somehow natural.
This equation i
the Dursleys an
Dursleys is fran
for example, w
nice but their m
the ridiculous
rather unpleasa
amounts of mo
portion of that
ards and their g
tives who are e
The moral issue
looked after by
the impression
can be exchange
port of their ch
prince implies t
are vile, the wiz
Harry is not ba
that they have t
placed with the
ardize his safety
having already
him makes him
Hagrid and Pr
well-being rend
need to trace ba
finalbooks, his
The second iss
this should be s
servant, the eq
well in Britain.
ment. Does he
ple? Perhaps his
is simplistic. L
complex cast of
not dictate thei
used as a short h
positively starv
less the issue th
trasted by the lo
Clearly the We
comfortable iss
to speak to eith
isolated by the
need) which en
Malfoy sees thi
tor in the moral
sions between H
in the construct
nence in the sc
The situation w
anxious to mak
on the social h
social structure
is entirely an is
doomed to be d
when she choo
other than a s
Hermione achie
The attention s
tic surgery ( G
cuss here but o
attention paid t
Potter, Viktor
Hermione gains
earlier comment
rided), the poin
world of wizar
all of his insid
enough. The st
School stories,
criticize Rowlin
pointed out tha
table. That arch
British writer
pupil run demo
sive to this day.
mative in that
fantastical struc
At Hogwarts, D
not the final a
owes deference
though there ar
are told that Du
pear to be in a
Cooper's The Da
heart of a glob
ingly without
around himse
Dumbledore, S
Harry to do any
Harry is assiste
ately see this be
than the range
a sign of great
what he did. He
asked to give u
but resistance h
knew that Harr
choice and Harr
truly brave in T
his parents but w
Rowling's worl
and wonder of
the non-magica
bate between go
egalitarianism.
all Muggles, are
ternity, but by
to be protected
magical "sport"
or house pet sta
0 CoS , 40-41).
The most tolera
Muggles, and th
but who refus
cause they do n
over Muggle ac
Muggles live alo
only one compl
most inconceiva
life-styles. This
segregated and
regard themselv
the madam in S
these people fe
shown to Mugg
ment: no one s
a hypocrite whe
(GoF, 362).
The only indic
Ron's casual co
197). It is obvio
ing slavery - b
help but use the
lationship in th
ever much the
never take away
acter of Winky
in Alexander's
manity. And to
dren on the ini
free themselves
justice must be
Conclusion
The structure of J.K. Rowling's books accepts a status quo and a formal
understanding of authority in which hierarchal structures are a given. What is
at stake, and potentially vulnerable, is never the hierarchy itself, but only he
who occupies its upper reaches. Justice, in Rowling's world, rests first on
"niceness": as long as the "proper" people are in charge, justice will be
achieved without social upheaval or divisiveness. Radicalism, as embodied in
Hermione, is both irrational, ignorant and essentially transient. Stasis and a
conformity to a certain status quo bolster success, justice and peace, whereas
positive action to change matters is always ascribed as best to foolishness and
at worse to evil intent. Thus the hierarchical structures actually support heroic
passivity and deny the characters agency. But the second support for justice in
the Potter books is "entitlement": those who are entitled through heredity ap-
pear to receive the greatest level of "justice" whether this be assistance in the
House Cup, excusai from punishment, or survival through the death of others
This is disguised both by consolatory rhetoric and through the extension of
"entitlement" to the friends of those entitled in a line of patronage clothed as
friendship. The result is a muddled morality which cheats the reader: while
the books argue superficially for fairness, they actually portray privilege and
exceptionalism, not in the sense of "elitism" but in a specifically hereditarian
context which protects some while exposing others; they argue for social mo-
bility while making such mobility contingent on social connections; and they
argue for tolerance and kindness towards the inferior while denying the op-
pressed the agency to change their own lives. In this they embody inherently
References
Alexander, Lloyd. The Book of Three. New Y ork, Holt, Rinehart and Winston , 1 964.
- . The Black Cauldron. New York, Holt, Rinehart and Winston , 1965.
- . The Castle of Llyr. New York, Holt, Rinehart and Winston ,1966.
- . Taran Wanderer. New York, Holt, Rinehart and Winston ,1967.
- . The High King. New York, Holt, Rinehart and Winston ,1968.
Aptheker, Herbert. American Negro Slave Revolts. New York: International Pub-
lishers, 1963.
Baum, L. Frank. The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. Chicago; New York: G.M. Hill Co.,
1900.
Barnes, John, One for the Morning Glory. New York: Tor, 1996.
Blyton, Enid. The Naughtiest Girl. London: George Newnes, 1940.
- . The Naughtiest Girl Again, London: George Newnes, 1942.
- . The Naughtiest Girl is a Monitor , London: George Newnes, 1945.
Burnett, Frances Hodgson. A Little Princess. First published as Sara Crewe, or what
happened at Miss Minchin 's. London; New York: Frederick Warne, 1 889.
Cooper, Susan. Over Sea, Under Stone. London: Cape, 1965.
Clute, John, "Grail, Groundhog, God Game: Or, Doing Fantasy." Journal of the Fan-
tastic in the Arts 10.4 ( 2000): 330-337.
Clute, John and John Grant, eds., The Encyclopedia of Fantasy. London: Orbit, 1997.
Davis, Cath Filmer. "What Is a Who and What Does it Do? Identity in Lloyd Alexan-
der's Prydain Series." The Fantastic Self: Essays on the Subject of the Self
Janeen Webb and Andrew Enstice, eds. North Perth, W. Australia: Eidolon Pub-
lications, 1999. 152-158.
Dahl, Roald. James and the Giant Peach. Windrush, 1988, cl967.
- . Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. London: Allen & Unwin, 1967.
- . Matilda. London: Cape, 1988,
Eddings, David. Pawn of Prophecy . New York: Ballantine Del Rey, 1982.
- . Queen of Sorcery. New York: Ballantine/Del Rey, 1982.
- . Magician's Gambit. New York: Ballantme/Del Rey, 1983.
- . Castle of Wizardry. New York: Ballantine/Del Rey, 1984.
- . Enchanter's End Game. New York: Ballantine/Del Rey, 1985
Elkins, Stanley M. Slavery: A Problem in American Institutional and Intellectual
Life. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1959.
Grant, John. "Gulliver Unravels: Generic Fantasy and the Loss of Subversion."
Extrapolation 41.1 (2000): 21-27.
Griffiths, D.W. Birth of a Nation (1915).
Ibbotson, Eva. The Secret of Platform 13. London: Pan Macmillan, 1994.
Jones, Diana Wynne. Howl's Moving Castle. London: Methuen, 1986.
- . The Homewardbounders. London: Methuen, 1981.
Katz, William L
York: Atheneu
Macmillan Inte
Kingsley, Charl
Lewis, C.S. The
- .
Voyage The
Makinen, Merja
Mieville, China
Historical Mat
- . Personal e-m
Mitchell, Marga
Moorcock, Mich
Victor Gollancz Ltd. 1987.
Nesbit, E. The Story of the Amulet. London: Fisher Unwin, 1906.
Rowling, J.K. Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. London: Bloomsbury, 1998.
- . Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone . London: Bloomsbury, 1997. [Pub-
lished as Harry Potter and the Sorceror 's Stone in the US).
- . Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. London: Bloomsbury, 1999.
- . Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. London: Bloomsbury, 2000.
Searsmith, Kelly, "News from Somewhere: A Case for Romance-Tradition Fantasy's
Reformist Poetic." Journal of the Fantastic in the Arts 11.1 (2000): 62-76.
Schoefer, Christine. "Harry Potter's Girl Trouble." Salon.com (January 23, 2000):
1-4.
Veldman, Meredith. Fantasy, the Bomb, and the Greening of Britain: Romantic Pro-
test, 1945-1980. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994.
Waggoner, Diana. The Hills of Faraway: A Guide to Fantasy. New York: Atheneum,
1978.
Zipes, Jack. Sticks and Stones : the Troublesome Success of Children 's Literature
from Slovenly Peter to Harry Potter. New York & London: Routledge, 2001 .
308