Column Rebar Comparision Table

Unit A/B
Basis Total rebar (kgs) Unit Cost(Rs) Cost(Rs)
Design Criteria 1577.251563 110 173497.672

Normal Practice (non complaince

with design codes) 1380.122363 110 151813.46
21684.212
Unit C/D
Basis Total rebar (kgs) Unit Cost(Rs) Cost(Rs)
Design Criteria 1766.55144 110 194320.658
Design reviewed 1537.64544 110 169140.998
25179.66

Foundation Depth Comparision Table

Unit A/B
Total area of foundation cost of Cost of Cost of dwarf
Basis Bearing capacity
required concrete(Rs) Excavation (Rs) wall(Rs)
Depth 2m 114 kN/m2 36.04 234014.88 27560.00 236446.25
Depth 1.5m 92 kN/m2 43.04 279467.48 21200 170461.25
-45452.60 6360.00 65985.00 26892.40
Unit C/D
Total area of foundation cost of Cost of Cost of dwarf
Basis Bearing capacity
required concrete(Rs) Excavation (Rs) wall(Rs)
Depth 2m 114 kN/m2 33.93 220322.52 25447.50 218322.42
Depth 1.5m 92 kN/m2 39.59 257061.80 19575 157395.23
-36739.28 5872.50 60927.19 30060.41
Column Rebars Review Unit A/B
Design Requirement
Column grid Number height area Volume Below Ground % kgs GF % kgs FF % kgs SF % kgs
C1 A4,C4,C3,C2 4 11.4 90000 4.104 1608 1.786666667 90.88416 1608 1.786667 161.5718 1608 1.786667 161.5718 1608 1.786667 4.048763
C1 A1,B1,C1 3 8.2 90000 2.214 1608 1.786666667 68.16312 1608 1.786667 121.1789 1608 1.786667 121.1789
C2 A2,A3,B2,B4 4 11.4 90000 4.104 2060 2.288888889 116.4312 2060 2.288889 206.9888 1608 1.786667 161.5718 1608 1.786667 161.5718
C3 B3 1 11.4 90000 1.026 2512 2.791111111 35.49456 2512 2.791111 63.10144 2060 2.288889 51.7472 2060 2.288889 51.7472 Grand Total
1797.336 11.448 310.97304 552.841 496.0698 217.3678 1577.251563
Normal Practice (Non-complaince to design codes)
Column grid Number height area Volume Below Ground % kgs GF % kgs FF % kgs SF % kgs
C1 A4,C4,C3,C2 4 11.4 90000 4.104 1608 1.786666667 90.88416 1608 1.786667 161.5718 1608 1.786667 161.5718 1608 1.786667 4.048763
C1 A1,B1,C1 3 8.2 90000 2.214 1256 1.395555556 53.24184 1256 1.395556 94.65216 1256 1.395556 94.65216
C2 A2,A3,B2,B4 4 11.4 90000 4.104 1608 1.786666667 90.88416 1608 1.786667 161.5718 1608 1.786667 161.5718 1608 1.786667 161.5718
C3 B3 1 11.4 90000 1.026 1608 1.786666667 22.72104 1608 1.786667 40.39296 1608 1.786667 40.39296 1608 1.786667 40.39296 Grand Total
1797.336 11.448 257.7312 458.1888 458.1888 206.0136 1380.122363

Column Rebars Review Unit C/D

Existing
Column grid Number height area Volume Below Ground % kgs GF % kgs FF % kgs SF % kgs
C1 D1,D2,D3 3 8.2 90000 2.214 1608 1.786666667 68.16312 1608 1.786667 121.1789 1608 1.786667 121.1789 0
C2 C3 1 11.4 90000 1.026 1608 1.786666667 22.72104 1608 1.786667 40.39296 1608 1.786667 40.39296 1256 1.395556 31.55072
C3 A1,A3,B1,B3,C1,C2 6 11.4 90000 6.156 2060 2.288888889 174.6468 2060 2.288889 310.4832 1608 1.786667 242.3578 1256 1.395556 189.3043
C4 B2 1 11.4 90000 1.026 2512 2.791111111 35.49456 2512 2.791111 63.10144 2060 2.288889 51.7472 1608 1.786667 40.39296
C5 A2 1 11.4 90000 1.026 2512 2.791111111 35.49456 2512 2.791111 63.10144 2512 2.791111 63.10144 2060 2.288889 51.7472 Grand Total
1797.336 11.448 336.52008 598.2579 518.7782 312.9952 1766.55144
Design Reviewed
Column grid Number height area Volume Below Ground % kgs GF % kgs FF % kgs SF % kgs
C1 D1,D2,D3 3 8.2 90000 2.214 1256 1.395555556 53.24184 1256 1.395556 94.65216 1256 1.395556 94.65216 0
C2 C3 1 11.4 90000 1.026 1608 1.786666667 22.72104 1608 1.786667 40.39296 1608 1.786667 40.39296 1608 1.786667 40.39296
C3 A1,A3,B1,B3,C1,C2 6 11.4 90000 6.156 1608 1.786666667 136.32624 1608 1.786667 242.3578 1608 1.786667 242.3578 1608 1.786667 242.3578
C4 B2 1 11.4 90000 1.026 1608 1.786666667 22.72104 1608 1.786667 40.39296 1608 1.786667 40.39296 1608 1.786667 40.39296
C5 A2 1 11.4 90000 1.026 1608 1.786666667 22.72104 1608 1.786667 40.39296 1608 1.786667 40.39296 1608 1.786667 40.39296 Grand Total
1797.336 11.448 257.7312 458.1888 458.1888 363.5366 1537.64544
UNIT C and D
Depth 2m

Safe Bearing Total Load Area provided

Grid Base reactions(kN) Soil Load (kN) Area Required
Capacity(kN/m2) (kN) (min 1.5mx1.5m)
(m2)
A1 127.71 114 12.77133333 140.48 1.232321637 2.32
A2 214.76 114 21.476 236.24 2.072245614 2.32
A3 115.91 114 11.59066667 127.50 1.118397661 2.32
B1 248.43 114 24.84333333 273.28 2.397163743 2.81
B2 365.43 114 36.54333333 401.98 3.526111111 3.93
B3 234.25 114 23.42466667 257.67 2.260274854 2.32
C1 303.61 114 30.36066667 333.97 2.929538012 3.07
C2 443.41 114 44.34066667 487.75 4.27848538 4.55
C3 286.33 114 28.63266667 314.96 2.76280117 2.81
D1 186.75 114 18.67533333 205.43 1.802005848 2.32
D2 290.79 114 29.07933333 319.87 2.805900585 2.81
D3 174.09 114 17.40866667 191.50 1.679783626 2.32
Total Area 33.93

Elements Length/Area thickness Volume (ft3) Unit Cost(Rs) Total cost(Rs)

Foundation 33.93 0.4 478.96 460 220322.52
Excavation 848.25 2.00 1696.50 15 25447.5
Dwarf Wall 701.4375 0.75 526.08 415 218322.4219
Grand Total 464092.4419

Depth 1.5m

Safe Bearing Total Load Area provided

Grid Base reactions(kN) Soil Load (kN) Area Required
Capacity(kN/m2) (kN) (min 1.5mx1.5m)
(m2)
A1 127.71 92 12.77133333 140.48 1.527007246 2.32
A2 214.76 92 21.476 236.24 2.567782609 2.81
A3 115.91 92 11.59066667 127.50 1.38584058 2.32
B1 248.43 92 24.84333333 273.28 2.970398551 3.35
B2 365.43 92 36.54333333 401.98 4.369311594 4.55
B3 234.25 92 23.42466667 257.67 2.800775362 2.81
C1 303.61 92 30.36066667 333.97 3.63007971 3.93
C2 443.41 92 44.34066667 487.75 5.301601449 5.58
C3 286.33 92 28.63266667 314.96 3.423471014 3.63
D1 186.75 92 18.67533333 205.43 2.23292029 2.32
D2 290.79 92 29.07933333 319.87 3.476876812 3.63
D3 174.09 92 17.40866667 191.50 2.081471014 2.32
Total Area 39.59

Elements Length/Area thickness Volume (ft3) Unit Cost(Rs) Total cost(Rs)

Foundation 39.59 0.4 558.83 460 257061.8
Excavation 652.5 2.00 1305.00 15 19575
Dwarf Wall 505.6875 0.75 379.27 415 157395.2344
Grand Total 434032.0344
UNIT A and B
Depth 2m

Safe Bearing Total Load Area provided

Grid Base reactions(kN) Soil Load (kN) Area Required
Capacity(kN/m2) (kN) (min 1.5mx1.5m)
(m2)
A1 111.35 114 11.13533333 122.49 1.074461988 2.32
A2 330.36 114 33.036 363.40 3.187684211 3.35
A3 352.37 114 35.23733333 387.61 3.400093567 3.35
A4 152.82 114 15.282 168.10 1.474578947 2.32
B1 228.76 114 22.876 251.64 2.207333333 2.32
B2 476.10 114 47.61033333 523.71 4.593979532 4.55
B3 530.01 114 53.00066667 583.01 5.114099415 5.23
B4 271.77 114 27.17666667 298.94 2.622309942 2.81
C1 133.39 114 13.33866667 146.73 1.287064327 2.32
C2 228.98 114 22.898 251.88 2.20945614 2.32
C3 293.59 114 29.35933333 322.95 2.832918129 2.81
C4 181.82 114 18.182 200.00 1.754403509 2.32
Total Area 36.04

Elements Length/Area thickness Volume (ft3) Unit Cost(Rs) Total cost(Rs)

Foundation 36.04 0.4 508.73 460 234014.88
Excavation 918.67 2.00 1837.33 15 27560
Dwarf Wall 759.67 0.75 569.75 415 236446.25
Grand Total 498021.13

Depth 1.5m

Safe Bearing Total Load Area provided

Grid Base reactions(kN) Soil Load (kN) Area Required
Capacity(kN/m2) (kN) (min 1.5mx1.5m)
(m2)
A1 111.35 92 11.13533333 122.49 1.331398551 2.32
A2 330.36 92 33.036 363.40 3.949956522 3.93
A3 352.37 92 35.23733333 387.61 4.21315942 4.55
A4 152.82 92 15.282 168.10 1.827195652 2.32
B1 228.76 92 22.876 251.64 2.735173913 2.81
B2 476.10 92 47.61033333 523.71 5.692539855 5.95
B3 530.01 92 53.00066667 583.01 6.337036232 6.72
B4 271.77 92 27.17666667 298.94 3.249384058 3.35
C1 133.39 92 13.33866667 146.73 1.59484058 2.32
C2 228.98 92 22.898 251.88 2.737804348 2.81
C3 293.59 92 29.35933333 322.95 3.510355072 3.63
C4 181.82 92 18.182 200.00 2.173934783 2.32
Total Area 43.04

Elements Length/Area thickness Volume (ft3) Unit Cost(Rs) Total cost(Rs)

Foundation 43.04 0.4 607.54 460 279467.48
Excavation 706.67 2.00 1413.33 15 21200
Dwarf Wall 547.67 0.75 410.75 415 170461.25
Grand Total 471128.73