Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A.P.A.C. Ltd.
By:
Dr N Phillips 30/Aug/2022
A.P.A.C. Ltd Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow WB/WCE/20
SUMMARY
Copyright Notice: A.P.A.C. Ltd. retains copyright of this report under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988.
The Ordnance Survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577) to reproduce map information; Copyright remains otherwise
with the Ordnance Survey.
Frontispiece: img_0652 western section of main cable trench between buildings; viewed looking west
2
A.P.A.C. Ltd Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow WB/WCE/20
Contents
Contents..............................................................................................................................................................3
List of Plates .......................................................................................................................................................4
Appendices .........................................................................................................................................................4
1 Introduction ................................................................................................................................................5
1.1 Planning Condition .............................................................................................................................5
1.2 Additional Condition ..........................................................................................................................5
2 Location, Geology and Topography ...........................................................................................................5
2.1 Location ..............................................................................................................................................5
2.2 Geology ..............................................................................................................................................5
2.3 Topography ........................................................................................................................................6
3 Brief Historical and Archaeological Background ......................................................................................6
4 Aims and Objectives ..................................................................................................................................6
4.1 Watching Brief ...................................................................................................................................6
4.2 Scope of work.....................................................................................................................................6
5 Methodology ..............................................................................................................................................7
5.1 General ...............................................................................................................................................7
5.2 Ground Disturbance ...........................................................................................................................7
5.3 Recording ...........................................................................................................................................7
6 Results ........................................................................................................................................................7
6.1 Geology ..............................................................................................................................................7
6.2 Trench 1..............................................................................................................................................8
6.3 Trench 2..............................................................................................................................................8
6.4 Trench 3..............................................................................................................................................8
6.5 Trench 4..............................................................................................................................................8
6.6 Trench 5..............................................................................................................................................9
6.7 Trench 6..............................................................................................................................................9
6.8 Trench 7..............................................................................................................................................9
6.9 Finds ...................................................................................................................................................9
6.10 Environmental ....................................................................................................................................9
7 Discussion and Interpretation .....................................................................................................................9
7.1 Discussion ..........................................................................................................................................9
7.2 Discussion ..........................................................................................................................................9
8 Archive .....................................................................................................................................................10
9 Acknowledgements ..................................................................................................................................10
10 Bibliography and references .................................................................................................................11
3
A.P.A.C. Ltd Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow WB/WCE/20
List of Figures
Figure 1 Location
Figure 2 Proposed Electric Cable Layout.
Figure 3 Electric cable trenches completed
Figure 4 Plan of watching brief observed, with main contexts and trench sequence
List of Plates
Appendices
4
A.P.A.C. Ltd Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow WB/WCE/20
1 Introduction
A planning application and listed building consent was applied for by Andrew Warner of Hawkes Edwards acting as
agent for Mr & Mrs Hoosenally (the clients). The application was for: works and alterations at Whitton Court, (the site)
to include the erection of a two-storey extension to rear elevation; a porch to side elevation; (part) underground 6-bay
garage; creation of self-contained flat; re-routing of vehicular driveway to include change of use of land; reinstatement of
garden terraces, ponds, and pavilions; and removal of trees. The planning application number is 17/04607/FUL and the
listed building consent number is 17/04608/FUL.
No development approved by this permission shall commence until the applicant, or their agents or
successor in title, has secured the implementation of a programme of archaeological work in
accordance with a written scheme of investigation (WSI). This written scheme shall be approved in
writing by the planning authority prior to the commencement of works.
The original conditions, above, were for a level 1 & 2 Building Recording Survey to be followed by an archaeological
watching brief. At the time of writing, the Building Recording had been completed in 2018: BS/WCW/18 but the main
watching brief: WB/WCW/2018 is still current but did begin in 2018.
In addition to the above stated works, a later alteration was proposed, requesting removal of the current overhead
electricity supply to the house and its replacement with below surface shielded cables: to improve the visual setting of the
site. As this alteration and the ensuing landscaping works would have the potential to impact upon potential archaeological
resources below ground, Shropshire County Council (SCC) again advised that any planning approval should include a
condition requiring a program of archaeological work, an archaeological watching brief.
As a result of this advice, APAC. Ltd drew up a separate written scheme of investigation (WSI) for this additional work:
WSI:WB/WCE/20 and sent it to the agent who forwarded to planning for approval. That WSI was drawn up using
information provided by the agent and the SCC planning portal.
This report therefore concerns only the watching brief conducted during the excavation of the trenches for the re-routing
of the electric supply cable only.
2.1 Location
Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow, Shropshire, SY9 3AB, NGR SO 57825 73496, fig 01, site location.
Whitton court is situated 27 miles north of Hereford.; when travelling north from Hereford on the A49 towards Shropshire,
a right turn towards and through Caynham Village leads east towards Whitton, (signposted).
Continue along the road taking the third left into Whitton Court.
2.2 Geology
Whitton Court area is located on a bedrock geology of Raglan Mudstone which presents within the excavation depths as
:a red/brown overburden of sandy clay with occasional banding and isolated patches of green sandy clay.
5
A.P.A.C. Ltd Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow WB/WCE/20
2.3 Topography
Whitton Court is located approximately 1km to the north of the small village of Whitton, to the east of Ludlow, Shropshire.
It is set in a gently undulating landscape characterised by irregularly shaped pastoral fields, narrow lanes, and small
nucleated settlements.
The site is situated at NGR SO 57825 73496 (Fig 2) and lies at approximately 173m above ordnance datum.
A background history of the site with mapping and documentary references was provided in the earlier Building Recording
Survey report: APAC.Ltd. BS/WCW/18. To summarise the manor house has visible C16th/C17th century remains, but
much of the structure is mid to late Victorian. Documentary evidence suggests a mid C12th origin for a building at the site
and there was some evidence that will be presented in the main watching brief: WB/WCW/18 that may support this.
The aim of the watching brief was to establish the presence/absence of archaeological structures or other significant
features within the works area. Should any archaeological resources be revealed their presence would be recorded and a
decision made as to any mitigation measures. The archaeological watching brief was be carried out to the standards laid
down in the Chartered Institute of Field Archaeologists, Guideline for Watching Briefs 2014, upd 2020.
The definition of an archaeological watching brief is a formal programme of observation and investigation
conducted during any operation carried out for non-archaeological reasons. This will be within a specified
area or site on land, inter-tidal zone or underwater, where there is a possibility that archaeological deposits
may be disturbed or destroyed. The programme will result in the preparation of a report and ordered
archive.
This definition and Standard do not cover chance observations, which should lead to an appropriate
archaeological project being designed and implemented, nor do they apply to monitoring for preservation
of remains in situ. A watching brief will preserve by record, within the resources available, any
archaeological deposits uncovered during groundwork.
The watching brief will ensure that: in the event of archaeological resources of significance, being
discovered and requiring treatment beyond the remit of the watching brief; then steps would be
implemented to ensure that their treatment would be undertaken within the standards recommended by the
CIFA.
Resulting from the watching brief, a report on the results will be produced, which will include a detailed
summary of the methodology, site history, deposits/features/ structures/artefacts uncovered and
interpretation of the results.
(CIFA. 2020).
The archaeology of the application site as a whole, in its wider local or regional context, was considered but the watching
brief was confined to those areas that were directly affected by the development. The original proposed development is
shown in the fig 02; plan provided by Western Power, but the completed layout is shown in fig 03.
It can be seen that there are some differences between the two layouts. These adjustments reduced ecological and
environmental concerns, namely, the disturbance to the mature trees along the steep eastern scarp above the ponds. The
re-sited route also reduced disturbance along the current access track for the current residents of the northern housing.
6
A.P.A.C. Ltd Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow WB/WCE/20
The revised route for the northern trench to the sub-station runs across the open field to the west of the houses and returns
under the 19th/20th century wall to the north of the properties. It should be noted that the single northern trench from pond
and out past the fence, including the excavation of the substation, was done without archaeological cover due to lack of
communication. The trench with included cable run, was later visually examined, and its approximated 100m route
plotted with GPS, before being fully backfilled.
5 Methodology
5.1 General
Except for the above-mentioned northern extent, all the trench work was completed over a period of seven days which
included: periods of back fill and cable duct laying as certain portions of the trench were unstable.
All work was carried out in accordance with the Health and Safety at Work act 1974 and the Management of Health and
Safety Regulations 1992. Health and Safety considerations were of paramount importance in conducting all fieldwork.
Safe working practises overrode archaeological considerations at all times.
After marking the trenches and cutting the tarmac surface with a disc cutter to reduce disturbance, a combination of a
50mm ditching bucket and a 100mm grading bucket; both toothless, were used to excavate down to the required depth.
All excavation work was conducted under constant archaeological supervision. Where potential archaeological horizons
were identified during the work, mechanical trenching was stopped in the immediate vicinity, and the features cleared by
hand using shovel or trowel as appropriate.
All spoil from the excavation was visually examined for artefacts and was scanned using a metal detector before its
removal from site in a dumper.
With the exception of the aforementioned northern run, the order of the trenching sequence was dictated by logistics of
the site access for both the residents and the spoil removal. The plan shown in fig 04, which concentrates on only the
active watching brief area shows the trenching sequence; numbered 1 to 7 from east to west.
5.3 Recording
A unique site code (WB/WCE/20) was allocated for all aspects of the project archive to be produced as a result of the
on-site works. All encountered contexts were recorded on pro-forma APAC Ltd context sheets and an ordered site
archive was maintained. Within this report text: all cuts are denotated with square brackets [ ], deposits with curved
brackets ( ), walls/structures with brackets { } and surfaces with angled brackets < >. A full list of contexts is given in
appendix I with Harris Matrix.
All photographs were taken with a recognised scale, saved in either TIFF, Raw or Jpeg format, with a resolution of at
least 12MP+. All photographs are listed in Appendix II, with a contact sheet included. Photographs used in the text are
denoted PL### and included in Plates listed in Appendix II.
No small finds were retrieved, or archaeological assemblages were recovered from Site.
6 Results
6.1 Geology
Superficial geology (1004) was encountered 750mm below the present-day ground surface; in areas disturbed by existing
tarmac and service runs, whilst in undisturbed areas, natural varied from 550mm in the east to 450mm in the northern
field run.
7
A.P.A.C. Ltd Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow WB/WCE/20
6.2 Trench 1
Trench 1, fig 04, PL01, consists of the main, 22m x 1m, east/west trench extending across the whole of the site; from the
grassy bank <1000>, towards the east, cutting through the parking space and compacted track <1001> and the tarmac,
<1007> along the centre and west. The most consistent sequence of deposition within the excavated area can be seen at
the eastern end where the grassy surface <1000> overlays a 200mm bioturbation layer (1002), which overlays a 200mm
deposit with some smaller building debris, (1003), before a sterile clay is reached (1004) at 750mm, PL02.
NB. Excavation for the new garage during the main watching brief WB/WCW/2018 and located some 2m west has
revealed the sterile clay to at least 7m depth.
Proceeding westward, the sequence changes: within the area of compacted trackway <1001> covers a bedding deposit of
gravels in a grey/black deposit, (1005), which fills a cut [1006] into the underlying deposit (1003), PL03. Context <1001>
is then replaced by a tarmac surface <1007> which accounts for the rest of the site up to the northwest bank. As stated
earlier the northern trench was excavated prior to the watching brief. Ostensibly, the sequence seemed similar to that of
the eastern grassy bank.
{1012} a length of grey plastic pipe and blue water pipe within cut [1003], with a band of yellow electric just visible
above, PL04, left edge of photograph. The pipes are new but the cut not discernible, but they are above (1005) and below
<1007).
{1031} salt glaze pipe, also in trench 3 laying under (1005) but cut{1032} into (1003), PL01.
{1014} a brick chamber {1014}, cut [1015] into natural (1004), PL05. The chamber has an external length of 1.4m and
an internal length of 1m, neither of the widths are known as the chamber extended beyond the southern trench wall. Worth
noting: alignment to the adjacent stable block wall south is 5° out and the chamber is positioned only 84mm away; the
combination of which may suggest the chamber predates the stable block. On cleaning the brickwork for recording, a
central mortared brick lid for the chamber collapsed revealing a central fill (1021) and some construction detail. The
longest edge being a single brick width whilst the end walls were double, PL04. A section of the fill was excavated with
a spade to a depth of 1m, PL06 & PL07, without finding a bottom. The fill was a black greasy sludge with an unpleasant
odour and a decision was made to not take a sample or disturb further on health grounds.
6.3 Trench 2
Trench 2 was a short 6m x 0.5m southern offshoot to a small outbuilding PL08. The stratigraphy here was <1001> over
(1005) over (1003) over (1004). The only disturbance was the exposure of {1031} just before it continued into Trench 1
(see above).
6.4 Trench 3
Trench 3 was another 0.5m wide section, this time extending 15m north along and into the house, PL09. The upper
sequence here was{1007} over (1005) but with no evidence of (1003). In its place, was a layer of building rubble (1008)
extending beyond the required depth of the trench, PL10. The rubble: some of it whole brick, was mixed with clay.
Natural (1004) was not encountered, the only disturbance was from a modern blue plastic water pipe {1009}, cut [1010]
into [1005]. (1008) was probably a ground levelling event possibly, contemporary with the construction of the house.
6.5 Trench 4
Trench 4 was another connection to the house; this time only measuring 3.4m x 0.5m, but otherwise identical in its main
stratigraphic sequence with trench 3. There was however, one difference, with a layer of potential laid brick surface (1020)
at the northern end, directly under (1007), replacing (1005), PL11. (1020).
A further disturbance was also encountered: abutting the house foundation, and continuing some 500mm below present
ground surface, was a brick chamber, {2017}, PL12 & PL13. This chamber was allocated a cut [1018] as the base does
cut natural (1004). The shaft when discovered was redundant and filled-in, with lighter building debris (2019).
8
A.P.A.C. Ltd Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow WB/WCE/20
Interestingly, the drain had a hinged lid for lifting; a usual fitting for a surface drain but unlikely for one at a depth of
500mm. The hinged, cast-iron drain cover was embossed Doulton, PL14.
NB Doulton & Co are well were known throughout the world for their ceramic products but in 1846 one of the
family; Henry Doulton, started a new enterprise in sanitary wares. It wasn’t until the late 19th century to pre-1937
that Doulton began involvement in Iron Founding:
https://www.gracesguide.co.uk/Doulton_and_Co
The presence of the surface drain cover at such a depth tends to support an original, lower ground surface in this area; in
keeping with the interpretation offered above for trench 3: a raised ground level with building rubble.
6.6 Trench 5
Trench 5 is a short 500mm length of trench to connect with the stable block. Unsurprisingly, its stratigraphy is the same
as trench 1 and it also contains a continuation of pipe {1012} and associated cut and fill, PL05.
6.7 Trench 6
Trench 6 is a 6m southern extension carrying the electric cables to the courtyard area of the stable block. Its continuation
beyond is unknown and was probably completed prior to the watching brief. The trench again had an identical sequence
to that of trench 1 including a grey plastic pipe, yellow electric tape and four electric cables {1026}, PL15. Context
{1026} is more than likely a continuation of {1012} and therefore, relatively modern.
6.8 Trench 7
Trench 7 was a short length of excavation to join trench 1 to the pre-dug section of the northern extension. Apart from a
concrete encased drainage duct{1029}, PL16, cut [1030] into <1007> the sequence was the same as trench 1. The
photograph also shows the depth of 500mm at the edge of the tarmac (ranging rods) at the join with the northern trench.
6.9 Finds
Some small fragments of 20th century domestic ceramics and a few shards of glass were observed but were not collected
as they could offer no useful information to the outcome.
6.10 Environmental
No material suitable for environmental analysis was retrieved from the watching brief. The fill (1021) of the brick chamber
was a potential health risk and was left in situ.
Undisturbed superficial geology (110) was encountered at a relatively shallow depth and the general fill above consisted
of recent levelling work using reused building debris and modern bedding and surfacing materials.
Later disturbances of the levelling events were present, but these consisted of service and drainage runs the oldest of
which would be mid Victorian.
7.2 Discussion
The results from the watching brief undertaken at during the trenches for the re-routing of the electricity supply were
successful in determining the general absence of any preserved archaeological resource within the development area.
9
A.P.A.C. Ltd Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow WB/WCE/20
8 Archive
The archive has been prepared according to the Management of Archaeological Projects, English Heritage, MoRPHE
V1.2 (2015) with the records fully ordered and indexed. The project archives consist of all original records, all
documentation that relates to the watching brief; copies of the WSI and any relevant correspondence included. The archive
is digital/documentary only and includes no physical samples or assemblages.
The original archive for the watching brief will be retained by A.P.A.C. Ltd.
A digital copy of the archive will uploaded to Oasis, and a copy of the report and relative data will be deposited with both
Shropshire Archive and HER.
The archives will be deposited within twelve months of the completion of the watching brief with the agreement of
the landowner.
A synopsis of the project will be submitted to CBA Midlands and the full client report published online through Scribd.
9 Acknowledgements
Thanks to the groundworkers and clients for allowing APAC. Ltd., to undertake the required work as efficiently as
possible.
10
A.P.A.C. Ltd Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow WB/WCE/20
APAC Ltd Report No. 209. BS/WCW/18 – Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow, Shropshire. Level 1 & Level 2
Building Recording Survey.
CIFA. Standards and Guidance: For the creation, compilation, transfer and deposition of archaeological
archives 2014 upd 2020
Standards and Guidance: For an Archaeological Watching Brief. 2014 upd 2020
English Heritage. 2014. Management of Research Projects in the Historic Environment. 2nd Ed
2011. Environmental Archaeology: A Guide to the Theory and Practice of Methods, from Sampling
and Recovery to Post-excavation. 2nd Ed
2018. Science for Historic Industries: Guidelines for the Investigation of 17th to 19th Century Industries.
Hawkes
Edwards, Heritage Impact Assessment July 2020
Watt, S. 2011. The Archaeology of the West Midlands. A Framework for Research. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Online Sources:
MagicMaps https://magicmaps.co.uk
A.P.A.C. Registered Address: Wyastone Estate, Wyastone Leys, Monmouth, NP25 3SR.
Tel: 07734962919. Mobile: 07734962919 Email: apac.philips@btinternet.com
Company Registration No 05041541 VAT Reg No 826 3628 19
Director: Dr. N. Phillips.
11
Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow, Shropshire
The Ordnance Survey has granted A.P.A.C. Ltd a Copyright Licence (No. 100046577)
N
17/04607/FUL
0 5 10 20 30
N
ce
fen
House
tarmac
Stable block
Stable block
<1007> House
{1017}
3
E.357862.5760
N. 273524.9783
Z. 175.1550
7 <1000>
{1029}
<1001>
<1007> 4
{1026} <1007>
5 1
{1012}
Stable block {1026} {1014}
<1001>
6 2
{1031}
E. 357859.7252
N. 273500.8428
Z. 174.3295
0 5 10 20
m
GPS: Co ordinates:
Geomax Zenith 25
Fig 04 Plan of watching brief observed, with main contexts and trench sequence A.P.A.C. Ltd WB/WCE/20
Whitton Court, Whitton, Ludlow, Shropshire.
PLATE 01
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 02
N
Section view: Initial cut trench 1, eastern
end. Main sequence <1000> over (1002)
House
over (1003) over (1004). Left extent <1001>
over (1005) in cut [106] over (1003).
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 03
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 04
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 05
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 06
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 07
N
Main trench, 1, western area against wall,
Internal brick chamber
House
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 08
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 09
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 10
N
North eastern off-shoot trench 3, <1007>
over (1003) over (1008)
House
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 11
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 12
N
Central northern offshoot trench, 4, against
cottage
House
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 13
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 14
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 15
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
PLATE 16
Stable block
0 5 10 20
m
Page 1 of 1
Site name: Whitton Court, Electric Appendix I A.P.A.C. Ltd
Project :518, Code: WB/WCE/20 Context list Contexts: <Surface> (Deposit) {Structure} [Cut]
[1010]
<1007>
[1032]
20th c
19th c
{1014}
[1015]
(1008)
(1003)
(1004)
Site name: Witton Court, Electric re-route Appendix II A.P.A.C. Ltd
PRN:###
Digital Photographic Record Project No:518.........Project code..WB/WCE/20....