Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A.P.A.C. Ltd.
Archaeological Perspectives Analysis Consultancy
REPORT
WB/BRY/14
By: Mr A. Phillips.
A.P.A.C. 3 King Street, Brynmawr WB/BRY/14
Summary
The client was instructed by BGCBC to arrange for a Level II building recording
survey which was conducted by APAC Ltd in October 2014 prior to any
demolition work. BS/BRY/14.
As part of the conditions imposed by GGAT, a further watching brief was required
during demolition and groundworks for foundations and services.
The watching brief undertaken during the demolition work was able to identify
and record developments to the building in the past but no archaeological
resources were impacted upon during the groundworks.
Copyright Notice:
A.P.A.C. Ltd. retains copyright of this report under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988.
The Ordnance Survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577) to reproduce map information; Copyright remains
otherwise with the Ordnance Survey.
1
A.P.A.C. 3 King Street, Brynmawr WB/BRY/14
Contents
Summary ......................................................................................................................................... 1
Contents ........................................................................................................................................... 2
Figures: ............................................................................................................................................ 2
Plates: .............................................................................................................................................. 3
Appendices ...................................................................................................................................... 3
Introduction ..................................................................................................................................... 4
Site Location and Description ......................................................................................................... 4
Brief archaeological and historical background .............................................................................. 5
Aims and Objectives ....................................................................................................................... 5
Watching Brief ................................................................................................................................ 5
Watching Brief Results ................................................................................................................... 6
Interpretation ................................................................................................................................... 7
Staff ................................................................................................................................................. 8
Archive: ........................................................................................................................................... 8
Acknowledgements: ........................................................................................................................ 8
Bibliography and References: ......................................................................................................... 9
Figures:
2
A.P.A.C. 3 King Street, Brynmawr WB/BRY/14
Plates:
PL01 Rubble wall extended into next property south eastern elevation, south western corner.
PL02 Mixture of uncoursed rubble, coursed stone, and brick. Lean to, built against previous build to
extend the building of a later phase kitchen.
PL03 Different phases of building. Later build extension built upon, but not tied to previous builds
north western elevation.
PL04 Kitchen extension. Ill fitted, between property to the east and property to the west’s porch
extension. Timber frame roof under slate.
PL05 Maintenance hole outside of north western kitchen extension. Filled with rain water.
PL06 Trench 1 north western elevation foundations (100), (101), (102) with plastic water pipe (105),
in fill (104) and cut (103).
PL07 North eastern party wall exposed.
PL08 Hole in south western party wall. Blocked up with concrete. Then given a wooden frame.
PL09 Flagstone floor, ground level within western party wall. Possible step.
PL10 Lime plastered stairwell in south western party wall exposed. Previous external wall.
PL11 Hole in south western party wall. Evidence of previous stairwell shown through an interior
wall built up against, but not tied to a previous exterior wall.
PL12 Feature in south western party wall possible earlier fireplace.
PL13 Width of fireplace after clearance.
PL14 Internal view of hidden chimney stack.
PL15 Photograph of Brynmawr early 20th century. Tripod
PL16 Internal debris, slate and brick taken from within blocked in fireplace.
PL17 Depth of fireplace from back exterior (earlier) wall to room interior, after clearance.
Appendices
Context sheet I
Complete photograph list II
3
A.P.A.C. 3 King Street, Brynmawr WB/BRY/14
Introduction
A Watching Brief Report has been prepared by Mr Adam Phillips, A.P.A.C. Ltd, in response to a planning
application for the demolition and rebuilding of a two-story house.
No: 3 King Street was identified by Glamorgan Gwent Archaeological Trust (GGAT); advisors to Blaenau Gwent
County Borough Council, (BGCBC), as having ‘historic importance by virtue of its origin, history and cultural
significance within the area’, BLG0169BHD.
Consequently, GGAT recommended a condition be imposed based on the model suggested by the Association of
Local Government Archaeological Officers in their document Analysis and Recording for the Conservation and
Control of works to Historic Buildings:
Reason: As the buildings are of architectural and cultural significance, the specified
records are required to mitigate the impact of development.
As the building has undergone some alteration, the proposed recording should take place
both prior to and during the undertaking of the demolition, as the demolition works are
likely to expose the historic core and this should be done under archaeological
supervision.
BLG0169BHD
The GGAT conditions required a Written Scheme of Investigation for the required archaeological work, which was
duly submitted and approved in writing before any work began, WSI:BS/BRY/14.
The preliminary building survey was compiled in October 2014, BS/BRY/14, prior to demolition.
Work at the site has been sporadic over the intervening years, dictated by the client’s work schedules, which were
themselves, continually delayed by ongoing disputes with a neighbour; however, watching brief conditions were
observed during any demolition or excavation.
The last onsite attendance for the watching brief was on the 30 th September 2015 at which point development again
ceased due further disputes with the neighbour.
Occasional observance of the site was undertaken for some months after but no further work was observed and later
communication with the client confirmed this.
After a span of time from the last watching brief, conformation for completion of any proposed demolition work
was sought from the client on April 2017.
This was confirmed on the same day allowing this report to be completed.
The location of the site can be gained from the A465, Heads of the Valley Road some 9 miles west of Abergavenny.
When travelling west from Abergavenny to Merthyr, at the top of the Clydach gorge is a roundabout, the second
turn of leads along King Street to Brynmawr.
4
A.P.A.C. 3 King Street, Brynmawr WB/BRY/14
The property to be developed is one of a group of four houses to the right of the Bridgend Inn, and is at NGR:
319555 212129, fig 01.
The surface geology at the site is a mixture of Pennine middle coal measures formation and South Wales lower
coals measures formation, forming (undifferentiated) mudstone, siltstone, sandstone, coal, ironstone, and ferricrete.
(BGS). The site however has been largely disturbed by building development in the area.
It is worth noting that the origin of Brynmawr as a town was aptly described thus: ‘In 1800 a collection of a few
farm cottages making up the village of ‘Waun-y-Helegyn’, (field of the willows) had exploded into the industrial
town of Brynmawr by the 1830s’, (Jennings, p86, 1934).
The spark for Brynmawr’s beginnings and fuel for its rapid growth are tied to industry, situated as it was on the
transportation infrastructure for the iron and coal industries; Nantyglo and Clydach iron works, in particular, with
the route through the Clydach gorge for both road and rail thereby strengthening its importance.
King St itself was the part of the main road through the gorge, the adjacent Bridge Inn taking its name from the
original bridge ‘Pont Clydach’ over the river Clydach; partially preserved under the present roundabout which was
built in the early 1960s.
The previous building recording survey, BS/BRY/14, provides a detailed account of the property No 3 King Street
and its development as part of a row of four Georgian fronted houses around 1821, to an apparent infill between two
houses to the east and a large extended property to the west, by 1915, figs 2 & 3.
The house to the east, No 2 was identified as the former public house; ‘Jolly Colliers’ and the lack of internal
features in No 3, such as stairs and hearth led to the supposition that No 3 was either an infill or an extension to the
public house.
The aim of the watching brief during demolition was to preserve by record, within the resources available, any
archaeological deposits uncovered during demolition and resulting groundwork.
The watching brief also ensured that: in the event of archaeological resources of significance, being discovered and
requiring treatment beyond the remit of the watching brief, that steps would be implemented to ensure that their
treatment would be undertaken within the standards recommended by the CIFA.
Watching Brief
The majority of the watching brief was undertaken between 27th July 2015, and 30th September 2015 with
occasional site visits thereafter to check progress.
Initial recording
A record of the features and stratigraphy exposed during excavation was kept including written notes and
photographs.
5
A.P.A.C. 3 King Street, Brynmawr WB/BRY/14
Assessment & Interpretation
Following the watching brief, the field notes and photographs were digitised to produce the record of the work:
Appendix I, annotated list of photographs.
Presentation Notes:
All contexts are denoted [#] in the text, listed in Appendix I, cross referenced in Appendix II.
Photographs used in the text are listed Pl # in the txt and a complete list of photographs can be found in appendix II
with contact sheets.
Demolition began with the removal of the roof, undertaken carefully by hand to minimise damage to the shared
party walls.
Work then progressed with the removal of the first-floor structure before the front and rear walls were reduced to
ground level.
……………………………………………………..
During this stage, evidence of an earlier wall was found at the south west corner; the south elevation wall appears to
continue through the western party wall suggesting that the neighbouring party wall is a later development, (PL01).
During the removal of the ground floor kitchen extension, the wall fabric was revealed to be a mixture of coursed
and uncoursed stone, finished with brick, (PL02).
The extension has been built against the north-western elevation of the main building. this is evident from the wall
being built as a lean to, against, and not tied in to the main buildings wall fabric, (PL03).
The lean-to extension was roofed by a timber framed ceiling, under slate, and then cemented in place above the
stone and brick fabric, (PL04).
Three small trenches were excavated as test pits to investigate the ground stability and these were recorded during
the watching brief, fig 04
Trench TR2, fig 04, was excavated just outside of the kitchen extension, to find out at what depth the garden wall
ended; however, this quickly flooded with possibly contaminated water, (PL05).
Trenches TR1 & TR3, fig 04 were excavated within the interior of the building, both showed identical stratigraphy.
Both trenches exposed the foundation of the building [100] and a soil fill [101] built upon natural sandy light brown
soil. [102]
Tri also exposed a white plastic water pipe [103], cut [104] and fill [105] evidently the site had already been
relatively recently disturbed by service works, (PL06).
The north-eastern party wall, (PL07), is featureless in its entirety, with none of the anticipated, (BS/BRY/1)
connections to No 3, which would have indicated its use as an extension
During the building survey, a cemented rectangle with a wooden frame was recorded in the south-western gable,
(PL08).
This was removed revealing a lime plastered recess in coursed stonework; 700mm x 700mm with a flagstone floor,
PL09).
The recess was found to have partial lime plaster surface, over coursed stonework, except in the rear face which had
dark grey skim pre-surface, (PL10).
Further investigation found that the wall, originally thought to be the internal party wall, was built up against that of
a previous internal wall, set behind.
6
A.P.A.C. 3 King Street, Brynmawr WB/BRY/14
The walls are quite clearly not built as one, showing two distinct phases of build not tied into, but against one
another, (PL11).
A further feature was exposed during surface preparation in the middle of the south-western party wall, (PL12).
Careful investigation revealed a bricked up central fireplace with iron former, arched lintel, (PL13) set upon
flagstones with an intact chimney stack set within the wall, (PL14).
The chimney stack is evident on a picture of the property in the early 20th century, (PL15).
Removal of the brick blocking to give access to the remains of the fireplace revealed a lot of the original carved
slate mantle and surrounds, PL16.
The resultant void was found to be around 800mm deep, PL17, similar to the side recess.
Phasing.
The main building was a two-storey building situated between two larger properties, Nos: 2 & 4.
The south-western party wall revealed a lot of evidence from which it was possible to interpret the buildings decline
in proportion.
The internal wall is a later edition, (PL11) blocking off an internal brick fireplace, (PL17) and possible stone stair
built to the right of it, (PL13).
Further evidence of the earlier external wall was found in the 1st floor, where the south-eastern elevation extends
into that of the neighbouring property, or more likely into the fabric of the previous south western party wall,
(PL01), fig 05a.
A lean-to was built upon the north-western elevation as a mixture of coursed, un-coursed stone and brick; roofed
with modern timber under slate, (PL02, PL04), fig05b.
Finds
No finds were unearthed during the trench excavations but the fireplace demolition did produce parts of a slate
fireplace mantle and surrounds.
These were not retained for post excavation analysis but were left with the client.
Interpretation
Cartographic evidence, alignments and symmetry would suggest that all four houses were built at the same time in
the early 19th century.
As a terrace of four, fronting on to the road they would probably have been identical in construction and
configuration; with the possible exception of No3, due to its use as a public house.
However, at this period residential properties offering beverages merely utilised a suitable room rather than a
purpose-built property.
Assuming identical construction and configuration, four houses would have a chimney each, in this case at the
south-western end, (to the left), as shown in the photograph fig 15.
Figure 15, however shows that no 4, (left) has two chimneys, and No 3 none, which archaeological evidence arising
from this work contradicts.
7
A.P.A.C. 3 King Street, Brynmawr WB/BRY/14
Again, assuming identical construction and configuration; houses No 1 and No 2 are the same, arguably if the door
of no 3 replaced an earlier window and the bottom window was originally a door there would be room for a ground
and first floor window to the left; now engulfed in the extension of no 4.
Unfortunately, there is no evidence in the front elevation of no3 to confirm this possibility and no 4 would appear to
have been extended beyond both front and back elevations, losing any original features.
The evidence above would suggest that the south-western party wall has been altered; expanding the adjoining No 4
into no3 by moving the party wall forward by at least 800mm but more is probable.
Staff
Archive:
The original archive for this project will remain with APAC Ltd and a copy deposited RCAHMW
Copies of the report will be deposited with the client, Cadw, GGAT HER, County Archive and Brynmawr Museum.
Acknowledgements:
Thanks to the groundwork’s contractors for their assistance and efficient handling of the development and Mr
Porter for his assistance.
8
A.P.A.C. 3 King Street, Brynmawr WB/BRY/14
APAC.Ltd BS/BRY/14, Level II Building recording survey. 3 King Street, Brynmawr, NP25
4RE was submitted to Blaenau Gwent County Borough Council: pl.app.nos
C/2014/0153).
CIfA . Code of Conduct and the Code of Approved Practice for the Regulation of
Contractual Arrangements in Field Archaeology 2014.
GGAT BLG0169BHD.
Proposed Demolition & Re-Build of 2Storey 1 Bedroom Terraced
House: 3 King Street, Brynmawr. Pl.App.No.: C/2014/0153.
Jennings, H., 1934. Brynmawr, A Study of a Distressed Area, Allenson & Co. London.
(Brynmawr Library)
9
A.P.A.C. Ltd Appendix I WB/BRY/14
Contexts
DSC08832 28/09/15 SONY-F828 L SW Feature in south western party wall possible earlier fireplace. PL12
DSC08839 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L SW Exposed brick domed fireplace in south western party wall
DSC08840 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L V Internal view of hidden chimney stack.
DSC08841 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L V Internal view of hidden chimney stack.
DSC08842 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L SW Exposed brick domed fireplace in south western party wall
DSC08843 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L W Exposed bricked up brick domed fireplace in south western gable wall
DSC08844 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L W Exposed bricked up brick domed fireplace in south western gable wall and exposed earlier edition stairwell.
DSC08845 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L W Exposed bricked up brick domed fireplace with flag stoned hearth in south western party wall
DSC08846 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L SW Exposed bricked up brick domed fireplace in south western party wall
DSC08847 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L V Internal debris, slate and brick taken from within blocked in fireplace. PL16
DSC08848 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L V Internal debris, slate and brick taken from within blocked in fireplace.
DSC08849 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L SW Depth of fireplace from back exterior (earlier) wall to room interior, after clearance. PL17
DSC08850 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L SW Width of fireplace after clearance. PL13
DSC08851 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L V ERROR
DSC08852 30/09/15 SONY-F828 L V Internal view of hidden chimney stack. PL14
3 King St, Brynmawr
The Ordnance Survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577) to reproduce map information
The Ordnance Survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577)
Fig 03: Ordnance Survey 6”: mile. Breckonshire XLVII.NE 1915 A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/BRY/14
3 King street, Brynmawr
Kitchen TR1
TR2
PA
RT
Y
W
Ground
AL
L
TR3
Floor
PA
RT
Y
W
AL
L
1m
N N
Kitchen
PA
PA
RT
RT
Y
Y
W
W
Ground Ground
AL
Stair
AL
L
L
well? Floor Floor
PA
RT
Hearth
Y
W
AL
L
PA
RT
Y
W
AL
L
1m 1m
Fig 05a: Initial phase Fig 5b: Second phase A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/BRY/14
King street, Brynmawr
DSC08565
Plate 01: Rubble wall extended into next property south eastern elevation, south western corner.
DSC08810
Plate 02: Mixture of uncoursed rubble, coursed stone, and brick. A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/BRY/14
Lean to, built against previous build to extend the building of a later
phase kitchen.
King street, Brynmawr
DSC08811
DSC08564
Plate 03: Different phases of building. Later build
extension built upon, but not tied to previous builds north
western elevation.
DSC08563
Plate 05: Maintenance hole outside of north western Plate 04: Kitchen extension. Ill fitted, A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/BRY/14
kitchen extension. Filled with rain water. between property to the east and property
to the west’s porch extension. Timber frame roof under slate.
King street, Brynmawr
DSC08815
Plate 06: Trench 1 north western elevation foundations (100), (101), (102) with plastic water pipe
(105), in fill (104) and cut (103).
DSC08816
Plate 07: North eastern gable party wall A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/BRY/17
exposed.
King street, Brynmawr
095149
Plate 09: Flagstone floor, ground level within western gable. A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/BRY/14
Possible step
King street, Brynmawr
DSC08829
DSC08828
Plate 10: Lime plastered stairwell in south western gable exposed. Plate 11: Hole in south western gable wall. A.P.A.C. Ltd Wb/BRY/14
Previous external wall, Evidence of previous stairwell shown through
an interior wall built up against, but not tied to a previous exterior wall.
Kings street, Brynmawr
DSC08850
DSC08832
Plate 12: Feature in south western gable possible earlier fireplace. Plate 13: Width of fireplace after clearance.
DSC07261
DSC08852
Plate 14: Internal view of hidden chimney stack. Plate 15: Photograph of Brynmawr early
A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/BRY/14
20th century.
King street, Brynmawr
DSC08847
Plate 16: Internal debris, slate and brick taken from within blocked in fireplace.
DSC08849
Plate 17: Depth of fireplace from back exterior (earlier) wall to room A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/BRY/14
interior, after clearance.