Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract – The lands bordering of the three rivers forest ecosystems, aggravated by unfavorable socio-economic
(FC3R) in northeastern Benin are continually subjected to and pedoclimatic contexts [5]. This degradation is
anthropogenic pressures which affect the renewal of characterized by a significant decrease in plant formations
biological resources and the ecosystem resilience. These and a considerable reduction in wood resources (fire wood
pressures are aggravated by climate change that threatens
and service wood). This phenomenon of degradation of
food security and biodiversity. Faced this situation, different
practices and adaptation measures developed locally that natural resources poses a threat to humanity and has
shown several level of acceptability and efficiency. Hence, the become a fundamental concern since the Rio Conference
actual study proposes to evaluate the endogenous adaptation in 1992 [1]. Benin suffers from the effects of climate
strategies in the land bordering the forest of the three rivers change, which limit its development, resulting in global
in order to point up the most effective. Thus, in the purpose warming, and decreasing variability in rainfall, droughts
to analyze those endogenous adaptation strategies, a survey and occasional floods [6]. Indeed, production becomes
was carried out among 301 farmers in the riparian villages of more and more unpredictable with climate change, which
FC3R. Data were processed in order to point up the socio- often creates confusion in agricultural planning [14].
economic effectiveness of those strategies. Thus, the
Faced with this situation, adaptation measures, adopted by
methodology of the matrix approach of risks developed by
World Bank was used for social acceptability evaluation. The the riparian’s populations, range from traditional or
econometric analysis was carried out using parameters: gross endogenous practices to improved endogenous practices
margin (GM), profit/cost (P/C) and man/day ratio (M/D). that also differ from one agro-climatic region to another
Tests like Kruskal wallis non parametric test and but can be adapted for transfer to enhance adaptation [3].
Pairwise.wilcox.test were also performed. Results showed 12 Hence the relevance of a new adaptation approach that
endogenous strategies developed against climate change were involves sustainable management, conservation and
identified, described and prioritized. The Agroforestry, the restoration of ecosystems to provide services that enable
large ridge perpendicular to the slope, the small ridge and people to adapt to the adverse effects of climate change
the flat plowing are the most effective strategies. Econometric
[11]. Across the globe, initiatives have been established to
analyses of these most adopted strategies reveal that large
ridges yield the highest GM (144113 XOF) and the highest assist communities in implementing approaches to adapt to
P/C ratio (0.99) and also have the advantage of requiring less and mitigate climate change; the Ecosystem Based
effort (24.57 H/J). It was followed by small ridges with GM = Adaptation (EBA) approach to ecosystem Adaptation [12].
144113 XOF, P/C = 0.99 and M/D = 25.76. Compared to the It is therefore an emergent anthropocentric approach put in
less effective strategies, flat plowing provides a higher GM place as part of a global adaptation strategy to help people
(117167 XOF) than agroforestry (GM=102994 XOF). adapt to the adverse effects of climate change while
However, the P/C ratio shows that flat tillage (0.80) is less preserving biodiversity and ecosystem services [16]. The
beneficial and required more effort than agroforestry (B/C = influence of human activities on the classified forest of the
0.92). Thus, the best endogenous strategies or practices to
three rivers is very important, threatening the
face the climate change and maintaining ecosystem resilience
in the FC3R are water and soil conservation strategies. sustainability of the peripheral agricultural and pastoral
systems and degrading this protected area [20]. For
Keywords – Benin, Climate Change, Ecosystem Resilience, example, any study that aims to contribute to better
Endogenous Adaptation Strategies, Three Rivers Classified management of the soil bordering the classified forest of
Forest. the three rivers is timely and is part of this adaptation
approach based on the sustainable management of
I. INTRODUCTION ecosystems. Hence the present that will evaluate and
analyze the adoption and the effectiveness of endogenous
The ecosystems degradation in the world is linked to adaptation strategies around the FC3R towards it
anthropogenic factors, including agricultural activities [7]. ecosystem resilience. This study aims is to evaluate the
The populations of the planet are dependent on intact endogenous adaptation strategies around the forest of the
ecosystems and the services they provide, such as soil three rivers in order to see the most effective by
fertility, clean water and food [18]. Over the past decades, prioritizing them and analyzing their effectiveness.
we assisted on a widespread degradation of natural I.
Copyright © 2017 IJAIR, All right reserved
38
International Journal of Agriculture Innovations and Research
Volume 6, Issue 1, ISSN (Online) 2319-1473
SCALE
The number of respondents was calculated per village by This prioritization reflected the level of effectiveness of
the following formula: each endogenous adaptation strategy.
Q = n / E × 100 - Analysis of the Socioeconomic Effectiveness of
With n = number of respondents; Endogenous Adaptation Strategies
Q = the proportion to be applied to the population of a The effectiveness analysis focused on endogenous
given village to have the number of respondents in strategies to improve maize yield, which is the basic crop
that village; for food security around the three rivers' classified forest.
E = total person for a 5-km around the forest. The best strategies obtained from the prioritization were
B. Method of Data Processing and Analysis subjected to econometric analysis in order to determine the
- Description of Endogenous Adaptation Strategies most effective. During the inventory of these strategies,
The data collected about the adaptation strategies the econometric parameters such as cost of realization,
identified were addressed. These strategies were listed and gross margin, ratio man/day of each strategy were
then briefly described according to local practices. In estimated. The most effective strategies for improving
addition, the main advantages and disadvantages of each farmers’ incomes were determined by taking into account
strategy were highlighted. The percentage adoption was the priority strategies, the econometric parameters
also calculated to assess the degree of adoption of these mentioned above, using the Kruskal Wallis test followed
strategies. by the Pairwise.wilcox.test to compare the mean of these
- Prioritization of Endogenous Adaptation Strategies parameters for each chosen strategy. The boxplots were
The effectiveness analysis of the adaptation strategies also performed for analysis for analysis of means, medians
used the methodology of the World Bank's Institute risk and deviations.
matrix approach, based on six feasibility criteria: cost,
easiness, effectiveness, rapidity, capacity and III. RESULTS
acceptability. Two steps were followed: II.
• The first step was to list the recorded strategies through A. Adoption of Endogenous Adaptation Strategies
the surveys with the farmers; - List of Endogenous Adaptation Strategies
• The second stage consisted of prioritizing and The preliminary study carried out in the riparian lands
classifying proposed adaptation strategies based on cost, of the FC3R identified sixteen (16) of the most used
easiness, effectiveness, rapidity, capacity and strategies for adapting to climate change. Among them,
acceptability (see Table 2). Criteria ranges are low, farmers are familiar with and practice 12 such as
medium, high. The criterion favors the achievement of agroforestry, crop diversification, crop density adjustment,
the strategy. A strategy that costs a low cost for the water and soil conservation techniques such as the large
criteria”cost” is a strategy that does not require new ridge perpendicular to the slope, small ridge perpendicular
needs for capacity building or technology transfer for its to the slope and flat plowing, fertilization technique, use of
implementation at a high cost as regards the criterion” resistant varieties, use of early varieties, support for agro-
capacity". meteorological monitoring, reforestation and direct
Thus, any strategy totaling a score lower than 12 is not seedling. Table 1 presents the description, advantages and
retained. Strategies were prioritized based on total scores. disadvantages of each strategy.
Table 1. Description, advantages and disadvantages of the most used climate change adaptation strategies
Strategies Description Advantages Inconveniences
AF Association of trees with crops Shade for farmers Hands raised for initial planting and
Fruit marketing for fruit trees upkeep
Use of trees for medicinal purposes
High organic matter
Brakes the wind speed
Conserves moisture
Reduces water erosion
Not require many upkeep
CD Crop rotation, crop association Restoration of soil fertility Requires greater technical experiences
Sustainable land management Secondary crops may not be favored
Romps the life cycle of pests for crops
CDA Reseeding or density adjustment Fight against the phenomenon of lodging Destruction of seedlings by pests
of young plant Adjustment of crop density Vulnerability of youngest plants
Increased harvest quantity Requires more monitoring and
complementary work
GB Large ridge of 80-100 cm in Increased crop density Undersaving trees during soil
thickness and 30-50 cm in Good soil loosening preparation
height, perpendicular to the Reduced number of ridges Little vital space between the two
slope Increased number of pockets per line parallel sowing lines of the same ridge
Easy and inexpensive installation Requires a little more physical effort
Fight against erosion
Maintains moisture in the soil
Good burial of the roots of the plants
- Degree of Adoption of Endogenous Strategies of plowing; FT: fertilization technique; RV: use of resistant
Adaptation varieties; EV: use of early varieties; AMM: support for
agro-meteorological monitoring; RB: reforestation; SD:
Fig. 3 shows the percentage of adoption of endogenous direct seeding
strategies around the FC3R.
Fig. 3. Percentage of Adoption of Endogenous
Strategies for Adaptation to Climate Change
Figure 3 shows that adaptation strategies adopted by more
than 60% of the populations of the the Three Rivieres
classified forest are: crop diversification (CD),
agroforestry (AF), Large plowing Ridge perpendicular to
the slope (GB), small ridge perpendicular to the slope
(PB), flat plowing (LP) and finally support to agro-
meteorological follow-up (AMM). Of all these strategies,
note that the GB and CD followed by the PB, LP and AF
are the most widespread because of their effectiveness
according to the remarks of the local populations.
B. Prioritization and Social Acceptability of
Endogenous Adaptation Strategies to Climate
Change
Prioritization of adaptation strategies showed that the
large ridge perpendicular to the slope, the small ridge
AF: agroforestry; CD: crop diversification; CDA: crop perpendicular to the slope, flat plowing and agroforestry
density adjustment; GB: large ridge perpendicular to the are the strategies that have a score greater than or equal to
slope; PB: small ridge perpendicular to the slope; LP: flat 12 according to the method of The World Bank's risk
matrix approach (Table 2). Thus we have according to - Flat Plowing is the third most effective strategy. It is
these criteria: relatively cheaper and faster, more or less easy to
- The large ridge perpendicular to the slope, which is one implement, and performs well. It is less acceptable than
of the anti-erosion techniques, is the most effective the previous ones by the farmers because of the
strategy. It is relatively cheaper, easy to implement, difficulties in choosing the sowing lines (see Table 2).
effective in erosion control and retains much moisture. It - Agroforestry ranks fourth and ranks as the most
is, moreover, very quick to implement and adopted by effective climate change strategies. It costs more or less
the majority of farmers because of its high acceptability expensive, it is more or less easy to execute, very
on all the riparian lands (see Table 2). efficient, more or less rapid to achieve, moderately
- The small ridge perpendicular to the slope is the second acceptable by farmers because of the constraint in the
most effective strategy. It costs relatively cheaper, easy hands of works raised for the initial planting and
to execute, effective in erosion control and retains much maintenance in Start of installation (see Table 2).
moisture. It is also less quick to execute than the large
ridge. The peasants have the capacity to carry it out and
it is widely accepted by local residents (see Table 2).
Table 2. Prioritization of endogenous strategies for adapting to climate change according to World Bank criteria
STRATEGIES COST EASINESS EFFECTIVENESS RAPIDITY CAPACITY ACCEPTANCE TOTAL RANK
AF 2 2 3 2 1 2 12 4
DC 1 1 1 1 2 1 7 5
AC 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 14
SC 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 15
APP 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 13
GB 2 3 2 3 3 3 16 1
PB 3 2 2 2 3 2 15 2
LP 2 2 3 2 3 2 14 3
TF 0 0 0 1 1 0 3 11
SE 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 16
VR 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 12
VP 1 1 1 1 1 1 5 6
EBP 1 1 1 0 1 0 4 10
AGM 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 9
RB 1 1 1 1 1 1 5 6
SD 1 1 1 1 2 1 5 6
1 = low; 2 = medium; 3 = high;
AF: agroforestry; CD: crop diversification; CDA: crop density adjustment; GB: large ridge perpendicular to the slope;
PB: small ridge perpendicular to the slope; LP: flat plowing; FT: fertilization technique; RV: use of resistant varieties;
EV: use of early varieties; AMM: support for agro-meteorological monitoring; RB: reforestation; SD: direct seeding
C. Economic Efficiency of Endogenous Strategies ridges with the following values: gross margin (144113
The results revealed a very significant difference XOF), P/C ratio (0.99) and H/J ratio (25.76). Compared to
between the different adaptation strategies (Table 3, 4, 5 the last two strategies, Flat plowing provides a higher
and Figures 4, 5, 6). The Pairwise.wilcox.test test showed gross margin (117167 XOF) than agroforestry (102994
that the large ridges followed by small ridges have the XOF). However, the P/C ratio shows that Flat plowing
highest gross margins and profit ratios; while agroforestry (0.80) is less beneficial and more labor intensive than
totaled the lowest values for these parameters. For agroforestry which requires labor and a B/C ratio of 0.92.
example, the large ridges yield the highest gross margin Thus, the large perpendicular ridge and the small ridges
(144113 XOF) and the highest P/C ratio (0.99) and also are the most effective strategies used by local population
have the advantage of requiring less physical effort (24.57 of the FC3R, which justifies its level of adoption by the
H/J). The small ridges are the best effective after the large farmers.
Table 3. Synthesis of the socio-economic parameters of the most used types of plowing
TYPES OF PLOWING
OPERATIONS LARGE RIDGE PLOWING FLAT PLOWING SMALL RIDGE PLOWING
Mean CV (%) Mean CV (%) Mean CV (%)
Field preparation 26494 21.54 27596 29.50 27409 15.55
plowing 30469 5.14 27442 10.15 27681 11.80
seedling 6077 11.43 6596 20.65 6332 35.55
First Clearing 12298 14.07 12058 4.88 11919 6.65
Second Clearing 12395 14.69 12019 4.92 12037 4.70
Third Clearing 12114 5.55 11942 4.01 12080 3.88
Herbicide 7624 8.42 7510 1.31 7500 0.00
Fertiliser 38090 15.08 38712 12.62 36693 7.71
Seeds 2504 1.82 2500 0.00 2500 0.00
COST 149527 8.86 146433 7.13 143935 4.45
RETURNS 292224 15.51 263604 13.79 277034 11.89
GROSS MARGIN 144113 31.25 117167 30.08 134387 24.86
BENEFIT/COST (B/C) 0.99 32.38 0.80 31.17 0.94 26.74
MEN/DAY (M/D) 24.57 10.75 26.51 10.52 25.76 10.53
Table 4. Syntheses of socio-economic parameters in Table 5. Gross margin, Man/day ratio and Profit/cost ratio
Agroforestry Systems of the most adaptated strategies: Results of the Kruskal
AGROFORESTERY Wallis test followed by Pairwise.wilcox.test
OPERATIONS (P value adjustment method: holm).
Mean CV (%)
Field preparation 26877 15.78 Gross margin Man / Day (H/J) Profit/Cost
Planting 61197 12.91 Stratégies d’adaptation (XOF) (P/C)
Keeping 25154 17.93 M CV (%) M CV(%) M CV(%)
COST Large ridge plowing 144113a 31.25 24.57a 10.75 0.99a 32.38
113313 9.82
(GB)
RETURNS 216307 14.79
Small ridge plowing 134387b 24.86 25.76a 10.53 0.94b 26.74
GROSS MARGIN 102994 28.28 (PB)
PROFIT/COST (B/C) 0.92 29.53 Flat Plowing (LP) 117167c 30.08 26.51b 10.52 0.80c 31.17
MEN/DAY (M/D) 28.08 15.61 Agroforestery (AG) 102994d 28.28 28.08a 15.61 0.92d 29.53
Kruskal-Wallis rank 0,000 - 0,000 0,000 -
sum test
IV. DISCUSSION It should be noted that most of the strategies that are
widely adopted and most effective, according to local
The analysis of the effectiveness of adaptation strategies population, are water and soil conservation strategies or
used the World Bank's risk matrix approach based on six anti-erosion strategies. That is confirmed by [19]
feasibility criteria previously cited. It emerges that according to which integrated water and soil management
endogenous adaptation strategies to climate change have could be determinative in food safety achieving [19]. [18],
several levels of effectiveness according to the farmers. Of [19], [17] go further by asserting that water and soil
the strategies developed or implemented, only four conservation is the real problem of agricultural
(Agroforestry, large ridges, short ridges and flat plowing) development in several tropical countries, including
are effective because they score are ≥12. Benin. That is then the reason why local residents prefer to
The econometric analysis allowed concluding that large prioritize endogenous strategies for water and soil
ridges and small ridges are more economical, easy to conservation to adapt to climate change.
implement than flat plowing and agroforestry. For most other strategies, farmers face enormous
Furthermore, those strategies ensure the ecosystem difficulties in their implementation. These include the high
sustainability and thus fit with the principle of Ecosystems cost of reforestation, for example, and the difficulty of
Based Adaptation (EBA). The socio-economic access to seeds for the use of resistant varieties and the
performance of these different plows is mainly related to high need of physical effort. This is in harmony with the
their ease implementation and their ability to control [2] study findings, which states that smallholder farmers
erosion and conserve soil moisture. Which characteristics are more vulnerable because low-resource countries are
are related to their architectural structure as confirmed by gradually trying to adapt to the climate change effects by
[21] who states that the difference in efficiency between implementing strategies and techniques of their own or
soil and water conservation technics is due to the with the help of the monitory services. Although many
difference in architecture between the types of barriers that farmers are already adapting to climatic variations,
constitute them when he comparing stony ropes with grass weather becomes less predictable and some of the farmers'
strips. Plowing increases the roughness of the soil and strategies may no longer be effective [13]. However
limits the rate of runoff of the first rains and this effect isprogressive adaptation to change is therefore not a
even more remarkable when plowing is done in ridges sustainable solution and farmers will have to prepare in
perpendicular to the slope [13]. These strategies advance for radical changes [17]. Adaptation cannot
contribute, therefore, the most in the resilience of the therefore be uniform or homogeneous, but rather a
FC3R ecosystem resilience.
Copyright © 2017 IJAIR, All right reserved
43
International Journal of Agriculture Innovations and Research
Volume 6, Issue 1, ISSN (Online) 2319-1473
diversity of mutually beneficial approaches, knowledge [12] IUCN (2015). THE IUCN RED LIST OF THREATENED
SPECIES™.
and know-how [11].
[13] CIRAD-GRET (2002). Memento de l’Agronome édition (2002).
Editions du GRET, Editions du CIRAD, Ministère français des
V. CONCLUSION Affaires étrangères (French Ministry of Foreign Affairs), ISBN
2-86844-129-7, 1691p.
[14] PAPFFCTR (2010). Participatory management plan for the three
This study, which examined the endogenous adaptation
rivers classified forest.
strategies around the FC3R, allowed to see the best [15] PARBCC (2008). Bulletin d'information Agro-météorologique,
performers in social and economic plan in this context of parution n°001. 7p, Cotonou/Bénin.
climate change. Thus, only four of the developed and [16] RGPH-4 (2013). General census of population and housing in
Benin.
implemented strategies (Agroforestry, large ridges, small
[17] Ronak S, Niranjan A (2007). Improved traditional practices to
ridges and flat tillage) are socially most acceptable and adapt to change, Journal of Unit of development of natural
economically profitable for local population. Findings also resource; Rajasthan, Inde. 3p.
reveal that the most effectiveness and largely adopted [18] Sivakumar MVK, Wallace JS (1991). Soil water balance in the
Sudano-Sahelian zone: Need, relevance and objectives of the
strategies implemented by local residents against climate
workshop. In : Sivakumar MVK, Wallace JS, Renard C.
change around the FC3R are water and soil conservation [19] Stroosnijder L (1996). Modelling the effect of grazing on
technologies. Those technologies allow them to achieve infiltration, runoff and primary production in the Sahel. Ecolog
food safety by enhancing their incomes and maintain Modelling 1996; 92 : 79-88.
[20] Toko M I (2000). Dynamique du milieu naturel en périphérie des
ecosystem resilience of this forest reserve according to
aires protégées : cas de la forêt classée des Trois Rivières
Ecosystem Based adaptation approach. (Bénin), étude par télédétection, diplôme d'études spécialisées
interuniversitaire en Sciences naturelles de la Terre et de la Viev
VI. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS (Dynamics of the natural environment on the periphery of
protected areas: the case of the Trois Rivières classified forest
(Benin), remote sensing study, interuniversity specialized studies
We acknowledge the Centre for Studies, Research and in Natural Sciences of the Earth and Life), orientation Sciences
Forestry Training (CERF Benin) for having contributed naturelles appliquées et Écodéveloppement (Applied and
financially and materially to the achievement of this Ecodevelopment), université de Liège (university of Liege), 80p.
[21] Zougmoré R, Guillobez S, Kambou N F, Son G (2000). Runoff
research works.
and sorghum performance as affected by the spacing of stone
lines in the semi-arid Sahelian zone. Soil Till Res 2000; 56 :
REFERENCES 175-83.