Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
Satya Nandini Arjunan and Introduction
Minu Zachariah are both
Any visitor who walks in to the premises of Avaneetha Textiles is sure to experience a sense
PAGE 506 j THE CASE JOURNAL j VOL. 18 NO. 3 2022, pp. 506-530, © Emerald Publishing Limited, ISSN 1544-9106 DOI 10.1108/TCJ-10-2021-0198
eight spindles and manufactured yarn with his personal investment. As the capacity of his
looms expanded to 100 spindles, he started his first spinning unit in 1995, KPR Mills, in
Sathyamangalam (a small town in Tamil Nadu). This unit initially had male and female
workers on the shop floor which were supported with hostel facilities. During that time, there
were two incidents that caused KPR to reflect upon and revise his business model.
He observed that while the male workers were actively involved in union activities, the
female workers were hardly concerned about them. The other incident occurred during one
of his routine factory visits. He noticed a young female worker on the shop floor, who came
to him with tears in her eyes. As he had a natural concern for his employees, he could not
stop enquiring about the reason for her unhappiness. Talking to her, he understood that the
girl was unhappy because she could not continue her studies in spite of getting good marks
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
in her 10th standard, as her family was poor and depended on her earnings for sustenance.
She requested him if he could help her continue with her studies while being employed.
KPR was deeply moved by the girl’s situation, which he thought could be the plight of many
other girls working in his mill.
Such incidents ignited a thought-provoking question for KPR, “Can I do something to
educate such underprivileged young women?” His genuine concern for his workers made
The deep interest of his young female employees in pursuing further education and their
Copyright encoded A76HM-JUJ9K-PJMN9I
sincerity at work without being distracted made KPR think of helping them and come out
with an innovative business model for combining work and education. He decided to recruit
girls for his factory, who were school dropouts so that he could provide them employment
as well as education. He was convinced that the education they acquire while on this job
would support their lives in general and future careers in this company or elsewhere. This
was how the “women-only” employees’ business model came into existence and was
applied by Avaneetha Textiles as well.
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
facilities and the work environment at Avaneetha Textiles by playing videos. The recruitment
process was conducted every month, initially, from the rural areas of Tamil Nadu. Later, as
the company’s recruitment policies became well-known among the villagers, the referral
system was further extended to neighbouring states. For instance, the mill hired women
from the Northeast who came through contacts. At any point in time, the mill had about 900
women workers available, of which about 850 were allotted work. The company preferred to
dropouts and those who successfully completed Grades 10 or 12. However, these
candidates were further enquired about whether or not they would be interested in
continuing their education. Those interested in higher education were given more
preference because it was easy for the company to enrol them for the respective higher
levels of education. The company aimed to improve their career prospects regardless of
their decision to stay in or quit the job.
Kalpana did not insist on getting any bond signed by the workers in return for the training
imparted to them for their job or education. Right after joining, the women were trained for a
month in the specific processes involved in their respective jobs, after which they would be
deployed on their actual jobs. There were six main processes involved in making yarn from
cotton (Exhibit 3). Some processes were to be performed on tall machines, which could be
operated only by relatively tall women. Hence, women workers were assigned to different
tasks based on physical requirements for a particular job.
permitted their daughters to stay, work and continue their education at the firm.
Furthermore, satisfied women workers spread the word about their work, training and
accommodation facilities which in turn attracted more and more women to this type of job
and life.
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
their friends and relatives when necessary. This was in sharp contrast with the practice in
other spinning units, where mobile phones were not permitted on the campus. The hostel
mess had a big dining hall and a fixed menu for each day (Exhibit 4).
A food committee was constituted with residents as members particularly responsible for
deciding on what a healthy and balanced diet must contain. Based on the suggestions of
the residents, changes were periodically incorporated to the menu. As the production unit
was functioning for 24 h, the mess served different meals for different parts of the day. For
The new recruits were allotted to hostel rooms in such a way that there were senior workers/
Copyright encoded A76HM-JUJ9K-PJMN9I
students in each room to guide them. Each floor had an in-charge who worked along with
the wardens and the volunteers. Although facilities such as a grievance team and a
suggestion box were made available for the residents, they did not report any major
problems or issues till date.
The hostel also had a recreational area for extra circular activities with necessary equipment
and trainers to coach women workers on sports and games of their interest. Moreover,
competitions were organized every year by the KPR Group, and employees of Avaneetha
Textiles competed with the employees of the various units of KPR Mills. Besides sports and
games training, the company was providing Yoga lessons for its workers. The other facilities
available on the campus were a library, a super market and a bank with ATM facility. The
campus was always bustling with activities, which included the celebration of all the local
festivals.
However, during the COVID-19 pandemic, all the women workers were instructed to remain
in the hostel and follow social distancing norms to the maximum extent possible. Although
work at the mill was halted during the lockdown due to the pandemic, all women workers
were paid regularly.
to the Tamil Nadu Minimum Wages Act. The cost-to-company (CTC) was INR 14,500
(approximately US$200) per month per employee inclusive of PF, ESI, and bonus. However,
education was free of cost and was not included in the CTC. However, the company made it
mandatory that the women paid 50% of the examination fees with a view to ensuring their
commitment towards studies.
Although the women were given a one-day weekly off, those above 18 were permitted to
leave the premises between 6 a.m. and 6 p.m., and those between 16 and 18 years of age
could leave the premises only if they were accompanied with their parents. The yearly
leaves amounted to a total of 25 days of which 16 days were optional and could be availed
at the rate of 8 days every 6 months. The remaining 9 days were kept aside for national and
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
local holidays. In addition to these, the women enrolled for various courses were granted
study leave of 5 days before their examinations as well as leave for the exam-days.
Medical facilities
The hostel also had a nursing station that was open for 24 h, where a doctor was available
on alternate days (Exhibit 6). Sanitary napkins were available in vending machines and
academic courses. For instance, some of the new recruits who dropped out in primary or
middle school chose not to continue their studies even though there was a provision for
them to get directly enrolled for Grade 10. Therefore, to Kalpana’s dismay, only around 30%
of the recruits enrolled themselves for further studies (Table 2). Among those registered,
about one third opted for vocational training programs related to tailoring, handicrafts, etc.
instead of academic courses. Kalpana tried to encourage them to enrol for academic
courses but she could not force them, as she was afraid if they would choose to quit.
Although only a few women workers that selected academic courses of their interest were
successfully able to complete their education, there were about one third of students who
discontinued. This was due to the inability to cope up with work and academic stress while
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
others were forced into marriage by their parents before they could complete their courses.
䊏 Cash-prize of INR 25,000 (US$344) for those securing marks in the range of
1,100–1,149 out of 1,200 in the Grade 12 exams.
䊏 Cash-prize of INR 1, 00,000 (US$1,378) for those securing 1,150 or more marks out of
1,200 in the Grade 12 exams.
This strategy was very successful in motivating and creating interest in women workers
towards education. For instance, a women worker secured 1,149 marks and requested for
the prize money, although she deserved only INR 25,000 as per norms, the management
was magnanimous enough to give her the higher prize money of INR 1, 00,000.
Transformed lives
Kalpana was pleased to notice the development of positive attitude and behaviors in
women workers after being absorbed into the firm. Being relocated to the hostel from their
rural areas, they were not familiar with the basic etiquette of urban life. They had to be
trained in various aspects of community living including table manners, dressing styles and
the use of restrooms. In general, it was observed that the women were able to quickly
mingle and socialize with each other, and that some understood the value of education for
the development of their personality and identity.
2015–2016 698 35 24 39 1 30 39
2016–2017 789 13 22 55 4 30 37
2017–2018 587 31 25 87 5 44 58
2018–2019 545 19 15 70 5 34 43
2019–2020 406 12 11 94 6 55 53
Source: Anand, Kalpana. “Re: Information required.” Received by Sasikala HR, 08 February 2021. Email interview
Graduation
As soon as the women workers completed their courses, Kalpana encouraged them to
search for better job prospects elsewhere. However, they were welcome to continue
working at Avaneetha Textiles for as long as they want. For instance, women workers
continued to work at the mill for around 2–5 years. However, the longest ever term served by
a women worker in the company was 9 years, who was recruited at 19. She pursued an
undergraduate course and MBA during her tenure and is currently working as a caretaker/
manager at the hostel. Usually, the girls would work with the mill up to a maximum of
25 years of age, by when they would be married off. So far, no one continued to work at the
mill after getting married as they would have to shift to different locations. Since 2008,
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
Avaneetha Textiles has transformed lives of 698 women workers that have successfully
graduated from various courses (Table 3).
Employment
After graduation from their respective courses, the women were given an opportunity to
undergo placement training. Even without such additional training, their newly acquired
Although it may appear that this innovative business model of “stay, work, study, and leave”
was beneficial only to the underprivileged women workers, it was equally lucrative for the
firm. For instance, the “women-only” employees’ business model was largely constructive in
completely eliminating the union activities in the factory.
As far as the efficiency at the mill was concerned, there was no difference between male
and female workers. However, with the innovative business model in place, there were
significant increase in efficiency and productivity due to lack of distractions due to union-
related activities. Another reason for the increase in productivity was the creation of a
residential worksite, which contributed to the minimization (rather than elimination) of
absenteeism at work, as the only reason for being absent was common illnesses. Moreover,
the model of combining work and study had a salutary impact on the attrition rates, as many
2008–2009 20
2009–2010 25
2010–2011 54
2011–2012 33
2012–2013 51
2013–2014 37
2014–2015 68
2015–2016 83
2016–2017 75
2017–2018 107
2018–2019 70
2019–2020 75
Source: Anand, Kalpana. “Re: Information required.” Received by Sasikala HR, 08 February 2021.
Email interview
were driven to complete their courses. The incentive for quitting abruptly was low even for
those not enrolled for courses, as they were from underprivileged backgrounds in need of a
job.
Furthermore, this business model was efficient in reducing labour-related costs. For
instance, as workers leave within 5 years, a new set of people were appointed at the junior-
most level and therefore, the wages were paid at the lowest rates. The company saved on
salary and increments at higher rates, as only a few continue their term beyond 5 years.
Consequently, their cost on gratuity payments was also minimal. All in all, Kalpana believed
that this business model provided a win–win strategy for both the employees and the
employer. On the social front, it has the salutary impact of promoting women empowerment
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
and gender equity.
aspirational value, and so they would buy one with their first month’s salary, however, in a
Copyright encoded A76HM-JUJ9K-PJMN9I
matter of time they got addicted to and distracted from it. It was observed in some cases
that the pressure from the company authorities on the girls about registering for further
studies was causing distress for them, due to which the company felt it was not advisable to
compel them further. Therefore, Kalpana believed that it was not feasible to compel them
any further. The fact that only 30% of the new recruits were opting to continue their studies
and a further 30% of them dropped out after enrolment was quite a worrisome fact for
Kalpana. She did not feel that this was good enough for achieving the lofty goal of
empowering under-privileged women through education they have set for the company.
At the end of a brief discussion on the issue with the company officials, Kalpana stated their
problem in the following words:
“How do we persuade 100% of the girls to opt for continuing their studies? We may also have to
think about the long-term sustainability of this business model. It is possible that in future there
may not be any need for educating the drop-outs, as the idea of universal education gets widely
accepted and implemented when “the learn while you earn program” would no longer be
relevant. How long do we sustain this model? What are the alternatives?” [1]
Notes
1. Anand, Kalpana. Personal Interview. 17 December 2020.
2. Tiruppur is a major textile and knit wear hub contributing to 90% of total cotton knit wear exports
from India.
PAGE 514
j THE CASE JOURNAL j VOL. 18 NO. 3 2022
Plate E1
Figure E1
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
Usage permitted only within these parameters otherwise contact info@thecasecentre.org
TCJ-10-2021-0198
Figure E2
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
Sasikala HR, 08 February 2021. Email interview
PAGE 516
j THE CASE JOURNAL j VOL. 18 NO. 3 2022
Plate E3
Exhibit 5. Classes being conducted at Avaneetha Textiles
TCJ-10-2021-0198
Authorised for educator review use only by Faraz Ali Shah, Capital University of Science and Technology Islamabad. Expiry date 4-Jan-2024
Usage permitted only within these parameters otherwise contact info@thecasecentre.org
Educational material supplied by The Case Centre
Copyright encoded A76HM-JUJ9K-PJMN9I
Plate E4
Corresponding author
Exhibit 6. Nursing station