Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
Blockchain or Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) is a disruptive technology that has
revolutionized the creation and management of digital assets, mainly user data involved
in transactions. The advent of Web 3.0 and other technologies can change how digital and
financial transactions are made using the Internet. This review paper takes forward the
discussion done in Manda & Polisetty, 2018. It appraises the recent developments in the
adoption of technology in India and the progress made so far, especially from 2018-2022.
The paper also discusses barriers and challenges of technology adoption hampering its
penetration in India. The review considers the Government and its policies, Regulators and
their regulation, Public Institutions and the infrastructure set up, and private institutions
(especially startups) and how they build next-generation distributed applications that take
advantage of Blockchain. The insight that the paper will offer to Academic researchers
and other stakeholders regarding the recent developments in the adoption of blockchain
technology is the proposed contribution of the literature review on this topic.
Keywords: Cyber infrastructure, capacity building, blockchain projects, financial transactions
JEL Classification: O33, O14, O38
Recent Trends in Blockchain Adoption in India 55
INTRODUCTION
The Fourth Industrial Revolution focused on the theme of Cyber-Physical Systems (Figure 1 shows
various sub-themes encircling the broad theme). It includes Digitalization/Integration of value
chains, Digitalization/Integration of Product and Service Offerings, and Digital Business Models
and Customer Access. Technology advancements in transactional data storage aided with strong
encryption have led to emerging technologies such as Blockchain. Blockchain falls under Digital
Business Models and Customer Access -> Authentication & Fraud Detection as per Shockoe.
There are real societal implications of Blockchain technology adoption (Figure 2). As per World
Economic Forum (WEF), Blockchain falls under Agency and Trust systems.
Blockchain in India made some progress as the technology is getting accepted by the
Governments and the Industry. This research article is an update to our earlier research work
(Manda & Polisetty, 2018). Though cryptocurrencies are discouraged, the underlying Blockchain
technology should be embraced owing to the numerous revolutionary positive disruptions it will
cause for the country. Blockchain Use-Cases such as Know Your Customer (KYC) and Anti-Money
Laundering (AML) are classical beneficial implementations. Further, the Indian Central Bank – the
Reserve Bank of India (RBI) wishes to launch its own Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC)
called Digital Rupee, thanks to the inspiration it received from the Government of India through
the Union Budget.
Not just the Governments and corporations but startups too are embracing Blockchain. 5ire, a
sustainable blockchain startup, raised $100 million in Series A funding, making its valuation $1.5
billion and a unicorn. The startup is into rewarding validators and creditors for taking sustainable
actions (Eetika, 2022).
India has already explored Blockchain use-cases and developed into Proof of Concept
(PoC) in areas such as e-KYC Document Management which is an inevitable and mandatory
compliance requirement, Trade Finance Cross-border Payments, Supply Chain Financing (such
as in automobiles and tracing parts back to auto ancillary companies), and Employee Loyalty/
Rewards, among others (Deloitte-ASSOCHAM, 2017). Considerable progress has been made in
the public sector – specifically in Land registration, Digital certificates, and Customs duty payment
(Deloitte-FICCI, 2018). Digital assets and the underlying blockchain technology are a strategic
priority, according to a 2021 global survey of participants in the financial services industry from
different countries. Eighty percent of respondents from various services who participated in a
survey stated that blockchain technology is essential to their business models (Deloitte, 2021).
While the Cryptotech Industry in India is still in its infancy, NASSCOM feels that the industry is
fast growing, driven by Bitcoin, DeFi, and Crypto Capital, and is poised to grow 2X faster, creating
800k+ jobs by 2030 (NASSCOM, 2021). The demand for Indian professionals is growing despite
a global slowdown in talent hiring. Companies like Binance have officially welcomed the Indian
Web 3.0 community to come and join their workforce.
56 Adaptation of Technological Advancement in India
Source: Shockoe
Figure 1: The evolution of the Fourth Industrial Revolution
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
This study uses scholarly articles, books, and other relevant sources to study the recent trends in
adopting blockchain technology. The study gathers available information, observes the technology
developments and the adoption that happened so far, records the observations, and describes the
derived benefits from such technology implementations. Keywords were used to filter relevant
Recent Trends in Blockchain Adoption in India 57
information from journals, research papers, websites, official websites of various companies and
other agencies, and annual reports.
DISCUSSION
According to the research, the digital market is steadily gaining speed with rising trends around the
world, and most developing and well-established countries dominate the sector of cryptocurrencies
and blockchain technology. According to the Blockchain Council, the top 10 countries that have
adopted blockchain technology are Japan, China, Lebanon, Switzerland, South Africa, United
Kingdom, Singapore, Bahamas, United States, and Estonia. India’s demographic dividend makes
the country a potential market for early blockchain adoption. The examples cited in the paper are
the PoC or early adoptions of Blockchain in India.
TRADE FINANCING
Indian banks have learned lessons from the past and recent frauds related to trade financing. In the
case of Nirav Modi and Mehul Choksi, about US$4 billion was fraudulently siphoned off from
Punjab National Bank by obtaining Letters of Undertaking for making payments to international
vendors. The events necessitated the need for improved security and transparency of transactions
in trade financing. The RBI Innovation Hub, Bengaluru, started a blockchain pilot solution that can
prevent loan fraud (Saikat, 2022). A PoC trial involved prestigious banks such as the State Bank
of India, HDFC Bank, ICICI Bank, Axis Bank, Bank of Baroda, and Union Bank of India. The
technology solutions are provided by SettleMint of Belgium, US-based Corda Technologies, and
IBM. The overall objective of this pilot run is to see how Blockchain fits into the Core Banking
System (CBS) of banks in India.
IIT Kanpur and NIT Rourkela are the first two educational institutions to be offering Blockchain-
based Digital Degrees. These institutions offer hardcopy certificates as well as digital certificates.
The digital certificates are tamper-proof and can be verified easily, thereby drastically reducing the
time required to confirm the originality of a degree certificate. IIT Kanpur introduced this at its 54th
convocation ceremony held in December 2021, while NIT Rourkela implemented this at the 19th
Convocation in August 2022.
The Maharashtra State Board of Skill Development (MSBSD) and Maharashtra State Innovation
Society (MSINS) used the Polygon-LegitDoc platform to issue blockchain-based diplomas.
The Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) expressed interest in implementing
a blockchain-based system for the issue of student results certificates. With this success, many
other Certification agencies and Educational institutions will consider coming forward to issue
Blockchain-based certificates, thereby simplifying the certificate verification system.
The Indian taxation system is a deterrent and punitive when investing and speculating crypto
assets. A broad term called – Virtual Digital Assets (VDA) – is used to encompass all forms of
cryptocurrencies within the tax ambit. Cryptocurrencies, NFTs, and other Virtual Digital Assets
(VDAs) are various Use-Cases of Blockchain. The proposed taxation system in India has placed
cryptocurrency gains under a deterrent tax structure in the Finance Bill 2022. Tax authorities are
seen asking banks and exchanges for transaction logs and even want them to update the Annual
Information Statement (AIS) records. Actor Amitabh Bachchan had to pay Rs. 1.09 crores as Goods
and Services Tax (GST) for the sale of NFTs worth Rs. 7.15 crores. A tax notice was issued by the
Directorate General of Goods and Services Tax Intelligence (DGGI). The existing tax systems
involving cryptocurrencies and NFTs are complex and deterrent in nature - more discouraging to
both traders and the cryptoexchanges.
The RBI supported the ban on cryptocurrencies considering they would lead to systemic risk in
the country and “dollarisation of the economy”. The RBI has placed Cryptocurrencies as a General
Risk (medium category) with a score of 4.4 as of May 2022 (RBI, 2022). As a technology, RBI is
keen on issuing Digital Rupee – the CBDC, and facilitating banks and financial institutions to test
the technology in applications such as trade finance (discussed above) and cross-border transaction
time. The CBDC policy will also impact the monetary policy and transmission time. There is little
or no experience in CBDT, even at the global level, but this area will see many developments shortly
(Auer & Böhme, 2020). The academic research literature on this topic is slowly building (Carapella
& Flemming, 2020). RBI Executive Director, in February 2022, hinted that technology choices
are open for them. They opined that the digital rupee need not necessarily be on the Blockchain
and that RBI treading is ‘carefully’ on its CBDC experiment and has not involved any external
agencies; thus far in its development. The RBI has not given any specific deadlines for the roll-out
of the digital rupee but accepted that it will be in line with the March 2023 deadline shared with
Sitharaman.
Shaktikanta Das, the Governor of the RBI, believes that technology-based businesses like
blockchain platforms and decentralized finance (DeFi) require a globally coordinated regulatory
approach (Animesh, 2022). The Indian Finance Minister stressed to “exercise caution” and that it
“will not take a rushed decision” but called upon global coordination for regulating cryptocurrencies
to protect investors. Global coordination is necessary for the sake of compliance required with the
Financial Action Task Force (FATF). FATF works as a coordinated response to prevent organized
crime, corruption, and terrorism. Cryptocurrencies are criticized for being the most preferred payment
source in cases of global crimes. Several countries are struggling with this regulatory ambiguity,
while few successfully took sides and either adopted or partially banned them (Karisma, 2022).
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) began investigating the top ten Indian cryptocurrency
exchanges in August 2022. Bank assets of Wazirx ware froze, and the relationship between Wazirx
and Binance ruptured. The deterrent taxation system and the not-so-accommodative business
environment for cryptocurrency exchanges have made Blockchain in India begin on the wrong
foot, experts believe (Pradipta, 2022) and that the need of the hour is progressive regulation for
crypto assets (Rajesh, 2022).
62 Adaptation of Technological Advancement in India
The National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) oversees India’s retail payment and
settlement systems and has begun experimenting with blockchain technology. Vajra is one such
platform it has built (Tarush, 2020). NPCI has already tasted success with its UPI and RuPay
ideas and is heading to the next level of the fight against global leaders such as Visa, MasterCard,
and Amex. The distributed features of Blockchain can ensure near-zero downtime, and NPCI will
benefit from its journey towards the internationalization of its ideas.
The Indian capital market regulator - the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) -
made it clear that all assets cannot be considered securities and that crypto assets are a tokenized
form of assets. Therefore, the tokens issued on those assets also cannot be construed as securities.
SEBI is, however, keen about embracing Blockchain as a technology and has released a few
related regulations. It issued the Operational Guidelines for Security and Covenant Monitoring
using Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) in March 2022. The regulation is aimed at further
strengthening the process of security creation, monitoring of security created, monitoring of asset
cover and covenants of the non-convertible securities by Debenture Trustee using blockchain
technology (Operational Guidelines for ‘Security and Covenant Monitoring’ Using Distributed
Ledger Technology, 2022).
Internet of Things (IoT) in March 2020. IIM Ahmedabad has included Bitcoin and Blockchain topics
as a PGP course elective in the Finance & Accounting stream. IIT Kharagpur launched a 12-week
free online training program, while IIT Kanpur offers a four-month certification program. Apart
from these formal institutions, several informal online edtechs and offline, face-to-face training
institutes have begun offering coding programs to write smart contracts and build distributed apps.
UpGrad has tied up with leading institutions such as IIIT Bangalore, Purdue University, Liverpool
John Moores University, and California Institute of Technology (CalTech). Few formal institutions
also tied up with edtechs for other training formats such as boot camps. A 138% increase in learners
was reported on Edtech platforms from March 2021 to March 2022 (Vikram, 2022). Unlike
other technology courses aimed at bridging the skill gap of already qualified software engineers,
blockchain courses are seeing interest for 12-month and 18-month Masters’ programs. Blockchain is
peering up with other technologies such as Metaverse and Web 3.0 as a course offering considering
the future potential of these technology trio. More institutions across all industries/sectors have to
come forward to explore how all can best absorb the technology advantages.
CONCLUSION
India is a highly populous country, has a rich technology talent pool, and is home to some of the
best startups working in emerging and disruptive technologies such as Blockchain, Metaverse, and
Web 3.0. Governments love to ‘maximize governance, minimize government,’ and Blockchain is
crucial in facilitating such an agenda. Thanks to the Blockchain strategy, the technology is poised
for faster adoption in the country. Society is beginning to reap some of the early benefits from the
public adoption put in place so far. Regulators are considering using Blockchain and/or Distributed
Ledger Technology (DLT). However, cryptocurrencies in India, like in many other countries in
world, face regulatory ambiguity. The transactions involving cryptocurrency as a trading/investing
asset have to face a tax burden that demotivates their usage. The industry lacks a representative
body to take up the issues they face and take the blockchain agenda forward. More academic
institutions should start offering technology courses and programs to penetrate awareness levels.
India will be able to make more Blockchain professionals when more academic institutions come
forward with formal and informal courses and training programs.
REFERENCES
• Animesh, S. (2022, June 17). Blockchain Regulation Requires Global Coordination: RBI
Governor. https://www.ndtv.com/business/blockchain-regulation-requires-global-coordination-
rbi-governor-3075246
• Auer, R., & Böhme, R. (2020). The Technology of Retail Central Bank Digital Currency. BIS
Quarterly Review. https://ssrn.com/abstract=3561198
• Carapella, F., & Flemming, J. (2020). Central Bank Digital Currency: A Literature Review. FEDS
Notes, 2020(2790). https://doi.org/10.17016/2380-7172.2790
64 Adaptation of Technological Advancement in India
• Deloitte. (2021). Deloitte’s 2021 Global Blockchain Survey: A new age of digital assets (Deloitte
Insights, p. 28). https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/insights/articles/US144337_Blockchain-
survey/DI_Blockchain-survey.pdf
• Deloitte-ASSOCHAM. (2017). Blockchain technology in India: Opportunities and challenges.
https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/in/Documents/strategy/in-strategy-innovation-
blockchain-technology-india-opportunities-challenges-noexp.pdf
• Deloitte-FICCI. (2018). Blockchain in Public Sector: Transforming government services
through exponential technologies. https://www2.deloitte.com/in/en/pages/public-sector/articles/
blockchain-in-public-sector.html
• Eetika, K. (2022, July 15). Indian ‘green’ blockchain startup raises $100 million, turns unicorn
in a crypto bear market. Business Insider India. https://www.businessinsider.in/cryptocurrency/
news/indian-green-blockchain-startup-raises-100-million-turns-unicorn-in-a-crypto-bear-market/
articleshow/92850567.cms
• FE Online. (2022, May 10). The India Blockchain Accelerator shortlists 14 early-stage startups
for its mentorship and financing program. Financial Express. https://www.financialexpress.
com/digital-currency/the-india-blockchain-accelerator-shortlists-14-early-stage-startups-for-its-
mentorship-and-financing-program/2519343/
• IBA. (2022). Indian Blockchain Alliance. https://indiablockchainalliance.org/
• Karisma, K. (2022). Comparative Review of the Regulatory Framework of Cryptocurrency
in Selected Jurisdictions: In P. M. Tehrani (Ed.), Advances in Computational Intelligence and
Robotics (pp. 82–111). IGI Global. https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-7927-5.ch005
• Manda, V. K., & Polisetty, A. (2018). Status Check on Blockchain Implementations in India. SSRN
Electronic Journal. https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3265654
• MeitY. (2021). National Strategy on Blockchain (p. 52). Ministry of Electronics and Information
Technology.
• NASSCOM. (2021). Cryptotech Industry in India: Decentralized Systems at the Centerstage of
digital evolution. NASSCOM. https://nasscom.in/knowledge-center/publications/cryptotech-
industry-india-decentralized-systems-center-stage-digital
• Pradipta, M. (2022, August 4). Blockchain in India got off on wrong foot, says former finance
chief. Forkast. https://forkast.news/blockchain-in-india-got-off-on-wrong-foot/
• Rajesh, B. (2022, July 25). India needs to have progressive regulation for crypto assets: Experts.
Business Standard. https://www.business-standard.com/article/markets/india-needs-to-have-
progressive-regulation-for-crypto-assets-experts-122072500743_1.html
• RBI. (2022). Financial Stability Report (No. 25). Reserve Bank of India. https://www.rbi.org.in
• Reddy, Y. V. (2010). Financial Sector Regulation in India. Economic and Political Weekly, 45(14),
40,45-50.
• Saikat, D. (2022, June 23). RBI taps top lenders to run Blockchain Pilot. Economic Times.
• Operational guidelines for ‘Security and Covenant Monitoring’ using Distributed Ledger
Technology (DLT), SEBI/ HO/ MIRSD/ CRADT/ CIR/ P/ 2022/ 3 (2022).
Recent Trends in Blockchain Adoption in India 65
• Som, L., & Faisal, N. (2017). Regulatory policy in India: Moving towards regulatory governance
(OECD Regulatory Policy Working Papers No. 8; OECD Regulatory Policy Working Papers,
Vol. 8). OECD. https://doi.org/10.1787/b335b35d-en
• Tarush, B. (2020, January 7). NPCI to adopt blockchain-based system ‘Vajra’ to secure online
payments. https://yourstory.com/2020/01/npci-blockchain-based-system-vajra-digital-payments/
amp
• Vikram, C. (2022, April 25). Increased interest in blockchain-related courses. Financial Express.
• Yatti, S. (2022, March 31). Bengaluru startup LegitDoc helps Maharashtra issuing caste certificates
via Blockchain. Business Line. https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/news/national/bengaluru-
startup-legitdoc-helps-maharashtra-to-issue-caste-certificates-via-blockchain/article65274041.ece
qqq