Professional Documents
Culture Documents
research-article2021
HANXXX10.1177/15589447211006857HandAbdolrazaghi et al
Surgery Article
HAND
Abstract
Background: There is limited evidence regarding the efficacy of different treatment options in patients with carpal tunnel
syndrome (CTS). This study aimed at assessing the effectiveness of nerve and tendon gliding exercises in the treatment of
patients with mild CTS. Methods: The current prospective, randomized trial with pretest-posttest design was conducted
on 80 patients with mild CTS randomly assigned to 2 groups. The treatment group was instructed to perform gliding
exercises in addition to the wrist splint use. The control group only used the wrist splint. All the patients were instructed
to use the splint at night and during the day if required. Patients were evaluated in terms of clinical parameters (ie, grip
and pinch strength). The severity of symptoms and functional status was also determined using the Boston Carpal Tunnel
Syndrome Questionnaire. The subjects were followed up for 6 weeks. Results: There were no significant differences in all
parameters between groups. The pretest-posttest analysis showed a statistically significant improvement in subjective and
objective parameters in the treatment group. However, in the control group, only a significant improvement was observed
in grip strength. Wrist splint use led to a significant change in the severity of symptoms only over the second week.
Conclusions: Both gliding exercise and wrist splint groups showed some improvement in the severity of symptoms and
functional status scores. However, the gliding exercises did not offer additional benefit compared with wrist splint alone.
Keywords: carpal tunnel syndrome, nerve gliding exercises, tendon gliding exercises, wrist splint, conservative treatment
repetitive wrist movements.10 Exercise therapy is one of the questionnaires, and conducted treatment allocations. A
newest methods to control CTS symptoms. Reduced nerve sports medicine specialist also visited the patients to com-
gliding was observed in the respective channel in patients plete special CTS examination, train the exercise proto-
with CTS,11 and exercise provides conditions for flexibility col, and follow up their compliance with the intervention.
and the enhancement of the nerve gliding. Flicking fingers, In the first visit, all the patients completed the Boston
even when hands are motionless, creates the proper move- Carpal Tunnel Syndrome Questionnaire (BCTQ). A log
ment of the median nerve and the flexing tendon along the book containing detailed explanation of prescribed exer-
wrist, which prevents adhesion.12 The alternating flexion- cises and a self-report daily exercise checklist were given
extension exercises of the wrist and fingers actually cause to participants. Subjects were free to withdraw from the
stretching of the carpal tunnel connections, widening the study at any time during the follow-up period. Follow-up
longitudinal area of the connection between the nerve and examinations were scheduled at 2- and 6-week intervals
transverse carpal ligament, reducing the tenosynovial swell- after the intervention.
ing, improving the venous return from the nerve nodes, and
reducing the pressure within the carpal tunnel.6,13 Although
Blinding
many studies are conducted on the effects of conservative
treatments on patients with CTS, their results are controver- Except sports medicine specialist who educated patients for
sial, and further studies in this area seem necessary. Based correct exercising, other researchers were blind to the allo-
on a recent systematic review, tendon and nerve gliding cated treatments.
exercises, when combined with conventional treatments,
may have a favorable effect on patients with CTS.6
Treatment Allocation
Therefore, the current clinical trial aimed at assessing
the effectiveness of nerve and tendon gliding exercises in Patients were randomly allocated to receive either splinting
the treatment of patients with mild idiopathic CTS. or splinting with exercise (Figure 1). A researcher (M.KH)
not involved in the selection and treatment of patients pre-
pared and sealed opaque envelopes containing the treatment
Materials and Method options. Every patient randomly chose 1 sealed opaque
envelope to determine the type of intervention. If bilateral
Study Population
symptoms were present, the hand with the more severe
In this clinical trial, all patients with clinically suspected CTS symptoms (according to the patient) was treated.
referred to the surgery and sports medicine clinic were
assessed for eligibility. The study was performed from Janu-
ary 2017 to February 2019 at Sina Hospital, Tehran, Iran. Treatment
Inclusion criteria were: age >18 years, reporting of symp- After assigning patients to specific groups, prefabricated
toms of CTS (pain, paresthesia in the area of hand innervated splints (wrist and forearm splint; Tynor, India) were given
by the median nerve), and electrophysiological findings of to both groups, and the subjects were asked to use it for 6
nerve compression (mild CTS). Exclusion criteria were: pre- weeks. In these splints, the wrist was held in a neutral posi-
vious treatment with splint or surgery; history of any trauma tion, and the fingers were free. The subjects were urged to
on the hands, neck, and shoulders within 3 months of the wear the splint during the night or in daytime in case of
study onset; history of wrist surgery; history of pregnancy; repetitive wrist movements. The patients in the treatment
diabetes; thyroid disorders; and any findings suggesting con- group were prescribed a tendon and nerve gliding exercise
ditions that interfere with CTS (eg, cervical radiculopathy). program developed by Totten and Hunter.14 In tendon glide
Informed consent was obtained from all patients for being exercises, fingers are held in 5 positions of straight, hook,
included in the study. All procedures followed were in accor- fist, tabletop, and long fist, respectively (Figure 2). The
dance with the ethical standards of the responsible committee fingers are in full extension between these positions. At all
on human experimentation of Tehran University of Medical stages of this exercise, the wrist is in a neutral position. By
Sciences, Tehran, Iran, and with the Helsinki Declaration. doing the nerve glide exercises, the median nerve moves
through the wrist and the fingers in 6 different positions. To
do this exercise, the elbows are kept supinated with 90° of
Protocol flexion, and the shoulder and neck are in the neutral posi-
Patients were selected based on medical history, physical tion. In the first state, the wrist is in a neutral position, and
examination results, and electrophysiological findings. In the fingers and thumb are in flexion. In the second state,
this study, a hand surgeon confirmed inclusion/exclusion the wrist is in a neutral position, and the fingers and thumb
criteria and completed neurologic examinations. A surgeon are in extension. In the third state, the wrist and fingers are
assistant obtained informed consents, collected self-report in extension, and the thumb is in a neutral position. Then,
Abdolrazaghi et al 3
the wrist, fingers, and thumb are held in the extension confirm daily exercise in the checklist tailored for this pur-
position. In the next step, maintaining the previous posi- pose. After the treatment, the patients were revisited, and
tion, the forearm is kept supinated. In the final step, a mild the tests performed at baseline were repeated for them.
extension is applied to the exercising thumb by the oppo-
site hand (Figure 3). Patients were asked to perform all the
Outcome Measures
exercises 3 times a day, 10 repeats each time, and hold
each position for 5 seconds. The exercise therapy lasted Demographic information and medical history of the sub-
for 6 weeks. During the treatment, patients were asked to jects were collected using a structured questionnaire.
4 HAND 00(0)
Note. Data are expressed as mean ± SD or No. (%). BMI = body mass index.
a
Higher scores indicate greater impairment.
Table 2. Comparison of the Total Score of Boston Questionnaire at Different Time Intervals Between 2 Groups.
Time, wk Treatment group Control group P value Treatment group Control group P value
0 25.6 ± 10.9 22.5 ± 9.0 .2 15.4 ± 7.2 13.8 ± 5.4 .4
2 21.8 ± 10.4 21.8 ± 9.6 .8 13.8 ± 7.2 13.7 ± 5.8 .4
6 16.9 ± 7.6 18.6 ± 6.9 .1 11.7 ± 5.1 12.2 ± 4.6 .1
only a significant improvement in the severity of the symp- were significantly higher in the treatment group than the
toms during the second to sixth week (P = .003) (Table 3). control group, none of the variables related to the symptoms
There was no significant difference between the 2 groups and function had a significant difference between the 2
regarding the severity of symptoms and functional status at groups.
baseline, as well as the second and sixth week. Except for At the examination performed 6 weeks after the treat-
the amount of weakness in the hand (P = .04) and one of ment, there was no statistically significant improvement in
the hand functions (buttoning up shirts) (P = .03), which all parameters in both groups, except for pinch and grip
6 HAND 00(0)
Table 3. Comparison of the Total Score of Boston Questionnaire at Different Time Intervals in Each Group.
Table 4. Comparison of Pinch and Grip Strength at Different Time Intervals in Each Group.
Time, wk Treatment group P value Control group P value Treatment group P value Control group P value
0 13.0 ± 4.0 <.001* 13.2 ± 4.1 .1 19.1 ± 7.9 <.001* 19.3 ± 6.9 .1
2 14.0 ± 4.4 13.7 ± 3.9 20.3 ± 7.8 19.7 ± 6.6
6 14.8 ± 4.4 <.001* 13.6 ± 3.9 .1 22.4 ± 7.8 .001* 21.3 ± 7.8 .005*
strength (Table 4). There was a statistically significant on CTS. They reported that both groups had improvement
improvement in pinch and grip strength at all times of assess- in all parameters. Although the results were more satisfac-
ment in the treatment group. Grip strength in the treatment tory in the group that received exercise than the group that
group improved from 19.14 to 22.47 kg (P < .001). Grip used only splint, the difference was not statistically sig-
strength in the control group showed only improvement after nificant except for the lateral pinch strength. In a similar
6 weeks from intervention onset (P = .005), but difference study by Pinar et al,13 a before and after intervention anal-
in pinch strength was not significant. ysis showed improvement in all of the outcome measures
in both groups. However, they found that the group in
which nerve gliding exercises were added to conservative
Discussion therapy approaches demonstrated more rapid pain reduc-
The main finding of the present randomized controlled tion and greater functional improvement, especially in
trial was that both the treatment and control groups grip strength. Another investigation assessed the effective-
improved over time. However, there were no significant ness of tendon and nerve gliding exercises as a part of
differences between the groups. Pinch and grip strength combined treatment, separately.23 The authors reported
significantly improved in the treatment group from base- that the combination of tendon gliding exercises with con-
line to the 6-week follow-up. In the control group, pinch ventional treatments may be more effective than nerve
strength was greater over 2 weeks; however, the improve- gliding exercises. The result of another study24 showed
ment was not sustained for the additional 4 weeks. Grip that the combination of orthosis, nerve/tendon gliding
strength in the control group significantly improved at the exercises, and ultrasound therapy did not offer additional
end of follow-up. There was no difference in the results of benefit compared with orthosis alone.
the Tinel, Phalen, and compression tests after the treat- In the control group, the wrist splint significantly
ment in the 2 groups. reduced symptoms over 2 weeks, and that improvement
Currently, several nonoperative interventions are used to was sustained for an additional 4 weeks. Although this
treat CTS. However, there are doubts about which treatment finding was consistent with those of other studies, in this
is the most appropriate one. Despite the low level of evi- study, wrist splint did not have any effect on functional
dence, the effectiveness of immobilization is somewhat status. A possible reason for the effectiveness of wrist
ascertained,12 although there still exists scarcity of evidence splint is decreasing pressure in the carpal tunnel by hold-
about the effectiveness of exercise in CTS treatment. Some ing the wrist firm in a neutral position.12 But in other
studies indicate limited evidence for the effectiveness of groups receiving exercise in addition to wrist splint,
exercise therapy.3,12,21 either severity symptoms or functional status improved in
In a study similar to the current one, Akalin et al22 2 and 6 weeks. In the control group, grip strength showed
assessed the effect of nerve and tendon gliding exercises improvement at the end of the sixth week. It was the time
Abdolrazaghi et al 7
that severity of symptoms decreased. It can be concluded Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran, and with the
that decreased symptoms led to grip strength improve- Helsinki Declaration.
ment. But in the treatment group, grip and pinch strength
as well as symptoms and functional status improved in Statement of Informed Consent
parallel and during the follow-up. Tendon gliding exer- Informed consent was obtained from all patients for being included
cises involve a sequence of finger movements, and nerve in the study.
gliding exercises include wrist and finger movements.
Gliding exercises reduce pressure inside the carpal tunnel Declaration of Conflicting Interests
through decreasing adhesions around the tendons and The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect
median nerve, tenosynovial edema, direct mobilization of to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
the nerve, improving the excursion of the nerve and ten-
dons, and facilitating venous return; thus, these dynamic Funding
exercises would improve symptoms.12,22,25 The pressure
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support
in the carpal tunnel is lowest in the neutral position; how- for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: This
ever, the pressure rises significantly as the wrist is moved research has been supported by Tehran University of Medical Sci-
into flexion or extension,25 but nerve and tendon gliding ences & Health Services as a thesis.
exercises with controlled active wrist and finger motions
can reduce pressure in the canal. Trial Registration
The limitation of this study was the short-term follow-
This trial has been registered at Iranian Registry of Clinical Trials
up. Outcome measures were assessed at 2 and 6 weeks. (http://www.IRCT.ir) with ID IRCT20191222045849N2
Thus, long-term results are unknown. However, this study
had methodological strengths, including the randomized ORCID iD
design, the use of valid and standard measures, and the
Maryam Mirshahi https://orcid.org/0000-0002-8754-4937
evaluation of the functional status of patients.
In this study, exercise therapy was prescribed in asso-
ciation with splint use. Future research needs to be con- References
ducted to determine the effectiveness of these exercises 1. Urits I, Gress K, Charipova K, et al. Recent advances in the
as a single treatment with a longer follow-up to deter- understanding and management of carpal tunnel syndrome: a
mine long-term effects of the intervention. It is also sug- comprehensive review. Curr Pain Headache Rep. 2019;23:70.
2. Padua L, Coraci D, Erra C, et al. Carpal tunnel syndrome:
gested that further studies be designed with a larger
clinical features, diagnosis, and management. Lancet Neurol.
sample size and a more strenuous adherence to the exer-
2016;15:1273-1284.
cise protocol. 3. Wipperman J, Goerl K. Carpal tunnel syndrome: diagnosis
and management. Am Fam Physician. 2016;94:993-999.
Conclusion 4. Mohammadi A, Afshar A, Etemadi A, et al. Diagnostic value
of cross-sectional area of median nerve in grading severity of
According to the results of this study, both gliding exercise carpal tunnel syndrome. Arch Iran Med. 2010;13:516-521.
and wrist splint groups showed some improvement in 5. Molinari WJ, Elfar JC. The double crush syndrome. J Hand
symptom severity and functional status scores. However, Surg. 2013;38:799-801.
the gliding exercises did not offer additional benefit com- 6. Kim S-D. Efficacy of tendon and nerve gliding exercises for
pared with wrist splint alone. carpal tunnel syndrome: a systematic review of randomized
controlled trials. J Phys Ther Sci. 2015;27:2645-2648.
7. Lee HS, Park SB, Lee SH, et al. The effect of cervical radicu-
Acknowledgments
lopathy on the outcome of carpal tunnel release in a patient
The present research has been supported by Tehran University of with carpal tunnel syndrome. Nerve. 2015;1:11-14.
Medical Sciences & Health Services as a thesis. The authors 8. Piazzini DB, Aprile I, Ferrara PE, et al. A systematic review
would like to thank the Epidemiology and Biostatistics Unit of of conservative treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome. Clin
Research Development Center of Sina Hospital for their technical Rehabil. 2007;21:299-314.
assistance. 9. Lewis KJ, Ross L, Coppieters MW, et al. Education, night
splinting and exercise versus usual care on recovery and
Ethical Approval conversion to surgery for people awaiting carpal tunnel sur-
This study was approved by our institutional review board. gery: a protocol for a randomised controlled trial. BMJ Open.
2016;6:e012053.
10. Schmid AB, Elliott JM, Strudwick MW, et al. Effect of splint-
Statement of Human and Animal Rights ing and exercise on intraneural edema of the median nerve in
All procedures followed were in accordance with the ethical stan- carpal tunnel syndrome—an MRI study to reveal therapeutic
dards of the responsible committee on human experimentation of mechanisms. J Orthop Res. 2012;30:1343-1350.
8 HAND 00(0)