You are on page 1of 23

ALCOHOL RESEARCH: C u r r e n t R e v i e w s

Alcohol’s Effects on the


Cardiovascular System
Mariann R. Piano, Ph.D.
Mariann R. Piano, Ph.D., is a
Professor in and Department Alcohol  use  has complex effects on  cardiovascular  (CV) health. The associations
Head of the Department of between drinking and CV diseases such as hypertension, coronary heart disease,
Biobehavioral Health Science, stroke, peripheral arterial disease, and cardiomyopathy have been studied extensively
University of Illinois at Chicago, and are outlined in this review. Although many behavioral, genetic, and biologic
variants influence the interconnection between alcohol use and CV disease, dose
Chicago, Illinois.
and pattern of alcohol consumption seem to modulate this most. Low-to-moderate
alcohol use may mitigate certain mechanisms such as risk and hemostatic factors
affecting atherosclerosis and inflammation, pathophysiologic processes integral to
most CV disease. But any positive aspects of drinking must be weighed against seri-
ous physiological effects, including mitochondrial dysfunction and changes in circu-
lation, inflammatory response, oxidative stress, and programmed cell death, as well
as anatomical damage to the CV system, especially the heart itself. Both the negative
and positive effects of alcohol use on particular CV conditions are presented here.
The review concludes by suggesting several promising avenues for future research
related to alcohol use and CV disease.These include using direct biomarkers of alcohol
to confirm self-report of alcohol consumption levels; studying potential mediation of
various genetic, socioeconomic, and racial and ethnic factors that may affect alcohol
use and CV disease; reviewing alcohol−medication interactions in cardiac patients;
and examining CV effects of alcohol use in young adults and in older adults.

Key words: Alcohol consumption; alcohol use patterns; alcohol effects and conse-
quences; cardiovascular system; heart; hypertension; coronary heart disease;
stroke; peripheral arterial disease; cardiomyopathy; atherosclerosis; inflammation;
alcohol-related research

Data from numerous epidemiologic consumption can be a double-edged subjects drink alcohol? What was the
studies over the last two decades have sword. This article reviews these effects pattern of drinking? And was the study
revealed complex associations between of alcohol consumption on CV condi- prospective (following subjects over
alcohol use and cardiovascular (CV) tions, such as HTN, CHD, stroke, time) or aggregate (pulling together
conditions such as hypertension (HTN), PAD, and alcoholic cardiomyopathy, data from several different studies to
coronary heart disease (CHD), stroke, as well as mechanisms that may medi- look for common trends)?
peripheral arterial disease (PAD), and ate the positive and the adverse effects The way in which alcohol consump-
cardiomyopathy. In particular, these of alcohol. tion has been measured and categorized
associations are strongly modulated varies, sometimes making it challenging
by the dose and pattern of alcohol to compare data among studies. More
consumption. Low-to-moderate daily Alcohol Consumption: Categories, studies today report alcohol consump-
alcohol consumption (i.e., <15 to 20 Measurement, and Patterns tion in terms of either “drinks” or
g/day, 1 to 2 standard drinks) is associ- grams/units of ethanol per day or week,
ated with a reduced risk of CV disease There are certain factors that are criti- and alcohol consumption is measured
and mortality, whereas greater amounts cally important to understanding and by self-report. Most investigators also
of alcohol consumption and a binge interpreting the data related to the define the amount of alcohol that con-
pattern of drinking (see definition in health consequences of alcohol con- stitutes a “standard” drink as 12 to 15 g
“Alcohol Consumption: Categories, sumption. For example, how was (with only slight variation).
Measurement, and Patterns”) have alcohol consumption measured? Despite the progress in standardizing
been linked to an increased risk. What were the drink sizes and alcohol measurement of alcohol, studies still
Consequently, the effects of alcohol concentrations? How often did the vary in how they define the different

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 219

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 219 5/23/17 5:39 PM


levels of drinking, such as low-risk or alcohol concentration to 0.08 drank alcohol at baseline), former
moderate and heavy drinking. Most percent or above. A typical adult drinkers (no alcohol in previous year),
often, low-risk or moderate drinking consuming the defined number of light drinkers (<7 drinks/week for men
has been defined as 1 to 2 standard standard drinks for binge drinking and <4 drinks/week for women), mod-
drinks per day and heavy alcohol would reach a blood alcohol concen- erate drinkers (7 to 14 drinks/week for
consumption as 4 or more standard tration of 0.08 in about 2 hours men and 4 to 7 drinks/week for women),
drinks per day. However, ascertaining (NIAAA 2015b). and at-risk drinkers (>14 drinks/week
the exact alcohol consumption thresh- for men and >7 drinks/week for
old for determining both the benefit women). After adjusting for age, gen-
and risk has been challenging, and Alcohol’s Effects on Blood Pres- der, body mass index (BMI), smoking
threshold levels continue to differ sure and Incident Hypertension status, family history of HTN, and
across studies. Additional factors make numerous socioeconomic variables,
it difficult to interpret the results of In healthy adults, consuming alcohol use generally was not associated
these studies, including underreporting low-to-moderate amounts of alcohol with 20-year incidence of HTN. The
of alcohol consumption, study design each day typically has no short-term exception was in European-American
characteristics (case–control studies), (i.e., acute) or substantial impact on women, for whom the risk of incident
and unaccounted confounding variables hemodynamics or blood pressure (BP). HTN was lower in those with any cur-
such as socioeconomic or lifestyle char- However, data suggest that binge rent alcohol consumption (Halanych
acteristics that may inadvertently affect drinking (more than 5 standard drinks et al. 2010). These CARDIA results
results (Emberson and Bennett 2006). in a single sitting) is associated with differ from meta-analyses and other
Advances are being made to address transient increases in BP that range large prospective studies, such as the
these factors. For example, alcohol from 4 to 7 mmHg for systolic BP and Nurses’ Health Study II (Thadhani
consumption typically has been mea- 4 to 6 mmHg for diastolic BP (Potter et al. 2002) and the Physicians’ Health
sured through self-report. Future studies et al. 1986; Rosito et al. 1999; Seppä Study (Camargo et al. 1997; Sesso et
would benefit from using direct and Sillanaukee 1999). al. 2008), which show a relationship
biomarkers of alcohol consumption, Nearly four decades ago, using data between consuming greater levels of
such as phosphatidylethanol (PEth), from the Kaiser Permanente Multi- alcohol and incident HTN.
to corroborate self-report of alcohol phasic Health Study, Klatsky and col- In a systematic review and meta-
consumption and distinguish among leagues (1977) reported that HTN analysis that included 16 prospective
low, moderate, and heavy alcohol prevalence (BP ≥160/95 mmHg) in studies on the effects of alcohol con-
consumption (Kechagias et al. 2015; White and Black subjects (men and sumption on the risk of HTN (systolic
Piano et al. 2015). With this in mind, women) consuming more than 6 BP >140 mmHg/diastolic BP >90
the National Institute on Alcohol drinks per day was about twice as mmHg), Briasoulis and colleagues
Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA) spon- much as in nondrinkers. Using a lower (2012) found that consuming more
sored a biomarker research challenge systolic BP cutoff value for the diagno- than 20 g ethanol/day (~1 to 2 drinks/
to discover and develop biomarkers of sis of HTN (systolic BP >140 mmHg), day) significantly increased risk of
alcohol consumption (NIAAA 2015a).1 data from many studies generally have HTN in women, and higher amounts
Such a biomarker would corroborate reaffirmed that high daily levels of (31 to 40 g/day) increased risk of
self-reported consumption and bring alcohol consumption are associated HTN in men. In women, there was a
more uniformity of reporting within with increased risk for HTN and over- J-shaped relationship between alcohol
and across studies. all incident HTN. However, data from consumption and HTN, where con-
Another trend in recent studies current meta-analyses indicate that sumption of <10 g/day was associated
of alcohol and CV risk and disease is the risk-threshold effect or amount with a reduced risk of HTN, whereas
to include a measurement for binge of daily alcohol intake associated with in men the alcohol−risk relationship
drinking. In most investigations, HTN is much lower than originally was more linear (figure 1).
this means consuming more than 5 reported in the Klatsky study. Results from another meta-analysis
standard drinks on a single occasion Halanych and colleagues (2010) of 12 cohort studies found a similar
for men and more than 4 standard examined the relationship between dif- dose−response relationship between
drinks for women. NIAAA defines ferent categories of alcohol consump- alcohol consumption and HTN for
binge drinking as a pattern of drink- tion and incident HTN (systolic BP males. A J-shaped relationship for
ing alcohol that brings the blood ≥140 mmHg/diastolic BP ≥90 mmHg females showed protective effects at or
or antihypertensive medication use) below consumption levels of 15 g/day
among participants in the CARDIA (Taylor et al. 2009). These data high-
1
The results of the NIAAA Wearable Alcohol Biosensor Challenge
were announced May 19, 2016, at https://www.niaaa.nih.gov/
study. The alcohol consumption cate- light how gender may be an important
research/challenge-prize. gories included never-drinkers (never modifier of the alcohol threshold level

220 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 220 5/23/17 5:39 PM


and can shape the alcohol benefit−risk systolic BP and diastolic BP were of fibrinogen (a glycoprotein that helps
relationship. 2.3 mmHg/1.3 mmHg higher in women form blood clots).
The discrepancy in findings across who consumed greater amounts of Most of the studies included in the
studies suggests that other characteris- alcohol (146 to 218 g/week, ~2 to 3 Briasoulis meta-analysis examined the
tics differ among the study subjects. standard drinks/day) than in those effects of alcohol consumption on
However (and importantly), the meta- who drank less (42 to 73 g/week, ~0.5 subjects with Stage I HTN (BP >140/90
analysis by Briasoulis and colleagues to 1 standard drink/day) or none at all. mmHg). Fan and colleagues (2014)
(2012) included all of the former studies There was no BP-lowering effect with examined the prevalence of prehyper-
and found that in the pooled analysis, lower alcohol amounts. In women, tension (systolic BP/diastolic BP 120
for both men and women, consuming these findings support the data from to 139 mmHg/80 to 89 mmHg)
>20 g ethanol/day (~1 to 2 drinks/day) meta-analyses and prospective studies, and found 52 percent of male current
was associated with a higher risk of suggesting that greater amounts of drinkers and 29 percent of female
developing HTN. alcohol consumption may increase BP current drinkers had pre-HTN.
Mori and colleagues (2015) examined To summarize, in both men and
and contribute to the development of
the dose-dependent effects of drinking women, alcohol consumption at levels
HTN. However, findings from this
on BP measured at regular intervals in above about 1 to 2 drinks per day is
healthy premenopausal women ages study do not support a BP-lowering associated with HTN. The alcohol−
20–45. These repeated measurements effect at the lower level of alcohol con- risk relationship tends to be J shaped
allowed comparison of BP among 24 sumption (42 to 73 g alcohol/week, in women and linear in men. More
participants at 3 drinking levels, each or ~3 to 5 standard drinks). Interest- research is needed to determine if cer-
for a 4-week consumption interval. ingly, in the Mori study, higher tain ethnic or socioeconomic groups
The study included periods of low- alcohol consumption was associated are more vulnerable to alcohol-induced
volume and higher-volume alcohol with a 10 percent increase in high- HTN. The American Society of Hyper-
consumption as well density lipoproteins (HDLs, which tension and the International Society
Figure 1 as of drinking
alcohol-free red wine for each partici- remove cholesterol from the blood of Hypertension recommended that
pant, whether or not she initially had and are associated with reduced risk men limit their alcohol consumption
been a lower-level or higher-level of atherosclerosis and heart disease) to no more than 2 drinks a day, and
drinker as defined by the study. Awake and a 14 percent reduction in levels women to no more than 1 drink a

2.4
*
2.2 Men
2.0 Women
*
1.8
Relative Risk (95% Cl)

1.6
1.4 *
1.2
1.0 *
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
<10 g/day 11–20 g/day 21–30 g/day 31–40 g/day 41–50 g/day >50 g/day

Alcohol Intake (g/day) vs. No Alcohol Use

Figure 1 Incidence of hypertension in men and women.

NOTE: * Indicates data significantly different from nondrinkers. For females, data at higher alcohol consumption levels (>40 g/day) were not analyzed.
SOURCE: Data from Briasoulis et al. 2012.

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 221

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 221 5/23/17 5:39 PM


day (Weber et al. 2014). To put the vein endothelial cells) (Liu et al. 2002). signaling pathways and decreases in
importance of BP control into perspec- Low-to-moderate ethanol consumption protective antioxidant levels. Alcohol
tive, at a population level, a 2-mmHg in rats (36 percent of caloric intake) also can increase levels of co-enzymes
increase in BP increases mortality from for 6 weeks increased nitric oxide pro- or reducing equivalents (e.g., reduced
stroke by 10 percent and from coronary duction and eNOS expression in the nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide
artery disease (CAD) by 7 percent aortic vascular wall (Kleinhenz et al. phosphate [NADPH]), which lead
(Lewington et al. 2002; Mori et al. 2015). 2008). Nitric oxide helps regulate to increases in ROS formation and
vascular tone. eNOS has a protective decreases in eNOS activity (Ceron
function in the cardiovascular system, et al. 2014). Several excellent reviews
Potential Biologic Mechanisms which is attributed to nitric oxide pro- offer more detailed assessments of
Underlying Alcohol-Induced duction. However, higher daily ethanol vascular cellular mechanisms (Cahill
BP Effects (blood alcohol levels >29 mM) for 6 and Redmond 2012; Husain et al.
weeks in another animal model was 2014; Marchi et al. 2014; Toda and
Several mechanisms may underlie associated with decreased eNOS expres- Ayajiki 2010).
alcohol’s effects on blood pressure. sion, increased release of endothelial-
These include impairments in cells that derived vasoconstrictor prostanoids,
lead to buildup of plaque in arteries and greater responsiveness of mesenteric Alcohol, CHD, and Stroke
(i.e., through alterations in endothelial arterioles to phenylephrine (Tirapelli
cell function and nitric oxide availabil- et al. 2008). Taken together, these The relationship between and among
ity), and disruptions in arterial-vascular findings show lower amounts of alcohol alcohol consumption, CHD, and
function (i.e., through myogenic may have a positive effect on nitric stroke has been extensively investigated.
mechanisms and changes in baroreceptor oxide signaling, but higher amounts Many of these studies have been
function), and hormonal imbalances alter this system and change arteriolar conducted in middle-aged and older
that control the body’s fluid and reactivity, which may led to an people and across populations. These
BP regulation (through the renin− increased risk for HTN. studies have used ecologic designs (in
angiotensin−aldosterone system In humans, endothelial function is which at least one risk-modifying health
[RAAS]). Some adverse BP-related assessed by measuring the widening factor is measured at the group level);
mechanisms that may be triggered by (i.e., dilation) of the brachial artery case–control designs (which compare
alcohol include changes in intracellular under different conditions. Some clinical cases with control subjects to
calcium levels, baroreflex control, and research noted that endothelial func- determine if an exposure is associated
heart rate and activation of other neu- tion is impaired in abstinent individuals with an outcome); and longitudinal
rohormonal systems besides the RAAS, with a long-term history of alcohol research designs (which gather data
such as the sympathetic nervous system abuse or alcoholism (Di Gennaro et from the same subjects repeatedly over
(Marchi et al. 2014). al. 2007, 2012; Maiorano et al. 1999). a length of time). Examples include
Several reports indicate that alcohol Other studies have examined the effect the Health Professionals Follow-up
first exerts a seemingly positive effect, of a single binge-drinking episode and Study (Harvard School of Public Health
followed by a more negative impact found impairment in brachial artery 2016a), the Nurses’ Health Study
(i.e., it is biphasic) on the endothelial− endothelial-dependent and -independent (Harvard School of Public Health
nitric oxide–generating system. The vasodilation (Bau et al. 2005; Hashimoto 2016b), the Framingham Heart Study
endothelium is a key regulator of vas- et al. 2001; Hijmering et al. 2007). (National Heart, Lung, and Blood
cular function. Endothelial dysfunction Therefore, as in animal studies, the Institute and Boston University 2016),
is an early indicator of blood vessel effects of ethanol on endothelial function the British Doctors Study, the Physicians’
damage and atherosclerosis, as well as in humans likely depend on the dose Health Study,2 the Copenhagen City
a strong prognostic factor for future and duration of ethanol consumption. Heart Study (Schnohr et al. 2002),
CV events (Deanfield et al. 2007; Ras Vascular wall oxidative stress also is and INTERHEART (Leong et al. 2014).
et al. 2013). Low-to-moderate levels a key mechanism in ethanol-induced The availability of these diverse datasets
of alcohol consumption may initially HTN. Oxidative stress is an imbalance has allowed for completion of several
improve endothelial function, whereas between production of free radicals comprehensive systematic reviews and
high daily levels and binge drinking and the body’s ability to detoxify or meta-analyses of alcohol, CHD, and
may impair it. fight off their harmful effects through stroke relationships. This section sum-
Other studies have shown that neutralization by antioxidants. Various marizes data from meta-analyses, along
low-to-moderate concentrations of studies with animals and humans
ethanol (20 mM) increase endogenous indicate that ethanol can increase the 2
British Doctors Study. Available at: http:/www.epi.umn.edu/
cvdepi/study-synopsis/british-doctors-study/. Accessed December
nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) expression development of reactive oxygen species 13, 2016. Physicians’ Health Study. Available at: http://phs.bwh.
in certain cells (i.e., human umbilical- (ROS), leading to increases in redox- harvard.edu/. Accessed December 13, 2016.

222 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 222 5/23/17 5:39 PM


with data from large international drink/day to ~5 drinks/day) were protective against CHD for subjects
studies such as INTERHEART (Leong cardioprotective for both CV mortality in most countries, except for people of
et al. 2014) and other recent studies and CHD mortality (figure 2). How- South Asian ethnicity living in South
using new methodologies such as ever, the association between alcohol Asia (India, Bangladesh, Nepal, Paki-
Mendelian randomization (reviewed consumption and CV mortality was stan, and Sri Lanka). INTERHEART
below in “Alcohol Consumption and insignificant when alcohol consumption results also suggested that the protec-
Total Stroke Incidence and Prevalence”). was >60 g/day, but remained significantly tive effect of any alcohol use against
reduced for CHD mortality. MI was greater in women and those
Findings from INTERHEART, a over age 45. Finally, data from
Alcohol Consumption and CHD 52-country case–control study of indi- INTERHEART support the finding
viduals with first myocardial infarction that the risk of MI is increased in the
In a comprehensive systemic review (MI), also supported the fact that 24 hours after consumption of 6 or
and meta-analysis, Ronksley and col- “alcohol use” was associated with a more drinks, suggesting that binge
leagues (2011) analyzed data from reduction in the odds ratio for first- drinking increases MI risk (table 1).
several prospective studies (n = 84), of time MI (table 1) (Leong et al. 2014). Mostofsky and colleagues (2016)
which 40 percent reported on all-male In addition, in the 24 hours after conducted a systematic review and
cohorts, 7 percent reported on women alcohol use, there was no effect of meta-analysis (n = 23 studies) to exam-
only, and 53 percent included men “alcohol use” on risk of MI. ine the effects of alcohol consumed in
and women. The most data-adjusted It is important to note that, unlike the 24 hours before MI onset. These
analysis, which included both men and other studies with more discrete alcohol investigators found a U-shaped rela-
women, noted that various alcohol consumption categories, alcohol use tionship between alcohol intake and
consumption levels (g/day) among was nonspecifically defined in INTER- MI risk, with the greatest benefit
active drinkers compared with non- HEART as the consumption of at least occurring after ~28 g of alcohol
drinkers were associated with a reduced 1 alcoholic beverage within the previous (~2 drinks, or moderate consumption)
relative risk for CV mortality, incident 12 months (Leong et al. 2014). Inter- in 1 day and a higher risk after ~108 g
CHD, and CHD mortality. Alcohol estingly, the strength of this association (~9 drinks, or heavy consumption)
consumption levelsFigurebetween
2 2.5 g/day was not consistent across different in 1 day. Within a week after alcohol
and 30 to 60 g/day (<1 standard geographic regions. Alcohol use was consumption, there was a lower risk of

2.2
CV Mortality (21 Studies)
2.0
CHD Mortality (31 Studies)
1.8 Stroke Mortality (10 Studies)
1.6
1.4
Relative Risk

1.2
1.0 *
* * * *
* * *
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
<2.5 g/day 2.5–14.9 g/day 15–29.9 g/day 30–60 g/day >60 g/day

Alcohol Intake (g/day) vs. No Alcohol Use

Figure 2 Relative risks (95% confidence intervals) for cardiovascular (CV), coronary heart disease (CHD), and stroke outcomes.

SOURCE: Data used from Ronksley et al. 2011.

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 223

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 223 5/23/17 5:39 PM


MI with moderate alcohol consumption “no alcohol intake” or 0 g/day (Zhang CHD and stroke. The investigators
but a greater risk with heavy alcohol et al. 2014). found that individuals with the A allele
consumption (Mostofsky et al. 2016). variant ADH1Brs1229984 consumed
less alcohol and had a reduced risk of
New Methods for Analyzing CHD and ischemic stroke compared
Alcohol Consumption and Total Alcohol Consumption and with noncarriers. This implies that
Stroke Incidence and Prevalence Stroke-Related Outcomes lower alcohol consumption, even in
light-to-moderate drinkers, was benefi-
Many epidemiologic studies also have Investigators are using new methods cial for CV health. These results chal-
been conducted to evaluate the associ- to examine the relationship between lenge the findings from several of the
ation between alcohol consumption alcohol consumption and CV outcomes. studies mentioned earlier that support
and total stroke incidence and preva- One such method includes Mendelian a cardioprotective effect of low-to-
lence, as well as the separate effects on randomization, an epidemiologic moderate alcohol consumption. They
specific stroke subtypes (e.g., ischemic study design that incorporates genetic also suggest that traditional epidemio-
and hemorrhagic). In the same system- information into traditional epidemio- logic studies may not capture important
atic review and meta-analysis noted logic methods. Mendelian randomiza- nuances related to selection bias or
above, Ronksley and colleagues (2011) tion offers an opportunity to test the other errors that can affect study
systematically examined the relation- relationship between a causal factor results (Chikritzhs et al. 2015; Holmes
ships between and among different (e.g., alcohol consumption) and a et al. 2014).
levels of alcohol consumption and specific outcome (e.g., CV disease).
incident stroke and stroke mortality. Holmes and colleagues (2014) used
They found a decrease or no effect on Mendelian randomization to deter- Conclusions About Alcohol
relative risk for incident stroke and mine if a relationship exists between
stroke mortality, respectively, at <2.5 g Consumption, CHD, and Stroke
drinkers with a certain variant in the
and 2.5 to 14.9 g of alcohol/day, and alcohol dehydrogenase ADH1B gene Based on these findings in both men
almost no overall associations of alcohol (rs1229984), which is associated with and women, alcohol consumption
consumption with levels between 15 reduced alcohol consumption, and the of about 1 to 2 drinks per day is
to 29.9 g and 30 to 60 g of alcohol/ likelihood of having fatal or nonfatal associated with a decrease in CHD.
day (figure 2). For heavier drinkers
(60 g/day) the risk for incident stroke
was greater compared with abstainers, Table 1 INTERHEART Data, Patterns of Alcohol Use, and Odds Ratio (OR) for Myocardial Infarction (MI).
and the risk for stroke mortality was
about one and a half times greater Pattern of Alcohol Use OR (95%) for MI p value
(figure 2). A subanalysis of stroke sub- Any alcohol use within 12 months
types revealed that when pooling the
risk among current alcohol drinkers Unadjusted 0.92 (0.87–0.96) <0.001
compared with nondrinkers, the risk
was actually higher for incident hemor- Adjusted (model 1) 0.81 (0.76–0.87) <0.001
rhagic stroke than for ischemic stroke
(n = 12 studies) (Ronksley et al. 2011). Adjusted (model 2) 0.87 (0.80–0.94) 0.001
In another analysis of these same Pooled* 0.84 (0.71–0.99) 0.04
studies, Zhang and colleagues (2014)
found a J-shaped relationship between Any alcohol use and risk of MI in subsequent
1.0 (0.9–1.2) 0.70
alcohol intake and stroke. Compared 24 hours
with no alcohol intake, consumption ≥ 6 Drinks and risk of MI in subsequent
of 0 to 20 g/day (or <2 drinks) was 24 hours 1.4 (1.1–1.9) 0.01
associated with a reduced risk of total
stroke, ischemic and hemorrhagic NOTE: Model 1 was adjusted for age (categorized as <45, 45−65, and >65 years), gender, geographic region, Dietary Risk Score,
stroke, and stroke mortality. However, exercise, smoking, marital status, employment, education level, depression, stress at work or at home, financial stress, body mass index
(BMI), and waist-to-hip ratio. Model 2 was adjusted as for Model 1 and for serum ratio of apolipoprotein B to apolipoprotein; total
alcohol levels >30 g/day (>2 drinks), cholesterol, high-density lipoprotein, low-density lipoprotein, and triglyceride concentrations; and history of hypertension or diabetes
and in particular >45 g/day (>3 drinks), mellitus. CI = confidence interval; MI = myocardial infarction; OR = odds ratio.
were associated with increased risk of *Pooled effect estimates from conditional logistic regression were stratified by geographic region and adjusted for Dietary Risk score,
exercise, smoking, marital status, employment, education level, depression, stress at work or at home, financial stress, BMI, and waist-to-
all stroke outcomes. It is important hip ratio.
to note that in this meta-analysis, SOURCE: Used with permission from Leong et al. 2014.

“low-alcohol intake” also included

224 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 224 5/23/17 5:39 PM


However, alcohol consumption may drinking had a protective effect on Alcohol and PAD
not have cardioprotective effects in incident heart failure in this age group.
certain racial or ethnic groups, such as On the other hand, drinking ≥5 Compared with CHD and stroke, the
in people of South Asian ethnicity liv- drinks/day (or ≥35 drinks/week) was relationship between alcohol consump-
ing in South Asia (Leong et al. 2014). associated with a significant risk of tion and PAD has been examined less
Although results related to levels heart failure. In subjects with reduced often, and to date there are no meta-
of alcohol consumption and stroke ejection fraction−related heart failure analyses or systematic reviews. PAD is
events are less clear, some conclusions (with the fraction of outbound blood used broadly to refer to pathophysio-
can be drawn. Approximately 1 pumped from the heart with each logic conditions affecting the arterial
to 2 drinks per day may have no heartbeat, or ejection fraction, at system. Fifteen years ago, two large
effect on or lead to a slight reduction <35 percent) and a history of ischemic prospective studies, one from the
in stroke events; however, greater heart disease or CAD (mean age 59), United States (the Strong Heart Study)
daily alcohol levels increase the risk Cooper and colleagues (2000) found (Fabsitz et al. 1999) and one from
for all stroke events and incident that light-to-moderate drinking (1 to Europe (the Rotterdam Study)
stroke types. In terms of stroke sub- 14 drinks/week) was associated with (Vliegenthart et al. 2002), examined
types, compared with nondrinkers, a significant reduction in progressive the effects of alcohol consumption on
current alcohol drinkers have an heart failure and hospitalization. How- PAD. Both studies used the ankle-to-
increased risk (~14 percent) for hem- ever, there were no positive effects in brachial index (<0.90), which com-
orrhagic stroke (Ronksley et al. 2011). subjects with mechanical or electrical pares BP measured at the ankle with
dysfunction of heart muscle, or non- BP measured at the upper arm, as a
ischemic heart disease, and although measure of PAD.
Alcohol and Heart Failure The Strong Heart Study enrolled
not significant, there was a slight risk
only American Indian subjects. After
Several studies and meta-analyses have for hospitalization for heart failure.
controlling for other factors, “current
been conducted to determine the rela- More recently, Cosmi and col-
alcohol drinking” in this cohort was
tionship between alcohol consumption leagues (2015) examined the effects inversely associated with PAD preva-
and the risk of developing heart failure of daily wine consumption in subjects lence in men and women (Fabsitz et
in healthy subjects, as well as in those enrolled in an Italian trial of heart fail- al. 1999). Because more specific infor-
with a history of MI or CHD. Heart ure patients (mean age ~67), most of mation was not available about levels
failure is a syndrome that often results whom had reduced ejection-fraction or amounts of alcohol consumption
from an MI or CHD. Studies also heart failure. Different levels of daily associated with what the researchers
have examined the “safety” of alcoholic wine consumption (i.e., sometimes, called “current alcohol drinking” and
beverage consumption in subjects with 1 to 2 glasses/day, and ≥3 glasses/day) only American Indians were included,
heart failure. had no effect on fatal or nonfatal out- it is difficult to generalize these findings.
In a meta-analysis of prospective comes (e.g., hospitalization for a CV The Rotterdam Study was designed
studies (n = 8) of healthy people ages event). Subjects who drank wine more to prospectively evaluate the occur-
21−81, Larsson and colleagues (2015) often, however, were less likely to have rence of chronic diseases in an aging
reported that, compared with non- symptoms of depression and more population (Vliegenthart et al. 2002).
drinkers, the risk for heart failure across likely to have a better perception of Their findings suggest that moderate
different levels of alcohol consumption health status. They also had lower levels alcohol consumption had no effect on
was greatest for those consuming 12 of circulating inflammatory markers, PAD in nonsmoking men (Vliegen-
drinks per week, intermediate for those such as C-terminal proendothelin-1 thart et al. 2002). In contrast, non-
consuming 3 drinks/week as well as for and pentraxin-3 (Cosmi et al. 2015). smoking women had a significantly
those consuming 14 drinks/week, and Thus, low levels of alcohol con- lower risk of PAD compared with
least for those consuming 7 drinks/ sumption (1 to 2 drinks, but not every nondrinking women for all levels of
week. Based on dose−response analysis, day) in patients with heart failure may alcohol consumption, with the lowest
consumption of 7 drinks/week was not exacerbate the condition, especially risks found in women consuming 20
associated with a 17 percent lower risk in those with heart failure attributable g/day of alcohol, or <2 drinks (odds
of developing heart failure. to ischemic CHD. Because heart fail- ratio 0.32 [95% CI 0.11−0.91]).
In contrast, Wannamethee and ure patients usually are older (over age Evaluating results from the Cardio-
colleagues (2015) recently examined 65) and often are prescribed numerous vascular Health Study, Mukamal and
different levels of alcohol consumption medications, both the effects of age colleagues (2008) found that drinking
and risk for heart failure in an older and of medication use should be care- 1 to 13 drinks/week was associated
population (mean age ~68) and found fully considered by patients, clinicians, with a lower risk of hospitalization
no evidence that light-to-moderate and researchers. related to lower-extremity arterial disease

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 225

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 225 5/23/17 5:39 PM


(defined as the diagnosis of atheroscle- note, only 19 percent of the subjects in sensitivity), hemostatic factors (e.g.,
rosis of native arteries of the extremi- the FRENA registry reported consum- fibrinogen levels and platelet reactivity),
ties or peripheral vascular disease) in ing >60 g/day of alcohol, limiting the and inflammation. In addition, and
older adults (mean age >70) compared generalizability of these findings. specific to CHD, alcohol consumption
with former and nondrinkers. How- As a result, existing data in this area may modulate ischemia−reperfusion
ever, older adults who consumed suggest either a weak positive or small mechanisms as blood flow is restored
>14 drinks/week did not experience inverse relationship between low-to- to tissues after oxygen deprivation.
the same reductions in PAD risk. In moderate alcohol consumption (e.g., Several of these potential mechanisms
the latter study, analyses were adjusted 1 to 13 drinks/week) and PAD preva- are briefly reviewed below.
for gender and many other confound- lence in men. Compared with other
ing variables, but men and women studies, Xie and colleagues (2010)
were not analyzed separately. reported a greater “protective” thresh- Risk Factors
Xie and colleagues (2010) conducted old of alcohol consumption (<60 g/day)
a large cross-sectional study of Chinese for PAD in men. However, in that One common risk factor for CV dis-
men ages ≥35 (n = 14,618). They found study, the mean age of both male ease is the composition of the lipids
an inverse association between a key and female participants was ~50 years, found in the blood, and the effects of
indicator of heart disease (i.e., ankle- nearly 15 to 20 years younger than in alcohol consumption on lipid profiles
to-brachial artery index >0.9) and other studies (Mukamal et al. 2008; have been extensively studied. Many
alcohol consumption of <60 g/day, or Vliegenthart et al. 2002). Findings are researchers have found that alcohol
about 4 drinks. Drinking ≥60 g/day less clear for women, with some studies intake increases HDL cholesterol
was associated with a decrease in the reporting a moderate inverse effect (HDL-c) levels, HDL (“good choles-
ankle-to-brachial artery index, indicat- (Vliegenthart et al. 2002) and others terol”) particle concentration, apolipo-
ing greater risk for PAD. In that same detecting none at all (Xie et al. 2010). protein A-I, and HDL-c subfractions
study, no effect or relationship was In terms of specific PAD complica- (Gardner et al. 2000; Muth et al.
found between any level of alcohol tions, Garcia-Diaz and colleagues 2010; Vu et al. 2016). Findings have
consumption and the ankle-to-brachial (2011) found no differences in PAD been equivocal for other lipids, such
artery index in women. outcomes between alcohol consumers as low-density lipoprotein cholesterol
Garcia-Diaz and colleagues (2011) and nonconsumers who had PAD. (LDL-c) (the estimated amount of
examined the effects of alcohol con- However, varying levels of daily alcohol cholesterol within LDL particles,
sumption among PAD patients consumption were associated with or “bad cholesterol”) and triglyceride
(n = 1,073). The PAD subjects chosen lower CV mortality and overall mor- levels (Rimm et al. 1999; Volcik et al.
had either cramping pain in the leg tality rate (Garcia-Diaz et al. 2011). 2008; Waskiewicz and Sygnowska
brought on by exertion (typically Larger prospective studies are required 2013). High triglyceride levels in
caused by obstruction of the arteries) to define the association between dose, the blood stream have been linked
and known as intermittent claudica- frequency, duration, and pattern of to atherosclerosis and, by extension,
tion, with an ankle-to-brachial index alcohol use and peripheral vascular increased risk of CHD and stroke.
<0.9; or they had previous vascular disorders more precisely, so that However, in a recently conducted
intervention or limb amputation for researchers may formulate specific Mendelian randomization study, Vu
PAD. These subjects were enrolled in recommendations for men and and colleagues (2016) reported that
the Factores de Riesgo y ENfermedad women with PAD across populations. low-to-moderate alcohol consumption
Arterial (FRENA) registry, which reduced triglyceride and LDL-c and
was designed to examine the natural increased HDL-c, in particular the
history of PAD in subjects (men and Mechanisms Related to HDL2-c subfraction. Interestingly,
women) with a mean age >62. Over an Alcohol’s Positive and Adverse the researchers found a nonlinear effect
average followup of 13 months, there Effects on CV Conditions of alcohol consumption on HDL2-c
were no differences between alcohol levels. This supports the findings from
consumers and nonconsumers in PAD Many of the CV conditions outlined other studies that the alcohol-induced
outcomes. However, mortality rates above share the pathophysiologic pro- changes in HDL-c do not fully account
were greater in nonconsumers com- cess of atherosclerosis and inflamma- for the lower risk of CHD in moderate
pared with alcohol consumers. The tion. Therefore, alcohol may exert its alcohol drinkers (Mukamal 2012).
FRENA registry found mortality protective or enhancing effects on these Other risk factors that are surrogate
benefits across all different levels conditions by modifying three broad markers of atherosclerosis and future
of alcohol consumption measured categories of mechanisms: risk factors CHD events, such as cIMT, also have
(e.g., <20 g/day, 21 to 61 g/day, and (e.g., lipid profiles, carotid intima- been examined. The relationship between
>60 g/day). However, as the authors medial thickness [cIMT], and insulin alcohol consumption and cIMT was

226 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 226 5/23/17 5:39 PM


inconsistent. Mukamal and colleagues cascade, fibrinogen also may play a are associated with reduced inflamma-
(2003b) reported that older adults proinflammatory role in the develop- tion, as indicated by markers such as
(age >70) consuming 1 to 6 drinks/ ment of certain CV diseases, including C-reactive protein and certain interleu-
week had lower cIMT compared vascular wall disease and atherosclerosis kins. Conversely, higher levels induce
with abstainers and those having (Davalos and Akassoglou 2012). Find- oxidative stress and a wide variety of
≥14 drinks/week. This is in contrast ings from a meta-analysis of 42 studies inflammatory markers. As reviewed
to results from other large population- by Rimm and colleagues (1999) below, oxidative stress in particular is
based studies of older (age >70) suggested that 30 g of alcohol/day likely a key event in the development
(Zureik et al. 2004) or middle-aged (2 standard drinks) was associated with of alcoholic cardiomyopathy (dis-
(ages 45−64) (Demirovic et al. 1993; a 7.5 mg/dl (−17.7 to 32.7) decrease cussed in “Acute and Long-term Effects
Djousse et al. 2002) adults, which did in fibrinogen concentration. Similarly, of Alcohol on the Myocardium”). Data
not find a relationship between level the results from the small randomized from numerous types of research studies
of alcohol intake and cIMT. crossover trial by Mori and colleagues show that alcohol may alter levels of
Some reports suggest that low-to- (2015) found that women consuming antioxidant enzymes and stimulate oxi-
moderate alcohol consumption is asso- alcohol (146 to 218 g/week, ~2 to 3 dative damage, and it may therefore be
ciated with favorable effects in insulin standard drinks/day) for 4 weeks showed involved in the pathogenesis of many
sensitivity and glucose metabolism, a 14 percent reduction in fibrinogen levels. types of alcohol-induced diseases (Ceni
key risk factors in the development Platelets and their role in clotting et al. 2014; Piano and Phillips 2014).
of diabetes (Greenfield et al. 2005).3 also affect CV disease. Altered platelet
Randomized placebo-controlled trials responses (e.g., increased platelet
conducted with nondiabetic post- activation/aggregation) leads to blood- Ischemic Preconditioning
menopausal women showed that 2 clot formation (or thrombosis) in
drinks per day significantly lowered certain CV conditions. Anticlotting Another mechanism underlying
insulin levels during fasting and after therapies are therefore the cornerstone the cardioprotective effects of low-to-
meals and increased insulin sensitivity of managing acute coronary syndromes. moderate alcohol consumption and
(Davies et al. 2002). Increased insu- Not surprisingly, alcohol consumption CHD in particular may be related
lin sensitivity, which is the opposite has complex and varying effects on to a phenomenon known as ischemic
of insulin resistance, is associated platelet function. Studies using different preconditioning, which produces
with a reduced risk for the develop- methodologies have shown that low-to- resistance to the loss of blood supply
ment of type 2 diabetes and CHD. moderate alcohol consumption decreases (and oxygen) to organs or tissues. If
platelet activation and aggregation in the blood supply is impaired briefly
certain cases—for example, in response (usually for <5 minutes) and then
to certain physiologic stimuli such as restored so that blood flow resumes,
Hemostatic Factors and the process is repeated two or
adenosine 5′-diphosphate (Salem and
Alcohol consumption can be associated Laposata 2005). On the other hand, more times, the cells downstream of
with both a favorable hemostatis/coag- significant daily alcohol consumption the tissue or organ are protected from
ulation profile as well as an adverse one increases platelet aggregation and reac- a final ischemic insult, when the blood
(Salem and Laposata 2005). Several tivity. Infection or other stressful events supply is cut off. In the heart, this
epidemiologic and randomized con- also can lead to immune-triggered would protect the heart muscle (myo-
trolled studies have found alcohol con- platelet production, a condition called cardium) from subsequent, more
sumption decreases coagulation factors rebound thrombocytosis, which may prolonged episodes of restricted blood
such as fibrinogen, which is a CV risk occur immediately after withdrawal flow (ischemia) followed by injury when
marker at elevated levels (Mori et al. from both heavy and one-time heavy that blood flow returns to the heart
2015; Rimm et al. 1999). In addition (binge) drinking (Numminen et al. (called reperfusion injury or ischemia−
to being essential to the coagulation 1996). Although highly individualized reperfusion injury; Veighey and
and dose dependent, alcohol use also Macallister 2012). Ischemic precondi-
3
Greenfield and colleagues (2005) studied the effects of alcohol can increase bleeding time (i.e., taking tioning results in smaller infarct sizes,
at meal time in a group of nonsmoking, healthy postmenopausal
longer to develop a clot)(Salem and fewer and less severe arrhythmias, and
women. Each woman was given either no alcohol or 15 g of
alcohol (1 standard drink) with either a low-carbohydrate or a Laposata 2005). prevention of endothelial cell dysfunc-
high-carbohydrate, high-fat meal. The women’s metabolic mea- tion (Veighey and Macallister 2012).
surements were then taken over the next 6 hours. The researchers
found that the alcohol-drinking subjects (particularly those who
During the ischemic phase, the flow
were insulin sensitive) had higher insulin levels and a slower Inflammation of oxygen and nutrients to the tissues
rise in glucose levels after a low-carb meal. They recommended is reduced, most significantly to the
confirming these results in younger women and in men, particu-
larly since their subjects had been older women, who have more
The effects of alcohol consumption on heart, brain, and kidneys. In contrast,
significant cardiovascular risk. inflammation are twofold. Lower doses during the reperfusion phase, despite

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 227

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 227 5/23/17 5:39 PM


restoration of blood flow, a series of mitochondrial permeability transition Impact of Drinking Patterns
dysfunctional biochemical and meta- pore, which can mitigate ischemia− and Types of Alcoholic
bolic changes are initiated that lead to reperfusion injury (Walker et al.
extensive accumulation of ROS. ROS
Beverages on Risk
2013). In addition, alcohol may atten-
induce a number of changes. One uate ischemia−reperfusion injury by Drinking patterns, and in particular a
is the opening of the mitochondrial activating protein kinase C epsilon binge pattern of drinking and higher fre-
permeability transition pore, which (PKCε) (Walker et al. 2013). Activa- quency of binge drinking, are associated
is formed in the mitochondria during tion of PKCε may protect the myocar- with a heightened risk of CV conditions
ischemic incidents, contributing to dium against ischemia−reperfusion such as HTN, stroke, and MI, as well
reperfusion injury and cell death. Others injury by stimulating the opening of as sudden death or increased mortality
include recruitment of neutrophils mitochondrial ATP-sensitive potassium after MI (Leong et al. 2014; Marques-
(white blood cells that are among the Vidal et al. 2001; Mukamal et al. 2005;
channels. This in turn prevents the open-
first inflammatory cells to respond Sundell et al. 2008; Wannamethee and
ing of the mitochondrial permeability
during inflammation) and dysfunction Shaper 1992). In a systematic review
of the sarcoplasmic reticulum, which transition pore (Walker et al. 2013).
(n = 37 studies), Feigin and colleagues
can affect calcium ion storage and Figure 3 summarizes the potential
(2005) found that excessive ethanol
release into muscle fibers. mechanisms underlying the cardiopro- intake (>150 g ethanol/week) was asso-
Alcohol may affect various mecha- tective and adverse effects of alcohol ciated with a doubled risk of subarach-
nisms implicated in ischemic precon- consumption. One or more mecha- noid hemorrhage. The latter findings
ditioning. Among these is the activation nisms may be in effect and/or may may relate to the overall large quantity
of mitogen-activated protein kinases cancel out another. This area of research of alcohol consumed (~12 standard
(MAPK) signaling cascades. MAPKs was briefly outlined here; more com- drinks/week) rather than a binge pattern.
are activated in response to stressful prehensive reviews on these mecha- Binge drinking in younger individuals
stimuli and help regulate apoptosis. nisms are available (Krenz and Korthuis also may increase the risk of stroke.
There also is desensitization of the 2012; Mathews et al. 2015). Haapaniemi and colleagues (1996)

Figure 3 Mechanisms related to the positive and adverse effects of alcohol on cardiovascular conditions, such as coronary heart disease and
stroke as well as cardiomyopathy. Different mechanisms may be in effect depending on the dose, duration, and pattern of alcohol consumption.

NOTE: BP = blood pressure, Ca2+ = calcium, CRP = C-reactive protein, DM = diabetes mellitus, HDL = high-density lipoprotein, LDL = low-density lipoprotein, PAI-1 = plasminogen activator inhibitor-1.
SOURCE: Adapted from Krenz and Korthuis 2012.

228 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 228 5/23/17 5:39 PM


found that acute intake on weekends Acute and Long-term Effects of and aortic peak pressure, which main-
and holidays of >40 g ethanol was Alcohol on the Myocardium tained cardiac output.
significantly associated with cerebral Other researchers have reported that
infarction within 24 hours in young acute alcohol consumption resulting
(ages 16−40) and middle-aged (ages Acute Effects in blood alcohol levels of 100 to 120
41−60) subjects. One possible mecha- mg% exerted no effect on cardiac
nism for the binge-associated increased The acute effects of alcohol on the performance (Blomqvist et al. 1970;
stroke risk is HTN. However, at least myocardium include a weakening of Child et al. 1979; Kupari et al. 1983a,b).
in younger people, HTN prevalence is the heart’s ability to contract (negative It is important to note that most stud-
low, suggesting that other mechanisms inotropic effect). Data from isolated ies were performed >30 years ago with
may be involved. papillary and heart muscle cell (myo- young subjects (mean age 23−35) and
It has been debated whether beverage cyte) experiments demonstrate that with small sample sizes (n = 4−12). As
type has differential effects. Some acute physiologic intoxicating doses a result, whether or how these findings
investigators have suggested that drink- of alcohol (80 mg% to 250 mg%) generalize to older healthy people and
ing wine may offer more protection can have a negative inotropic effect those with CV disease is unknown.
against CV disease because it contains (Danziger et al. 1991; Guarnieri and However, in an elderly community-
polyphenols, such as resveratrol and Lakatta 1990). These effects also may based population (i.e., the Athero-
flavonoids, which are micronutrients involve an irregular and often very sclerosis Risk in Communities Study,
with antioxidant activity (Tangney and fast heart rate (arrhythmia) during mean age at time of study 74−76 years),
Rasmussen 2013). However, among which the heart’s upper chambers Gonçalves and colleagues (2015)
studies designed to examine the influ- (atria) contract chaotically out of examined the effects of different levels
ence of beverage type, no differences coordination with its lower chambers of weekly alcohol consumption on
have been found in CV disease out- (ventricles), known as atrial fibrilla- alterations in cardiac structure and
comes or biologic markers, such as tion, or (rarely) sudden cardiac death. function. These investigators found
HDL-c (Mukamal et al. 2003a; Volcik Investigators have used a variety of increasing amounts of alcohol were
noninvasive tests to evaluate the acute associated with mild alterations in
et al. 2008). Differential associations
effects of alcohol consumption on cardiac structure and function, which
of CV risk with certain beverage types
myocardial function and hemodynamics were greater in women. In the United
such as wine instead have been attrib-
in healthy humans. As with isolated States, it is estimated that by 2060
utable to other lifestyle factors (e.g., there will be 98 million adults age >65,
increased physical activity) or drinking animal heart experiments, some inves-
tigators have found that acute alcohol more than twice the number in 2014
with meals (Malarcher et al. 2001). (Administration on Aging 2014). In
The findings from INTERHEART, exposure (blood alcohol levels 40 to
110 mg%) depresses myocardial systolic addition, recent research indicates that
in which “any alcohol use” had no car- this generation will potentially con-
dioprotective effects in certain popula- function in humans (Delgado et al.
sume alcohol at higher rates than pre-
tions, such as in people of South Asian 1975; Lang et al. 1985; Timmis et al.
vious generations (Barry and Blow
ethnicity who live in South Asia (e.g., 1975). However, these changes were
2016). Consequently, more research
India, Bangladesh, Nepal), led to spec- transient, with small changes from may be necessary to better understand
ulation about beverage type, beverage baseline. For example, in one study, the effects of alcohol consumption on
quality, and drinking pattern as import- the ejection fraction decreased by 4 the CV systems of older adults.
ant mediators (Leong et al. 2014). percent after alcohol consumption Certain arrhythmias, such as atrial
Finally, in studies of people from (Delgado et al. 1975). In another fibrillation, may be the most serious
certain Eastern European countries, study by Lang and colleagues (1985), consequence of consuming large
investigators have failed to find a cardio- however, the researchers noted a amounts of alcohol, and in particular
protective effect with any level of ethanol decrease in the maximum pressure binge drinking. Larsson and colleagues
consumption (Britton and McKee 2000). developed by a ventricle at any given (2014) have reported that binge drink-
This suggests that alcoholic beverage left ventricular volume, plotted as the ing (defined by these researchers as
type may be an important mediator, end-systolic pressure dimension slope, having more than 5 drinks on a single
because in countries such as Russia, as well as a decrease in the rate-corrected occasion) was associated with an
spirits are the alcoholic beverage of velocity of left-ventricular fiber increased risk of new-onset atrial fibril-
choice. However, the negative associa- shortening—and cardiac output was lation. Atrial fibrillation is one of the
tions between alcohol consumption and increased. Most likely, the decrease in most common arrhythmias and is
CV outcomes in these countries also contractility was offset by correspond- strongly associated with adverse CV
may relate to pervasive patterns of ing decreases in afterload (end-systolic events, such as stroke (Conen et al.
binge drinking (Leon et al. 2009). wall stress), systemic vascular resistance, 2011). Results from retrospective studies

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 229

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 229 5/23/17 5:39 PM


enrolling adults ages 40−60 also have found the mean alcohol consumption three potential ways in which alcohol
linked binge drinking to a heightened was ~11 drinks/day for at least 20 years, exposure can lead to excess free-radical
risk of sudden death (Wannamethee with most patients consuming slightly generation and oxidative stress: ethanol
and Shaper 1992). less (6 to 8 drinks/day). The researchers metabolism, ethanol effects on antioxi-
reported a mean age for these ACM dant proteins and antioxidant enzymes,
Long-term Effects patients of ~50, and more than half and activation/alteration in neurohor-
were current cigarette smokers. monal systems (table 2) (Fernández-
Alcoholic cardiomyopathy (ACM) is a ACM patients can present with either
heart-muscle disease found in individ- Checa et al. 1998; Piano and Phillips
diastolic or systolic dysfunction and 2014). At least in the myocardium,
uals with a history of long-term heavy may or may not have symptoms
alcohol consumption. It is character- many adverse cardiac intracellular
of heart failure. When these patients are effects found after chronic alcohol
ized by a dilated left ventricle (LV), treated with standard heart failure ther-
normal or reduced LV wall thickness, consumption can be attributed to
apies, they have good clinical outcomes oxidative stress:
increased LV mass, and (in advanced and reduced mortality rates. Factors
stages) a reduced LV ejection fraction associated with poor outcomes (e.g.,
(<40 percent) (Piano and Phillips 2014). • Myocyte loss and disarray;
greater mortality or transplantation)
There are no specific immunohisto- included a history of atrial fibrillation;
chemical or immunological biomarkers • Sarcoplasmic reticulum dysfunc-
an electrocardiogram QRS width >120
or other criteria for an ACM diagnosis tion, which can lead to systolic
milliseconds (ms), compared with the
(Piano and Phillips 2014). Therefore, a normal range of 70 to 100 ms; and dysfunction as well as a thickening
key factor in diagnosing ACM is a long- not being treated with beta-blockers of the heart muscle that can make
term history of heavy alcohol abuse with- or digoxin (Guzzo-Merello et al. 2015). ventricles larger, known as cardiac
out CHD or other cardiac conditions Long-term heavy alcohol consump- hypertrophy (Bing et al. 1974;
such as inflammation of and damage to tion induces adverse histological, cellu- Segel et al. 1981);
the myocardium, known as myocarditis. lar, and structural changes within the
ACM’s exact prevalence remains myocardium. As with other alcohol- • Changes in handling of intracellular
elusive. The proportion of cardiomy- induced pathologies, mechanisms con- calcium ions (Zhang et al. 2014);
opathy cases attributable to alcohol tributing to ACM include oxidative
abuse has ranged from 23 to 40 percent stress, apoptotic (programmed) cell • Depressed or disturbed mitochon-
(Piano and Phillips 2014). Recently, death, impaired mitochondrial bioener- drial function (Pachinger et al.
Guzzo-Merello and colleagues (2015) getics and stress, derangements in fatty 1973; Segel et al. 1981; Weishaar
reported that, among 282 patients acid metabolism and transport, and et al.1977);
with a dilated cardiomyopathy pheno- accelerated protein breakdown; these
type, 33 percent had ACM. Both men will be discussed in the following sec- • Decreased myofibrillar ATPase
and women can develop ACM. How- tions. These mechanisms contribute to activity, which affects muscle con-
ever, some reports indicate that alcohol- the myocyte cellular changes that lead traction (Hastillo et al. 1980; Segel
dependent women develop ACM after
to intrinsic cell dysfunction, such as sar- et al. 1975);
consuming less alcohol over a shorter
coplasmic reticular dysfunction and
period than do age-matched alcohol-
changes in intracellular calcium handling • Decreased myofibrillar calcium
dependent men (Fernández-Solà et al.
and myocyte loss. However, modulatory sensitivity, which affects contractile
1997; Urbano-Marquez et al. 1989).
influences related to drinking patterns, force generation in the heart (Piano
In humans, the exact amount and
genetic susceptibility, nutritional factors, et al. 1999);
duration of alcohol consumption asso-
ethnicity, and gender also many play a
ciated with development of ACM
role (Piano and Phillips 2014) (figure 4). • Contractile protein fragmentation
remains unknown. The point at which
alcohol-induced abnormalities appear and disarray (Jiang et al. 2012;
over the course of a person’s lifetime Tsiplenkova et al. 1986; Urbano-
drinking also is not well established Oxidative Stress and Apoptosis: Marquez et al. 1989); and
and is highly individualized. This sug- Linked Mechanisms
gests either protective or adverse inter- • Fatty acid accumulation within
action effects of genetic or lifestyle factors intracellular organelles, which can
(Piano and Phillips 2014). Among include atypical storage of fat in
ACM patients (n = 94) referred to a Oxidative Stress heart tissue that can lead to dys-
heart failure and heart transplant unit, In examining alcohol-induced pathol- function (Beckemeier and Bora
Guzzo-Merello and colleagues (2015) ogies, other researchers have suggested 1998; Hu et al. 2013).

230 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 230 5/23/17 5:39 PM


In various biologic systems, oxidative levels of antioxidant substrates (e.g., animal models. These data suggest that
stress can be measured or inferred by decreased glutathione levels) or levels antioxidant defense mechanisms that
several biologic indexes. These can or activity of antioxidant enzymes (e.g., attempt to protect the heart against
include measurement of antioxidant decreases in catalase or superoxide oxidative damage appear to be initiated
enzymes (e.g., catalase or glutathione dismutase) (Edes et al. 1986, 1987; soon after drinking alcohol. Also, as
peroxidase) or scavenging proteins Ribiere et al. 1992; Vendemiale et al. noted below, data from other studies
(e.g., glutathione), oxidative damage 2001) and/or lead to increased levels demonstrate the protective role of
(e.g., increase or presence of protein or accumulation of other markers of administered antioxidants, such as a
carbonyl and conjugated diene levels), oxidative stress (such as conjugated synthetic compound that mimics the
or measurement of circulating oxida- dienes, protein carbonyls, or 3-nitroty- native superoxide dismutase enzyme,
tive products (e.g., isoprostanes) (Dalle- rosine) (Edes et al. 1986, 1987; Ribiere called a superoxide dismutase mimetic.
Donne et al. 2006; Montuschi et al. et al. 1992; Tan et al. 2012; Vende- This suggests a direct or indirect role for
2004). Collectively, data from human miale et al. 2001; Zhang et al. 2014). ethanol-mediated oxidative stress in the
heart (Jiang et al. 2012; Tan et al. 2012).
and animal models suggest that alcohol Evidence of oxidative stress is found
Data from transgenic animal models
may alter important components of the after short periods of alcohol con- and pharmacologic approaches strongly
antioxidant defense system, such as sumption (2 to 18 weeks), at least in support a role for ethanol-induced
oxidative stress in CV disease. Using
both pharmacologic and transgenic
approaches, Tan and colleagues (2012)
Alcohol Consumption showed that administering an ROS
> 7–15 Drinks/Day > 5 Years Alcohol
Sex scavenger (a superoxide dismutase
mimetic) to mice receiving a diet high
• Oxidative stress in ethanol for 2 months significantly
• Activation of neurohormonal systems
(RAAS and sympathetic nervous system)
reduced nitrative damage (i.e., decreased
3-nitrotyrosine accumulation, a marker
of decreased cell damage and inflam-
• Apoptosis Nutritional mation). In addition, there was no
• ↑ Collagen and fibrosis Factors
• ↓ Neuronal nitric oxide synthase expression
evidence of nitrative damage in mice
• ↓ Synthesis and/or accelerated degradation of proteins bred to disrupt (i.e., knock out) the gene
• Intrinsic myocyte dysfunction for angiotensin I receptor (AT1-KO)
• Derangements in fatty acid metabolism and transport that had been given ethanol for a similar
length of time (Tan et al. 2012). Both
Cell dropout and weakly contracting myocytes experimental approaches also prevented
accumulation of ethanol-induced
scarring (collagen and fibronectin);
• LV dilation, wall thinning, and hypertrophy
• Decreased diastolic and systolic function Race and apoptotic cell death; and changes in
Ethnicity the size, shape, and function of the
Continued Drinking heart after injury to heart muscle
(ventricular remodeling).
• Progressive LV dilation and wall thinning Genetic Other researchers have used genetic
• Signs and symptoms of heart failure Variants
approaches (i.e., transgenic animals)
to prevent ethanol-induced oxidative
Figure 4 Pathophysiologic schema for the development of alcoholic cardiomyopathy (ACM). stress. One approach included overex-
As noted in the text, the exact amount and duration of alcohol consumption that pression of proteins such as insulin-like
results in ACM in human beings varies. The exact sequence of the development growth factor (IGF-1), which stimu-
of ACM remains incompletely understood. Data from animal models and human lates growth and cell proliferation and
beings with a history of long-term drinking suggest that oxidative stress may be has antiapoptotic effects (see Zhang et
an early and initiating mechanism. Many cellular events, such as intrinsic myocyte al. 2014). In contrast to control mice,
dysfunction, characterized by changes in calcium homeostasis and regulation the IGF-1−expressing animals exhibited
and decreased myofilament sensitivity, can come about due to oxidative stress.
no evidence of changes in expression
Variables in gray ovals represent potential mediating factors.
of antioxidant enzymes (i.e., superoxide
NOTE: LV = left ventricle, RAAS = renin−angiotensin−aldosterone system. dismutase-1) or any decreases in
SOURCE: Adapted from Piano and Phillips 2014. contractile function after 16 weeks
of ethanol consumption. The findings

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 231

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 231 5/23/17 5:39 PM


suggest a protective effect of overexpres- Table 2 Potential Ethanol-Induced Sources of Reactive Oxygen Species.
sion of IGF-1 in the transgenic animals
(Zhang et al. 2014). Ethanol Metabolism
• An ↑ in the flux of reducing equivalents into the electron transport chain due to an ↑ in
nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide production related to ethanol metabolism (↑ NADH/NAD+ ratio).
Apoptosis • An ↑ in cytochrome P450 2E1 metabolism of ethanol.
• An ↑ in alcohol dehydrogenase metabolism of ethanol and accumulation of acetaldehyde
Apoptosis also may be an important (leading to ROS formation and acetaldehyde adduct formation).
mechanism in ACM and a conse-
• Nonoxidative metabolism by fatty acid ethyl ester synthase and/or phospholipase D.
quence of oxidative stress. Studies have
found evidence of apoptosis in humans Ethanol Effects on Antioxidant Proteins and Antioxidant Enzymes
with ACM and in animal ACM models. • Alcohol-induced inhibition of transport proteins responsible for transporting glutathione from
Fernández-Solà and colleagues (2006) cytosol into the mitochondria (e.g., glutathione transport from cytosol into the mitochondria)
evaluated apoptosis in the hearts of and ↓ antioxidant enzyme levels and activity (e.g., superoxide dismutase).
adults with long-term alcoholism
(n = 19, drinking for 26 years), adults Activation/Alteration in Neurohormonal Systems
with long-standing hypertension • Increased autoxidation of catecholamines.
(n = 20), and those with no known • An ↑ in angiotensin II and norepinephrine levels.
disease (control subjects, n = 7). Apop-
tosis as evidenced by increased protein NOTE: NAD = nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide, NADPH = nictotinamide adenine dinucleotide diphosphate, ROS = reactive oxygen species.
SOURCE: Used with permission from Piano and Phillips 2014.
expression of two key proteins—one
that promotes apoptotic cell death
(i.e., BAX) and one that inhibits it increased number of mitochondria, ATP. Common findings in alcohol
(i.e., BCL-2)—was significantly higher mitochondriosis (small mitochondria studies from the 1970s and early 1980s
in both the alcoholic subjects and in closely packed together), and an increase included decreases in mitochondrial
the hypertensive subjects, compared in lysosome-like structures that break indices that reflected mitochondrial
with control subjects (Fernández-Solà down biomolecules in myocardial post- state III respiration, or ADP-stimulated
et al. 2006). Moreover, apoptosis was mortem biopsy samples from people respiration (Pachinger et al. 1973;
of a similar magnitude in the alcoholic with a long-term history of heavy alcohol Segel et al. 1981; Williams and Li
and the hypertensive subjects. More consumption (Hibbs et al. 1965; 1977). The latter changes in these
recent findings from this research Tsiplenkova et al. 1986; Vikhert et indices could be brought about by
group corroborate that apoptosis al. 1986). ethanol-induced imbalances in the
occurs in humans who have a long More contemporary studies have reducing equivalents nicotinamide
history of heavy alcohol consumption not found evidence of mitochondrial adenine dinucleotide (NAD) and nico-
(Fernández-Solà et al. 2011). injury in biopsy samples from long- tinamide adenine dinucleotide hydro-
term alcohol drinkers (Miró et al. gen (NADH), an important chemical
2000). Differences among results from pathway involved in oxidative stress.
Mitochondrial Dysfunction human studies may relate to small sam- In cardiomyocyte mitochondria as well
and Changes in Mitochondrial ple sizes, duration of drinking, and as other mitochondrial types, such
degree of myocardial dysfunction. In imbalances could lead to further
Bioenergetics the Miró study, alcohol drinkers also decreases in cellular respiration and
Researchers have found evidence of had been receiving pharmacologic treat- oxidative phosphorylation.
mitochondrial dysfunction or impaired ments such as beta-adrenergic blocking More recent studies have confirmed
bioenergetics related to alcohol con- agents that reduce blood pressure and that 4 to 16 weeks of ethanol con-
sumption. This is not surprising, because also may have antioxidant effects. sumption was associated with mito-
mitochondria are a major target for Changes in mitochondrial function chondrial dysfunction. This was
free-radical injury. Dysfunctional have been reported from a number of evidenced by decreased myocardial
mitochondria are less efficient, can animal studies in different species, ATP content levels, changes in the
become a source of ROS, and are more under various alcohol consumption mitochondrial membrane potential,
likely to initiate apoptosis (Marzetti et paradigms (ethanol in water or liquid and decreases in cytochrome oxidase
al. 2013). diet), and after variable durations of activity in conjunction with decreased
Histological studies published several chronic ethanol consumption (6 weeks myocardial contractility (e.g., decreased
decades ago reported evidence of mito- to 6 months). Through the process of ejection fraction and fractional short-
chondrial injury, such as mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation, the mito- ening) (Hu et al. 2013; Laurent et al.
enlargement and disorganization, chondria generate ~90 percent of cellular 2014). Although the connection is

232 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 232 5/23/17 5:39 PM


still speculative, this reduction in ATP consumption can also affect long-chain suggest that ethanol-induced decreases
synthesis may be enough to depress fatty acid (LCFA) uptake, as well as in myocardial protein synthesis may be
important intracellular functions that increased expression of the genes encoding mediated in part by decreased activity
support heart health, such as sarcoplas- for proteins involved in the formation of of an enzyme called mammalian (or
mic reticulum uptake of calcium ions triglycerides from free fatty acids and mechanistic) target of rapamycin
and cross-bridge cycling in muscle con- glycerol, or triglyceride esterification, and (mTOR) (Lang and Korzick 2014;
traction. Prolonged ethanol consump- in LCFA transporters (Hu et al. 2013).4 Vary and Deiter 2005; Vary et al.
tion also may decrease expression of 2008). mTOR regulates cell growth,
several types of mitochondrial proteins, proliferation, motility, and survival;
such as NADH dehydrogenase, isoci- Accelerated Protein protein synthesis; and transcription
trate dehydrogenase, and long-chain- Degradation (Donohue 2009). Decreases in mTOR
specific acyl-CoA dehydrogenase, as activation may play a role in reduced
well as proteins within the citric acid Long-term alcohol use decreases myo- myocardial protein synthesis, ventricu-
cycle (Fogle et al. 2010). This kind of cardial protein expression and synthe- lar wall thinning, and dilation.
mitochondrial dysfunction, including sis and accelerates protein degradation Alterations in protein physiology
decreased expression of some of these in the myocardium (Lang et al. 2005). and content also can result from accel-
proteins, is integral to cardiac ischemic− This in turn disrupts myocardium erated protein degradation. The normal
reperfusion injury, which occur rou- function, including contraction and destruction of molecules and cell organ-
tinely with MI—the most common relaxation of the cardiac walls, impair- elles (called autophagy) may be especially
incident of CV disease, itself the number- ing the heart’s ability to pump blood. important in triggering ACM. Auto-
one cause of death (Tompkins et al. Using mass spectrometric−based pro- phagy is performed by lysosomes and
2006). teomic analysis in an animal model, involves a breakdown (catabolism) of
Fogle and colleagues (2010) found unnecessary or damaged proteins in the
that long-term alcohol consumption cell. This mechanism also is essential to
Derangements in Fatty Acid was associated with decreases of 30 to cell and organism survival during stress
Metabolism and Transport 54 percent in cell-scaffolding proteins and nutrient deprivation. Under the
(myofibrillar α-myosin and actin) and latter conditions, autophagy helps gen-
Derangements in fatty acid metabo- mitochondrial proteins (mitochondrial erate and recycle carbons and amino
lism and transport and formation of dehydrogenases and electron transport acids through degradation of large
fatty acid ethyl esters (FAEEs) also proteins), glycolytic enzymes (glycogen (macromolecular) cellular constitu-
have been implicated in ethanol-induced phosphorylase and alpha-enolase), and ents. However, as with other CV
cell injury. FAEEs can be formed in fatty acid metabolism proteins (fatty pathological conditions, such as heart
the body during ethanol metabolism, acid transport protein and LCFA acyl- failure and cardiac hypotrophy, there
when ethanol reacts with fatty acids or CoA ligase). These investigators also is evidence of increased autophagy with
triglycerides. FAEEs can attach to found decreases in peroxiredoxin 5, chronic alcohol consumption. Guo
mitochondria and disrupt mitochon- antioxidant protein 2, and glutathione and colleagues (2012) studied autophagy
drial function. Lange and Sobel (1983) transferase 5—important antioxidant in mice with and without an overexpres-
were the first to identify an increase in enzymes whose cardiovascular protective sion of the enzyme alcohol dehydroge-
FAEE content in postmortem myocar- functions still are not fully understood. nase to show that 8 weeks of ethanol
dium samples obtained from those For example, some findings suggest an consumption was associated with
subjects who routinely had used large inverse role between peroxiredoxin 5 increased myocardial markers of autoph-
amounts of alcohol (n = 2) and who and stroke severity. During a severe
agy, such as autophagy-related 7 protein.
had a history of recent alcohol intoxi- Increased autophagy as a possible
stroke, peroxiredoxin 5 is consumed
cation (n = 4). mechanism underlying the adverse
and its production impaired (Kunze
The idea that FAEEs are involved myocardial effects of ethanol is intrigu-
et al. 2014).
in ACM pathogenesis and are cytotoxic ing. This is especially true in light of
Other ethanol-induced changes may the relationship between a sensor of
is supported by the fact that increased
tissue levels of FAEE are considered be related to enzymes that modulate stress (mTOR) and nutrient depriva-
the mechanism underlying cell death protein synthesis and/or breakdown tion and how essential autophagy is to
induced using a procedure to control (e.g., ubiquitine-ligases). Several reports cell survival. Activation of mTOR leads
and prevent recurrence of cardiac 4
Triglycerides are the main component of body fat in humans.
to inhibition of autophagy. As noted
arrhythmias (i.e., septal ablation) They do not pass readily through cell membranes, and they are above, chronic alcohol exposure leads
(Yoerger et al. 2006). major components of very-low-density lipoproteins (VLDLs), which to a decrease in mTOR activity, which
are converted in the blood to LDLs. High levels of triglycerides
Other researchers have confirmed in in the blood have therefore been linked to atherosclerosis, heart
corresponds to increased markers of
animal models that long-term ethanol disease, and stroke. autophagy (Lang and Korzick 2014).

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 233

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 233 5/23/17 5:39 PM


The autophagy pathway also is rapidly (Rehm et al. 2009). Nearly all the data example, certain levels of alcohol con-
upregulated during ATP depletion, on humans exploring the relationship sumption that lower risk for CHD may
mitochondrial dysfunction, and oxida- between alcohol consumption and CV increase it for other CV conditions,
tive stress. Ethanol-mediated increases risk—including some indications of such as stroke. In addition, data from
in autophagy therefore may be an potential CV benefits associated with studies using new research methods,
important mechanism underlying the low-to-moderate alcohol consumption— including Mendelian randomization,
adverse myocardial effects of ethanol. are derived from epidemiologic studies. suggest that the relationship between
Some of the potential cellular Therefore, because there are no ran- low-to-moderate alcohol consumption
changes related to ethanol consump- domized controlled trials, health care and cardioprotection merits more crit-
tion reviewed above are illustrated in professionals should not recommend ical appraisal (Holmes et al. 2014).
figure 5. More than one cellular event alcohol consumption as a primary or Alcohol use remains, as Saitz (2015)
may be happening at the same time, secondary lifestyle intervention. Instead, has memorably noted, “no ordinary
and, as with other chronic health con- clinicians should continue to recom- health risk.” Heavy daily alcohol con-
ditions, the relevant mechanisms may mend strategies such as a healthy diet sumption and binge drinking increase
be synergistic and interrelated. and exercise. Adults who choose to the risk of developing CV disease. The
drink can be encouraged to follow the growing rate of binge drinking in the
alcohol consumption recommendations United States is a serious concern
Summary and Future Directions from NIAAA (table 3). (Kanny et al. 2013). ACM, though
for Research Data derived from systematic reviews not a leading cause of heart failure
and meta-analyses suggest that alcohol- nationwide, can be associated with
Alcohol consumption remains a major dose and CV-health relationships marked changes in cardiac function,
risk factor for global burden of disease differ for various CV conditions. For symptoms, and poor quality of life.

Ethanol Ethanol
Nonoxidative Metabolism
↑ ANG II
Oxidative Metabolism via ADH
and CYP2E1
↑ FAEE
AT1

Robust ROS Generation


Oxidase/NOX

Cytochrome c
↑ NADPH

Activity

↓ ATP
Caspase-3 Activation
↓ Gene Expression ↓ mTor Activation
↑ ATG Signaling Apoptosis

Autophagosome ↑Autophagy
Lysosyme Fusion

Ethanol

Figure 5 Summary of potential cellular changes related to ethanol. Ethanol-induced changes may be related to oxidative or nonoxidative pathways
of ethanol metabolism. More than one mechanism may be activated and may lead to the multitude of ethanol-induced changes in cellular
proteins and cell function. As reviewed in the text, data from pharmacologic and transgenic approaches revealed an important role for
oxidative stress and the hormone angiotensin II.

NOTE: Ang II = angiotensin II, ATG = atrogin, ATI = angiotensin I receptor, ATP = adenosine triphosphate, CYP2E1 = cytochrome P450 2E1, FAEE = fatty ethyl esters, mTOR = mammalian (or mechanistic)
target of rapamycin, NADPH oxidase/NOX = nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate-oxidase, ROS = reactive oxygen species.
SOURCE: Adapted from Piano and Phillips 2014.

234 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 234 5/23/17 5:39 PM


Table 3 Drinking Levels Defined
• Considering the growing number Britton, A., and McKee, M. The relation between alcohol
and cardiovascular disease in Eastern Europe: Explaining
of older adults, more research is the paradox. Journal of Epidemiology and Community
The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse needed to better understand the Health 54(5):328−332, 2000. PMID: 10814651
and Alcoholism defines low risk drinking effects of alcohol consumption on Cahill, P.A., and Redmond, E.M. Alcohol and cardiovascu-
for developing alcohol use disorder as: the CV systems of older populations. lar disease: Modulation of vascular cell function. Nutri-
• No more than 4 drinks on any single day ents 4(4):297−318, 2012. PMID: 22606372
and no more than 14 drinks per week for
Camargo, C.A., Jr.; Stampfer, M.J.; Glynn, R.J.; et al.
men age 65 or younger. Prospective study of moderate alcohol consumption and
• No more than 3 drinks on any single day Acknowledgments risk of peripheral arterial disease in US male physicians.
and no more than 7 drinks per week for Circulation 95(3):577−580, 1997. PMID: 9024142
women and men over the age of 65. Because of space limitations, not all of Ceni, E.; Mello, T.; & Galli, A. Pathogenesis of alcoholic
the excellent scientific work on alcohol liver disease: Role of oxidative metabolism. World Journal
and the cardiovascular system could be of Gastroenterology 20(47):17756−17772, 2014. PMID:
Susceptibility factors, such as gender, 25548474
race/ethnicity, genetics, and socioeco- assessed in this review. Some of the
information presented here was previ- Ceron, C.S.; Marchi, K.C.; Muniz, J.J.; and Tirapelli, C.R.
nomic factors, may influence alcohol’s Vascular oxidative stress: A key factor in the development
positive and adverse health effects. ously published. For further detail, of hypertension associated with ethanol consumption.
When clinicians are counseling please see Piano 2002 or Piano and Current Hypertension Reviews 10(4):213−222, 2014.

patients about alcohol consumption, Phillips 2014. PMID: 5801625

they should consider all these factors, Chikritzhs, T.; Stockwell, T.; Naimi, T.; et al. Has the leaning
tower of presumed health benefits from “moderate”
as well as any history of alcohol depen-
dence. Of course, any advice about Financial Disclosure alcohol use finally collapsed? Addiction 110(5):726−
727, 2015. PMID: 25613200
alcohol consumption and related The author declares she has no Child, J.S.; Kovick, R.B.; Levisman, J.A.; and Pearce, M.L.
health issues needs to be targeted competing financial interests. Cardiac effects of acute ethanol ingestion unmasked by
for each patient. autonomic blockade. Circulation 59(1):120−125, 1979.
This review suggests several recom- PMID: 361280
mendations for future research: References Chobanian, A.V.; Bakris, G.L.; Black, H.R.; et al. Seventh Re-
port of the Joint National Committee on Prevention, De-
tection, Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Pressure.
• Using direct biomarkers of Administration on Aging. Aging Statistics. Washington, DC:
Hypertension 42(6):1206−1252, 2003. PMID: 14656957
alcohol, such as PEth, to corrobo- Administration for Community Living, U.S. Department of
Health and Human Services, 2014. Available at: http:// Conen, D.; Chae, C.U.; Glynn, R.J.; et al. Risk of death and
rate self-report of alcohol consump- www.aoa.acl.gov/Aging_Statistics/index.aspx. Accessed cardiovascular events in initially healthy women with
tion and distinguish between and July 26, 2016. new-onset atrial fibrillation. JAMA 305(20):2080−2087,
among low, moderate, and heavy 2011. PMID: 21610240
Barry, K.L., and Blow, F.C. Drinking over the lifespan: Focus
alcohol consumption. on older adults. Alcohol Research: Current Reviews Cooper, H.A.; Exner, D.V.; and Domanski, M.J. Light-to-
38(1):115−120, 2016. PMID: 27159818 moderate alcohol consumption and prognosis in patients
• Examining the potential mediation with left ventricular systolic dysfunction. Journal of the
Bau, P.F.; Bau, C.H.; Naujorks, A.A.; and Rosito, G.A. Early American College of Cardiology 35(7):1753−1759,
of genetic, socioeconomic, and and late effects of alcohol ingestion on blood pressure 2000. PMID: 10841221
racial and ethnic factors within the and endothelial function. Alcohol 37(1):53−58, 2005.
alcohol−CV disease relationship, PMID: 16472719 Cosmi, F.; Di Giulio, P.; Masson, S.; et al. Regular wine con-
sumption in chronic heart failure: Impact on outcomes,
specifically regarding development Beckemeier, M.E., and Bora, P.S. Fatty acid ethyl esters: quality of life, and circulating biomarkers. Circulation:
of ACM. Potentially toxic products of myocardial ethanol metabo- Heart Failure 8(3):428−437, 2015. PMID: 25925415
lism. Journal of Molecular and Cellular Cardiology
Dalle-Donne, I.; Rossi, R.; Colombo, R.; et al. Biomarkers of
• As suggested by Klatsky (2015), 30(11):2487−2494, 1998. PMID: 9925383
oxidative damage in human disease. Clinical Chemistry
reviewing alcohol−medication Bing, R.J.; Tillmanns, H.; Fauvel, J.M.; et al. Effect of pro- 52(4):601−623, 2006. PMID: 16484333
interactions, considering the longed alcohol administration on calcium transport in
Danziger, R.S.; Sakai, M.; Capogrossi, M.C.; et al. Ethanol
large number of antiplatelet agents, heart muscle of the dog. Circulation Research 35(1):
acutely and reversibly suppresses excitation-contraction
33−38, 1974. PMID: 4366862
lipid-lowering, and antihypertensive coupling in cardiac myocytes. Circulation Research
therapies prescribed to people with Blomqvist, G.; Saltin, B.; and Mitchell, J.H. Acute effects of 68(6):1660−1668, 1991. PMID: 2036717

CV conditions. ethanol ingestion on the response to submaximal and Davalos, D., and Akassoglou, K. Fibrinogen as a key regu-
maximal exercise in man. Circulation 42(3):463−470, lator of inflammation in disease. Seminars in Immunopa-
1970. PMID: 5451231 thology 34(1):43−62, 2012. PMID: 22037947
• Examining the CV effects related
Briasoulis, A.; Agarwal, V.; and Messerli, F.H. Alcohol con-
to alcohol use in young adults Davies, M.J.; Baer, D.J.; Judd, J.T.; et al. Effects of moder-
sumption and the risk of hypertension in men and wom- ate alcohol intake on fasting insulin and glucose concen-
(ages 18−30), a group that con- en: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of trations and insulin sensitivity in postmenopausal women:
sumes the most alcohol and binge Clinical Hypertension (Greenwich) 14(11):792−798, A randomized controlled trial. JAMA 287(19):2559−2562,
drinks the most. 2012. PMID: 23126352 2002. PMID: 12020337

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 235

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 235 5/23/17 5:39 PM


Deanfield, J.E.; Halcox, J.P.; and Rabelink, T.J. Endothelial Fernández-Solà, J.; Estruch, R.; Nicolas, J.M.; et al. Com- Harvard School of Public Health. Nurses’ Health Study 3.
function and dysfunction: Testing and clinical relevance. parison of alcoholic cardiomyopathy in women versus Cambridge, MA: President and Fellows of Harvard College,
Circulation 115(10):1285−1295, 2007. PMID: 17353456 men. American Journal of Cardiology 80(4):481−485, 2016b. Available at: http://www.nhs3.org/. Accessed April
1997. PMID: 9285662 15, 2016.
Delgado, C.E.; Gortuin, N.J.; and Ross, R.S. Acute effects of
low doses of alcohol on left ventricular function by echo- Fernández-Solà, J.; Fatjo, F.; Sacanella, E.; et al. Evidence Hashimoto, M.; Kim, S.; Eto, M.; et al. Effect of acute intake
cardiography. Circulation 51(3):535−540, 1975. PMID: of apoptosis in alcoholic cardiomyopathy. Human Pathol- of red wine on flow-mediated vasodilatation of the brachi-
1139762 ogy 37(8):1100−1110, 2006. PMID: 16867874 al artery. American Journal of Cardiology 88(12):
1457−1460, A1459, 2001. PMID: 11741577
Demirovic, J.; Nabulsi, A.; Folsom, A.R.; et al. Alcohol con- Fernández-Solà, J.; Lluis, M.; Sacanella, E.; et al. Increased
sumption and ultrasonographically assessed carotid ar- myostatin activity and decreased myocyte proliferation in Hastillo, A.H.; Poland, J.; and Hess, M.L. Mechanical and
tery wall thickness and distensibility: The Atherosclerosis chronic alcoholic cardiomyopathy. Alcoholism: Clinical subcellular function of rat myocardium during chronic
Risk in Communities (ARIC) Study investigators. Circula- and Experimental Research 35(7):1220−1229, 2011. ethanol consumption. Proceedings of the Society for
tion 88(6):2787−2793, 1993. PMID: 8252692 PMID: 21463333 Experimental Biology and Medicine 164(4):415−420,
1980. PMID: 6447877
Di Gennaro, C.; Biggi, A.; Barilli, A.L.; et al. Endothelial Fogle, R.L.; Lynch, C.J.; Palopoli, M.; et al. Impact of chron-
dysfunction and cardiovascular risk profile in long-term ic alcohol ingestion on cardiac muscle protein expres- Hibbs, R.G.; Ferrans, V.J.; Black, W.C.; et al. Alcoholic car-
withdrawing alcoholics. Journal of Hypertension sion. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research diomyopathy: An electron microscopic study. American
Heart Journal 69:766−779, 1965. PMID: 14296642
25(2):367−373, 2007. PMID: 17211243 34(7):1226−1234, 2010. PMID: 20477769
Hijmering, M.L.; de Lange, D.W.; Lorsheyd, A.; et al. Binge
Di Gennaro, C.; Saccani-Jotti, G.; Pinelli, S.; et al. Endothe- Garcia-Diaz, A.M.; Marchena, P.J.; Toril, J.; et al. Alcohol
drinking causes endothelial dysfunction, which is not pre-
lial dysfunction and high cardiovascular risk profile in severe consumption and outcome in stable outpatients with
vented by wine polyphenols: A small trial in healthy volun-
alcoholics improve only partially following a medium-term peripheral artery disease. Journal of Vascular Surgery
teers. Netherlands Journal of Medicine 65(1):29−35,
alcohol withdrawal. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental 54(4):1081−1087, 2011. PMID: 21684714
2007. PMID: 17293637
Research 36(2):242−250, 2012. PMID: 22013918
Gardner, C.D.; Tribble, D.L.; Young, D.R.; et al. Associations
Holmes, M.V.; Dale, C.E.; Zuccolo, L.; et al. Association be-
Djousse, L.; Myers, R.H.; Province, M.A.; et al. Influence of of HDL, HDL(2), and HDL(3) cholesterol and apolipopro-
tween alcohol and cardiovascular disease: Mendelian
apolipoprotein E, smoking, and alcohol intake on carotid teins A-I and B with lifestyle factors in healthy women and
randomisation analysis based on individual participant
atherosclerosis: National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute men: The Stanford Five City Project. Preventive Medicine data. BMJ 349:g4164, 2014. PMID: 25011450
Family Heart Study. Stroke 33(5):1357−1361, 2002. 31(4):346−356, 2000. PMID: 11006059
PMID: 11988615 Hu, C.; Ge, F.; Hyodo, E.; et al. Chronic ethanol consump-
Gonçalves, A.; Jhund, P.S.; Claggett, B.; et al. Relationship tion increases cardiomyocyte fatty acid uptake and de-
Donohue, T.M., Jr. Autophagy and ethanol-induced liver between alcohol consumption and cardiac structure and creases ventricular contractile function in C57BL/6J mice.
injury. World Journal of Gastroenterology 15(10):1178− function in the elderly: The Atherosclerosis Risk In Com- Journal of Molecular and Cellular Cardiology 59:30−40,
1185, 2009. PMID: 19291817 munities Study. Circulation: Cardiovascular Imaging 8(6), 2013. PMID: 23422163
2015. PMID: 26015266
Edes, I.; Piros, G.; Forster, T.; and Csanady, M. Alcohol-in- Husain, K.; Ansari, R.A.; and Ferder, L. Alcohol-induced
duced congestive cardiomyopathy in adult turkeys: Effects Greenfield, J.R.; Samaras, K.; Hayward, C.S.; et al. Benefi- hypertension: Mechanism and prevention. World Journal
on myocardial antioxidant defence systems. Basic Research cial postprandial effect of a small amount of alcohol on of Cardiology 6(5):245−252, 2014. PMID: 24891935
in Cardiology 82(6):551−556, 1987. PMID: 3435400 diabetes and cardiovascular risk factors: Modification by
insulin resistance. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Jiang, F.; Wang, P.; Zhao, F.L.; et al. [Serum levels of
Edes, I.; Tószegi, A.; Csanády, M.; and Bozoky, B. Myocardi- CC-chemokine ligand 18 in the patients with pneumoco-
Metabolism 90(2):661−672, 2005. PMID: 15522927
al lipid peroxidation in rats after chronic alcohol ingestion niosis]. Zhonghua Lao Dong Wei Sheng Zhi Ye Bing Za
and the effects of different antioxidants. Cardiovascular Guarnieri, T., and Lakatta, E.G. Mechanism of myocardial Zhi 30(9):678−680, 2012. PMID: 23257093
Research 20(7):542−548, 1986. PMID: 3779751 contractile depression by clinical concentrations of etha-
Kanny, D.; Liu, Y.; Brewer, R.D.; et al. Binge drinking—
nol: A study in ferret papillary muscles. Journal of Clinical
Emberson, J.R., and Bennett, D.A. Effect of alcohol on risk United States, 2011. MMWR Supplements 62(Suppl. 3):
Investigation 85(5):1462−1467, 1990. PMID: 2332501
of coronary heart disease and stroke: Causality, bias, or a 77−80, 2013. PMID: 24264494
bit of both? Vascular Health and Risk Management 2(3): Guo, R.; Hu, N.; Kandadi, M.R.; and Ren, J. Facilitated etha-
Kechagias, S.; Dernroth, D.N.; Blomgren, A.; et al. Phos-
239−249, 2006. PMID: 17326330 nol metabolism promotes cardiomyocyte contractile dys-
phatidylethanol compared with other blood tests as a
function through autophagy in murine hearts. Autophagy
Fabsitz, R.R.; Sidawy, A.N.; Go, O.; et al. Prevalence of biomarker of moderate alcohol consumption in healthy
8(4):593−608, 2012. PMID: 22441020
peripheral arterial disease and associated risk factors volunteers: A prospective randomized study. Alcohol and
in American Indians: The Strong Heart Study. American Guzzo-Merello, G.; Dominguez, F.; Gonzalez-Lopez, E.; et Alcoholism 50(4):399−406, 2015. PMID: 25882743
Journal of Epidemiology 149(4):330−338, 1999. PMID: al. Malignant ventricular arrhythmias in alcoholic cardio- Klatsky, A.L. Alcohol and cardiovascular diseases: Where
10025475 myopathy. International Journal of Cardiology 199:99− do we stand today? Journal of Internal Medicine 278(3):
105, 2015. PMID: 26188828 238−250, 2015. PMID: 26158548
Fan, X.; Hua, W.; Xu, Y.; et al. Incidence and predictors of
sudden cardiac death in patients with reduced left ven- Haapaniemi, H.; Hillbom, M.; and Juvela, S. Weekend and Klatsky, A.L.; Friedman, G.D.; Siegelaub, A.B.; and Gerard,
tricular ejection fraction after myocardial infarction in an holiday increase in the onset of ischemic stroke in young M.J. Alcohol consumption and blood pressure—Kai-
era of revascularisation. Heart 100(16):1242−1249, women. Stroke 27(6):1023−1027, 1996. PMID: 8650708 ser-Permanente Multiphasic Health Examination data.
2014. PMID: 24895352 New England Journal of Medicine 296(21):1194−1200,
Halanych, J.H.; Safford, M.M.; Kertesz, S.G.; et al. Alcohol
Feigin, V.L.; Rinkel, G.J.; Lawes, C.M.; et al. Risk factors for consumption in young adults and incident hypertension: 1977. PMID: 854058
subarachnoid hemorrhage: An updated systematic review 20-year follow-up from the Coronary Artery Risk Develop- Kleinhenz, D.J.; Sutliff, R.L.; Polikandriotis, J.A.; et al.
of epidemiological studies. Stroke 36(12):2773−2780, ment in Young Adults Study. American Journal of Epidemi- Chronic ethanol ingestion increases aortic endothelial ni-
2005. PMID: 16282541 ology 171(5):532−539, 2010. PMID: 20118194 tric oxide synthase expression and nitric oxide production
in the rat. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research
Fernández-Checa, J.C.; Kaplowitz, N.; Garcia-Ruiz, C.; and Harvard School of Public Health. Health Professionals Fol-
32(1):148−154, 2008. PMID: 18028525
Colell, A. Mitochondrial glutathione: Importance and low-up Study. Cambridge, MA: President and Fellows of
transport. Seminars in Liver Disease 18(4):389−401, Harvard College, 2016a. Available at: https://www.hsph. Krenz, M., and Korthuis, R.J. Moderate ethanol ingestion
1998. PMID: 9875556 harvard.edu/hpfs/index.html. Accessed April 15, 2016. and cardiovascular protection: From epidemiologic

236 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 236 5/23/17 5:39 PM


associations to cellular mechanisms. Journal of Molecular Liu, J.; Tian, Z.; Gao, B.; and Kunos, G. Dose-dependent adults: The Cardiovascular Health Study. Arteriosclerosis,
and Cellular Cardiology 52(1):93−104, 2012. PMID: activation of antiapoptotic and proapoptotic pathways by Thrombosis, and Vascular Biology 23(12):2252−2259,
22041278 ethanol treatment in human vascular endothelial cells: 2003b. PMID: 14563651
Differential involvement of adenosine. Journal of Biological
Kunze, A.; Zierath, D.; Tanzi, P., et al. Peroxiredoxin 5 Mukamal, K.J.; Maclure, M.; Muller, J.E.; and Mittleman,
Chemistry 277(23):20927−20933, 2002. PMID: 11919181
(PRX5) is correlated inversely to systemic markers of in- M.A. Binge drinking and mortality after acute myocardial
flammation in acute stroke. Stroke 45(2):608−610, 2014. Maiorano, G.; Bartolomucci, F.; Contursi, V.; et al. Noninva- infarction. Circulation 112(25):3839−3845, 2005. PMID:
PMID: 24385276 sive detection of vascular dysfunction in alcoholic pa- 16365208
tients. American Journal of Hypertension 12(2 Pt. 1):
Kupari, M.; Heikkila, J.; Tolppanen, E.M.; et al. Acute effects Muth, N.D.; Laughlin, G.A.; von Muhlen, D.; et al. High-density
137−144, 1999. PMID: 10090340
of alcohol, beta blockade, and their combination on left lipoprotein subclasses are a potential intermediary be-
ventricular function and hemodynamics in normal man. Malarcher, A.M., Giles, W.H., Croft, J.B.; et al. Alcohol tween alcohol intake and reduced risk of cardiovascular
European Heart Journal 4(7):463−471, 1983a. PMID: intake, type of beverage, and the risk of cerebral infarction disease: The Rancho Bernardo Study. British Journal of
6628423 in young women. Stroke 32(1):77−83, 2001. PMID: Nutrition 104(7):1034−1042, 2010. PMID: 20426890
11136918
Kupari, M.; Heikkila, J.; and Ylikahri, R. Acute effects of National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI) and
alcohol on left ventricular dynamics during isometric Marchi, K.C., Muniz, J.J., and Tirapelli, C.R. Hypertension Boston University. Framingham Heart Study. Boston: NHLBI
exercise in normal subjects. Clinical Cardiology 6(3): and chronic ethanol consumption: What do we know af- and Boston University, 2016. Available at: www.framing-
ter a century of study? World Journal of Cardiology 6(5): hamheartstudy.org. Accessed April 15, 2016.
103−108, 1983b. PMID: 6851270
283−294, 2014. PMID: 24944758
Lang, C.H.; Frost, R.A.; Summer, A.D.; and Vary, T.C. Molec- National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism
Marques-Vidal, P.; Arveiler, D.; Evans, A.; et al. Different al- (NIAAA). Part I: Overview Information—Biomarkers of
ular mechanisms responsible for alcohol-induced myopa-
cohol drinking and blood pressure relationships in France Alcohol Consumption and Alcohol-induced Tissue Injury
thy in skeletal muscle and heart. International Journal of
and Northern Ireland: The PRIME Study. Hypertension (SBIR [R43/R44]). Bethesda, MD: NIAAA, 2015a. Available
Biochemistry & Cell Biology 37(10):2180−2195, 2005.
38(6):1361−1366, 2001. PMID: 11751718 at: http://grants.nih.gov/grants/guide/rfa-files/RFA-AA-11-
PMID: 15982919
004.html. Accessed April 13, 2016.
Marzetti, E.; Csiszar, A.; Dutta, D.; et al. Role of mitochon-
Lang, C.H., and Korzick, D.H. Chronic alcohol consumption
drial dysfunction and altered autophagy in cardiovascular National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism
disrupts myocardial protein balance and function in aged,
aging and disease: From mechanisms to therapeutics. (NIAAA). College Drinking. Bethesda, MD: NIAAA, 2015b.
but not adult, female F344 rats. American Journal of American Journal of Physiology: Heart and Circulatory Available at: http://pubs.niaaa.nih.gov/publications/Col-
Physiology: Regulatory, Integrative and Comparative Physiology 305(4):H459−476, 2013. PMID: 23748424 legeFactSheet/CollegeFactSheet.pdf. Accessed April 13,
Physiology 306(1):R23−33, 2014. PMID: 24226028
2016.
Mathews, M.J.; Liebenberg, L.; and Mathews, E.H. The
Lang, R.M.; Borow, K.M.; Neumann, A.; and Feldman, T. Ad- mechanism by which moderate alcohol consumption in- Numminen, H.; Hillbom, M.; and Juvela, S. Platelets, alcohol
verse cardiac effects of acute alcohol ingestion in young fluences coronary heart disease. Nutrition Journal 14:33, consumption, and onset of brain infarction. Journal of
adults. Annals of Internal Medicine 102(6):742−747, 2015. PMID: 25889723 Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry 61(4):376−380,
1985. PMID: 3994186 1996. PMID: 8890776
Miró, O.; Robert, J.; Casademont, J.; et al. Heart mitochon-
Lange, L.G., and Sobel, B.E. Myocardial metabolites of drial respiratory chain complexes are functionally unaf- Pachinger, O.M.; Tillmanns, H.; Mao, J.C.; et al. The effect
ethanol. Circulation Research 52(4):479−482, 1983. fected in heavy ethanol drinkers without cardiomyopathy. of prolonged administration of ethanol on cardiac metab-
PMID: 6831662 Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 24(6): olism and performance in the dog. Journal of Clinical
859−864, 2000. PMID: 10888075 Investigation 52(11):2690−2696, 1973. PMID: 4748507
Larsson, S.C.; Drca, N.; and Wolk, A. Alcohol consumption
and risk of atrial fibrillation: A prospective study and Montuschi, P.; Barnes, P.J.; and Roberts, L.J, 2nd. Isopros- Piano, M.R. Alcoholic cardiomyopathy: Incidence, clinical
dose-response meta-analysis. Journal of the American tanes: Markers and mediators of oxidative stress. FASEB characteristics, and pathophysiology. Chest 121(5):
College of Cardiology 64(3):281−289, 2014. PMID: Journal 18(15):1791−1800, 2004. PMID: 15576482 1638−1650, 2002. PMID: 12006456
25034065
Mori, T.A.; Burke, V.; Beilin, L.J.; and Puddey, I.B. Random- Piano, M.R., and Phillips, S.A. Alcoholic cardiomyopathy:
Larsson, S.C.; Orsini, N.; and Wolk, A. Alcohol consumption ized controlled intervention of the effects of alcohol on Pathophysiologic insights. Cardiovascular Toxicology
and risk of heart failure: A dose-response meta-analysis of blood pressure in premenopausal women. Hypertension 14(4):291−308, 2014. PMID: 24671642
prospective studies. European Journal of Heart Failure 66(3):517−523, 2015. PMID: 26123682
17(4):367−373, 2015. PMID: 25598021 Piano, M.R.; Rosenblum, C.; Solaro, R.J.; and Schwertz, D.
Mostofsky, E.; Chahal, H.S.; Mukamal, K.J.; et al. Alcohol Calcium sensitivity and the effect of the calcium sensitiz-
Laurent, D.; Mathew, J.E.; Mitry, M.; et al. Chronic ethanol and immediate risk of cardiovascular events: A systematic ing drug pimobendan in the alcoholic isolated rat atrium.
consumption increases myocardial mitochondrial DNA review and dose-response meta-analysis. Circulation Journal of Cardiovascular Pharmacology 33(2):237−242,
mutations: A potential contribution by mitochondrial to- 133(10):979−987, 2016. PMID: 26936862 1999. PMID: 10028931
poisomerases. Alcohol and Alcoholism 49(4):381−389, Mukamal, K.J. Understanding the mechanisms that link Piano, M.R.; Tiwari, S.; Nevoral, L.; and Phillips, S.A. Phos-
2014. PMID: 24852753 alcohol and lower risk of coronary heart disease. Clinical phatidylethanol levels are elevated and correlate strongly
Leon, D.A.; Shkolnikov, V.M.; and McKee, M. Alcohol and Chemistry 58(4):664−666, 2012. PMID: 22322978 with AUDIT scores in young adult binge drinkers. Alcohol
Russian mortality: A continuing crisis. Addiction Mukamal, K.J.; Conigrave, K.M.; Mittleman, M.A.; et al. and Alcoholism 50(5):519−525, 2015. PMID: 26051989
104(10):1630−1636, 2009. PMID: 19681805 Roles of drinking pattern and type of alcohol consumed Potter, J.F.; Watson, R.D.; Skan, W.; and Beevers, D.G. The
Leong, D.P.; Smyth, A.; Teo, K.K.; et al. Patterns of alcohol in coronary heart disease in men. New England Journal pressor and metabolic effects of alcohol in normotensive
consumption and myocardial infarction risk: Observations of Medicine 348(2):109−118, 2003a. PMID: 12519921 subjects. Hypertension 8(7):625−631, 1986. PMID:
from 52 countries in the INTERHEART case-control study. Mukamal, K.J.; Kennedy, M.; Cushman, M.; et al. Alcohol 3522422
Circulation 130(5):390−398, 2014. PMID: 24928682 consumption and lower extremity arterial disease among Ras, R.T.; Streppel, M.T.; Draijer, R.; and Zock, P.L. Flow-
older adults: The Cardiovascular Health Study. American mediated dilation and cardiovascular risk prediction: A
Lewington, S.; Clarke, R.; Qizilbash, N.; et al. Age-specific
Journal of Epidemiology 167(1):34−41, 2008. PMID: systematic review with meta-analysis. International Journal
relevance of usual blood pressure to vascular mortality: A
17971339 of Cardiology 168(1):344−351, 2013. PMID: 23041097
meta-analysis of individual data for one million adults in
61 prospective studies. Lancet 360(9349):1903−1913, Mukamal, K.J.; Kronmal, R.A.; Mittleman, M.A.; et al. Rehm, J.; Mathers, C.; Popova, S.; et al. Global burden
2002. PMID: 12493255 Alcohol consumption and carotid atherosclerosis in older of disease and injury and economic cost attributable to

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 237

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 237 5/23/17 5:39 PM


alcohol use and alcohol-use disorders. Lancet Taylor, B.; Irving, H.M.; Baliunas, D.; et al. Alcohol and Volcik, K.A.; Ballantyne, C.M.; Fuchs, F.D.; et al. Relation-
373(9682): 2223−2233, 2009. PMID: 19560604 hypertension: Gender differences in dose-response rela- ship of alcohol consumption and type of alcoholic bever-
tionships determined through systematic review and age consumed with plasma lipid levels: Differences
Ribiere, C.; Hininger, I.; Rouach, H.; and Nordmann, R. meta-analysis. Addiction 104(12):1981−1990, 2009. between Whites and African Americans of the ARIC Study.
Effects of chronic ethanol administration on free radical PMID: 19804464 Annals of Epidemiology 18(2):101−107, 2008. PMID:
defence in rat myocardium. Biochemical Pharmacology
Thadhani, R.; Camargo, C.A., Jr.; Stampfer, M.J.; et al. 17855114
44(8):1495−1500, 1992. PMID: 1417973
Prospective study of moderate alcohol consumption and Vu, K.N.; Ballantyne, C.M.; Hoogeveen, R.C.; et al. Causal
Rimm, E.B.; Williams, P.; Fosher, K.; et al. Moderate alcohol risk of hypertension in young women. Archives of Internal role of alcohol consumption in an improved lipid profile:
intake and lower risk of coronary heart disease: Meta- Medicine 162(5):569−574, 2002. PMID: 11871925
The Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities (ARIC) Study.
analysis of effects on lipids and haemostatic factors.
BMJ 319(7224):1523−1528, 1999. PMID: 10591709 Timmis, G.C.; Ramos, R.C.; Gordon, S.; and Gangadharan, PLoS One 11(2):e0148765, 2016. PMID: 26849558
V. The basis for differences in ethanol-induced myocardial
Ronksley, P.E.; Brien, S.E.; Turner, B.J.; et al. Association Walker, R.K.; Cousins, V.M.; Umoh, N.A.; et al. The good,
depression in normal subjects. Circulation 51(6):1144−
of alcohol consumption with selected cardiovascular the bad, and the ugly with alcohol use and abuse on the
1148, 1975. PMID: 1132103
disease outcomes: A systematic review and meta-analysis. heart. Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research
BMJ 342:d671, 2011. PMID: 21343207 Tirapelli, C.R.; Leone, A.F.; Yogi, A.; et al. Ethanol consump- 37(8):1253−1260, 2013. PMID: 23527963
tion increases blood pressure and alters the responsive-
Rosito, G.A.; Fuchs, F.D.; and Duncan, B.B. Dose-dependent ness of the mesenteric vasculature in rats. Journal of Wannamethee, G., and Shaper, A.G. Alcohol and sudden
biphasic effect of ethanol on 24-h blood pressure in Pharmacy and Pharmacology 60(3):331−341, 2008. cardiac death. British Heart Journal 68(5):443−448,
normotensive subjects. American Journal of Hypertension PMID: 18284813 1992. PMID: 1467026
12(2 Pt. 1):236−240, 1999. PMID: 10090355 Wannamethee, S.G.; Whincup, P.H.; Lennon, L.; et al. Alco-
Toda, N., and Ayajiki, K. Vascular actions of nitric oxide as
Saitz, R. Alcohol: No ordinary health risk. Addiction 110(8): affected by exposure to alcohol. Alcohol and Alcoholism hol consumption and risk of incident heart failure in older
1228−1229, 2015. PMID: 26173155 45(4):347−355, 2010. PMID: 20522422 men: A prospective cohort study. Open Heart
2(1):e000266, 2015. PMID: 26290689
Salem, R.O., and Laposata, M. Effects of alcohol on hemo- Tompkins, A.J.; Burwell, L.S.; Digerness, S.B.; et al. Mito-
stasis. American Journal of Clinical Pathology 123(Sup- chondrial dysfunction in cardiac ischemia–reperfusion in- Waskiewicz, A., and Sygnowska, E. Alcohol intake and car-
pl.):S96−S105, 2005. PMID: 16100871 jury: ROS from complex I, without inhibition. Biochimica et diovascular risk factor profile in men participating in the
Biophysica Acta 1762(2):223−231, 2006. PMID: 16278076 WOBASZ Study. Kardiologia Polska 71(4):359−365, 2013.
Schnohr, P.; Jensen, J.S.; Scharling, H.; and Nordestgaard, PMID: 23788341
B.G. Coronary heart disease risk factors ranked by impor- Tsiplenkova, V.G.; Vikhert, A.M.; and Cherpachenko, N.M.
tance for the individual and community: A 21 year follow- Ultrastructural and histochemical observations in human Weber, M.A.; Schiffrin, E.L.; White, W.B.; et al. Clinical
up of 12,000 men and women from the Copenhagen and experimental alcoholic cardiomyopathy. Journal of practice guidelines for the management of hypertension
City Heart Study. European Heart Journal 23: 620−626, the American College of Cardiology 8(1 Suppl. A):22A− in the community: A statement by the American Society of
2002. PMID : 11969276 32A, 1986. PMID: 3711540 Hypertension and the International Society of Hypertension.
Urbano-Marquez, A.; Estruch, R.; Navarro-Lopez, F.; et al. Journal of Clinical Hypertension (Greenwich) 16(1):
Segel, L.D.; Rendig, S.V.; Choquet, Y.; et al. Effects of
The effects of alcoholism on skeletal and cardiac muscle. 14−26, 2014. PMID: 24341872 
chronic graded ethanol consumption on the metabolism,
New England Journal of Medicine 320(7):409−415,
ultrastructure, and mechanical function of the rat heart. Weishaar, R.; Sarma, J.S.; Maruyama, Y.; et al. Reversibility
1989. PMID: 2913506
Cardiovascular Research 9(5):649−663, 1975. PMID: of mitochondrial and contractile changes in the myocar-
127656 Vary, T.C., and Deiter, G. Long-term alcohol administration dium after cessation of prolonged ethanol intake. American
inhibits synthesis of both myofibrillar and sarcoplasmic Journal of Cardiology 40(4):556−562, 1977. PMID:
Segel, L.D.; Rendig, S.V.; and Mason, D.T. Alcohol-induced
proteins in heart. Metabolism 54(2):212−219, 2005. 562064
cardiac hemodynamic and Ca2+ flux dysfunctions are re-
PMID: 15690316
versible. Journal of Molecular and Cellular Cardiology Williams, E.S., and Li, T.K. The effect of chronic alcohol
13(5):443−455, 1981. PMID: 7265254 Vary, T.C., Deiter, G., and Lantry, R. Chronic alcohol feeding administration on fatty acid metabolism and pyruvate
impairs mTOR(Ser 2448) phosphorylation in rat hearts. oxidation of heart mitochondria. Journal of Molecular and
Seppä, K., and Sillanaukee, P. Binge drinking and ambula-
Alcoholism: Clinical and Experimental Research 32(1): Cellular Cardiology 9(12):1003−1011, 1977. PMID: 563474
tory blood pressure. Hypertension 33(1):79−82, 1999. 43−51, 2008. PMID: 18028531
PMID: 9931085 Xie, X.; Ma, Y.T.; Yang, Y.N.; et al. Alcohol consumption and
Veighey, K., and Macallister, R.J. Clinical applications of ankle-to-brachial index: Results from the Cardiovascular
Sesso, H.D.; Cook, N.R.; Buring, J.E.; et al. Alcohol consump- remote ischemic preconditioning. Cardiology Research
tion and the risk of hypertension in women and men. Risk Survey. PLoS One 5(12):e15181, 2010. PMID: 21152041
and Practice 2012:620681, 2012. PMID: 22400123
Hypertension 51(4):1080−1087, 2008. PMID: 18259032 Yoerger, D.M.; Best, C.A.; McQuillan, B.M.; et al. Rapid fatty
Vendemiale, G.; Grattagliano, I.; Altomare, E.; et al. Mito-
Sundell, L.; Salomaa, V.; Vartiainen, E.; et al. Increased acid ethyl ester synthesis by porcine myocardium upon
chondrial oxidative damage and myocardial fibrosis in
stroke risk is related to a binge-drinking habit. Stroke ethanol infusion into the left anterior descending coro-
rats chronically intoxicated with moderate doses of etha-
39(12):3179−3184, 2008. PMID: 18832741 nol. Toxicology Letters 123(2−3):209−216, 2001. PMID: nary artery. American Journal of Pathology 168(5):1435−
11641048 1442, 2006. PMID: 16651611
Tan, Y.; Li, X.; Prabhu, S.D.; et al. Angiotensin II plays a criti-
cal role in alcohol-induced cardiac nitrative damage, cell Vikhert, A.M.; Tsiplenkova, V.G.; and Cherpachenko, N.M. Zhang, C.; Qin, Y.Y.; Chen, Q.; et al. Alcohol intake and risk
death, remodeling, and cardiomyopathy in a protein kinase Alcoholic cardiomyopathy and sudden cardiac death. of stroke: A dose-response meta-analysis of prospective
C/nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate oxidase- Journal of the American College of Cardiology 8(1 Suppl. studies. Internal Journal of Cardiology 174(3):669−677,
dependent manner. Journal of the American College of A):3A−11A, 1986. PMID: 3711541 2014. PMID: 24820756
Cardiology 59(16):1477−1486, 2012. PMID: 22497828
Vliegenthart, R.; Geleijnse, J.M.; Hofman, A.; et al. Alcohol Zureik, M.; Gariepy, J.; Courbon, D.; et al. Alcohol
Tangney, C.C., and Rasmussen, H.E. Polyphenols, inflam- consumption and risk of peripheral arterial disease: The consumption and carotid artery structure in older French
mation, and cardiovascular disease. Current Atherosclero- Rotterdam Study. American Journal of Epidemiology adults: The Three-City Study. Stroke 35(12):2770−2775,
sis Reports 15(5):324, 2013. PMID: 23512608 155(4):332−338, 2002. PMID: 11836197 2004. PMID: 1551416

238 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 238 5/23/17 5:39 PM


Glossary

Actin: A family of globular multifunctional proteins, Autophagy-Related 7 Protein: Myocardial marker


each of which forms (together with myosin) the contractile of autophagy; also thought to modulate tumor-
filaments of muscle cells, and is also involved in motion suppression protein−dependent cell cycle pathways
in other types of cells. during prolonged metabolic stress.

Afterload: The pressure in the left ventricle wall during Baroreflex: Also known as baroreceptor reflex; one
ejection of blood; the end load against which the heart of the body’s homeostatic mechanisms that helps to
contracts to eject blood. maintain blood pressure at nearly constant levels; part
of a rapid negative-feedback loop that can begin to act
Alpha-Enolase: Also known as enolase 1 (ENO1). A in less than the duration of a cardiac cycle (fractions of
glycolytic enzyme expressed in most tissues, one of the a second), and thus a key factor in dealing with postural
isoenzymes of enolase. Functions as a glycolytic enzyme hypotension, the tendency for blood pressure to
and as a structural lens protein, with a shorter isoform decrease on standing due to gravity.
functioning as a tumor marker.
BAX Protein: Apoptosis-regulator protein that promotes
Alpha [α]-Myosin: A protein of the myofibril (elongated apoptotic cell death by interacting with and increasing
contractile thread in striated muscle cells); with actin, the opening of the mitochondrial voltage-dependent
forms actomyosin, responsible for the contractile anion channel (VDAC), which leads to loss in
properties of muscle. membrane potential and release of cytochrome c and
other pro-apoptotic factors from the mitochondria.
Angiotensin I Receptor: A cellular receptor responsible
for signal transduction of the vasoconstricting stimulus BCL-2 Protein: Apoptosis-regulator protein that inhibits
of angiotensin II, the main effector hormone; important apoptotic cell death.
in the renin−angiotensin−aldosterone system (RAAS),
which regulates plasma sodium concentration and Body Mass Index (BMI): Quantifies the amount of tissue
arterial blood pressure. mass (muscle, fat, and bone) in an individual based
on mass (weight) and height, with categories labeled
Antioxidant Protein 2: Antioxidant that affects certain underweight, normal weight, overweight, or obese;
disease processes, including atherosclerosis. commonly accepted BMI ranges are underweight:
under 18.5, normal weight: 18.5 to 25, overweight:
25 to 30, obese: over 30.
Apolipoprotein A-I: The major protein component of
high-density lipoprotein (HDL) in plasma, or “good
cholesterol”; plays a specific role in lipid metabolism. Carotid Intima-Medial Thickness (cIMT): Measurement
of the thickness of the carotid arteries, which supply
Atherosclerosis: A disease of the arteries characterized the brain, used to assess cardiovascular disease
by deposition of plaques (made up of fats, cholesterol, risk, since increased thickness is a marker of early
cellular waste products, calcium, and fibrin) on arterial stages of heart disease; a cIMT test is done with
inner walls, which can restrict blood flow; commonly ultrasound, takes 10 minutes, is painless, and involves
called hardening of the arteries. no radiation exposure.

Atrogin: Protein expressed during muscle atrophy; C-Reactive Protein: Acute-phase reactant protein in
atrogin-1 is expressed in cardiac and skeletal muscle blood plasma, secreted by the liver, whose level increases
and directs muscle protein degradation after muscle in response to inflammation; can help predict risk of
atrophy response has been triggered. heart disease or stroke.

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 239

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 239 5/23/17 5:39 PM


Glossary (continued)

reduced form of glutathione to certain foreign chemicals,


C-terminal Proendothelin-1: Circulating inflammatory which makes these molecules less toxic.
marker, elevated during heart failure and acute
myocardial infarction. Glycogen Phosphorylase: Glycolytic enzyme that
catalyzes the rate-limiting step in the breakdown of
Cross-Bridge Cycling: Four-step cycle of muscle glycogen, the main storage form of glucose in the body.
contraction in skeletal and cardiac muscle; named for
myosin protein heads (cross-bridges) of thick filaments Glycoproteins: Proteins important to various cell−cell
in a sarcomere, the functional unit of a myofibril or interactions, including white blood cell recognition;
contractile protein, which bind to and move along found on surface membranes of platelets and integral to
actin in the sarcomere’s thin filament, an interaction bleeding cessation, formation of blood clots, and normal
that is the molecular basis for force generation and platelet aggregation and adherence to the endothelium.
movement in muscle cells.
Interleukin: Glycoprotein produced by white blood cells
Cytochrome P450 2E1: Membrane protein expressed in for regulating immune response, including three dozen
high levels in the liver, responsible for fatty acid oxidation currently identified types.
and conversion of ethanol to acetaldehyde and to
acetate in humans; also metabolizes foreign chemical Isocitrate Dehydrogenase: Enzyme that catalyzes the
substances in the body, including toxic environmental third step of the citric acid cycle while converting
chemicals and carcinogens. NAD+ to NADH in the mitochondria.

Isoprostane: Inflammatory mediator that augments


Endogenous Nitric Oxide Synthase (eNOS): Protective
the perception of pain and is a biomarker of oxidative
enzyme that produces most of the nitric oxide in the
stress; elevated levels may contribute to increased risk
vascular system and helps prevent platelet aggregation
of heart attack in people taking certain kinds of
and adhesion.
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs.

Fatty Acid Ethyl Ester (FAEE): Nonoxidative metabolite


Long-Chain Fatty Acids (LCFAs): Chief components of
of ethanol, sometimes used as a biomarker of alcohol
dietary fats; turned into triglycerides and taken up into
consumption; intoxicated humans have high levels of
cells, where they are metabolized by the mitochondria and
FAEE in blood, pancreas, liver, and hair. yield large quantities of ATP; ingestion through certain
foods promotes lipid accumulation and insulin resistance.
Fibronectin: Glycoprotein that in soluble plasma form
is a major protein component of blood plasma and
Long-Chain-Specific Acyl-CoA Dehydrogenase:
plays a major role in cell adhesion, growth, migration,
Mitochondrial enzyme that participates in fatty acid
and differentiation and is important in wound healing metabolism; mitochondrial mutations in it may be
and formation of blood clots. associated with some forms of dilated cardiomyopathy,
which enlarges and weakens the left ventricle, making
Glutathione: Antioxidant capable of preventing damage it harder for the heart to pump blood.
to important cellular components caused by reactive
oxygen species such as free radicals, peroxides, lipid Lysosome: Membrane-bound organelle in most animal
peroxides, and heavy metals. cells that contains hydrolytic enzymes that can break
down almost all biomolecules; involved in cellular
Glutathione Transferase 5: Metabolic isoenzyme that secretion, plasma membrane repair, cell signaling,
helps in detoxification by catalyzing the binding of the energy metabolism, and waste disposal.

240 | Vol. 38, No. 2 Alcohol Research: C u r r e n t Reviews

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 240 5/23/17 5:39 PM


Glossary (continued)

Mechanistic (or Mammalian) Target of Rapamycin Phosphatidylethanol: Phospholipid formed only in


(mTOR): Kinase that regulates cellular metabolism, the presence of ethanol, used as a direct biomarker of
growth, and proliferation; inhibits T-cell proliferation previous alcohol consumption.
and proliferative responses induced by certain cytokines.
Prostanoid: Signaling molecules that include
Mendelian Randomization: A epidemiologic method of prostaglandins, which mediate inflammatory and
using measured variation in genes of known function anaphylactic reactions; thromboxanes, which mediate
to examine the causal effect of a modifiable exposure vasoconstriction and help form blood clots (thrombosis);
on disease in nonexperimental studies.
and prostacyclins, which help resolve inflammation.
NADH Dehydrogenase: Flavoprotein that reversibly
oxidizes NADH to NAD+ in mitochondria, in the Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS): Chemically reactive
metabolic pathway that cells use to oxidize nutrients, molecules containing oxygen, formed as a natural
thereby releasing energy to reform ATP. byproduct of normal oxygen metabolism and
integral to cell signaling and homeostatis; in times
Nicotinamide Adenine Dinucleotide Phosphate-Oxidase of environmental stress or with ionizing radiation,
(NADPH Oxidase): Membrane-bound enzyme complex may result in significant damage to cell structures,
found in plasma membrane that faces the extracellular known as oxidative stress.
space; major cause of atherosclerosis from its production
of reactive oxygen species and resulting accumulation
of cholesterol-containing macrophages in arterial walls. Renin−Angiotensin−Aldosterone System (RAAS):
Neurohormonal system involved in regulation of
plasma sodium concentration and arterial blood
Nitric Oxide: Important cellular signaling molecule pressure; can be activated by loss of blood volume or
involved in many physiological and pathological drop in blood pressure; angiotensin-converting enzyme
processes; integral to vasodilation and increased blood
(ACE) inhibitors reduce formation of angiotensin II, a
flow in blood vessels; acts as powerful vasodilator with
a short half-life of a few seconds in the blood; can strong vasoconstrictor.
contribute to reperfusion injury after ischemia.
Sarcoplasmic Reticulum: Smooth endoplasmic
Pentraxin-3: Circulating inflammatory marker integral reticulum found in muscle cells that regulates the
to protection against pathogens and to control of calcium ion concentration in the cytoplasm of striated
autoimmunity; facilitates pathogen recognition by muscle cells; stores calcium ions and pumps them into
macrophages and dendritic cells; appears to be sarcoplasm when the muscle fiber is stimulated, thereby
primarily protective in both acute infections and playing a major role in muscle contraction.
acute coronary syndromes.

Subarachnoid Hemorrhage: Bleeding into the


Peroxiredoxin 5: Protein that acts protectively as an subarachnoid space of the brain, the area between the
antioxidant in different tissues under normal conditions
and during inflammatory processes; cardioprotective arachnoid membrane and the pia mater, the brain’s
functions still to be determined. innermost membrane; a form of stroke that can lead
to severe disability or death.
Phenylephrine: Selective α1-adrenergic receptor used
as a decongestant and also as a vasopressor to increase Thrombocytosis: Excessive production of platelets
blood pressure in patients with reduced blood pressure, (thrombocytes) in the body; often without symptoms,
especially from septic shock. but can cause thrombosis or formation of blood clots.

Alcohol’s Effects on the Cardiovascular System | 241

9012_NIAAA_ARCR_Journal_Organs_vol38_#2_TXT_v04_FINAL.indd 241 5/23/17 5:39 PM

You might also like