Professional Documents
Culture Documents
002 - Soil Mechanics - Triaxial
002 - Soil Mechanics - Triaxial
me introduce myself
1
10/12/2021
https://www.instagram.com/geotechnical_antgineering/
EFFECTIVE
Pg. 6
2
10/12/2021
200 m
5m
3
10/12/2021
4
10/12/2021
Bolton (1987)
• Triaxial is able to measure/observe the following properties/behaviour in soil:
• Small strains stiffness;
52nd Rankine Lecture • Dilation and contraction due to large shear strains;
• Critical state in which infinite shear strains develop;
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malcolm_Bolton • Speed of drainage, which controls pore-water pressure;
• Friction and cohesion
• Each at varying degrees of precision Pg. 19
• By intuition, we may think that strong materials will be stiff; and weak materials will be soft
5
10/12/2021
Membrane
Membrane stretcher
Drain lines (make sure
there is no air in the drain) Circular filter Triaxial cell
Porous paper wall
stones Triaxial top
part
Pedestal
Rod
Vacuum grease
O rings
Filter paper strips
TRIAXIAL APPARATUS
If the axial load cell is installed above the triaxial chamber, some https://www.gdsinstruments.com/gds-
errors maybe produced due to friction between loading ram and the products/triaxial-automated-system-load-
top of triaxial chamber frame-type
GEOTECHNICAL ANTGINEERING
6
10/12/2021
Top part
Base Part
7
10/12/2021
TRIAXIAL APPARATUS
https://www.globalgilson.com/porous-stones
1200
https://www.globalgilson.com/porous-stones
8
10/12/2021
9
10/12/2021
Measure the diameter of the soil Measure the height of the soil specimen Measure the weight of the soil
specimen with vernier caliper with vernier caliper specimen
This port is connected into a small
hole in which fluids can go inside
or outside of the triaxial chamber
(outside of the soil specimen)
The port controls fluid pressure
outside the specimen, i.e. ()
Gently put the soil in the soil lathe Using wire saw cut the sides of the
soil sample. Trim all sides until it
makes a cylindrical shape. The guide
on the soil lathe will produce a
cylindrical sample with 35 mm
diameter
Extrude soil specimen from soil Put the soil cylindrical cutter on top of Using spatula, cut the remaining soil
sampler, for undisturbed sample can use the extruder to cut the soil into a of the soil cutter
Shelby tube as the soil sampler triaxial sample shape. Make sure the
height is at least twice the diameter.
The usual triaxial sample size is 38 mm
in diameter and 76 mm in height
GEOTECHNICAL ANTGINEERING Pg. 38 GEOTECHNICAL ANTGINEERING Pg. 40
10
10/12/2021
Gently put the soil horizontally in the Using wire saw trim the bottom part Measure with vernier caliper the height
mini soil lathe. of the specimen with the aid of mini of the soil specimen. Make sure the
soil lathe. height is at least twice the diameter,
which is 70 mm.
The soil excess which is trimmed can be placed into a tin to
measure its water content.
This is so we can calculate the volume of solid in the soil specimen. However,
we need to measure the specific gravity too in order to do the calculation.
Compress the sample into the mold in 10 layers with 10 Extrude the soil specimen manually
tamps per layer
Trim the remaining Measure the circumference of the soil Measure the weight of the soil
soil with wiresaw specimen specimen
11
10/12/2021
Put O ring on top of the membrane and slowly place the Add the compaction sleeve firmly over the overflow tray.
overflow tray sample down to the O ring Then measure the height of the sample minus compaction
sleeve. Divide the sample by ten lifts
By knowing the height of each layer of sand and its density and the volume of the
mold, we can find out how much material we need to use for each layer and how
many layers do we need. The reason for using ten lifts is to ensure our sample is
as uniformly compacted as possible
Use large O rings to tightly fit the triaxial cell to the base Put the membrane inside the mold and put two O rings to Weigh the sand, and put the sand inside the membrane Compact the sand, repeat until the membrane is full
secure the bottom part
Put the porous stone inside the membrane Stretch the membrane to the top of the mould, then use This is how it looks like when it’s full Using a flat knife, smoothen the top face of the sample
vacuum to suck the membrane so it would stick to the wall of
the mould Pg. 48
12
10/12/2021
Slowly pullout the overflow tray and remove the remaining Thoroughly clean the sand on the top of the sample and the
excess sand, weigh this extra sand base of the cell. Make sure there are no particles left. The
particle can cause a blockage on cell pressure pipes and
possibly damage the pressure controller
The sand loss should also be minimized, otherwise the density
of soil specimen will be overestimated Remove the mold and the sample is ready to be tested
Put another porous stone and the top pedestal. Gently lift the
membrane while holding the top cap in place Pg. 49 GEOTECHNICAL ANTGINEERING Pg. 51
Roll the o ring to the top pedestal and roll the excessive Connect the top cap to the back pressure
membrane around it. Make sure it’s really secured and no air or
water can go in. Use one more o ring to secure the membrane
Pg. 50
13
10/12/2021
Dip filter paper in the water to make sure it is Carefully lay the filter paper on top of saturated porous
saturated stone
Give a little water across the base and carefully slide the saturated porous stone Carefully place specimen on top of filter paper Saturate another circular filter paper and carefully
across the base pedestal so there is no air in the system place it on top of the specimen. Give a little water on
top of the filter paper so the specimen can fully
contact the paper and to eliminate as much air bubbles
as possible
14
10/12/2021
Put another saturated porous stone on top of the filter Put the loading cap on top of the stone
paper
Put filter paper strips all along the side of the specimen, from one
porous stone to another. This shorten the drainage path of the specimen
and make consolidation much faster. Bolton state that it can be up to
43 times faster than single drainage.
Side drains filter paper should not encroach within 10 mm of the lower
porous disc where pore pressure is measured, it would affect the
reading otherwise
15
10/12/2021
Use two O rings each to seal the membrane to the top and base pedestals. The O rings are stretched using a help of a ring
Put the membrane inside membrane stretcher. The membrane should be pulled around stretcher
evenly and not twisted.
Pull the membrane over the base and top Put the small O rings and pieces of tubing to the top Put the two tubes on the top pedestal
pedestal. pedestal
16
10/12/2021
CLOSING OFF THE TRIAXIAL CHAMBER SUMMARY THUS FAR – BASE SETUP
Pedestal
Put the top part of the triaxial cell. Triaxial cell after assembly
Put the connecting rods Porous stone
Make sure the piston has to be able to
go into the top cap Filter paper
Soil sample
17
10/12/2021
Vent line
O rings
Open the vent line on top of the cell so Fill the water outside the Remember that the system needs to be
Filter paper cage there is no pressure inside the cell saturated in order to get the correct
specimen until the cell is
full results.
So get as much air bubbles as possible out
Membrane of the system.
If there is a visible air bubble in the drains,
pump out more water to push off the air
O rings bubbles.
Obtain initial
reading
Cell cylindrical wall
Rod Loading
piston
Top
part
Measure the height of the sample. Push the piston gently until touching the top cap, don’t push it too hard
so the soil specimen is not damaged. With vernier caliper measure initial height and height after
consolidation
18
10/12/2021
TEST PROCEDURE OF TRIAXIAL CD • May take 5 working days to achieve with a clayey soil
Termination criteria After increasing the value of cell pressure and back pressure, open the pore
pressure valve.
• Test can be stopped when the soil specimen has failed If the pore pressure reading is close to the back pressure (10 – 20 kPa), close
• This usually corresponds to the maximum principal stress difference (for dense/overconsolidated both pore pressure and back pressure valves. Check the B-value of the specimen.
specimen)
If pore pressure reading is not close to the back pressure, continue to increase the
• Or at 15% axial strain (Bolton specifies 20%); (for loose/normally consolidated specimen, however, cell pressure and back pressure in increments of 35 – 140 kPa, keep the
dense/overconsolidated specimen can also be axially loaded to this level to obtain critical state) difference between cell pressure and back pressure at lower than 35 kPa.
Back pressure
Suitability of results
Pore pressure
• The shear strength obtained from this test can be used for embankment stability analysis, earth pressure
calculations, and foundation design Cell pressure
19
10/12/2021
To conduct B-value check, close the back pressure valve and drainage valve,
while keeping the pore pressure valve and cell pressure valve open. Increase the
cell pressure by 70 kPa and wait about 10-15 minutes, when the pore pressure no
longer changes, the current B-value can be calculated:
0 123/
B -+. /
0 /.. 13/44 3/
If the B-value is above 0.95, the soil specimen can be considered saturated.
If the B-value has not reached 0.95, close the pore pressure valve and reopen
the back pressure valve. Then repeat the saturation process on the previous
slide.
If the B-value is still less than 0.95 after several saturation process, it can be
considered saturated.
Back pressure
Pore pressure
Cell pressure
NOTES:
• After 2 mins determine and record maximum value of
the induced pore pressure
• Pore pressure may decrease after the immediate
response and then increase slightly with time, if this
occurs value of 0 should be plotted with time and the
asymptotic pore pressure used as the change in pore
pressure
• A large increase in 0 with time, or values of 0
greater than 0 3 indicate a leak of chamber fluid into
the specimen
• Decrease of 0 with time may indicate a leak in that
part of the pore pressure measurement system located
outside of the chamber
• Reapply the same effective consolidation stress as
existed prior to B-value measurement by reducing the
chamber pressure or by increasing the back pressure
Back pressure
Pore pressure
Cell pressure
20
10/12/2021
21
10/12/2021
22
10/12/2021
σ3 σ3
Shearing phase
• Vertical stress (deviatoric stress) is gradually increased until specimen fails. Take readings every
0.1% for the first 1% strain, then every 1% until termination criterion is reached.
• At this stage, drainage valve can either be opened or closed.
• Shearing rate for soil specimen is determined from the consolidation phase
σ1
σ3 σ3
JUST LIKE OEDOMETER, RECORD DATA AT INCREASING INTERVALS CONSOLIDATION AND SHEARING PROCESS
There are 2 distinct phases on any triaxial tests:
t (hour) t (min) Deformation
0.1 Isotropic consolidation phase
• Back pressure is closed, and cell pressure is increased.
0.25 • There is a confining stress all around the specimen and during this phase soil can be allowed to
consolidate or not consolidate depending on the test that is going to be performed.
0.5 σ3
1
2
4 σ3 σ3
8
0.25 15 Shearing phase
• Vertical stress (deviatoric stress) is gradually increased until specimen fails. Take readings every
0.5 30 0.1% for the first 1% strain, then every 1% until termination criterion is reached.
1 60 • At this stage, drainage valve can either be opened or closed.
• Shearing rate for soil specimen is determined from the consolidation
σ1 phase
2 120 Assuming that failure will occur at about 4%
4 240 axial strain, a suitable strain rate is
8%
8 480 • With side drain 67
%& :;
23
10/12/2021
SPECIMEN REMOVAL
Termination criteria
• Test can be stopped when the soil specimen has failed
• This usually corresponds to the maximum principal stress difference (for dense/overconsolidated
specimen)
• Or at 15% axial strain (Bolton specifies 20%); (for loose/normally consolidated specimen, however,
dense/overconsolidated specimen can also be axially loaded to this level to obtain critical state)
Suitability of results
• The shear strength obtained from this test can be used for embankment stability analysis, earth pressure
calculations, and foundation design. Suitable for soils that have been fully consolidated and sheared
Excerpt from Head (1989)
Pg. 94 quickly as well as soil in drained conditions. Pg. 96
24
10/12/2021
25
10/12/2021
SUMMARY OF TRIAXIAL UNCONSOLIDATED UNDRAINED TEST IT IS NOT ENOUGH JUST TO KNOW HOW TO DO THE TEST,
ASTM D2850 – 03a
WE NEED TO UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY ARE FOR
• The test is conducted on either intact or reconstituted specimen
• The specimen is mounted using either a dry or wet mounting procedure
• Specimen shape and dimensions are measured prior to mounting
• Test specimen is then back pressure saturated
• After saturation, the specimen is not allowed to drain
• The test specimen is then axially loaded at a constant rate with
• Drainage lines closed, no water is allowed to drain
• Instead, pore water pressure is measured (optional)
Termination criteria
• Test can be stopped when the soil specimen has failed
• This usually corresponds to the maximum principal stress difference (for dense/overconsolidated
specimen)
• Or at 15% axial strain
Suitability of results
• ASTM state that triaxial UU test is applicable to situations where the loads are assumed to take place so
rapidly that undrained loading occurs
Quoted from Atkinson (2007)
• It is not applicable when the loading condition differs from the test (i.e. slow loading conditions)
Pg. 101 Pg. 103
26
10/12/2021
Triaxial CU
• Vertical deformation
• Vertical load (deviatoric load)
• Pore water pressure measurement
Triaxial UU
Cui et al. (2017)
• Vertical deformation
• There is surface friction between the unlubricated ends of the test specimen, as well as at the end of the
• Vertical load (deviatoric load)
platen and the test apparatus
• This result in lateral and vertical restrain
Advanced measurement
• Therefore there is unequal deformation along the specimen, zero at the ends, maximum in the middle of
• It is also possible to measure small strain measurement, lateral deformation and local axial deformation of the specimen
soil using Hall Effect or LVDT local strain transducers
• For soil specimen with a height to diameter ratio of 2, the middle third of the specimen is more or less
unrestrained
27
10/12/2021
INTERPRETATION OF TRIAXIAL CD
https://www.gdsinstruments.com/__assets__/Products/00035/
Hall-Effect-and-LVDT_datasheet.pdf Pg. 109
=
>
28
10/12/2021
CONVERTING RAW DATA – LOAD ON SPECIMEN CONVERTING RAW DATA – LOAD ON SPECIMEN
• The raw data obtained from our triaxial test is load • Then we can use the new area = + Δ= to calculate the corrected deviatoric stress
• You may remember that what we need is stress A< ΔA
= + Δ=
• One may think, we can simply divide the load by the area of the soil specimen, Q/A > Δ>
? ?
FG
The strain is simply 6%
G
= =
> > Δ> > > Δ>
= + Δ= = + Δ=
ΔA ΔA
• But we need to remember that the soil specimen deforms as it is loaded, i.e. area increases
?
• If we measure the lateral/radial deformation directly, it is easy to do the correction C
(= + Δ=)
• If no lateral strain measured, change in area ∆A, must be inferred from the measurements of the changes
?
in length (∆H) and volume change (∆V) C (> Δ>)
A< ΔA
CONVERTING RAW DATA – LOAD ON SPECIMEN CONVERTING RAW DATA – LOAD ON SPECIMEN
• Let’s first define the initial (V0) and final volume after loading (Vf), followed by the volume change • Then we can use the new area = + Δ= to calculate the corrected deviatoric stress
A< =>; AB = + Δ= > Δ> A< ΔA
= + Δ=
ΔA A< AB > Δ>
? ?
= =
> > Δ> > > Δ>
= + Δ= = + Δ=
ΔA ΔA
• Putting the equations together, we get
?
ΔA => = + Δ= > Δ> C
(= + Δ=)
= + Δ= > Δ> => ΔA
?
=> ΔA A< ΔA C (> Δ>)
= + Δ= A< ΔA
> Δ> > Δ>
Initial measurement of sample
29
10/12/2021
CONVERTING RAW DATA – LOAD ON SPECIMEN STRESS-STRAIN CURVE & VOLUME CHANGE
H
• Then we can use the new area = + Δ= to calculate the corrected deviatoric stress • Now let’s plot the volume change vs. axial strain chart as void
HJ!K
A< ΔA ratio (/) vs. axial strain (6% )
= + Δ= • Obviously the trend/shape of the graph for both loose
> Δ>
sand/normally consolidated clay and dense
? sand/overconsolidated clay will be the same
• They will just have different starting points, instead of 0
6% • The loose sand will have higher initial void ratio while;
• The dense sand will have lower void ratio
+ΔA
• When they reached a certain level of shear strain, both dense
=
> > Δ> and loose soil will reach approximately the same void ratio
STRESS-STRAIN CURVE & VOLUME CHANGE STRESS-STRAIN CURVE & VOLUME CHANGE
H H
• There is two typical stress-strain (H 6% ) curve obtained • Now let’s take a look at the particles to explain the
HJ!K HJ!K
from triaxial CD test contraction & dilation, as well as why there is peak strength
• For loose sand or normally consolidated clay, the shear stress
will gradually increase as the soil is strained, until no more
increase in shear stress can be observed with further increase
in strain
• For dense sand or overconsolidated clay, the shear stress will
6% increase until it reached a peak (HJ!K ), then gradually 6% • For loose sand, the particles start in loose arrangement, and
decreases until no more decrease in shear stress can be shearing results in contraction
+ΔA +ΔA
observed with further increase in strain • For dense sand, the particles start in tighter arrangement,
• For the same material, e.g. the same sand, the shear stress there is some ‘interlocking’ among particles, as the soil is
which no more change can be observed with further straining sheared, the particles overcome the interlocking and dilates,
will approximately be equal resulting in increase in volume
6% 6%
• Now let’s take a look at the volume change (ΔA) versus axial
strain (6% ) chart • Obviously the loose sand particles cannot contract forever;
-ΔA -ΔA likewise the dense sand particles cannot dilate forever.
• For loose sand or normally consolidated clay, the soil volume
continues to contract (volume reduction) until it reaches a / Otherwise loose sand will become dense sand, and dense sand
point where further straining cause no more volume change will become loose sand.
• For dense sand or over consolidated clay, the soil volume • The soil will reach a state whereby the particles just slide
initially contracts, then the soil starts to dilate (volume across one another, resulting in no more change in volume,
increase) as it is further sheared. The soil continues to dilate void ratio as well as shear stress
until it reaches a point where further straining cause no more • This state is critical state, and very fundamental behaviour of
volume change soil
30
10/12/2021
6% M + ΔM γ0.7 6%
> > Δ> • One obvious choice is to derive its maximum value, i.e. at the very beginning of the shearing
+ΔA
• This modulus corresponds to small strain shear modulus (G0), also named as maximum shear modulus (Gmax)
• As previously mentioned, this parameter is very important for a more accurate serviceability analysis, as well as
dynamic loading response
6% • In PLAXIS, in addition to maximum shear modulus, another necessary parameter for HSS model is γ0.7, the threshold
ΔM Δ> shear strain where the shear modulus of soil is 0.722 of G0
6 ;6
-ΔA M % > • To obtain the threshold modulus, we need to obtain secant modulus corresponding to 0.722 of G0 value
6L 6
/ - ; - 6% 6
6% 6% • Do note that we will require readings at very high resolution (advanced measurement) as well as automatic data
Since acquisition to obtain accurate G0 value
6L 6% + 6 + 6 6% + 26 • Remember that the maximum shear modulus happens at strain below 0.05%, while the first manual reading is taken at
0.1% strain
It means that
6L 6% 26%- 6% 1 2-
6L
O3+PQ/RS 1 2-
6% 6% Pg. 122 GEOTECHNICAL ANTGINEERING Pg. 124
31
10/12/2021
0.5 HJ!K
6% 6%
• When we use Mohr Coulomb constitutive model in PLAXIS, the notation used for the modulus is E50, what does • To obtain shear strength parameters, we use the Mohr’s Coulomb failure criterion
the 50 mean?
• We draw semi-circles of major principal stress ( % ) and minor principal stress ( )
• The 50 means 50% of the maximum shear strength H
• First draw a horizontal line corresponding to the maximum shear stress (HJ!K ) obtained during the test or !"
• Next draw a horizontal line corresponding to half of maximum shear stress (0.5 HJ!K )
• Finally draw a secant modulus at the intersection between 0.5 HJ!K and stress-strain curve
• Then draw the best fit tangent just touching the three Mohr circles
• The angle of this tangent is friction angle, while the vertical intercept is cohesion
• Depending on the choice of % (either at critical state or peak), we can obtain & or !" & !"
E50ref 100 *+
50 *+
6%
•
•
When we conduct triaxial tests, we conduct the test at least three times at three different confining pressures
Will we obtain the same modulus for all different confining pressures?
INTERPRETATION OF TRIAXIAL CU
• Obviously not!
• Remember that soil is stress dependent materials, and its stiffness is very much dependent on the confining
pressure of soil
• To take into account the difference in stiffness at different confining pressure, PLAXIS offers the hardening soil
model, and its modulus parameter is named E50ref
• The ref refers to reference confining pressure, by default this is set at 100 kPa (the users are free to modify this)
• For Mohr Coulomb modulus (E50), the user has to manually adjust the stiffness depending on the soil’s depth
• In hardening soil model, this is done automatically
32
10/12/2021
33
10/12/2021
https://slideplayer.com/slide/5935048/
4$
INTERPRETATION OF TRIAXIAL UU
UZ [U\
• The undrained shear strength is half of the deviatoric stress applied 4$ , and $ 0
• As the soil specimen is not consolidated prior to shearing, for a soil sample that has perfect saturation, i.e. Sr =
100%, during the increasing of cell pressure stage, all the additional confining pressure is taken by the pore water
pressure, hence the soil’s effective stress is identical
• But often, soil tested is not in perfect saturation Sr < 100%, hence there will be some consolidation occurring
during the increasing of cell pressure stage
• This gives an apparent friction angle and cohesion, however, the results does not reflect the real soil behaviour
34
10/12/2021
Head (1998)
Head (1998)
GEOTECHNICAL ANTGINEERING Pg. 137 Pg. 139
L
• Stiffness parameters: v, E, E50, E50ref, G0, γ0.7
• Strength parameters: , , !" , !" , #, cu, $ , su
]
• Raw data is very important, owner can request for the raw data to be provided and laboratory has no
L
rights to refuse
] • However, laboratory can opt not to supply their interpretation methods
• Owner hired consultants can conduct their own interpretation
• The soil samples we take are under a certain confining pressure, depending on their depth
• We have learnt about dilation and critical state
• When we take the samples out of the ground, it undergoes unloading
• Critical state is the state of soil in which further shearing does not induce anymore change in shear
• If we do not reapply the same confining pressure as it was in the field, the behaviour obtained from laboratory
will not be representative to what will happen in the field stress, volume and void ratio
• As demonstrated by the effect of stiffness under different confining pressures
• Thus one of the three test conducted should have a confining pressure equal to: • We have also learnt about stress dependent stiffness
vertical stress in the soil = unit weight x depth – pore water pressure (if any) • It is important to know the stress level the soil is at in the field, before and after construction
• If undrained shear strength is required, it is better to conduct field measurement instead, e.g. vane shear test • This is to ensure relevant modulus are used for design
35
10/12/2021
EXTRA NOTES ON TRIAXIAL TESTING (CD, CU, UU) EXTRA NOTES ON TRIAXIAL TESTING BY BOLTON
Extra Notes
• The results produced by following this standard is dependent on the competence of the personnel
performing it
• As well as the suitability of the equipment and facilities used
• Agencies that meet the criteria of practice in ASTM D3740 are generally considered capable of competent
and objective testing/sampling/inspection
• Compliance with ASTM D3740 practice, however, does not assure reliable results
• Reliable results depend on many factors & ASTM D3740 can only evaluate some of those factors
36
10/12/2021
37
10/12/2021
38